Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / Edward II Didn’t Die at Berkeley Castle: The 700‑Year Cover‑Up
Transcript
- 0:00On September 21st, 1327, King Edward the Second of England
- 0:04died at Berkeley Castle and one of the most brutal executions in
- 0:09medieval history. According to the official story,
- 0:11his captors held him down and inserted a red hot poker into
- 0:15his body, a method designed to kill him without leaving
- 0:20external marks. It was the perfect political
- 0:23murder, except nobody ever saw his face at the funeral.
- 0:26His widow, Queen Isabella, the woman who'd overthrown him,
- 0:30refused to allow a state funeral with an open casket.
- 0:34And three years later, the Earl of Kent was executed for treason
- 0:38because he believed Edward was still alive and tried to rescue
- 0:42him. And there's this, a letter
- 0:44written by an Italian Bishop claiming Edward escaped to
- 0:47Europe and lived as a hermit for 14 more years.
- 0:51But here's the question nobody wants to ask.
- 0:54If Edward the Second died at Berkeley Castle, what if his own
- 0:58wife staged his murder to keep him from ever reclaiming his
- 1:02throne? Today we're investigating one of
- 1:04medieval England's greatest conspiracies, and by the end,
- 1:09you'll see how this 700 year old playbook is still being used
- 1:13today. I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate.
- 1:15I investigate the hidden forces behind history, from royal
- 1:19murders and lost colonies to modern elites, NGOs and
- 1:24propaganda. And this is the hidden truth
- 1:27about Edward the Second. Welcome back to the Jeremy Ryan
- 1:48Slate show. I'm your host Jeremy Ryan Slate,
- 1:50the CEO and Co founder of Command Your Brand.
- 1:54We help our clients to appear on some of the biggest podcasts out
- 1:57there. You want to see how we can help
- 1:58you? Grab our free brand authority
- 2:01analysis. Head over to
- 2:02commandyourbrand.com/analysis. Reminder if you're brand new to
- 2:07this channel to like this video, leave us a comment and smash
- 2:11that subscribe button if you want to learn more of history's
- 2:14mysteries. So let me give you the version
- 2:17they teach in the history books. Edward the Second became king of
- 2:20England in 13 O seven. He was a disaster from the
- 2:23start, militarily weak, politically incompetent, and
- 2:28obsessed with his male favorites to the point where he ignored
- 2:32his royal duties. His biggest mistake?
- 2:35Elevating Hugh the Spencer the younger to become the most
- 2:39powerful man in England. The Spencer wasn't just Edward's
- 2:42favorite. He was ruthless, corrupt, and
- 2:45used the King's protection to seize lands and wealth from
- 2:49English nobles. This included lands belonging to
- 2:52Edward's own wife, Isabella of France.
- 2:56By 1325, Isabella had enough. Edward sent her to France to
- 3:00negotiate a peace treaty with her brother, King Charles the
- 3:044th. But instead of coming back, she
- 3:06stayed in Paris and started plotting.
- 3:10She found an ally, Richard Mortimer, an exiled English
- 3:13Baron who'd escaped from the Tower of London.
- 3:16Together they became lovers and Co conspirators.
- 3:20In September 1326, Isabella and Mortimer invaded England with a
- 3:25small army. And here's what's remarkable
- 3:28they barely had to fight. English nobles flocked to
- 3:31Isabella's banner. Why?
- 3:33Because they hated Dispenser more than they feared treason.
- 3:37Within weeks, Edward's support collapsed.
- 3:41Edward and Dispenser fled W trying to escape to Ireland.
- 3:45They didn't make it. In November 1326, they were
- 3:49captured in Wales. Dispenser was executed
- 3:53immediately hanged, drawn, and quartered in one of the most
- 3:57brutal public executions medieval England had ever seen.
- 4:01Edward was imprisoned. On January 20th, 1327,
- 4:06Parliament forced Edward to abdicate in favor as his 14 year
- 4:10old son, who became Edward the Third.
- 4:12But here's the problem. Edward the Second was still
- 4:15alive. As long as he lived, he was a
- 4:18threat. Nobles who regretted supporting
- 4:20Isabella could rally behind him. Foreign powers could use him as
- 4:23a pawn. His son could restore him when
- 4:27he came of age. Isabella and Mortimer had
- 4:30overthrown a king, but they hadn't eliminated the threat.
- 4:34So Edward was moved to Berkeley Castle in Gloucestershire, under
- 4:37the custody of Lord Thomas Berkeley and two of Mortimer's
- 4:41men, Sir John Moultrievers and Sir Thomas Gurney.
- 4:45And that's for the official story says he died.
- 4:48According to the chroniclers writing years later, on the
- 4:50night of September 21st, 1327, Edward the Second was murdered
- 4:55in his cell. The method?
- 4:57A red hot poker inserted into his body through a horn designed
- 5:01to kill him internally without leaving visible marks on his
- 5:05corpse. So why this method?
- 5:07Because Edward was technically still a king.
- 5:10His murderers needed his death to look natural so they could
- 5:14display the body and prove he was dead.
- 5:17Except that's not what happened. Red flag number one is that
- 5:21nobody saw his face. When Edward's body was displayed
- 5:25at Berkeley Castle and later at Gloucester, the face was
- 5:29covered. The official reason?
- 5:31While the body had been embalmed and needed time to be properly
- 5:35prepared. But here's what's strange.
- 5:38Medieval royal funerals always featured open caskets.
- 5:42The whole point was for witnesses to confirm the king
- 5:45was actually dead. Queen Isabella herself refused
- 5:49to attend the funeral. She stayed away from Gloucester
- 5:52entirely. Why would a widow refuse to see
- 5:55her husband's body unless she knew it wasn't really him?
- 5:59Red flag number 2 is Lord Berkeley's denial.
- 6:02In 1330, when Isabella and Mortimer's regime finally fell,
- 6:07Lord Thomas Berkeley was questioned about Edward's death.
- 6:10His answer? He claimed he wasn't even at
- 6:13Berkeley Castle when Edward died.
- 6:15He said he was away, and when he returned he was told the king
- 6:19had died of natural causes. Think about that.
- 6:23The man officially in charge of guarding Edward the Second
- 6:26claimed he didn't know Edward had been murdered, even though
- 6:30supposedly happened in his own castle.
- 6:33Either Berkeley was lying to save himself, or Edward's death
- 6:37was staged by Moultrieveres and Gurney without Berkeley's actual
- 6:42knowledge. Red flag #3 is the Earl of
- 6:45Kent's execution. Here's where it gets really
- 6:48interesting. In 1330, three years after
- 6:51Edward supposedly died, Edmund the Earl of Kent was executed
- 6:55for treason. His crime?
- 6:57Plotting to rescue Edward the Second because he believed
- 7:01Edward was still alive. Now you might be thinking Kent
- 7:06was just delusional and a conspiracy theorist, but here's
- 7:10the problem. Kent wasn't some random noble.
- 7:13He was Edward the Second's own half brother.
- 7:16He had access to court intelligence, he had connections
- 7:19to people who would know the truth.
- 7:22And according to records, Kent wasn't alone.
- 7:25Several senior clergy members and nobles also believed Edward
- 7:29was alive in 1329 to 1330. They were communicating with
- 7:33someone they believed was Edward, and they were planning
- 7:37to restore him. Why would Edward's own brother
- 7:40and multiple high-ranking officials believe he was alive
- 7:43unless there was evidence he'd survived?
- 7:46The official story is that they were tricked by Mortimer's
- 7:50agents into believing Edward lived so that Mortimer could
- 7:53expose and execute them as traitors.
- 7:56But here's another explanation. They believed Edward was alive
- 8:00because he was alive in the 14th century.
- 8:03A letter surface that changes everything.
- 8:06It's called the Fieski letter, written by Manuela Fieski, an
- 8:10Italian Bishop and papal notary who had connections to the
- 8:14English court. The letter was addressed to
- 8:17Edward the third Edward the second son, and it tells a very
- 8:20different story at what happened at Berkeley Castle, Berda
- 8:24Fieski, on the night Edward was supposed to have been murdered.
- 8:28His guards, maltrevers and Gurney came to kill him, but
- 8:33Edward's Porter warned him. Edward killed one of the guards,
- 8:36escaped through a window and fled.
- 8:39He made his way to Ireland, then to France, and eventually to
- 8:43Italy, where he lived as a hermit in various monasteries.
- 8:48Fieski claims he personally met Edward and heard this story
- 8:52directly from him. Now, historians have debated the
- 8:55Fieski letter for centuries. Some say it's genuine, others
- 9:00call it a forgery or a fantasy. But here's what we know for
- 9:03certain. One, the letter contains details
- 9:07about Edwards imprisonment that weren't widely known, suggesting
- 9:11the author had inside information. 2 Manuela Fieski
- 9:15was a real person with documented connections to the
- 9:19English court and the papacy. He wasn't some random forger. 3
- 9:24The letter was preserved in a French archive, not an English 1
- 9:29suggesting it was never meant to become public propaganda.
- 9:33And finally, 4 If Edward the Third received this letter and
- 9:37believed it might be true, it would explain why he later
- 9:40showed mercy to the some of the people involved in his father's
- 9:44overthrow, including eventually pardoning Multiverse.
- 9:49According to the Fieski letter, Edward lived out his days as a
- 9:52hermit in Italy, moving between monasteries and doing penance
- 9:56for his failures as a king. He never tried to reclaim his
- 9:59throne. He never revealed himself
- 10:01publicly. Why?
- 10:03Because by that point, his son Edward the Third was ruling.
- 10:07Successfully revealing himself would have overthrown England
- 10:11back into chaos. Or because Isabella and Mortimer
- 10:15made it very clear what would happen if he tried to come back.
- 10:20So let's talk about motive. From 1327 to 1330, Isabella and
- 10:24Mortimer ruled England through the teenage Edward the Third.
- 10:28They controlled the Treasury, distributed lands and titles to
- 10:32their supporters, and eliminated anyone who threatened them.
- 10:35As long as ever the Second was alive, whether imprisoned or in
- 10:39hiding, he was a threat to their power.
- 10:42If he was actually dead, they needed people to believe so or
- 10:46no one would try to restore him. If he was alive but hidden, they
- 10:49needed people to believe he was dead for the exact same reason.
- 10:53That's why the Earl of Kent had to die.
- 10:55He was asking too many questions.
- 10:57He had had too much evidence that Edward might actually be
- 11:00alive. Whether Edward was actually
- 11:02alive or not didn't matter. Hence, belief that he was alive
- 11:07made him dangerous. And here's the most interesting
- 11:10part. Edward the Third never
- 11:12investigated his father's death in 1330, when he finally
- 11:16overthrew Isabella and Mortimer. He had Mortimer executed and
- 11:20imprisoned his own mother. But he never put anyone on trial
- 11:24for murdering Edward the Second. Why not?
- 11:27Well, the official explanation is that Edward the Third wanted
- 11:30to move on and unite the Kingdom.
- 11:32But there's another possibility. Edward the Third knew the truth.
- 11:36Or he suspected it and decided it was better for everyone if
- 11:40his father stayed dead. If Edward the Second was alive
- 11:44and living as a hermit in Italy, revealing that truth would have
- 11:48been a disaster. It would have raised questions
- 11:51about Edward the Third's legitimacy.
- 11:53It would have given foreign powers ammunition against
- 11:57England. Better to let the official story
- 12:00stand. So why does the 700 year old
- 12:03conspiracy matter today? Well, it's because the playbook
- 12:06hasn't changed all that much. When powerful people need
- 12:09someone to disappear, they have two options actually.
- 12:13Kill them or make everyone believe they're dead while
- 12:17keeping them alive and hidden. Both achieve the same goal of
- 12:21removing the threat from the board.
- 12:23Think about witness protection programs.
- 12:25When someone becomes too dangerous to prosecute but too
- 12:29valuable to kill, what the governments do?
- 12:32They give them a new identity, relocate them, and officially
- 12:36declare them missing or dead. Or consider high profile deaths
- 12:41where the circumstances are suspicious, the evidence is
- 12:43sealed, and key witnesses will they disappear?
- 12:47The official story gets locked in before anyone can ask hard
- 12:51questions. Look at political dissidents who
- 12:54die in custody under mysterious circumstances, but their bodies
- 12:58are never properly examined, autopsies are blocked, and
- 13:02families are prevented from independently verifying their
- 13:06death. The Edward the Second playbook
- 13:08is simple. One is to remove the threat from
- 13:11public view 2. To control the narrative about
- 13:14what happened 3. To prevent independent
- 13:18verification, 4. To eliminate anyone who
- 13:21questions the official story, and five, to make sure the
- 13:25people in power benefit from the death.
- 13:28Does this sound familiar? Whatever the second case teaches
- 13:31us is that the official history is written by whoever controls
- 13:35the narrative at that moment. Isabella and Mortimer controlled
- 13:39England from 1327 to 1330. During that time, they control
- 13:43what people believed about Edward the Second's death.
- 13:46Even after they fell from power, Edward the Third had reasons to
- 13:50maintain their story rather than expose the truth.
- 13:54And 700 years later, we're still debating what really happened
- 13:58because the people with power successfully controlled the
- 14:03investigation, the evidence and the narrative.
- 14:06That's not ancient history. That's the blueprint.
- 14:09So what really happened to Edward the Second?
- 14:11Here's what we know for certain. His face was never shown at his
- 14:15funeral. His own brother believed he was
- 14:18alive three years later. Multiple nobles and clergy
- 14:23believe he survived. A credible Italian Bishop
- 14:27claimed to have met him in exile.
- 14:29Edward the Third never investigated his father's
- 14:32murder, and the people who supposedly killed him gave
- 14:36contradictory accounts. Did Edward die at Berkeley
- 14:39Castle on September 21st, 1327? Well, maybe.
- 14:44Or did Isabella and Mortimer stage his death, hide him away,
- 14:48and eliminate anyone who got too close to the truth?
- 14:51The evidence suggests the official story is at a minimum
- 14:55and complete, and at a maximum, it's one of the most successful
- 14:59cover ups in medieval history. But here's what matters.
- 15:03Whether Edward died that night or lived for 14 more years as a
- 15:07hermit, the conspiracy worked. Isabella and Mortimer got what
- 15:12they wanted, Edward removed from power permanently.
- 15:16Edward the Third got what he wanted, a stable throne without
- 15:20the chaos of his father's return.
- 15:22And the English nobility got what they wanted, a new regime
- 15:26that protected their interests. Everyone in power benefited from
- 15:31Edward being dead, so he stayed dead officially.
- 15:35That's how elite conspiracies work.
- 15:37It's not about what's true. It's about what serves the
- 15:41people in power and when they control the investigation, the
- 15:45evidence, and the narrative, well, you control history
- 15:49itself. The next time you hear an
- 15:52official story about someone's death, especially when that
- 15:55death is politically convenient, when the evidence is controlled,
- 15:59when the questions are shut down, and when everyone in power
- 16:04benefits from that person being gone, remember Edward the
- 16:08Second? Remember that this playbook is
- 16:10700 years old and ask yourself this.
- 16:13What aren't they telling us? I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate.
- 16:18Keep investigating, keep questioning, and never trust the
- 16:22official story when the powerful write it.