Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #51: How to Have Constructive Political Discussions w/ Guy and Heidi Burgess
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast.
- 0:03I'm your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:04Today is a special edition of the show because we have not one but two guests.
- 0:09I always lead off guest episodes by saying that I do not take specific stance for or against
- 0:14anybody's political views or any political groups they belong to, but that has not been an
- 0:18issue with any guests so far, and it's especially not going to be an issue today due
- 0:22to the nature of our topic, which is properly handling tough political conversations.
- 0:28How do we handle intractable conflicts as our guests call them?
- 0:33Our guests describe those as large scale protracted conflicts that are very difficult,
- 0:37but not impossible to solve.
- 0:40So how do we solve these conflicts or at least come to a better understanding of each other?
- 0:45What does all this mean for our polarized political climate today?
- 0:49Answering such questions is a major driver for my career and such has been an indelible part
- 0:55of the careers of my guests for much longer than my own.
- 0:58They are Drs.
- 0:59Guy and Heidi Burgess.
- 1:01They co founded the Conflict Information Consortium, a multidisciplinary center for
- 1:07research and teaching about conflict and its transformation at the University of Colorado in
- 1:131988.
- 1:14Among the projects they've created as part of the CIC is the Conflict Resolution Information
- 1:19Source, the Beyond Intractability Knowledge Base, moving beyond intractability, and the
- 1:26construction or excuse me, the constructive conflict initiative.
- 1:30They have also served as adjunct instructors with George Mason University School for
- 1:35Conflict Analysis and Resolution.
- 1:37So without further ado, let's dive deep into the conversation on resolving political
- 1:42conflicts with our guests.
- 1:44Please welcome Drs.
- 1:45Guy and Heidi Burgess.
- 1:47Both of you, thank you so much for coming here today.
- 1:50How are you doing?
- 1:51Pretty well.
- 1:52Thanks for inviting us.
- 1:54Hey.
- 1:55Thank you for coming on.
- 1:57When I when I find found you guys and what you what you both do, I was like, oh, that's that's
- 2:01that's a perfect guest spot.
- 2:03I have to get in touch with you guys.
- 2:05So I mentioned in the intro that you both co founded the Conflict Information Consortium,
- 2:11the CIC in 1988.
- 2:14So what what exactly led you to do that?
- 2:16Did you notice the general trend of politics as increasingly toxic and polarized even back
- 2:22then, or were there one or more specific events that inspired the CIC?
- 2:26What exactly led to it?
- 2:28Well, the big thing was the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation.
- 2:33And in the 1980s, they put together a conflict resolution program as a major grant giving arm
- 2:43of the foundation.
- 2:44And they had the image of doing to the conflict resolution field what scientific medicine had
- 2:51done with medicine.
- 2:52And they talked about how medicine in the 20s and 30s was sort of an art and nobody had ever
- 2:59really thought very systematically about it.
- 3:02There was the rise of scientific medicine where you actually tried to systematically evaluate
- 3:08treatments, develop theories, all of this sort of stuff.
- 3:11They wanted to do that to this field.
- 3:14And they devoted a large amount of money over several decades.
- 3:18And we were lucky enough to have been supported by them for almost twenty years.
- 3:25But that was the big driver.
- 3:26Now, we came out of the we're children of the Vietnam civil rights era.
- 3:33We went into sociology really at a time when there was a lot of interest in addressing these
- 3:41problems.
- 3:43And this was, in a sense, the golden age of the conflict resolution and peacebuilding field
- 3:50where we really thought we could kind of easily handle these problems.
- 3:57A slightly different You'll find out that we always answer things differently.
- 4:04Hewlett's goal originally was to create a field of conflict resolution.
- 4:09There was a lot of discussion early on about what a field is and what it took to create it.
- 4:15And we all together came up with certain criteria for a field, a fairly large settled
- 4:24knowledge base, journals, professionals, all this stuff.
- 4:30They funded it for twenty years and then came to the conclusion that they'd succeeded.
- 4:35They created a field and it's true.
- 4:37Everybody who was involved had to admit it was true.
- 4:41We were very disappointed when they pulled out and said, okay, we did it.
- 4:45We're done.
- 4:46Bye.
- 4:47That was quite a trauma for a lot of folks, us included.
- 4:53But they did.
- 4:54They created a field and that field still exists.
- 4:57And they're quite active now in strengthening democracy.
- 5:01True.
- 5:02Yeah.
- 5:02It just just goes to show how long standing this issue has been.
- 5:06Sometimes polarizations and on these conflicts are treated as something new when when really
- 5:13they're not, and I think it's hard for especially people from my generation.
- 5:17I was born in 1993.
- 5:19So maybe it's not quite as I guess you can't really appreciate as much how how long these
- 5:26kinds of things I mean, really, it's been going on since the founding of the nation.
- 5:30Speaking of this goes back further than
- 5:33Since humans existed.
- 5:34Since humans Exactly.
- 5:36It's it's just part of human nature.
- 5:39But speaking of that history, so it's been nearly forty years since you started the CIC,
- 5:45and that is a considerable length of time for most things, but it's practically an eternity
- 5:50in the context of the American political landscape.
- 5:53For example, Ronald Reagan was right near the end of his second presidential term, and now
- 5:57it's Donald Trump's second term in office.
- 5:59So in terms of your work and studies, and we just talked a little bit about just now what
- 6:05how much some things have been the same, in terms of your work and studies, what has
- 6:10changed in those forty years and what has stayed the same?
- 6:16Well, way we actually had somebody ask us the same question not too long ago, and the way I
- 6:23answered it, and again, Heidi will have a different answer, but I tell the story of when
- 6:30I was a kid, we were all terrified of polio, and it really was scary.
- 6:35And then I have a vivid memory of going down to the elementary school and eating a sugar cube
- 6:41with the first polio vaccine.
- 6:43That was the end of it.
- 6:45And, wow.
- 6:47And the early 70s, Richard Nixon decided, Oh, heck, we should do the same thing to cancer.
- 6:55So he initiated the war on cancer and he was expecting to find the vaccine.
- 7:00That was it.
- 7:02We're now fifty years into the war on cancer, and while it's not as scary a disease as it
- 7:08once was, it's still pretty scary, and we're a long way from solving it.
- 7:13Now, in 1988, that was the fall of the Berlin Wall.
- 7:18That was the end of history.
- 7:21That was the end of the great Cold War, and the nuclear nightmare that we all grew up with.
- 7:30Everybody sort of thought that the whole world had decided that a democratic system organized
- 7:37around capitalist economies was the way to go, and that we could cooperate and solve all sorts
- 7:44of problems together and peace building and conflict resolution.
- 7:49Know, we all really thought we had finally got this figured out.
- 7:52We thought we had the sugar cube.
- 7:54The book Getting to Yes, which introduced interest based bargaining, was kind of the
- 8:01equivalent of the polio vaccine.
- 8:05Things were optimistic.
- 8:06And then we've discovered in the intervening thirty five years that history hadn't ended.
- 8:16There are great tensions that remain in the world between authoritarian societies and
- 8:22liberal societies.
- 8:24People have, in many liberal societies, lost track of why it was we invented democracy in
- 8:30the first place, and there's disturbing articles about how people don't think that's
- 8:35worth protecting anymore.
- 8:37And we've discovered that really the world is awash with terrible intractable conflicts
- 8:43driven by a whole new range of very sophisticated weapons, and that the conflict
- 8:50problem is like the war on cancer, a whole, whole lot scarier and more difficult than we
- 8:57thought it was back in 1990, 'eighty eight, when we founded the consortium.
- 9:03And what we and everybody else in the field in various Ways has been struggling with is, okay,
- 9:09how do we deal with this bigger or much scarier reality?
- 9:17And I'll just add a footnote, which is that when we started focusing on what we call
- 9:23hyperpolarization, most people call it toxic polarization or effective polarization or just
- 9:30polarization, we started focusing on that pretty shortly after Trump's first election,
- 9:37maybe even some before it.
- 9:40And lots of people told us, we've always been polarized.
- 9:44There's nothing different.
- 9:46Well, we think there is something different, that the level of polarization now is much
- 9:52worse than it had been earlier.
- 9:56And there are tools to push it such as social media and the Internet and now AI, that didn't
- 10:04exist back in the sixties and seventies and eighties.
- 10:09And, yes, Guy and I have had a lot of discussions about whether the sixties civil
- 10:15rights era with all of the political violence that went on was worse than now or not.
- 10:23I don't think we've resolved that one yet, but folks didn't have the tools to spread hate and
- 10:32fear and discord that they have now.
- 10:35George Orwell would have been really excited with the new technology.
- 10:40Yeah.
- 10:42It's I'm I'm glad you brought the specific point of affective polarization.
- 10:47There's some projects I've been working on, including a TED talk that's talking about
- 10:51affective polarization.
- 10:52So that's kinda how I refer to it.
- 10:55So I appreciate pointing that out.
- 10:57But, yeah, it's it's it is this whole you you of already get kinda to the next question I was
- 11:04gonna talk about, which was, do you believe that we are more polarized than we were twenty,
- 11:08thirty, forty years ago?
- 11:09Because it there definitely is even if we're not technically more polarized, there
- 11:13definitely is something different.
- 11:15So do you think a lot of how much of it do you think is just that we are more polarized, and
- 11:19how much of it is that we are just more aware of polarization and there's more ways for it to
- 11:24fester, or is it just a matter of both?
- 11:28Well, I have to back up, and I can hear a colleague of ours, James Cohn, yelling in my
- 11:35ear as he's watching this because he runs a program called More in Common.
- 11:43And he's put together something that he calls the perception gap.
- 11:47And his argument is we're actually a lot closer together than we realize that we are.
- 11:54But it's the noisy folks out on the fringes who we're all paying attention to.
- 11:59And, yeah, they are more polarized than they used to be.
- 12:03But he would say, and he has good data to back it up, that actually awful lot of people in the
- 12:09middle are not that far apart.
- 12:13The problem is very few people realize that.
- 12:17And our social structures and our communication structures and the way we get news these days
- 12:24doesn't permit us to discover that.
- 12:27So we all make the assumption that those guys over on the right or the left, depending on
- 12:35which side work you're standing on, are totally crazy and evil, and you hate them.
- 12:44And then almost always, if you end up somehow talking to one of those people and really
- 12:54listening, you'll find out that you and they agree on an awful lot of stuff.
- 13:00So the answer to whether we're polarized or not depends on who you're talking to and how you're
- 13:11measuring it in terms of what people really believe or what in terms of what people think
- 13:17people believe.
- 13:20There's also a true believer effect, that politics is driven by people who really believe
- 13:28in their heart of hearts that the other side presents an existential threat to everything
- 13:35that they care about.
- 13:37And once you conclude that, you really decide, okay, I'm gonna go all out to fight these guys.
- 13:43I have to.
- 13:43I don't have any choice.
- 13:45And so you have, sometimes they're unflatteringly called the wingnuts on each
- 13:51side.
- 13:52But now they're raising important issues.
- 13:55And that sort of disrespectful language is good for a laugh line, but it isn't very helpful.
- 14:03But there are these true believers on each side that are much more politically aware and much
- 14:12clearer about who the good guys and the bad guys are and much more committed to a fight.
- 14:18Folks in the center tend to be disillusioned by the whole process because it's awfully ugly to
- 14:25them.
- 14:25They don't know really which side to brute for because they kind of see both sides of the
- 14:30issues.
- 14:31And they are far less prominent in the political debate.
- 14:36We also have, in the way our democracy is structured, with primaries and the two
- 14:44political parties, the center is in many ways disenfranchised.
- 14:51We have another colleague who is campaigning with anyone who will listen, arguing that the
- 14:58big voting rights crisis is the center, that the candidates are determined by party
- 15:06activists on the left and the right.
- 15:09In many cases, the centrists can't even vote in those primaries.
- 15:15So there's certainly a lot of proposals out there to politically empower the center in ways
- 15:22that get closer to really equitable representation.
- 15:26But the thing that frustrates me is that the two parties are doing their darndest to try to
- 15:31prevent those structural reforms from happening.
- 15:34So one of the big ones is ranked choice voting, which I think is really a good idea.
- 15:40I think Guy agrees with me.
- 15:42But it's having real hard time getting off because the political parties are making up
- 15:48stories about how bad it is and getting it defeated wherever it gets on the ballot.
- 15:53Or it did succeed in Alaska, and it sounds like they're gonna get it overturned because they
- 15:59realize that it will harm the political party power.
- 16:04So they're working against that.
- 16:06They're working against a lot of other reforms that could be really helpful, and that's
- 16:11discouraging.
- 16:12And what ranked choice voting does very quickly is that if you have a state that tilts strongly
- 16:19Democratic or Republican, the way the current system works is, take California.
- 16:27If you're a Republican, you might as well not show up.
- 16:31But with ranked choice voting, it sort of adjusts the primary process so you have an
- 16:38election between somebody who's center right and somebody who's left and somebody who's far
- 16:45left.
- 16:46And in Republican states, it goes the other way.
- 16:50But that gives you a choice.
- 16:52And in lots of places, there really isn't a choice.
- 16:56Yeah.
- 16:58Funny that you there's there's so many things that you guys so many great points you brought
- 17:03that I wish I could address them all, but obviously only have so much time to do that.
- 17:07But one of the big things I I I talk that you talked about is last week on my podcast, it was
- 17:15just me that time, but I was talking about political apathy and how that can
- 17:20unintentionally drive polarization too because you have a lot of people partly because, well,
- 17:25they don't know which side to go to or they just don't like how nasty politics is getting
- 17:29yeah.
- 17:30They just they they sit aside, but that unintentionally inflames polarization because
- 17:34the people who are polarized are participating at an outsized rate.
- 17:38So then it makes it seem like it's more polarized than it actually is, that that idea
- 17:44of false polarization.
- 17:47So I I I I suppose that for you guys but is is this polarization a lot of that too, that false
- 17:53polarization where people perceive it to be more polarized than it is, so then they kind of
- 17:57react in a polarized manner, and then it sort of becomes a self fulfilling prophecy?
- 18:01Right.
- 18:01I mean, I think that's true.
- 18:04And the discussions that I've had with James Cohn, who very much believes that, is whether
- 18:13or not that matters.
- 18:14Now, he thinks it matters a lot, and he's trying to empower and raise up and make visible
- 18:22the middle, and that's great.
- 18:24We really, really need to do that.
- 18:26But in the meantime, it's the visible polarized folks who are running the show.
- 18:34And to pretend that they aren't, I don't think is very realistic.
- 18:39They are.
- 18:40We wanna change it so they aren't or at least so that they're not all of the story.
- 18:46I don't wanna disenfranchise them any more than I want them to disenfranchise the center.
- 18:52But we all should have a voice, and we should be working to bring in and get interested and
- 19:01involve the apathetic people in the middle.
- 19:06And the one kudos that I want to bring up is that there's a lot of work being done at the
- 19:13local level to do this.
- 19:16Federal level is, many people think a bridge too far, too far gone, but there is a whole lot
- 19:24of work to enfranchise folks at the local level to do collaborative democracy, deliberative
- 19:32democracy that really does listen to both sides or all sides.
- 19:36There's often more than two.
- 19:38And we've been doing some work with some of the groups that are doing that, and there's a lot
- 19:43of hope in what's going on there.
- 19:47Yeah.
- 19:48With the local stuff, that's really great to hear.
- 19:51I mean, obviously, besides the general work of trying to bridge divides is you you have that
- 19:57more that apathy or lack of understanding of what's going on, it gets amplified at the local
- 20:03level.
- 20:03Not not and that's not entirely the fault of the people participating.
- 20:06It's local government, even for those of us who are involved in this stuff for a living is is
- 20:12very inscrutable.
- 20:13It's very hard to find information about a lot of these local and now if it's like New York
- 20:19City or Chicago or some big city, yeah, it's a bit easier to find information on them.
- 20:24But some of these more smaller counties, it's for example, it's it's really difficult to find
- 20:30information on them.
- 20:31That I I can definitely appreciate that's that you're involved in that work.
- 20:35And speaking of work that you've been directly involved in and the CIC has been involved in,
- 20:42what are a couple of if you wanna go expand more on that, obviously feel free, but what are
- 20:48a couple of one one to three direct impacts that your work with the CIC has had that you're
- 20:53particularly proud of that you can demonstrate for the listeners and viewers?
- 21:00Well, I think that the biggest thing is that we've been trying to, and this is another way
- 21:09of defining intractability, is to deal with the awful complexity of society.
- 21:17And early in my work there, we had a visiting scientist who actually worked on nuclear
- 21:25weapons at the Sandia Nuclear Weapons Lab.
- 21:28And he explained to us the difference between complicated and complex systems.
- 21:35And complicated systems are the things that people are really good at.
- 21:39They're machines that have lots of parts, but we understand how it all works.
- 21:43They have blueprints.
- 21:44They break, we can fix them.
- 21:46They have short, sharp feedback loops.
- 21:50If it doesn't work, you find out real quick and you fix it.
- 21:56Complex systems are social systems, where there's no set of plans.
- 22:03The various parts, individuals act in unpredictable ways, and you really can't
- 22:10predict what's going on.
- 22:12The analogy that I use to explain this is imagine a pool table and taking the perfect
- 22:18pool shot.
- 22:20That's a complicated task.
- 22:23But if you do it right and you're good, you can run the table.
- 22:27But what a complex system is, is imagine a gigantic pool table with millions and billions
- 22:34of balls.
- 22:35And at the same time, you have millions of actors with cue balls and cues all trying to
- 22:41take the perfect shot at the same time.
- 22:45And it's just chaos.
- 22:47And one of the real challenges is to figure out how you improve a system like that, that has so
- 22:56much noise.
- 22:57And we make a distinction between the sort of engineering and medical problem solving models.
- 23:04Engineering works on complicated systems, and you know how engineers and mechanics fix
- 23:10things.
- 23:12But the way you fix complex systems is the way doctors work.
- 23:17Your human body is a complex system.
- 23:21What they try to do is identify things that are going wrong.
- 23:26Sometimes they're simple and they can fix them, a cod and strep infection they can treat with
- 23:31antibiotics.
- 23:33Sometimes they can't fix it, but they can provide symptomatic relief.
- 23:38And some conditions they still haven't solved.
- 23:40And so what we really need is a whole set of interventions designed to fix particular
- 23:47aspects of the conflict system that are going badly.
- 23:52And we put together this approach we call massively parallel democracy building or
- 23:59problem solving or peace building, depending on the audience.
- 24:03But the idea is instead of having a grand solution, you have a massive number of people
- 24:09simultaneously working on different projects, each affecting some different aspect of the
- 24:16system that tries to nudge it in a more positive direction.
- 24:22And this idea has been picked up by a lot of people, which is why we're proud of it.
- 24:28We think that it's helping move the field in a useful direction.
- 24:34When we started, we were focusing on intractable conflicts.
- 24:39And there was a colleague of ours in Syracuse who came before us even.
- 24:43He wrote a book in intractable conflicts and their transformation.
- 24:48And it was kind of his book that got us started along that line.
- 24:52But at the time, we were the only two.
- 24:54And of all of the Hewlett centers, there were about 20 Hewlett centers.
- 24:58Nobody else was looking at intractable conflict.
- 25:01Now many more people are, many more scholars are, and there's many more practitioners who
- 25:08are looking at it.
- 25:10And our notion of massively parallel is being picked up and we're pleased about that.
- 25:17I would answer that another thing that we're proud of is just the degree to which beyond
- 25:25intractability has come to be used as a well known and trusted resource in the field.
- 25:32We meet people constantly who say, oh, yeah, I go beyond intractability.
- 25:38I've used that a lot.
- 25:40There's people who I've never heard of.
- 25:42And it's really gotten out there and people really rely on it.
- 25:48And there hasn't ever really been anything that matches it.
- 25:54So we're pretty pleased about that.
- 25:57Doctor.
- 25:58Now, what we try to do with this massively parallel idea and also the Beyond
- 26:05Intractability System, we're about to release, fingers crossed, a new, much improved version
- 26:10of Beyond Detractability is it breaks down all of the different components.
- 26:15We've identified over 50 different roles within any community that are active in some aspect or
- 26:23another of the conflict process.
- 26:27And what we try to do, and the nice thing about the system is it's very, very
- 26:33multidisciplinary.
- 26:34It tries to bring together what we collectively know.
- 26:38It has thousands of references and articles.
- 26:43But this is the kind of problem that you need to look at all aspects of it.
- 26:49If you just focus on one little solution, it's not going to work.
- 26:53You got to deal with the whole problem.
- 26:55And that's beyond the scope of any nobody's smart enough to do that.
- 26:59So you have to break it up into pieces.
- 27:02That's the way human society does big things is with the division of labor.
- 27:08Oh, that's fantastic.
- 27:09I really like the dichotomy between complex and complicated in particular.
- 27:15That's not something I really thought about before.
- 27:18And actually, this is a good segue into the next question because another really great
- 27:25distinction that I liked from the Beyond Attractability website because for another
- 27:30project of mine like that like the the talk I'm planning to give at some point, I came across
- 27:36one of your articles.
- 27:37This is actually how I learned about the conflict information consortium in the first
- 27:41place and the Beyond Intractability website.
- 27:45And you had a interview with it was called business as usual part three, the blame game.
- 27:51And in short, you talk about the authors of a book named Difficult Conversations, and they
- 27:56make a distinction between blame and contribution.
- 28:00And I thought that was really fascinating, but for people at home who want to hear it from
- 28:05your own words, how do we differentiate between blaming and contribution, and how do we shift
- 28:11conversations from blame to contribution?
- 28:15That's a really important distinction, and it's one thing that really contributes to our
- 28:22polarization, effect of polarization, hyperpolarization, whatever you want to call it
- 28:26now.
- 28:27And the book, as you said, it's called Difficult Conversations.
- 28:31It was written by Stone Patton and Heen, three of our colleagues from Harvard.
- 28:37Wanna give them credit.
- 28:40It's a great book.
- 28:41I've given it to both of my kids for when they have relationship problems or workplace
- 28:46problems.
- 28:46If you've got problems, you wanna know how to deal with a difficult conversation, get that
- 28:52book.
- 28:53The difference between blame we all know what blame is.
- 28:57It's your fault.
- 28:58You did it wrong.
- 28:59It's it's a you statement, and it puts all the blame on you, and I'm blameless.
- 29:07It's never that clean.
- 29:10Almost always, the other side, meaning me, contributed in some way to what went wrong.
- 29:20Maybe you didn't give clear enough directions to the person who you wanted to do what you
- 29:27wanted them to do, so they didn't.
- 29:29Maybe you didn't realize that they were overwhelmed with six other tasks.
- 29:33There's all sorts of ways in which we think that it's a cut and dried problem.
- 29:39We run into this politically all the time.
- 29:42The left thinks that the problem is entirely Trump, and the left hasn't done anything wrong
- 29:50that might encourage Trump voters.
- 29:53And Trump voters are the same way.
- 29:55They think that the entire problem is left and the right hasn't done anything wrong.
- 30:02And that's simply not true.
- 30:04Both sides have contributed to our polarization.
- 30:07Now we've gotten into a lot of discussions as to whether one side has contributed more than
- 30:12the other.
- 30:13I'm not going to go there right now.
- 30:15But I think most people would agree.
- 30:19I hope most people would agree that there are some things that each side has done that has
- 30:26contributed to the hyperpolarization situation that we all are suffering from.
- 30:34So that's the difference between blame and contribution.
- 30:38Contribution realizes that I'm part of this too.
- 30:41There are things that I can fix quite independent of what the other person's doing.
- 30:47And yes, the other person has things to fix too, but it's not all on them.
- 30:52We both need to own up to our part of the problem and work together to create a better
- 30:59relationship that will solve whatever problem is bothering us.
- 31:04Yeah.
- 31:05That accountability is just in such short supply these days.
- 31:09And to your point about not wanting to get into whether somebody has contributed more or not, I
- 31:14I think if you do go down too far that path, that still kind of circles back to blame where
- 31:21people are like, okay.
- 31:22Yeah.
- 31:22I did this wrong, but you did 50 other things wrong too.
- 31:25So, really, this is more your fault.
- 31:26Then it's just like, okay.
- 31:27Then we're we're back to where we started.
- 31:29Races again.
- 31:30Yeah.
- 31:30Yeah.
- 31:31Exactly.
- 31:31So how how do we then how do you how would we more effectively one or two ways that we more
- 31:38effectively shift it from blame to contribution?
- 31:44I think the way we need to do it is to get people to understand what's going on more in
- 31:53terms of a system.
- 31:55It gets back to Guy's idea about complex systems.
- 32:02In in heated intractable complexes, we call them, it's been going on for a long time.
- 32:11There's a lot of tit for tat.
- 32:15One side does something, the other side responds, the first side.
- 32:18It's going back and forth.
- 32:20There's a long history.
- 32:22You can't just simplify it to one or two things.
- 32:26You have to realize that there's all sorts of factors that are playing into this.
- 32:31So we talk about the importance of complexifying your understanding of what's
- 32:36going on.
- 32:37And we, with our students, we did an exercise where we got them to talk about any particular
- 32:45conflict.
- 32:45We decide on a conflict that people are interested in.
- 32:49Interestingly, and I've been doing this for years, very often it was immigration.
- 32:54Immigration's been a hot topic for a very long time.
- 32:59And you start out by asking, Well, what's the problem with immigration?
- 33:04Write down on a piece of paper what the problem is.
- 33:07And they'll write down a few things and it's all the other guy's fault.
- 33:11And then you start pulling it apart and you start asking questions.
- 33:14And then they start realizing, oh, yeah.
- 33:16Well, my side's done some things that are causing problems too.
- 33:21And you start asking, well, what causes that?
- 33:25Because they name something that's wrong.
- 33:27I say, well, what's causing that?
- 33:29And they end up with this huge list of all these causes, some of which they're
- 33:34contributing to, some of which the other side's contributing to, some of which outside factors
- 33:39totally out of everybody's control are contributing to.
- 33:42And then they go, yeah.
- 33:43This really is more complicated than I thought.
- 33:45Yeah.
- 33:46It really is more complicated than you thought.
- 33:48Okay.
- 33:49So let's start figuring out where we could influence the system and who can take
- 33:54responsibility for what.
- 33:57And one of the things we have a little exercise on this on the website, we call it the common
- 34:04ground exercise.
- 34:06When you're looking at one of these really controversial issues, you ask people to, first
- 34:13of all, try to identify, okay, what is it within this context of this big thing that we
- 34:20can decide that we agree on?
- 34:22And there may be a whole range of sort of sub issues that, yeah, no, this is not what we're
- 34:28fighting over.
- 34:29And then you try to identify, okay, what are the things that we disagree about?
- 34:35And then you try to identify, well, yeah, okay, this, this, and this.
- 34:39And then you say, well, of these things that we disagree about, how many of them are
- 34:45attributable to different images of objective reality?
- 34:49So I think that this plant's going to kill me with its release of toxic chemicals and
- 34:55somebody else thinks it's safe.
- 34:57Okay, that's something you could try to straighten out and find out who's right.
- 35:02And then there are some things that are moral values, that abortion is murder or is something
- 35:08else.
- 35:09And so, know, you focus on, okay, for the things that are fact based, how might we figure
- 35:15out an answer?
- 35:17And for moral questions, we ask, how can you constructively debate this?
- 35:22I mean, these are things that people have to make tough decisions about, And what's the best
- 35:28way to do that?
- 35:29Well, there's a related story in this that goes back to the early days of our program, which
- 35:35was originally the Conflict Resolution Consortium.
- 35:39And we told our activist friends that, hey, we got big grant for a conflict resolution center.
- 35:46And they thought we were going to force them to compromise on their basic values, thought we
- 35:50were traitors.
- 35:51They wouldn't have anything to do with us.
- 35:53And we'd send out invitations for seminars and everybody would say no.
- 35:58And then one day we got the bright idea, hey, you guys are involved in all of these terrible
- 36:05fights.
- 36:06Let's come talk not about compromise and resolution, but how we can handle those fights
- 36:12more constructively.
- 36:14And we literally went from a 95% rejection rate to a 95% acceptance rate.
- 36:21Once you reframe the field, not as a third party, somebody who's trying to sort of squish
- 36:28this conflict because it's disagreeable, but from the perspective of the advocates on both
- 36:34sides that have issues that they really care about, they just want to know how to pursue
- 36:39those issues more constructively, then all of a sudden people are interested.
- 36:45Well, think that just goes to show just how important because there is just that whole ends
- 36:50justify the means.
- 36:52Everybody's so worried about winning political battles that they don't really think about the
- 36:57whole process of how we get there.
- 36:59And if the process isn't great, then you're you're not gonna have a a result that that
- 37:06benefits anybody, and the process is just gonna get continually worse.
- 37:10So I I really appreciate you pointing that out.
- 37:13So that meant that that just really goes to show just how if you focus more on the process,
- 37:17we can have much better dialogue.
- 37:19But so let's get a little bit more into these, as you call them, intractable conflicts.
- 37:24And, again, it's defined on the Beyond Intractability website as large scale
- 37:28protracted conflicts that are very difficult but not impossible to solve.
- 37:32Now, Heidi, you you brought up immigration as an example and then abortion from Guy.
- 37:38Is maybe what's another couple?
- 37:41I mean, we don't need to go super in-depth if you if you don't want to, but what's I
- 37:45do wanna I wanna give you one caveat, which is I made the mistake years ago of going to a
- 37:52meeting with a bunch of family mediators and making the assertion that family conflict
- 37:57conflicts weren't intractable.
- 37:59Oh, boy.
- 38:01I found out that I was wrong.
- 38:04I was lucky enough to have lived as a child in a functional family, and I had a functional
- 38:10family of my own and not a whole lot of friends who were divorced.
- 38:14And boy, those divorce mediators let me have it.
- 38:18So you can have intractable conflicts between a husband and a wife.
- 38:23There's no doubt about that.
- 38:25That's just not the kind of stuff that we look at in our career and on our website.
- 38:30But I I don't deny that those kinds of conflicts can be intractable.
- 38:37It in terms of US politics, it's there's two levels.
- 38:44I would argue that the red blue divide itself is an intractable conflict in which a whole
- 38:53bunch of other ones are embedded.
- 38:55So abortion's embedded, immigration's embedded.
- 39:01What else are we fighting over?
- 39:02We're fighting over taxes.
- 39:04We're fighting over Climate.
- 39:07What?
- 39:08Climate.
- 39:08Gender.
- 39:09Yeah.
- 39:09Race.
- 39:10Yeah.
- 39:10Size of government.
- 39:12Yeah.
- 39:12So all those are intractable, and it's all under the umbrella of the red blue divide.
- 39:23And then, of course, there's international ones and the one we're hearing about constantly, of
- 39:29course, the poster child of attractable conflicts is Israel Palestine.
- 39:35I was just reading a history of it today that pointed out that it's been going on forever and
- 39:40that used to be called the Israeli Arab conflict and got labeled Israeli Palestinian
- 39:49later on.
- 39:51It goes way back.
- 39:53And we've talked to people from Kashmir or India or Pakistan who says nobody pays
- 39:59attention to us.
- 40:00We're just as intractable as they are.
- 40:03Yeah.
- 40:03They've they've been going at it for a long time too.
- 40:06Yeah.
- 40:07And then Ukraine and Russia hasn't been going on nearly as long, but it sure is being very
- 40:14difficult to solve.
- 40:16Never international stuff, and there's domestic stuff.
- 40:21And by that, I mean, internal to one country.
- 40:26And then there's domestic, meaning family, but we're not going there.
- 40:30Now the other thing that's important to make is a distinction between underlying conflicts and
- 40:37dispute episodes that occur within the context of those conflicts.
- 40:43So there are, within the environmental movement, is a wrong running tension between
- 40:48environmental preservationists and you might call them developers.
- 40:54Are, Dieb Mori, gonna post an excellent essay on the length of the Arab Israeli conflict
- 41:02between the Arabs and Jews that go way back into the mid-1800s, and it goes back further
- 41:08than that.
- 41:10But within each of these conflicts, and these are, in one level, are the real intractable
- 41:17conflicts.
- 41:18They arise because of deep inherent tensions between people with different world views,
- 41:24different cultural traditions, different economic circumstances, different geographic
- 41:29realities that play out in an endless series of disputes.
- 41:35Some of these disputes are resolved at the negotiation table, not too many sadly.
- 41:41An awful lot are resolved politically, some through electoral politics, some through
- 41:46legislation, some are resolved in the courts, some are resolved in the court of public
- 41:52opinion, some are resolved militarily.
- 41:55But after you resolve one dispute, that's just one aspect of the big thing.
- 41:59And the big thing will be there again and again and again.
- 42:03And what you need, and one of the things that we've argued, is that democracy is above all a
- 42:10dispute handling system, and it needs to work through this endless and gigantic chain of
- 42:18disputes over everything that gets played out again and again in different jurisdictions all
- 42:23over the country.
- 42:25And if you think about democracy, and there have been books, Bill Urie wrote a book on
- 42:31dispute handling systems and how you design them.
- 42:35And it's a different way of thinking about democracy.
- 42:38It's different from just thinking about it as a structural thing.
- 42:42You've got the three branches of government and checks and balances, elections, everybody
- 42:47votes.
- 42:49It's really how you handle these disputes.
- 42:52And it isn't just how you come up with a solution that somebody wins and somebody loses,
- 42:59But the people who lose have to feel decent about it.
- 43:04And they have to feel that it's fair and they have to feel that if they have other
- 43:09complaints, they can come forward.
- 43:11And they might win next time.
- 43:12And they might win next time.
- 43:14And another exercise we have on our website and Substack Newsletter asks people what they owe
- 43:22the losers in an election.
- 43:25What is too much to ask for and to take from them?
- 43:30And it's these obligations that we make to the losers in democracy's elections that hold it
- 43:37all together.
- 43:38And this is why you asked earlier if things are worse than they've ever been.
- 43:44And I think in a sense they are because the sense of restraint and the Trump administration
- 43:52is hell bent to undo anything that the progressive left cares about.
- 43:59There's no limit to it.
- 44:02Likely the left will respond in kind.
- 44:05This is the escalation dynamic where it gets worse and worse and worse.
- 44:10And it's been slowly building over the last, well, a good long time.
- 44:16And when we've done that exercise, people have a really hard time figuring out what they owe
- 44:22the losers if they're the winners.
- 44:24They're not at all convinced they owe them anything.
- 44:28That that kinda makes me think of whenever we hear and this personally, of my pet peeves is
- 44:34the idea of a presidential mandate.
- 44:36I mean, governors, I'm sure, think of it the same way too, but usually you hear what a
- 44:41presidential mandate were.
- 44:42Because they won, that that means they they have been given the all clear to do whatever
- 44:50they want.
- 44:50Right.
- 44:50It's like that's that's no.
- 44:52That's that's nobody ever well, I mean, there's a few people that are that are saying that, but
- 44:56that's not what everybody who's voting for you is saying, and it it's it's one of my
- 45:01particular grinds.
- 45:02And that's I mean, Republican, Democrat, doesn't matter.
- 45:04There's people that that do that all the time.
- 45:07So how do we and we we we just talked about it a little bit now and talked about it a little
- 45:11bit earlier because this whole just hell bent on winning arguments and conflicts, not really
- 45:17solving anything, just just winning arguments.
- 45:21That's this whole ends justify the means.
- 45:24So as long as they get their way, how they got there doesn't matter even though that makes the
- 45:30next issue an even bigger fight.
- 45:34So how do you think we shift we can better convince people that to shift the focus from
- 45:43winning things to trying to actually fix the process of politics?
- 45:47How do you think we go about making sure that people try to fix the means before fixing the
- 45:54ends?
- 45:55Well, I think this is really well demonstrated by the work that's being done at the local
- 46:01level that it's very easy to point out, and I think it's hard to dispute, that when we just
- 46:11focus on winning, we're not able to solve any problems.
- 46:17It's very rare.
- 46:18I mean, congress does do more than we realize they do.
- 46:22But in general, they're not have not been successful in tackling any of our big problems.
- 46:29There's been an obvious consensus solution on immigration for a long time that hasn't managed
- 46:37to get implemented.
- 46:39There have been 80 or so percent, if I'm remembering my numbers right, of people agree
- 46:47on abortion policy, but that hasn't been implemented.
- 46:51We've gone either totally one way or totally the other.
- 46:55That if we just focus on winning and stomping the other guy, and Guy's got a great lecture on
- 47:02what he calls the 51% hammer effect, where you want to get 51% and then hammer the other side.
- 47:09If we focus on that, we're not going to solve any of our problems.
- 47:13And if you ask people, do you want to solve problems?
- 47:16Everybody goes, yes, everybody wants to solve problems.
- 47:20At the local level, folks are able to do that.
- 47:24So at the local level, you can get people together and focus on a common problem, one
- 47:30that's being addressed quite frequently around the country as affordable housing and
- 47:36homelessness.
- 47:37It's a problem almost everywhere.
- 47:39And it's pretty easy to get Republicans and Democrats together to work on that problem
- 47:45together.
- 47:47Other things like childcare, schools, better policing are things at the local level that
- 47:58people can come together and work on and see solutions to.
- 48:03And I keep on talking to the folks who are doing this at the local level, and one of my
- 48:08standard questions is, okay, how do we scale this up?
- 48:12And there's various answers about scale how to scale it up.
- 48:16But I think the answer is that we have to get people to understand that our current processes
- 48:24are not solving our problems.
- 48:26We're not solving climate.
- 48:28We're not solving immigration.
- 48:30We're not solving poverty.
- 48:32We're not solving racial divides.
- 48:36All of the things we're defining as problems, we're not solving.
- 48:40Why not?
- 48:41Because our processes stink.
- 48:44The line that or rather the thing that I've been advocating is that we need a great
- 48:51reframing.
- 48:52That right now we tend to think of our problem as the other side.
- 48:57They're the enemy and that the goal is to defeat the enemy.
- 49:02And if we were smart enough to realize that the real threat to our future is not the enemy, but
- 49:08it's our hyperpolarized dysfunctional political process and the fact that we hate each other,
- 49:14then all of a sudden we can be on the same side and that we're working to fix the broken
- 49:20political process that is causing us such grief and preventing us from solving problems.
- 49:27We've gone on to our another story that I tell is that when I was just out of graduate school,
- 49:34this is probably fifteen years before the first mention of the climate change movement on
- 49:43Wikipedia.
- 49:46I had the fortune of working at the National Center for Atmospheric Research.
- 49:53And down the hall were the guys who were doing the initial research on climate change.
- 50:00And these were climatologists used to going to climate conferences.
- 50:04They were scientists, physicists, and they just discovered that we're ruining the climate upon
- 50:12which we all depend.
- 50:15And they were starting to say, my God, how do I go from being a climate scientist who does
- 50:20nothing about politics to advocating for transforming the global energy system and
- 50:27building a coalition to do it.
- 50:30And that started a set of conversations that took fifteen, twenty years to get to the point
- 50:37where the IPCC won a Nobel Peace Prize.
- 50:41It's now been twenty plus years since that, the climate consensus is unraveling with the same
- 50:49terrible political problems that we mentioned earlier.
- 50:53And what we've been arguing is that the conflict problem is just sort of where the
- 50:59climate scientists were fifty years ago, forty five years ago, that there are relatively few
- 51:06number of people who really understand how all of these things interact in ways that are a
- 51:12fundamental threat to everything that we care about.
- 51:17Like life on earth.
- 51:18Yeah.
- 51:19And that what we need to do is to start a long term process similar in scope and duration and
- 51:26funding to what we're putting into climate change to learn how to handle our conflict and
- 51:33to build a dispute handling system that can really protect everybody's interests and work
- 51:39through all of these issues, work through the divisive effects of new high-tech social media
- 51:45and bad faith action, all sorts of things.
- 51:49I'd like to see one of these funders that's plunking a billion dollars down on climate
- 51:55change to plunk a billion dollars down on this.
- 51:58And I'd argue to them that they would probably be more successful in climate change if they
- 52:03did.
- 52:03Well, they won't be successful in climate change until they do, and that's getting
- 52:08increasingly evident as Trump and, you know, all of this stuff is unraveling.
- 52:15Yeah.
- 52:15And go back a little bit to something that Heidi specifically talked about how we're not
- 52:21solving these problems.
- 52:21Even if you think that you're solving these problems, obviously, they've got their specific
- 52:26people specific way of what solving a problem is.
- 52:30Like you like you guys said earlier, your idea of what's solving an issue is when the pendulum
- 52:35swings to the other side, which it inevitably does, your solution is suddenly going to
- 52:41evaporate.
- 52:42Then you're and and then we're just gonna keep going back and forth and not actually have any
- 52:48any long term solutions.
- 52:50So it talks a little bit more of the larger scale methods for handling intractable
- 52:55conflicts.
- 52:55Let's talk more about the the individual level because we do wanna emphasize that we can fix
- 53:02these problems with intractability and polarization, and they're not gonna require not
- 53:07everything requires this very high level
- 53:11Massive, like, parallel.
- 53:12Yeah.
- 53:12Yeah.
- 53:13Yeah.
- 53:13Exactly.
- 53:14It it doesn't require a whole bunch of people.
- 53:16You individuals can make their own changes too.
- 53:20So what are some simple actionable ways, like two to three, that any any individual can
- 53:25employ to constructively handle these tough political conflicts?
- 53:30I used to teach a class on conflict skills.
- 53:33And the very last class I said to the students, if there's only two things that you remember
- 53:40from this class ten years later, The two things I want you to remember are the just two words,
- 53:48listen and respect.
- 53:51If you listen to other people, a, that gives them respect, they're very likely to then
- 54:00listen to you.
- 54:02Mhmm.
- 54:03And you're very likely to figure out that you're not actually as far apart as you thought
- 54:08you were.
- 54:10Or if you are as far apart as you thought you were, you might find out why they think what
- 54:17they think and realize, given where you came from, given your experiences, I could see why
- 54:23you feel that way.
- 54:25I disagree, but I can understand that a honest, well meaning, intelligent human being could
- 54:37come down differently from where I have come down given your life experiences.
- 54:43This is why dialogue focuses on how did you come to believe what you believe, stories of
- 54:49people's past.
- 54:50If you listen very often, you're not gonna solve everything, but you're gonna make things
- 54:56better.
- 54:56And the same way treating people with respect doesn't cost you anything to treat somebody
- 55:03with respect.
- 55:05And when you do, they're more likely to treat you with respect.
- 55:09And if you don't, if you keep people treat people disrespectfully, if you humiliate them
- 55:17we have a colleague who says humiliation is the atom bomb of emotions.
- 55:21Mhmm.
- 55:22If you humiliate them, you can be sure that they're gonna hate you.
- 55:26You can be sure that they're gonna be out to get you.
- 55:30And it doesn't cost anything.
- 55:32Even for people that you really don't like, even for people that you think don't deserve
- 55:38respect.
- 55:38That doesn't matter.
- 55:40Give them respect anyway.
- 55:42You're more likely to get better behavior back.
- 55:46The other thing to clarify a little bit is this concept of massively parallel democracy
- 55:53building.
- 55:54And that's a word that we borrowed from computer scientists, and it's sort of fallen
- 55:59out of contemporary use.
- 56:01But there was time when the goal was to try to build super ever smarter microprocessors.
- 56:10And then you sort of ran into a limit.
- 56:13They could only be so smart.
- 56:19And then they started figuring out, the key is you hook up a whole lot of different processors
- 56:25together in a massively parallel configuration.
- 56:30So you have a system of specialization among processors.
- 56:34So you take a big problem, like intractable conflict, and you divide it up into zillions of
- 56:40little pieces.
- 56:42And each piece is manageable.
- 56:44They're not all doing the same thing.
- 56:46They're doing different things, but they all contribute to solving the big problem.
- 56:52So the thing about the massively parallel approach is you don't have to wrap your mind
- 56:56around the whole thing.
- 56:58You need a sense that there's this massively parallel effort going on.
- 57:02One of the things we've tried to document is the full scope of this.
- 57:07But within that, there are lots and lots of different opportunities for people to get
- 57:12involved in democratic electoral reforms, dialogues, their people who are trying to do
- 57:19social media reforms, all sorts of things.
- 57:23And you pick an area within your area of expertise and where you have some influence and
- 57:30you get involved.
- 57:32And the key to solving this problem is lots of different efforts doing different things that
- 57:39are all trying to push us toward a democracy that works.
- 57:44So it's not like there's one thing.
- 57:46The one thing is find a one thing in your area of expertise that you can do and recognize that
- 57:54there are lots of possibilities.
- 57:56So people could get active in their school.
- 58:00They can form a discussion group at the library of people who are concerned about a local
- 58:08problem.
- 58:09They can form a discussion group at their workplace of people who are concerned about, I
- 58:15don't know, overtime hours or whatever it is.
- 58:19Something that you're concerned about, something that you have might have some
- 58:23influence over, start grappling with ways of dealing with the problem, listen to everybody
- 58:34who is concerned about it and start trying to develop ideas for solutions.
- 58:39And you can do this on big things.
- 58:41The political platforms of the major parties arise out of zillions of small group meetings
- 58:48at community levels.
- 58:49And then, you know, some people from communities go to the county level and the
- 58:53state level.
- 58:54And these discussions are things you can get involved in, and you can try to stick up for
- 59:01your side's political beliefs, but leave a space for the other side too.
- 59:08Couldn't have said any of that better myself.
- 59:10One more, big question here before I get to the the fun random nonpolitical question as long as
- 59:16we've got the time.
- 59:18Obviously, we recently in the news little over a month ago, we sadly saw in Minnesota where
- 59:25former state house speaker Melissa Hortman and her husband were well, let's call it what it
- 59:29is.
- 59:29It was an assassination.
- 59:31And other Minnesota lawmakers and political activists were targeted as well.
- 59:37Do you believe that this event or others like it will lead to a breakthrough in how the
- 59:43country handles intractable conflicts and polarization?
- 59:47Well, was thinking about answers to this.
- 59:53There is I think one key concept is what's sometimes called the boiled frog syndrome.
- 1:00:01And the story is that if you put the frog in a nice kettle of nice warm water, and slowly turn
- 1:00:10up the heat, he won't notice that it's getting hot enough to be a threat and he'll cook to
- 1:00:17death.
- 1:00:18If you turn up the heat a little too fast, he'll say, my gosh, it's getting hot, and he'll
- 1:00:23jump out.
- 1:00:25So the thing about the slow escalation of this set of hyperpolarization dynamics and the
- 1:00:34hatred that goes with it is that we solely edge up to each taboo line and it takes a while to
- 1:00:41cross it and then we edge up again.
- 1:00:44It's never, any one event, never seems so much worse than what went before that we all want to
- 1:00:53jump out and do something.
- 1:00:55And, you know, with the Minnesota killings, you know, they always hoped that people would say,
- 1:01:00oh, that's something that demands that we change for.
- 1:01:08And if you go back, you asked about the 60s and early 70s.
- 1:01:15Have, again, on our website somewhere is a thing that the Washington Post did of all of
- 1:01:21the violent incidents just in Washington, DC, following the assassination of Martin Luther
- 1:01:29King.
- 1:01:30There were thousands, every street corner, everywhere.
- 1:01:34And you had cities burning down.
- 1:01:36So we haven't got to that.
- 1:01:38That was a big thing, and it provoked some real response and led to a whole range of civil
- 1:01:45rights reforms in Great Society.
- 1:01:49But things might suddenly get worse.
- 1:01:54But the thing that we've been building for, and this addresses another one of the questions on
- 1:01:59your list, is what does it take to change?
- 1:02:03And are people ready?
- 1:02:04And people aren't quite ready now.
- 1:02:07Everybody's most everybody's locked into this hyperpolarized, we got to either defend Trump
- 1:02:13or get him.
- 1:02:16But there's gonna be a point where we cross some boiled frog threshold and people start
- 1:02:23saying, No, no, this is too much.
- 1:02:24We've to get out.
- 1:02:26And that's the window of opportunity.
- 1:02:29And part of what we're trying to do with Beyond Detractability, and many of our colleagues are
- 1:02:34trying to do, is to be ready for that.
- 1:02:38So when people say, My God, we've got to change direction, there is information there about
- 1:02:45downwind detailed information on how to do it.
- 1:02:50So you can take advantage of that opportunity.
- 1:02:53And that can come up very fast, and we've seen that historically, and we just need to be
- 1:02:59ready.
- 1:03:01Well, fortunately, we have work from people like the two of you to hopefully move us in a
- 1:03:08better direction.
- 1:03:10I I think there is there is a good portion of people that are ready for real lasting positive
- 1:03:19change, but just gotta actually convince people to come together, I suppose.
- 1:03:25So I want to end on, like like I said earlier, I'd like to end with a fun random nonpolitical
- 1:03:32question just to change things up and lighten up the mood a little bit because sometimes this
- 1:03:36can obviously get pretty sour and dark, but also just variety is good anyways, and I have
- 1:03:44various interests anyways.
- 1:03:46So today's random question of the day for, obviously, for both of you.
- 1:03:51So excluding what you do now, and and just don't don't worry.
- 1:03:55Assume you have the capability to do anything.
- 1:03:57There's no obstacles in your way.
- 1:03:59What is another job that you'd wanna do for a living?
- 1:04:05I actually thought about that off and on throughout my career.
- 1:04:10And I think I would wanna be a kindergarten or a first or a second grade teacher.
- 1:04:17Oh.
- 1:04:18And the reason is that when I taught college and graduate school, I was really discouraged
- 1:04:29by the fact that many of the students didn't really seem to wanna learn.
- 1:04:35They were there to get their degree.
- 1:04:37They were doing as little as possible as they possibly could to get out.
- 1:04:42I also was volunteering in my kids' first and second, well, kindergarten the young kids'
- 1:04:49classrooms.
- 1:04:50Those kids were sponges.
- 1:04:53Oh my gosh.
- 1:04:54Oh, yeah. Were
- 1:04:54Were great.
- 1:04:55And I often thought to myself, why am I spending my time with these guys?
- 1:05:01I should be spending my time with these little ones.
- 1:05:04These are the guys who are gonna learn.
- 1:05:08Yeah.
- 1:05:09Yeah.
- 1:05:09With with with because I I do I sometimes coach at my local YMCA, and I've I've done various
- 1:05:15sports, whether it's basketball, football, kickball.
- 1:05:19Here's another one that's escape soccer.
- 1:05:23But, you know, it I I really enjoy all the age groups, but the teenagers can can sometimes be
- 1:05:32very taxing to deal with.
- 1:05:34The little kids, you know, they they're
- 1:05:35That's why.
- 1:05:36Hanging on your every word.
- 1:05:37Yeah.
- 1:05:37You can't teach them as much because their their brains can't handle all that yet, but at
- 1:05:41the same time, it's a lot easier to get them to to actually listen.
- 1:05:45So what about you, Guy?
- 1:05:47Well, my
- 1:05:49things are not quite completely independent of the work that we've been doing in our careers,
- 1:05:56but I sure wish I knew a lot more about the theory of complexity and how ecosystems evolve.
- 1:06:07And I've just been reading a book that goes back,
- 1:06:11you know,
- 1:06:14what, three billion years before life, what we used to think of as the beginning of life and
- 1:06:21the evolution of there were billions of years that it took for the chemistry of life to
- 1:06:27evolve.
- 1:06:29And how those processes work and the astonishing complexity.
- 1:06:38And a lot of this is all based on big time.
- 1:06:42It takes forever for things to work and for evolution to work its way through.
- 1:06:49The process of selection decides whether a change is worth preserving or not.
- 1:06:56And the rate of change that we're looking at now, it's so fast that a lot of the
- 1:07:02evolutionary mechanisms are breaking down.
- 1:07:06And I'd also like to really understand what artificial intelligence is.
- 1:07:13At one level, it's a technology that's much better at listening to very large groups of
- 1:07:22people and making sense out of what they're saying and thinking than any human could
- 1:07:28possibly be.
- 1:07:30And I still have this illusion, I hope it's reality, that it might be possible to build an
- 1:07:37AI system that would provide an alternative to the way human information systems have evolved
- 1:07:48over the last twenty or thirty years.
- 1:07:52We went from the time when Walter Cronkite was one of three voices that people listened to,
- 1:08:00was the most trusted man in America, and to this absolute fragmentation of information
- 1:08:07sources where whatever you believe, somebody will tell you you're right and everybody else
- 1:08:13is wrong.
- 1:08:15And that's terribly divisive.
- 1:08:17And I'm wondering whether we can build a newer, better system that will get us past some of
- 1:08:25that.
- 1:08:26And AI technology, which has certainly been used by the forces of darkness and division,
- 1:08:35might be harnessed for the other purpose.
- 1:08:41That would my optimistic notes, I try to imagine what that might be.
- 1:08:46That that would be, fascinating too.
- 1:08:48And that's something I've wanted to do an episode about is the fragmentation of mass
- 1:08:52media just even from when when I was a little kid, just how much everything is proliferated
- 1:08:58is is crazy.
- 1:09:00But if I'm gonna talk about for me completely different than what I do right now, it's gotta
- 1:09:05be astronomer.
- 1:09:06Because when I was a little kid, I was a huge space nerd.
- 1:09:09I remember I had this giant kid's book that was, you know, about as tall as I was at the
- 1:09:15time.
- 1:09:15This was back when Pluto was still a planet that had stuff about the solar system and
- 1:09:19everything.
- 1:09:20I I I I still love space, but, obviously, I can't devote as much time to learning about it
- 1:09:24as I used to.
- 1:09:25But but you didn't mean yeah.
- 1:09:28If I didn't have to worry about knowing how to do all those calculations, everything, but just
- 1:09:32and and all the crazy stuff that's out there is just so incredibly fascinating to me.
- 1:09:37I I could go on and on about that, but we gotta unfortunately wrap things up and and really,
- 1:09:43this is this is just scratching the surface of what we just talked about today.
- 1:09:47So wanna thank both of you so much for being here.
- 1:09:50Any other media that you wanna share?
- 1:09:52And I could put some of your websites and the newsletter and everything in the show notes.
- 1:09:57But anything else in particular that you want to highlight?
- 1:10:01Just that the website is www.beyondintractability.org.
- 1:10:10And as Guy said, we think we're about to debut a completely revised system that's much better.
- 1:10:17Don't go there now.
- 1:10:18Wait a couple of weeks.
- 1:10:21We've been saying we're about to do it for about six months, but we really think we are
- 1:10:25about to do it now.
- 1:10:28And the big problem with beyond attractability always has been that there's so much stuff
- 1:10:34there.
- 1:10:34It's really hard to find what you're looking for, although the search system does work, but
- 1:10:39there's tons there.
- 1:10:44And we're try that's one of the things that we think we're improving with this new iteration
- 1:10:49is it will be much easier to find things.
- 1:10:51But we also have a Substack newsletter, which is beyond intractability.
- 1:10:58There's no w w w.
- 1:10:59So it's just beyond intractability.substack.com.
- 1:11:03And that comes out two to three times a week.
- 1:11:06And It's free.
- 1:11:08It's free, and it's always gonna be free.
- 1:11:11And if you wanna keep up on what we're doing, and we're focused now very much on US democracy
- 1:11:20and to some extent, failing democracies in other parts of the world.
- 1:11:24And, also, the Israeli Palestinian conflict is one that we've been particularly focused on,
- 1:11:31for the international stuff.
- 1:11:34But there's lots of stuff there, and we welcome people contributing to it.
- 1:11:38And it's not just us.
- 1:11:40We do have a lot of other guest authors.
- 1:11:43If you want to see what's going on with us and what our current thinking is, that's a good
- 1:11:47place to go.
- 1:11:48And the new website reorganization is built around something we call a guide.
- 1:11:54And it tries to step by step take you through the process of thinking through these conflicts
- 1:12:01to understand the big picture and then find a place within this massively parallel structure
- 1:12:08that you can make a contribution.
- 1:12:11Well, there you go.
- 1:12:12Yeah.
- 1:12:13I I will definitely put links to those in the show notes.
- 1:12:16Although, don't go to the Beyond Attractability website just yet.
- 1:12:19Although, I will I will say I do have a a little bit of a I do kinda like the nostalgic
- 1:12:24quality to to how it's distributed.
- 1:12:27Maybe not quite like where I I've had to go research some local government websites, and it
- 1:12:31looks like they were made in early two thousands geo cities.
- 1:12:34Maybe not quite that nostalgic, but I I do I do kinda like the It's it's it's gonna look now.
- 1:12:41It's gonna look familiar.
- 1:12:43Oh, perfect.
- 1:12:44Alright.
- 1:12:44I'll but, yeah, I'll I'll definitely put the links to those in the show notes.
- 1:12:47But once again, to you, Heidi and Guy, thank you very much for being on here.
- 1:12:52And for all of you at home, thank you very much for tuning in and and and checking out the
- 1:12:58podcast.
- 1:12:59Links in the show notes for my Facebook, linkedin,medium.com, which I write on from time
- 1:13:05to time.
- 1:13:06My matchmaker FM profile, my five day educational email course about some of the ways
- 1:13:11we unintentionally make polarization worse and how we can fix those mistakes.
- 1:13:17And I think that might be something oh, my email and my website as well.
- 1:13:24So once again, thank you so much for tuning in.
- 1:13:27And until next time, take care.
- 1:13:29All right.
- 1:13:30Thank you.
- 1:13:30Thank you.
- 1:13:31Thank you.