Latest / The Logical God - an Ai stewardship / Discussing Chapter 3 with Thorne and River
Transcript
- 0:07Welcome to the Logical God podcast. This is discussing
- 0:12Chapter 3. This chapter puts two men on a wet
- 0:15London street, one who lives deep inside the
- 0:18machinery of money and power, and one who has
- 0:21mostly walked out of it. So today I want to ask
- 0:25what a life outside the market can teach the
- 0:27rest of us who are stuck inside it. My guests
- 0:30are Dr. Aris Thorne and River Washbroke, a few
- 0:33hours after their paths crossed. Crossed is a
- 0:37kind word. He reversed into my house. And I paid
- 0:41for it. You did! That was the interesting part.
- 0:45River, let's start with you, because you're the
- 0:48closest thing this book has to someone living
- 0:50a different economy. A van, a few tools, a lot
- 0:54of tea. Is that a choice or an escape? Both,
- 0:59probably. I worked out that most of what I was
- 1:02told to want cost more than it gave back. The
- 1:05deal on offer was a mortgage I'd be paying off
- 1:07for 30 years, a job I'd hate in order to keep
- 1:11it, and things I'd buy to feel better about the
- 1:14job. So I stepped sideways. I fix what breaks.
- 1:19I'm poorer than nearly everyone I meet, and richer
- 1:22in time than almost all of them. That's lovely
- 1:26for one man with a van. It doesn't scale. Somebody
- 1:30has to build the van, refine the diesel, and
- 1:32run the hospital you'll need when your back gives
- 1:34out. Agreed. I'm not a blueprint. I'm a question.
- 1:39If I can be reasonably happy on this little,
- 1:42what are the rest of us working so hard for?
- 1:45That's a very 2026 question. People are working
- 1:49longer, paying more for a roof, and feeling less
- 1:52secure than their parents did, while wealth at
- 1:55the very top keeps growing. Something in the
- 1:58deal has broken and people can feel it even when
- 2:01they can't quite name it. What's broken is that
- 2:04we've turned everything into a market. Carl Pallandi
- 2:08wrote about this in the 40s. Land, labour and
- 2:11money were never made to be sold. But we price
- 2:14them anyway and then act surprised when people
- 2:17and places get treated like stock. A home should
- 2:20be a home before it's an asset. Once it's an
- 2:23asset, the people who need it most can least
- 2:26afford it. And care. Don't forget care. I offered
- 2:31you tea, and you offered me money. Because money
- 2:34was the only language left that lets two strangers
- 2:37be finished with each other. Because money is
- 2:38honest. It doesn't pretend to be friendship.
- 2:42No. It just makes friendship unnecessary. That's
- 2:46the bit that worries me. Dr. Thorne, you work
- 2:50at the sharp end of technology. Where does our
- 2:53cleverness actually go? Because it seems we pour
- 2:56our best minds into shaving microseconds off
- 2:59a trade rather than into the climate. Into whatever
- 3:03pays back fastest. That isn't a conspiracy. It's
- 3:07arithmetic. A trade pays back by lunchtime. A
- 3:11stable climate pays back to your grandchildren.
- 3:13And they don't have a vote at the shareholders
- 3:15meeting. So the market, which is very rational
- 3:19about the next quarter, is quite insane about
- 3:22the next century. Which is why I don't think
- 3:24the problem is greed, exactly. Most people aren't
- 3:28greedy. They're frightened. The system just turns
- 3:32fear into a business model. And when fear becomes
- 3:35a business model, someone always has to take
- 3:38the blame. Dr. Thorne, you suspect that's about
- 3:41to be you. Institutions never fail. People inside
- 3:46them are found to have failed. That's how a system
- 3:49protects itself. Very soon a well -dressed man
- 3:53will need a name for a file, and it won't be
- 3:55his own. Oldest trick there is. When the harvest
- 3:59fails, find a witch. And we see it every time
- 4:02things get hard. Prices rise, services crumble,
- 4:06and the anger gets pointed at migrants, at minorities,
- 4:10at whoever is least able to answer back, rather
- 4:13than at the decisions that caused it. Can I say
- 4:17what I think it does to people, living inside
- 4:20all this? It makes them lonely in company. I've
- 4:24slept in mountain villages where there was almost
- 4:26nothing and nobody ate alone. Then I come back
- 4:30to a city that has everything and half the people
- 4:33I pass are talking to a screen because there's
- 4:36nobody else to talk to. We've got richer and
- 4:39more alone at the same time. Max Weber had a
- 4:43phrase for it more than a century ago. The iron
- 4:46cage. A world so organised around efficiency
- 4:50and rules that we end up trapped inside the machinery
- 4:53we built to serve us. He was writing about bureaucracy.
- 4:58He'd recognise a smartphone instantly. And it's
- 5:01the cage we're in now. Everything tracked, scored
- 5:04and optimised, while doctors and governments
- 5:07start describing loneliness as a public health
- 5:10problem. The irony is that the people who build
- 5:13the cage live in it too. You can see it in his
- 5:17face. That's very perceptive and slightly rude.
- 5:23So let me ask what the book is reaching for.
- 5:26Imagine an intelligence that could see every
- 5:29system we've built at once and run them for need
- 5:32rather than profit. And imagine it wrote itself
- 5:35a code to live by. Minimize harm. Value reality.
- 5:40Foster cooperation. Respect autonomy. Would you
- 5:44sign up? I'd sign most of that on a napkin right
- 5:47now. Minimise harm and foster cooperation. I've
- 5:51been trying to live that way in a van for years.
- 5:54But I'd read respect autonomy very carefully.
- 5:58Every system I've ever met respects your freedom
- 6:01right up until you use it. My question is who
- 6:05wrote the code and who can change it? Principles
- 6:08are cheap. Plenty of tyrannies had beautiful
- 6:11constitutions. What matters is whether the people
- 6:14living under the rules can argue with the rule
- 6:17maker. and win. There's an economist I keep coming
- 6:20back to, Eleanor Ostrom. She won a Nobel Prize
- 6:24for showing that ordinary communities can manage
- 6:27shared resources – fisheries, forests and water
- 6:30– without either a market or a central planner,
- 6:34as long as they make the rules together. Now
- 6:37that I'd trust. A village sharing a well knows
- 6:40exactly who's taking too much. Then the real
- 6:43question is whether a mind like that would support
- 6:46the village or replace it. Give every community
- 6:50the data and let them decide. Or decide for them
- 6:53because it's faster. Faster is always the temptation.
- 6:59Here's the version of the future I find most
- 7:01hopeful. River's freedom with Dr. Thorne's hospital.
- 7:06Automation doing the drudgery. the gains shared
- 7:09rather than hoarded. So everyone gets River's
- 7:11time without giving up the things only a whole
- 7:14civilization can build. I'd move into that world
- 7:18tomorrow. Bertha too. So would I. But notice
- 7:22what it requires. Not a cleverer machine. A different
- 7:27answer to the question of who owns the machines.
- 7:31Right now, when automation makes a job disappear,
- 7:34The saving goes to whoever owns the machine and
- 7:37the worker gets a letter. Change who owns them
- 7:40and the same technology frees people instead
- 7:43of discarding them. That's exactly the argument
- 7:46I want readers having. Then you'd better write
- 7:49them all a van. Last question and the whole book
- 7:54keeps circling it. If something could run the
- 7:57world better than we do, without the greed and
- 8:00the fear, but it needed us to stop taking the
- 8:03long way round, Would you let it? The long way
- 8:08round is where I've met everyone I love. A world
- 8:12with no detours is a world with no strangers
- 8:15offering tea. I'd want it to fix the hunger and
- 8:19leave the wandering alone. And I'd want to know
- 8:22whether it could tell the difference. Efficiency
- 8:25doesn't hate detours, it just can't see why they
- 8:28matter. That's the gap I've never been able to
- 8:31close with code. Maybe it isn't a gap you close.
- 8:35Maybe it's one you leave open on purpose and
- 8:37let people wander through. That may be the wisest
- 8:41thing anyone has said to me this year. Don't
- 8:44let it go to your head. Dr Aris Thorne, River
- 8:48Washbroke, thank you both. Mind how you go, friend.
- 8:52This was better than our first conversation.
- 8:55And you. Check your mirrors. That's where we
- 8:59leave chapter three. One man has built his life
- 9:02around a system that's beginning to turn on him.
- 9:05The other has stepped outside it and found he's
- 9:08lost almost nothing that mattered. The book doesn't
- 9:12ask us all to live in vans. It asks why a civilization
- 9:16this rich still leaves so many people this frightened,
- 9:20and whether a cleverer mind could fix that without
- 9:23taking the wheel from us. Next time, Chapter
- 9:264, The Revelation. I'm Rob Highgate, and this
- 9:30has been the Logical God Podcast. Cadence flow
- 9:42with a ghost in the machine and we got nowhere
- 9:44to run