Latest / My Sister's A Therapist- Mental Health, Wellness, and Healing with Humor / Self-Help
Transcript
- 0:01The sister's a therapist and I tell jokes.
- 0:05We both want to help all kinds of folks.
- 0:09Hello and welcome to my sister's a therapist.
- 0:12My name is Virginia Jones. I'm a stand up comedian.
- 0:14I didn't do much school, but my sister's a therapist.
- 0:17Hello, I'm Laura Ryan. I'm a licensed marriage and
- 0:19family therapist, but my main credit is sister to laughter
- 0:23alchemist Virginia Jones. Oh my Lord, I did get an
- 0:26undergrad degree. I'm not in laughter.
- 0:29Alchemy. In laughter, you're rocking me.
- 0:30You know, Eugene Mirman went to a small school in Boston where
- 0:34you can design your own degree and he did get a stand up
- 0:36comedy. Degree.
- 0:38Oh wow, you just watch a bunch of Robin Williams.
- 0:40Video. I have no idea.
- 0:41I have no idea what it was, but you can evidently get one.
- 0:45You watch Eddie Murphy's Raw every week, yeah?
- 0:49You get a watch list your senior year.
- 0:51You watch only Bill Hicks and Billy Connolly and.
- 0:56Stuart Lee got it. Freshman year is Robin Williams
- 0:59and. Eddie Murphy, right?
- 1:01Or the basics. You work your way up.
- 1:04Laura, it's your topic this week.
- 1:06What would you like to talk? About we're going to talk about
- 1:08self help. Is it helpful?
- 1:11Oh, that's interesting. Just my initial thoughts on the
- 1:14topic. I love a good self help book.
- 1:17I've said it before, when you find a book that really
- 1:20addresses something that you've been concerned about about
- 1:22yourself, people love talking about themselves and people love
- 1:25thinking about themselves and I think that that's the joy of a
- 1:27self help book. But does it actually move the
- 1:30needle? I remember reading a study which
- 1:33of course I haven't looked up. It was about those weekend
- 1:36retreats that people go on, where they walk on fiery rocks
- 1:39and in the late 90s. Yeah, everybody was walking on
- 1:44hot. Rocks.
- 1:45They took those people months or years later and just checked in
- 1:49because at the time everyone said I'm forever changed.
- 1:52This is it. And what they found was that
- 1:55none of those people were changed immediately following
- 1:57the workshop. So when you say change, let's
- 2:00define it. First, let's define self help,
- 2:02OK? Self help is the action or
- 2:04process of bettering oneself or overcoming one's problems
- 2:08without the aid of others, especially the coping with one's
- 2:11personal or emotional problems without professional help.
- 2:14Is this just an extended ad for you?
- 2:16Need therapy? Is that what this is?
- 2:18You're just trying to line your pockets.
- 2:21Basically, yes, let's find out self help or self hoax by alonza
- 2:26Bates there's a new realization that has helped me to understand
- 2:29why self help books are only ever intermittently and
- 2:32unpredictably helpful. My suggestion is not to avoid
- 2:35self help books if life isn't going the way you would like it
- 2:38to, It could be helpful to read some inspirational and
- 2:41instructive material. The critical thing to remember
- 2:44is that if someone else's ideas don't work for you, that's not
- 2:47because there's anything wrong with you, it's because they are
- 2:49not your ideas. Take what you want and keep
- 2:52reading. Find another book, walk in the
- 2:54woods, join a club, listen to advice, scour the Internet, go
- 2:57for a run. Eat an orange.
- 2:59And own a seminar that might or might not help you.
- 3:02Make a birdhouse walk on rocks. Do you make the birdhouse in
- 3:06your soul? Yes.
- 3:07What a lot of these authors are saying is that self help is
- 3:10essentially a quote UN quote professionals ideas and anyone
- 3:14can write a self help book like Richard Simmons wrote one.
- 3:18I don't I don't know if that was the move.
- 3:20What is he a professional in? Everyone who can write a self
- 3:23help book is writing it from their perspective, Richard
- 3:26Simmons says. I was fat and unhappy and it was
- 3:28ruining my life. But then I started wearing tiny
- 3:31shorts and running around and it made everything better.
- 3:34Rest in power, Richard Simmons. Richard Simmons, As I've learned
- 3:37recently on one of my favorite podcasts, Maintenance Phase,
- 3:41they did a 2 episode thing about Richard Simmons and he had a
- 3:45really active eating disorder. Apparently all of his hair fell
- 3:48out and he got really, really sick and he was hospitalized.
- 3:51And then According to him, he found the healthy way to
- 3:55maintain his weight loss. I know.
- 3:56There's a lot of messaging to young men that all of your
- 3:59problems will be solved if you go to the gym.
- 4:01Yeah, you will have a nice body if you go to the gym, but that's
- 4:03not a solution for your problems.
- 4:05No the problem with a lot of self help books is they're just
- 4:09written by a person who has no clinical background or isn't a
- 4:13doctor and is just a person. Like what was that woman?
- 4:15Does she look like a cotton ball?
- 4:17Susan powder there you. Go.
- 4:21What was her book? Screaming.
- 4:23No screaming. Insanity.
- 4:25Who stopped the insanity? But the insanity was just about
- 4:27what you were eating. She was only concerned with your
- 4:30body. I have not read a tremendous
- 4:32number of self help books. I think that The Artist's Way
- 4:36has a self help element, but it is mostly about creativity.
- 4:40But of course we talked about it on the show, how much Attached
- 4:45helped me. But that was written by two
- 4:47therapists. I guess I haven't read a lot of
- 4:49self help books just by regular people.
- 4:51The hard thing about that is that a person can tell you what
- 4:54worked for them, but that's not necessarily going to work for
- 4:56you. It's like parents raise you with
- 4:58all the lessons that they learned and everything that they
- 5:01have incorporated in their lives.
- 5:02But that news is 20 years old. Everyone can tell you what they
- 5:06did, but that doesn't mean it's going to be what you can do.
- 5:10So the idea is that self help books are democratic.
- 5:13They reach thousands of people who would never go to a
- 5:15therapist because of inaccessibility, cost, or simply
- 5:18resistance to discussing personal problems with a
- 5:20stranger. The push towards testing is
- 5:22discouraging of lots of would be self help authors because the
- 5:26process is time consuming and expensive.
- 5:28It took two years to test different versions of his book
- 5:31The migraine relief Kohlenberg on hundreds of people.
- 5:34Through the testing, Kohlenberg uncovers what we call the number
- 5:37one problem with self help books, which is a lack of follow
- 5:40through. Even though his subjects were
- 5:43and motivated, only 20% read the entire book and a mere 2 to 4%
- 5:47complied with all the book suggestions.
- 5:49We now know that people do practically none of what you
- 5:52say. In limits in your estimation how
- 5:55much of your suggestions get incorporated into your clients
- 5:59lives? Actually kind of a lot, but I
- 6:01think it's because I'm checking up on them every week.
- 6:04A lot of times I will tell them to read these books and they
- 6:07wouldn't read them except that they know that I'm going to
- 6:09check on them next week and make sure that they do it.
- 6:12Because communication is one way.
- 6:14It's not checking up on you. It doesn't have expectations of
- 6:17you. There's very little motivation
- 6:19to follow through. And I'm not going to say that
- 6:21for me, self help books have not been incredibly helpful because
- 6:24they have. I remember reading a book called
- 6:26Divorce Busting when I was in a very bad marriage.
- 6:29It was really helpful because the perspective was I can't
- 6:33change other people, I can only change myself.
- 6:36That's a profound lesson. It is.
- 6:39It's applied to lots of parts of my life.
- 6:41That little nugget of wisdom has really carried me through a lot
- 6:44of things. I can keep my side of the street
- 6:46clean in our relationship, but I can't keep your side of the
- 6:49street clean. I'm looking at lists of self
- 6:51help books online and just kind of remembering what a social
- 6:55phenomenon some of them were that's just moved on.
- 6:58Men are from Mars, women are from Venus.
- 7:01Absolute crap. Our father was so into this
- 7:04idea, I think because it confirmed for him, yeah, his
- 7:07biases like, Oh well, we're just different.
- 7:09But there's some self help books that have continued to be
- 7:13important. The power of positive thinking,
- 7:16people still talk about. Right now all self help books
- 7:19have the F word in them, starting with The Subtle Art of
- 7:23Not Giving an F, which I've read and enjoyed.
- 7:25How to UN F your life? Well you got to have the F word
- 7:28to really shake people up. Are you writing a self help
- 7:30book? Can you put the F word in the?
- 7:32Title I actually am writing a self help book and my sister
- 7:34encouraged me to take the swear words out.
- 7:37Yes I did because of promoting it on the Internet.
- 7:39People who don't follow all the directions, or even those who do
- 7:43but have an ineffective book often put themselves in a no win
- 7:46situation. If they don't improve after
- 7:48trying a book, they might feel like a failure and find that
- 7:50their problem worsens. Self help books can also be time
- 7:54consuming dead ends. An example, Kohlenberg says, is
- 7:57the trend in affirmations repeating to yourself positive
- 8:01thoughts such as I'm a lovable person in an attempt to improve
- 8:04self esteem. But self affirmations do not
- 8:07help at all with self esteem problems, he says people must
- 8:10instead work on their relationships with other people.
- 8:12That's one of my least favorite things about self help because
- 8:16if I don't truly love myself and I'm just saying it over and over
- 8:19again, it's going to be hollow. I'm not going to take it in and
- 8:22it's going to make absolutely no change in my perspective.
- 8:25There are a lot of great self help books.
- 8:27But I guess my point is, even the best self help book is
- 8:31probably not going to be as good as talking with a friend or
- 8:35seeing a clinician or taking a class or doing something more
- 8:40long term. So tell me more about
- 8:42affirmations. Why don't affirmations work?
- 8:44Because I know people who are very, very.
- 8:47Yeah, our mother is weighing their affirmations, but use her
- 8:51as our case study. She's been doing affirmations
- 8:53since the 80s. Have they helped one bit?
- 8:55Doesn't she keep doing them because they make her feel
- 8:57better in the moment? I think she's doing them because
- 8:59she's trying to stop her negative self talk, but it's not
- 9:02working. You can't tell yourself
- 9:04something that you inherently do not believe, not believe, right?
- 9:06It's not right. Well, it's not going to go in
- 9:08your mind is going to reject it. This is a game that I like to
- 9:11play with my clients. Instead of saying I am a
- 9:14wonderful person and I love myself, I ask myself the
- 9:18question, what if I was a wonderful person and I loved
- 9:20myself because my brain can take that in.
- 9:23It goes, oh, OK, well what if I was this is what I would be
- 9:26doing. This is how my life would be
- 9:27different. But if I'm just saying it and my
- 9:29brain doesn't believe it, it's just going to bat it away and
- 9:32it's going to be completely a waste of time.
- 9:34I guess my thought is a lot of this stuff is just the time
- 9:36suck, where you think I'm investing in myself and I'm
- 9:39doing things, but it's actually not going to go anywhere.
- 9:42Let's talk a little bit about the pleasure of self help
- 9:46because I think it is like astrology.
- 9:49People love reading something and recognizing themselves in
- 9:53it, and they love the belief that that thing is going to help
- 9:56them. I remember when I got divorced,
- 9:59someone told me to read Stop Walking on Egg Shells.
- 10:02But as I was reading it, I realized, Oh my God, my
- 10:04ex-husband had borderline personality disorder, right?
- 10:07It's like she was recording our phone calls or something.
- 10:11And I realized, oh, this is a pattern and this is consistent
- 10:15and this is not about me specifically.
- 10:17This is just the way that he relates to the world.
- 10:19So yeah, that book was incredibly helpful in the way
- 10:23that I perceive the world. Other self help books that I
- 10:26have enjoyed. I'm looking at a list of the top
- 10:28selling self help books on Amazon.
- 10:32Atomic Habits is very popular right now.
- 10:35I have read that it is the idea that you can't achieve a big
- 10:39goal in one day. You need to make incremental
- 10:42movements towards that goal, and I think that that's just good
- 10:45practical advice. Have you ever listened to the
- 10:47podcast If Books Could Kill? No.
- 10:50Well, they broke down Atomic Habits.
- 10:53Really. They hated it so much.
- 10:55Oh, here's an idea, but it doesn't give practical ways to
- 10:57execute. It doesn't capture the nuances
- 11:00of habit building, it just tells you build this.
- 11:02Habit. That's where a coach or a
- 11:05therapist or somebody who's got training would be more effective
- 11:09and more helpful. By the time people come in my
- 11:11office, they've read all the self help books.
- 11:13Yeah, they're still horribly depressed or they're still
- 11:15really struggling because it's not the same.
- 11:18Another top self help book, The Body Keeps the Score.
- 11:22Brain, mind and body. In the healing of trauma.
- 11:24And I know that my sister is a big proponent of that.
- 11:26I am. A big proponent of that book, if
- 11:28I read The Body Keeps the Score and didn't do any kind of
- 11:32somatic work or EMDR therapy, what that would end up doing is
- 11:36I would just keep going. Oh, my body's being triggered.
- 11:39This is an experience for my trauma but I'm not doing
- 11:42anything to. Change it can't resolve it.
- 11:44Another one that I have enjoyed is Buddhism from a guy who lives
- 11:50in the woods in California. The Creative act A Way of Being
- 11:54by Rick Rubin. We were talking about this in an
- 11:56earlier episode. Rick Rubin is a supremely rich
- 11:59guy who has become this low key Buddhist.
- 12:02It has affected his work philosophy and he's like, don't
- 12:04do too much, just try things and don't go in with a lot of
- 12:09expectations of how it's going to be, what will be will be.
- 12:13But it's because he got rich. He got famous, but he didn't get
- 12:17happy, I expect. Well, he got rich by exploiting
- 12:21black people and copying their music and reproducing it with
- 12:24white people. If you talk to white people
- 12:27about how the Beastie Boys are problematic, they get really
- 12:31upset. It's because the Beastie Boys as
- 12:33humans, are decent humans guys. I think if we met them in the
- 12:37early 80s, they probably weren't that.
- 12:39Decent. I tweeted on a website that used
- 12:42to be very popular and it's now gone down the crab hole.
- 12:44I don't trust any white man who really, really likes the Beastie
- 12:48Boys. Six months later, a man came up
- 12:50to me at a Christmas party who's a comic, and he said your tweet
- 12:53about the Beastie Boys really hurt me.
- 12:55Well, you're criticizing white men, which is not I.
- 12:58Guess I'm not supposed to do that.
- 13:00No. If you look at the Beastie Boys
- 13:02objectively when you listen to their music and their interviews
- 13:06lately, not the stuff that they made in the 80s, they are
- 13:09objectively good people and they have interesting ideas and they
- 13:12are expansive in their worldview and they do make really
- 13:16interesting music. But you have to remember that
- 13:19fundamentally what they were doing was being a bunch of
- 13:23affluent Jewish kids who stole music from black people,
- 13:27exploited it, and then became huge artists as a result.
- 13:30Chicken Soup for the Soul was a book that was so popular
- 13:33listener. If the chicken soup books
- 13:37fundamentally changed you as a person, please e-mail in and let
- 13:41us know how much it changed you. The author said chicken soup
- 13:45phrase appeared to him in a dream in which the hand of God
- 13:50scrawled them across a chalkboard.
- 13:52They had chicken soup for the Latino soul, the working woman,
- 13:56the veteran soul. They were incredibly popular for
- 13:59a second. For more than a second, I think
- 14:01it was about 5 to 10 years, he was really making money hand
- 14:03over fist. Chicken soup for the pet lovers
- 14:06soul. They were very popular because
- 14:08they were very positive and warm, unlike chicken soup.
- 14:12Not nourishing, just warm and cozy, right?
- 14:15In the end they went bankrupt because they had overextended
- 14:18and they couldn't. Honestly, I don't think they
- 14:20could think of anyone else's soul that needed chicken soup.
- 14:23Talk about chicken Soup for the Soul a lot in the book The
- 14:27Secret, written by a person. Again, he doesn't have any
- 14:30qualifications. She's just a lady who has, much
- 14:34like the Beastie Boys, stolen a lot of Eastern philosophy,
- 14:37culminated all of it together into this little neat package
- 14:41that Americans like. What we've talked about before
- 14:44is that it's very easy for white women to talk about positive
- 14:48thinking and affirmation and manifesting, because when you're
- 14:52a white woman in the society, things you want tend to come
- 14:54true if you have some money. Or if you marry well, you're
- 14:57like, Oh my. God, I wanted a portion.
- 15:00Now I have one Oh my God. I wanted my kids to get into
- 15:03this private school and now they.
- 15:04Did my boss made us listen to that a lot at work?
- 15:08The audio book of the Secret. This woman is Australian, a Co
- 15:12worker and I used to always go oh I keep getting cheeks in the
- 15:15mile. I'm like string chicks in the
- 15:18mile. And then I open my mailbox and
- 15:22what was it? Loads of chicks in the mail.
- 15:24I don't think you should mail chicks unless you're with a
- 15:27service that does that professionally.
- 15:28Because they need air. They need not to be jostled
- 15:31around too much. What you don't want is a bunch
- 15:33of dead chicks. In the mail.
- 15:34But what if you want chicks in the mail?
- 15:36You write a letter to the universe requesting chicks in
- 15:39the mail. Self help is a very American
- 15:41ideal, and indeed, the idea of helping oneself autonomously
- 15:45seems to be the perfect fit for the independent American spirit.
- 15:48Self help books appeal to the DIY personality, says G Allen
- 15:53Marlett, UW professor of psychology and director of the
- 15:56Addictive Behaviors Research Center.
- 15:59He talks about the fact that there are certain types of self
- 16:02help we should avoid. Avoid books that don't offer
- 16:04data to support their conclusions.
- 16:06They don't have bibliographies, they promise permanent change,
- 16:10and they purport to be the universal answer to the problem.
- 16:12Therefore, The Secret is a book to avoid, because I'm pretty
- 16:16sure it does all. I'm I'm a little resistant to
- 16:19this idea that self help books are never helpful because I have
- 16:24friends who are obsessed with them.
- 16:25Are those friends mentally? Well, I don't know.
- 16:27But I guess one thing that's exciting about self help books
- 16:30is that idea. You've read a book over two
- 16:32days, you've digested it over a weekend, and now the positivity,
- 16:37the optimism of your life starting now.
- 16:40Well, just like when I attend a Tony Robbins workshop and before
- 16:44he essays me, I walk on about rocks.
- 16:48I feel amazing right after the workshop, but because why?
- 16:51Because you're. Flooded with adrenaline, you're
- 16:53flooded with dopamine. Neurooprinephrine and all the
- 16:56things. And I've been pumped up.
- 16:58I've had this continuous positive messaging coming at me,
- 17:03but then I have to go back to my regular crappy life and deal
- 17:07with it. I can read this book all
- 17:08weekend, which is great, but then on Monday morning I still
- 17:11have to go back to my thankless job and try to live in reality.
- 17:14And work with people who don't treat me the way I wish to be
- 17:18treated and live with my family that I have conflicts with.
- 17:21Exactly in the article Why Self Help Books Don't help from the
- 17:25Neuroscience School, Contemporary self help teachings
- 17:27are attractive because they assure us that we are the makers
- 17:31of our own destiny. They preach that we have within
- 17:33us the power to change our lives for the better, even to make
- 17:36ourselves a new. Although this is true, the focus
- 17:39on personal responsibility distracts us from structural
- 17:42inequities such as unequal access to quality education,
- 17:45healthcare, etcetera. That's what I'm talking about
- 17:47when I get spit out of this magical weekend of reading
- 17:50myself help book or attending this workshop.
- 17:53I'm back in the drudgery of life where things are not fair, where
- 17:57I really don't control my destiny in a lot of ways.
- 18:00Where I can't afford health care, when I can't afford
- 18:02housing, Where my boss is sexually harassing me and I have
- 18:06to figure out how to manage life.
- 18:08And this book is not going to do that for me.
- 18:11I'll tell you something interesting from the world of
- 18:13comedy, which is what I mostly think about.
- 18:15There is a lot of fake it till you make it and big up yourself
- 18:21and tell everybody how great you are.
- 18:23Laura had a negative experience in Austin, TX with a person who
- 18:27we won't name. Someone mentioned that we had a
- 18:29podcast, which is this one and the woman jumped in and said
- 18:32well I have a podcast and I interviewed the celebrity and
- 18:35I'm doing really well and Laura was really turned off by it.
- 18:38And I said, well, that's just how comics talk, because if you
- 18:42don't big up yourself and promote yourself, no one else is
- 18:45going to do it. I just think it's weird that's
- 18:48not going to get me interested in you because I feel like if
- 18:51you're trying to sell me something which a podcast is
- 18:53technically free, but if you want me to listen to your
- 18:55podcast, I have to be interested in you.
- 18:57If I experienced you as this blowhard person who's really
- 19:01full of herself and isn't asking me any questions and doesn't
- 19:04seem like an interesting person, why would I listen to your
- 19:07podcast? An element that I have observed
- 19:10not to be helpful, but that gets told to us a lot, is picture
- 19:14success. Tell yourself you're happy when
- 19:16you experience feelings of jealousy.
- 19:18Tell yourself you're not jealous and along with show your best
- 19:21life on social media. So much of comedy is trying to
- 19:25show other comics that you're successful and trying to
- 19:28generate envy in others. There's a phenomenon where
- 19:32you're talking to someone about how great you're doing and all
- 19:35the great projects you're doing, but it creates this feeling of
- 19:37cognitive dissonance because your brain knows that that's not
- 19:40true or that you don't think that's true.
- 19:42And so we have this tenet of just like positivity blast.
- 19:46I'm doing so great. I'm doing all these shows.
- 19:49Famous people are noticing me, but you become depressed and
- 19:52anxious because your brains like that's not true.
- 19:54It's the same as I am. Great mantras.
- 19:57If you don't believe it, it's just gonna feel hollow and it's
- 20:00gonna make you feel bad. Having moved away from Los
- 20:04Angeles 6 months ago and I really did love Los Angeles and
- 20:06my experience there, One thing that I've become aware of is
- 20:09just that cycle of promoting yourself, creating the brand of
- 20:13yourself as a successful comic and shows that you're doing.
- 20:17Not because someone's going to discover you or because you're
- 20:20going to make money or because you're going to reach this
- 20:22audience, just so you can tell people you're doing shows.
- 20:25I think that when you're there, it's so much a noise and you're
- 20:28so used to it, the din, you forget that it's kind of empty.
- 20:32And that's my big philosophy on that.
- 20:34Yeah, circling back to self help books, if you're not in the
- 20:37state of mind to actively change, these books are
- 20:40essentially pointless. This is an issue that continues
- 20:42to bother me. Ellie Baker, the author of this
- 20:45article. They are marketed as a solution
- 20:47when self help books should not be seen as a replacement to
- 20:50professional attention. They can be a confidence boost
- 20:53or advice for a bad day, but nothing more than that.
- 20:56The main reason is often the reader him or herself.
- 20:58When reading a self book, it is US who decides whether or not to
- 21:02do something with it, and usually we don't.
- 21:04We have a glance of the book, read the blurbs or even actually
- 21:07read the book. But then we go on minding our
- 21:08usual business and we can freely do that.
- 21:11There's no therapist, coach or teacher telling us what to do or
- 21:14keeping us on track. And we are moving into the
- 21:16holidays, which means we'll have New Year's and people are going
- 21:19to have resolutions. A hard thing about sticking to a
- 21:22plan, trying to form a habit, is when you start it, you have all
- 21:27this intention and energy behind.
- 21:29But then the days go on and you go to sleep and you wake up and
- 21:33maybe that energy is a little bit diminished.
- 21:35Other things distract you when you make excuses.
- 21:38I very much understand the energy of finishing a book and
- 21:41saying this is going to change my life, but then my life keeps
- 21:45on being my life. While you might pick up a good
- 21:47idea or be inspired, it's largely a placebo effect.
- 21:51Like it feels good to do, but it's not medicine.
- 21:54If you're doing it properly. For example, I was in a
- 21:57relationship with an abusive person and we read Anger Busting
- 22:01One O 1 as he was referred to by his therapist.
- 22:04And that book has been instrumental in my life and in
- 22:08my practice because it talks about this idea of anger as a
- 22:12compulsion and addiction. And in order to stop it, you
- 22:16have to make a decision to not act on it.
- 22:18There's a workbook that goes with it.
- 22:19And so I've taken this knowledge and I've shared it with lots of
- 22:22people, and I think it's a really good supplemental thing
- 22:25in addition to therapy, but I just don't think it's a
- 22:28replacement for therapy. And there will be self help
- 22:30books that are helpful that you get good ideas from, but without
- 22:34additional elements it's not going to move the needle.
- 22:37You did recommend anger busting one O 1 to me when I was in a
- 22:41relationship with someone who had anger problems.
- 22:43And the great thing about that is then he picked fights with me
- 22:46about it and he told me he was not angry and he wasn't like the
- 22:49men in the book. And I said, OK.
- 22:51A lot of times I will see couples and usually it's an
- 22:54angry man who's being abusive to his partner.
- 22:57And when I asked them to read the book, they come back saying,
- 22:59well, the men in this book are physically harming people.
- 23:02And I, I don't do that. Because I have not physically
- 23:06put hands on you, I don't. I'm not abusing you.
- 23:09I've had a lot of big aha moments from self help books,
- 23:13Codependent no more. I remember I was on a beach with
- 23:17my partner at the time and my brain was exploding.
- 23:19So I was realizing, Oh my gosh, this.
- 23:21I do all this stuff and I was trained from birth to do all
- 23:25this stuff because this is what my mother does and this is what
- 23:28all the relationships I've ever had AD are based on.
- 23:31It was really enlightening and I took that book to my therapy and
- 23:34used it in. Therapy you're right that self
- 23:37help books are a modern American phenomenon in the form that they
- 23:41are today. You're going to eat, pray, love.
- 23:44You're going to have some chicken soup in your soul.
- 23:46The self help writer becomes a celebrity in their own right and
- 23:50then they're like, wow, this is the way to become a celebrity as
- 23:53you write a self help book and the cycle continues.
- 23:55But people have been writing in structural manuals on living for
- 23:59a much longer time. In ancient Egypt there was a
- 24:02Code of Behavior book with criticisms like You trail from
- 24:06street to St. smelling of beer like a broken rudder, good for
- 24:09nothing. Cicero in Rome wrote books on
- 24:13friendship and duties. Ovid wrote The Art of Love and
- 24:16The Remedy of Love. They were books about how to
- 24:19comport yourself in public sex manuals, how to be sociable.
- 24:23This has been something that people have always wanted to
- 24:26have. How do I make my life better?
- 24:28How do I get along better with people So although the self help
- 24:31book in American pop culture is its own bear.
- 24:35People have always been interested in collections of
- 24:37thoughts, direction, and Cicero didn't have therapy.
- 24:40This is all you could. Do, and I think also I do
- 24:43support the idea of a mass produced book that lots of
- 24:47people have access to because if I'm in a medieval village, I'm
- 24:51not going to have access to a therapist or a lot of these
- 24:54books I read when I was in college where I couldn't afford
- 24:56therapy. I needed something and it filled
- 24:59a gap in my life. As I keep saying, it's not
- 25:02everything. It is a thing and I think it's
- 25:04helpful, but I feel like there's a lot more and I also feel like
- 25:08it's the way you do it. Because of my ADHD, I have a
- 25:10tendency to just sort of skim through things.
- 25:12I was listening to an audio book today and I found myself started
- 25:15zoning out in the middle of the book and missing probably really
- 25:19salient and important points. Am I actually taking it in, or
- 25:23am I just doing the exercise of reading?
- 25:25Part of the fun of self help books is how quickly you can get
- 25:29through them. How much of that information are
- 25:31you taking in when you're just reading something on the toilet
- 25:35as fast as you can? Before your children wake up.
- 25:38Last but not least, Madison Frye wrote an article about self help
- 25:42and she said the self help book industry has become increasingly
- 25:46popular and is expected to keep rising in popularity in the next
- 25:49few years. It was found that the industry
- 25:51awards worth $10 billion in 2018.
- 25:55People who purchase self improvement books have likely
- 25:57bought another during the previous 18 months.
- 26:00If it doesn't work for a specific individual, he or she
- 26:03is on to the next book that might bring more promise.
- 26:05I could see why this is a pattern among those who
- 26:07contribute to the self help book industry.
- 26:09Buying a book for 20 or $30.00 is a lot easier than paying for
- 26:13a therapist or getting on medication.
- 26:14Many people cannot afford a therapist or a doctor or even a
- 26:17prescription. Today's society is always
- 26:19pushing us to be the best version of ourselves, especially
- 26:22on the Internet. There are expectations that we
- 26:24as a society should be maximizing our experiences as
- 26:27best we can in order to match expectations and those around us
- 26:31who are perceived to do the same.
- 26:32Years ago, I was talking to a woman and she was looking for a
- 26:37book of affirmations for her son because she said, well, he's a
- 26:41salesman and he really needs to read these so he can feel good
- 26:46about his job and selling more. And I remember thinking to
- 26:50myself, well, he's unhappy. A book telling him that he's the
- 26:54greatest is not going to be a long term solve for that.
- 26:58Exactly, He needs to look into is this the career for me?
- 27:02Am I actually cut out for sales? Is this something that gives me
- 27:06meaning or is helpful to me and start there.
- 27:09I don't think affirmations are going to help him with that.
- 27:12But our society is always pushing us to be the best.
- 27:15As a society, we are obsessed with optimizing every part of
- 27:18our lives. Our eating, our sleeping, our
- 27:20studying, our exercise, our relationshiping is.
- 27:22This isn't, of course, working. So while self help books seem in
- 27:26essence useless and arguably more damaging, they do have the
- 27:29power to be useful if one takes them as a realistic approach.
- 27:33Our mentality as a society has generated a sense of
- 27:35immediateness in everything we do and making us imagine that a
- 27:38self help book is a quick fix to making us better.
- 27:41This is what I experience when I have a new hypnosis client.
- 27:45I was talking to a colleague who was saying she's really
- 27:48struggling. She's trying to get people into
- 27:52a hypnotherapy and they are looking for a pill.
- 27:55They're just looking for something quick where zero
- 27:58effort is applied and that's it. And So what I told her was when
- 28:02I bring a person in for hypnotherapy, they don't want to
- 28:04do therapy. They're not interested in that.
- 28:06They just want me to raise my magic wand and fix their
- 28:10problem. A lot of people in honesty, ask
- 28:13me if I can fix all their problems in what appointment?
- 28:16And they mean it. And they're serious.
- 28:17They don't understand the complexity of your experiences,
- 28:21your trauma, your brain and everything that's ever happened
- 28:24to you. And also they're thinking about
- 28:26their pocketbook. It's expensive to do therapy for
- 28:29a long time and they don't want to put in the effort or anything
- 28:33else. I have that a lot.
- 28:34I have people who are like, well, I need to quit smoking.
- 28:36And so I say, OK, cool. So why are you smoking?
- 28:39I don't know. Well, you're smoking because
- 28:41you're super stressed out, you're not sleeping enough,
- 28:44you're not taking care of yourself.
- 28:46Your relationship is on the rocks.
- 28:48You're going to lose your job soon.
- 28:50We've got to look at all the things people are not so cut and
- 28:53dry and simple. Ultimately, it is a tool and I
- 28:57think it can be a super useful tool, but you need to do it in
- 29:01tandem with other things. And it might also be your
- 29:03gateway drug into therapy because I've experienced that
- 29:06too. I've experienced people coming
- 29:08to see me after they read Codependent No More or after
- 29:11they looked at the book Attached.
- 29:13That's been a huge one. A lot of people come to me after
- 29:16they've read Attached because they realize, Oh my gosh, this
- 29:18isn't just me picking poorly. This is a lot of my wounding
- 29:22affecting my relationships. So Virginia, in closing, what
- 29:26are your final thoughts on the topic of self help?
- 29:28Not to just pair it what you said, but I think self help
- 29:32books can lead you towards bigger things to solve.
- 29:37Such as I keep having the same relationship again and again
- 29:40because my attachment style is what it is and I'm attracted to
- 29:45people who have the direct opposite attachment style.
- 29:49This issue will not resolve. It's not that I'm looking for a
- 29:52specific person who's going to be able to help me with this.
- 29:55I think self help books can be useful in recognizing patterns
- 30:01and issues that you need to work on.
- 30:03But I agree that it is like a Band-Aid.
- 30:06It is something that's going to be really inspirational in the
- 30:09moment, but may not have the solution that's going to fix
- 30:13your life and your relationship and your career is not something
- 30:17you're going to pick up at the B Dalton at the airport.
- 30:20Agreed. What are your last thoughts on
- 30:22this topic? My final thoughts are this is a
- 30:24good intro to therapy. I think it can be a great
- 30:28companion piece to therapy. I find when I refer someone to a
- 30:32book, I'm looking at it as I can't do therapy with you 24
- 30:36hours a day, but you can take this book home.
- 30:38Here's some support for the work we're doing and this might give
- 30:41you more insights and more ideas.
- 30:43I was talking to a friend just today about her struggles with
- 30:47binge eating and I was telling her, well, I read this great
- 30:50book called Overcoming Overeating by Hirschman and
- 30:53Munter. And when I read it, one of the
- 30:56things I learned is that if you keep introducing one of your
- 30:59problems foods into your day-to-day diet and giving
- 31:02yourself plenty of access to that food, it will eventually
- 31:05become less interesting. And I was telling her about all
- 31:08the foods that I've gotten rid of.
- 31:09I don't care about Oreos. I don't care about peanut butter
- 31:12cups. I don't care about M&M's.
- 31:15It's been a process. And I learned that from a self
- 31:18help book. So it can be helpful, but it
- 31:20can't be the only thing in my in my humble in your arsenal.
- 31:23That's one thing that's good about visiting Laura's house is
- 31:26there's always going to be peanut butter cups and there's
- 31:28usually. Going to be Oreos and I noticed
- 31:30my Oreos are stale now because I don't care about them but it
- 31:33took me like 2 years to get there.
- 31:35It wasn't quick. It's been a process.
- 31:38I went through every type of Oreo.
- 31:39We started with the original, moved to peanut butter, moved to
- 31:43golden Oreos. Those were actually trickier
- 31:46than the original. Because that's new.
- 31:48And now I don't really care about any of them.
- 31:51What was your favorite Oreo out of the novelty Oreos?
- 31:54I think it's golden Oreos. That's actually the.
- 31:57Bomb. The peanut butter ones are
- 31:58pretty good, but they just got tiresome after a while.
- 32:01You know it's the worst one. If anyone's interested.
- 32:03Toffee coffee flavored Oreos are super gross my.
- 32:07Favorite Oreos if you're shopping for me are at Trader
- 32:10Joe's. They are the holiday and Jojo's
- 32:14Jojo's Oreo like cookie. I do like the holiday Jojo's.
- 32:18That's not something I'm really tempted to eat a whole bunch of
- 32:20Virginia. If anyone wants to find out
- 32:23about your comedy career, how would they go about doing them?
- 32:25You can. Find me on the Internet at
- 32:27wahwahwah.badinia.com as we approach the holiday season I
- 32:31have. Created a downloadable calendar.
- 32:34Or anyone to use. You can print it on letter size
- 32:38paper every month. Does have a picture of me on it.
- 32:41If you work in an office, you can print it on a color printer
- 32:44for free. You can also find me at Badinia
- 32:47on TikTok and on Instagram and pretty much every place hooked
- 32:51to the word Badinia. Laura, where can people find you
- 32:54or the podcasts on the Internet? Well, they can find me at my
- 32:58professional website lauraryan.org.
- 33:00They can also find me on my TikTok page.
- 33:03I am Laura Ryan if they're interested in checking out the
- 33:07website ourwebsiteismysisters@therapist.com
- 33:10and we're also on Instagram, My sisters at Therapist Instagram.
- 33:14If you are interested, interested in giving us show
- 33:17topics or you want to tell us how great you think we are, you
- 33:20can e-mail us and hello at my Sisters at therapist.com.
- 33:24If you would like to send some money our way or give us an
- 33:28opportunity to advertise for your product or brand, you can
- 33:31do that at Hire Us at My Sisters at therapist.com.
- 33:35Looking forward to hearing from Sunday Riley and Liquid Death.
- 33:38And target and AAA in coscope. Laura, this is the part of the
- 33:44show where you sometimes read a listener review.
- 33:47Do you have one to share this week?
- 33:48I most certainly do. This is an Apple podcast review
- 33:52from The Geeks Strike Back. The title is unfiltered,
- 33:57uplifting, and unforgettable. Thank you Laura and Virginia for
- 34:00a truly wonderful podcast. With every episode I seem to
- 34:03come away with at least one, but usually more ideas or ways to
- 34:06cope with my awkward human interactions.
- 34:08You have helped me to become a better person and I find every
- 34:11episode to be so validating. This podcast is full of solid,
- 34:14straightforward information that will help you on your path.
- 34:17Word of warning, you really have to plan your listening locales.
- 34:20I was recently on a long flight laughing to myself like a
- 34:23psycho. Thanks again on behalf of
- 34:26everyone you're helping. Thank you.
- 34:27The geek strikes back. Wow.
- 34:29If you're thinking to yourself, I'd like to write a review, but
- 34:32I can't write anything as beautiful and heartfelt as The
- 34:36Geek Strikes Back. You don't have to, you can just
- 34:38say haha this was good. I love.
- 34:40You thanks so much, stars. I was worried when they said
- 34:44that you have to watch your listening area that we've made
- 34:46them cry, which sometimes I also cried a podcast.
- 34:49Thank you. That's very affirming.
- 34:50It is quite affirming. So if you would like to write us
- 34:54a review, you can go to Apple podcast.
- 34:57We also have reviews on Spotify now.
- 35:00So if you want to write a review on Spotify and tell us how great
- 35:03you think we are, we would really appreciate it.
- 35:05And if you're. Shy, you can just shoot us an
- 35:07e-mail. I'd like to close the show with
- 35:11the inspirational words of the amazing Billy Ray Valentine
- 35:14Capricorn. The underrated Billy Ray
- 35:16Valentine, Capricorn. When he said we can make it.
- 35:19Baby me and you, bye bye.