Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 7)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:03Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to pick up
- 0:06where we left off with the alex Acosta interview with
- 0:09the OIG inspectors. Question, Okay, in Exhibit eight, you actually
- 0:16got the in Exhibit seven, you can see that in
- 0:19the bottom part of that that you received a copy
- 0:21of the prosecution memo. On the second page of the
- 0:24exhibit at the top, answer right, question redacted is forwarding
- 0:29to you the prosecution memo? Answer rite question. In Exhibit eight,
- 0:34you see that redacted as forwarding or sending that chain
- 0:37excluding redacted. That is redacted redacted or redacted redacted and
- 0:41you additional items in Operation Leap year and there's a
- 0:46summary of the indictment, the evidence regarding the individual victims. Okay, so,
- 0:50as of May eleventh, you had before you the prosecution memo,
- 0:54the proposed indictment, and the substantial amount of additional information.
- 0:59Did you read the prosecution memo? Answer right? So, I
- 1:03don't recall, and I don't know you are going to say,
- 1:06why don't I But this was a long time ago.
- 1:08I don't recall if I read it or if I
- 1:10went back to the office and sat down with redacted
- 1:12and redacted and went over it. I can't recall from
- 1:15this far, I can say that it looks, based on
- 1:18this that I was at the US Attorney's conference. The
- 1:22idea of printing this out on a hotel printer, I wouldn't.
- 1:25I can't believe I would have printed this out on
- 1:28a hotel printer. Question, let alone read it on an airplane?
- 1:32Correct answer, Let alone read it on an airplane. That
- 1:35would just not have been my practice. Question. But going
- 1:38back arriving back to your offices, was it your practice
- 1:42to take voluminous documents like this and go through them
- 1:45yourself or did you rely on your senior staff? Answer?
- 1:50I would typically rely on my senior staff. They're the
- 1:53experienced ones that have seen these matters before. They would
- 1:57go through it. We'd sit down, we'd talk about the issues.
- 2:00We might have it in front of us, almost like
- 2:02you've got all those binders there, but you know you're
- 2:05calling my attention to particular issues, and we'd sort of
- 2:08talk it through. Question and you recall doing that in
- 2:11this case? Answer? I recall having discussions with senior staff
- 2:15about the case. Question who answer is certainly redacted and
- 2:19redacted at various points. I can't say that I did
- 2:23that in May versus April versus June. I can't give
- 2:26you timelines. Question, Well, we're talking about May, because you've
- 2:31got the actual process. Answer. It would have been my
- 2:35practice based on this to go back and discuss it.
- 2:38And so based on my practice, I would have gone
- 2:41back and likely discussed it. I doubt I would have
- 2:44printed this out at whatever hotel I was at. Question
- 2:47but even when you go back to the office, would
- 2:50you have somebody printed out so you would have had
- 2:52it available? Answer? I may have had someone printed out
- 2:56so it's available. I may have focused on particular parts
- 2:59of it. Question what kind of issues would you have
- 3:02focused on? In other words, in other words, some might
- 3:05go straight to the facts, some might be interested in
- 3:08the legal theories. What was your approach? Answer? So I
- 3:12think it depended on the case question. Okay, answer here,
- 3:16you had legal questions and you also had witness issues,
- 3:19and I would think that those would have been the
- 3:21two primary areas. Question would you have gone through the
- 3:25indictment and the prosecution memo and all of those other
- 3:28materials or just relied on your experience seeing your people redacted?
- 3:32And redacted answer as a general practice, probably some combination
- 3:37as a general and general recollection. The concerns in this
- 3:41case weren't about the sort of details of what happened,
- 3:44because we believed he did what he did. The concerns
- 3:47were about some of the legal issues around it and
- 3:50some of the issues in terms of testimony. Question of victims,
- 3:54answer of victims, question all right. On page nine Exhibit
- 4:01nine is an email that you are not on, but
- 4:03that notes that redacted as advising redacted, that you as
- 4:07your memo and left Court's letter. Gerald left Court, new
- 4:11York attorney who was one of the members of Epstein's
- 4:13defense team. Did you know him? Answer? I did not.
- 4:17Question did you ever encounter him? As far as you recall, answer,
- 4:22I did not question, all right, he had according to
- 4:24the documents, we have made two substantial submissions in February
- 4:29of that year in an effort to dissuade them from
- 4:32pursuing a prosecution, and we have every reason to believe
- 4:36and no reason not to believe, that that's what it's
- 4:39being referred to. Do you recall reviewing substantial submission from
- 4:42Defense Council at this time attacking a very granular detail,
- 4:47the credibility of witnesses and so on. Answer, I don't
- 4:50recall reviewing those. Again, I recall discussions well my senior
- 4:54team about issues that included credibility, and I'm not sure
- 4:58if its credibility is the right word. But how the
- 5:00victims would do on the stand question okay, and who
- 5:04do you recall talking to about that? Answer? So some
- 5:07combination of redacted and redacted would have been the likely
- 5:11I recall the discussion. I don't recall whether it was
- 5:14redacted or whether it was redacted or redacted, but the
- 5:17logical inference would have been it would have been some
- 5:20combination of redacted and redacted. Question Okay, redacted has told
- 5:25us that during this period he was not actively involved
- 5:29in the case. Question, but that redacted was Would that
- 5:32be consistent with your memory? Answer that sure, I mean
- 5:37they were a team. They became more or less involved
- 5:39based on needs. Question and was there any particular if
- 5:44redacted was working with you directly on reporting on his
- 5:48assessment of the case, was there any reason for redacted
- 5:51to be involved? Answer? I might bounce ideas off him.
- 5:55I mean he was he was the right across. So
- 5:57we work closely. But you know redacted was a crime
- 6:00chief and if he was in the weeds, Redacted and
- 6:04I would speculate would sort of much like me, defer
- 6:07to his judgment because they've known each other and they've
- 6:10worked together and they had a good working relationship. Question
- 6:15and is it do we understand correctly that as first
- 6:18assistant Redacted has a brief that really encompassed the entire office? Answer?
- 6:24He did, he supervised the civil, the criminal, the appellate,
- 6:28and the forfeiture. Question. All right, there is here in
- 6:32this email that you did not see back in the
- 6:34day Exhibit nine, a pushback from redacted regarding the rush
- 6:38that Redacted is in to pursue the case. And he says,
- 6:42this is obviously a very significant case and Alex wants
- 6:45to take his time in making sure he is comfortable
- 6:48before proceeding. Can you tell us what the basis would
- 6:51be for or was for that assertion by redacted? Answer? So,
- 6:57I can't tell you from the recollection what the basis
- 6:59is is. I can speculate that the material is being
- 7:02transmitted Friday morning. He gets cut off the eleventh answer
- 7:07by Acosta. Yeah, so Friday morning. It hasn't been reviewed
- 7:11by anyone in the management chain, much less approved and
- 7:14edited and redacted that Monday is saying, why don't I
- 7:18have a decision, and so truly extenuating circumstances, typically you'd
- 7:25give you know it, it'd have to go through the
- 7:27management chain up to the US attorney. And so he's
- 7:30pushing back saying, it's been a day or it's been
- 7:33a weekend. I'm just reading between the lines here. Question
- 7:37who had authority to sign off on the Epstein prosecution
- 7:40to say indict answer? So as a delegated matter, redacted
- 7:45had signature authority, as did as did it redacted? As
- 7:50did it redacted? And obviously I did. As a practice matter,
- 7:53this is something that would have gone through the chain
- 7:56and that we would have then discussed. Question, but why
- 7:59have level is it? Because, as redacted says, obviously a
- 8:03very significant case answers So at my level, not only
- 8:07because of the facts, because it's not about the facts,
- 8:10but I do think that there are legal issues that
- 8:12implicated policy that we were thinking through. Question and what
- 8:17were the legal issues and what were the policy issues? Answer?
- 8:21So the legal issues and also factual issues in terms
- 8:24of the witnesses. So the legal issue, so there's an
- 8:27email from redacted based on you know, the contemporaneous record
- 8:31that alludes to some of this. In my experience at
- 8:34the Civil Rights Division, trafficking cases involved, you know, I
- 8:38can describe some some horrific cases of girls being held
- 8:41against their will. You know, you add CP matters with
- 8:45young women, sometimes incredibly young, that the office prosecuted. As
- 8:50trafficking laws were being developed, there was a lot of
- 8:53discussion about what's the difference between trafficking and solicitation, And
- 8:57the discussion took place as the trafficking laws were being developed,
- 9:01and so this implicated that, and it implicated what the
- 9:05local and what is federal? Question? All right? So in
- 9:08the first you're talking in the first category, you're talking
- 9:11about the individual charges that had been that were proposed,
- 9:14which included both trafficking and coercion and enticement or enticement
- 9:20answer correct question, all right? And in the latter you
- 9:24felt that did you to what extent did the witness victim?
- 9:27Witness kind of credibility issues implicates policy answer, So I
- 9:32think I said that policy and victim in that In
- 9:35that there was certainly discussion between me and my management
- 9:39about concerns as to how the victims would sort of
- 9:41stand up in court. Question, so, what would make you
- 9:45comfortable before proceeding? What would you what at the point
- 9:49would have made you comfortable about proceeding? Answer? So I
- 9:53think that at this point, I don't think it's what
- 9:55would have or would not have made me comfortable? And
- 9:59I'm speculating. I think it came in on a Friday.
- 10:02Let's talk this through. Question, But you've just identified for
- 10:06us issues in your mind had to be resolved. Question
- 10:11all right, okay, at that point, does your recollection have
- 10:15any doubt that some form of indictment or charging instrument
- 10:18against Epstein was likely to become viable? Answer? So it
- 10:23was a case that I thought it very important that
- 10:26we do something. How that something played out, I think
- 10:29had all along been a matter of discussion. Question as
- 10:33something other than what the US Attorney's Office does, which
- 10:36is prosecute. Answer well, no, I mean what the US
- 10:40Attorney's Office does is ensure that justice is served. Question right, answer,
- 10:45and in partnership with state attorneys. And sometimes that means
- 10:48state attorneys take the lead. Sometimes that means that the
- 10:51US Attorney's Office takes the lead. And a lot of
- 10:54times we actually you know, we would share staff because
- 10:57sometimes it made sense, you know, for one part or
- 11:00the other to take the lead. So writ large, I
- 11:04thought throughout it was a very important that something happened.
- 11:08There were concerns all along. I can speculate that this
- 11:11is just a reflection of those continuing concerns. Question as
- 11:16expressed by you to redacted in the ordinary course, answer
- 11:21as developed as a group throughout this if we go
- 11:24back to what exhibit question June of two thousand and six, answer,
- 11:30so Exhibit three says in that meeting, I summarized the
- 11:34case in the state attorney's office handling it. I acknowledged
- 11:38that we needed to do work to collect evidence establishing
- 11:41a federal nexus, and I noted the time and money
- 11:44that would be required for an investigation. And so as
- 11:47far back as the initial meeting there is discussion about
- 11:50the federal nexus and whether this is a state or
- 11:54federal case. Question all right. Exhibit seven is an early
- 11:58email from redacted to you early meeting. It precedes the
- 12:02one we just looked at, and early in that it's
- 12:05right as you're receiving the prosecution memo and you ask
- 12:09him have you read the memo? And curious why you
- 12:13ask redacted rather than redacted. Answer, I don't recall. I
- 12:17can speculate, and I have two thoughts that I'll speculate.
- 12:20One is redacted to her direct supervisor, and I might
- 12:24be thinking her second line supervisor. So why is redacted
- 12:28sending me this? Redacted? Have you read this? Ie? Did
- 12:31you jump the chain? Secondly, I think I may have
- 12:34wanted to have multiple opinions on this. It's most likely
- 12:37that I had talked to or redacted already because Redacted
- 12:40and I talked more often, and I'm asking another person
- 12:43in the management chain, Hey, what do you think Let's
- 12:46have multiple opinions on the table here? Question? Well, is
- 12:50this the first time other than redacted that we see
- 12:53you getting a recommendation? Answer right? Question? When Redacted says
- 12:58he thinks that you should charge him, the office should
- 13:00charge Epstein. He has issues with a charging strategy proposed
- 13:04by redacted, but one he says, we all need to
- 13:07get on the same page as to whether the statute
- 13:10covered the conduct and whether the conduct is the type
- 13:13we should charge. I think the answer to both is yes,
- 13:16although there is some risk on some of the statutes.
- 13:20He proposes that the Office start with a complaint, which
- 13:23is not unusual, is it? Answer, it happens, yes, question
- 13:27all right, which allows the defendant to be arrested and
- 13:30ideally detained, and then the defendant is then highly motivated
- 13:34or incentivized to work a pre indictment resolution. That's what
- 13:38redacted is proposing. He also notes that it's important, in
- 13:42his view, to cap them with conspiracy accounts to make
- 13:45a plea attractive, and the court could give us a
- 13:48hard time with that if we had to dismiss indicted accounts.
- 13:52All right, folks, we're gonna wrap up right here, and
- 13:54in the next episode dealing with the topic, we're gonna
- 13:57pick up where we left off. All of the information
- 14:00that goes with this episode can be found in the
- 14:03description box.