Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 133: Understanding the French political crisis with Katy Lee
Transcript
- 0:07You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:09I'm your host, Lindsay Trimuta. Well, it's been now a week since
- 0:14the very messy results of the European elections left France
- 0:18in a state of great uncertainty. And in that time, we've seen at
- 0:22least a year or Two's worth of political maneuvering.
- 0:25Naturally, there's a lot to unpack following President
- 0:28Macron's decision to dissolve the lower House of parliament
- 0:31and call snap elections for the end of June.
- 0:34To discuss the role of these elections and what Macron's move
- 0:37means for the country, as well as look into the political
- 0:40alliances that have formed in record-breaking time, I'm joined
- 0:44by Paris based journalist and podcaster Katie Lee.
- 0:47She's a former staff writer for the AFP and the Co founder and
- 0:50Co host of the award-winning podcast The Europeans is the
- 0:55reason to remain hopeful. Have a listen and find out.
- 1:01Katie, welcome to the show. Hey, Lindsay, thanks so much for
- 1:04having me. Nice to be here.
- 1:06It's been a long time since I wanted you to come on the show.
- 1:08You are the Co host of a brilliant podcast called the
- 1:11Europeans. You're a fellow journalist in
- 1:13Paris and, you know, this perhaps is the best opportunity
- 1:17to have you on in many ways because it really is like
- 1:21Europe's soap opera. And specifically France is
- 1:26taking the, the, the starring role.
- 1:28But, but I thought, you know, based on a, a Twitter thread
- 1:31that you published on Monday, I figured, you know, this would be
- 1:36a good time to get your take on what's been happening and also
- 1:39explain to some people why are we even having this
- 1:43conversation? Like, what are the European
- 1:45elections? Why do we care and what does,
- 1:48you know, the events of the last week?
- 1:49What do they really mean for us moving forward?
- 1:51So I know you did a podcast episode about the European
- 1:54elections and why they're important, yet also why they're
- 1:58sometimes not treated in the same way as other elections by
- 2:02voters. Can you maybe start there?
- 2:04What are we talking about? What is the setting here?
- 2:07So the very basics are that last weekend every country in the
- 2:11European Union voted for their members of the European
- 2:14Parliament. So this is the only direct vote
- 2:17that you as a EU citizen of any European country get in sort of
- 2:22a direct vote in, in who represents us in any of the
- 2:24institutions in Brussels in the European Union.
- 2:28So we were voting for that. But as you say, you know, these
- 2:30elections tend to not get taken as seriously as national
- 2:34elections that turn out pretty much everywhere apart from
- 2:38countries that have compulsory voting tends to be lower than it
- 2:41is in national elections. And you know, I can hold my
- 2:44hands up and say that I have been part of this problem.
- 2:47This is the only the 2nd European election that I have
- 2:49voted in because disgracefully, despite being someone who has a
- 2:53podcast about European politics before the previous European
- 2:57election, I didn't vote because it seemed complicated and I
- 3:00didn't understand it and stuff that happened in the European
- 3:03Union seemed far away. But who you vote for in these
- 3:07elections, you know, this has a direct role in the kinds of
- 3:11policies that we're going to see shaping this entire continent of
- 3:15Europe across the next five years.
- 3:17So it really, really does matter.
- 3:19And the other thing about the fact that fewer people tend to
- 3:22turn up in these elections every time is that you tend to see
- 3:28people with stronger opinions turning up, which means that
- 3:31fringe parties tend to do better.
- 3:33And that is certainly something that we've seen this time
- 3:36around. There seem to be two kind of
- 3:38competing narratives of how these elections went, and no one
- 3:41can really agree on which one is true.
- 3:43I think they're both true to some extent.
- 3:45One is that the centre held essentially, so centrist parties
- 3:50across the EU generally did pretty OK and certainly enough
- 3:55for centrist ish parties, mainstream parties to together
- 4:00be able to form a sort of governing coalition within the
- 4:04European Parliament and they'll be the sort of central people
- 4:06making policy for the next five years.
- 4:09The other narrative is that there has been a far right
- 4:11search and this is true to some extent.
- 4:14This is going to be the most right leaning European
- 4:17Parliament that we've ever seen. But if you kind of zoom in on
- 4:20different countries, it's really a couple of countries that have
- 4:24pushed that far right search and one of them is Germany and the
- 4:27other one is the country that you and I are in right now, it's
- 4:30France. Yeah.
- 4:31And which is problematic because they also have a great number of
- 4:34seats, correct both of these countries in the in the
- 4:36Parliament. Yeah, because the number of
- 4:38seats that you have in parliament depends on your
- 4:40population. Germany and France are the most
- 4:42the most populous countries in Europe and therefore they have
- 4:45the most seats. So for some people, it was also
- 4:48an opportunity to to give a protest vote to the incumbent.
- 4:53You know, we kind of the results within France were predicted,
- 4:56but what wasn't predicted was how our president would react
- 5:01after the fact. So you came out on Monday
- 5:03morning, Sunday night, maybe even.
- 5:05Wait, it's been a week. Yeah, I don't know what day it
- 5:08is, but you, you came out very quickly with a very astute
- 5:12analysis about his decision, which was to dissolve the
- 5:18assembly Nacional, which is essentially the lower House of
- 5:20parliament, which which effectively like stops policy
- 5:25making at least until a new assembly is formed.
- 5:30Why did you think, I mean, you're, you're positing
- 5:32essentially that he may not have had many other options, but I'm
- 5:36curious if you still think that way now that we're Friday and
- 5:41after, you know, you've had maybe time to process the events
- 5:44of the week. Like do you still think he
- 5:45really had no other option but to do this at this time?
- 5:50Yeah, I do still think that I I am increasingly worried about
- 5:53the consequences of the gamble, but I do still think it was a
- 5:56gamble that he ultimately was going to have to make.
- 6:00You know, when Macron made this decision on Sunday night to call
- 6:06a national election, a general election, a parliamentary
- 6:09election on the basis of the fact that the far right Marine
- 6:14Le Pen's party had done very, very well in the European
- 6:16elections, a lot of people were just thinking, what the hell is
- 6:19this guy doing? You know, this isn't necessary
- 6:22in this country. We have parliamentary elections
- 6:24every five years. We last had parliamentary
- 6:26elections in 2022. So it would have been completely
- 6:29reasonable for Macron to say, you know, these this vote
- 6:33indicates that people are not very happy with my government.
- 6:37But if they don't like it, they're going to have to wait
- 6:39another few years and then there'll be more elections where
- 6:41they can vote us out. And when I say us, I I also mean
- 6:44that the, the, the government of Macron is something that's
- 6:47really important to take into account is that he doesn't have
- 6:50a majority in parliament. So that's one thing to bear in
- 6:53mind when you're thinking about like, why did he make this
- 6:55absolutely crazy decision? Because he didn't have to do it
- 6:58right. It's not necessary.
- 6:59He could have just argued if you don't like us, tough, you'll
- 7:02have a chance to vote us out in a couple of years.
- 7:05The reason I think it was necessary was just the fact that
- 7:08already in the weeks ahead of the election, the Hassan Blum or
- 7:13National were screaming that if they did win very, very well in
- 7:17these elections, which of course they did, that they should have,
- 7:21that there should be a general election, there should be a
- 7:23parliamentary election. And it goes without saying that
- 7:27they would have continued to say that and to have kept screaming
- 7:30that the government was illegitimate and that they need
- 7:32to have an election for weeks. I really think that would have
- 7:35just dominated the political agenda for weeks.
- 7:37And Macron's government is already very weak.
- 7:40He does not have a majority in parliament.
- 7:43And the other thing is that there was probably going to be a
- 7:46vote of confidence in his government coming up in
- 7:48September over the budget. So this was going to happen at
- 7:52some point anyway, I would argue.
- 7:54And by announcing it now, he was able to claim back the
- 7:57initiative and say, OK, at least I've got control of the
- 7:59narrative. It, it's interesting because I
- 8:03think one of the big things that people are saying is that, you
- 8:06know, doing this right as a lot of people are starting to go on
- 8:09vacation right before the Olympics, it means that they're
- 8:11sort of like checked out. But I think he was banking on
- 8:14this being like, let's do it now before people are really checked
- 8:17out fully. And and not only that, I think,
- 8:23you know, the threat of the far right and seeing that
- 8:25performance probably meant for him like this is a chance maybe
- 8:29to let the population decide whether they're fully ready for
- 8:33this. However, what's happened in the
- 8:35days since is that the left, so all of the left parties,
- 8:39including the the Socialist Party, which is sort of like a
- 8:43Social Democratic Party, and then all the way through the
- 8:46far, far left have created a kind of rebranded Popular Front
- 8:51or from Popular. And my take, and I'm not sure, I
- 8:55would love to know what you think, is that Macron maybe
- 8:57didn't bank on the left being able to organize so quickly
- 9:00because historically they have not been able to.
- 9:03And what kind of threat this now represents, given that the far
- 9:07right is also pretty active and unified, although there have
- 9:12been some hiccups along the way. Do you think he calculated?
- 9:16Did he expect that this decision could lead to such mobilization
- 9:21on the left? It's really difficult to know
- 9:23whether he has gone into this election genuinely expecting to
- 9:27win it, right? I mean, you look at his ratings
- 9:30and you think how can he possibly think he's going to
- 9:33he's going to win this election? Nobody wants this guy to be in
- 9:35government anymore. So that's the question.
- 9:38Because obviously if he did call it in theory he is, he is
- 9:42playing to win here. But the chances of him actually
- 9:45getting a majority of this election are slim.
- 9:48What's happening on the left is, is really, really interesting.
- 9:51As you say, the left in France and really across Europe has
- 9:54like such a bad track record of uniting and being able to put up
- 9:59a sort of genuine opposition over the past, well, 5-7 years.
- 10:04And suddenly, like almost overnight, they came together
- 10:06and said, OK, we're going to do this.
- 10:08Whether that alliance will last after this election is another
- 10:12question. So previously for the last
- 10:14elections that we had here in 2022, there was also a leftist
- 10:17union. And it's kind of fizzled out
- 10:19since they've started disagreeing over things like
- 10:21Gaza and Ukraine. So that's been pretty messy.
- 10:25But yeah, I I don't think he probably did expect the left to
- 10:28unify as as quickly as they did. The great irony of this election
- 10:33is that Macron came to power in 2017, obliterating the left and
- 10:38the right. Right, like he took over.
- 10:40And he did that by saying, I, you know, mainstream politics
- 10:43has failed you. I'm going to be above the party
- 10:47system and I'm going to be completely different.
- 10:49And I'm going to be the solution to all of your problems.
- 10:51And people bought that because people are sick of mainstream
- 10:53politics, as they are in quite a lot of Western democracies right
- 10:56now. You know, they, they just feel,
- 10:58well, an increasing number of voters feel that mainstream
- 11:00parties do not have the solutions.
- 11:02And Macron, even though he is sort of ultimately the most
- 11:07mainstream guy and that he promised to be neither of the
- 11:08left or of the right, but was sort of vaguely centrist.
- 11:12You might argue that in practice he's been sent to right.
- 11:15He he certainly came in here promising to smash the system
- 11:19and he did electorally. So after Macron came in the
- 11:23centre left withered basically away.
- 11:27Socialist Party had been like a, a huge party of government
- 11:30historically in France. And just for the last seven
- 11:33years have they've been so lost. And now we see the left kind of
- 11:36coming together as a result of this election gamble, which is a
- 11:41really exciting thing to see. So in fact, the narrative for
- 11:44this election is now not like, is Macron going to win?
- 11:47Because everybody knows that he's probably going to see a
- 11:50very disastrous showing. The question is like, what's the
- 11:53battle between the left bloc and the far right bloc going to look
- 11:57like? Those are the forces that really
- 11:59matter in this election. And it's going to be really
- 12:01fascinating to see what happens. There Well, and also you're
- 12:04talking about sort of the unified left and right.
- 12:07What we've seen happen also on the right is that the Republican
- 12:10who were historically sort of yeah, the right wing but not far
- 12:14right. They are completely fractured
- 12:17because their president, who was already very, very far right
- 12:21leaning. I mean, it's amazing he didn't
- 12:23move just, you know, decamp to the RN, which is called the
- 12:28separable national earlier. But essentially what he did was
- 12:31went on television and was like, yes, I'd like us to unite with
- 12:35the far right. And the rest of his party were
- 12:38like, excuse me, No, Sir, no, this is not happening.
- 12:43So they tried to sort of unseat him.
- 12:44He said that was not, you know, a legal maneuver that they could
- 12:49do. He locked himself in his office
- 12:51in this like really dramatic show of, of, of supposed
- 12:55strength. Of course, the vice president
- 12:57had a key, a spare key to the office.
- 13:00So she goes in and is like, hello, while we share this
- 13:03office. And so now he, he looks like an
- 13:06absolute fool. But my, my point of saying this
- 13:09is that we've, we've seen a normalization of the far right
- 13:13to the point where someone in the Republican or sort of right
- 13:18party was willing to go further to the right.
- 13:21And what does that maybe mean also for the people who find
- 13:24themselves? I mean, maybe that's where Matt
- 13:26Cohen is hoping, hoping to sort of recuperate some of these
- 13:29votes because there are a lot of people, a lot of the voting
- 13:31public do not identify with either of these extremes.
- 13:35So someone who might have voted for the Republican is like,
- 13:38well, if they are going to end up aligning, which it looks like
- 13:41they might not, right? But still, if they were going to
- 13:43move further right, I don't identify that any with them
- 13:46anymore. Where am I supposed to direct my
- 13:49vote? And similarly, you mentioned
- 13:51the, you know, how impressive it is to see the organizing on the
- 13:54left. But there are a lot of very
- 13:56controversial figures in some of the left wing parties, including
- 14:00left France and Sumies, which is not technically by the
- 14:03Constitutional Council considered a radical left party.
- 14:06They are left further left than the Socialist Party, but they're
- 14:10not the communists and they're not the anti capitalists.
- 14:13But there are some really divisive figures within these
- 14:16parties that are also isolating some of the sort of center left
- 14:20and Social Democrats. So, you know, could this be sort
- 14:23of like, could this lead to like a hung parliament and then it's
- 14:26just complete chaos and then, you know, nothing gets done?
- 14:30Oh, very easily. It very easily could.
- 14:33I mean, there are so many outcomes that it kind of makes
- 14:35your brain want to explode. Like I, I don't want to rule out
- 14:38the possibility that Jordan Bardella, who is this, you know,
- 14:42under 30 year old whiz kid who is seen as sort of Marine Le
- 14:46Pen's heir and waiting. And he's been her kind of the,
- 14:49the, the face of her European election campaign.
- 14:53I want to rule out a world where he becomes Prime Minister, which
- 14:56is quite a terrifying prospect. Like there are so many
- 14:59uncertainties. And on the left, you know, it's
- 15:01it's a really good point that you raised because if you think
- 15:05about what's happening on the left, what this union of the
- 15:07left actually means is that they're not going to run
- 15:09candidates against each other, right.
- 15:12So whatever your constituency is, you are going to see one
- 15:16candidate from one of these different left wing parties.
- 15:19And if you live in an area where you know, you do have a left
- 15:22hold stands for me candidate, but they're not somebody that
- 15:24you would vote for. And you would consider yourself
- 15:26to be much further to the right than that, more of a, a, a
- 15:29socialist voter, a mainstream left voter.
- 15:31You might be tempted to switch to Macron or maybe not vote at
- 15:35all. And the same goes for the right.
- 15:36You know, there's this interesting situation on the
- 15:38right as, as you say, the hypothetical have been moving
- 15:41further and further to the right.
- 15:44And actually, when you looked at the, I don't know if you also
- 15:46got through your letterbox, I guess you probably did all of
- 15:50this election campaign literature for the, for the
- 15:52European election. So you get like a little list of
- 15:54what their manifesto is, what their policy principles are.
- 15:57And when I read the Republican policy platform for the European
- 16:02elections, it read almost more right wing than the hassle, more
- 16:06national platform. You know, they were talking
- 16:08about building physical borders around Europe to Wallace in so
- 16:13that refugees can't get in this sort of thing.
- 16:15They've been drifting further to the right.
- 16:17The thing is that sort of they're a lot more socially
- 16:19acceptable, right? The Republican have always been
- 16:22the face of the mainstream, right?
- 16:24That's kind of their legacy party, the party of Jacques
- 16:26Chirac. And so they're seen as a
- 16:29mainstream option, even if the policy positions of this party,
- 16:35and this is something that we're seeing in different right wing
- 16:38parties across Europe, we're seeing the same sort of drift to
- 16:42the right, further to the right. So parties that still are
- 16:46considered socially to be mainstream right wing parties
- 16:50are actually looking more and more like sort of Le Pen
- 16:54parties, the Maloney parties of the world in any case.
- 16:58Yeah, absolutely. I mean, every, everything is
- 17:01shifting. And I wonder how much of that
- 17:03has to do with sort of TikTok culture and social media and
- 17:07making some of these figures look very normal.
- 17:10I mean, that's, that's part of the reason that Bardela has
- 17:13gotten to be such a, such a favorite and almost like a like,
- 17:18you know, the, the, the popular guy at school, you know, he, he
- 17:20wears suits. He wears not saying that popular
- 17:23guys in school wear suits and turtlenecks, but just to say
- 17:26that he, you know, he's like very put together.
- 17:27He's, he's casual, but put, you know, very composed.
- 17:32He's always talking about how he loves candy.
- 17:34So they're like making this some like huge defining
- 17:37characteristic about him. And on TikTok, he's posted
- 17:39videos of him munching on 100% sugar candies before he goes on
- 17:45to an interview. And you're just sort of like,
- 17:46what, what is the image making that's going on here and why is
- 17:51it so powerful in reaching people?
- 17:53Before you talked about sort of how it's very likely that the
- 17:57results on, well, first June 30th and then July 7th is the
- 18:01second round of the legislative vote.
- 18:04They could be kind of chaotic. What are the risks?
- 18:08There's been a term that people have started to hear which is
- 18:10cohabitation. And that means effectively that
- 18:13the president, the incumbent, doesn't have a majority and
- 18:15therefore needs to have someone in his administration, like a
- 18:18Prime Minister who reflects the rest of the Assembly.
- 18:22And so the prospect is that either someone from the far
- 18:26right or someone potentially from the left could govern with
- 18:29him. Is that a fair understanding of
- 18:31this concept? Yeah, I would say so.
- 18:33And it's a very real possibility.
- 18:35You know, you would assume that the well, the option that Macron
- 18:39would much prefer, of course, would be some sort of with the
- 18:44with the leftist bloc. If that's something there's an
- 18:47option. It doesn't actually seem by the
- 18:49way, that they're going to do that badly.
- 18:50Like people are starting to talk, Pulse is starting to talk
- 18:52about the fact that maybe, maybe this actually could be a decent
- 18:57fight between the left bloc and and the far right.
- 19:00It's not something we can rule out.
- 19:02But yes, we also very much cannot rule out a potential
- 19:06situation where Macron is governing in Coit Bitesian with
- 19:12Jordan Banila, which is a crazy prospect and something that no
- 19:16one would have seen coming. And that's I think why a lot of
- 19:19people, you know, Brits like me, are often at the moment
- 19:21comparing this moment to David Cameron's Brexit gamble.
- 19:25You know, it's this thing where he said, I've been painted into
- 19:27a corner, I don't have any choice, I have to do this.
- 19:31But the consequences are potentially disastrous.
- 19:34And in that case, of course, the consequences were very
- 19:37disastrous. Now, Macron, I don't know, the
- 19:40jury's out as to whether he is like playing some incredible
- 19:43game of 5T chess and he's actually a genius and has this
- 19:46whole thing worked out, or if he is just doing something
- 19:50extremely, insanely irresponsible with the fate of
- 19:54our nation. I don't know.
- 19:56I don't know the answer to that. It's a bit troubling.
- 19:58I mean, look, he, he definitely got us through COVID.
- 20:01He you know a lot of. A lot of the business world, so
- 20:06the corporate world will say that he's been good for
- 20:08streamlining a lot of, you know, complicated administrative
- 20:11things on the environment. He hasn't been strong enough on
- 20:15women's rights and and, you know, protections.
- 20:17He hasn't been strong enough on so many issues.
- 20:20He's sort of either fallen flat or just been a bunch of empty
- 20:24promises. And so you sort of wonder at
- 20:26what point do you say I am hugely unpopular and there's
- 20:29very little that I'm going to be able to do that regains gets the
- 20:32population to trust me again. But I, I, I just think it's sort
- 20:35of like when you're that much of A narcissist, you can't imagine
- 20:39that people that they're just the idiots who don't understand
- 20:42anything. And that's why they dislike you.
- 20:44But I'm very worried because, you know, I'm glad you brought
- 20:46up Brexit in your experience. This to me smacks very heavily
- 20:50of, you know, 2016. And no one thought that Trump
- 20:53could get elected. And the reality is there's a big
- 20:56chunk of the population there in the UK and in France that do not
- 21:01feel listened to, that feel completely, well ignored as
- 21:04well. And so, you know, here at least
- 21:05you have the culture of taking to the streets and you'll make
- 21:07yourself heard. But that doesn't always mean
- 21:10that sort of a solution follows that expression of of
- 21:14frustration. I guess I'm wondering what you
- 21:16think, you know, is this just sort of the way all Western
- 21:19countries are going and that like, we have to figure out how
- 21:22to listen to each other better? And, you know, do you think the
- 21:25French government has been lacking in, in their awareness,
- 21:29I guess, of some of the social media tools that have been used
- 21:33by their competitors to, to tap into what people really want?
- 21:38Yeah, well, I mean, Macron is not especially bad at social
- 21:41media. I think he's actually pretty
- 21:42decent at it. He's not a 28 year old, you
- 21:45know, he's not as good a TikTok as as Bardena is.
- 21:49I think, you know, there has always been this this narrative
- 21:53of like France is a perpetually dissatisfied country.
- 21:57And no matter how good things are here, people are always
- 22:00going to hate the people in power.
- 22:01And it's true, people in France do turn negatively against their
- 22:06leaders, I think faster than they do in perhaps other Western
- 22:10democracies. We are perhaps an an ungrateful
- 22:13people over here. But I also don't want to make it
- 22:16sound like people haven't got reasons to be dissatisfied.
- 22:20You know, when you look at some of the headline figures, you'd
- 22:22be like, oh, France is the the most attractive country for
- 22:25foreign investment for the fifth year in a row.
- 22:27Things to be seem to be working out pretty well here, but those
- 22:30sort of things do not affect the reality of the average person.
- 22:34You know, the average person here is struggling with the cost
- 22:37of living crisis. They are maybe working in a job
- 22:40which has possibly like quite high levels of precarity,
- 22:43despite the stereotype of France as people being unfireable.
- 22:48There's been like huge wage stagnation.
- 22:50There are reasons to be pissed off and so people are looking
- 22:53for other solutions. I think the problem with the
- 22:56rise of TikTok and particularly the way that the far right has
- 22:59been using TikTok, is that it, it really promotes this idea of
- 23:04simple solutions to our problems.
- 23:06You know, like it's everything is done in like 1520 seconds and
- 23:09it's like, oh, you know, just kick the immigrants out and
- 23:12things will be better. There is a sort of lack of, of
- 23:16nuance. And I think that that is
- 23:18something that has encouraged people to to turn to parties
- 23:22like the Hassan Blabon Nacional who are maybe offering the the
- 23:27simplistic solutions to things. The thing about that hassle
- 23:30bloom on us, you know, is that they have never been in power,
- 23:32right? And ever since we had this last
- 23:34parliament, they've been, you know, the main opposition force
- 23:37in the French parliament. So they've been able to be there
- 23:40shouting and criticizing round the clock without actually
- 23:43governing. Now what Macron is doing with
- 23:45this election is saying, well, you know, you guys, the voters,
- 23:49with every passing election, you are voting in ever bigger
- 23:52numbers for these people. Do you actually want them to
- 23:55govern? And he's giving the people that
- 23:58option. I'm not sure that people do want
- 24:00them to govern. And especially with the European
- 24:02elections, there is a tendency to express dissatisfaction in
- 24:05the way that you might not do when it comes to an actual
- 24:09national parliament. Because for better or worse,
- 24:12people do see those European elections as as less
- 24:15consequential than a national election.
- 24:17So I do think he will see people voting slightly differently in
- 24:21this election. Having said that, I really don't
- 24:23want to underplay the polls. You know, there are a really
- 24:26serious number of people, 1/3 of the country, maybe up to a
- 24:30little bit more than that of the population, who really do want
- 24:34to see Marina Penn in power. And that is a very scary
- 24:37prospect. And not only that, she has been
- 24:39very good at trying to change the image of her party, right?
- 24:43Already there was a name change, you know, she kicked her father
- 24:46out. She kicked her niece out.
- 24:47Now the niece, Mario Marichal is also aligning with her for this,
- 24:51the purposes of this, these elections.
- 24:54And and what I was reading earlier today was that actually
- 24:57she like Macron has been courting a lot of the, you know,
- 25:00heads of heads of business, trying to show that she could be
- 25:05a good partner in cutting taxes, doing business in France a
- 25:11little bit easier, but at what cost, right.
- 25:13So I'm a bit, I'm a bit worried. Do you think also that people
- 25:17who are like, no, we can't say that the that the RN is the
- 25:20anti-Semitic, anti immigration, anti anti other that they were
- 25:25historically. I mean, can we really say that
- 25:27that has just been completely effaced from their platform just
- 25:30because she's not using those words?
- 25:33Yeah, it's pretty interesting. I spent the last presidential
- 25:37election night at Marine Le Pen's election night party and
- 25:41wait a minute things very wait why?
- 25:44As a journalist, OK, OK, not for fun, although I will say that
- 25:49her food spreads are really good.
- 25:50Like there's there's no buffet like Marine Le Pen buffet.
- 25:54Well. That's how they get you.
- 25:56That's how they get you with candy.
- 25:57You see, they're luring children off the street with candy.
- 26:01There's like a deep conspiracy theory that could be made around
- 26:04this, I feel. Anyway, I spent an election
- 26:07night at her event and it was very interesting how the her
- 26:12press team felt as a a foreign journalist.
- 26:15I am a French national now, but I have a British accent.
- 26:17I was born British. They were very, very, they just
- 26:20wanted to treat me very nicely the whole night, you know, as a
- 26:23foreigner. And the other thing that was
- 26:25very interesting is that they kept wedding me out, people of
- 26:29colour, supporters of Galla, of the of the Hassan Romanella for
- 26:33me to interview. Thank.
- 26:34They were very keen for me to interview these people.
- 26:36And I've noticed there's a few times covering RN events over
- 26:40the last sort of 5-6 years as Marine, the pen has been doing
- 26:45this process of what she calls D demonization.
- 26:49She's been really successful in that campaign.
- 26:51You know, first thing with her image, it was all about painting
- 26:54her as a sort of like slightly kooky cat lady.
- 26:56She has those are cats. She loves cats.
- 26:58She's kind of like your fun auntie.
- 27:01It's been a really successful campaign, but it's also
- 27:03something that has been helped generally by the normalization
- 27:06of her policies by parties that are further to the centre, like
- 27:10the Hyperbika taking on policies that are really things that
- 27:15would have been considered three or four years ago to be much
- 27:18further to the right. It's a bit, again, sorry to
- 27:20bring things back to Britain, but similar to what we're seeing
- 27:22in the UK with the Conservatives, this Rwanda
- 27:25policy, you know, of, of shipping refugees off asylum
- 27:28seekers off to a quote UN quote safe third country.
- 27:31It's something that I don't think we would have called a
- 27:34mainstream center right policy 56789 years ago.
- 27:39And it's, yeah, it's symptomatic of something that we're seeing
- 27:42all over Europe. So I guess the question is, you
- 27:45know, we are we're June 14th, the next vote is in two weeks.
- 27:50What is the sentiment that you've seen evolve over the last
- 27:55week when it comes to how the electorate?
- 27:58Maybe you've seen this through just social media and following
- 28:01what people are saying or maybe in your own friend group.
- 28:03Like, do people feel torn? Because the narrative I'm
- 28:07seeing, at least from the people who are very left wing is, well,
- 28:11obvious. It's an obvious choice.
- 28:12We're going to vote for the the Popular Front.
- 28:14But there are people, like I said, who really are vehemently
- 28:18opposed to some of those parties that are involved, having any,
- 28:23any affiliation with them whatsoever.
- 28:25And also, you know, there's these themes of anti-Semitism
- 28:28and a lack of support for certain world conflicts like
- 28:32Ukraine. These are are pivotal issues for
- 28:35some people and they really struggle to say I'm willing to
- 28:39look beyond this. And then others are saying we
- 28:41know that there are problems. We know that each each party is
- 28:45imperfect and we have to hope that should we get through, we
- 28:48canmore easily, you know, hold people accountable for their bad
- 28:51behavior and change things. But, you know, the track record
- 28:55of changing things isn't, you know, doesn't lead to a lot of
- 28:58optimism. Do you think that like this
- 29:00could be the time finally that leads to a sea change or or is
- 29:06it just sort of up in the air and we just have to wait and
- 29:08see? The optimist in me hopes that
- 29:11things are a little bit different this time.
- 29:14Like Sunday night, everybody in my circle, I, I have a sort of
- 29:18left of centre circle, shall we say.
- 29:20And everyone in my circle was really despondent of just like
- 29:24this is going to be an absolute disaster.
- 29:26You know, the last couple of days we have seen the left get
- 29:28it together, which itself feels like a miracle.
- 29:31Whether it will hold. I don't know how many of those
- 29:33people are willing to hold their noses and potentially vote for
- 29:37parties. You know, if they are in a
- 29:38constituency where there only is a candidate from a party that
- 29:41they find controversial in order to block the far right, how many
- 29:44people will actually do that? I do think it will be more than
- 29:48half. I hope it will be more than
- 29:49half, but I, I really don't know.
- 29:51And also, this is something that I wanted to say earlier, the
- 29:54participation rates are everything in these elections,
- 29:56right? So the election system that is
- 29:59used for these elections is a run off system.
- 30:01So basically on the 30th is a general, you know, a vote for as
- 30:06many candidates as there are standing in that constituency.
- 30:09And if somebody gets more than 50% of the vote, representing at
- 30:15least 25% of the voters within that constituency, they get
- 30:19elected. And if not, there's a run off a
- 30:22week later. So we don't like this is
- 30:24actually quite a key thing. How many people are going to
- 30:27take part in this election? Macron has called for mass turn
- 30:30out and for this everyone to turn up and and vote against the
- 30:33Heisen bloom on Nacional. The thing is that this argument
- 30:37of like we must turn out on mass to to fight the far right.
- 30:40It has been losing some of its potency in recent years because
- 30:44I think voters are getting a bit tired of being told to vote for
- 30:47this and being told to vote in opposition.
- 30:49You know, like, vote to block something rather than vote for
- 30:52something that is actively a good idea or actively an
- 30:54inspiring idea. And that's getting really
- 30:56tiring. I think people really want fresh
- 30:58ideas. Now, whether those fresh ideas
- 31:01are going to come from this left bloc, which is pretty divided,
- 31:05is an interesting question. There's a new element that's
- 31:08been thrown in, which is the sort of emergence of this other
- 31:12fairly charismatic guy, Rafael Gruxmann, who was the candidate
- 31:17who led the Socialists in their European election campaign.
- 31:21And he actually managed to get the Socialists to really a
- 31:26pretty decent score, matching Macron's number of seats.
- 31:30In fact, they got 13 seats, as did Macron's liberal grouping.
- 31:33And that's been quite an interesting thing because the
- 31:36Socialists basically ever since Francois Hollande left power,
- 31:39have been a spent force in French politics.
- 31:43And now with Kluxmann, there's a sense of like, oh, are the
- 31:46centre left sort of vaguely back?
- 31:48This is kind of interesting. And that's thrown a really
- 31:51interesting element into left wing politics.
- 31:54This has been this injection of of personality for the last
- 31:57several years. Menel Shaw has really dominated
- 32:00the sort of the left wing in terms of big personalities and
- 32:04he is famously difficult to work with.
- 32:07Doesn't seem to be getting on great with Glucksmann so it
- 32:09doesn't really bode well. No.
- 32:12And also, I mean, Glucksmann is kind of hated by anyone who
- 32:15supports Menorchon's party left Franz Las Humis.
- 32:19It's like the vitriol and the infighting is so extreme.
- 32:23You're like, OK, this is This is why nothing moves forward.
- 32:25But yes, he did perform very well.
- 32:28And he did, Glucksmann did say, yes, the party societies will
- 32:32align and he himself will align with this block.
- 32:35So I think you're right. They people need hope.
- 32:37And maybe for once this will at least give us something to fight
- 32:41for or fight toward after the fact.
- 32:44But I guess you're right, it's anyone's guess at this point.
- 32:47Just two weeks to to to figure it out.
- 32:49But if I'm understanding correctly, you're sort of
- 32:52insinuating that voting the first round is just as important
- 32:57as making the your voice heard. Should there not be an absolute
- 33:00majority for the second round? Yeah, you've got to turn up a
- 33:03vote for both rounds. You have to.
- 33:06This is me telling you officially this is.
- 33:08This is good. We all have to listen to Katie.
- 33:09This is the the gospel on your podcast, the Europeans.
- 33:15How much of this you know is is sort of reflective of the kinds
- 33:20of stories you and your your Co host talk about?
- 33:23Oh, that's a good question. Because we we, we try and strike
- 33:26a balance between unpicking the stories that have been massive
- 33:31in Europe over the past week. And this is one week where all
- 33:34eyes have been on France. And I happen to live here.
- 33:36So in the episode that we're recording on Monday, we're
- 33:39absolutely going to talk about this.
- 33:41But we also tend to try and strike a balance between the
- 33:45big, big stories and stories that you probably haven't heard
- 33:48about, the kind of stories that might make it to sort of like
- 33:50halfway down the Europe page of a national media outlet, those
- 33:56kinds of stories. So yeah, big stories, plus
- 33:59kooky, weirder stories that are still very interesting and worth
- 34:02your time. And we love kooky, weird
- 34:04stories, and there are plenty of those coming out of Europe.
- 34:06Is that the best place people can follow your work?
- 34:08Is is through the podcast? Yeah, it is at the moment.
- 34:12I was briefly loaded back onto Twitter by the absolute soap
- 34:16opera that has been French politics this week.
- 34:18Blame. I'm not really there otherwise.
- 34:20Which is sad because this is one of those weeks where I've just
- 34:22thought, oh, Twitter can be so great.
- 34:24It has been so informative and so funny over the past week.
- 34:27French Twitter. It's really been a great place
- 34:29to be. It's been on and you punctured
- 34:31through the noise, though. I mean, you came right back in
- 34:33and it was immediately visible. So I was relieved to see you
- 34:36back on there. Don't expect me back again.
- 34:39Because. The pressure.
- 34:41To perform not there at the moment because Twitter is
- 34:44probably after the elections, going to return to just being a
- 34:46general cesspit. So yeah, you can find me on my
- 34:49podcast. OK, Katie, what you've done with
- 34:52the Europeans has always been, you know, such a such a
- 34:56highlight for me. And I'm really glad to see you
- 34:58back commenting, even if briefly on Twitter.
- 35:03Thank you so much for coming by to explain what we're
- 35:06experiencing and hopefully there will be good news or some
- 35:10semblance of positive news in two weeks time.
- 35:12We will see. Thank you so much for having me.
- 35:16If you enjoy the show, it would mean the world if you would rate
- 35:19and leave a review on Spotify, Apple or wherever you get your
- 35:23podcasts. Until next time, Abiento.