Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Phantom time hypothesis
Transcript
- 0:00From the unexplained to the mundane, come join us on our journey to the fringe.
- 0:11Hello and welcome to Journey to the Fringe, the place where mainstream topics go to get
- 0:16their freak on.
- 0:17We are your purveyors of metaphorical filth, Taylor and Chussy, and today we are going
- 0:22to be going back to one of those plastics that had terrible audio.
- 0:26And I think this is very timely and in a leap year nonetheless too.
- 0:30So Chelsie, we are once again going to be looking at the Phantom Time Hypothesis.
- 0:36I don't know how much of this episode you remember.
- 0:38I think it's a fun episode and I'm hoping we can actually hear it very well this time
- 0:42around.
- 0:43Fingers are crossed.
- 0:44Fingers are crossed.
- 0:45Because you never know.
- 0:47But yeah, I think this is a great topic, especially when we're hitting this time of year.
- 0:52That is the original start of the year.
- 0:56It has been suggested that April Fools originates because in the Middle Ages New Year's Day
- 1:00was celebrated in Europe on March 25th, which would be the start of the actual year.
- 1:05That's the spring solstice, the refresh, that's when the year starts.
- 1:09With a holiday that in some areas of France specifically ended on April 1st.
- 1:14Those who celebrated New Year's Eve on January 1st made fun of those who celebrated on the
- 1:18other date by the invention of April Fools Day.
- 1:22It's funny that it became kind of like a cultural acceptance of making fun of people
- 1:26to push them into the original peer pressure, I guess.
- 1:30I can get behind that.
- 1:31Yeah.
- 1:32And instead of it being wild mushrooms that they found in the forest, it was just pushing
- 1:35them to use a different calendar, which picks a very arbitrary day I might add to celebrate
- 1:40its start of the year on.
- 1:41It's nothing special happens on January 1st.
- 1:44Maybe after Christmas?
- 1:46The whole point is like the winter solstice is December 21st.
- 1:49So like why 10 days after the winter solstice?
- 1:51Just seems kind of arbitrary.
- 1:53I wonder who we would ask answers to get answers that was weird.
- 1:58Ask it into the void.
- 1:59The void?
- 2:00Yeah.
- 2:01But who answers back?
- 2:02You might get an echo.
- 2:03An echo?
- 2:04Yes.
- 2:05So the use of January 1st as a New Year's Day became common in Europe around the mid-16th
- 2:14century, and that date was not adopted officially until 1564 by the Edict of Roussillon, which
- 2:21is of course impeccable French around here, when France switched from the Julian calendar
- 2:25to the Gregorian calendar as called for during the Council of Trent in 1563.
- 2:29Now, Chelsea, I think it's important at this point where we get into a little bit of that
- 2:33complicated math.
- 2:34Do you remember how long an astronomical year is?
- 2:38I think you can take a guess, can't you?
- 2:40Because we have this whole like calendar thing in place.
- 2:43Oh wait, wait, wait, wait, we are right.
- 2:45Now that you put it that way, I just heard math and I was like nope.
- 2:48Not really math at this point.
- 2:50How long is a year?
- 2:52365?
- 2:53A calendar is usually 365, you are correct.
- 2:57Oh good, I got it right.
- 2:58This year is 366.
- 3:01So most people would say an astronomical year is 365.25 because every four it adds one.
- 3:08Yeah, that's what I meant.
- 3:10Yeah.
- 3:11But that's not actually how it works.
- 3:13It did under the Julian calendar, which was introduced in 45 BC.
- 3:18However, an actual year is 365.24219 days.
- 3:24And that means a difference of 11 minutes per year between 365.25 and that calendar.
- 3:31We're losing or gaining that per year?
- 3:35We have a slightly longer year by 11 minutes, with that's our the 0.25 year.
- 3:41Okay, how do we catch it?
- 3:44That's actually, it seems weird.
- 3:46Like 11 minutes isn't that long, but over a thousand years, 11 minutes will add up to
- 3:51a lot and it'll completely throw off all of our seasons based on calendars.
- 3:56This calendar, the Julian calendar, falls a day behind an astronomical year every 128
- 4:02years.
- 4:03Over a millennium, that's going to be eight days that you're going to fall off.
- 4:06It will always accumulate that way unless you're actively taking steps to change your
- 4:09calendar.
- 4:10And we haven't.
- 4:11Well we haven't.
- 4:12Don't remember ever adjusting by 11 minutes.
- 4:15You got to remember that our calendar isn't actually 365.25.
- 4:19The Gregorian calendar is a leap year every four years.
- 4:23Unless it's divisible by 100, then we take out the leap year.
- 4:28Unless it's also divisible by 400, in which case we add in the leap.
- 4:32The 2100 will not be a leap year, but 2000 was.
- 4:36Okay, that is complicated.
- 4:41But that's why, like I said, it's not 365.25, it's 365.24219 days.
- 4:48So that's where we get all those extra decimals.
- 4:52So we adjust for this.
- 4:55Our calendars always take it into account.
- 4:59We don't need to think about it.
- 5:00Our phones got it on them already.
- 5:03It's dictated from above.
- 5:04Great.
- 5:05I love that.
- 5:06I wouldn't age to be alive.
- 5:08I know because, you know, daylight savings would be the death of all of us if we had
- 5:12it.
- 5:13Yes, it would.
- 5:14Great.
- 5:15Now, with this all, it's this is one more thing I need to talk about.
- 5:19And that is the date of Easter, which is basically one of our only holidays that isn't necessarily
- 5:25calendar based.
- 5:26It's actually lunar based because Easter is a function of the date of the spring equinox
- 5:32the Sunday after the ecclesiastical full moon on or after March 21st, which was adopted
- 5:38as an approximation of the March equinox.
- 5:40European scholars have been well aware of the calendar drift since the early medieval
- 5:44period.
- 5:45And that is something that people wanted to make sure is Easter is always falling in
- 5:48this period.
- 5:49It has to do a lot with Passover, I believe, for the Jewish calendar as well.
- 5:54The Gregorian calendar comes along and he says, wait, we're getting way out of hand
- 5:58here.
- 5:59We need to change the calendar.
- 6:00This Julian calendar, we're losing a day every 128 years.
- 6:02We need to fix this.
- 6:03How do they find that out?
- 6:04I wonder.
- 6:05We've been looking at the sky for a long time.
- 6:07We're able to figure shit out like this.
- 6:09I think it's the easiest way to explain it.
- 6:11Okay, I can accept that.
- 6:14The Gregorian reform shortened the average calendar year by.0075 days to 365.2425 based
- 6:22on those calculations we talked about, which stopped the drift of the calendar with respect
- 6:26to the equinoxes.
- 6:27Now, it's not perfect.
- 6:29We still lose about 20 seconds per year with this new calendar, but that's a lot less than
- 6:3311 minutes.
- 6:34Yeah, I guess.
- 6:36And the error accumulated over the 13th century since the Council of Nicea, where the Julian
- 6:41calendar was put into place, was corrected by a deletion of 10 days from the calendar.
- 6:46The Julian calendar day, Thursday, October 4th, 1582 was followed by the first day of
- 6:51the Gregorian calendar, Friday, October 15th, 1582.
- 6:55The cycle of the weekday was not affected.
- 6:57I know I should have been taking that in.
- 7:00October 4th to October 15th, the next day.
- 7:04And it's still the same year, right?
- 7:06Same year, yeah.
- 7:07Yeah, it was totally listening to you.
- 7:09So that's, yeah, it's a bunch of nerd stuff with calendars.
- 7:13There's not many calendar nerds anymore, but back in the day, boy, were there tons of calendar
- 7:17nerds.
- 7:18Can I just quickly ask, I'm not sure if you know, why is the Pope in Church of the calendar?
- 7:25Basically the calendar is in place because we need to know when we have festivals, which
- 7:29include Easter and Christmas, which are big in the churches.
- 7:35There's also, you know, the whole farming side of it, but basically why the church is
- 7:38so controlling of it is because of the religious holidays.
- 7:41Okay.
- 7:42And then, so he's not really in church, but he would be like all the Catholics like adopted
- 7:48it and maybe it was just like the religion most people followed that.
- 7:52Oh yeah, the Catholic Church was massive at the time.
- 7:55Yeah, I guess it still is.
- 7:57Yeah.
- 7:58But you know, if the new Pope actually came out and said we're using a different calendar,
- 8:02probably wouldn't get as adopted as fast.
- 8:03Oh, that's true, but he does.
- 8:06Unless the Pope talked to, oh no, what's his name?
- 8:10Friar Decephir, whatever.
- 8:12And he goes and talks to...
- 8:13I was just going to bring up the Friar.
- 8:15Yeah.
- 8:16If that Friar went and talked to Microsoft and Apple and just got them to change the
- 8:20phones, like we would all just follow.
- 8:22We would have no joy.
- 8:23I guarantee it.
- 8:24We would have no joy.
- 8:25And that's just going to leave behind the Amish, which I'm going to feel bad for, but
- 8:29there I don't know what's going to happen in that situation, guys.
- 8:32I know A24 just coming up with a new Civil War movie in the US, and I'm guessing that
- 8:36might actually be the entire story of it.
- 8:39Is that this Friar, I forget his name, Benati?
- 8:42I think that's it, but it sounds familiar.
- 8:43Something like that.
- 8:44I've got to assume that's the story of it, is that this Friar goes and talks to the
- 8:49big tech companies and they says, hey, let's change the calendar up and all hell breaks
- 8:53lose from there.
- 8:54This is really a war between phone users and phone non-users.
- 8:58I mean, yeah, I guess the Amish probably do follow their own calendar, right?
- 9:02But I think they're an offshoot of Catholicism, are they not?
- 9:05I have no friends.
- 9:06I'm speculating way too much.
- 9:07I know they're Christian.
- 9:08I have no idea what kind.
- 9:09This is a strange way to look at them.
- 9:11So Chelsea, I had to give you that backstory.
- 9:14Brace yourself for this.
- 9:15This is the true Phantom Time Hypothesis.
- 9:17Oh no.
- 9:18We don't live in the year 2024.
- 9:21It's actually the 1700s, 1726, I believe, to be accurate, as proposed by Haribot Illig.
- 9:29That seems like quite the loss.
- 9:31Yeah, that's 300 years right there.
- 9:33Now this really comes up because it answers the question like a lot of people are like
- 9:37dark ages happen.
- 9:38We don't know a lot about them, but there are these things that happen.
- 9:41But what if they actually didn't?
- 9:43And that's why we don't know much about them.
- 9:45It's because we just skipped 300 years.
- 9:48Why would we skip 300 years because of everything you just said?
- 9:52So this theory comes from 1995, was revised in the year 2000, and it says between antiquity,
- 9:581 AD, and the Renaissance, historians count approximately 300 years too many in their chronology.
- 10:04In other words, the Roman Emperor Augustus really lived 1700 years ago instead of the
- 10:08conventional 2000 years ago as a result of the year 614-911 simply being made up.
- 10:15Okay, does he give reason?
- 10:18A little bit.
- 10:19The easiest way to understand doubts about the accepted chronology of well-known history
- 10:24is to seriously systematize the problems of medieval research.
- 10:28This will lead us to detect a pattern which proves my thesis.
- 10:31And this, sorry, this comes from Ulrich's writings.
- 10:34This will lead us to detect a pattern which proves my thesis and gives reason to assume
- 10:38that a phantom time period of approximately 300 years has been inserted between 600 AD
- 10:42and 900 AD either by accident, by an misinterpretation of documents, or by deliberate falsification.
- 10:49This period and all events are supposed to have happened therein never existed.
- 10:54Buildings and artifacts described in this period really belong to another period.
- 10:57Art historians explain and describe artifacts and buildings of this period as anachronistic,
- 11:02but they never follow up on their assessments.
- 11:04One of the best examples, intensively surveyed, is the Chapel of Achaen, circa 800 AD, which
- 11:10seems to come approximately 200 years too early.
- 11:13The way of constructing an arch shown in this chapel has no predecessor.
- 11:18Arched isles are usually only in the 11th century in spare, and the construction of
- 11:22choirs with rising arch and also rising barrel vaulting is not resumed until 200 years later
- 11:28at the portal of Tornus.
- 11:30The vertical steepness of the interior arches of the Achaen Chapel is more accentuated than
- 11:34those of churches built two centuries later.
- 11:37One of these is the 1094 consecrated Abbey Church of Atmarsheim, although missing some
- 11:44details of the early model, nevertheless it is the best copy of Achaen.
- 11:48However, these and many other arguments implicate that the Chapel of Achaen has to be regarded
- 11:52as a building of the second part of the 11th century.
- 11:56Ferdosis, well known epic the Chaename, written around 1010 AD, ends in the last Persian king
- 12:02Yazdegerd III, who died 651 AD.
- 12:06The epic tells nothing about the Islamic conquest of Persia and has no allusions to Islam at
- 12:11all.
- 12:12It simply skips 300 years of Islamic influence as if it had never existed.
- 12:16And many hilltop strongholds are known in Italy and throughout southern France, as well
- 12:21as in various parts of Achaen region and Asia Minor.
- 12:24But although castle building began in these regions in the 7th century, none of the structures
- 12:29built at that time have survived into the modern age.
- 12:34Especially the 7th century fortresses were replaced by greater and larger edifices in
- 12:38the 10th, and more especially 11th centuries, and it is these which we see today.
- 12:42The 10th and 11th century fortresses were built directly on the 7th century foundations,
- 12:47with nothing of the 8th or 9th century intervening.
- 12:50Even stranger, we find that whilst the age of castle building commenced in southern Europe
- 12:54during the 7th century, it only began in northern Europe in the 10th.
- 12:58And what is even worse, the boundary between the two ages of castle building is often no
- 13:02more than a few kilometers apart.
- 13:04Thus for example, the first fortified hilltop sites on the southern coast of France appear
- 13:08in the 7th century, whilst just a few kilometers away, the Perinian foothills, the first castles
- 13:12appear in the 10th century.
- 13:14This is the case for example at Lourdes, where the fortified stronghold was clearly designed
- 13:19to guard the Perinian passes against Muslim raids in the 10th century.
- 13:23Yet just a few kilometers to the west at Montseguer, a fortified stronghold also designed to guard
- 13:29against Muslim raids is dated to the 7th century.
- 13:32Illeg found a document stating almost 1700 structures were built in these missing years.
- 13:37He could not even find archaeological evidence that 97% of these structures ever even existed,
- 13:43let alone were built in this period.
- 13:45Moreover the Parsis, the Zerothustra worshippers in India have been debating their own chronology
- 13:50furiously since messengers from Iran in the 18th century told them that they made a mistake
- 13:55in counting the years since their flight from the homeland.
- 13:58Modern encyclopedias vary in their assertions between the 7th and 10th century for the events.
- 14:03The history of the Jews shows centuries of darkness as a discontinuity that support the
- 14:07thesis of the Phantom Time as well.
- 14:09One of the important modern works of Jewish history bears the descriptive title the Dark
- 14:14Ages, Jews in Christian Europe 711-1096.
- 14:18Here are two quotations from this.
- 14:20It seemed that they, the Jews, totally disappeared together with the breakdown of the Roman Empire.
- 14:27However we don't find any evidence of their presence until the Carolinian period.
- 14:33For the Carolinian period historians find only written sources whereas material sources
- 14:37like buildings and artifacts exist just for the time of 1000 AD.
- 14:41And for the region outside of Germany we are told, quote, of course we know from inscriptions
- 14:46and other sources about Jewish societies and single persons in nearly all provinces of the
- 14:50Roman Empire.
- 14:51And we can reasonably suppose, with or without proof, that there is in fact no district without
- 14:56Jews.
- 14:57Nevertheless there doesn't exist any evidence and only little probability that a substantial
- 15:01number of Jews lived anywhere in the western world at this time.
- 15:04The new existing stratigraphies of German towns give evidence of the Phantom Time in
- 15:10Frankfurt and main archaeological excavations did not find any layer for the period between
- 15:16659-1080.
- 15:17Nevertheless, it has been assumed that something has been found in order to avoid empty centuries
- 15:22which is unconceivable.
- 15:23Thus the absent period was construed by layers composed of waste ceramic fragments from other
- 15:28locations which were spread to fill in the gap to support no one chronology.
- 15:33Archaeological research in ceramics encounters big problems for the projected Phantom Time.
- 15:37Two quotations here for this, quote, the evolution of a half century is unclear, writes Peter
- 15:42Vichitil in his 1991 publication about ceramics of the 8th to 13th century from settlements
- 15:48of the main triangle and 30 years earlier Werner Harnigl had some troubles with the slow moving
- 15:54evolution of vessel forms in the 7th, 8th, and 9th centuries at the North Sea coast.
- 15:58It is impossible to find an order in their ceramic vessels.
- 16:01Even to construct a relative chronology still seems to be impossible.
- 16:05Therefore the ceramic experts try to solve this problem with mathematical statistical
- 16:08methods.
- 16:09The medievalists is confronted with a dangerous and confusing host of false documents and
- 16:13this was the reason for organizing the conference.
- 16:16This is with regards to the Gregorian Conference.
- 16:18The Bavarian State Secretary of Education, Culture Hans Meier summarized the problem and
- 16:23nobody came to contradict him, quote, falsification of the Middle Ages, end quote, are really
- 16:28no minor subject for medievalists.
- 16:29In this conference we treat the central problem of historical scientific research, the question
- 16:34for authenticity of the documents and even more the concept of truth in an important
- 16:38period of history of mankind.
- 16:39Horace Fierman, president of the Monumenta Germania Historica, emphasized a special peculiarity
- 16:46of some of the important fake documents.
- 16:48He demonstrated that the important fakes of the Roman Catholic Church have an anticipating
- 16:52character.
- 16:54These documents had to wait for their great moment to come.
- 16:56The centuries after being produced, these fakes were integrated into the framework of
- 17:00the clerical and laical world.
- 17:01This is from Fierman, 1988, page 90.
- 17:04Fierman's opinion was that in the first place, the environment must exist before a fake can
- 17:09be effective.
- 17:10We were shown fakes from preceding centuries.
- 17:12We divined chronological distortions, therefore we inspected the calendar calculations mentioned
- 17:17above with the results of a time error amounting to three centuries.
- 17:20Then we looked for gaps in special reports and publications, also for periods of stagnation
- 17:25or strange events repeating in similar manners after approximately 300 years.
- 17:30I only refer to some of these great numbers of puzzles, a gap in the history of buildings
- 17:35in Constantinople's, a gap in the doctrine of faith, especially in the gap of evolution
- 17:39in theory and meaning of purgatory, a 300 year reluctant introduction of farming techniques,
- 17:45and of war techniques, a gap in mosaic art, and a repeated beginning of the German orthography.
- 17:51The puzzles historiography led the way, pointing out again and again, the gap which we soon
- 17:57termed phantom time.
- 17:58Now Chelsea, this probably is where we get to the question I guarantee you have right
- 18:02now.
- 18:03Why the hell are you just making up 300 years?
- 18:05Yeah.
- 18:06Is it because of the 11 minutes?
- 18:08This is where we get to it.
- 18:10But who could have an interest in faking so many documents and why did the fakers need
- 18:14a phantom time of 300 years?
- 18:16We developed two hypotheses which basically don't contradict.
- 18:20Hypothesi one, Otto the third didn't live accidentally around the year 1000 AD.
- 18:24He himself made this date.
- 18:26He wanted to reign in this year because this suited his understanding of Christian millennialism.
- 18:31He defined this date with the help of his famous and well-versed friend Gerbert de Roulac.
- 18:37Gerbert pulp Sylvester II, in reality they lived approximately 700 years after the birth
- 18:42of Jesus.
- 18:44So basically a ruler wanted to live in the year 1000, which is a very historically important
- 18:48year.
- 18:49In reality they lived approximately 700 years after the birth of Jesus Christ, but never
- 18:53until then had the years been reckoned after Christ.
- 18:57Perhaps unaware of their error and without intending to falsify, they defined one special
- 19:02year as 1000 AD.
- 19:04Consequently chroniclers had to invent 300 years of history to fill up the empty period.
- 19:09What a great occasion for dynasties and kings.
- 19:11You can design the planned future as a construct of the past.
- 19:14And this apparently happened.
- 19:15Otto the third construed Charlemagne as the model hero.
- 19:19He himself wanted to be.
- 19:20Supposedly he sketched Charlemagne's history only a bit, or it wasn't even him but the
- 19:24generations after him who lined up a whole full life picture.
- 19:29Especially the clergy hoped to get advantage in its confrontation with the emperors which
- 19:33had started in the 11th century.
- 19:34Hypothesis 2, Constantine the 7th of Byzantium, organized a complete rewriting the whole Byzantium
- 19:40history and the famous German Byzantianist Peter Schreiner has demonstrated how officially
- 19:46his historiography interprets this process.
- 19:48Beginning in the year 835 AD, monks rewrote piece by piece all texts which have been written
- 19:53in Greek in the new form of writing, hence called meniscula.
- 19:57Schreiner postulates that each text was produced only once and then the originals were destroyed.
- 20:02This means that all existing texts of the then leading culture nation have been changed
- 20:06or rewritten completely in new script in the lifetime of two generations or even faster
- 20:12and have been well invented we suppose.
- 20:15It is important to explain the motivation of the emperor Constantine the 7th.
- 20:18I only want to demonstrate that an action of rewriting and faking like this has happened.
- 20:23If it could happen in Byzantium, it might have happened at any other place too.
- 20:27Moreover, the Ophanu, mother of Otto the 3rd, came from Byzantium and was a niece of emperor
- 20:33Demyskis, a descendant of the same dynasty as Constantine the 7th as to the question
- 20:38of who faked and why there could be many speculations, it seems that in this question, surprises
- 20:43are ahead which could create trouble for many academic institutions as well as other social
- 20:48groups.
- 20:49I would like to repeat that our method consists in questioning specific research, problems
- 20:54of archaeology and historiography.
- 20:56I must emphasize that the thesis of the phantom year is one proposal for solving those problems.
- 21:01It works surprisingly well and yields amazing results.
- 21:04It seems that scientists today do not see the common pattern in all of these problems
- 21:09which repeatedly appear because there exists an unexpressed and unconscious prohibition
- 21:14against questioning the chronology as if it were unimpeachable.
- 21:17My request therefore is this, where and how could our research work possibly join?
- 21:23What could we do together until today our research work was done marginally?
- 21:28But from now on it enters an important stage.
- 21:31The project has become so giant that it cannot be worked out by a few people with small resources,
- 21:36support from official institutions has become necessary so that we can continue our work
- 21:40at the edge of specialty.
- 21:42So Chelsea, that is the phantom time hypothesis.
- 21:45There were 300 years which don't seem to be historically supported to have existed in
- 21:50Europe because it's just funny, nothing seems to happen during it.
- 21:53Yeah, I feel like I understand it a lot better this time around.
- 21:57Not sure why, but I do have some things to say that just miraculously just left my head.
- 22:04That makes sense.
- 22:05It does.
- 22:06The Dark Ages seem like nothing seems to happen, so it makes a lot of sense.
- 22:11Yeah, and it almost seems like an Occam's razor.
- 22:15Like the simplest answer.
- 22:17Yeah, the simplest answer, it really just seems to be the simplest answer.
- 22:21It makes sense, it's simple.
- 22:23What I don't get is when they change the calendar, they're like, okay, we're moving 10 years,
- 22:28it's documented.
- 22:2910 days.
- 22:3010 days, of course.
- 22:32But why wouldn't they document this?
- 22:35And the other part of it too, I didn't mention at this point yet.
- 22:38I thought I had, I haven't looked over the script apparently enough in the year and a
- 22:41half since we've done, or the two years since we've done this episode.
- 22:45It was actually weird that they picked 10 days because it should have been a different number,
- 22:50based on it being 128 years to one day.
- 22:54That would mean that there are 13 days out of line.
- 22:57So if you take those three days away, that's 300 years.
- 23:03Because remember, this happened in the 1500s, they moved it 10 days, and it's 128 years
- 23:08per day.
- 23:09So if we just times that by 10, it would be the year 1280 would be 10 days.
- 23:12Like what?
- 23:13That's crazy.
- 23:14So it seems weird that they picked that amount as if they knew that we were 300 years off.
- 23:21That is weird.
- 23:22Maybe it's in the Vatican Museum in the vaults.
- 23:24Yeah, in the archives.
- 23:27The other thing is, I think it's interesting that things fall in and out of 300 years that
- 23:34are close by to each other, almost as if they didn't get the memo quite in time.
- 23:40Because that's how things would travel.
- 23:41It's not like they send an email and like CC everybody in on it.
- 23:45Yeah, they would have to go like word would have to spread like, hey, just an FYI.
- 23:50And yeah, Europe's a pretty big region for the whole of Europe to have this weird 300
- 23:54year window that you can't see what's going on, or it just seems super vague what's going
- 23:59on.
- 24:00It's a very fun hypothesis.
- 24:01And had it happened say in the 1800s, boom, mud flood, you're covered.
- 24:06This is perfect.
- 24:07But unfortunately, I just need to say this does not work at all with mud flood because
- 24:11this happens 300 years before the proposed mud flood.
- 24:17So the Tartarians would have been well around during this entire thing.
- 24:21Unless they're the ones who kept the normal calendar and said, you guys are all stupid.
- 24:26These 300 years are made up.
- 24:27So it took Europe 300 years to accumulate all this power to flood them out.
- 24:33Finally.
- 24:34Yeah, we're just helping out the mud flitters right now.
- 24:37If they could have just picked 1500 when the mud flood happened, that would have been great,
- 24:41but it doesn't make any sense because this isn't when the cities were built.
- 24:47It's a fun theory.
- 24:48I like it a lot.
- 24:50It seems to make sense.
- 24:51And it's being proposed by people who actually seem to understand the archaeology at least
- 24:55of that time.
- 24:56Correct?
- 24:57Like it seems fun.
- 24:58It's pretty cool.
- 24:59I really like it.
- 25:00I can really wrap my head around it this time.
- 25:02Last time I got very confused.
- 25:03Yeah, I remember that.
- 25:05But I'm understanding it this time around.
- 25:10From here, though, Chelsea, unfortunately, we're going to talk about the criticism's
- 25:13phantom time hypothesis has received since it was first proposed.
- 25:18The biggest one is simply that adding three centuries to European history makes it disagree
- 25:22with other historical regions.
- 25:24Like you know, there's the Islamic expansion throughout the Middle East, which would have
- 25:28been happening during that time.
- 25:30There's the Tang dynasty in China that would have been happening during this time.
- 25:33We don't see any discrepancy.
- 25:35The histories wouldn't line up anymore if we just deleted 300 years from our history
- 25:40of those regions.
- 25:41Yeah.
- 25:42And it's basically saying like this is a very Western oriented theory.
- 25:46You can't just delete 300 years from the entire world.
- 25:49The rest of the world seems to have a natural build up throughout that is consistent and
- 25:53trackable.
- 25:54So if we just delete 300 years, then all the rest of the world has confusing problems
- 25:59with their history.
- 26:00OK, that didn't make sense to me for a second.
- 26:02But yeah, that does make sense.
- 26:03Yeah.
- 26:04What's going on in Europe then?
- 26:06Basically, famine.
- 26:07It was dark.
- 26:08Like the sun didn't shine.
- 26:10I wouldn't say the sun was completely blotted out, but it is considered a cold period and
- 26:15crops didn't grow as well in Europe during that time.
- 26:18So it's hard to be building up history when you're trying to just find food.
- 26:23OK, sure.
- 26:24The next part of it, which actually I think this throws the biggest wrench in the cogs
- 26:28for this theory, ancient astronomy, which we know all of our like the challenges are
- 26:34all built off astronomy.
- 26:35We've been doing astronomy for a very long time.
- 26:37We've been tracking a lot of things.
- 26:39Observations in ancient astronomy, especially those cited prior to 600 AD, agree with the
- 26:44usual chronology and not with the phantom time hypothesis.
- 26:48Besides several others that are perhaps too vague to disprove the phantom time hypothesis,
- 26:52two in particular are dated with enough precision to question this hypothesis.
- 26:56Then Pliny the Elder in 59 AD and Fodius in 418 AD both make astronomical observations,
- 27:04which we can look at the sky, basically zoom it back to that year and say, OK, it makes
- 27:10sense.
- 27:11This was done exactly at this time.
- 27:13We can't do that if we delete 300 years.
- 27:15Basically, if you see a solar eclipse, we can go back in time based on our understanding
- 27:19of astronomical movements to say when that happened.
- 27:22But if we delete 300 years, it doesn't make any sense anymore.
- 27:25OK, so based on astrology, astronomy, astronomy, those 300 years still have.
- 27:33We're there.
- 27:34Yes, because it doesn't make any sense from observations that we see prior to those 300
- 27:39years to calculate it out.
- 27:40That's too bad.
- 27:41Yeah.
- 27:42In addition, observations during the Tang Dynasty in China and Haley's Comet, for example,
- 27:45are consistent with our current astronomy with no phantom time added.
- 27:49You know, because this is disappointing.
- 27:51Haley's Comet comes around every so many years, and if you delete 300 years and not
- 27:56like a perfect cycle of Haley's Comet, then you're going to have some.
- 28:00They've got us there with Haley's Comet, I think.
- 28:03Comet.
- 28:04Dynamech.
- 28:05Comet.
- 28:06Full with English today.
- 28:07Archeological remains in dating methods such as dendocrinology, which is tree ring dating.
- 28:12Also refute rather than support phantom time hypothesis.
- 28:15This thing where I'm talking about how it should have been 13 days or something like
- 28:18that instead of 10 days added to the calendar.
- 28:20The Gregorian reform was never actually purported to bring the calendar in line with the Julian
- 28:24calendar as it had existed at the time of the institution in 45 BC, but as it had existed
- 28:30in 325 AD, the year the Council of Nicaea, which had established a method for determining
- 28:35the date of Easter Sunday by fixing the vernal equinox on March 21st in the Julian calendar.
- 28:40By 1582, the astronomical equinox was occurring on March 10th in the Julian calendar, but
- 28:46Easter was still being calculated from a nominal equinox on March 21st.
- 28:51In 45 BC, the astronomical vernal equinox took place on March 23rd.
- 28:56It looks missing three centuries, thus corresponding to the 369 years between the institution of
- 29:01the Julian calendar in 45 and fixing it in the Council of Nicaea in 325 AD.
- 29:06So there's not really 300 missing years because we didn't just set the date at zero.
- 29:12That's not when the date actually happened.
- 29:14It's not very disappointing.
- 29:16I know.
- 29:17And the last point here is if Charlemagne and the Carolingian dynasty were fabricated,
- 29:22there would have to be a corresponding fabrication of history for the rest of Europe, including
- 29:26the Anglo-Saxon England, the Papacy, the Byzantine Empire.
- 29:31The Phantom Time Pipe period also encompasses the life of Muhammad and the Islamic expansion
- 29:36into the areas of the former Western Roman Empire, including the conquest of Visigothic
- 29:41Iberia.
- 29:42And the history too would have to be forged or drastically misdained.
- 29:45It would also have to be reconciled with the history of the Tongs in China and its contact
- 29:50with the Islamic world, such as the Battle of Talas.
- 29:53The other thing too, just like they're talking about there, you actually need a whole lot
- 29:57of people working together to fabricate 300 years.
- 30:01Because it's not just Italy's calendar doesn't add up.
- 30:04It's all of Europe.
- 30:05So you need people in Italy, Sweden, Britain, France, Germany, all to be making up this
- 30:11history.
- 30:12Having a degree at a time where communication between these regions wasn't exactly great.
- 30:17There's no cables laid yet.
- 30:19I did make that point.
- 30:21They're just waiting on the marathon runner to go give them word.
- 30:25Maybe the horse boys.
- 30:26Change the calendar 300 years.
- 30:28Yep, the first and most accurate game of telephone ever played.
- 30:35I was fully for the Phantom Time Theory.
- 30:37It's a great hypothesis.
- 30:39I love it.
- 30:40It's going from the mud-flood hypothesis to the Phantom Time hypothesis.
- 30:44They're night and day in their reasoning.
- 30:46But like, it works.
- 30:47But it doesn't work.
- 30:49From a European perspective, it works.
- 30:52And ignoring everything else.
- 30:54Like what the fuck is going on in Europe during that time?
- 30:57The Dark Ages.
- 30:58Okay, that's all I got.
- 31:00But yeah, that's the episode.
- 31:01I hope Chelsea, anything you want to say before we end?
- 31:04I've been saying everything that I needed to say as I go, as I usually do.
- 31:08As I save it, but no, I quite enjoyed this time around.
- 31:12I feel a lot less confused and disappointed.
- 31:16I personally am all for us just mentally living our best life in the 1700s and just bringing
- 31:22back those fashion statements.
- 31:23If we all wanted to just go back to the 1700s that way, I'm all for it.
- 31:27Yeah, that would be nice if we couldn't do that.
- 31:30I'm talking high collars, corsets, and like five layers of dress for women.
- 31:35And I wonder what the hairstyles of the...
- 31:38Do we get to go back to remember the guy with the nice facial hair that was from the mudwudge?
- 31:44Mudwudge?
- 31:45I don't think we've covered the mudwudge.
- 31:48Oh, it's a call.
- 31:50Remember the guy with the nice mustache?
- 31:54I do, but that's the 1800s.
- 31:55We got 100 years to go till then.
- 31:57I shouldn't have even brought it up.
- 31:59I can't remember anything about it.
- 32:02Anyhow, we are here fully advocating for you to live your best 1700s life you can.
- 32:08But in the meantime, I have been Taylor here with Chelsea.
- 32:11We are Journey to the Fringe.
- 32:12Thank you all for listening and we'll see you next week.
- 32:14Bye.
- 32:17Thank you for listening to Journey to the Fringe.
- 32:19If you have liked what you have listened to, please like, share, subscribe, or follow
- 32:25depending on what venue you are listening to us through.
- 32:28Also please, if possible, leave a five star review as that really helps us in the algorithms.
- 32:34If you wish to interact with us, please check us out on your social media of choice.
- 32:39I bet you we are there.
- 32:41And if you really want to communicate with us and give us ideas for new episodes or tell
- 32:46us that we're wrong and terrible, either way, please send us an email at journeytothefringe.com.
- 32:52For now, I'll see you in the next episode.