Latest / Politics By Faith w/Mike Slater / Were America's Founders Deists Like Scholars Suggest?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Politics by Faith.
- 0:04So excited about today's special.
- 0:07I've quoted this book a million times.
- 0:10It is the most marked up book I've ever
- 0:12read.
- 0:12It's called Reading the Bible with the Founding Fathers.
- 0:15Daniel Dreisbach,
- 0:16he's a professor at American University.
- 0:19We talked with him in this first half of our special here.
- 0:21Here's my monologue
- 0:23about faith and our founders,
- 0:25and then
- 0:26Professor Driesbach.
- 0:34America is the greatest country in the world.
- 0:37Thanks for being here.
- 0:38Welcome to our special America 250,
- 0:40Faith
- 0:41and
- 0:42the Founders.
- 0:42I am incredibly excited
- 0:44to talk to Daniel Dreisbach,
- 0:45author of Reading the Bible
- 0:47with the Founding Fathers.
- 0:48I don't know if you can tell,
- 0:49this is the most
- 0:52Marked up,
- 0:53folded over page book I've ever read in my entire life.
- 0:56Can't wait to talk to him in just a few minutes.
- 0:59In honor of America's 250,
- 1:00we're gonna do a couple of specials on America and how awesome America is.
- 1:04And how we're unique and special
- 1:07and worth preserving and fighting for.
- 1:09And I start every hour of my radio show
- 1:11saying America's the greatest country in the world.
- 1:13Same thing
- 1:13with the show as well.
- 1:14Started doing that in college
- 1:16because that was the thing you could not say in college.
- 1:18It was very fashionable
- 1:19to hate America and even fly the American flag
- 1:22upside down out of your dorm room window.
- 1:25So I was sure to say it on my college radio show and it's stuck ever since and
- 1:29it's still true.
- 1:31There are so many things about America to me that are impossible.
- 1:35That
- 1:37the only conclusion I can make
- 1:38is
- 1:39God.
- 1:41And we go back to the beginning,
- 1:42right?
- 1:42I,
- 1:43I don't know where you want to start at the beginning,
- 1:44but me,
- 1:45it's the fact that Europeans ever even explored
- 1:49here.
- 1:50The,
- 1:50the reason why Columbus went west
- 1:53across this
- 1:54ocean,
- 1:55this unknown ocean,
- 1:56was because the Muslims conquered the land between Europe and China,
- 2:00and the Muslims cut off the trade routes,
- 2:02so Europeans couldn't travel it without fear of Muslims cutting their head off.
- 2:06So,
- 2:06The
- 2:07Europeans are like,
- 2:07well,
- 2:07we gotta go west,
- 2:08let's go west
- 2:09over the ocean.
- 2:10Also,
- 2:10inspiring Columbus,
- 2:13specifically,
- 2:14Jerusalem was under the control of Muslims.
- 2:17So Columbus sailed west with the goal of reaching Asia
- 2:20to meet with the Khan of what is today China,
- 2:23convert him to Christianity,
- 2:25and then use that alliance to launch a crusade
- 2:28to recapture Jerusalem from Muslim control,
- 2:30right?
- 2:31That's
- 2:32Like,
- 2:33first of all,
- 2:34that is.
- 2:36Deserving of a
- 2:37now newly renovated statue in Washington DC,
- 2:40a man like Christopher Columbus,
- 2:41but that's a pretty insane combination of events.
- 2:44So the fact that Europeans
- 2:46ever were in the place where they needed to move in this direction,
- 2:51that to me that's gone.
- 2:52Also,
- 2:53it wasn't the Muslims who sailed to the New World,
- 2:55it wasn't the Chinese,
- 2:57it was the Europeans,
- 2:58praise God,
- 2:59and it wasn't just Europeans
- 3:01who settled in America,
- 3:02it was specifically the British,
- 3:04the Spaniards,
- 3:05they settled,
- 3:06uh,
- 3:06you know,
- 3:06Mexico and,
- 3:07and,
- 3:07and South America,
- 3:09and it resulted in very different
- 3:11outcomes
- 3:12which we still see the differences in today.
- 3:14But the conquistadors,
- 3:15they came in search of gold.
- 3:16The separatist Christians
- 3:18from England,
- 3:19they came in search
- 3:20of creating a new Israel.
- 3:22True freedom
- 3:23to worship God according to the Bible.
- 3:26There's a million quotes we could give.
- 3:27John Withrop,
- 3:27he was the governor of the Massachusetts Bay Colony in 1630.
- 3:30He said,
- 3:30we shall find
- 3:31that the God of Israel is among us
- 3:34when 10 of us shall be able to resist a 1000 of our enemies.
- 3:38When he shall,
- 3:38that's in the Bible,
- 3:39when he shall make us a praise and glory
- 3:42that men shall say of succeeding generations,
- 3:45may the Lord make it like that of New England.
- 3:51Their plantation
- 3:54Did it God's way
- 3:58Now,
- 3:59a little fun side story.
- 4:01That's Plymouth.
- 4:03There was another colony nearby.
- 4:06Called uh
- 4:07Marymount.
- 4:09Controlled by
- 4:10Thomas Morton,
- 4:11another British guy,
- 4:12but he had a totally different motivation.
- 4:15His motivation was to mock
- 4:17the Puritans.
- 4:18He set up a
- 4:19distinctly un-Puritan colony called Marymount.
- 4:23He literally built a maypole idol
- 4:26with horns on top of it
- 4:28that they danced around while drunk
- 4:30with the natives,
- 4:31so they had these orgies and drunken feasts to pagan gods.
- 4:35So William Bradford at Plymouth,
- 4:37he gathered his men to attack
- 4:40the,
- 4:40the,
- 4:40his fellow Brits
- 4:42at Marymount,
- 4:43but when they got there,
- 4:44they were all drunk
- 4:45that not a shot
- 4:46was fired,
- 4:47and they grabbed Morton and exiled him
- 4:49back to England.
- 4:50That was the end of the Marymount Plantation.
- 4:52Praise God.
- 4:53I share that story.
- 4:54I love that story because
- 4:55from our very first days,
- 4:57we purified this land,
- 4:59that we kept the pagans out.
- 5:02This is
- 5:03holy land.
- 5:05Some of the things that are just impossible
- 5:07without
- 5:07God to me,
- 5:08um,
- 5:09how about the fact that we're 3000 miles of ocean away from
- 5:12the king
- 5:13and the king left us alone.
- 5:15And not only,
- 5:16he left these amazing Christian men and women alone to govern themselves.
- 5:21And that was started from the very beginning of the Mayflower Compact.
- 5:24The Mayflower Compact literally starts out saying,
- 5:26in the name of God,
- 5:27amen,
- 5:27that's the very beginning.
- 5:28And then it says,
- 5:28we whose names are underwritten
- 5:30have undertaken for the glory of God
- 5:33and the advancement of the Christian faith.
- 5:36That's the Mayflower Compact,
- 5:38when they first stepped foot on this country,
- 5:40the foundation of America's identity right from the very
- 5:44beginning.
- 5:45And because of that
- 5:47big ocean
- 5:48between us and the king,
- 5:49we were left alone for a long time.
- 5:50I think the parallel here would be evolution.
- 5:54Yeah,
- 5:55like that's the,
- 5:56the default
- 5:57belief that most people believe in evolution,
- 5:58right?
- 5:59Just cause I'm smart,
- 5:59so I believe in evolution.
- 6:01But the more you learn about the human body,
- 6:03and the more you learn about
- 6:05Like human cells
- 6:07and science and
- 6:09and space,
- 6:10the more you realize like obviously this wasn't an accident,
- 6:14this is just how this all just like happened,
- 6:15it's ridiculous.
- 6:17And
- 6:17same thing with America,
- 6:18the more you read about America,
- 6:20the more you realize that this wasn't an accident,
- 6:22and our founders knew it wasn't either.
- 6:26I think of the French and Indian War.
- 6:29This is why the British became so involved in
- 6:31America because after the French and Indian War,
- 6:32the British were broke,
- 6:33so they started to care more about this American colony because
- 6:36they wanted to control us more and tax us more.
- 6:38But because we had 150 years of independence with that big ocean,
- 6:42we didn't take very kindly to this.
- 6:44But
- 6:45we weren't a bunch of pagan fools.
- 6:48Like the French were,
- 6:49the French with their revolution
- 6:50led to 50,000 heads getting chopped off by the guillotine.
- 6:56We weren't those people
- 6:58We were men and women
- 6:59of God.
- 7:01Who were brilliant,
- 7:02who knew the history of the West,
- 7:03who knew the Bible,
- 7:04of course,
- 7:04deeply.
- 7:05And knew the history of the West
- 7:07and knew their role in it.
- 7:09It's amazing,
- 7:10we'll talk with Daniel about this in a moment.
- 7:12Our founding fathers,
- 7:13they didn't need to quote the Bible.
- 7:14They,
- 7:14they,
- 7:15they,
- 7:16they were seeped in it.
- 7:17Everything they thought and said is from the Bible.
- 7:20They,
- 7:20they didn't be like,
- 7:20well,
- 7:21in
- 7:21Proverbs 19,
- 7:22they didn't do that.
- 7:23They just
- 7:23said
- 7:24and everyone knew what they were talking about.
- 7:26Uh,
- 7:26Patrick Henry's speech,
- 7:27Give me liberty,
- 7:27give me death.
- 7:28Every other line is a biblical reference.
- 7:32And our founders are brilliant.
- 7:37And the fact that they embarked on this journey.
- 7:41It's incredible,
- 7:42and it wasn't easy,
- 7:43it wasn't quick,
- 7:44you know,
- 7:44it took 8 years.
- 7:46the Revolutionary War was 8 years.
- 7:48It wasn't a day.
- 7:49It wasn't a news cycle.
- 7:50It was 8 years.
- 7:51Could you imagine the anger at George Washington?
- 7:53How could you have led us into this foolish war,
- 7:55you fool.
- 7:56I can't believe I told you this was a terrible idea.
- 7:588 years of doubt and anger and death and the misery
- 8:02of Valley Forge.
- 8:04The losses from Washington across New York.
- 8:06What are you doing?
- 8:07Why did he lead us into this foolish war?
- 8:08It's unbelievable.
- 8:09And then George goes for broke on Christmas Day crossing the Delaware.
- 8:13But again,
- 8:13just,
- 8:13just God,
- 8:14God's role of it.
- 8:15Three groups of people crossing the river,
- 8:18the Delaware River.
- 8:18Two of the groups didn't even make it.
- 8:20And then Washington's group got across,
- 8:22but it took so long that they got
- 8:24to attack
- 8:24after the sun already came up,
- 8:25they lost their element of surprise
- 8:27and still won.
- 8:28All of it's impossible.
- 8:31And the more you read about it,
- 8:32the more impossible it all seems.
- 8:33Incredible.
- 8:34Men and women all to be alive at the same time.
- 8:40Seeped in a culture that came out of the,
- 8:41the Great Awakening,
- 8:43it's all God,
- 8:44it's always all God.
- 8:46But it's so obvious.
- 8:48And they knew it.
- 8:48One of the found one of the um.
- 8:51Symbols of the
- 8:52of America that they came up with,
- 8:53one was the eagle,
- 8:54right?
- 8:55And the other was the pyramid.
- 8:56It's on the,
- 8:57it's still on the dollar bill today.
- 8:59Right,
- 8:59there's the unfinished pyramid,
- 9:0013 steps,
- 9:01and what's above it,
- 9:02the Eye of Providence.
- 9:04The triangle
- 9:05represents the Holy Trinity.
- 9:08I'm gonna stop early cause I wanna talk to Daniel here in a moment.
- 9:10I can't wait to chat with him
- 9:12ever since I started reading his book and it's just awesome.
- 9:14Reading the Bible with the founding fathers.
- 9:16I'll just end with a quote here from the
- 9:19uh president of Yale University during the Revolutionary War,
- 9:21Timothy Dwight is his name.
- 9:23There's a dorm room named after him.
- 9:25No one knows who Timothy Dwight was,
- 9:26even though he's a prominent part of campus.
- 9:28No one knew,
- 9:29no one knew,
- 9:30but
- 9:31we do.
- 9:32He said it is impossible
- 9:34for the mind,
- 9:35which is not totally destitute of piety,
- 9:38to behold the sublime.
- 9:40The awful,
- 9:41the amazing
- 9:42works of creation and Providence
- 9:45without marking in them all the mighty hand of God
- 9:48and feeling strong emotions of reverence
- 9:51toward the author
- 9:52of these stupendous works.
- 9:55He was talking about the earth.
- 9:58But it's also true about America.
- 10:00How are we here?
- 10:02When you think about that with evolution,
- 10:03like how is this,
- 10:04how,
- 10:04like what are we doing?
- 10:05How is,
- 10:05how did this happen?
- 10:06How are,
- 10:07how are we thinking and talking and
- 10:08like how does,
- 10:09how like our digestion system work and how do we breathe and
- 10:12the amount of oxygen is perfect and the gravitational pull
- 10:14is perfect and our distance from the sun is perfect.
- 10:16Everything's perfect.
- 10:17How is this possible?
- 10:18And
- 10:19a corollary to that is
- 10:21Well,
- 10:21how are we Americans here
- 10:23in this country,
- 10:24America?
- 10:26Thank you,
- 10:27God.
- 10:28And now it's up to us
- 10:29to not lose it.
- 10:32Cannot wait
- 10:32to talk to
- 10:33Daniel Dreisbach reading the Bible with the founding fathers.
- 10:36Next,
- 10:37right here
- 10:38on Politics by faith.
- 10:50Welcome back to our special here on Politics by faith,
- 10:54an honor to talk to our next guest,
- 10:55Daniel Dreisbach.
- 10:57He's the author of Reading the Bible
- 10:59with the Founding Fathers.
- 11:00He's a professor at American University.
- 11:02And as I said before,
- 11:03this is the most
- 11:05marked up,
- 11:06underlined,
- 11:06starred,
- 11:07uh,
- 11:08I have another,
- 11:08uh,
- 11:10notation I make with an exclamation.
- 11:11Point of something's like shocking,
- 11:13most exclamation points,
- 11:14most folded over pages.
- 11:15I had to come up with a system of
- 11:17like little folded over page
- 11:19and then like medium and big folded over page depending on how
- 11:23amazing.
- 11:23I've never,
- 11:24I've never written up a book like this
- 11:25and I can't recommend enough.
- 11:26Reading the Bible with the Founding Fathers.
- 11:28Professor,
- 11:29how are you,
- 11:29sir?
- 11:29I am doing very well and I'm delighted to join you this morning.
- 11:33I'm so grateful you're here.
- 11:34What?
- 11:36Why did you write this book?
- 11:37What,
- 11:37what need did you see?
- 11:39What big questions do you have to answer for people?
- 11:43Well,
- 11:43I've been reading,
- 11:44uh,
- 11:44for many years,
- 11:45uh,
- 11:45the literature from the American founding,
- 11:48and as you know,
- 11:49you can go to the library and find a whole
- 11:51bookshelf filled with books on how John Locke or Montesquieu
- 11:54founded America.
- 11:56And,
- 11:56uh,
- 11:57and it is true that these are individuals that contributed to the,
- 12:01to the political thought and theory of the American founding,
- 12:04but,
- 12:04uh,
- 12:04I was quite dismayed that there was almost nothing written.
- 12:08About the influence of the Bible or more generally Christianity
- 12:13on the American founding.
- 12:14And so
- 12:15I saw that as a,
- 12:16as a,
- 12:17uh,
- 12:17a large,
- 12:19um,
- 12:19uh,
- 12:19gap in the literature and I thought it was important to,
- 12:22to add this
- 12:24influence,
- 12:25uh,
- 12:25to the mix of influences on the founding generation
- 12:29and the,
- 12:29and the political institutions that they created in the wake of independence.
- 12:34You filled a huge hole.
- 12:36I've never heard of 95% of anything in this book ever,
- 12:39and,
- 12:39and I,
- 12:40I kept looking stuff up like that can't be true,
- 12:42that can't be true,
- 12:42and it's all true.
- 12:43Can you give us an example of how deeply,
- 12:46I don't even know what the right word is like
- 12:47imbibed or something.
- 12:48I don't,
- 12:48I don't know,
- 12:49but like how deeply ingrained
- 12:51the Bible was into our founding fathers and founding grandfathers.
- 12:56Well,
- 12:56let's start with the Bible's influence on the,
- 12:58on the culture more generally.
- 13:00Uh,
- 13:00this is a generation,
- 13:02uh,
- 13:02that learned to read with a copy of the Bible open in front of them.
- 13:07Uh,
- 13:07the King James translation of the Bible in particular
- 13:10is an ideal tool for literacy education.
- 13:13And so this is a generation
- 13:15that knew the Bible well
- 13:18and it informed all aspects of,
- 13:21of.
- 13:21Their life
- 13:22from arts and letters to
- 13:24uh uh to to
- 13:26to education
- 13:27and so it's not gonna surprise us that they then
- 13:30look to the Bible when thinking about how to construct
- 13:34new political institutions
- 13:36in the aftermath of this
- 13:38uh separation uh from,
- 13:40from Great Britain.
- 13:41It's just a part of the culture.
- 13:43It's a part of their language and vocabulary.
- 13:47My go to example of that is you analyzed Patrick Henry's Give me liberty,
- 13:51give me death speech,
- 13:52and
- 13:53literally every other line is a biblical reference
- 13:55and a biblical illusion
- 13:57and that's to prove how
- 13:59ingrained it was and,
- 14:00and also everyone knew it,
- 14:01like the audience knew it,
- 14:02he knew it,
- 14:03they knew it,
- 14:03everyone knew it,
- 14:04and today we read it and don't know it.
- 14:07And
- 14:07it's like,
- 14:08well,
- 14:08that's how far we've fallen.
- 14:09I think there's a very interesting,
- 14:11I think there's a very interesting point to be made here,
- 14:14and that is
- 14:15many contemporary scholars,
- 14:17many modern scholars miss the role of the Bible or quotations from the Bible,
- 14:22uh,
- 14:22because they don't know it.
- 14:24They're not familiar with the distinctive language
- 14:26and rhythms of the King James Bible.
- 14:29But
- 14:29if we look at much of the discourse of the American founding,
- 14:33they too.
- 14:33are quoting the Bible without citation or without specific
- 14:38acknowledgement that it is coming from the Bible,
- 14:40but I think that simply points out
- 14:43the difference of,
- 14:44of influence on their culture and our culture.
- 14:47They didn't need quotation marks and,
- 14:50and Bible citations
- 14:52to inform them
- 14:53that this was biblical language,
- 14:55that this was a biblical quotation
- 14:57that was being invoked by a Patrick Henry or
- 15:00Or a uh a George Washington.
- 15:03Washington was constantly referencing,
- 15:05uh,
- 15:05the Bible,
- 15:06but if you read modern biographers of Washington,
- 15:10there's almost no acknowledgement of the influence of the Bible
- 15:13on the discourse of a George Washington.
- 15:16But again,
- 15:16I think that simply underscores that we live in a biblically illiterate culture,
- 15:21whereas the founding generation lived in
- 15:24a profoundly biblically literate culture.
- 15:29Something,
- 15:29let's take a simple example,
- 15:30like when Ben Franklin says,
- 15:31uh,
- 15:32you know,
- 15:32if two,
- 15:33if two birds,
- 15:34uh,
- 15:35can't fall,
- 15:36uh,
- 15:37you know,
- 15:37what are,
- 15:37what are the chances that the Lord has no knowledge about,
- 15:40uh,
- 15:41the affairs of a nation,
- 15:42the rise or fall of an empire.
- 15:43If you're biblically illiterate,
- 15:44you don't understand that the two sparrows line is,
- 15:46is referencing the Bible.
- 15:47So you'd be like,
- 15:48oh well,
- 15:48he's not referencing the Bible.
- 15:49They're like,
- 15:50well,
- 15:50no,
- 15:50he is,
- 15:50he's not quoting the verse,
- 15:52but everyone knew what he was talking about.
- 15:54Can you give me an example of how that translated into
- 15:57what
- 15:58laws and or systems
- 16:00these founding fathers set up?
- 16:01Like what are the biblical connections there?
- 16:04Well,
- 16:05let me start with what I think is the most significant
- 16:07and profound influence of the Bible on the American founding.
- 16:11More than one American founder said,
- 16:13if we're going to build new political institutions,
- 16:15if we're going to build
- 16:17new governments and write new constitutions,
- 16:19the starting point is this
- 16:21understanding.
- 16:22It must be an understanding
- 16:24of who man is,
- 16:25of human nature.
- 16:27And,
- 16:27and this is an area where they
- 16:29constantly were looking
- 16:31to the Bible to get an understanding
- 16:34of,
- 16:34of the nature of man.
- 16:37And,
- 16:37and the answer that they came up with is that man was a fallen creature.
- 16:41They learned this from reading Genesis chapter 3 and
- 16:44the story of the fall in the garden.
- 16:46And what did they do?
- 16:47They build a government
- 16:49that took that fallen nature.
- 16:52into account.
- 16:53This explains the founding generation's near obsession
- 16:57with separation of powers and checks and balances because they
- 17:00understood that humans were inclined to aggrandize their power,
- 17:05to abuse that power,
- 17:07and so they were constantly looking
- 17:09for methods and means to tie down the exercise of power by fallen sinful.
- 17:16Creatures.
- 17:17Now,
- 17:17we can move beyond that and talk about some very specific ways
- 17:21in which the Bible
- 17:22informed,
- 17:23um,
- 17:24uh,
- 17:25ideas and principles in their constitutional government.
- 17:28They found in the Old Testament,
- 17:30for example,
- 17:31uh,
- 17:31principles laying out the idea of,
- 17:34of,
- 17:34of no double jeopardy.
- 17:36They saw in Exodus 23,
- 17:39a roadmap for principles.
- 17:40of due process.
- 17:42They saw in Exodus 18:21,
- 17:46the,
- 17:46the
- 17:47characteristics they should look for in their,
- 17:50in their rulers.
- 17:52And so we could go through a very long list of biblical
- 17:57sources
- 17:57that inform some very specific
- 18:00ideas that were built into their constitutional systems of government.
- 18:05Your book also really inspired me to do more
- 18:07research on this group I call the founding grandfathers.
- 18:09I don't know the proper term for them,
- 18:10it'd be like the generations before our founding fathers cause
- 18:13the founding fathers had to grow up in some culture,
- 18:15um,
- 18:15right,
- 18:16they had to have some professors and teachers.
- 18:17So we just quoted Timothy Dwight a moment ago,
- 18:20uh,
- 18:20I think our last special we quoted Jonathan Mayhew,
- 18:22um,
- 18:23but,
- 18:23but can you tell us about
- 18:24these people and really even specifically maybe even
- 18:27the preachers of these people and the,
- 18:28and the role
- 18:29that the Bible scholars and,
- 18:31and church leaders had
- 18:33in let's say like 1700s America.
- 18:36Well,
- 18:36an interesting question that historians still debate to
- 18:40this day is what influence did the Great Awakening
- 18:44in the first half of the 18th century
- 18:47have on the ideas and,
- 18:49and the political thought of the American founding generation
- 18:52in the second half of the 18th century.
- 18:55My own view is that the,
- 18:56the Great Awakening,
- 18:57those great preachers,
- 18:59uh,
- 18:59we think of a George Whitfield and a Jonathan Edwards,
- 19:03um,
- 19:03I,
- 19:03I think it's hard to imagine
- 19:06the,
- 19:06the,
- 19:06the,
- 19:06the culture of the founding generation absent
- 19:10that spiritual awakening earlier in that century.
- 19:15It's often said that Patrick Henry,
- 19:17his great oratorical skills were nurtured by listening to and watching him,
- 19:23watching the great,
- 19:25uh,
- 19:25the great preachers of the Great Awakening.
- 19:29Um,
- 19:29but even More specific and,
- 19:31and well-defined areas.
- 19:33You mentioned Jonathan Mayhew.
- 19:35Uh,
- 19:35Jonathan Mayhew gave a sermon 1749,
- 19:401750 on the anniversary of the beheading,
- 19:44the execution of Charles the First of England
- 19:47in which Mayhew lays out an argument
- 19:50in defense of resisting
- 19:53or rebelling against tyrannical rulers.
- 19:56This was a Profoundly influential sermon that Mayhew gives.
- 20:01It's printed and reprinted throughout the colonies.
- 20:04Uh,
- 20:05John Adams writes that he heard that sermon or was aware of that sermon as a young man
- 20:10and that
- 20:12he,
- 20:12he read it and reread it till he had almost memorized it.
- 20:16But my point here is this that Mayhew laid out a biblical defense of resisting
- 20:23unjust and Tyrannical rulers,
- 20:26and this is going to provide a profound
- 20:30biblical rationale
- 20:32that Americans are going to look to and draw on
- 20:36when it comes to their own
- 20:38view of the tyranny of George III and Parliament,
- 20:42and this is going to give them comfort that
- 20:44that this is an idea that enjoys divine favor,
- 20:48rebelling against tyrannical rulers.
- 20:52OK,
- 20:52I want to get back to divine favor,
- 20:54bookmark that one for a second.
- 20:55But this is what I'm talking about everyone watching here.
- 20:57Again,
- 20:58reading the Bible of our founding fathers
- 20:59is the name of the book.
- 21:01I'm reading along and you hear the name Jonathan Mayhew,
- 21:03and then you hear John Adams say,
- 21:05as you said,
- 21:05like,
- 21:06I've read it so many times,
- 21:07I memorized it.
- 21:07It was,
- 21:08it was like the most read
- 21:09sermon in the whole country.
- 21:11Everyone knew it.
- 21:12Everyone was aware of it.
- 21:13I've never heard of it in my entire life.
- 21:15Like,
- 21:16how can I
- 21:17How can I go my entire life as an American?
- 21:19I've never heard of Jonathan Mayhew,
- 21:21let alone,
- 21:21of course,
- 21:22read his work.
- 21:22So I,
- 21:23I say that
- 21:24to ask you.
- 21:25As a professor,
- 21:27the default position
- 21:28from almost all Americans,
- 21:30particularly young Americans,
- 21:31is that separation of church and state,
- 21:33our founders were deists,
- 21:34they weren't Christians,
- 21:35this isn't a Christian nation,
- 21:37and your book and your scholarship just flies right in the face of that.
- 21:41How do your students
- 21:43react
- 21:44to
- 21:45what you say here?
- 21:47Well,
- 21:48your reaction is,
- 21:49is not an uncommon one.
- 21:50I often give a,
- 21:51a talk on the book,
- 21:52and I'll,
- 21:53I'll see,
- 21:54uh,
- 21:54someone
- 21:55sort of barreling towards me from,
- 21:56uh,
- 21:57from,
- 21:57from the audience,
- 21:58and they're red in the face and I go,
- 22:00oh boy,
- 22:00they're gonna really lay into me.
- 22:02They're gonna really challenge me.
- 22:03And,
- 22:04and when they actually get to me,
- 22:05they say,
- 22:06you know,
- 22:06uh,
- 22:06I,
- 22:07I have,
- 22:07uh,
- 22:08I,
- 22:08I went through,
- 22:09uh,
- 22:09elementary school,
- 22:09I went through high school,
- 22:10I've been to college,
- 22:11I got a master's degree,
- 22:13and how is it
- 22:14That I went through all that education and I've never once been exposed
- 22:19to the perspective that you have laid out in your book.
- 22:23Uh,
- 22:23I think it reveals a profound failing
- 22:26in our education system.
- 22:27I think it also reflects a kind of a secular bias
- 22:31in,
- 22:32in 20th century,
- 22:33uh,
- 22:34education and,
- 22:35and,
- 22:35and 20th century scholarship on the American founding.
- 22:38I think we find that the leading scholar.
- 22:41Scholars of the 20th century
- 22:42are largely biblically illiterate,
- 22:45and they're drawn to those founders who speak in the language
- 22:49of the Enlightenment or what they believe the Enlightenment to be.
- 22:53And so they're drawn to the secular
- 22:55aspects or the secular arguments that were often made
- 22:59and completely miss or dismiss.
- 23:02I'm more concerned about the dismissing part,
- 23:04but they largely miss those arguments.
- 23:07that were informed
- 23:09by,
- 23:10by a,
- 23:11a spiritual perspective,
- 23:13a biblical argument.
- 23:15You mentioned earlier,
- 23:16separation of church and state.
- 23:18That's an interesting concept that,
- 23:20that found,
- 23:21uh,
- 23:21a,
- 23:21a rooting,
- 23:23uh,
- 23:23both in the Enlightenment but also in a profoundly biblical,
- 23:27uh,
- 23:28uh,
- 23:28perspective.
- 23:29Think of the Baptists.
- 23:30The Baptists were ardent advocates
- 23:32for separation of church and state.
- 23:34But not necessarily an argument rooted in the enlightenment,
- 23:37but one that they believed
- 23:39to be rooted in a biblical perspective.
- 23:43They're thinking about giving to Caesar that which is Caesar and to God,
- 23:46that which is God.
- 23:47There's a kind of a separation principle there.
- 23:50And so we miss
- 23:52the,
- 23:52the spiritual influences,
- 23:54the biblical influences
- 23:56that inform so many of the important ideas of the American experiment.
- 24:02Hm.
- 24:02What about the students who resist you,
- 24:05who,
- 24:05who barrel towards you not to thank you,
- 24:07but
- 24:07to be angry at you,
- 24:09uh,
- 24:09for saying this?
- 24:10How do,
- 24:10how do you begin
- 24:12to unwind
- 24:15decades of
- 24:18Of wrong thinking about our founding.
- 24:20Well,
- 24:21I think this is where the evidence comes into play.
- 24:24One of the things I take some pride in is that in my book,
- 24:28every single quotation,
- 24:31and every single claim,
- 24:32I,
- 24:33I try to document,
- 24:34not simply to secondary sources,
- 24:35but to primary sources.
- 24:37When I quote the American founders,
- 24:40as you will see in my extensive footnotes,
- 24:43uh,
- 24:43in notes I should say,
- 24:45uh,
- 24:45I am citing the
- 24:47Very best primary sources
- 24:50available to modern scholarship and so
- 24:53again it's not me
- 24:55speaking,
- 24:55it's not even secondary,
- 24:57the secondary literature that's advancing some argument.
- 25:00It's,
- 25:01it's the words of the founders and the founding generations themselves,
- 25:05and so,
- 25:06uh,
- 25:06look,
- 25:07I,
- 25:07I should also point out that uh
- 25:09I,
- 25:09I don't make the claim that the Bible is the only source of influence.
- 25:14I do make the point more than once in the
- 25:17book is that the founding generation was remarkably literate,
- 25:22remarkably well read,
- 25:24and they drew on diverse sources.
- 25:27Yes,
- 25:27they read people like John Locke and Montesquieuu.
- 25:32They read and studied earlier experiments in republicanism.
- 25:37They were careful students of the Roman Republic,
- 25:40and Other experiments in republicanism,
- 25:43so they're drawing on diverse
- 25:46influences.
- 25:47My claim is that the Bible is,
- 25:50is in that mix of influences.
- 25:53Now I would argue it's a very important
- 25:56part of that mix of influences,
- 25:58but I certainly am not dismissing
- 26:01that there were influences on the founding
- 26:04generation apart from the Bible and Christianity.
- 26:08That should be uncontroversial,
- 26:09but,
- 26:10but,
- 26:10so I just opened up randomly to one of the leafed pages.
- 26:13Um,
- 26:14this is,
- 26:14uh,
- 26:15Ben Franklin.
- 26:16I'm not gonna read the whole thing,
- 26:17but just in this one paragraph.
- 26:20He,
- 26:20he quotes,
- 26:21again without citing,
- 26:22but he quotes
- 26:23Daniel 4:17,
- 26:24Matthew 10:29,
- 26:26Luke 12:6 12:6,
- 26:27Psalm 1271,
- 26:29Genesis 11:19,
- 26:31Deuteronomy 28:37,
- 26:33uh,
- 26:33Chronicles 7:20,
- 26:34Psalm 44:14.
- 26:36That's all in one paragraph of a speech that Ben Franklin gave.
- 26:40And Ben Franklin is supposed to be like the most pagan of them all,
- 26:43right?
- 26:43And you even take time to debunk,
- 26:45I think a proper debunk,
- 26:46I don't know what would you want to use,
- 26:47this idea of the Jefferson Bible.
- 26:49I remember growing up thinking about the Jefferson
- 26:50Bible where he took out all the miracles.
- 26:52Well,
- 26:52he also kept in the resurrection
- 26:53and like a bunch of other stuff.
- 26:55So what do you make of
- 26:57the spotlight put on Jefferson's deism?
- 27:00That's right.
- 27:01You mentioned,
- 27:02uh,
- 27:02uh,
- 27:03uh,
- 27:03uh,
- 27:03deism and,
- 27:04uh,
- 27:05a little bit earlier
- 27:06in your remarks,
- 27:07and,
- 27:07and this is one of those areas where I think modern scholarship has,
- 27:11has really gotten it wrong.
- 27:12Uh,
- 27:13so,
- 27:14one of the challenges,
- 27:15of course,
- 27:15is that,
- 27:16uh,
- 27:16um,
- 27:17how do we define deism.
- 27:18Deism is a,
- 27:19is a belief system without a,
- 27:21uh,
- 27:22a,
- 27:22a sacred text.
- 27:23It doesn't have a pope or a bishop.
- 27:25It doesn't have a formal.
- 27:27Creed and so
- 27:28the very term deism uh covers a,
- 27:31a rather broad range of ideas
- 27:34from a kind of Unitarianism to something that's
- 27:38verging on atheism,
- 27:40not quite there,
- 27:41but
- 27:41verging on atheism.
- 27:43But if you take that definition of deism that we all learned in high school,
- 27:47you remember the clockmaker God
- 27:49definition of deism,
- 27:51that there was a creator God,
- 27:52he
- 27:53wound up the world and let it
- 27:56sort of operate on its own and then he removed himself from the material world.
- 28:00If that's our definition of deism,
- 28:03I don't think you're going to find a single
- 28:06significant founding father
- 28:08who embraced deism.
- 28:10Now deism is going to come into its own in the 19th century,
- 28:13but in the late 18th century,
- 28:15I don't think there's a single
- 28:17founding father that we could.
- 28:19appropriately call,
- 28:21uh,
- 28:21a deist using that high school definition of deism that we all learned,
- 28:26uh,
- 28:26without,
- 28:27without exception,
- 28:27this was a generation that believed that God,
- 28:30on occasion,
- 28:32sometimes more often in the views of one founder than another,
- 28:35but
- 28:36this was a God who would on occasion
- 28:38intervene in the material world,
- 28:41in the affairs of man.
- 28:42Jefferson
- 28:44makes claims that God.
- 28:46Intervenes in the material world.
- 28:48Franklin
- 28:49makes that claim,
- 28:50uh,
- 28:51and so you can go through the list of the so-called deist founders
- 28:55and,
- 28:55and,
- 28:55and almost none of them
- 28:57meet that,
- 28:58that definition that we all learned for,
- 29:01for deism.
- 29:02Um,
- 29:02and now,
- 29:03I don't want to make the claim
- 29:05that they're orthodox Christians by any means.
- 29:08I,
- 29:08I think Jefferson and a,
- 29:10and a Franklin.
- 29:11Uh,
- 29:12give much evidence that they're not
- 29:14orthodox Christians,
- 29:15maybe not even Christians themselves,
- 29:18but they knew the Bible,
- 29:20they used the Bible,
- 29:21they were drawn to biblical arguments
- 29:25on significant points,
- 29:28and it informed their larger political theory.
- 29:31They were also,
- 29:32we should note,
- 29:33gifted communicators,
- 29:34and they knew the audience to whom
- 29:36they were.
- 29:37Addressing their remarks and so
- 29:39not surprisingly,
- 29:41gifted communicators like a Franklin Jefferson or even a Thomas Paine
- 29:46speaks in a biblical or biblical-like language
- 29:50simply to connect with their audience,
- 29:52but I think it goes much deeper than simply
- 29:55this rhetorical
- 29:56appeal to the Bible.
- 29:57They're appealing to the Bible on,
- 29:59on,
- 30:00on basic fundamental principles as well.
- 30:04Daniel Dreisbach,
- 30:05I just want to encourage everyone,
- 30:06please read the book,
- 30:07Reading the Bible with the,
- 30:08with the founding fathers.
- 30:10Do it for America's 250.
- 30:12Uh,
- 30:12and,
- 30:12and
- 30:13it,
- 30:14it's incredible.
- 30:14I can't recommend it enough.
- 30:15It's the top book I recommend right now.
- 30:17Professor,
- 30:17thank you for your time.
- 30:18Thank you for being a professor,
- 30:19for speaking to kids,
- 30:21and for
- 30:21changing the generation
- 30:23in every way you can.
- 30:24Very grateful.
- 30:25Well,
- 30:26thank you
- 30:26for having me and,
- 30:27and thank you for the kind words about the book.
- 30:29I really,
- 30:30really appreciate that.
- 30:31Thank you.
- 30:32Hope we can talk again.
- 30:33Daniel Gisbach right there.
- 30:34The book is called Reading the Bible with the Founding Fathers,
- 30:36and I,
- 30:37I know that you will mark it up,
- 30:39uh,
- 30:39as much as I have mine.
- 30:40Mike Slater,
- 30:41News Radio,
- 30:42Mike Slater on
- 30:43the first TV.
- 30:44Spread the word.