Latest / Bloomberg Law / Justices Ready to Uphold Gun Ban on Domestic Abusers
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 2: Can't Stop, Hat Stop, Hat Stop.
- 0:15Speaker 1: Hundreds of protesters were outside the Supreme Court today to
- 0:19Speaker 1: support a thirty year old federal ban on guns for
- 0:22Speaker 1: domestic abusers. Inside, the justices suggested during oral arguments that
- 0:27Speaker 1: they would not strike down that ban that's been used
- 0:29Speaker 1: to block more than seventy seven thousand gun sales in
- 0:32Speaker 1: the past twenty five years. And it didn't even seem
- 0:35Speaker 1: like it was a hard issue for the justices. Both
- 0:38Speaker 1: liberals and conservatives sounded persuaded by arguments from the Solicitor
- 0:42Speaker 1: General that the prohibition is in line with the long
- 0:45Speaker 1: standing practice of disarming dangerous people. My guest is Second
- 0:49Speaker 1: Amendment expert Adam Winkler, a professor at UCLA Law School.
- 0:53Speaker 1: Let's start with the big question. Did it seem like
- 0:56Speaker 1: justices across the board were inclined to uphold this federal
- 1:00Speaker 1: gun ban for people subject to domestic violence restraining orders?
- 1:05Speaker 3: It did. It felt very one sided in the Supreme
- 1:08Speaker 3: Court today, and it felt like that almost all the justices,
- 1:12Speaker 3: if not all the justices, were inclined to uphold the
- 1:15Speaker 3: federal ban in this case.
- 1:17Speaker 1: This is the first test of last year's ruling that
- 1:20Speaker 1: strengthened Second Amendment protections and established a constitutional right to
- 1:25Speaker 1: carry a handgun in public. So in order to understand this,
- 1:29Speaker 1: I think we have to explain how the historical analysis
- 1:32Speaker 1: approach has caused confusion in lower courts and led to
- 1:37Speaker 1: striking down gun control laws. So maybe you could just
- 1:40Speaker 1: give us a briefing on the historical analysis.
- 1:43Speaker 3: In the Bruin case, Justice Thomas's majority opinion said that
- 1:47Speaker 3: for gun laws to be constitutional and permissible today, they
- 1:51Speaker 3: must have historical analogs in the seventeen and eighteen hundreds
- 1:55Speaker 3: when the Second Amendment was adopted and the Fourteenth Amendment
- 1:58Speaker 3: was adopted, operating the Second Amendment to apply to the states.
- 2:02Speaker 3: As a result, courts have really struggled over the last
- 2:05Speaker 3: year or so trying to find gun laws back in
- 2:09Speaker 3: those days that are sufficiently analogous to many common sense,
- 2:14Speaker 3: mainstream gun laws that we have today. Truth be told,
- 2:18Speaker 3: many of our gun laws are kind of twentieth century inventions.
- 2:21Speaker 3: Bans on felms possessing firearms, bans on the mentally ill
- 2:25Speaker 3: possessing firearms, and the issue in today's case, ban on
- 2:28Speaker 3: domestic abusers possessing firearms. These are laws that don't have
- 2:32Speaker 3: any obvious analog in the seventeen and eighteen hundreds, and
- 2:37Speaker 3: so this law was struck down by the Fifth Circuit,
- 2:40Speaker 3: just like courts around the country have been striking down
- 2:42Speaker 3: gun laws for lack of a clear historical precedent.
- 2:46Speaker 1: So then how did the justices get around that lack
- 2:50Speaker 1: of a clear historical precedent and all end up seemingly
- 2:54Speaker 1: in favor of this bank.
- 2:55Speaker 3: Well, first of all, I think it's important to note
- 2:58Speaker 3: what elizabethgar a Solicitor General, began her oral argument with
- 3:04Speaker 3: by noting the statistics that show that domestic abusers with
- 3:08Speaker 3: firearms are an incredibly deadly mix, and that every state
- 3:13Speaker 3: in the Union, well not every state, I think it's
- 3:15Speaker 3: forty eight states in the federal government have prohibited domestic
- 3:18Speaker 3: abusers from possessing firearms, showing that what she intended to
- 3:22Speaker 3: do was not just rely on the history and tradition,
- 3:25Speaker 3: but on the common sense idea that some people are
- 3:27Speaker 3: too dangerous to have firearms. What the court seemed to
- 3:31Speaker 3: be inclined to do is allowed the government to frame
- 3:36Speaker 3: their gun laws at a higher level of generality you
- 3:39Speaker 3: don't have to show that there's a history and tradition
- 3:42Speaker 3: of domestic abusers being prohibited from possessing firearms, And of
- 3:46Speaker 3: course there isn't a long history and tradition of that,
- 3:49Speaker 3: but maybe you could show that there's a history and
- 3:52Speaker 3: tradition of prohibiting dangerous people from possessing firearms, and domestic
- 3:57Speaker 3: abusers are just a modern day understanding of people who
- 4:01Speaker 3: are just too dangerous to have come.
- 4:04Speaker 1: So Justice Thomas wrote the bruined decision. Was he in
- 4:08Speaker 1: line with what you just said?
- 4:11Speaker 3: It seemed Justice Thomas did ask several questions from the bench.
- 4:15Speaker 3: It's kind of surprising to go to the Supreme Court
- 4:17Speaker 3: now and to see how active Justice Thomas is as
- 4:20Speaker 3: a questioner. Before COVID, he didn't seem to ask many questions,
- 4:24Speaker 3: but it really has changed. He was an active questioner
- 4:27Speaker 3: and he didn't really show his cards very much. He
- 4:30Speaker 3: did press the Solicitor General to defend the standard that
- 4:34Speaker 3: they were offering, but by and large it was hard
- 4:37Speaker 3: to get a read on exactly Justice Thomas's views, but
- 4:40Speaker 3: the views of most of the other justices came through
- 4:43Speaker 3: pretty loud and clear and tell us a.
- 4:45Speaker 1: Little bit more about their views.
- 4:47Speaker 3: Well, the Chief Justice kept asking, well, you know, isn't
- 4:51Speaker 3: it obvious that this is a very dangerous person, this Rahimi.
- 4:54Speaker 3: He's had several incidents where he's fired firearms had been
- 4:57Speaker 3: irresponsible with them. Obviously, Justices Soda, Mayor and Kagan and
- 5:03Speaker 3: Jackson seemed more on the side of the Solicitor General
- 5:07Speaker 3: in the United States, although I will note that Katanji
- 5:10Speaker 3: Brown Jackson did ask some very very difficult questions of
- 5:14Speaker 3: the Solicitor General today and pushed her to really define
- 5:17Speaker 3: the boundaries of the argument that she was making. One
- 5:20Speaker 3: could interpret that as skepticism, or more likely she wanted
- 5:24Speaker 3: the Solicitener General to give her the really good argument
- 5:27Speaker 3: that she could use, Justice Jackson could use when she
- 5:30Speaker 3: goes into conference with the other justices in the next
- 5:33Speaker 3: couple days.
- 5:34Speaker 1: Yeah, so Justice Jackson said, what's the point of going
- 5:37Speaker 1: to the founding Eerr did she and the other liberal
- 5:40Speaker 1: justice It seemed like they wanted to use the case
- 5:43Speaker 1: to revisit that history based test.
- 5:46Speaker 3: It did appear so, although maybe issues not that optimistic
- 5:50Speaker 3: that she could do it, but it did seem like
- 5:52Speaker 3: she was pressing that it's very hard to defend this
- 5:56Speaker 3: domestic violence abuser band when people are subjet to a
- 6:00Speaker 3: restraining order in light of the history and tradition of
- 6:03Speaker 3: which that the Bruin Court offered. Although Bruin said that
- 6:07Speaker 3: you should look for analogous laws, I think that at
- 6:10Speaker 3: the end of the day, the government is hard pressed
- 6:12Speaker 3: to draw a very close analogy. Instead, the analogies were
- 6:16Speaker 3: very general and didn't exactly apply.
- 6:18Speaker 1: On point, did a majority of the Conservative justices seem
- 6:22Speaker 1: to want to limit any decision to the facts here?
- 6:26Speaker 1: Justice Neil Gorsuch said at one point, do we need
- 6:28Speaker 1: to get into any of that?
- 6:30Speaker 3: It did seem like several of the justices, including Justices Gorsch, Thomas,
- 6:35Speaker 3: and Alito, we're looking for ways to narrow the consequence
- 6:39Speaker 3: of ruling against Rahemi in this case and in favor
- 6:42Speaker 3: of upholding the law, talking about whether there might be
- 6:46Speaker 3: different as applied challenges that someone could bring, or whether
- 6:49Speaker 3: there might be some common law defenses that one could
- 6:53Speaker 3: bring to a charge that one was possessing a firearms
- 6:56Speaker 3: illegally in violation of the domestic violence restraining order, And
- 7:00Speaker 3: several of the justices, at least Justice Alito expressed some
- 7:03Speaker 3: discomfort with the idea that these domestic violence restraining orders
- 7:07Speaker 3: could be very long lasting and yet don't have very
- 7:11Speaker 3: serious procedural requirements that correspond with broad notions of due process.
- 7:17Speaker 1: Perhaps the Solicitor General said the court should use the case,
- 7:21Speaker 1: the present case, to give more guidance to the lower
- 7:24Speaker 1: courts and to correct lower courts quote profound misreading of
- 7:27Speaker 1: the bruined decision. Do you think we'll get any major
- 7:31Speaker 1: statements out of this ruling.
- 7:34Speaker 3: I think that's going to be one of the big questions.
- 7:36Speaker 3: Is this a really narrow ruling that just cobbles together
- 7:40Speaker 3: a majority, or is it an opinion that will provide
- 7:44Speaker 3: more guidance to the lower courts. Justice Kagan specifically asked
- 7:48Speaker 3: about that and about the necessity, and the Solicitor General
- 7:51Speaker 3: had a very clear and precise answer that there were
- 7:54Speaker 3: three errors being committed by the lower courts. They were
- 7:58Speaker 3: only looking to regulation and not looking to other historical sources.
- 8:01Speaker 3: They were looking at regulation, but we're really looking for
- 8:04Speaker 3: twins rather than for historical analogs. And also that the
- 8:09Speaker 3: absence of regulation should not always be read against the government,
- 8:13Speaker 3: especially when a problem like domestic violence was not really
- 8:16Speaker 3: thought of as a problem back then, So.
- 8:19Speaker 1: I admit that I find this historical analysis test with
- 8:23Speaker 1: Second Amendment cases just bordering on ridiculous. Were there any
- 8:28Speaker 1: clues as to whether the Conservatives remained behind the historical
- 8:33Speaker 1: analysis that Thomas put in place.
- 8:36Speaker 3: Well, I think that the Solicitor General made a very
- 8:39Speaker 3: strategic choice not to challenge the history and tradition test
- 8:43Speaker 3: of Ruin, but instead seek to, if anything, recapture its fluidity,
- 8:50Speaker 3: its ability to be useful to uphold laws, not just
- 8:53Speaker 3: to strike down laws. And so she was not asking
- 8:57Speaker 3: the court to abandon the history and tradition test. She
- 9:00Speaker 3: was saying that the lower courts have been misapplying that test,
- 9:03Speaker 3: and that to capture the true essence of that test
- 9:06Speaker 3: means that you should approach the issue the way she did,
- 9:09Speaker 3: at a slightly higher level of generality, focusing on dangerousness
- 9:13Speaker 3: rather than looking for historical precedents of domestic abusers being
- 9:17Speaker 3: prohibited access to firearms.
- 9:19Speaker 1: Do you think then that this reasoning would apply to
- 9:23Speaker 1: gun control measures that deny firearms to other potentially dangerous people,
- 9:28Speaker 1: for example, drug addicts or felons.
- 9:31Speaker 3: Well, those questions, of course, will have to be answered
- 9:33Speaker 3: by the Court in the coming years, but it certainly
- 9:36Speaker 3: was on top of mind for some of the justices.
- 9:40Speaker 3: Justice Kagan asked, specifically of the public defender who was
- 9:43Speaker 3: challenging the law, well, you say that bans are not
- 9:47Speaker 3: constitutionally permissible of the sort, But what about mentally ill
- 9:50Speaker 3: people who have been prohibited? Is that okay? And the
- 9:53Speaker 3: attorney kind of hedged, prompting Justice Kagan to say that
- 9:56Speaker 3: you're running away from your own argument because of its
- 9:59Speaker 3: unt doable consequences. And indeed, I think it was very
- 10:03Speaker 3: much on top of mind for the justices that if
- 10:05Speaker 3: they struck down this law, it would be hard to
- 10:08Speaker 3: figure out how they would uphold bans on felons possessing firearms,
- 10:12Speaker 3: or bands on drug abusers possessing firearms, and even something
- 10:16Speaker 3: like background checks, because again, we didn't have such laws
- 10:20Speaker 3: or really anything like them in the seventeen and eighteen hundreds.
- 10:23Speaker 1: Yeah, Justice Kavanaugh expressed concerns about that. Did any of
- 10:27Speaker 1: the other justices talk about background checks?
- 10:30Speaker 3: No, that was only if I recall correctly. Justice Kavanaugh,
- 10:33Speaker 3: who asked about historical ban on sale and the attorney
- 10:38Speaker 3: challenging the domestic violence restraining order ban in this case, said, well,
- 10:42Speaker 3: there is a stronger historical tradition to regulate commercial sales.
- 10:47Speaker 3: But at the same time, he said, well, we're dealing
- 10:49Speaker 3: with a ban on possession of firearms in the home,
- 10:52Speaker 3: And he said, there really isn't any history and tradition
- 10:55Speaker 3: of bans on people having firearms in their own home.
- 11:00Speaker 1: So if you had to guess, would you guess that
- 11:02Speaker 1: it's going to be a limited opinion or a broader opinion.
- 11:06Speaker 3: If you were to guess, I would say this is
- 11:08Speaker 3: likely to be a nine to nothing, maybe eight to
- 11:11Speaker 3: one or seven to two opinion. And I think because
- 11:14Speaker 3: of that, the larger the majority, the less likely it
- 11:17Speaker 3: is to be very far reaching. That it may be
- 11:20Speaker 3: one of these cases that gets assigned to Justice Gorsich
- 11:23Speaker 3: to just do as little damage as possible to the
- 11:25Speaker 3: bruined test. But I do think that this case was
- 11:28Speaker 3: no matter how big the majority is, to uphold the
- 11:31Speaker 3: federal law here. If indeed the court does uphold the
- 11:34Speaker 3: federal law here, it will be very good news for
- 11:37Speaker 3: gun safety reform advocates. They've been struggling to defend gun
- 11:41Speaker 3: laws in courtss on guns without serial numbers, bans on
- 11:45Speaker 3: assault weapons. Even last week, a court struck down the
- 11:48Speaker 3: restriction on felons possessing firearms. So if the Court does
- 11:51Speaker 3: move to this higher level of generality, it says that
- 11:54Speaker 3: government can prohibit people who are dangerous from having firearms,
- 11:58Speaker 3: it would provide a basis for defend a lot of
- 12:00Speaker 3: core gun laws that we really rely on in modern
- 12:04Speaker 3: twenty first century America and adam.
- 12:06Speaker 1: Last week, the Supreme Court agreed to decide the fate
- 12:10Speaker 1: of the federal criminal ban on bump stocks, the attachments
- 12:14Speaker 1: that let a semi automatic rifle fire much like a
- 12:18Speaker 1: machine gun. What do you make of that? Do you
- 12:20Speaker 1: make anything of it?
- 12:21Speaker 2: No?
- 12:21Speaker 3: I don't make much of it. I think that is
- 12:23Speaker 3: really an administrative.
- 12:24Speaker 2: Law case, and it's about whether.
- 12:26Speaker 3: The administrative agency went too far in interpreting its powers
- 12:31Speaker 3: under the Gun Control Act and other federal statutes that
- 12:34Speaker 3: regulate firearms. And so I think that although they both
- 12:38Speaker 3: deal with firearms regulation, both these cases they're very different.
- 12:42Speaker 3: One's a Second Amendment case that's going to be decided
- 12:44Speaker 3: on Second Amendment grounds, and how huge impact on how
- 12:47Speaker 3: other Second Amendment cases are handled. Whatever the Court does
- 12:50Speaker 3: on the bump stocks will be much more important for
- 12:53Speaker 3: administrative law and the scope of administrative agency authority under
- 12:57Speaker 3: the Constitution and thus will have a much bigger impact
- 13:01Speaker 3: well beyond guns, to all sorts of regulatory areas where
- 13:04Speaker 3: administrative agencies weigh in.
- 13:07Speaker 1: There are certainly a lot of administrative law cases this term.
- 13:11Speaker 1: Thanks so much, Adam, I always appreciate your insights. That's
- 13:14Speaker 1: UCLA law professor Adam Winkler. California has been a leader
- 13:18Speaker 1: in legislation benefiting undocumented residents, such as allowing them to
- 13:23Speaker 1: get driver's licenses. Now, the state's higher education system is
- 13:27Speaker 1: looking to be their largest employer by relying on an
- 13:31Speaker 1: untested legal theory. University of California regents are fast approaching
- 13:36Speaker 1: a self imposed deadline of November thirtieth to issue a
- 13:40Speaker 1: plan that makes the school system the first public institution
- 13:44Speaker 1: to hire students and staff regardless of their legal immigration status.
- 13:49Speaker 1: What you means, immigration law expert Leon Fresco, a partner
- 13:52Speaker 1: at Hollanden Knight. Leon explained this plan or this plan
- 13:57Speaker 1: that's forming, Well.
- 13:59Speaker 2: Here's what happening. The government of the state of California
- 14:03Speaker 2: is trying to take an interesting legal argument in order
- 14:08Speaker 2: to be able to have their state institutions such as
- 14:12Speaker 2: their state universities be able to employ undocumented individuals within
- 14:17Speaker 2: their universities, and they're trying to do that on the
- 14:21Speaker 2: basis of a novel legal argument that the federal immigration
- 14:25Speaker 2: law doesn't apply to them.
- 14:27Speaker 1: There's a federal law that makes it illegal for employers
- 14:30Speaker 1: to knowingly recruit or hire undocumented workers.
- 14:35Speaker 2: So basically here's what happens. So eight USC. Section thirteen
- 14:38Speaker 2: twenty four to a is the title of the Immigration Code,
- 14:42Speaker 2: where they say that no employer can hire for wages
- 14:48Speaker 2: for actual labor foreign nationals unless they actually have been
- 14:53Speaker 2: given authorization to work in the United States. But either
- 14:57Speaker 2: they have to be a citizen, a lawful permanent resident,
- 14:59Speaker 2: or or they have to possess a document from the
- 15:03Speaker 2: federal government that permits them to lawfully work in the
- 15:06Speaker 2: United States. That if not, the employer can be subject
- 15:09Speaker 2: to a host of fines and potentially prison time. But
- 15:13Speaker 2: what the state of California is saying for its universities
- 15:17Speaker 2: and its other state institutions, potentially, what they're saying is
- 15:21Speaker 2: that they are not subject to that law. Because there
- 15:25Speaker 2: are a number of Supreme Court cases in other contexts
- 15:29Speaker 2: that talk about when the federal government wants to subject
- 15:34Speaker 2: state governments to various policies and employment laws and other
- 15:39Speaker 2: things that they actually have to say that. And so
- 15:42Speaker 2: the fact that the federal government didn't say that specifically
- 15:46Speaker 2: here that state governments and local governments are considered employers,
- 15:51Speaker 2: the idea would be that perhaps the state governments and
- 15:54Speaker 2: local governments don't then have the duty to verify the
- 15:58Speaker 2: employment authors status of employees in order to hire them
- 16:04Speaker 2: as legal workers in those institutions.
- 16:06Speaker 1: Where would the federal government mention the states explicitly?
- 16:09Speaker 2: Would They would have to say it in the statue.
- 16:11Speaker 2: So the statue just says any employer. And so the
- 16:15Speaker 2: question is does any employer specifically include the states or
- 16:19Speaker 2: does it not? Because there is the argument that and
- 16:23Speaker 2: this would have to be for the courts to decide
- 16:26Speaker 2: that in addition to saying any employer, the statue would
- 16:29Speaker 2: also actually specifically have to say any employer includes state
- 16:34Speaker 2: and local public entities.
- 16:37Speaker 1: Do you think that that's a very broad reading?
- 16:41Speaker 2: Here's the issue. There are so many cases on the
- 16:45Speaker 2: flip side of the issue of what state governments are
- 16:49Speaker 2: permitted to do visa the immigration law, the main one
- 16:53Speaker 2: being Arizona versus the United states, which says states can't
- 16:57Speaker 2: take matters into their own hands to enforce immigration law.
- 17:02Speaker 2: And then you have the Fifth Circuit case where Texas
- 17:05Speaker 2: had sued the Obama administration about not having sufficient border funding.
- 17:11Speaker 2: And there have been a number of cases about states standing,
- 17:15Speaker 2: et cetera, where the courts have not been amenable to
- 17:20Speaker 2: these issues of states taking matters into their own hands
- 17:24Speaker 2: visa the immigration law and saying that laws either apply
- 17:28Speaker 2: or don't apply to them. Basically, the federal government has
- 17:31Speaker 2: been given by the courts this large authority to say,
- 17:35Speaker 2: here's what the immigration law is, here's who it applies to,
- 17:39Speaker 2: here's who it doesn't apply to. And so it will
- 17:41Speaker 2: be interesting to see if California does this, could it
- 17:45Speaker 2: survive a court talent. But an actual other interesting question
- 17:48Speaker 2: is would Divide the administration actually engage in a court
- 17:53Speaker 2: talente against the state of California or would it just
- 17:57Speaker 2: simply let sleeping dogs lie and not do anything and
- 18:00Speaker 2: wait for some subsequent administration to do it. So there's
- 18:03Speaker 2: a lot to be considered here because it's not necessarily
- 18:07Speaker 2: intuitive that the Biden administration would sanction California for doing this.
- 18:13Speaker 2: So both things would have to be seen A. Would
- 18:15Speaker 2: California do this? B Would the Biden administration either engage
- 18:20Speaker 2: in employment sanctions or engage in some other declaratory or
- 18:24Speaker 2: injunctive relief court case to try to get this practice
- 18:27Speaker 2: end and then see who would prevail if those two
- 18:30Speaker 2: things actually end up happening in an election year.
- 18:33Speaker 1: It seems unlikely that the Biden administration would go after California.
- 18:38Speaker 2: Do you think, I mean, it seems very difficult to
- 18:42Speaker 2: think that it would happen immediately. I think it's the
- 18:45Speaker 2: kind of thing where they would say, look, we're taking
- 18:47Speaker 2: it under advisement, we're investigating the claim, et cetera. And
- 18:52Speaker 2: then the issue is would there be sufficient political pressure
- 18:55Speaker 2: for them to actually go in and soothe the State
- 18:58Speaker 2: of California because there's too to initiate this. You could
- 19:01Speaker 2: either sue the State of California for declaratory slash injunctive
- 19:05Speaker 2: relief on their just general program that permits this, or
- 19:09Speaker 2: you could actually go to the employers the way I
- 19:12Speaker 2: does when any employer is hiring undocumented people, and just
- 19:16Speaker 2: actually do an enforcement action and say hey, stop employing
- 19:20Speaker 2: these people, and then you know the state can do
- 19:24Speaker 2: the litigation. So either way. Both of those are options,
- 19:28Speaker 2: and it would be very interesting to see how the
- 19:30Speaker 2: Biden administration would respond to this, or maybe they would
- 19:33Speaker 2: do nothing. And I don't have an immediate inclination like
- 19:38Speaker 2: I usually do on what would happen, because I think
- 19:40Speaker 2: it's just such a new possibility that I don't think
- 19:44Speaker 2: the Biden administration is prepared for or ready to consider
- 19:47Speaker 2: this yet.
- 19:48Speaker 1: Could California taxpayers sue? I'm looking for a group that
- 19:52Speaker 1: would have standing to sue.
- 19:55Speaker 2: Well, here's the problem. I don't know that California taxpayers
- 19:59Speaker 2: would have to stand to sue under this same now
- 20:02Speaker 2: Biden versus Texas decision that dealt with generally this issue
- 20:07Speaker 2: of prosecutorial discretion and that being the federal government's role.
- 20:12Speaker 2: If you recall earlier this year, the Supreme Court said
- 20:15Speaker 2: that the states can't get involved in forcing the federal
- 20:20Speaker 2: government to enforce immigration law when they believe that the
- 20:24Speaker 2: federal government is not sufficiently enforcing immigration law. And so
- 20:28Speaker 2: I don't know if taxpayers can do it. Here's an
- 20:31Speaker 2: interesting group that might be able to do it is
- 20:34Speaker 2: that if there was some sort of labor union that
- 20:37Speaker 2: would be formed that would say we're having to compete
- 20:40Speaker 2: against these undocumented workers for jobs. Perhaps they can do
- 20:45Speaker 2: it because there have been labor unions that have sued
- 20:49Speaker 2: under similar theories and they've been allowed to have standing
- 20:52Speaker 2: in the courts to do that. So I do think
- 20:55Speaker 2: perhaps if anti immigrants folks can form some sort of
- 20:59Speaker 2: labor union or consortium of workers, or can convince one
- 21:04Speaker 2: of the labor unions to sue, it's possible that that
- 21:07Speaker 2: group would have standing in order to do this.
- 21:10Speaker 1: This is a very elemental question, but they'll be getting
- 21:14Speaker 1: taxes taken out. Do undocumented people file taxes?
- 21:20Speaker 2: Well? This is always one of the fascinating parts of
- 21:24Speaker 2: undocumented migration is that to the extent that income gets
- 21:28Speaker 2: withheld from undocumented immigrants, which actually happens all the time
- 21:33Speaker 2: because it happens under two different regimes. One would be
- 21:37Speaker 2: that the undocumented immigrant gets this thing called a TIN,
- 21:41Speaker 2: a taxpayer identification number, which is basically out in the open.
- 21:46Speaker 2: Everybody's admitting that there's money coming in to the undocumented
- 21:50Speaker 2: immigrants and it's going under this tax payer identification number,
- 21:54Speaker 2: and it's basically the employer and the employee's saying, look,
- 21:58Speaker 2: we may have many other legal problem, but we don't
- 22:00Speaker 2: have a tax problem. We're doing everything right tax wise.
- 22:04Speaker 2: That's one potential option. The other option that happens already
- 22:10Speaker 2: is many times undocumented people will actually take somebody's Social
- 22:14Speaker 2: Security number and just use it, and some money's being
- 22:17Speaker 2: paid on that number, but it's not that person who's working.
- 22:21Speaker 2: And so what I'm saying is the federal government is
- 22:24Speaker 2: making money off of that work, and it's not actually
- 22:27Speaker 2: paying any benefits. So what actually ends up becoming very
- 22:30Speaker 2: interesting is when the Congress proposes these bills to legalize
- 22:35Speaker 2: undocumented people for some period of time, this actually becomes
- 22:39Speaker 2: a huge revenue raiser. There's all this money being paid
- 22:42Speaker 2: in in payroll taxes and there's no money being paid out.
- 22:45Speaker 2: But eventually, once people get citizenship, then they end up
- 22:50Speaker 2: being able to accrue that money back. But if they
- 22:52Speaker 2: don't end up ever becoming citizens and these people end
- 22:55Speaker 2: up becoming unlawful for their whole lives and just working
- 22:59Speaker 2: at California state institutions, this actually becomes a huge revenue
- 23:03Speaker 2: raiser for the federal government.
- 23:05Speaker 1: Oddly enough, coming up, I'll continue this conversation with Leon Fresco.
- 23:10Speaker 1: What might a budget compromise on immigration look like I'm
- 23:14Speaker 1: Jim Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg. I've been talking
- 23:17Speaker 1: to Leon Fresco of Holland and Knight about California's higher
- 23:21Speaker 1: education system, looking at a plan that would make the
- 23:24Speaker 1: school system the first public institution to hire students and
- 23:28Speaker 1: staff regardless of their legal immigration status. It would rely
- 23:33Speaker 1: on an untested legal theory. Lee, I have another very
- 23:37Speaker 1: basic question. So I was reading about all these undocumented students.
- 23:44Speaker 1: They're in graduate programs. You know, some states are paying
- 23:47Speaker 1: their tuition. Is there any danger ever? I mean, do
- 23:51Speaker 1: they live in fear of ice knocking at their door
- 23:55Speaker 1: or is that not a thing anymore?
- 23:58Speaker 2: Well, so I would say here the components of this one.
- 24:01Speaker 2: There's a number of these young people who are protected
- 24:04Speaker 2: under DACAS, So those people have zero fear at the moment,
- 24:08Speaker 2: other than that DACAS could end up finally being stricken
- 24:11Speaker 2: by the Supreme Court when it gets there. That's working
- 24:14Speaker 2: its way up to the court. And there are court ruling
- 24:16Speaker 2: saying that doca's illegal, but that are stayed pending Supreme
- 24:20Speaker 2: Court review. So there's that. But I mean, there's not
- 24:23Speaker 2: an immediate fear, but there's a sort of longer term fear.
- 24:27Speaker 2: Then there's the group of people who say, well, at
- 24:30Speaker 2: least it's the Biden administration, and the Biden administration has
- 24:34Speaker 2: this sensitive location policy where they say they won't go
- 24:37Speaker 2: into places like schools or courts or churches to deport people,
- 24:44Speaker 2: So at least while those individuals are in school, they
- 24:47Speaker 2: have some sense of security that they feel that ICE
- 24:50Speaker 2: won't actually engage them in these locations to try to
- 24:54Speaker 2: deport them. And then there's the third situation, which is, okay, well,
- 24:57Speaker 2: what would happen if either these folks are detained not
- 25:00Speaker 2: in their university, or perhaps the Trump administration comes in
- 25:04Speaker 2: and changes all these rules, Well, then that's the whole
- 25:07Speaker 2: third bucket. But for the moment, people are in these
- 25:11Speaker 2: usually these first two buckets because they're either protected by
- 25:14Speaker 2: the fact that they're on the school campus or even
- 25:17Speaker 2: further protected by the fact that they currently have DAKA.
- 25:20Speaker 1: And California has been a leader in legislation benefiting undocumented residents.
- 25:28Speaker 2: Yes, and they have these two main laws that they're
- 25:31Speaker 2: known for. One is this thing called the Trust Act,
- 25:35Speaker 2: which is this huge sanctuary state enforcement regime which basically
- 25:40Speaker 2: says that unless the person is a very very violent criminal.
- 25:44Speaker 2: No state or local authorities of any kind are permitted
- 25:48Speaker 2: to interact with ICE or assist ICE in any way,
- 25:51Speaker 2: shape or form with regards to ICE's ability to detain
- 25:56Speaker 2: or remove foreign nationals who shouldn't be in the United
- 25:59Speaker 2: Slate State. So that's one main thing that they do,
- 26:03Speaker 2: and then the second main thing that they do has
- 26:05Speaker 2: to be on the benefit side. They provide undocumented people
- 26:09Speaker 2: with healthcare under the California Emergency Medicaid program, and they
- 26:14Speaker 2: also are very generous with regard to their policies in
- 26:20Speaker 2: terms of not allowing private detention facility companies to get
- 26:24Speaker 2: licenses to operate in California, and in terms of giving
- 26:29Speaker 2: people scholarships and things of this nature. So there's all
- 26:33Speaker 2: kinds of ways that they impede immigration enforcement but also
- 26:38Speaker 2: encourage people to live in California even if they do
- 26:41Speaker 2: not have lawful immigration sidus.
- 26:44Speaker 1: So what's happening at the border, Because there are so
- 26:48Speaker 1: many other crises going on, there hasn't been as much
- 26:51Speaker 1: focus on it, but is immigration up.
- 26:55Speaker 2: Well, yes, the numbers are very high on the border
- 26:58Speaker 2: at the moment, and so what's had is we're going
- 27:00Speaker 2: to have a very interesting confluence for November fifteen, which
- 27:04Speaker 2: is when the government funding is supposed to run out,
- 27:07Speaker 2: which is that the current news Speaker of the House
- 27:09Speaker 2: Johnson is saying that there has to be something on
- 27:13Speaker 2: the border done in order for funding to continue for
- 27:16Speaker 2: the federal government and the Biden administration and appropriators who
- 27:20Speaker 2: I've actually personally spoken to the Democratic side realized that
- 27:24Speaker 2: probably something is going to have to get here, and
- 27:27Speaker 2: the kinds of things they're talking about deal with this
- 27:31Speaker 2: process of this initial screening of people instead of just
- 27:36Speaker 2: saying that if you articulate any kind of claim, you
- 27:40Speaker 2: get to stay in the country, raising the states on
- 27:43Speaker 2: how detailed and how direritorious the claim has to be
- 27:48Speaker 2: in order to initially be able to stay in the
- 27:51Speaker 2: United States. There's a lot of conversation about this, and
- 27:54Speaker 2: there's also a lot of conversation about this theme we've
- 27:57Speaker 2: been talking about in the past, about keeping people in
- 28:00Speaker 2: nic attention if they have no place to go, if
- 28:04Speaker 2: they don't have a sponsor who's going to agree to
- 28:06Speaker 2: house them. And so I think both of those areas
- 28:09Speaker 2: are areas that are actually legitimately being talked about by
- 28:14Speaker 2: Democrats and Republicans. I don't know if there will end
- 28:17Speaker 2: up being in agreement, But I think there is some
- 28:19Speaker 2: understanding now for the first time that there's going to
- 28:22Speaker 2: need to be some movement there in order to send
- 28:25Speaker 2: the tide of what's happening on the border, because.
- 28:27Speaker 1: We've discussed this before, and there was a New York
- 28:30Speaker 1: Times article about how some of the migrants are coming
- 28:35Speaker 1: with addresses that they've been given from other migrants so
- 28:39Speaker 1: that they could show them and say, oh, I have
- 28:42Speaker 1: a place to go, and it's not actually true, it's
- 28:45Speaker 1: just an address.
- 28:47Speaker 2: Correct. The idea is that you will actually need a
- 28:50Speaker 2: US citizen or lawful permanent residence to come forward and say,
- 28:54Speaker 2: here's my income, here's my residence, here's an affidavit or
- 28:58Speaker 2: my license or whatever that shows on me, and that
- 29:01Speaker 2: I'm willing to actually sponsor this human being in my house.
- 29:05Speaker 2: So this is the kind of thing that's being contemplated
- 29:07Speaker 2: right now. Those discussions are happening, but we'll have to
- 29:10Speaker 2: see if they end up happening, because there's a lot
- 29:14Speaker 2: of pressure also on the left flank of the Democratic
- 29:16Speaker 2: Party not to do it without some sweetener in exchange,
- 29:21Speaker 2: and the kinds of sweeteners they're talking about. Our DACA,
- 29:23Speaker 2: which the Republicans will never do. And so there's other
- 29:27Speaker 2: sweeteners that are less in terms of at least giving
- 29:29Speaker 2: people who can make it through a higher threshold at
- 29:33Speaker 2: the beginning. Well, if they can make it through, then
- 29:35Speaker 2: allow it to work on day one so that there
- 29:38Speaker 2: isn't this idle period where they're not working. That's very
- 29:42Speaker 2: interesting stuff, and so that's potentially a compromise, but we'll
- 29:45Speaker 2: have to see what happens.
- 29:47Speaker 1: So today the Ninth circu is going to hear arguments
- 29:50Speaker 1: challenging the Biden administration's asylum ban. YEP, tell us a
- 29:55Speaker 1: little bit about this and where you think this is going.
- 29:57Speaker 2: The Biden administration has tried to have sort of a
- 30:00Speaker 2: carrots and sixth approach where they tell people move to
- 30:04Speaker 2: the ports of entry to ask for asylum so that
- 30:08Speaker 2: you don't have to actually sneak across the border to
- 30:11Speaker 2: do it, because we don't want you doing that, and
- 30:13Speaker 2: if you do do that, we won't let you actually
- 30:15Speaker 2: apply for asylum. And so there's a ban on that.
- 30:21Speaker 2: And the Trump administration had tried this. There was some
- 30:25Speaker 2: preliminary discussion during the Trump administration and an initial Ninth
- 30:29Speaker 2: Circuit decision saying that it was illegal to have this
- 30:32Speaker 2: kind of asylum ban because the statue says anybody can
- 30:36Speaker 2: apply for asylum even if you've crossed illegally, and so
- 30:39Speaker 2: that you can't make crossing the border illegally one of
- 30:43Speaker 2: the discretionary factors later that you can use to deny asylum,
- 30:47Speaker 2: which is what the Bite administration has tried to do
- 30:50Speaker 2: and has what the Trump administration tried to do previously.
- 30:53Speaker 2: And so this is now going for renewed consideration in
- 30:57Speaker 2: the Ninth Circus to try to see if this is
- 30:59Speaker 2: true true, and it will eventually make its way to
- 31:02Speaker 2: the Supreme Court because the Biden administration definitely wants to
- 31:06Speaker 2: be able to have this asylum ban in place. Now,
- 31:09Speaker 2: what's interesting is this asylum ban doesn't actually end up
- 31:13Speaker 2: banning anybody. It just says you can't get asylum. You
- 31:17Speaker 2: can get something else called withholding of removal that allows
- 31:20Speaker 2: you to say. It just doesn't give you a pass
- 31:23Speaker 2: to a green card or citizenship or being able to
- 31:26Speaker 2: petition for your relatives. But at least you are able
- 31:29Speaker 2: to say. And so I don't know how much of
- 31:32Speaker 2: a deterrence this ends up being, and at least sumerically,
- 31:35Speaker 2: we've seen it hasn't been much of a deterrence because
- 31:38Speaker 2: at the end, it's not that really people are coming
- 31:41Speaker 2: here for quote unquote asylum. They're coming here to quote
- 31:44Speaker 2: unquote stay, and so that ability to say isn't hampered
- 31:49Speaker 2: by this asylum man. It's only the ability to get
- 31:52Speaker 2: a green card or citizenship or be able to apply
- 31:55Speaker 2: for your relatives that's hampered by this asylum ban.
- 32:00Speaker 1: I haven't come up with an immigration question yet that
- 32:02Speaker 1: you haven't been able to answer, Leon, but I'll keep
- 32:05Speaker 1: striving toward that. Thanks so much. That's Leon Fresco, a
- 32:09Speaker 1: partner at Hollanda Knight. And that's it for this edition
- 32:12Speaker 1: of The Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always get
- 32:15Speaker 1: the latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast. You
- 32:18Speaker 1: can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www
- 32:22Speaker 1: dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast Slash Law, and remember
- 32:26Speaker 1: to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at
- 32:29Speaker 1: ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and you're
- 32:33Speaker 1: listening to Bloomberg