Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / The benefits of doing business with India and Brazil | Special Series
Transcript
- 0:11Welcome to this very special series on India and Brazil on
- 0:15the KJ Master Class Live every fortnight.
- 0:18Along with my esteemed friend and podcast host from York, you
- 0:21can see him on the screen. We explored together our
- 0:24nation's journeys in business, culture and politics and
- 0:28podcasting as we strive to find our rightful place in the global
- 0:32arena. And as you can see, joining us
- 0:35live from Campinas, Brazil is Stormed York who has spent his
- 0:38whole life there known as the an American known as the king of
- 0:43multicultural communication and networking.
- 0:46With a wealth of experience in market development and product
- 0:49management across diverse businesses, Tom is the founder
- 0:53and host of three business podcasts, a public speaker and
- 0:56author. His deep expertise and extensive
- 0:59network will provide invaluable insights into Brazil's dynamic
- 1:03landscape and it is indeed and today we will be talking on
- 1:07profitable, you know business environment in Brazil and India
- 1:11for companies who want to invest here, especially small companies
- 1:15who will find their liking of business environment in both and
- 1:19both their countries. So we will be giving Tom this
- 1:23whole thing over now so that he can talk about the business
- 1:26environment in Brazil. So that more and more people
- 1:30learn about the business opportunities there, about the
- 1:32good environment, ready for businesses to come in.
- 1:36Over to you, Tom. Well, thank you again, AJ Thanks
- 1:39to our people following us now. This is the special series, This
- 1:44is our 4th chat that we've done talking about business and
- 1:50business between and in India and Brazil.
- 1:54So as we gain more energy. As we've gained more inertia
- 1:59from our chats, we both have been able to see and follow
- 2:04these last few months exactly what we're, we say could happen.
- 2:09It's happening. We've talked about success
- 2:12stories here for small businesses, we've talked about
- 2:15success stories there and here for big businesses.
- 2:19We've talked about different markets.
- 2:22We've talked a little bit about bricks, which are the, which is
- 2:26the the name of Brazil. Russia, India, China and South
- 2:32Africa, when we talk about that group and what I see today is
- 2:39that both India and Brazil, they're not the game changers,
- 2:44but India and Brazil today are the game setters.
- 2:48And why is that the positive business environment in India is
- 2:54known? We've talked about that the
- 2:57opportunity that's there, expansion, the multicultural
- 3:01influences even within India, the number of languages that
- 3:06you've learned that you have and how to deal with cultures within
- 3:10your own country. And we've talked about here from
- 3:13the Brazil standpoint that Brazil is a culture.
- 3:17It's still learning to to to to work on the on the global stage,
- 3:21all right and to gain its own strength.
- 3:24But more recently, we've seen that.
- 3:26The importance of the two countries, all right.
- 3:29And I don't want to criticize any other country out there in
- 3:32the world, but I do want to call attention to Indian Brazil.
- 3:36But we are at present here 2023 the game setters.
- 3:41So we have individually massive markets, massive opportunities
- 3:45we've talked about. But what's happened here
- 3:48recently in the Brazil economic scenario that I want to?
- 3:54Talking a couple points here today, a couple weeks ago we've
- 3:58seen a change in the credit rating for the country.
- 4:02So the international credit rating agencies like Fitch and
- 4:06Standard and Poor's Moody, they give a rating to a country.
- 4:12It's like we have person, we have our own credit rating.
- 4:15So if Tom wants to go out and borrow money, if a J wants to go
- 4:18out and borrow money, we have a credit rating and maybe the bank
- 4:22or the lenders will give us money, maybe they won't.
- 4:24And maybe they'll give us money charge a higher interest rate or
- 4:28maybe they won't. And the same thing happens with
- 4:30the country. So years ago, Brazil had what
- 4:34was called an investment grade rating and that investment grade
- 4:39credit rating opens an Ave. of investment possibilities from
- 4:44massive investment funds. They could come because they
- 4:48needed. They could only invest in
- 4:49countries that have investment grade.
- 4:52Brazil lost that in 2015. So what happened from 2015 until
- 4:58now, we haven't gained it, but it stopped the number of
- 5:01investments coming to Brazil. And we know you can have
- 5:05opportunities. I can have an opportunity, You a
- 5:08J can have an opportunity, but we need resources.
- 5:11We need money to make the engine run.
- 5:15It's the fuel for for economic growth, for money, and we know
- 5:19there's a lot of money out there.
- 5:22So that was a water on the fire from the Brazilian Stanford for
- 5:27many years. So last month the rating agency
- 5:33started to change a more favorable aspect to the
- 5:36Brazilian rating. It's not investment grade, but
- 5:40the tendency is set, it's pointing that direction.
- 5:45And why is that? It's not because they think it's
- 5:47a good idea. But the economic indicators show
- 5:52that the growth, the the, the risk in Brazil has dropped.
- 5:57And and risk dropping risk comes from political stability.
- 6:00All right. It comes from engagement from
- 6:03companies and banks. All right, A credible rating I
- 6:07would I will learn, I will learn, I will earn and learn.
- 6:12I will loan money to A J. Because I know A J, I, I feel
- 6:17that A J will pay me back, All right, I I'm comfortable with
- 6:23that. That's for Tom and A J.
- 6:25It's also the same for companies, for country, All
- 6:28right. So that's changing.
- 6:29So money is starting to flow. It has at the beginning, it
- 6:32starts to flow again to be well and that's the lifeline for any
- 6:37company. So that is happening.
- 6:40Unemployment in Brazil has dropped slightly.
- 6:44The good side is we got more people working.
- 6:47We have more people economically engaged.
- 6:50We still have a pool of Labor force that can still fuel
- 6:57companies coming here. They'll have labor all right and
- 7:02labor that can be applied very shortly.
- 7:06Inflation has started to drop. Inflation dropping shows the
- 7:10prices drop. So the prices drop.
- 7:14The the, the capability of person to be able to buy more
- 7:17started to happen. So all these things come
- 7:19together at one time. So that has helped the ratings
- 7:25looking towards Brazil be more favorable.
- 7:28So when we see this tendency for a more positive outlook goes
- 7:33back to the company, goes back to what we've talked about, is
- 7:37this a good place to invest? Is this a good place for Indian
- 7:40companies to come? We've talked, we've talked about
- 7:44the opportunities. It's there.
- 7:46The reverse is the same. If Brazilian companies are more
- 7:49comfortable, if they see a horizon that's more secure,
- 7:56they're also interested in going out and developing markets.
- 8:02They can develop these markets if they have access to money, if
- 8:06they're Brazilian company to go to India, which would be
- 8:11today's. Outlook, a very favorable
- 8:15investment and opportunity. They would also need the money.
- 8:19So this is the game setter that I see that's happening.
- 8:23India is in a comfort zone, a certain comfort zone as we
- 8:27compared to the rest of the world.
- 8:29Brazil was also becoming that. So when you have a comfortable
- 8:34business climate, that's when things really start happening.
- 8:37That's when the locomotive starts getting out of the.
- 8:42Getting it, getting on the tracks and getting out of the
- 8:44station, that's what's happening right now.
- 8:46And this is midterm Brazil. Historically, Brazil has always
- 8:51been stronger in the second-half of every year.
- 8:55Companies also start producing here.
- 8:57The year end in Brazil talk about Christmas, which was an
- 9:01adventure, but the end of the year vacations.
- 9:05This is the time when we have the harvest.
- 9:08Here some more money from agriculture.
- 9:11Has always been a strong second-half.
- 9:15So my outlook for this year is going to be very stronger
- 9:20because of all of these indicators that we're seeing.
- 9:23So that's our, that's our word today.
- 9:25All right. This is where things are going.
- 9:28This is what we see in our chat #4 wonderful wonderful this is,
- 9:33this is indeed a nice thing, you know.
- 9:36And the whole concept was that you know we all as together we
- 9:41see our countries fighting to try for you know for the
- 9:44rightful place in the global arena.
- 9:46So I'm sure this is a great news for Brazil.
- 9:49And in in a way it also makes me happy because Brazil is part of
- 9:55the BRICS. Brazil we we in India, a lot of
- 9:58we look at Brazil as some someone like us part of that
- 10:04whole you know if you call it a third world which we are but
- 10:07developing very, very fast and now taking ready for that big
- 10:11leap to be in the big League of Nations.
- 10:14But I'm sure this this step along with several other steps
- 10:18will bring in much more strength to Brazil's economy and also
- 10:23make it not only stronger for itself but also with bring that
- 10:28strength to the BRICS and also bring much more strength to the
- 10:32India, Brazil partnerships going forward.
- 10:35And and that that that's a great step.
- 10:38So how do you see, Tom, this particular thing, the rating
- 10:42division positively is going to impact in terms of that now do
- 10:47you expect more investment from outside into Brazil?
- 10:51Well, I want to say yes, because investment, part of the
- 10:55component of any investment of any business environment.
- 10:59It's psychological. If you have money in your pocket
- 11:03and I have money in my pocket. And I think that next month or
- 11:07the month after, I will continue having money.
- 11:10I may be enticed to spend that or apply it or invest it as an
- 11:16investor. If I'm looking to countries like
- 11:19Indian, Brazil and I see that comfort zone, I also am more
- 11:25comfortable in putting my money there because there are options
- 11:29throughout the world what I see happening today.
- 11:34All right. Is it Brazil and India, You
- 11:39mentioned the third, third world countries.
- 11:42We've we've heard them being talked about as being the
- 11:44emerging economies second tier or whatever.
- 11:50I I think we have to find a new classification.
- 11:56And why is it? I would go back to that.
- 11:57I would, I would call us and the bricks, the game setters.
- 12:04So it isn't to be big, big or biggest, the first year, second
- 12:07year, whatever, But the tendencies, the economic
- 12:12indicators are the same everywhere.
- 12:14When you look at the International Monetary Fund,
- 12:17they're comparing numbers all the time amongst all of the
- 12:19countries. It's like a big scoreboard,
- 12:22right? And nobody wins the game, but
- 12:26you can favorably be position. So again, Indian Brazil are
- 12:31favored in position and that helps.
- 12:33People who have the money need to decide on where to put it.
- 12:38It's like a logical aspect and it's always risk.
- 12:41Risk is a decision that's not made on a monthly basis.
- 12:46It's made daily. In our world today, it's made
- 12:51instantaneously. So when I wake up here in
- 12:55Brazil, I already see what Asia what India has decided on the
- 13:02stock market. You have already decided what my
- 13:07today is going to be, all right and it's it's already deciding
- 13:12what the West Coast of the United States is going to be.
- 13:15So your day has already happened.
- 13:16You've already lived the better part of today.
- 13:21So the psychology of where are you in India going to put your
- 13:25money starts with that. If you're comfortable with
- 13:29Brazil, you I'm saying companies in India.
- 13:33And companies in India have, I would say and we've talked about
- 13:37that they do have an understanding as you mentioned,
- 13:40we have a a feeling of comfort between countries, right.
- 13:47The sameness is important. So part of that, if you start
- 13:53seeing numbers that are more positive, you as an investor in
- 13:56India, you as a CEO in India? Who this morning had to decide
- 14:05on and we're we're the start of another month, Where do we put
- 14:08the money here. A company in India has options
- 14:12everywhere. So psychologically these looks
- 14:15more favorable or sees numbers that are more favorable to
- 14:19Brazil. He just might want to decide in
- 14:21that morning meeting in India, but let's do that, let's invest
- 14:27more in Brazil, let's go there. Things are looking good.
- 14:30They're looking better. So that happens.
- 14:34That happens. So you see Brazil is being
- 14:36decided before Brazil even wakes up.
- 14:41And so that's where these numbers become important and in
- 14:45boardrooms throughout the world, All right, that happens every
- 14:49day. It's constant.
- 14:51The chats of we're having our chat about Indian Brazil every
- 14:5615 days or so. But CE O's and and the directors
- 15:01and the CF O's and the CM O's of all companies, they have this
- 15:06chat every day. They may set up a monthly
- 15:10meeting, but daily they're checking numbers.
- 15:13Daily they're they're seeing what's happening.
- 15:16They're adjusting whatever they thought would be their plan for
- 15:20July or August or September that is being adjusted constantly.
- 15:26This information flows. India is the center of
- 15:29technology for all of this. India has been the Center for
- 15:34customer satisfaction, customer involvement for years.
- 15:40But you have you as a as a tension you as companies in
- 15:44India, you have the pulse you have a you have a more feeling
- 15:50about many different examples. So that's positive.
- 15:54So the the light back to. Brazil and the engagement and
- 15:58these numbers that come out with dating inflation going down,
- 16:03unemployment going down, those are the numbers where
- 16:08everybody's thinking about in business every day.
- 16:11Brazilian business persons, the same thing, all right.
- 16:15Technology is the same here. Companies are interacting, many
- 16:19companies in Brazil, multinationals, they're
- 16:22connected to the world, the world's connected to them.
- 16:25We have many European companies here.
- 16:27We have Indian companies, we have the Asian companies,
- 16:31American companies, Latin, everybody's here.
- 16:35So these dialogues, which are instantaneous, the XL charts
- 16:41happen constantly. But the psychology, we look at
- 16:44numbers. A J, we do that, I do that.
- 16:47You do that. We look at numbers.
- 16:50But we have to. We have to get inside ourselves.
- 16:55And adjust to those numbers that we see.
- 16:57Am I going to go, am I not going to go?
- 16:59Do I assume the risk and the higher you get in the in the
- 17:02company, the more responsible, the more responsibility you
- 17:06have. You have interviewed hundreds of
- 17:09CE O's, right? And you know more than that.
- 17:15That's how they think they're looking at opportunities.
- 17:20But the decision? Stops, then starts with them,
- 17:25right? Absolutely, Absolutely.
- 17:28Most of these companies, they look at investments, they look
- 17:32at that money saved. They look at that their money
- 17:35invested is properly giving them the returns.
- 17:38And in those aspects, these ratings also matter.
- 17:41And they will certainly be, you know, a lot of more CEO's, more
- 17:44global companies will be willing to put money into Brazil now.
- 17:49And I'm sure a lot of Indian companies will also start
- 17:51looking at we have been talking about, you know, profitable
- 17:54business opportunities, especially for small businesses.
- 17:58Even podcasting is growing. So that also can be one big area
- 18:02where you know a lot of people can because once when companies
- 18:06come in, podcasting is a great medium for you know, marketing
- 18:09tool for, for individuals, for brands, for companies, for
- 18:14coaching, for coaches, for consultants and business has
- 18:17come, everything come along with that and everything else grows
- 18:21even food companies and all because there are a lot of
- 18:24international people will keep on coming and that is that's the
- 18:27way the economy is connected with one thing or the other from
- 18:30India. In India also you see the
- 18:33ratings are different. Now we have also been dealing
- 18:36with ratings sometimes good, sometimes not sometimes very
- 18:39good and this is the way. But as of now India has a very
- 18:43special place because of the global dynamics because a lot of
- 18:47companies, the countries now are looking to move away a bit of a
- 18:51or quite a bit of their manufacturing from China and it
- 18:56is, it is their choice. They want to earlier on look at
- 19:01China in the days it is like you dont want to put all your
- 19:04manufacturing X into or the into one particular basket and and
- 19:10that is why they are trying to put in which is the right way to
- 19:14do and India suits them well because of certain reason.
- 19:17One it's a democracy it's a it's a big market in itself more 1.4
- 19:23billion people. It's not a small market.
- 19:26Companies like Apple have already set up their
- 19:28manufacturing capacities here increase their manufacturing
- 19:32capacities here and that is a good thing.
- 19:34Other companies are also coming in the other beyond democracy.
- 19:38We have got very good skilled labor in terms of a lot of you
- 19:43know either babies technology beat any other area beat
- 19:46manufacturing and that is one thing stands out good, it's a
- 19:50fairly stable place. Some states are much more, much
- 19:54more conducive and they are providing a lot of benefits for
- 19:59companies which are coming there.
- 20:01The labor force is also very good in terms of, you know, you
- 20:05don't have to spend as much as you would have to.
- 20:08In any other say bigger countries even in the US or any
- 20:12other place. So this gives a lot of, you
- 20:15know, lot lot of juggling power to companies and and this is
- 20:21where India is certainly going to benefit.
- 20:24And I'm sure this also applies to companies in Brazil's, even
- 20:28small businesses in Brazil who may want to come to India.
- 20:33And the good part is that being part of BRICS, you know it is.
- 20:38So this bricks, this is, this brick is a good thing, but the
- 20:41other bricks are not good. So it's time for some good
- 20:44bookcase for both India and Brazil, I would say in terms of
- 20:47investments. Well, he had the term of bricks.
- 20:51The bricks was sort of a an idea.
- 20:54It was a joining of countries was sort of on the shelf for a
- 20:59long time and we've seen recently it's it's having a more
- 21:05global importance. Recently, other countries want
- 21:10to be part of BRICS, which is, I would say something relatively
- 21:14new. I was just listening to an audio
- 21:18podcast about Saudi Arabia and part of discussion there was the
- 21:22interest that Saudi Arabia has in becoming a member of BRICS.
- 21:28And back to what you said, the stability of both India and
- 21:35Brazil. And the economic importance is
- 21:39not only from the economic standpoint important for the the
- 21:44Saudi Arabia, but when we look at the logistics, a path, one of
- 21:50the paths from Brazil to India is through the Middle East and
- 21:55we're talking about logistics facilities in air, cargo, air
- 21:59freight or even maritime. Basically would go through the
- 22:05Middle East. So that becomes a stepping stone
- 22:09in both directions. And so for Indian companies and
- 22:12most times when we look at a map, we don't think of it that
- 22:14way. At least here we're thinking
- 22:17West. But no, we need to go east and
- 22:21that could be through the Middle East as a stepping stone, a
- 22:25favorable stepping stone in terms of transportation.
- 22:28Most of the air routes, the flights that leave from Brazil
- 22:31wanting to go to India would be going through the Middle East.
- 22:35So that's part of the an economic equation but also the
- 22:38logistic equation of doing business.
- 22:41And as you say say manufacturing point in India, it becomes even
- 22:45more important because one thing is to produce, but today it's to
- 22:52be able to produce and export globally.
- 22:56And that's an advantage I see that India has, right?
- 22:58That's also an advantage that I think Brazilian companies are
- 23:02seeing in India. They're coming awake to
- 23:05geography in a different way. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 23:11And a lot of countries now view India as the as a safe zone for
- 23:18either investment, long term relationships, long term
- 23:22partnerships, long term business, long term you know
- 23:26that everything is safe. The business political
- 23:29environment is also very stable here.
- 23:32Even regional governments as I mentioned earlier, they are
- 23:36giving a lot of incentives to companies and now a lot of
- 23:40regional government, state governments are also separately
- 23:43reaching out to the outside world.
- 23:45So in that aspect we are trying to communicate that we are very
- 23:51much open for business and if you come and open your business
- 23:55it will not close. It will be very, very fruitful
- 23:58and beneficial for everybody. And we also want see at the same
- 24:03time we have a Make in India policy also.
- 24:05So this is also enabling or giving that impeaches to the
- 24:10mindset also that we brought to bring companies to make in
- 24:14India. We have had a long history of
- 24:17buying from outside, but now we even if those companies are
- 24:23making and we need those things, we are inviting them to come
- 24:27make here and then send it out to the world.
- 24:30We will be your buyers here, but we also must be a part of that
- 24:35manufacturing process and and you tell us what you need, we
- 24:39will give it to you. And in that sense, I see that
- 24:42you know Brazil has also a great opportunity in terms of having
- 24:47that same sameness and and. And I I agree with you, but I I
- 24:52want to reiterate that another competency, another skill set
- 25:00that Indians have again is the multicultural understanding and
- 25:04communication. And when we look out in the
- 25:07world, we see an interesting number of CEO's of major
- 25:12corporations are Indian. Obviously, they have the mental
- 25:18capacity to do what they do. But part of that I see and
- 25:23they've shown that is a multicultural understanding of
- 25:27the world of business. And when we look to other
- 25:31countries, it's not necessarily that way.
- 25:35So that is an advantage. And again, that's the advantage
- 25:40of doing business in and with India because that I've seen as
- 25:44a challenge anyway, it's a challenge in Brazil.
- 25:46It's a challenge for Brazilian companies to get out.
- 25:49They they have to develop a multicultural understanding of
- 25:52whatever market they want to want to do.
- 25:56And other companies or countries wanting to come here have to
- 25:59understand the culture of Brazil and align to that with that
- 26:04ability to do that. India has had it for a long
- 26:08time. So I think you're probably a
- 26:10couple steps forward than other places are.
- 26:16And again, it's leadership and how to do things, how to open up
- 26:20your market, how to attract companies.
- 26:21So I think there's a lot of learning that Brazil can do when
- 26:24it looks to India, right, right. So this is, this is a good
- 26:29development, good to way to see things and I'm sure as we go by
- 26:33we will, we will have more and more things to discuss on these
- 26:37aspects in this India, Brazil business chat between the both
- 26:42of us. And I'm sure we will get more
- 26:45perspective from of things within the two of us from
- 26:49outside and maybe going forward we might get more people to
- 26:52share the perspective on on this show.
- 26:55Any final words any that you would like to share on this
- 26:59topic top? Just more of the same, I think
- 27:04part of We're in chat #4. What I would say is come back
- 27:07for chat #5. There will be more, I would say
- 27:11more of the same. There will be similar things of
- 27:14how we can adapt. We're learning, all right.
- 27:16You and I are learning with each other and as we say, business
- 27:20comes from people. It does.
- 27:22But again, learning how to understand what the important
- 27:26thing. What if we learned in four chats
- 27:29a lot. So it's a non ending thing, It's
- 27:33never over, it's always ongoing so.
- 27:37Looking forward to being back and chatting again.
- 27:40Absolutely, absolutely. We both are learning, we both,
- 27:43both our countries are also learning and as we learn, we, we
- 27:48understand things better. And then your communication,
- 27:52your chats with the world grow better and and I'm sure this
- 27:56even Brazil has become, will become better at, you know,
- 28:00communicating with the world better and getting more
- 28:03investments to itself. And that is such a welcome
- 28:06thing. And India also looks at at the
- 28:09future with a great deal of hope because we have got a lot of
- 28:12things to do. And in that India and Brazil
- 28:17together also have a lot of commonality and can achieve a
- 28:21lot together with this. It's a wrap on this very special
- 28:25edition of the KJ Master Class Life.
- 28:28Thank you so much indeed for joining us.
- 28:31Thank you again.