Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 138: On the state of French Politics with Alexander Hurst
Transcript
- 0:06You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:08I'm your host, Lindsay Trermuda. It's been several months now
- 0:12since the president threw us into a mess by calling a snap
- 0:15election. You'd be forgiven, of course,
- 0:17for forgetting that even happened this year.
- 0:20The Olympics did a good job, after all, of distracting us
- 0:23from our circumstances in France.
- 0:25But in the first week of September, Macron finally named
- 0:28a Prime Minister after seven weeks or so of meeting with
- 0:31potential candidates and rejecting all of them.
- 0:35But what does this mean for the country?
- 0:37And what does it signal for voters who cast their ballots
- 0:39for the Left Coalition? In today's episode, I speak with
- 0:43Alexander Hearst, a writer and columnist for The Guardian based
- 0:46in Paris, whose recent op-ed looks into what went wrong and
- 0:50what issues the new government inherits.
- 0:54Alex, welcome to the show. Hi, Lindsay.
- 0:57Thanks for having me. So you're a contributor for The
- 1:00Guardian, As I told everyone in my introduction and in one of
- 1:04your latest columns, you wrote something that made me laugh,
- 1:06which I don't think was the full intention, but it certainly
- 1:10captured what we're experiencing here politically in France.
- 1:14And you wrote that an analogy for French politics spoken by
- 1:19your friend is that scene from Succession when the character of
- 1:22Rogan Lloyd tells his adult children why he won't just pass
- 1:25over the keys to the company to them.
- 1:27And he says, I love you, but you're not serious people.
- 1:31And you argue that the left wing coalition that failed to meet
- 1:34the moment this summer in France and show that it could do the
- 1:37difficult work of compromising and working together reflects a
- 1:41similar lack of seriousness. So can you catch everyone up to
- 1:45speed? You know, what was happening
- 1:47during the Olympics that people weren't paying attention to?
- 1:49And why are we now stuck with the right wing Prime Minister
- 1:53who seems plucked from out of nowhere?
- 1:56Right. So exactly, I think there's lots
- 1:58of blame to be cast around. First.
- 2:01I just want to start with, it's understandable why a voter in
- 2:03France would feel really frustrated right now, right?
- 2:06So we had Macomb call the legislative elections, and the
- 2:10entire legislative elections were run on this idea that the
- 2:13left wing and the center and the center right needed to band
- 2:17together and vote strategically to keep the rest of the moment,
- 2:20now the far right out of power. And that happens.
- 2:23And of course, nobody had a majority in parliament.
- 2:26Everybody had a minority position.
- 2:27The left block had the most seats of any of the blocks that
- 2:31had banded together to keep the RN out of power.
- 2:34And what happened is a right wing Prime Minister who is only
- 2:38going to survive as Prime Minister as long as the RN
- 2:41doesn't vote to throw him out of power.
- 2:44And so if you're a French voter, you're sitting here thinking, so
- 2:47the party that I voted strategically to block is now
- 2:50the party that is propping up this right wing Prime Minister,
- 2:54who himself is from a political family that had a very small
- 2:58number of seats and whose party split in half because half of
- 3:00them effectively joined the far right.
- 3:02So does my vote matter? What happened?
- 3:05None of the results of this election were respected.
- 3:08What's the point? So I think there's a vast sense
- 3:11of disillusionment, which is really justifiable.
- 3:14And and then I can empathize heavily with, of course, and how
- 3:18we got to that point. I think there's a lot of blame
- 3:20to throw at the left as well. And when I talk about the French
- 3:24left, I think for voters who are listening from the United
- 3:27States, for example, we often tend to think of left right
- 3:30politics as a line. Or maybe we approach it with the
- 3:33XY scatter plot to take into account economic differences and
- 3:37social cultural differences. And when we come to European
- 3:40Union member states, I think we need to add in a third
- 3:43dimensional Z axis, which is European federalism.
- 3:46Do we want more integration or less integration?
- 3:48And that, I think, allows us to understand why there are really
- 3:522 lefts in France and why they're really incompatible.
- 3:56And what happened is the left had this marriage of convenience
- 3:59in order to, you know, effectively keep the RN from
- 4:03power, or so we thought during the legislative elections.
- 4:06And then it took this approach that I think is just as
- 4:10disdainful of democracy as what happened.
- 4:13So the far left leader, Jean Luc Manolochon has had sort of a
- 4:16menes, as you would say in French, on left wing politics.
- 4:19He really has been in the driver's seat of this car.
- 4:22And after the results of the election, he took this approach
- 4:25of our way, the highway. It's going to be our program,
- 4:27the whole program, nothing but the program, which is totally
- 4:29unrealistic considering that they had 182 seats total in the
- 4:33left wing coalition out of 577 seats in the French parliament.
- 4:37You can't say our program, the whole program, nothing but the
- 4:40program. When you have a minority, it's
- 4:42mathematically. Just to just to pause for a
- 4:44second, he also was technically not even, I mean, was he really
- 4:49representing La France and Sumis?
- 4:51He's sort of this figure that just remains attached but claims
- 4:55to not be the one calling the shots, or at least that's what
- 4:59his the rest of the party seems to say that no, no, no, no, it's
- 5:02not Jean RUC Manochon who's in charge.
- 5:04It's not him who's making all the decisions.
- 5:07We're doing this together. But everyone in other parties
- 5:10fears that actually he's still the one, as you said, with with
- 5:14total control over the ideology of the party.
- 5:16So was his role really as codified as as what you're
- 5:21describing? That's an interesting question.
- 5:23I mean, it's not codified. And the entire rest of the left
- 5:27really kind of, you can tell they want to emancipate
- 5:29themselves from Jean Luc Melon Schoen, who is deeply, deeply
- 5:32unelectable, right? If Emmanuel Macron and Jean Luc
- 5:34Melon Schoen share anything, it's that they are they elicit
- 5:37this deep rejection among the French electorate as a whole.
- 5:41And so to what extent was Melon Schoen technically in the
- 5:43driver's seat? I don't know if it really
- 5:45matters because effectively he was in the driver's seat.
- 5:47And so the left wing takes this approach led by Melon Schoen and
- 5:51they spend 7 weeks not being able to come to any sort of
- 5:54agreement amongst themselves of who they would put forward as a
- 5:57potential left wing Prime Minister.
- 5:59Yet they're they're complaining and potentially, you know,
- 6:02justifiably so that my phone won't name a left wing Prime
- 6:05Minister. OK, but who?
- 6:06And so every time you get a suggestion from the really far
- 6:10left of the of the coalition, the mental showness left of the
- 6:13coalition, it's clearly not going to fly with anybody who
- 6:16they would need to build a coalition to have an actual
- 6:18majority in Parliament. Any time you get a suggestion
- 6:20put forward from the more center left part of the coalition, the
- 6:23Social Democratic wing of the left wing alliance, it doesn't
- 6:26fly with Jean Luc Melichon's coalition.
- 6:28And so it all gets torpedoed. And so there are a series of
- 6:31names that could potentially build a broader coalition, as
- 6:34happens in other European countries.
- 6:36Belgium, long history of coalition politics, even after a
- 6:38really long delays in getting there.
- 6:40Germany, long history of coalition politics, other
- 6:43European parliaments this is commonplace.
- 6:45And in France, you just have this series of egos and of
- 6:48course the 2027 election impending, which kind of gives
- 6:51the impression that the far left didn't really want to govern.
- 6:54The center left probably didn't really want to govern either
- 6:57because they know it's going to be a shit show and they're going
- 7:00to have to deal with the results of that in, you know, 2027 when
- 7:03they're trying to run for the presidency.
- 7:06The center can't govern because it made this big bold bet of
- 7:10calling the elections in the 1st place and it was handed a
- 7:12smaller coalition and parliament than it had.
- 7:16Nobody wants the far right to govern.
- 7:18And so, so we end up with this situation where the the name
- 7:21that comes out is sort of this mid level administrator in the
- 7:25Paris city government who has no history of building a National
- 7:29Coalition, has no history of being present in European
- 7:31politics and an international and an international stage.
- 7:35And it doesn't really make any sense.
- 7:36And of course it doesn't. Fly right now.
- 7:38Why does Marine Rupin end up having a lot of veto power in
- 7:42the end? You you mentioned when you first
- 7:44started talking about this, that our current or our new Prime
- 7:47Minister Barnier, who is right wing essentially will need to
- 7:52cater to, you know, the far right who could try to launch a,
- 7:57a motion of censure that would effectively kick him out.
- 8:01And so there's this idea of if we're going to compromise with
- 8:03anyone, it's going to be the far right.
- 8:05Why is that? So I played around with one of
- 8:08those simulators on the Moans website where you could try and
- 8:11build coalitions yourself. And essentially I this is one of
- 8:13the kind of tragically funny things in French politics at the
- 8:16moment is there really are only majorities against everything in
- 8:19the country. And so the, the only way to to
- 8:24get to a coalition involving the center, the center left, it was
- 8:29to have and not LFE Mellon Schoen's party, who all these
- 8:33other parties said was a no go for them to even consider
- 8:35joining a coalition. And there was like a six seat
- 8:38majority that was possible. And you needed to have every
- 8:41single party that was not LFE or the RN.
- 8:44And then you needed to include these regionalist parties,
- 8:47which, you know, maybe they're compatible, maybe they're not.
- 8:49It was really going to be mathematically impossible.
- 8:52And so the minute the left says, well, we will censure Barnier's
- 8:55government, we will effectively have a vote of no confidence to
- 8:58try and bring down his government.
- 9:00If you have the RN join them, then that passes because now
- 9:04there's a majority against Barnier.
- 9:05If you have the RN say we'll kind of play this hands off for
- 9:09the moment, then Barnier can survive.
- 9:12Ultimately, I think this really just benefits the RN because at
- 9:15the moment, when it's politically opportune for them
- 9:17to do so, they can, you know, snap their fingers, pull the
- 9:21string, bring it down, and they now get to control the timing of
- 9:24when that happens. Right.
- 9:26And I want to get more into who Bani is and why Macron would
- 9:30have accepted him as a as a leader.
- 9:32But before that, I want to to speak to something else you
- 9:36included in your story, which is that it's common for the French
- 9:39left to speak of France as if it's the US.
- 9:43What do you mean by that? Or what did you mean by that?
- 9:46You know, I don't know if they would consciously say that
- 9:48they're doing that. So I think there's this effect
- 9:50of Americans being kind of so numerous and so loud on social
- 9:53media and a lot of discussions online playing out in English
- 9:56where we kind of unconsciously start to view our own political
- 9:59situations and struggles through somewhat of a star spangled
- 10:03lens, especially when we talk about inequality and other
- 10:06things. You know, I wrote a column for
- 10:08The Guardian a bit over a year ago, maybe a year and a half
- 10:11ago, where I talked about having taken a straw poll of my
- 10:13students in a class that I was teaching at the time at Science
- 10:16PO and asking them to sort of place France in terms of
- 10:22inequality among OECD countries. So I, I cut all the names off of
- 10:26the graph. I put just the graph up and I
- 10:27said, where is France on here in terms of inequality from highest
- 10:30to lowest in the OECD. And pretty much uniformly all
- 10:33the students put it in the top quarter of countries.
- 10:36And for inequality, which is where the United States lies,
- 10:39actually, France is near the bottom in terms of inequality.
- 10:42And if you want the actual numbers, the Gini coefficient,
- 10:45which is the measure that economists use to talk about
- 10:47inequality in the society, for the US it's .41 and for France
- 10:52it's .31. So there's quite a significant
- 10:55difference between inequality in those two societies.
- 10:58And so I think it's important for us to to always keep in mind
- 11:01what our own contexts are the constraints that were under the
- 11:05incentives that we can try and produce to get to the places
- 11:09that we want to move politics towards and that we want to move
- 11:11social equality and economic equality towards.
- 11:14And sort of the consequences that always trickle down and
- 11:17result. And shouldn't use that for that
- 11:19phrase trickle down because it it makes us think of something
- 11:22that I really hate. Trickle down economics.
- 11:25Just sort of like spill out from that and impact what we're
- 11:28really trying to do. And so maybe just to put France
- 11:31in some context because there is a, you know, there are serious
- 11:35decisions to make about about the budget in France and to put
- 11:39some of that into context when we talk about debt, you know,
- 11:41France has lower debt to GDP than the United States does.
- 11:45But almost half of that debt is held outside of France.
- 11:48And so it's not a country that's majority paying itself in the
- 11:52future. A lot of its debt is held by
- 11:55foreigners who are buying French debt and getting the return, the
- 11:58interest rate of return on that debt.
- 12:00And it is a more open economy in the US And what I mean by that
- 12:03is not that it's freer. I mean that 33% of French GDP is
- 12:07imports of goods and services. Only 15% of USGDP is imports of
- 12:11goods and services. So if you do fiscal stimulus,
- 12:14more of that leaks out of France to other places than would leak
- 12:17out of the US to other places in terms of government spending as
- 12:22a percentage of the economy. And France government percentage
- 12:25of GDP is 57%. It's the highest of any wealthy
- 12:28nation in the world. It's actually the fourth highest
- 12:30in the entire world. And so when you hear the idea
- 12:32that France has gone down the path of ultra neoliberalism,
- 12:37ultra neoliberalism would cease to have any sort of meaning in
- 12:40the real world if France went on the path of ultra neoliberalism.
- 12:43And France is a part of the euro, right?
- 12:45It doesn't borrow in the global reserve currency, which is the
- 12:48US dollar and gives the United States what a former French
- 12:52President once termed an exorbitant privilege in the
- 12:54sense that it can continue to emit debt almost indefinitely
- 12:58and there will always be buyers for it.
- 13:01In France's case, the interest rate on that debt can tick up
- 13:05and it could put the country into a situation at which point
- 13:07it becomes pretty unsustainable to be paying interest on the
- 13:11debt. And currently it's about €55
- 13:12billion a year. We should keep in mind means €55
- 13:16billion a year that the French government can't invest in
- 13:19education and research and healthcare and infrastructure
- 13:24and clean energy transition. And so just the idea that people
- 13:28that want to reduce the debt, that's a naturally right wing
- 13:31position to take, I don't agree with.
- 13:33I think there are times when we should have debt spending, when
- 13:36we should stimulate the economy, when we should go ahead and do
- 13:38that. There are times when it doesn't
- 13:40make sense to continue to add to a large debt that then is
- 13:44trapping you with these interest payments that are diverting
- 13:47money that you could actually be using in potentially more
- 13:50productive ways, especially when half of that debt is held by
- 13:53people outside the country. Yeah, that's very interesting.
- 13:56I don't think I realized about the where the debt was being
- 13:59held, but certainly the figures you included in your piece were
- 14:02were quite alarming and which just suggests that Barnier who's
- 14:06coming in is actually inheriting quite a difficult situation.
- 14:09I had also read that France was potentially going to be
- 14:13downgraded. Is that correct in terms of
- 14:15their standing? I, I, I'm not super you're
- 14:20you're probably more in tune with the, the economics of all
- 14:25of this, but just that there's a, a grade, right?
- 14:28The a it's a. AAA and things like that and
- 14:31those are important because different pension funds and
- 14:34different investment funds that would buy sovereign debt, they
- 14:37have rules and some of them are only allowed to invest in you
- 14:40know, AAA or AA rated debt. And so if it it gets downgraded,
- 14:44then de facto there's a whole class of funds that have to sell
- 14:49off that debt and then interest rates rise or they can't
- 14:51purchase that debt in the future, which means there's less
- 14:54demand for it. And global capital markets, I'm
- 14:56sorry, this we could get really wonky, but actually what's more
- 14:59interesting to me is sort of the high level.
- 15:01What does this mean for us in terms of the society and where
- 15:03do we go? Absolutely.
- 15:05Because I mean, the thing that you mentioned, which is the
- 15:08money going toward paying off interest on debt is money that
- 15:11isn't being reinvested into the country.
- 15:12And there are plenty of services that are so badly in need of
- 15:15funding. And So what is this guy Barnier
- 15:19walking into then? And he was chosen for some very
- 15:22particular reasons. He was the Brexit negotiator.
- 15:25He's obviously pro Europe. But he is not likely to try to
- 15:30upend Mac Hall's big reforms, the pension reform being one of
- 15:34them. But what else is what else does
- 15:36his role mean for us and particularly with with this
- 15:39issue of debt? You know, I don't know when you
- 15:42have government spending that's such a high percentage of GDP
- 15:45and a tax take that is quite high.
- 15:47It's almost 50% of the economy. I think it's around 4748 percent
- 15:50is the tax take. And gap between those two is the
- 15:53the deficit that we're talking about that then adds to the
- 15:56debt. You have limited room for
- 15:58maneuver, right? And I think the government
- 16:00recently is announcing that they are looking at ways to raise
- 16:03taxes on the ultra wealthy and some corporations that are
- 16:07multinational corporations. And, and this is a place where
- 16:11governments should be looking to raise revenue.
- 16:13But again, one of my frustrations with French
- 16:16politics and really all politics in European Union nation states
- 16:21is that it often is really myopically focused on the
- 16:24national level when a lot of the solutions that we need to get to
- 16:28are only achievable at a European level.
- 16:32And so I, I would love to see a radical reimagining of how we
- 16:37talk about national domestic politics and reframing them
- 16:41through a European level, something like a common
- 16:44corporate tax floor, for example, out of European level
- 16:47that would then be collected up to that point by the EU.
- 16:50Replace national contributions to the EU budget would mitigate
- 16:53a lot of the, the arguments that you hear from far right parties
- 16:57about we're sending all this money to Europe, Europe, Europe,
- 16:59Europe. Let's give the EU its own funds.
- 17:02And then we have an entity that looks from a top down level and
- 17:06says what's good for Europe as a whole.
- 17:09France and Germany might be competing for, you know, TSMC to
- 17:13build this semiconductor fab in France or Germany.
- 17:16Actually, it really helps Europe as a whole if we have a
- 17:19semiconductor fab in Europe. This is something that's
- 17:21important for the European economy.
- 17:22It will spill out in all these different ways and neither
- 17:26France or Germany are really going to look at it in that way.
- 17:28For example, if you have Ohio competing against Arizona for a
- 17:31TSMC fab, each state wants to get it. the US government really
- 17:35just cares that there that TSMC is investing in the United
- 17:38States, that now those semiconductors are part of the
- 17:41US supply chain. So there needs to be some sort
- 17:44of similar approach at a European level, especially if
- 17:46we're talking about the energy transition.
- 17:48It's also something that really only can happen at a European
- 17:51level. If you want other sort of
- 17:53interesting data, I was looking at this earlier, you can, you
- 17:56can find emissions, like current emissions data online.
- 17:59I'm a little bit of a of a geek and so I was looking some of the
- 18:03stuff up. You know what France is
- 18:04generating in terms of emissions actively.
- 18:08And at the moment, France is generating 20 grams of CO2
- 18:13equivalent per kWh. That will mean anything to
- 18:16anybody doesn't mean anything to me unless I look at it in
- 18:18context of what other countries are doing.
- 18:21In Germany, that same number is 218 grams of CO2 equivalent per
- 18:25kWh. Right now, at this moment, if we
- 18:27go across the Atlantic to the US to the part that I grew up in
- 18:30the Midwest, it's 372g. If we move a little farther W if
- 18:35we get to 730 grams of CO2 per kWh.
- 18:40So why do I bring that up? Because looking at our energy,
- 18:47energy transmissions at the European level, you realize that
- 18:50Europe is able to have this really high component of not
- 18:56just nuclear, which France has a lot of nuclear, but of solar and
- 18:59wind, in part because energy gets traded across national
- 19:02borders, right? There's a a European market for
- 19:04energy. And if you can't trade energy
- 19:05across national borders and everybody is duplicating the
- 19:08ways that they're producing energy, If Spain is producing a
- 19:11ton of solar, France can't benefit from it.
- 19:14If France is producing a ton of nuclear here, Germany can't
- 19:16benefit from it. But you can't trade energy
- 19:18across borders. And so it actually supports the
- 19:21development of more renewables in Europe.
- 19:24And so just in lots of different ways.
- 19:26I would love to see policy take this sort of top down European
- 19:29look at things of maybe we need fiscal stimulus.
- 19:33Maybe it can't just be done in France by the French government
- 19:36emitting French debt and trying to spend that money in France.
- 19:38Maybe it really needs to happen at a European level and go for
- 19:42really big scale adjustments of how Europe is producing energy,
- 19:46how Europe is incentivizing the reindustrialization of different
- 19:50regions, how Europe is approaching housing policy, even
- 19:53how Europe is approaching its youth.
- 19:55For example, Erasmus is something that lots of
- 19:57university students get to benefit from.
- 19:59What if there were a European sort of civil service year where
- 20:03anybody from 18 to 25, regardless of whether you go
- 20:06into a trade, whether you begin work right at 18, whether you go
- 20:09to university where you could have an exchange?
- 20:12Year somewhere in Europe being placed as a volunteer with an
- 20:15organization working, you know, in the in the suburb, somewhere
- 20:19in a low income suburb or working to help a farm
- 20:22transition to regenerative agriculture practices in some
- 20:26way creating the sense of of Europeanization among the
- 20:30European, but also then giving people experiences that they can
- 20:34drop them and jump off from and in really phenomenal ways.
- 20:38To your knowledge, are are these even plans that are up for
- 20:42discussion, especially the sort of tax, common tax, corporate
- 20:47tax rate within Europe or is it sort of been vetoed because
- 20:50there are too many Member States that are aren't interested in
- 20:53playing that game? You know, I think at some level
- 20:55everyone realizes that there is a problem with big multinational
- 20:58corporations playing the tax evasion game.
- 21:01And there have been proposals among the OECD to try and have
- 21:05some sort of global minimum tax rate for these corporations.
- 21:09Unfortunately, it's always tough to come to international
- 21:12agreements, especially when certain countries see it in
- 21:15their own narrow interest to undercut other countries in
- 21:18terms of tax rates and then draw companies there.
- 21:21I think this would be something that would be only a net benefit
- 21:24for Europe to do. And there have been proposals
- 21:26throughout the years. I don't know if it's if it's
- 21:28something that's close to happening.
- 21:30Well, certainly if France were to do that in its own little
- 21:33silo, you know what would happen, which is that people
- 21:36will say, well, these companies are going to leave, then they're
- 21:38going to take all of their head offices and their employees and
- 21:41they're going to move them somewhere else.
- 21:42You know, that's why it works in Ireland.
- 21:44All these big tech companies have their sort of European
- 21:47headquarters because it's fiscally interesting for them to
- 21:49be based in Ireland. Like if we make it too
- 21:51difficult, just like it's the same argument that French people
- 21:55love to make. If you talk about taxing the
- 21:57wealthy, well then the wealthy are going to leave.
- 21:59And I'm not so sure that's 100% true if there's enough evidence
- 22:04to suggest that that's an inevitability.
- 22:06But but certainly Macron doesn't seem keen to be the one to do
- 22:10these things. But do you think that Barnier,
- 22:12who again comes from a more fiscally conservative background
- 22:18and who sees this looming debt as probably the big hurdle to to
- 22:22jump over in this first his first month in office, what do
- 22:27you think he can do and what do you think might happen?
- 22:34Easy questions, I know, big questions podcast I know what do
- 22:37I think he can do? You know, I think very little.
- 22:40I think marginally they can maybe reinstate some sort of tax
- 22:45that really targets extremely high net worth individuals and
- 22:50households. I would love to see, I think
- 22:54pursuing large tech companies in terms of fines is potentially
- 22:59quite an interesting avenue. A lot of the times we see
- 23:02companies get a slap on the wrist for violating privacy
- 23:05laws, doing other things that are finable actions, you know,
- 23:09egregiously avoiding taxes in this way or that.
- 23:11And a lot of the times you see these fines that appear
- 23:14relatively minimal and they go nowhere near the maximum that
- 23:18would actually start to be in disincentive to engage in that
- 23:20kind of behavior in the future. Maybe they'll start to see that
- 23:23as a little bit of a cash cow. Apple just recently lost court
- 23:27case that it had an EU level where Ireland, which didn't even
- 23:30want to, was forced by the EU to collect €13 billion in taxes
- 23:36from Apple. You know, I this goes back to my
- 23:39common corporate tax rate. You always hear this argument
- 23:41from Ireland that we can't raise their taxes because they'll all
- 23:44leave. Well, if everybody in Europe
- 23:45raised the corporate tax rate to 15%, I think Ireland is at 12
- 23:491/2 percent. If the minimum is set at 15%,
- 23:51then what incentive do companies have to pick up from Ireland and
- 23:55move somewhere else for the exact same tax rate, right?
- 23:58So it doesn't make much sense. Like we could universally raise
- 24:01the floor all together on these companies and start to claw back
- 24:06some of this money that floats around offshore and never is
- 24:11taxed, never benefits services, never benefits people At the
- 24:15same time, You know, I do think that often it's, I think it's an
- 24:20easy solution. We can just tax more.
- 24:24And what France has actually done well over the past few
- 24:27years is incubate and grow a tech sector.
- 24:31And it's not necessarily that low taxes help a tech sector to
- 24:34grow. I think there are other things
- 24:36that tie into retirement that have more of an impact on
- 24:39Europe's ability to build large tech companies, which is the one
- 24:42thing that Europe is always feeling inadequate about when it
- 24:45compares itself to the United States.
- 24:47And that has more to do with the amount of funding that's
- 24:49available for venture capital. And a lot of the funding that's
- 24:52available in the United States comes from big pension funds
- 24:54like, you know, the CalPERS, the California Teachers Union, which
- 24:58has an enormous pension fund that is funding all their
- 25:00retirements. That gives a certain percentage
- 25:02to be invested in venture capital that then goes into
- 25:05early stage tech companies and fuels them into Googles and
- 25:10apples and metas. And whatever is problematic is
- 25:13some of the things that these companies do are.
- 25:17I think when you talk about some of the stuff in France, people
- 25:19have an immediate very hesitant, very skeptical, very allergic
- 25:22reaction. And again, I would say if we
- 25:25started to think about public policy differently, we can
- 25:27account for some of the ways in which individual retirement
- 25:31accounts are not the solution. And that's maybe not a desirable
- 25:34way to push everybody's retirement, but France, for
- 25:37example, Mary's public and private funding and delivery
- 25:40extremely well. When it comes to healthcare, you
- 25:43and I probably both have a health mutual from somewhere.
- 25:45Yes, a mutual. Exactly.
- 25:47And so there's this marriage between the Social Security
- 25:50system and sort of doctors that are practicing on their own,
- 25:54doctors that work at public hospitals, mutuals that come in
- 25:57as nonprofit, additional insurances.
- 25:59And they're really affordable. Every month I pay like €72.00 a
- 26:03month for mine. And it boosts reimbursement and
- 26:05a host of different ways. I think you could design a
- 26:08system of public pension funds that sort of function in the
- 26:11same way. And that if we take Piketty at
- 26:13his word, actually, where the return on capital is greater
- 26:15than the growth rate of wages in an economy would be a way of
- 26:19returning the means of production to workers by having
- 26:23workers own more of the economy and this benefiting from the
- 26:26gains generated in the economy. But again, I think that some of
- 26:30this is probably way too far out there for the next month of
- 26:33Michel Barnier's prime ministership.
- 26:36And what is he going to actually be able to do?
- 26:38I think not much, to be honest, really not much.
- 26:41There's no majority for anything.
- 26:43For anything. Well, and is that supposed to
- 26:46reassure us that the people that have been since named to other
- 26:49ministry postings who are very problematic, anti LGBTQ,
- 26:53anti-gay marriage, transphobic, all sorts of, you know, really
- 26:59colorful CVS that leave a lot to be desired?
- 27:03Or does that mean we shouldn't worry too much about these
- 27:06individuals who are, you know, getting a lot of ire from from
- 27:11the voting public, specifically people who voted center left or
- 27:14full left? No, I think that you should
- 27:17always be worried when someone has, you know, reigns of
- 27:20administrative power. There's passing legislation,
- 27:23there's the ways that, you know, the administration functions in
- 27:26terms of attitudes it takes or approaches that it takes.
- 27:30Executive power isn't always dependent on a legislation
- 27:34passing a parliament. So I, I think it's absolutely
- 27:37concerning and it's disturbing. They're definitely ministers who
- 27:40I wouldn't want as the head of certain ministries.
- 27:44And one curveball question, we are also in an American election
- 27:47year and you know, you said you're from the Midwest, I'm
- 27:50from Pennsylvania, very, very important state.
- 27:54And a lot of questions I'm getting from the French are
- 27:58related to how likely we think it will go the way the way I
- 28:04think certain parts of the world are hoping it goes, which is to
- 28:08say we avoid another Trump term, which could be very disastrous,
- 28:12especially given this project 2025.
- 28:15To what degree do you think that the outcome, kind of like the
- 28:18last time when Trump was elected, would have serious
- 28:22implications for a country like France?
- 28:24I think it has really serious implications for the European
- 28:28Union. It has implications in terms of
- 28:30trade. Trump is a person, a president,
- 28:33who believes that the European Union is an enemy.
- 28:36He loves all the autocrats around the world.
- 28:39He has a thing for Vladimir Putin which rests, which remains
- 28:42relatively inexplicable. I think you would see his
- 28:46transactional style of politics really come into play where he
- 28:50thinks we can, you know, bash the Europeans on this and we can
- 28:53extract this. And then we can turn around and
- 28:56do this, you know, in the Southeast Asia and we can
- 28:58extract this And you would have really a collapse of it would it
- 29:02would be atrocious for US foreign policy. the United
- 29:04States benefits in so many ways that I don't think it ever
- 29:08actually talks about or acknowledges in public from the
- 29:11global system that it's created over the past, you know, 80
- 29:14years. And also which it disrespects
- 29:18and doesn't feel constrained by, which is deeply regrettable.
- 29:23But I think you could have a collapse of a lot of things and
- 29:25it would be really difficult for Europe, I think, to be facing
- 29:29China, which is highly cost competitive on lots of exports
- 29:33that wants to flood the European market with that result in the
- 29:36dis industrialization of large spots of Europe with Russia
- 29:40continuing a war against Ukraine that now the United States is
- 29:44not a part of her that has flipped sides on.
- 29:46And Trump is, you know, doing actively things to pressure
- 29:50Ukraine to surrender and for Putin to take over as much
- 29:53territory as he can and then set himself up to do this all over
- 29:56again. And then Europe facing United
- 29:59States, which is acting like a trade competitor and actively
- 30:02seeking to extract European industry as much as possible to
- 30:05the I think it would be bad news for for Europe, but then it's
- 30:09going to turn around and be really bad news for the United
- 30:11States. Well, of course it's.
- 30:13Going to be bad news domestically.
- 30:14It would be bad news on a foreign policy level when you've
- 30:17turned all of your erstwhile allies into competitors and
- 30:20people who are who are benefiting from you.
- 30:23Then don't start crying when suddenly you want a global
- 30:26coalition to, you know, pick up the slack or side with you when
- 30:32it comes to China and Southeast Asia and trade policy and
- 30:36competition and blah, blah blah blah blah.
- 30:38Yeah, the, the instability that it represents is quite, quite
- 30:42scary. And I think it's important, I
- 30:44think for listeners to remember, especially the listeners I have
- 30:47that are in the US, that the implications go far beyond, you
- 30:51know, American borders. And I know that's not what the
- 30:53US voter is thinking of, but it does further destabilize the US
- 30:57long after someone like a Trump or some other autocratic leader
- 31:02leaves office. And you it takes a lot of time
- 31:05to repair the damage that that. The Trump presidency just to, I
- 31:10mean, I know we both agree on this, but just like to go a step
- 31:14further, it's kind of game over for climate change policy in the
- 31:16world, right? Well, exactly, exactly.
- 31:19That is something that is already imposing huge costs on
- 31:22us that we don't want to talk about.
- 31:23And it's something that will impose even greater costs on us,
- 31:26especially in the cost people in developing countries who will be
- 31:30forced to eve en masse and become climate refugees and the
- 31:33reactions that will elicit in the developing world which has
- 31:36produced the majority of the problem.
- 31:39I don't want to sound like a whiner and a complainer.
- 31:41I just completed a two week sort of half reporting road trip from
- 31:45DC to New Orleans with a French friend.
- 31:48I was wondering what you were doing in the US.
- 31:49And it was fun to get his comments and observations on
- 31:52things that he appreciated, things that he thought were
- 31:54weird and bizarre, things that were amusing, things that
- 31:57induced rage about the United States and, and going through
- 32:02that swath of the country. And it was really just kind of
- 32:07eye opening because I, you know, now I've lived out of the
- 32:10country for so long. And Ohio, where I grew up in
- 32:13Massachusetts, where I went to undergrad, are quite different
- 32:16from Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana.
- 32:21And so it's, you know, I saw fewer Trump signs and I thought
- 32:24we would. But then again, maybe that's
- 32:27because everybody is voting Trump in those areas and you
- 32:30don't need to sort of and they don't.
- 32:32Need to be promoting him. Yeah, I'm, I'm not sure, but it
- 32:36was interesting. You said you were travelling
- 32:37with a French French. French friend, yeah.
- 32:40And do they feel a level of angst and apprehension about
- 32:46November 5th? And that even if he does lose
- 32:50that, it will, you know, it won't end up like it did the
- 32:53last time with some sort of massive coup.
- 32:55I mean, I think that's quite scary for a lot of people who
- 32:58aren't even living in the US. Yeah, I think it's quite scary.
- 33:02I think he feels a certain amount of apprehension.
- 33:04This is a friend who follows US politics extremely closely, but
- 33:07had only ever been to New York before.
- 33:09So this was kind of like a first, a first time for him and
- 33:12in some ways the first time for me to see see some different
- 33:14parts of the country. There's a lot more to to to
- 33:17report, I'm sure. There's more to unpack and maybe
- 33:20in some future columns. Right.
- 33:22OK. So I won't give anything too
- 33:24much away, but you, you will continue to report, I'm sure, on
- 33:27how this situation in France unfolds.
- 33:30But your work is also, you know, you're, you're, you talked about
- 33:33the Olympics, you talk about all sorts of other things.
- 33:36Any anything in particular coming up that you can tease
- 33:40that people will read in the Guardian?
- 33:42Oh, that I can tease. Well, I think some of the
- 33:44observations from this US road trip were were interesting.
- 33:47You know, I taught this course at Scion's PO2 first year
- 33:49students two years in a row. Not this past year, but the
- 33:52previous years. And it was looking at US
- 33:55democracy, confronting race and inequality and looking at sort
- 33:58of Alexi de Tocqueville's famous political science texts,
- 34:01Democracy in America. And he has these 5 themes in the
- 34:05book that he traces through. And he says these are really the
- 34:07things that make up the character and the nature of
- 34:10American democracy back in 18, the 1830s.
- 34:13And so chatting with my friend Guillaume, we thought it would
- 34:15be really, really fun to sort of update those.
- 34:18All of those themes are so relevant.
- 34:19And that was sort of the idea of my course.
- 34:21But if Tocqueville had like us travelled through the US today,
- 34:25what things would he sort of pick out as, as being the things
- 34:29that make American democracy what it is?
- 34:32And so I'm really, I'm really excited to sort of write a
- 34:35column going through those five. And I'll just give everybody a
- 34:38teaser. This is a mutual observation
- 34:40while we were driving through through the country
- 34:43entertainment. And there's a part of American
- 34:45politics that is inextricable from the need to be entertained.
- 34:50And really, American life that is inextricable from the need to
- 34:53be entertained. That is so fascinating.
- 34:55And I think you saw that at play with the Olympics closing
- 34:59ceremony as well, which? I love the opening and the
- 35:04closing and for the Paralympics I I thought that they were.
- 35:07Well, sure, but the, but the, the transition from Paris to LA,
- 35:11when LA took over, you could feel the difference.
- 35:15I like to joke that it felt like, you know, the Super Bowl
- 35:18halftime show style taking over and like that, that's what we
- 35:22can expect. But we saw it at one of at the
- 35:24delegate at the at the Democratic convention with Lil
- 35:28Jon coming out in what was it? Was it representing Georgia
- 35:32delegates? You know, I mean, there was
- 35:34this. I think you, I think you nailed
- 35:36something and I'm, I'm now very excited to.
- 35:38Read. Well, yeah, I mean, we went
- 35:39from. Like A5 act.
- 35:40Opera structure in the French closing ceremony to to like this
- 35:44beach party with Snoop Dogg showing up on on a tricycle.
- 35:49Yeah, I'm not. I'm not sure that that says a
- 35:51lot of really great things, but but to to unpack as as we say,
- 35:57Alex, thank you so much for coming on to explain some of
- 36:00this. I'm sure we're going to need to
- 36:02have an update in a few months time and until then everyone can
- 36:06read you on the Guardian and next year when one of yours
- 36:10comes. Out and I wish I had a
- 36:11publication date to to tell everybody about but.
- 36:14To follow. To follow.
- 36:17Thanks, Lindsay. It was great to be here.
- 36:20It's the show for today. Thanks for listening.
- 36:22As always, if you're streaming this on Spotify, be sure to
- 36:26check out a little poll that awaits you pertaining to this
- 36:28discussion. Just Scroll down on the episode
- 36:30page within the app and vote. And if you enjoy the show, I'd
- 36:34love it if you'd subscribe, share with a friend, and pick up
- 36:38the books that inspired it, The new Paris and the new Parisien.
- 36:42Until next time, Abiento.