Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Special Episode: A Guide to Property Damage Claims Following a Natural Disaster
Transcript
- 0:00This program and the associated written materials are provided for informational purposes only
- 0:04and are not intended and must not be taken as legal advice on any particular set of facts
- 0:10or circumstances. You should not act or refrain from acting on the basis of any content included
- 0:15in this program without seeking legal or other professional advice on your specific matter.
- 0:20This program contains general information and may not reflect current legal developments
- 0:24or address your specific situation. This program and the associated written materials
- 0:29are not intended as a solicitation.
- 0:34Good afternoon everyone. Thank you for joining us during this devastating time. First and foremost,
- 0:43I just want to say that everyone on here, this great panel, all of our hearts break for those
- 0:50of you who have lost so much. Personally, my family and I have been in and out of hotels and
- 0:54evacuation, but I cannot imagine what you all must be going through during this terrible time.
- 1:02We are honestly here for you to help you get you to the next step because every day moving forward
- 1:11is a day closer to you rebuilding your life and getting your family back on your feet and hopefully
- 1:19your houses, your buildings, your businesses rebuilt. So we wanted to put this together to get you
- 1:26on the right direction. We know that right now it feels extremely hopeless and helpless and
- 1:32extremely confusing about what to do next. So we partnered with the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 1:39and put together a panel of true experts in this area of insurance claims and the best way to start
- 1:49it as well as attorneys that specialize in wildfire law to help guide you through this process.
- 1:58And the first thing we want to say is that every person on here, we've all agreed this is in no way
- 2:04whatsoever a solicitation. We are here to strictly provide information that can help you and your
- 2:10loved ones. And the great majority of home and business owners who are harmed by these wildfires
- 2:19do not need an attorney. In fact, most insurance issues do not require an attorney and are not
- 2:25intended to involve attorneys. And so we know there's a lot of misinformation out there and we
- 2:32want to set the record straight that we hope after this you have a guide and we will provide a hand
- 2:38book and a handout that'll help you secure what is yours, what you've paid for in a premium through
- 2:45your insurance in a step-by-step way so that you should never be paying a lawyer to recover what
- 2:50you need. We just want to make sure that you are all aware of that. And there's again misinformation
- 2:56from certain attorneys out there that are saying you need to hire an attorney to pursue your claim
- 3:01or a public adjuster. A lot of that is just not true at this stage and a lot of that you can
- 3:06handle on your own without having to pay a lawyer. So in this talk, we are, like I said,
- 3:14strictly talking about the insurance claim process as well as some wildfire legal issues that you
- 3:21may come upon. But we are not tax attorneys and there is a tax section with the Beverly Hills
- 3:29Bar Association that will soon be putting on a webinar like this to give you guidance and advice
- 3:37on what happens to your property that you lost in the tax implications of those. So we cannot
- 3:44give that tax advice. In fact, any advice we give you should consult an attorney. We are just trying
- 3:50to help you guide to get to that next place to help you rebuild and make your life better out of what
- 3:56you're going through. But there is a tax group that's going to give tax specific advice. So with that,
- 4:04this great panel made up of experts throughout the state who have handled so many of these
- 4:10type of tragic cases, I'm going to have them introduce themselves and then we're going to go
- 4:14through and discuss the step by step advice that we can give. With that said, I know many of you
- 4:21have lots and lots and lots of questions. We will be monitoring those questions and I will give them
- 4:28to this great panel as they come in. Obviously, we can't answer all of them and we know this is
- 4:34only supposed to be an hour, but we've all discussed and we want to give you our time. So we're
- 4:40happy to stay longer if need be to really make sure everyone leaves this in a better place
- 4:47than when they started because we know how terrible it is what you're all going through. So we are
- 4:51here for you. We're here to help. With that, our first speaker Amanda, if you can introduce yourself
- 4:57to our listeners. Good afternoon. My name is Amanda Riddle. I am an attorney in the Bay Area.
- 5:04I have been practicing law for 23 years and for the last 15 of those, I have represented
- 5:12victims and survivors of wildfires and explosions caused by utility companies. I've represented
- 5:20about 6,300 clients to date. I was one of the attorneys that negotiated the $13.5 billion
- 5:29settlement with Pacific Gas and Electric Company on behalf of Northern California wildfire victims.
- 5:35All right. David Paylitz, if you can introduce yourself. Hi, my name is David Paylitz and I'm
- 5:41a licensed attorney. I've been practicing in the state of California for 16 years. I've also
- 5:47been an insurance broker and agent for the last 12 years and I'm head of the Los Angeles office for
- 5:55Novus On-Writers and Novus Insurance Services. All right. Stacey? Hi, I'm Stacey Tucker. I have been
- 6:03a licensed attorney in California since 2001 and I'm actually admitted in five different states
- 6:09along up and down the West Coast. And my entire practice has been focused on insurance companies.
- 6:15And since the Tubbs Fire in 2017, I've been representing insurers against insurance companies
- 6:22for issues that arise in payments for wildfire damage. And as Dan accurately said, at this early
- 6:33on, you don't need an attorney. It's later on where issues may arise and we'll walk through that as
- 6:40well. All right. And John Torbett? Hi, my name is John Torbett. I'm an attorney here in Los Angeles.
- 6:46I've been practicing for almost 30 years now. One of my specialties is real property litigation.
- 6:53And within that, I specialize in inverse condemnation. I've actually taken one of these cases to a
- 7:00trial, to verdict, which is kind of unusual because they don't tend to go to trial.
- 7:05Well, the inverse condemnation would apply if somebody like Southern California Edison,
- 7:10for example, has liability in this case. I worked on about 18 or 19 cases in the Woolsey Fire,
- 7:17which was the Malibu Fire that broke out in November of 2018. I worked with Dan Kramer and we
- 7:24took a case, was a big case. We opted out of what they called the Mediation Protocol and
- 7:29we're ready for, we had a liability trial set in August of last year and we ended up settling it
- 7:34on the proverbial courthouse steps. So I have experience with wildfires and lots of experience
- 7:41with inverse condemnation. Yes. And like I said, I'm Dan Kramer. I'm a trial lawyer here in Westwood,
- 7:47California with Kramer trial lawyers. And with that, let's get to what everyone here wants to know.
- 7:54Amanda, let's start with you to get an overview of this step-by-step process that these people can
- 8:00start. Sure. So first of all, I want to let you know that I have all my notes on another screen
- 8:06over here. So if I'm looking back and forth, that's why. So my perspective as I shared is from
- 8:12representing clients against utilities who have caused fires and explosions. I don't handle
- 8:21insurance claims. I don't sue insurance companies like Stacy does, but rather I see the insurance
- 8:28claim file later as part of the case against the utilities. So in my cases, I've represented
- 8:36homeowners, renters, adults, children, businesses, families of people who perished in the fire.
- 8:45And through that, I've handled thousands of cases with destroyed homes, with damaged properties. So
- 8:53I've seen thousands of insurance files following wildfires. And so that's where my perspective and
- 8:59my knowledge comes from. Through that, I've learned an awful lot about insurance claims that we want
- 9:06to share with you today. So question number one that I get a lot is, should I even bother filing
- 9:13an insurance claim? People are concerned that if they file an insurance claim, their insurance
- 9:20is going to be canceled, their premiums are going to go up. Stacy's going to address later the
- 9:27cancellation issue. But the answer is yes, if you have insurance and you suffered a loss,
- 9:35damage, destruction of your property, of your business in these fires, yes, you should file
- 9:42an insurance claim. You pay premiums so that that insurance is available when you need it.
- 9:48And this is one of those times that you need it. You are going to need money to recover from this
- 9:57fire and your insurance coverage is the fastest way that you're going to get a good sum of money
- 10:04in your hands. So yes, we do recommend that you go ahead and file an insurance claim. If you have
- 10:10suffered a loss and you have an insurance policy. So how do you file an insurance claim?
- 10:17A lot of you have done that already. So I may be a couple of days behind what you've already done,
- 10:25but for those who have not yet, you can call your insurance broker that you got your insurance policy
- 10:33through. You can call the insurance company directly. You can go to their website. You can,
- 10:40a lot of the times, add a claim on your app. So there are numerous ways to locate your
- 10:45insurance company. File an insurance claim under any and all policies you may have. Homeowners,
- 10:53business, auto, boat, any specialty insurances that you have, because sometimes insurance policies
- 11:03have uncommon coverages in them and you never know where you're going to find coverage. We see a lot
- 11:10of times where students, for instance, are no longer living at home, but they're still covered by
- 11:18their insurance policy of their parents or someone has recently moved and their old insurance policy
- 11:26still covers them for the next 30 days, something like that. So any and all insurance policies that
- 11:32you have, you should open claims under. It is better to have an open claim and not need it than to,
- 11:41you know, not have the claim open when you do need it. Make sure your insurance company,
- 11:48once you are assigned to a claims rep, make sure your insurance company has all your current contact
- 11:55information, your phone number, your email address. If you are displaced from your home and you know
- 12:02that that mailing address is not going to work for you, it's a good idea to open a post office box,
- 12:08another address that you're going to have consistently over the next couple of years
- 12:13so that your insurance company can reach you. Find out the name of your claims representative,
- 12:20get their contact information, get their email, get their phone number. That is your go-to person.
- 12:26When you do get your claims representative assigned to you, go over some basic procedures with them,
- 12:33ask them how is this claim going to work, what timelines do I have, what information and documents
- 12:41do you generally require. Obviously as time goes on, you'll have that question more specifically,
- 12:48but get a general understanding with your claims rep of what the questions that you
- 12:55need to get answered are. It is a very good idea to confirm all of your communications
- 13:02with your insurance company in writing. Email is fine, you don't need to do snail mail.
- 13:10The law requires your insurance company to respond to any questions that you have about your policy
- 13:19within 15 days. Sorry Amanda, on that note, when these people are calling their broker or their
- 13:26carrier, should they be asking for an email address to communicate as well right off the bat?
- 13:31Yes, absolutely. Especially if you're displaced, it's a little hard right now for people to be
- 13:37going to a post office, but most people hopefully they did take their phone, their laptop, and so
- 13:44email is a really good form of communication. Get the email address for your claims representative
- 13:50and it's a good way for you to communicate with them. I think I was saying the law requires
- 13:58the insurance company to respond to you within 15 days of your requests. If you have that request
- 14:06made in writing that starts that 15 days ticking, there's no question about whether you made the
- 14:14request and there's no misunderstandings. So that's kind of the how you start with an insurance claim.
- 14:23Ask your insurance claims representative to provide a copy of your policy, your full insurance
- 14:29policy, including your declarations page. So the policy is the full contract,
- 14:35the declarations page is kind of a one pager that summarizes all of the
- 14:42coverages you have. How much do you have for rebuilding your home? How much do you have for
- 14:47contents? So get your policy, your declarations page, and all of this is in the written materials
- 14:55that we're providing to you so you don't have to memorize everything I'm saying. Also ask for
- 15:02copies of any writers or endorsements. Writers and endorsements are add-ons that people may have
- 15:08purchased in addition to the standard insurance policy. A lot of people will get add-ons or
- 15:15writers and endorsements for instance if they've got a large jewelry collection, an art collection,
- 15:22something that goes beyond the value of the general policy. So get the policy, get the
- 15:28policy, get the declarations page, get all writers, and get all endorsements. Again that 15-day rule
- 15:36applies. If you make that request to your insurance company they have to provide you those documents
- 15:43within 15 days. When you get those documents, read them. Is this the coverage that you expected?
- 15:52Do you have any questions? What are your limits? These are things that you can get from those
- 15:58documents and then if you have questions you should contact your claims representative, contact your
- 16:05insurance broker so that you can ask them you know what does this mean. I see that I've got
- 16:12rebuild coverage here but I also had something called ERC which is extended replacement coverage.
- 16:19What does that mean? How does that apply? So make sure you read your policy and all of the
- 16:26associated documents when you get them. Understand what your coverage is. Understand what the
- 16:32procedures are that you need to follow and ask your claims rep or your insurance broker if you
- 16:39have any questions. Sorry Amanda on this written communication I'm seeing some good questions
- 16:47about this. Farmers for example is asking to communicate via their their own web portal.
- 16:52It's obviously in farmers control should that be a concern because they control the portal.
- 16:58Should the policyholder ask for different ways to communicate? So whatever way you communicate
- 17:05with them in writing you want to have a record of it. I've not used the the farmers portal. If it is
- 17:13you know a lot of doctor portals will have the messages going back and forth and afterwards
- 17:20you can't see the past message. So if the portal allows you to have a record of the messages
- 17:28that would be fine to use. If it doesn't if it's just they disappear kind of like Snapchat I guess
- 17:36they disappear. I'm too old to use that but if they disappear then you want to have a record. So
- 17:42if you want to use that portal and you're concerned about whether or not there'll be a record if you
- 17:51do it through your phone screenshot the message that you're sending screenshot both ways maybe
- 18:01make a folder in your phone where you can store all of those. So I don't have a problem with using
- 18:07their portal. I want you to just make sure that you have a record of the communications so that
- 18:14there's no confusion and so that if there are any arguments later about what coverage you have,
- 18:21what information you were given, what questions you have that you have a record of that.
- 18:28So your insurance policy is a contract. When you bought that insurance policy you entered
- 18:36into a contract with your insurance company. You pay premiums in as part of that contract
- 18:42and when you need coverage they have to give you something in return. So under California law if
- 18:50you are in a contract with somebody they have to treat you in good faith and they have to treat you
- 18:55fairly. They are not your insurance company your insurance claim rap claims rap they often push back
- 19:03they often act as if they're your adversary. Do not let them forget that you have a contract with
- 19:11them they must treat you in good faith and they must treat you fairly. Do not let them forget that.
- 19:19Okay let's talk about what kinds of coverage you may see in your insurance policy. So there are
- 19:27obviously different policies but focusing on homeowners policies. Coverage A generally this
- 19:35is what it looks like California's fair plan is different that's more lumped together. Stacey's
- 19:40more of an expert on that than I am. Stacey and Dave have seen a lot of those policies. But on a
- 19:48farmer's state farm all state chub those kinds of insurance policies homeowners they're generally
- 19:58going to have four main categories. The first is dwelling which is your primary structure your
- 20:05house on your property. The second coverage B is other structures detached garage septic system
- 20:17um sheds um uh you know gazebos hot tubs pools sometimes come under other structures. So ask
- 20:28your claims rap which which of your structures make sure they're aware of all structures on your
- 20:35property which go under the other structures coverage which go under the dwelling coverage.
- 20:40Uh coverage C is personal property your contents your clothes your furniture your books your home
- 20:50goods um I generally explain it to clients as if your house is a dollhouse and you tip it upside
- 20:56down everything that falls out is the personal property everything that stays is called real
- 21:01property. Um so coverage C is generally your contents. Coverage D is the one most of you
- 21:09were dealing with right now which is loss of use also known as additional living expenses.
- 21:17That is the coverage for those additional expenses that you are facing because you are
- 21:24displaced from your home. You're having to eat out in restaurants because you don't have your
- 21:30kitchen to cook in. You're having to stay in hotels like Dan mentioned because you are not
- 21:36able to stay in your home. So these loss of use coverage additional living expense coverage
- 21:43covers those additional expenses that you would not have had to incur if you were in your home.
- 21:51Then they're often um on uh homeowners policy some extra coverage uh you've got building
- 21:59and code and permit upgrades so if you are rebuilding your home um you're going to have
- 22:07permit costs you're going to have code upgrades the the cities and the counties often do not let
- 22:13you build the home you already had because codes have changed since so you've got uh additional
- 22:20coverage to cover um increased costs because of code upgrades. You have extended replacement
- 22:27coverage a lot of times in homeowners policy which is an additional amount if you choose to rebuild
- 22:33they will sometimes go up another 50% on the dwelling coverage to cover that real but rebuild
- 22:40cost and then a lot of the time you'll have landscaping coverage your trees your shrubs your um
- 22:47a lot of the time the landscaping also covers hardscape so your uh pathways your your decks that
- 22:55type of thing so talk to your when you look at your policy figure out you know if it covers all of
- 23:02those coverages if you have questions about which parts of your property fall under which of those
- 23:09coverages um again as I said sometimes hardscape and um decks are sometimes under coverage be
- 23:17other structures sometimes they're under the landscaping coverage so talk to your claims
- 23:22rep about where those fall excuse me um so that's homeowners coverage renters if you have renters
- 23:32insurance generally only have um c and d which is the personal property contents coverage and the
- 23:41loss of use additional expenses coverage sorry I'm already losing my voice
- 23:46so renters take a look at your policies again you'll probably have coverage for your contents
- 23:57and you'll have coverage for your additional living expenses um as I said California fair plan
- 24:03is different so review your policy uh and Stacy and Dave will have more information on that
- 24:10uh moving to what you're most immediately dealing with like I said is your loss of use
- 24:19and additional living expenses so that is again the the costs that you are facing because you're
- 24:26displaced from your home um the law requires that in the event of a total loss of your home so if
- 24:34your home was destroyed that your insurance company is required to pay an advance of four months at
- 24:42least four months of those displacement expenses um upon your request so if you have not if you've
- 24:51lost your home and you have not already received or being have been told that your four months
- 24:57advance um loss of use payment is on the way contact your claims representative and ask for that you
- 25:04are entitled to four months in advance if you have lost your home find out from your claims
- 25:11representative what kind of additional living expenses your insurance carrier covers is it
- 25:18hotels um is there a cost limit on those hotels um is it meals is there a cost limit on those meals
- 25:29find out what what your your coverage will cover so that you're not incurring expenses and finding
- 25:36out later the hard way that they're not covered track your expenses so even though your insurance
- 25:44company will give you a four months payment in advance in a lot of cases they may later say
- 25:51we want you to document how that money was spent so get receipts itemized receipts don't not just
- 26:00that charge slip you want itemized receipts that show what you spent your money on um remember that
- 26:07a lot of the time with receipts i've i've seen this when i see the receipts years later in
- 26:13litigation cases especially if the receipts are those carbon kind with the yellow backing the ink
- 26:20fades and rubs off so make sure you either photocopy take a photograph on your phone and again create
- 26:30maybe a folder of all of your receipts in your phone um or at very least write a note at the top
- 26:37in pen that's not going to fade date amount and what you spent it on because i see a lot of those
- 26:43receipts when they're you know couple years old and we're dealing with um you know claims we're
- 26:49dealing with litigation and the ink has faded off of those receipts sorry amanda we have some a lot
- 26:55of questions on this four month advanced uh and so one of the one of the questions we're having is
- 27:01for the four months advanced um does the home have to be completely destroyed or is it enough to just
- 27:05be rendered unavailable the language says total loss and so um that's going to be defined by the
- 27:13insurance company but that's a good question i was wondering that maybe stacey and dav you know the
- 27:18answer is total loss um a destruction of the home or is it if the insurance company deems the home
- 27:26uninhabitable at least for a given amount of time go ahead david i was going to say
- 27:35if the home is uninhabitable that is akin to a total loss so you could definitely make that
- 27:42argument that if if i can't come back to my home it is unlivable um for the foreseeable future then
- 27:50you have a very good argument that it is a total loss and they should under the state of emergency
- 27:55minimums they should advance you the four months and then how and then how are they calculated if
- 28:01it is in advance so you don't know what you're gonna have to spend or how much you're gonna have to
- 28:05spend for the next three months what is the calculation seeing with me yeah so pretty much
- 28:14you have a home whether it's a thousand square feet two thousand square feet you know different
- 28:20you what you take is the fair market value of what your home would be if you were to rent that type
- 28:27of home and you're able to use that number as a number for the advancement for your expenses so uh
- 28:35just using like a round number if you had a two thousand square foot home and the fair market rental
- 28:40value is ten thousand dollars a month then you should be entitled for advancement of at least
- 28:46four months so forty thousand dollars now obviously um you want to look at your limits um because uh
- 28:55some people don't have as much loss of use as other people so you want to make sure that even
- 29:00if you're getting that advance that it's that it's in line because you are going to be capped at some
- 29:04point um so make sure that whatever you're asking for is reasonable it's enough to cover you but
- 29:11also be aware that there will be a limit at some point and that's a good point um so i think dave
- 29:18said two things that i want to just confirm everyone heard first um on the definition of total loss
- 29:25it may be a discussion and you may have to make an argument of my house was not destroyed it was
- 29:32not burned down but it has been deemed uninhabitable and therefore it is a total loss i'm going to be
- 29:38displaced for a minimum of four to six months and so you're you've got a good argument that they should
- 29:45be paying you out that four months um shoot i forgot this the second thing that you just said that i
- 29:53wanted to clarify apologies um it'll come back to me at some point say that again so market value uh
- 30:02or uh maybe the cap on how much yes thank you was the cap thank you very much so sometimes when you
- 30:09look at your loss of use coverage sometimes there is a monetary cap and sometimes there is a time cap
- 30:18um and so sometimes it'll say up to three years or sometimes it'll say up to x number of dollars
- 30:26sometimes it will say as incurred which means the number the amount of money that you incur in
- 30:34additional living expenses will be covered as incurred is a very vague term so that is something
- 30:40you should be discussing with your claims representative to understand what that means
- 30:45and what the parameters are on what you're allowed to incur so we're getting some of these other
- 30:51questions uh you some families have loss of use in their insurance policy but then they go live with
- 30:57a loved one for x amount of months can they still claim the loss of use that they would they be
- 31:02entitled to that they should be um i've had a lot of clients at least justify that by saying i'm
- 31:12living with a loved one i'm contributing to utilities i'm contributing to groceries that type
- 31:18of thing you should be entitled to your loss of use sometimes again that is a discussion
- 31:25and you need to talk about what expenses you will be incurring even if you are living with a family
- 31:30member and amanda can i jump in not just for a second on that one thing a good strategy in those
- 31:37situations is to sign a rental agreement with the um relative that you're living with and then you
- 31:44provide it to the insurance company and that demonstrates what you're what you are incurring
- 31:50so that you can clearly and unequivocally have proof of the situation that you're in
- 31:57it's great advice and and one thing that i would just add to that is that make sure
- 32:03that even if you get in advance which they're they must give to you in in a short fashion
- 32:10is you need to make sure you keep that a ledger of all of your expenses because remember that
- 32:15after this four months advance you're going to need to show that if you want supplemental uh money
- 32:22that you're going to have to provide a list of all your expenses including whatever rent
- 32:27uh whatever you know furniture costs of food travel things like that so just because you got
- 32:34your four months well you're not entitled to that next chunk of change unless you start showing proof
- 32:40of all the use so make sure that no matter what is you start keeping track of everything from day one
- 32:47yeah and so so keep all copies of your receipts um like i said sometimes they fade so taking a photo
- 32:55of the receipt making a photocopy of the receipt i had a former client um from the campfire place
- 33:03tell me today that he used an app called Expensify Ex P E N S I F Y and he used that to track all of
- 33:14his displacement expenses and to store pictures of his receipts um so there are apps out of out
- 33:22there that you can use um but stay organized uh make sure you have an accounting um if you even
- 33:30if you were normally organized remember that you've just you've just gone through and you
- 33:34are continuing to go through a traumatic and we just put that in the in the chat the link to that
- 33:39website oh wonderful Expensify I haven't I haven't looked at it much but a client told me this morning
- 33:44um that he found it very useful after the campfire so um but stay organized um organizational skills
- 33:53may not be um as as good now as as they were because you're you're juggling so many things so
- 34:00a filing system is great different envelopes for different expenses different folders for
- 34:06different expensive but as as Dave just said whatever you do make sure you are tracking those
- 34:12expenses and keeping the backup documentation so that when your insurance company comes along later
- 34:19and says um we need to see what you've spent this money on in order to determine whether or not you
- 34:25get additional additional loss of use you you have that information um I'm going to move on to
- 34:34to personal property um coverage Dan do we have any other ALE questions that you want to pop in
- 34:41before I do that um no go ahead but but I may come back to a couple but go ahead okay so um
- 34:49additional living expenses loss of use that's what you're really facing right now the next thing
- 34:55that you're going to start doing is working on your property claims I'm going to focus on personal
- 35:01property your contents and then I'm going to toss to Dave and a little bit to talk about your real
- 35:06property which is your your dwelling in your your property your land in the event again
- 35:13of a total loss and again that term total loss may be a discussion um in the event of a total loss
- 35:22resulting from a state of emergency which we have we have here the governor has declared a state of
- 35:27emergency your insurance company must offer you payment for your personal property loss of no
- 35:37less than 30 percent of your policy limit for your dwelling as long as your home was furnished at
- 35:47the time of the loss and in the amount of no more than $250,000 so let me break that down
- 35:54now if you lost your home and it was furnished at the time of the fire um your insurance company
- 36:04has to give you 30 percent for your personal property of your dwelling a coverage so if your
- 36:12dwelling a coverage is I'm going to use round numbers a million dollars your insurance company
- 36:19has to know I'm not going to use a million dollars because it's over the $250,000 cap if your dwelling
- 36:25a coverage is $500,000 your insurance company needs to pay you and you've totally lost your home and
- 36:33your home was furnished at the time your insurance company needs to pay you 30 percent of that $500,000
- 36:40which is 150 grand towards your personal property loss right up front so that's another thing you
- 36:48ask your claims representative I've lost my home my home was furnished at the time of the fire
- 36:56and I want my 30 percent payment 30 percent of my amount of dwelling a it's a little bit tricky
- 37:04so talk that one through with your insurance rep um if your insurance company I will tell you
- 37:13I will tell you in sorry I mean I mean before you go there just we do have a good question it's just um
- 37:18does the personal property 30 percent change if there was a secondary structure like a small
- 37:23studio on the property as well both the total loss it's it's no well um I'm not quite sure of the
- 37:32question the question is that I believe the answer is the total property so that's what I thought right
- 37:39personal property in the dwelling and personal property in the other structures are all included
- 37:44under the person the same personal property clap and that 30 percent covers all of them it's not
- 37:5130 percent for what was in my house and 30 percent what was in my shed if that's the question yes I
- 37:56think that's right okay um your insurance company um may pay in in recent fires probably starting in
- 38:08the 2015 um or the 2017 wine country fires insurance companies are more quickly paying out 75 percent
- 38:20to 100 percent of your personal property uh coverage they're saying the house was destroyed
- 38:27we're just going to pay out the full amount um not all of them are though so if your insurance
- 38:33company is going to require you to do a personal property inventory which is an inventory of
- 38:41everything was in your house the condition it was in and um the fair market value of that property
- 38:50at the time of the fire you um the the the law says that if it is impractical for you to list
- 39:01every single item um you know every chair every sweater every coat that you can group your personal
- 39:11property items into categories if it is too difficult so you can say clothes x dollars
- 39:20furniture in the live you know probably break it down by room furniture in the living room x
- 39:25dollars so you can group by categories if your insurance company is going to require a personal
- 39:32property inventory um if you have to make an itemized personal property inventory if you are
- 39:41required to go item by item um or that's something that you feel you need because you want to preserve
- 39:48a list of everything you lost there are a lot of tips that we have to help you do that so
- 39:53um and I will caution you personal property inventories creating them is very very emotionally
- 40:02taxing this whole process of course is emotionally taxing but when you are sitting there making a
- 40:08list of everything that you lost in your home it can be very emotionally taxing um it can trigger a
- 40:15lot of your trauma so pace yourself take breaks you don't need to do this all at once you don't
- 40:20need to do any of this all at once you need to pace yourself through this process because you're
- 40:25you're running a marathon here not a sprint so some tips on creating an itemized personal property
- 40:33list go room by room in your house living room kitchen family room visualize that room
- 40:43visualize the property that was in that room talk to your family your friends about each
- 40:50room so that you can work together to remember what was in that room think about what was in the
- 40:56drawers think about what was in the cupboards in the closets in each room create a separate list
- 41:04for each room and I find um clients have the most success when they do that on a computer so if you
- 41:12have access to excel or any other kind of spreadsheet program it's a really good way to make your
- 41:20personal property list you make a workbook for the entire personal property and then you make a
- 41:26separate worksheet tab family room living room kitchen for each room that way you can go back
- 41:35to the list each time you remember something a lot of the time when you're creating your personal
- 41:40property unfortunately you won't remember an item until two months later when you go to need it and
- 41:47then you'll remember oh shoot I lost that you can go back to that individual room list on the excel
- 41:54worksheet and add it in there the other reason that a spreadsheet or excel list is a good one is
- 42:01because you can add up the values of your property that you lost more easily you can sum those properties
- 42:09if you don't have access to excel you can do it on paper a separate sheet or sheets maybe in a binder
- 42:17with tabs something to keep you organized and keep those rooms separate so that you can keep going back
- 42:23as a man a couple questions I'm getting a lot of these questions on the personal property
- 42:27yeah the first one is deals with sort of smoke damage in toxins and if there's not a total loss
- 42:34of the personal property but toxins in the first drapes sheets whatever they're deemed unusable
- 42:41as well as you know due to smoke damage can you still claim that as a loss of personal property
- 42:47I would I would definitely put that as as part of your claim with these wildfires the
- 42:56level of smoke damage especially in fabric items that can't be wiped clean is going to be
- 43:03excessive I would not your your couch is destroyed even if it was not burned your drapes are destroyed
- 43:11your clothes are destroyed even if they were not burned they have absorbed huge amounts of smoke
- 43:18and so again I think that's something you're going to you may be in a push and pull with your
- 43:23insurance company on but I would absolutely claim that even if the property was not burned that it
- 43:31is destroyed beyond use because it is so damaged from this a few more a lot of people are asking
- 43:37questions about this personal property so one just again just to I know you touched on it but
- 43:43what proof exactly can the insurer require when it is a total loss depends on the policy the policy
- 43:50is going to require that or lay out those requirements personal property losses but I
- 43:57actually you know that's probably my next my next point actually personal property losses are much
- 44:03tougher than rebuild loss because most people don't have pictures of all of their stuff but
- 44:11a good place to look and frankly a lot of you unfortunately lost your homes right after Christmas
- 44:18and so a lot of the stuff that you lost may have been new so your Amazon account your online receipts
- 44:26for you know online ordering if you got Christmas presents from family members or friends ask them
- 44:35if they have the receipt if they have you know that in their Amazon that type of thing so you've
- 44:41got documents to show the date of purchase you've got documents to show the purchase price and
- 44:47and here's a sorry just a few interest in the interest of time so a couple more is my insurer
- 44:53has offered 75% of my personal property coverage without proof is this a good option in some
- 45:00situations for some people I see you shaking or sorry go ahead sorry for some people it is a very
- 45:06good option um for some people they sorry my blinds are closing behind me um for some people
- 45:15that's a very good option mainly because making a personal property inventory is very difficult
- 45:22and very time consuming and very taxing some people do not want to be burdened with making a full list
- 45:28of everything in their house they want to take the 75 percent it is an option I will tell you
- 45:35that um you're then leaving 25 percent on the table because you're only getting 75 percent not the
- 45:41full 100 percent I will also tell you that if um which John is going to talk about if there is a
- 45:48later lawsuit against um a whoever caused these fires let's put it that way for now um then
- 45:58you're going to still have to prove up those personal property losses and so if that's something
- 46:02that's in your mind as potential for the future you're better off doing the personal property
- 46:07inventory now and having it while things are fresh in your mind than waiting three years and having
- 46:12to do that but for some people I have a lot of clients who take the 75 percent and say I do not
- 46:19want to go through the burden of taking of making a personal property inventory and that is absolutely
- 46:25the right decision if that works for you and a couple questions on this 30 percent um is the 30
- 46:30percent state minimum of your personal property coverage I think under is that coverage C or coverage
- 46:37of your dwelling coverage A your dwelling coverage A so if your dwelling coverage A is $500,000 they
- 46:44have to give you 30 percent of that and it doesn't take it out of your dwelling A it takes it out of
- 46:51your your coverage C but that's where the calculation comes from so it's $500,000 in dwelling A they
- 47:00give you 150,000 but it comes out of your coverage C that's where the money comes out of it's just
- 47:06that's how they come up with the calculation and then does the 30 percent of personal property
- 47:10apply with California fair plan I don't know Stacy that's a Stacy Stacy indeed it does it does yes
- 47:18also one thing to note with all of these insurance policies you need to read carefully to see if you
- 47:23have coverage for actual cash value or replacement value if you have actual cash value then they will
- 47:31take depreciation based on the age and condition of your goods which means you get maybe 50 cents on
- 47:37the dollar so check your policies see which type of coverage you have because it can make a huge
- 47:44difference well just thought can you explain quickly replacement value how it would be different
- 47:49replacement value is what it would cost for you to go out and buy a new one your house is gone you
- 47:53need to buy a new tv you give them the receipt for the tv you just bought at Costco they pay it
- 47:58it actual cash value is very different they look they ask you how old was your tv when you
- 48:07when it burned let's say you bought your tv five years ago okay they then run it through a depreciation
- 48:13program and deduct the depreciation for that to determine how much they think you should get so if
- 48:20you paid a hundred if you if you paid a thousand dollars five years ago what is that worth now it's
- 48:29probably five or six hundred dollars and then our our appliances such as water heaters and all that
- 48:35refrigerate is that part of personal property that should be part of dwelling a because it's
- 48:40attached anything that's attached to your house physically is considered coverage a refrigerator
- 48:48those be usually yes generally a yeah can i just say one thing go ahead i'm sorry because
- 48:59we haven't gotten to the litigation part but obviously defendants if in fact there will be
- 49:04a defendant in these cases um that they're they're definitely going to want to see as much detail as
- 49:10possible so as difficult as it as it is in your current circumstance you know we use the insurance
- 49:17claim file all the time in litigation and you do the best you can obviously can only inventory what
- 49:22you what you you know can remember and you can only come up with the receipts that you have or any
- 49:28kind of evidence of what you you spent to buy the personal property but in in regard to perspective
- 49:34litigation it is definitely in your best interest to document that as best you can so and going back
- 49:43to the fair market value stacey um some people are asking what's the what's the best way to approach
- 49:48it is it is it a negotiation with the carrier if it's cash value to run it through like a fair
- 49:54market value calculator how do you negotiate that or do you have to accept what they say
- 49:59it you can absolutely push back but it is very difficult this is one of the areas where people
- 50:06experience the most frustrations with their insurer and as we said at the start of your claim
- 50:13there's no reason to assume you're going to have problems as you move forward if you do start to
- 50:18have problems that is when you may want to consider talking with a public adjuster because
- 50:23they have a lot more experience in negotiating and pushing back on these things than you individually do
- 50:29and they may be able to get you a better deal and stacey get just i know we're touching on it
- 50:35we've all heard the term public adjuster but can you just explain to us what that means a public
- 50:40adjuster is somebody who puts themselves out into the world they're trained they take courses
- 50:49they're certified by the state to represent you in an insurance claim um i personally don't recommend
- 50:57starting out with one from the get go because i don't think you need them um most people are going
- 51:02to very quickly get their claims paid and move on with their lives if that is not the experience
- 51:08you're having over the course of the next few months that's when you may want to consider
- 51:14retaining a public adjuster who represents you with the insurance company and handles it all
- 51:20for you so that you don't have to deal with the insurance company they charge a percentage of what
- 51:26they are able to collect for you so if you do choose to get a public adjuster and you do it
- 51:33later on in your claim you'll want to make sure that your agreement with them only covers future
- 51:38money that they're able to collect for you and not what you were already paid through your own
- 51:42efforts so so what should our listener i mean what what's the best caution here because a lot of
- 51:47things are being thrown at all of our these people who are going through this terrible situation
- 51:51it's confusing they have a lot going on they haven't slept people are hitting them up from attorneys
- 51:56to public adjusters what's your best advice on what to stay away from or be careful with
- 52:02and what do they want to look for if they're going to go down that path stay away from anyone who's
- 52:07trying to get you to hire them right now you are overwhelmed you are trying to manage this
- 52:14hour by hour and anybody who's trying to take advantage of you in that time period is not
- 52:20somebody you probably want to be working with so the public adjusters and attorneys who are
- 52:24flocking around hotels try try and evacuation sites trying to gin up clients the very fact
- 52:31that they're doing that is a good notification that they're probably not people you want to be
- 52:37working with i don't want to push any particular companies but do a google search of public
- 52:46adjusters in your area there are the the well-known ones will quickly come up and you can call you
- 52:55can talk to them if and when you start running into issues you don't need help right away um
- 53:02usually a public adjuster it used to be five percent of the money they obtained for you they
- 53:07would keep as their fee i'm hearing it's gone up in some cases to 15 to 25 percent now which
- 53:13that's a huge amount of your claim you need that to rebuild you don't need to be paying it to your
- 53:18public adjust this and this really is it sounds like to be should be a last resort situation because
- 53:23hopefully i mean 90 plus claims should just be paid out if not more and this is really one of the
- 53:29big reasons we want to put this on so quickly because we are all seeing the misinformation
- 53:34out there i'm seeing attorneys promise great results huge you know we're going to recover
- 53:39millions whatever they're saying be very very very weary of people promising you automatic
- 53:45paydays we're guaranteeing things and really pushing truly what scares me and this is why
- 53:51we want to get this information out there is that's going to take away from your rightful claim
- 53:55that you would have gotten on your own so be very very careful please and tell your friends
- 53:59be very careful anyone promising things and then turn around take a percentage of your claim
- 54:04a year from now you're like i could have gotten that myself now i'm i've lost 30 of what was rightfully
- 54:09mine because of this person took that when i could have done this on my own so please please
- 54:14please tell your friends be very careful and disasters like this sorry disasters like this bring out
- 54:21scam artists um and so like stacey said it's it attorneys are not allowed to solicit so if any
- 54:30attorney is approaching you if any public adjuster is approaching you versus you approaching them for
- 54:37their services that's a bad sign so you know that that brings a lot of people out um to to
- 54:45dovetail on one thing that john said about potential future litigation if you use a public
- 54:52adjuster to get your you know insurance coverage and you pay that public adjuster 25 you cannot
- 55:01get that 25 percent that you paid out back in a litigation in the future um so just i want to go
- 55:09finish my my section please let's go back i want to get on fema i got a toss d and i know i've
- 55:14talked for an hour when i meant to talk 15 minutes but um going back to that question of what information
- 55:23do the insurance companies require so you've got your inventory any receipts that you can find
- 55:29online receipts that that's the benefit of online shopping frankly is that we have a lot of of of
- 55:34documents showing what we owned and what we purchased and how much for um ask family and friends
- 55:41if they have photos if you know if you had a party recently or a family event recently and you know
- 55:48that you know cousin susie is is really active with her camera ask her for those pictures it's
- 55:54going to be able to show what was in your house when you make that personal property stacey touched
- 56:00on this when you make your personal property inventory if you are doing a full inventory
- 56:05do not omit any items so if you are listing everything out you know that your insurance
- 56:12coverage is 200 grand don't stop when you hit 200 grand list everything because as stacey just said
- 56:20your insurance company and the event that you have an actual cash value policy is going to
- 56:26depreciate they're going to knock 30 percent off every value that you put there then your 200 grand
- 56:33list is now 140 thousand dollars so keep going until you've listed everything um we covered my last
- 56:43point on personal property inventory sorry amanda we do have a another really important question here
- 56:47because rickardo laura the insurance commissioner for the state of california i believe is said
- 56:52that no itemization of personal property is needed in the event of a total loss due to the state of
- 56:59emergency um i know that look we're all still many people are evacuating today so this is very
- 57:05fluid for everyone here but any comments on those or anything we can clarify on that from anyone
- 57:11yeah you may be required instead to list every item you may be um you may have you may be able to
- 57:17group you may not have to do a personal property inventory at all but as john pointed out you may
- 57:24want that personal property inventory later um if there's litigation it's better to do it now so
- 57:31so yes the your insurance company like that prior question your insurance company may say
- 57:37will pay you 75 percent you don't need to do an inventory if that's an option that works for you
- 57:43you can take that option if your insurance company says will give you the 100 percent you can group
- 57:49items you can categorize items if that's what works for you you can do that if you were someone who
- 57:55wants to do a full itemized personal property inventory the tips i just gave you're going to
- 58:00help you do that so i generally tell clients you need to do what is best for your family you are
- 58:08in a marathon you are not on a sprint you got a lot of stuff that you're going to need to be doing
- 58:14in the next couple of years and some people are like i just don't want to bother with the personal
- 58:19property inventory if that's what works for you that's fine as john said understand that later
- 58:25if there is a litigation we are going to be lacking that documentation but that's something that you're
- 58:31going to have to decide for yourself with your family about whether or not you want to go through
- 58:35that burden i'm going to move on to fema do you want you have any other personal property
- 58:41issues you want to raise dan i mean i think we covered a lot i'm sure that there's so many
- 58:44questions i mean these people are asking truly you know really important wonderful questions
- 58:49we're trying to get through as many as we can if things pop up that are that are important i'll
- 58:52i'll throw it back at the group okay and i think and davin states you're going to touch on insurance
- 58:57issues again okay fema fema is a huge one if you apply for fema use caution um fema disaster
- 59:07assistance is for uninsured and underinsured losses it is for things you do not have insurance for
- 59:18the fema website very clearly states if you have insurance you should file a claim
- 59:25with your insurance company immediately fema assistance cannot help you with losses that
- 59:33are already covered by your insurance so if you have insurance you need to make your insurance
- 59:39claim you are not going to get assistance from fema without complications um if you do not have
- 59:47insurance if you are eligible for fema if you have an uninsured loss fema may require um proof of
- 59:55use so all of those tips i gave you before about how to track your expenses for additional living
- 1:00:01expenses and for personal property coverage you can use those for fema keep your receipts get itemized
- 1:00:09receipts um use some sort of filing system and use an account or keep a log or an account of how
- 1:00:19fema how you spent the funds that fema gave you we're getting a lot of questions too about the
- 1:00:28intersection between fema and gofundme accounts stacey and i had this discussion this morning
- 1:00:34the fema website says that fema cannot duplicate benefits that you received from another source
- 1:00:42so if you're getting five grand from fema and five grand from gofundme you cannot be using them
- 1:00:50for the same assistance for the same expenses because you cannot use other funds for something
- 1:00:58that fema gave you so make sure you're not spending your gofundme funds um or any other similar type
- 1:01:06of gift donation funds red cross funds um on the same expenses that are covered by fema so have a
- 1:01:14clear accounting this is what i spent my fema funds on this is the documentation that backs it up
- 1:01:21this is what i spent my gofundme funds on this is the documentation that backs it up there is no
- 1:01:27duplication so just i mean we're getting some just we've seen maybe a little clarification on this so
- 1:01:32um if your insurance covers let's say x amount 100 000 hypothetically it's obviously under
- 1:01:41you're underinsured fema will cover can cover the losses that go above that or not and just just
- 1:01:48be very clear because we're getting a lot of questions on this well that's part of the problem
- 1:01:52it's not very clear fema does is not very clear by what they mean by uninsured and uninsured
- 1:01:58underinsured but their website says if you have insurance go to your insurance company do not come
- 1:02:04to us and i will tell you i have had clients who had insurance understood that they were under insured
- 1:02:14got fema assistance and then fema later came back and said you had insurance for that even if they
- 1:02:23you know use the money for different things and they didn't have enough insurance you had
- 1:02:27insurance for that we want our money back and let me be clear when fema comes to you and asks for
- 1:02:33its money back it does not come back nicely and say excuse me mrs smith it seems we've made a mistake
- 1:02:42let's talk this out and work this through they come back at you with you defrauded the federal
- 1:02:48government by taking funds that you should not have taken so you do not want to be taking fema
- 1:02:56funds if you have insurance that could possibly cover any individual loss if you have questions
- 1:03:04about that if you were insured and you have questions about whether you supply fema don't
- 1:03:09do it online go to a fema assistance center and talk to them or ask your questions because
- 1:03:18like i said i have it they have come back at my clients and said you should not have accepted
- 1:03:24those funds we're demanding our money back you defrauded the federal government so so i think
- 1:03:29i think the best advice is be 100 transparent if you are going to go down the fema path with what
- 1:03:34your coverage is what you intend to use it for you don't want to mess around with it because they
- 1:03:38they will charge misdemeanors right for this kind of thing and so it's the last thing you want to deal
- 1:03:42with just be very very transparent and then recommend getting that all in writing i assume
- 1:03:47with whoever you're talking to at fema yeah i mean the problem is you're dealing with the federal
- 1:03:52government and so they're not going to be sitting there you know helping you write notes but i i
- 1:03:58strongly suggest if you have any kind of insurance that if you apply to for fema you go to an
- 1:04:04a fema government assistance center and ask someone who actually works for fema this is the
- 1:04:12insurance i have can i still apply for fema versus applying online and making that mistake because
- 1:04:19like you said and it's only one example so i don't want to freak people out but i did have a client
- 1:04:24who accidentally took fema assistance while he had insurance and they he was charged with a misdemeanor
- 1:04:32and we're getting a lot of go fund me questions on how that would be an offset stacy did you want
- 1:04:37to touch on that or manda it won't be a go fund me won't be an offset related to insurance they
- 1:04:44are entirely separate so you can get go fund me funds and assistance from family and relatives
- 1:04:51without it affecting your insurance that's not a problem it's related to fema that it can become
- 1:04:58an issue fema has on their website a section about go fund me that explains if you get funds from
- 1:05:07go fund me you have to make sure that they are not specifically earmarked for something that
- 1:05:15fema has given you money for so if fema gives you money to rebuild you can't use the go fund me
- 1:05:22money to rebuild you could potentially use it for something else and you'll need to be able to
- 1:05:27demonstrate that you did that you're not commingling the funds which will make it confusing so for
- 1:05:33many reasons there's it could get very dicey combining go fund me and fema i personally
- 1:05:40wouldn't recommend it there are no issues having to go fund me account along with your insurance
- 1:05:45it won't affect your insurance yeah you're gonna want to keep them separate you're gonna want to keep
- 1:05:50them accounted for separately and you're going to want to make sure that you're not do you're not
- 1:05:55taking duplicate funds like stacy said if you have a go fund me that says you know help the jones
- 1:06:02family rebuild their home you don't want to be taking fema money to rebuild your home because
- 1:06:08that is a duplication and fema is very clear that we are not going to give you money for something
- 1:06:14where you have another source of income again like dan said that income may not be sufficient
- 1:06:22that's where you get into a discussion with fema of well what if i have some but not enough you
- 1:06:28just need to be careful last thing i want to say on fema if you are receiving fema funds to pay rent
- 1:06:40for a rental property because you've been displaced for your home sometimes fema will pay that rent
- 1:06:48directly generally in cases where if you are living in lower income housing section 8 housing
- 1:06:55something like that fema instead of giving you the money will pay the rent directly to the county
- 1:07:02or the agency that you are renting from if you then move into a different county into a different
- 1:07:10agency area make sure that fema moves the money with you and is not still paying the old rent
- 1:07:19the old rent again it's only one situation but i had a client who was um there's an elderly woman
- 1:07:27she was in her 80s she lived in section 8 housing after a fire she was in section 8 housing in one
- 1:07:34county fema was directly paying that money the rental money in that county she moved to another
- 1:07:42county fema was paying the second county but didn't stop paying the first county so she's now got
- 1:07:50duplicate funds even though she's not the one receiving the money they came after her and
- 1:07:55demanded that she get the money back so fema is a great resource it's great for immediate funds
- 1:08:03if you have any other source of income be very very careful with fema like i said they do not come
- 1:08:08back nicely and ask you for your money back they come back in a you defrauded the government by
- 1:08:14taking money you shouldn't have kind of way so that is you know we've covered um your insurance
- 1:08:22company claim your additional living expenses your personal property fema and so now i'm going to
- 1:08:29toss to dav to talk about rebuild thank you and so first of all also remember that your insurance
- 1:08:38agent in your broker is also a first line of you know the fence and somebody who you should get
- 1:08:45assistance from they're free they place the policies they know the policy that hopefully they
- 1:08:50knew know the policy that they put you in so always ask them for advice are they obligated to
- 1:08:55date are the brokers are the agent who sold the policy are they obligated to help out in the situation
- 1:09:01per se not obligated but they every agent does a lot of and a lot of uh agencies and brokerages
- 1:09:07actually have a specific claims department that will assist you so make sure to utilize them if
- 1:09:12they have one um but uh that's definitely uh it's and it's you it's always free usually so definitely
- 1:09:19uh to contact them so obviously the biggest part of your insurance policy is going to be your your
- 1:09:26home or your commercial building uh whichever was damaged during this event um i will tell you that
- 1:09:34anyone who's afraid that oh i have the fair plan this is fire insurance fire insurance is covered
- 1:09:40by just about every policy you have so anyone who says i have fair plan it's not covered for a wildfire
- 1:09:46incorrect anybody who has coverage for their drawing or their structure this is what the main
- 1:09:53purpose of an insurance policy so anyone who has a fear of that um i hope to dispel that rumor
- 1:09:59whether you're uh adequately insured or under insured that's something that stacey will talk about
- 1:10:03but when you're looking at the coverage for the structure for your home uh you first look to see
- 1:10:10is what kind of valuation you have most policies do have what's called replacement costs we've kind
- 1:10:15of talked about this but it's the amount of money that will cost to either repair or replace the
- 1:10:22property that was damaged uh in in this case obviously most a lot of people have a total loss
- 1:10:29so you you've got a completely uh uh ruined structure that will need to be rebuilt in a home
- 1:10:38or a structure that's been so damaged and uninhabitable that will need to be replaced
- 1:10:42or in the event that you just have damage it's the amount of money that will cost in in today's
- 1:10:48market to replace or repair whatever that is damaged so that's usually you can either find it
- 1:10:55either in your section a that we've talked about in uh homeowners policies it could also be called
- 1:11:02uh building coverage uh or it could be called uh structure coverage so you're going to look to see
- 1:11:08what kind of limits you have and you're going to see the valuation again usually it's replacement
- 1:11:13costs we have talked about what it means that if you possibly have what's called um actual cash value
- 1:11:20and that's taking the replacement costs and then it is depreciated um and unfortunately it's tough to
- 1:11:27on your own to figure out what that depreciation is but usually the current insurance company
- 1:11:32will tell you that what the depreciation is of that building depending on on the age is it Dave is
- 1:11:39it helpful to have a real estate appraiser help to determine the fair market value and replacement
- 1:11:44value i i definitely would most people don't have access to what is considered um replacement costs
- 1:11:52there are a few different companies out there that can give you a replacement cost estimate based on
- 1:11:58your address uh the type of structure it was when it was built and then also the square footage and
- 1:12:04then any improvements so you can either go to an appraiser you can go to one of these online
- 1:12:10websites uh that could give you an estimate uh insurance companies will have their own in-house
- 1:12:16valuations but i highly recommend uh for people who are looking to see what is going to be the
- 1:12:22replacement cost for for example especially for anybody who has lost their home completely
- 1:12:26to find out what is it is the replacement cost and what is an estimate to further supplement that
- 1:12:35we then will probably go to a contractor and a contractor will tell you um based on uh again
- 1:12:42the square footage um based on you know finding something that is like kind to what you had so
- 1:12:48you you're not going to be able to obviously if you had a 2 000 sport foot at home you can't say
- 1:12:53well i want to replace it with a 4 000 square foot home unless you're overinsured which is rarely the
- 1:12:58case the insurance company will only give you what it costs to replace what you had at the time of the
- 1:13:04loss um so a contractor a reputable contractor's license will help you do that um other evidence
- 1:13:12that you can use to to prove what you had before is um go on redfin go on zillow they usually have
- 1:13:19uh pretty updated pictures of what your your property looks like if not again we've talked about using
- 1:13:26uh pictures uh to you know to help people understand what your house looked like but
- 1:13:33usually property records should have an updated value of at least the square footage of your home
- 1:13:41or but also the your insurance broker agent who uh was making the about helping the insurance
- 1:13:47company making the valuation they'll have a record of how many square feet um and you'll use that
- 1:13:53to determine what is the cost of per square foot to rebuild your home um so
- 1:14:02you the other ways we've discussed this also uh previously but what are what are we looking at so
- 1:14:09we're looking at the replacement costs and in the limit but sometimes we've talked about that we've
- 1:14:14had what's called extended replacement cost coverage and that can be an additional 10 percent
- 1:14:19it can be an additional 25 percent it could be additional 50 percent to what that dwelling
- 1:14:25or building coverage uh limit was so let's say hypothetically if you add a million dollars in
- 1:14:31coverage and you had what's called that extended replacement cost endorsement you then either
- 1:14:37have 101.1 million 1.25 million 1.5 i've seen them uh as high as 75 percent in some policies so
- 1:14:46you'll definitely want to take a look not just at that initial number on what's your dwelling or
- 1:14:51structure coverage but to see if you have endorsement for extra coverage so so here here's a question
- 1:14:56that a few people have asked about the square footage if there's unpermitted finished square
- 1:15:01footage how does that come into play um in terms of the replacement cost what if there's structures
- 1:15:07that are not shown in the square footage of the home so what's your how would you do with it so
- 1:15:12for anybody who has made like additions um i would use evidence based on uh you take the
- 1:15:19contractors quotes and any evidence that you had to show that you made some sort of addition
- 1:15:23um now but that you know if you're making an addition uh to the main structure then that's
- 1:15:31added to that's what would be covered under that dwelling um or section aid coverage now if you added
- 1:15:38let's say like an adu which would be considered a separate structure that is under the what's under
- 1:15:44the section b coverage uh for other structures so you wouldn't you wouldn't lump that in with your
- 1:15:50section a coverage that would be your section b which is your other coverage can i if i can just
- 1:15:56add one thing because that that exact issue happens a lot in the litigation where the public record
- 1:16:03shows that the house was a thousand square feet but the the client's telling me it was really 1500
- 1:16:09square feet because they've done an addition potentially unpermitted or they did it permitted
- 1:16:15but the county records are not accurate and so pictures are a good way to prove that but also
- 1:16:21if you worked with an architect if you worked with a contractor who gave you um a bid if you can show
- 1:16:29that you made payments if you show that you have plans that an architect drew up that's another way
- 1:16:36good way of showing you did add on to your house but that it's not reflected in the public records
- 1:16:42and it's not reflected in the insurance file because a lot of the time clients will add on to
- 1:16:47their house even permitted but will forget to tell their insurance company so there are ways
- 1:16:52to show your insurance company i used a contractor i used an architect here's pictures of my my new
- 1:17:00adu like david said right one one more thing to note on that um there are specific policies that
- 1:17:08state in the in the language that it only covers permitted space read your policy carefully find
- 1:17:15out if it's covered basements can be another big issue because under the appraisal for real estate
- 1:17:24in california basements are not listed as square footage however and i'm going to talk about this
- 1:17:30in my piece then a little bit the um software that's used by the insurance companies does need to know
- 1:17:37about the basement square footage if it's going to calculate it correctly and that is often a big
- 1:17:44issue um and i personally have had litigations about that um so be aware that you may not have
- 1:17:53all of your square footage listed in there and that it could be it could be an issue and one
- 1:17:57that the insurance company may push back on absolutely and and and that's why you definitely
- 1:18:02want to be able to get as much documentation to prove uh that additional square footage that may
- 1:18:08not have been uh readily available for everybody for the insurance company to to get another one
- 1:18:15more coverage in addition that we've also kind of briefly talked about the ordinance and law coverage
- 1:18:22which is the building upgrades coverage so if you had an older home in order to rebuild a home to
- 1:18:28modern code uh you are often entitled to that extra coverage to add to the uh dwelling coverage
- 1:18:38sometimes that can be a fight especially about how much and based on the age but uh definitely
- 1:18:44it's something that you should be asking for saying in order for me to rebuild my home in
- 1:18:50order to be updated to code that i need this extra coverage and you should be entitled to it
- 1:18:55uh whether they give it to you or not again can be can be a fight but you know it's definitely
- 1:19:01something that you should be uh pushing for um going forward because i know we are living in time but
- 1:19:09what happens when you actually get the money um to replace your home because most people
- 1:19:16have mortgages and a lot of times when you um get your insurance policy you add your mortgage
- 1:19:24to the policy and if you look at the uh language of your mortgage uh they are entitled to uh be
- 1:19:34added on the check that is given by the insurance company so a lot of people this can be an issue
- 1:19:42when you're underinsured but it this is definitely something where you definitely need to speak with
- 1:19:48your mortgage company because they are going to be expecting to be in communication with uh you
- 1:19:55through this insurance process because any money that is given from the structure or the building
- 1:20:00coverage they will have their name as well on the check and most likely based on the rules of your
- 1:20:07of your uh mortgage loan you actually need to endorse the check and needs to go to the uh to
- 1:20:14the mortgage company which they keep in escrow until your house is either rebuilt or potentially
- 1:20:22purchased for another property which i know we'll discuss later about what your options are but keep
- 1:20:29in mind that to get ahead of this i definitely would recommend at you know talking to your
- 1:20:35mortgage company giving them the situation that you've lost your home or your home's uninhabitable
- 1:20:40and how to work out the deal because that is going to be an issue when the money comes is
- 1:20:48uh what rights do you have what rights do the mortgage company have and it will determine
- 1:20:55whether you decide to rebuild your home whether you decide to purchase a new property and the
- 1:21:02mortgage company will have a say and it'll be a big determining factor of what what your decisions
- 1:21:08are so just keep that in the back of your mind that you will be dealing with that uh if you do
- 1:21:14have a mortgage on your home um so under california law though one thing is that you do have an option
- 1:21:22of either rebuilding your home or taking the money to buy another home so again whether you have a
- 1:21:30mortgage or not will determine your decision but you do not have to use the money that you get from
- 1:21:35your structure coverage uh to build on that actual property and i know that a lot of people are wondering
- 1:21:42well you know how can i rebuild in a place that may take months or even years um you know to become a
- 1:21:50of a vibrant town again and um so you do have that option assuming that there's no issues with the
- 1:21:57mortgage company that's saying hey i can't rebuild here it's going to take years um i don't know if i
- 1:22:04have enough money to you know rent for you know the foreseeable future therefore i need to take
- 1:22:11the money and you're allowed to use that money to uh purchase another home or another structure
- 1:22:17whether it's a commercial property as well uh and then just uh going further uh i think a lot of
- 1:22:24people have the fear is what's going to happen to my insurance policy when i make these large claims
- 1:22:30um you should know that riccardo Lara put a moratorium on any cancellations from an insurance
- 1:22:38company until january 7th the next year so no matter what you will have continued coverage
- 1:22:45with your insurance company uh over the next year because most people's policies will probably renew
- 1:22:51sometime between the time of the event and january 7th so they cannot cancel you
- 1:22:57um and one thing further is that because this is a state of emergency wildfire it is against
- 1:23:05the law that even once this moratorium is lifted they cannot use the loss of a wildfire uh as the
- 1:23:13sole reason to cancel you going forward so they they can make other uh decisions in order to
- 1:23:21non renew you or cancel you in the future but it cannot be for making a claim here so it's again
- 1:23:27we've talked about this uh on the panel earlier if you can make a claim make it do not fear about
- 1:23:33your insurance going forward because for the uh for this exact situation it cannot penalize you
- 1:23:41having said that the future of uh you know california and homeowner's insurance is obviously
- 1:23:48going to be in flux so that's a totally other subject but for now do not be fearful putting
- 1:23:54so david a couple questions on the on the mortgage show if the insurance only covers the building
- 1:23:59say 300 000 but the mortgage also includes the land say 700 000 does the lender then take the whole
- 1:24:06coverage a basically so so the the lender will make a determination of how much is structure versus
- 1:24:13how much is the land so um so the answer is no they can't take it because the land is worth x
- 1:24:20dollars they will do it based on uh the the value of the building um but you know again that goes to
- 1:24:30whether the building was adequately insured or not okay and and and i know we're it's well
- 1:24:39obviously well past 130 this is just such invaluable information we still have we still
- 1:24:43have thousands of people still on this so i obviously this is very important we want to
- 1:24:47keep going to get as many questions answered and help as we can so we're going to keep rolling
- 1:24:53hey a dan can i add one thing just from the litigation perspective um purchase morning
- 1:24:58purchase money mortgages in california non-recourse as well so if you have your purchase money
- 1:25:03mortgage in place um that doesn't necessarily pertain to the insurance but that's something
- 1:25:08for people to keep in mind like oh my god i've got a three million dollar mortgage on this property
- 1:25:13and i'm going to get x amount for my structure damage on my policy but am i going to be able
- 1:25:18am i going to get foreclosed on or whatever that that's a kind of separate issue from this
- 1:25:23that's something so i guess what is the purchase what what is the purchase money mortgage that
- 1:25:28means when you you get your mortgage to purchase the property as opposed to refinancing it down the
- 1:25:33road it's okay and then non-recourse meaning they can't go after the the borrower for a deficiency
- 1:25:40if somehow they foreclosed i'm not suggesting that's going to happen i don't know but the point is i
- 1:25:46spoke with someone the other day who has a three million dollar mortgage and he was really worried
- 1:25:50about whether or not he was going to get foreclosed on if they were going to sue him for the deficiency
- 1:25:54because the property is not worth what it was the lot's not even probably worth what it was at this
- 1:25:59point we'll see i don't think that happened in the malibu fire i think the land value stayed the same
- 1:26:05but the point is is that people are concerned like oh my god i'm going to get sued and
- 1:26:10they're going to foreclose if it's your purchase money mortgage they can't sue you but that that's
- 1:26:15a little bit different from the or outside the insurance uh scope of the of this of this talk
- 1:26:21but i just want people to understand that that they're you know there there are a variety of
- 1:26:26things you need to address and you shouldn't be so worried if it's your initial mortgage when you
- 1:26:31purchase the property all right go ahead dave yeah and just one more thing because um our people
- 1:26:40may be asking well it may cost me uh i have i've 1.5 million dollars in my structure and my extended
- 1:26:49replacement costs and i've got you know another 200 000 in an ordinance but it's going to cost me
- 1:26:542.5 million dollars to rebuild it in today's market now unfortunately you only get to the amount
- 1:27:02under replacement costs unless you have what's called guaranteed replacement costs which has been
- 1:27:06mostly phased out in most policies there are very few policies in existence that will pay you out to
- 1:27:12whatever it costs to rebuild you only get to the limit of what you have um and again that's really
- 1:27:21going to whether you have enough or not that's going to be a something that i think stacey's
- 1:27:25going to speak about going forward but that you unfortunately do not have any more recourse under
- 1:27:32your policy than what your limits are all right i would say unfortunately because of the cost of
- 1:27:40rebuilding and cost of building in california a lot of people are going to be under insured
- 1:27:46they're going to have less money in their cover jay and their extended rebuild um than they're going
- 1:27:54to need to rebuild their house i know that after the wine country fires it was something like the
- 1:27:59statistic was something like people only had 65 percent of insurance to cover the the cost of
- 1:28:06rebuild um that may be different here i know that there are programs that are um being pushed for
- 1:28:12for rap faster rebuild but it it's likely that a lot of people are going to be under insured when
- 1:28:19it comes to the cost of rebuilding their home yeah all right are we hitting it off to stacey now
- 1:28:25yeah and just one last thing if anybody who is fortunate to let's say have like a pool or something
- 1:28:31else that is a fix to the ground that is part of your other structure coverage um anything that is
- 1:28:37above ground let's say like a like a like a portable hot tub that would be part of your
- 1:28:41contents but if you'd had like any other type of like other structure or anything that's a fix to
- 1:28:47your land that's uh like a pool then that's covered under your other structure coverage so
- 1:28:52if anyone needs to make a claim for that make sure it's under that provision all right stacey
- 1:29:01all right can't wait to hear from you here yeah go ahead thank you everyone for sticking with us
- 1:29:05during this i know that we've been doing this for a while now um i'm here to talk to you about
- 1:29:10all of the things that california and the department of insurance have put in place to protect you
- 1:29:16and then a little bit about what they were trying to protect you from so that you understand the
- 1:29:20issues and are prepared if you do encounter issues um we've talked a lot about insurance regulations
- 1:29:28already amanda and david touched on several i'm going to talk about a few more the fact that if you
- 1:29:35don't want to rebuild you can use all of your coverage including extended replacement coverage
- 1:29:40and building code upgrades to purchase a new home um that's new a lot of these were just put in place
- 1:29:46in the past two years so you are in a good position among california wildfire victims
- 1:29:54in terms of having laws that protect you um the insurer cannot deduct the value of your land from
- 1:30:01a replacement home purchased so don't don't worry about that it's not limited to rebuild
- 1:30:08they can't say oh you're buying this two million dollar house um but it's half of that's the land
- 1:30:14value and therefore we're only going to pay you half of it they can't do that anymore um we also
- 1:30:20talked about the fact that the insurer has to offer an immediate payment of 30 of the policy
- 1:30:25limit up to 250 000 and you don't need to use your insurer's inventory form they are often
- 1:30:32incredibly confusing and difficult to to use you can just use a spreadsheet you can create
- 1:30:39your own spreadsheet you can do it on a piece of paper by hand whatever works for you they have
- 1:30:45to accept it now and you can bulk list items um what i don't know the bulk the ability to bulk
- 1:30:52list is new i don't know what insurance companies are going to do about questioning the amount of
- 1:30:59something which is unfortunately something that happens a lot um i haven't seen it yet so it'll
- 1:31:05be interesting to see what the insurance company does if you say that you had 10 sweaters and it
- 1:31:10was a thousand dollars because each sweater was a hundred dollars the insurance company may say what
- 1:31:15kind of sweater costs a hundred dollars um one thing to note most of the people handling your
- 1:31:20claims do not live in california they don't live in southern california they're not familiar with
- 1:31:24the costs of the area and the lifestyles of the area most of these people live in the
- 1:31:34the midwest or the south and have never been to california so there may be a lot of disconnects
- 1:31:40in terms of things you're reporting that you own compared to their understanding of what people have
- 1:31:45in their homes something to be aware of them if i may a lot of them are because of the magnitude of
- 1:31:51the number of claims a lot of them are going to be contract for a short period of time to add to
- 1:31:58handle the influx of the claims they're not going to be long term so that's another good reason to
- 1:32:03make sure that you keep really good records of your communications with them because they are
- 1:32:08speaking to you on behalf of your insurance company i've seen many cases where that insurance claims
- 1:32:14rep disappears and takes documents with them so you need to keep your own records and understand
- 1:32:22that there's no there's no educational requirement or significant training requirement for your claims
- 1:32:28adjusters many of them go to become a claims adjusters straight out of high school um so
- 1:32:35they also are given hundreds of claims to manage it once so they are overwhelmed they're often poorly
- 1:32:41trained frequently they're not trying to be difficult um but your experience of it still
- 1:32:47may be that they're being difficult just something to note um and that brings us to a couple more
- 1:32:52regulations that they're required to follow they have to acknowledge your claim and provide forms
- 1:32:56and begin investigating your claim within 15 days of notice um they have to respond to questions and
- 1:33:02calls and emails within 15 days i think i'm and a touched on that um you are allowed at any time to
- 1:33:08request a copy of your claim file um all claims related documents the insurance company is not
- 1:33:13going to want to give this to you they are going to push back very hard because they don't want you
- 1:33:17looking at their internal notes but under california insurance code 2071 you can request a copy of all
- 1:33:24those documents for review you can also get a copy of your policy which seems obvious but you will
- 1:33:31you may also have a difficult time getting anything more than your declarations page it can be very
- 1:33:35difficult to get a copy of the full policy if your insurer assigns you to three or more claims
- 1:33:41handlers in a six month period they have to provide you a written status report summary
- 1:33:46summarizing what's happened to date and give you one ongoing person as a point of contact with a
- 1:33:52direct means of communication that will stick with you throughout the remainder of the claims
- 1:33:55process um that that had been a big problem in prior years and this is a new regulation
- 1:34:01they can't keep every three months sorry on that note um we got some questions about that uh someone
- 1:34:08said we don't have a claims rep and we filed the day it burned down last wednesday how long do they
- 1:34:13have to assign us how much time do they have to supposed to have 15 days now do assign somebody
- 1:34:19that's just to assign somebody well to assign part of assigning somebody is providing the claim forms
- 1:34:25and beginning the investigation it you necessarily have to assign someone to the claim to begin the
- 1:34:30invest investigation so yes i would say they have to do it within 15 days that doesn't mean
- 1:34:36that they will one of the difficult issues with the regulations is that short of litigation
- 1:34:41there's no enforcement mechanism and so they may flout the regulations and be very frustrating
- 1:34:52one of the things we're going to talk about in a minute is the department of insurance and the
- 1:34:55ways in which they can help you but that is something that you can reach out to the department of
- 1:34:58insurance for for assistance is when they're just blatantly ignoring the regulations um because you
- 1:35:07don't want to bring litigation for delay and difficulty getting in touch with people that's
- 1:35:14if you encounter that over and over again that's going to be more of a public adjuster issue um
- 1:35:20litigation is for for big issues and and stacey um if you are anyone who is having an issue saying
- 1:35:28you know i filed my claim a week ago um this is a really good time to really get your insurance
- 1:35:34agents involved to uh advocate your behalf and speed up the process um either he he or she is a
- 1:35:40captive agent uh who works with the company they know that all the adjusters very well um and they
- 1:35:46have direct access to you know speaking with them and they can assist you or in the alternative uh in
- 1:35:52uh a broker agent who has a large amount of business can make calls to uh managers uh of
- 1:35:59the insurance companies and they usually have usually a lot of cloud to help speed up the process so
- 1:36:04this would be a good time if you haven't spoken to anybody yet saying i've filed my claim i haven't
- 1:36:10talked to anyone talk to your insurance agents or broker that helped you put the policy in place
- 1:36:14absolutely right um your insurer is supposed to accept or reject your claim within 40 days of
- 1:36:23receiving proof of claim unfortunately they have a large back door to that because they're allowed
- 1:36:29under the regulations to request more time to review but they have to put it in writing and say
- 1:36:33what else they need and say when they think they'll be done so if you get a series of letters stating
- 1:36:39that they need more time and they're still reviewing that's them complying with the regulations um no
- 1:36:45matter what the time limit in your policy is your the time limit in your policy probably says you have
- 1:36:51x amount of months to rebuild or repair um in a state of emergency you have 36 months to rebuild
- 1:36:58from the date the first payment is made to you not from the date you lost your house from the date
- 1:37:03the first payment is made i realize that sounds like a ridiculously long amount of time and why
- 1:37:08would you ever need that most people are not even going to be able to talk to a contractor for at
- 1:37:13least a year simply because the contractors are going to be overwhelmed and it can take a very
- 1:37:19long time to rebuild what i've seen with clients is um anywhere from three to six years and so you
- 1:37:26should be aware of this um if it takes longer than 36 months to rebuild from the date of the first
- 1:37:33payment additional six month extensions can be provided for good cause that you have to demonstrate
- 1:37:38to the insurance company what good cause means um you also have 36 months to use your um additional
- 1:37:45living expenses um regardless of what it says in your policy because it's a state of emergency
- 1:37:51and if you've been restricted access to your property by a civil authority if you were evacuated
- 1:37:57your insurer must pay you up to two weeks of additional living expenses without dispute
- 1:38:02um if you and your insurer disagree as to the cost of repairs typically either side is allowed to
- 1:38:08require appraisal which is a long internal process um in a government declared disaster they cannot
- 1:38:15compel it so they if you disagree they can't force you to go through the appraisal process if you
- 1:38:21don't want to about the amount it will cost to rebuild um your insurer cannot cancel your insurance
- 1:38:27while your home's being rebuilt cannot charge you on renewal for the cost of your non-existent home
- 1:38:33they can only renew for for what is actually there on the property so if your home is gone
- 1:38:38then that's the cost of the land um the insurer must offer to renew for 24 months after a loss
- 1:38:44caused by a disaster all of that's in california insurance code section 675.1 and all of these
- 1:38:51are listed in the materials that were given to you so you can look them up and include them in
- 1:38:57letters to your insurance company and let your insurance company know what you're talking about
- 1:39:01and as i think was already brought up there's been a one-year moratorium um for zip codes in
- 1:39:07or adjoining the palisades and eaten fires no insurer can cancel or non-review in or non-renew
- 1:39:13in those areas for a year um the next thing i'm going to talk about is under insurance
- 1:39:18i realize this is a big issue for a lot of people um in and it's been an issue for decades
- 1:39:25the department of insurance has been studying this for decades in 2011 um the department of
- 1:39:31insurance passed a regulation called 2695 183 um it requires all insurers all agents and all
- 1:39:38brokers to provide a detailed written estimate of your replacement cost when they sell you a policy
- 1:39:44and you accept it they don't have to give it to you if you if they offer you a policy and you
- 1:39:49don't accept it but if you take the policy they are required to give that to you within three days
- 1:39:54if you make any changes if they make any changes to your coverage um other than automatic inflation
- 1:40:00increases they are required to give you a written estimate if you ever call to discuss your coverages
- 1:40:07they are required to give you this detailed written estimate showing their understanding of
- 1:40:11what's in your house of what was built in your house so that you can look at it and say yes all of
- 1:40:17this is right or the square footage is wrong this doesn't seem right i have five bedrooms not three
- 1:40:24bedrooms um the reason this was put in place is that over the past 20 years insurance companies
- 1:40:30have moved to using replacement cost estimator software instead of sending out individuals
- 1:40:36to manually do it at your house um most insurance companies are now using something called 360 value
- 1:40:45and 360 value can be significantly customized to put an enormous amount of detail about your home
- 1:40:50in there however it's up to the individual using the software to decide how much information put in
- 1:40:56360 value pre-fills all of the all of the information based on what it can find online
- 1:41:02that's usually public records things like zillow or um redfin anything it can find it pre-fills with
- 1:41:12that and also its understanding of your neighborhood um and so your broker or insurance company is
- 1:41:19supposed to then go over those pre-fills with you and make sure that they're right unfortunately a
- 1:41:24lot of times that doesn't happen and that's where most under insurance begins also 360 value automatically
- 1:41:33assigns what's called a quality grade to a property a quality grade is a multiplier that is applied to
- 1:41:39all costs related to a property um the the different quality grades are usually economy standard above
- 1:41:46average custom and premium above average is what a lot of houses are are are given by 360 value but
- 1:41:54above average is intended to be used by tract housing so if you're in a large housing development
- 1:42:00that was all built at once and all looks very similar that's above average if you are living in
- 1:42:07a home that was designed individually by an architect and built individually that's automatically
- 1:42:12supposed to be at least custom and premium is higher end custom homes most I don't want to say
- 1:42:19most many brokers and agents and insurers do not look at the quality grade they um don't ask the
- 1:42:27insured about the equality grade and explain what it means and why it's important it is the single
- 1:42:31most important factor in your insurance it can it can change how much insurance you have by close to
- 1:42:37100 percent the difference between economy and premium um also it's important for you to understand
- 1:42:44upfront we've all gotten insurance from insurance companies we know the process you call you tell
- 1:42:51them at your home address they give you a number you agree to take it and you're done um under the
- 1:42:58law you are responsible for that amount that they gave you you're responsible for selecting the amount
- 1:43:03of coverage you have and your insurer your insurer takes that position that you chose the amount it's
- 1:43:10not they didn't choose it they you decided what you wanted if you'd asked for more maybe they would
- 1:43:15have given it to you but you didn't um the california courts have upheld this over and over again as
- 1:43:22well um the only situations in which you can push back on under insurance are one if the if the broker
- 1:43:32or insurer didn't give you a replacement cost estimate to review um that's why the 2695 183
- 1:43:40regulation was put in place so that they're required to give you a chance to double check the
- 1:43:44information and make sure it's right if you were not provided one under california insurance
- 1:43:50regulations that is a per se misleading statement which means it's automatically a false statement
- 1:43:56that they made to you um the other situation in which the insurance company or agent or broker
- 1:44:03can potentially be held responsible is if you asked straight out is this going to be enough
- 1:44:09for me to rebuild in the event of a fire and they said yes this is what you need you're good um at
- 1:44:16that point by choosing to opine on it they take responsibility for it the law is not crystal clear
- 1:44:24on this and this is a major major issue with many wildfire victims because almost everyone is going
- 1:44:31to be underinsured um to find out how insurance companies were handling wildfires from 2020 to
- 1:44:392023 the department of insurance investigated most major insurers in the california market and put
- 1:44:44out publicly available market conduct exam reports specific to wildfires and these are described in
- 1:44:51detail with a link where you can get them in the handouts but i'm just going to touch really briefly
- 1:44:58all state was required to pay 7.5 million dollars in additional claim payments by the department
- 1:45:02of insurance after they reviewed a handful of claims um because all state wasn't providing
- 1:45:07replacement cost estimates to insurers which kept them from identifying errors also all states
- 1:45:13internal guidelines said a property should be reinspected once every five years but all state
- 1:45:17wasn't conducting any reinsfections csa a csa a was forced to refund 65 000 in premiums and pay
- 1:45:26over 40 million dollars in additional claims payments it relied on the prefilled data without
- 1:45:31ever checking with the insured it didn't have training materials for its agents on how to use
- 1:45:35360 value it issued separate endorsements for specific outbuildings to insurers where the insured
- 1:45:41would select the amount let's say you have a detached garage with an ad u and you got your
- 1:45:47insurance in 1990 and in 1990 you said yeah i think i need 100 000 to replace that well csa a took
- 1:45:53about 100 000 and never increased it and never asked you about it again and so if your house burned
- 1:45:59down today they take the position that you chose that in 1990 and that's what you have um csa a
- 1:46:05also stated that it offered code upgrade coverage of 25 but it failed to inform its insurers that
- 1:46:13it wasn't a separate amount it was a sub limit of coverage a and so they thought they had an
- 1:46:18additional 25 to rebuild when in fact they did not um also code upgrade it is really important
- 1:46:25if you have an older home um because older older homes were not built anywhere close to code and
- 1:46:32as we've already mentioned in this presentation the insurance companies only required to put back
- 1:46:37what you had and so if what you had was not up to code unless you have code upgrade coverage
- 1:46:43they're not required to cover it and that's important to understand and that's why it matters
- 1:46:49now in the market conduct report csa was allowed to respond and csa promised the doi that as of
- 1:46:56june 2020 it would provide all of its insurers with the key replacement estimate estimated data points
- 1:47:01including quality grade and an explanation with every renewal and that that would include the
- 1:47:06average construction cost for their geographic area per square foot um if you did not get that and you
- 1:47:13have csa coverage that would be a talking point for you they looked at fair plan too now fair plan
- 1:47:21you're not going to have much success arguing under insurance with fair plan because they have a hard
- 1:47:26three million dollar cap for all of their coverage combined so all of your coverage together is never
- 1:47:32going to add up to more than three million dollars because of this most fair plan insurers in southern
- 1:47:37california will find themselves underinsured what the doi focused on the doi is the department of
- 1:47:42insurance by the way the doi focused on fair plans handling of smoke damage claims houses that don't
- 1:47:49burn to the ground often have an enormous amount of smoke damage and fair plan takes the position
- 1:47:55that unless you can you can demonstrate actual physical damage that it um isn't covered at all
- 1:48:02and that is remains an open issue with fair plan um the department in their response to the department
- 1:48:09of insurance fair plan said we disagree we're not changing our position and the department of
- 1:48:14insurance threatened regulatory action which i don't know what has happened since then um so i don't
- 1:48:21know what that is fair plan was also notorious for failing to meet all required time limits
- 1:48:26which probably isn't surprising many people um nationwide and allied are owned by the same
- 1:48:32company nationwide was forced to pay nationwide and allied were forced to pay out 22 million
- 1:48:37dollars in additional claims payments and refund 165 thousand dollars in premiums a decade earlier
- 1:48:44it had been forced by the department of insurance to include a checkbox on its applications to make
- 1:48:49sure that the agent offered extended replacement cost um nationwide apparently at some point that
- 1:48:55checkbox fell off their application software and didn't nobody knew or paid attention and so many
- 1:49:01many people were not offered extended replacement cost who should have been they also failed to ask
- 1:49:06about other structures on a property so if you had a pool fencing retaining wall septic it wasn't
- 1:49:13included in their replacement cost estimate state farm was required to pay 5.6 million in additional
- 1:49:19claims payments um they failed to update replacement cost estimates after the initial insurance was
- 1:49:25issued regardless of how long ago it was issued um agents were frequently found at state farm to
- 1:49:30have changed the replacement cost to artificially lower it in the hopes of attracting more customers
- 1:49:36thinking that if you're if their amount that they were offering you was less than the competition
- 1:49:41you would go with them but that then results in you being underinsured state farm promised in its
- 1:49:46response that in 2023 all homes in california valued over four million dollars would undergo
- 1:49:52in-person interior and exterior inspection inspection so if your home was um insured at
- 1:49:59four million dollars or more state farm was required to send somebody to do an interior and
- 1:50:03exterior um inspection state farm also determined in its underwriting guide lines that it shouldn't
- 1:50:09use 360 value on homes valued over 750 thousand dollars because it didn't address the level of
- 1:50:15detail required to do it accurately despite that state farm continued to use 360 value on everything
- 1:50:22the last market conduct report is for usa a um usa a was required to make additional
- 1:50:27payments of 5.6 million um when usa a moved um to 360 value in 2016 it did not correct the
- 1:50:36property information in its files it instead adopted the pre-filled information which overwrote
- 1:50:42accurate information and um even though that information remained in their files if they
- 1:50:49had looked they never looked um they also were supposed to automatically include home protector
- 1:50:54endorsement on any policy where the insurance was at least 100 or more of their estimated
- 1:50:59replacement cost value which gives you its extended replacement cost it gives you an extra 25 of
- 1:51:04coverage but usa rarely did that meaning that insurers had access to insurance that they didn't
- 1:51:10know they had and all of those market conduct reports can be found publicly available online
- 1:51:16at the department of insurance website um there are a couple of situations you could run into
- 1:51:23initially in the next few months where you could have serious problems with your policy one of
- 1:51:28those is a rescission an insurance company if you is allowed at any time when they look at your
- 1:51:36application no matter how old the application is to if to see if they can identify any false
- 1:51:42statements on it and if they do they can do what's called rescinding your policy they it's like it
- 1:51:48never existed they pay you back the premiums you paid them over the years and say it was nice knowing
- 1:51:53you they are not required if they rescind a policy to make any payments under it it's like you never
- 1:51:58had insurance um the most common misrepresentations that are that occur are when the home is not
- 1:52:06legally owned by the insured this can be something as simple as your home is technically in a trust
- 1:52:12but the insurance was made out to you individually insurance companies have tried to rescind policies
- 1:52:17based on that um or let's say the home is owned by your elderly parent who isn't able to manage
- 1:52:26shift paperwork very well anymore and so you got updated insurance and it was in your name
- 1:52:32the insurance company may rescind the policy if the insurance comes if the insurance is in your
- 1:52:36name but you don't own the home if you didn't identify a pool on your application and you had
- 1:52:44a pool that's a basis for them to rescind the policy also a number of people in prior wildfires
- 1:52:51found that they fair plan rescinded their coverage because they were growing marijuana on their property
- 1:52:58they didn't the insurance didn't think it was a problem because under state law it was no longer
- 1:53:04considered a crime but if it's if the homes used for anything illegal under state or federal law
- 1:53:10then they are allowed to rescind and under federal law that remains an issue we've also talked about
- 1:53:16the fact that the insurance company cannot cancel you it's true that they cannot cancel you if you
- 1:53:23miss payments however then your insurance policy lapses that's not considered a cancellation it's
- 1:53:30considered um your error um so a lot of people may be finding out now that their auto payment missed
- 1:53:38a payment over the last couple of months and suddenly they don't have insurance the insurance
- 1:53:43company required to inform you if you've missed a premium payment and give you the opportunity
- 1:53:50to make that and it's called a grace period during that grace period you have coverage so if your
- 1:53:56house burned down during the grace period you still have coverage just and if your insurance
- 1:54:01company tells you otherwise that's an issue um if the insurer didn't notify you of the pending
- 1:54:06laps you may still have coverage if they sent it to the wrong address you may still have coverage
- 1:54:12if the insurer previously accepted late or partial payments that were made in a similar manner to the
- 1:54:17one that they're now arguing lapsed your coverage you may still have coverage those are situations
- 1:54:24that could arise in the next few months as you're wending your way through your initial claim
- 1:54:29those are really the only situations where you should need to reach out for help right away
- 1:54:34um otherwise you you should be able to get your claim paid without having to retain assistance
- 1:54:42and without having to give up the money you need to rebuild to any third party
- 1:54:50that is what i was going to talk about in terms of under insurance and if there are any questions
- 1:54:56about that i'm happy to answer them otherwise um john if you want to start
- 1:55:00yeah we we have a good list of general questions that we got a lot of but let's have john go and
- 1:55:07then i'll throw it to everyone um and we'll just go through this list of questions so
- 1:55:12so now we're going to transfer a little bit transition a little bit from talking about
- 1:55:16insurance and the steps you need to take john along with amanda um is are going to talk about
- 1:55:23some potential other avenues of recovery potential lawsuits you're hearing out out
- 1:55:29hearing about out there we just want to kind of quell some misinformation and update you on
- 1:55:34what your rights may be outside of the insurance to recover for the tremendous loss many of you
- 1:55:41have suffered so john if you can kind of give us the basics on how that works all right so um
- 1:55:47i'm going to try to be relatively brief because we're going along here so the litigation process
- 1:55:53is amanda and and the other speakers have said that that should be a secondary consideration
- 1:55:59not it's very important but in terms of the process you've got to focus on your insurance
- 1:56:04claim now and try to get that squared away as best you can and then there is potentially at least
- 1:56:12a litigation remedy that you could try to be made whole essentially right now as you may have
- 1:56:19heard in the media we don't really know the cause and origin for sure of any of these fires calfire
- 1:56:24does their investigation that's the state agency that investigates these things and that's what
- 1:56:28they look for the cause origin origin means where did start causes what caused it and um
- 1:56:35there's been stuff in the in the uh in the media the palisades fire they they say that there was a
- 1:56:42fire on new year's eve caused by fireworks and that may have been somehow a hot spot and it ended
- 1:56:47up causing the palisades fire we don't know for sure there may end up being a viable third party
- 1:56:53that has some liability for having caused that in the eat and fire right now there's a video i
- 1:56:58saw it on on the local news here on channel four on sunday there was a couple that lives in
- 1:57:04al-tadina and they they have a video of a fire right under a electrical uh transmission line
- 1:57:12um at 6 35 p.m. last tuesday uh and that's been the basis i believe of of several complaints that
- 1:57:20have already been filed uh in the eat and fire and i think the other fires are still being
- 1:57:25investigated i'm not really sure uh if they have any ideas about the cause and origin of those but
- 1:57:32so that makes my presentation kind of hypothetical but uh if if for example in the the defendant
- 1:57:39that's been sued in the eat and fire to date um is southern california adison they were the defendant
- 1:57:45in the wilsey fire that uh that dan and i uh litigated pretty hard on one case and i worked on
- 1:57:50about 18 of them um it's what's called an investor owned utility so it's a publicly
- 1:57:57traded corporation but it's not a governmental entity like the los angeles department of water
- 1:58:02and power for example so the reason that's important is there are different considerations
- 1:58:07when you sue a different kind of uh defendant um even though the edison is not a public entity it is
- 1:58:16considered a utility that serves the public and it can be sued on what's called inverse condemnation
- 1:58:24which is the the groveman of the case that's a word lawyers use to say that's the essence of your
- 1:58:30of your cause of action is that you have what's called an inverse condemnation case that's a
- 1:58:35constitutional claim provided for under the uh the california state constitution and the reason
- 1:58:42that's important is because you need to that's the best claim that you can assert against a utility
- 1:58:49or a um or a public entity if there turns out to be some public entity right now i don't know
- 1:58:55that that's the case um but the inverse condemnation claim is important because and actually to kind of
- 1:59:01get back to the point litigation serves to try to make up your shortfall you do your claim and your
- 1:59:06insurance in in woosie we did not you know the the clients that hired us every single one of them
- 1:59:11was under insured their insurance wasn't going to fully make them them whole um and then they you
- 1:59:17know and those people got their policy limits that was my experience by the way was people
- 1:59:21who experienced a total loss essentially got their policy limits on their policy and it takes a lot
- 1:59:26more time than usually to rebuild it takes a long time unfortunately and almost everybody had uh
- 1:59:34exceeded their alternative living expense uh payouts on their insurance policy so that's
- 1:59:41what we we do you hire a lawyer to say okay we need to sue the responsible party and the general
- 1:59:47the general law in california is even if you get paid by your insurance company 100 percent of your
- 1:59:55of your uh the the policy limit um you can still sue the responsible party who injured you for 100
- 2:00:04percent of your loss um there's a legal principle called the collateral source rule that says um
- 2:00:13it's an evidentiary rule and it's a substantive rule which means evidence of insurance it's not
- 2:00:18admissible and evidence of trial it doesn't matter the person that injured you doesn't get to benefit
- 2:00:23from the fact that you were responsible and you got an insurance policy and you paid premiums on
- 2:00:28that policy they shouldn't be able to benefit now there's one caveat to that is the insurance carriers
- 2:00:34have what's called a subrogation right on every policy i've ever seen and what that word means what
- 2:00:39subrogation means is there's two things that can happen the insurance carrier could actually file
- 2:00:46its own complaint against the party that injured you and that's called a subrogation action subrogation
- 2:00:52means that the insurance company stands in the shoes of the injured party they're insured and
- 2:00:58they sue the responsible party they can do that that happened in the in the willsy case for example
- 2:01:05all the insurance companies banded together they hired a firm and they filed their complaint for
- 2:01:10what's called subrogation to try to recover all the money that they paid out to their insurers
- 2:01:16as a result of the fire in willsy they did the same thing in in uh in the thomas fire and and
- 2:01:21that by the way that's the reason i'm going to reference those is that the the immediately preceding
- 2:01:27wildfire litigation in los angeles county uh was the thomas fire which was up in northwest
- 2:01:34la county and ventura county which unfortunately led to those horrible mudslides in monocito where
- 2:01:4120 or 30 people were killed that was in 2017 believe it or not the thomas fire still being
- 2:01:47litigated um then the willsy fire happened in november of 2018 um and that's still being litigated
- 2:01:56too the reason that that's important is number one um there was a subrogation action filed by
- 2:02:03the insurance carriers so when you file your complaint in both those cases that's probably
- 2:02:08what's going to happen here if it turns out that edison is is really going to be sued by people
- 2:02:12at least in eaton right now they are and there may be other there may be other defendants where
- 2:02:17edison may even be a defendant in the other fires but the point is is that the insurance carrier can
- 2:02:25sue and when you sue edison or the the responsible party um the edison is going to say well we get
- 2:02:33a credit because they sued for subrogation the insurance carrier so we should get a credit
- 2:02:38for the money that your insurance carrier paid out so if you have a three million dollar loss
- 2:02:42you got 1.2 million on on your insurance policy you have a short fall of 800 thousand dollars
- 2:02:49you can still sue the the responsible party for 100 of your loss but the insurance carrier has
- 2:02:57a right to say hey you know we paid you and you've been overcompensated now so we want to get part
- 2:03:02of that recovery so so john just do just so i can kind of uh just summarize everything real quick
- 2:03:09and a man to feel free to jump in but just from from from the start hypothetically if a public
- 2:03:15utility or public entity is responsible for this these individuals who lost their homes personal
- 2:03:22property even their personal injury god forbid a wrongful death is tragic as that is they may
- 2:03:27have a viable claim against so call edison or whatever the entity is the defendant may be they
- 2:03:34can sue them under this inverse condonation and then they are entitled to what are the the options
- 2:03:41of damages i know we've talked a lot about here loss of use when you deal with the insurance you
- 2:03:46talk about are they responsible to rebuild your home to give you what is the value of the home the
- 2:03:52day before the fire interest all those things what what is the items of damages that the people on
- 2:03:58here may be entitled to if it is true that so call edison is responsible for the damages in the losses
- 2:04:06amanda or john whoever wants to john go first and i'll i'll jump in if i need to in the woosy fire
- 2:04:14as an example uh they repeat there were a couple deaths so there's a there's a potential wrong
- 2:04:18there's obviously wrongful death k claim on those cases there were emotional distress claims there
- 2:04:24was obviously all the property that you lost the the real property and personal property you also
- 2:04:31can recover for loss of use of your property from the date of the incident the date that it was destroyed
- 2:04:37to the date that it's actually restored and you can move back in um and then under under inverse
- 2:04:42condemnation the reason that's such a good claim is that and not only do you get loss of use um
- 2:04:50you can sue to recover all of your lost personal property you can you can obtain damages for
- 2:04:56for um pre-judgment interest your attorney's fees you can get your uh expert witnesses uh their cost
- 2:05:04paid for and then the general rule for loss of real property is you get the lesser of
- 2:05:09of diminution in value to the property as a result of the injury or cost of repair however
- 2:05:16there's without going all the tall grass the orndor versus christiana case says that if you
- 2:05:22have a bona fide interest to repair your property which definitely applies i've i've done this a lot
- 2:05:27i've never ever lost that you say no we have a bona fide interest especially in your primary
- 2:05:32residents to rebuild that property even if the cost of rebuild it would be more than what they
- 2:05:37would say the diminution value would be you can get cost of repair so what that mean and and by the
- 2:05:42way all right let's yeah let's let's break that down a little bit let's break that down a little
- 2:05:46bit for so so hypothetically you have a million dollar home you've been there for 40 years and
- 2:05:52you love it you want to rebuild that home your insurance is only 300 000 let's say hypothetically
- 2:06:00then you would you would sue and you would say well we want we're asking for the full cost it
- 2:06:07will cost to repair it in today's dollars so it's not it's not how much you paid for it back in 1960
- 2:06:1450 000 dollars who knows it's what is the cost it will cost to replace what i had the day before
- 2:06:19the fire in the dollars of the date it will be start to be rebuilt is that correct that's getting
- 2:06:25into some of this tone grass as well because dan and i tell with that on our case but yes amanda
- 2:06:30why don't you i mean that your your comments or thoughts on this yeah so it's um as john said the
- 2:06:38law allows you to recover when we're talking about the rebuild of property the law allows you to
- 2:06:44recover the cost of rebuild or the diminished value of the property whichever is less unless
- 2:06:52you have a genuine desire to rebuild the property at that point you can get the higher cost of
- 2:07:00rebuild but that higher cost of rebuild needs to be reasonable in light of the prefire value
- 2:07:08and the value of the property after you rebuild it so i did a i did cases in the butte fire which
- 2:07:16is in calaveras county they have huge forested properties with very small houses i had a client
- 2:07:21whose property was worth 800 000 before the fire it would have cost tens of millions of dollars to
- 2:07:32restore that property because they had barns they had um they had a large trees all of that
- 2:07:41no one is go no court is going to give you tens of millions of dollars to restore a property
- 2:07:48that before the fire was only worth 800 000 so there is going to be you can get more than it was worth
- 2:07:55but there is going to be a cap on that a reasonableness cap there's cases that have you know gone up
- 2:08:02there's no hard line let me just say that there's no hard line but there is there is a cap there
- 2:08:09um you want to talk more about real property or
- 2:08:13real property or real property right um well what i was going to say is but yeah look that's why
- 2:08:18that's why it's a good idea to hire somebody with experience in inverse condemnation and and wildfires
- 2:08:24there's a there's a case in california where there was a a road built by someone that without the
- 2:08:29permission of the of the property owner and they chopped down a bunch of trees and it actually
- 2:08:34increased the value of the property uh after the road was built but the the owner said no it was my
- 2:08:41home and i want those trees it was a beautiful forest and and he's successfully sued even though
- 2:08:46the value went up but the point is you have a right to sue the responsible party for for a 100%
- 2:08:53of your loss and as with again with some hypothetical considerations there will be a claim in by edison
- 2:09:01most in the eat and fire if they're to defend it or whoever the defendant may be that they should
- 2:09:06be getting a credit for the money that you received from your carrier but but the collateral source
- 2:09:12will says that's not absolute and then again when they file the lawsuit like they did in and wills in
- 2:09:18willsy and thomas um that was that was kind of the protocol and that's the way that they they did it
- 2:09:25and if i if i could say one a couple other things real quick and then we can answer questions um one
- 2:09:30of the things that dan and i have heard of people and i've spoken to two people both of whom it
- 2:09:35told me that this has happened in the in al-tadina that they've got again they've got law firms saying
- 2:09:40oh you've you've got to file right now or else you're going to be back in the end of the line and
- 2:09:45and um you know that the edison made a clear bankruptcy and all this stuff that shows you
- 2:09:51that lawyer doesn't know what what preferences are in a bankruptcy filing and that's not how these
- 2:09:56cases work uh the last two cases in l.a county superior court which using history as a guide
- 2:10:02when there's a large number of these plaintiffs they do what's called coordination they coordinate
- 2:10:07the the cases so every plaintiff the files they're complained will be assigned to the same judge and
- 2:10:13the same courtroom and then that that coordinated case they will organize the leadership of that
- 2:10:19so that they can organize how much how discovery is done etc but given the fact that they're coordinated
- 2:10:26uh subject to to statues of limitations you're under no rush to file your case because it's not
- 2:10:34going to matter the date of filing they're going to coordinate coordinate everything they're going
- 2:10:39to start to litigate the case um woosie was interrupted by the covid uh lockdown stuff but
- 2:10:46that the point is is that they were starting to do what's called bellwether cases where they literally
- 2:10:52picked them out of a hat uh and started the process of the defendants and the plaintiffs choosing what
- 2:10:57what case they actually wanted to go forward none of which did but the point is none of that had
- 2:11:02anything to do with the date you file your complaint you have so so so yeah so yeah so so we could
- 2:11:08obviously go down there's a lot to talk about in this this is a very nuanced area of the law and
- 2:11:13that's why when you're talking to these attorneys or people especially in this eat and fire that could
- 2:11:18because there's potential claim just make sure whoever you're talking to ask them these questions
- 2:11:24and make sure they're they know inverse condemnation I mean we have two great experts here but there's
- 2:11:29many other great ones out there but there's a lot who I've seen out there who are claiming to be
- 2:11:33experts but they've never handled a wildfire case as Amanda knows who's handled a lot John knows that
- 2:11:39they're very nuanced and it's a very nuanced area of the law that you just make want to make sure
- 2:11:43that you're in good hands and don't rush into something because people are trying to scare you
- 2:11:48into it right now the most important thing as we've discussed get your insurance claims that's why
- 2:11:53we really want to spend a lot of time on that like Stacy Dave Amanda everyone's been talking about
- 2:11:59we just on this litigation this is not to scare you or have you rush into it we just want you to
- 2:12:04be aware in the back of your mind you may have other avenues there because what you're going
- 2:12:08through is terrible and unfortunately insurance is obviously much less than what you need we just
- 2:12:13want you to we just want to comment on it so you know your rights there'll be a whole probably
- 2:12:17another webinar on it and all that there's a lot of areas we can discuss but just just any final
- 2:12:22words on that Amanda or John before I want to get back to the questions on insurance any final words
- 2:12:27on any potential utility litigation Amanda any final words then I'll go to John. Just to say
- 2:12:35you had asked what someone can recover in a litigation that isn't covered by insurance
- 2:12:41in addition to the uninsured portion of the you know the underinsured property losses
- 2:12:49John touched on the fact that if you've lost a loved one in the fire you can make a claim for
- 2:12:55wrongful death which is the loss of relationship support and compassion that you had with that
- 2:13:03person the other thing that you will have that that all of the people who evacuated people
- 2:13:11who lost their homes will have sustained that's not going to be covered by insurance is emotional
- 2:13:16distress claims and there are two of those just generally one kind of is related to the trauma
- 2:13:23from evacuating from your property during the time of the fire which is an incredibly traumatic
- 2:13:30situation the other is called it's a claim called nuisance which I find to be a kind of a you know
- 2:13:36silly term because it sounds so trivial but nuisance is the mental anguish for the loss of
- 2:13:45use and enjoyment of your home and the displacement the I lost that the emotional feeling that you
- 2:13:51have of the I lost my home I'm not in my home I've lost my belongings you know that is something
- 2:13:59that I'm sure a lot of people are already experiencing that is a claim that you can get
- 2:14:04financial compensation for if there is a defendant a viable person company on the other end of a
- 2:14:10lawsuit so there are some under insured claims and then there are claims which aren't even covered
- 2:14:17by insurance because insurance doesn't cover your emotional distress you know that that's a good
- 2:14:22point that's what's going to say in addition to inverse condemnation there are several tort
- 2:14:26claims that are usually part of these cases which are nuisance and trespass there's even a
- 2:14:31there's even a potential statutory claim in these wildfires but the point is is that as we said you
- 2:14:37can get the cost to repair your property you can get the loss of use for the time from the date that
- 2:14:42it was injured to the date it's restored to its you by the way you have a you have a right to
- 2:14:47recover what you had on the day of the fire is what you have you don't have to build in the
- 2:14:52litigation context you don't even have to rebuild anything you just have a right to to recover for
- 2:14:57what you lost but but those those tort claims are important because the nuisance claim is absolutely
- 2:15:03I know in the Woolsey fire that was that was part of almost every claim and it was actually
- 2:15:08people were able to recover you know a fairly substantial amount of money that and that's
- 2:15:12completely outside the the context of insurance and then also is it just the the distress you I
- 2:15:19mean you're fleeing from a fire that emotional distress and the fear it's horrible and that was
- 2:15:24a big deal in Woolsey and it's going to be a big deal in some of these fires too I think so that
- 2:15:28that's the benefit of litigation to put make up the shortfall and to get damages that aren't really
- 2:15:34available under insurance so so the final thing is the statute of limitations that people should
- 2:15:39know about in these yeah if it's it's a little complicated but I'll try to be very brief if
- 2:15:45it's an investor owned utility like Addison which is a private even though it's a publicly
- 2:15:50traded corporation it's not a public entity like a governmental entity like DWP you have three years
- 2:15:55that's the statute limitation for injured injury to property of three years I think wrongful death
- 2:16:01may be one year but it's not it's two okay yeah two anyway it's two you so just to be clear because
- 2:16:11so so on the personal injury side you have two years from the date of the incident to file
- 2:16:16your lawsuit two years from the date of the incident until to file your lawsuit that's
- 2:16:23that's the statute limitations there and then what if it's a governmental entity okay that that's
- 2:16:27different because again if against Addison and the Eden fire since they're the defendant and it
- 2:16:32seems like again DWP doesn't serve Altadena so if in fact it's an electrical that's the cause
- 2:16:40you've got three years to to file your claim and as I said the way this is going to play out if it
- 2:16:44does become a big case it's coordinated you know the date you file is not going to matter how you
- 2:16:53resolve if you just file an inverse condemnation claim that's outside the government code says
- 2:16:58that's outside the government claim process you have three years to to file your claim if it is a
- 2:17:03governmental entity then you have to file what's called a government claim within six months of
- 2:17:08the incident if then the government has 45 days to respond if they don't respond then you have
- 2:17:15two years from the date of the incident to file your claim if they if they do respond to deny
- 2:17:23I believe that's also six months from that date of the denial to file your lawsuit
- 2:17:29yeah so the time it's three years for property damage it's two years for personal injury and
- 2:17:38emotional distress is included in personal injury so if it just be clear it's not it's it's only
- 2:17:45three years for property damage but you there are some sooner time limits right yeah but here's the
- 2:17:50bottom line we're not suggesting you wait a long time to do this we're just saying that if somebody
- 2:17:54is pressuring you sign it now they're declare bankruptcy and somehow there's some advantage
- 2:17:59to filing today as opposed to 60 days from now that's not true you should absolutely obviously
- 2:18:05this is going to be the first thing on your mind obviously is dealing with this and you should get
- 2:18:12a skilled lawyer I think an inverse condemnation that's what I recommend and you should ask them
- 2:18:17if they've ever litigated wildfires because there's a lot of that there's there's some there's some
- 2:18:22specificity to that and these the experience of dealing with these coordinated cases I think is
- 2:18:27beneficial but you have time and you should take your time to pick the right lawyer and it again
- 2:18:35if there is a viable you know defendant that has the wherewithal to pay this it's obviously something
- 2:18:42you want to do because almost everybody's going to be you know that their their actual injuries
- 2:18:47and damages are going to be more than what they're going to receive on their insurance policy.
- 2:18:52All right on that let's let's go to some some of these final questions here. Let's see what deems
- 2:19:00uh and I'll throw this to the whole group try to do rapid fire here what deems a property that was
- 2:19:04damaged but not destroyed uninhabitable. That's going to be a fight with your insurance company
- 2:19:11or a discussion I should say that will be a discussion with your insurance company.
- 2:19:15If if uninhabitable or any type of similar word is used in your policy start there look at the
- 2:19:22language surrounding it look to see if it's a defined term otherwise that that could be a
- 2:19:28sticking point if the insurance company says there's no reason you can't live in there and you
- 2:19:32you argue that there is smoke damage is a big component of that a lot of people say they can't
- 2:19:37breathe and the insurance company says sure you can and these are the situations where people
- 2:19:44start getting frustrated and may want outside help but not most people aren't going to encounter
- 2:19:51this most people will get paid out and be done. So under California law under California law to
- 2:19:57have your property be habitable you do have to have electricity, heat, running, hot and cold water
- 2:20:04so if your utilities are impacted even if your property is not destroyed your property is deemed
- 2:20:10uninhabitable. Smoke damage if you really get into a fight with your insurance company there are
- 2:20:18companies that can do air quality testing to show whether or not the air in your home is toxic and
- 2:20:26unsafe for humans. And so I'm guessing if LEDWP says do not drink the water that probably makes
- 2:20:32it uninhabitable correct? Yeah okay. So darn good, darn good argument. Yeah. A couple of
- 2:20:40lots of questions on how much smoke damage causes a total loss what about soil contamination
- 2:20:47is it probably not defined like that is it? Exactly it's not defined for smoke damage it's
- 2:20:52going the insurance company is going to encourage you to have it cleaned. If you have it cleaned
- 2:20:58and it's still damaged it smells it's it's not working a lot of things are subtly warped by the
- 2:21:04heat around the house even if the house didn't burn down these are all issues to look at. Again
- 2:21:11it's something you're going to have to negotiate individually with your insurance company different
- 2:21:15companies and different adjusters may take different positions. So soil contamination so what is
- 2:21:21likely going to happen and I've seen talk of this with government agencies but I don't know if they
- 2:21:28specifically stated this is that FEMA working with the Army Corps of Engineers working with the
- 2:21:35Office of Emergency Services for the state of California will likely come in and scrape the
- 2:21:41lots where the dwelling was and that is mainly because when your house burns down you got
- 2:21:48batteries in your house you may have paint in your house and so those toxins do get into the
- 2:21:54soil and so they will come in Army Corps of Engineers and scrape those lots so that the
- 2:22:03hazardous material is removed. If you go back to your property if you're allowed back to your
- 2:22:09property before your lot scrape please take precautions steel boots is a good thing and
- 2:22:1695 mask is a good thing because think about the things the electronics that you had in your house
- 2:22:22all of that technology is melted and into the ground but FEMA and the Army Corps of Engineers
- 2:22:28will likely come in and scrape all of those lots. Insurance companies will generally cover that cost
- 2:22:34under your debris removal coverage. They did that in the Woolsey fire they scraped off that they had
- 2:22:41the Department of Health or somebody but in LA County they did it so they will presumably do it
- 2:22:46neat and all these places actually. Yeah they generally do it they also work closely with
- 2:22:53like the Department of Environmental Health for the county to ensure people about the air quality
- 2:23:00and the soil quality so that people are feeling more comfortable about going back to their lots.
- 2:23:07Insurers are asking for photos or videos of our property but we're not allowed back in the
- 2:23:11neighborhood. Do you just wait until you can or anything else you can do Dave? You have to wait
- 2:23:19if you weren't able to sneak in I know a lot of people try to sneak in taking pictures and videos
- 2:23:24they are providing satellite images now for a lot of the areas so you can use that that's pretty
- 2:23:32it's becoming pretty clear at least for homes that are completely damaged for ones that obviously
- 2:23:38are still standing unfortunately you're probably not going to get a really good look until you're
- 2:23:43able to get back in so unfortunately until then your options are limited. Lots of questions
- 2:23:51or go ahead Amanda. At some point Cal Fire is going to issue a damage inspection report their
- 2:23:58DINs report which goes address by address and lists properties that are destroyed more or less than
- 2:24:0550% damaged and undamaged that's probably going to take a while though you'll probably have dealt
- 2:24:12with your insurance before then but if there are you know debates about whether or not you're in
- 2:24:18the fire zone that DINs report to put Cal Fire damage inspection report is going to be helpful.
- 2:24:24Lots and lots of questions what if fair plan runs out of money I don't know if anyone here has the
- 2:24:30answer to that but I can walk through I mean David do you want to go I mean I'll go ahead I'll
- 2:24:37supplement it we need to yeah there there is a process they have a certain amount of cash on hand
- 2:24:44after that then it go they have reinsurance through other insurance companies that will cover it if
- 2:24:52the reinsurance is used up because they have a few billion dollars of reinsurance but there's a good
- 2:24:58chance that this is going to go beyond that then all of the insurance companies in California who
- 2:25:05are required to support the fair plan are going to be asked to kick in yeah that's that's all we
- 2:25:12know that's that's how that's how it works and we don't know beyond that I would imagine that the
- 2:25:17insurance companies may push back on it they are required to do it under the agreements they've
- 2:25:24entered into with the state but I can't imagine they're going to do so happily I think we touch
- 2:25:29touch on this but I think it's do we start to pay our mortgage if our house was destroyed
- 2:25:34yes yes although you know definitely reach out there's you know you can get a forbearance
- 2:25:43make it some sort of an agreement you know with your mortgage company if for any reason they
- 2:25:49let's say they credit you and say you don't have to pay the next four months be aware that they will
- 2:25:55tack that four months on to the the end of your your mortgage so you're not getting anything for
- 2:26:01free you're just maybe getting a temporary reprieve yeah forbearance is not forgiveness right it's a
- 2:26:07delay lots of questions on people who were in the process of renovating and renovations were underway
- 2:26:15what if the insurance hadn't changed since the reno started possibly completed construction ad use
- 2:26:23there are there are a few issues with this the insurance company is going to take the position
- 2:26:28that if you didn't tell them that they're not responsible for the additional value to your home
- 2:26:36also there are policies there are policies where if you're if you were undergoing significant
- 2:26:42renovation you may have needed a some separate insurance coverage for during the renovation it
- 2:26:48is possible and i'm not trying to scare anyone i just want to alert you to this it's possible
- 2:26:53that your current insurance doesn't provide coverage while your house is being renovated
- 2:26:59and that means it is possible you could find yourself uninsured i'm not saying that that is
- 2:27:05the case at all i'm saying you should look into it because you don't want to find this out
- 2:27:11further down the road so so i know this is unrelated but anyone i guess the recommendation
- 2:27:18for anyone doing remodel reach out to your insurance make sure you have coverage while you
- 2:27:26remodeling correct so um from a homeowner's perspective there's two things that usually
- 2:27:33should do if it's anything um that requires maybe demolition anything more than just you know
- 2:27:39you know minor cosmetic work you should always inform your uh homeowners insurance company
- 2:27:46that you're doing this work and what's called it's it's home under construction endorsement
- 2:27:52anything that's anything significant uh is usually as as Stacey alluded to could be voided
- 2:27:58in your policy for coverage and you do need what's called a builder's risk policy um and or of course
- 2:28:04the construction so um you know uh if if you were doing major construction um you know that again
- 2:28:13that could be an issue if you did not alert your insurance company or have supplemental coverage um
- 2:28:19and then um same same with a commercial people okay a lot of people are concerned that they took
- 2:28:27FEMA funds already but have insurance should they do something should they self report or anything it
- 2:28:34doesn't hurt to self report i it's like i said FEMA uses the terms uninsured and underinsured
- 2:28:42and they do not define them well but they're very clear that your insurance your losses
- 2:28:48need to be covered by your insurance before being covered by FEMA so yes i would self report and see
- 2:28:55if that needs to be resolved and document when and who you talk to uh what if um you have a very
- 2:29:03high deductible that you can't afford will FEMA can FEMA cover that i've not seen them cover that in
- 2:29:10the past i don't know if they'll do that this time that's a question to ask but i've not seen that in
- 2:29:15the past um let's see this is a question can can you please let us know if there's anything that
- 2:29:23HOA homeowners people living in condos or master plan community should keep in mind regarding
- 2:29:29property insurance claims and rebuilding um those get very tricky um because the
- 2:29:41well if there is that's a condo with an HOA the person only owns the inside of the four walls
- 2:29:47and the HOA can sell the entire thing they can choose to rebuild they can choose not to rebuild
- 2:29:54and then you are in a situation where you as the condo owner do not have the choice
- 2:30:03i think that's the same for any complex where the HOA owns the land and owns the property and
- 2:30:09gets to decide so i would say keep in contact with your HOA representatives the HOA president
- 2:30:19find out who what their insurance is find out what their intentions are ask them to keep everybody
- 2:30:26update that does get tricky because you know versus owning a single family home where you own the
- 2:30:31home and the property and you get to make the decision on what you're going to rebuild you
- 2:30:36don't have that the same decision when there's an HOA involved especially if it's a condo or an
- 2:30:41apartment and you need to look at what's called the CC and ours which are essentially the bylaws
- 2:30:47of those kinds of corporate mutual benefit corporations so if you have those you should
- 2:30:52look me probably need to talk to a lawyer but you're right there's uh there's a distinction between
- 2:30:56the common areas and the and the you know the separate the portion of the complex that the owner
- 2:31:03owns but and there are a lot of attorneys in the state of california that do specialize in HOA
- 2:31:09issues it's not a practice area i do but there's a number of firms you can you can find who specialize
- 2:31:15in HOA issues yeah um a couple of final questions here uh if i had a total loss does umbrella
- 2:31:23insurance work with HOA insurance dave you probably no no umbrella insurance uh really goes to uh
- 2:31:31liability and because this is a property claim this uh um unfortunate umbrella policies do not
- 2:31:37cover that yeah umbrella policies are usually i did something wrong and i have to pay somebody
- 2:31:43and i have extra coverage to protect my assets versus someone hurt my destroyed my property which
- 2:31:49is is not generally covered by an umbrella the only thing i would say is the distinction though is
- 2:31:54some people sometimes conflate what is an umbrella policy versus what is an excess policy so you can
- 2:32:00have excess property coverage which would then supplement on top of your primary policy so
- 2:32:07that would be different so if you do have an excess property policy then obviously uh then that would
- 2:32:14be to your benefit and you definitely would make a claim assuming that the claim the property
- 2:32:18damage exceeds your primary and that's a good reason to make claims under any policies you have
- 2:32:25it's better to get a denial than find out later that you could have had coverage and you didn't
- 2:32:29right um lots of questions about what if i'm a landlord do i get loss of use if i wasn't there
- 2:32:36where if i didn't live in the property yes and um yes you you if you are a landlord you should have
- 2:32:45a and david may be able to speak more to this you should have a policy that is specific to a
- 2:32:52landlord to renters a landlord policy rather than a homeowner policy yeah and that includes
- 2:32:59that includes fair rental value which means you should be able to have that income replaced
- 2:33:05every month until the place is rebuilt or habitable again that that's true in the litigation
- 2:33:13context too if you're a landlord you've got you you can recover the rental income
- 2:33:18so it's called different things but it's kind of you get your money but it's it's a different
- 2:33:23kind of policy and it's called different things yeah and by the way you want to definitely check
- 2:33:27your policy because it's not necessarily a given that you have that coverage so you want to make
- 2:33:32sure that you do have that coverage in place so there are some some cares there you are a landlord
- 2:33:40and you are renting uh that you're whether it's a dwelling or another type of structure and sometimes
- 2:33:47you you would have wanted to make sure your agent brought put that coverage or the insurance
- 2:33:51care put that coverage but it's not a given so you want to definitely check your policy to make sure
- 2:33:56you have it okay all right well um I know that we went way over but we just think it's so important
- 2:34:07I know everyone on here really believes that we just want to you know give you as much information
- 2:34:11as we can we know that there was a lot here that we unpacked um and we do have materials that the
- 2:34:19BHBA will be sending out to every single person who registered there'll be a packet that Stacy and
- 2:34:25Amanda and the rest of the speakers put together and there's a link in materials that I know they've
- 2:34:30been put on a google drive throughout this webinar on a chat they will also be emailed a recording
- 2:34:35of this will live on the BHBA youtube page so feel free to send it around again we know this is a
- 2:34:42lot of information you all are just suffering tremendous loss here and have a lot to think about
- 2:34:48like I said haven't slept so you can rewatch this or replay this look at the materials I know all of
- 2:34:54these speakers here are willing to help any any chance they get anything you need just let us know
- 2:35:00just to simple questions that I know we didn't get to we'll be happy to help and I think again the
- 2:35:05moral of the story is that a lot of this can be done without having to hire somebody to do it so
- 2:35:12the money that you need right now you you you should be able to get 100 of the insurance that
- 2:35:19is owed to you without having to hire someone only in the situations where it does become the
- 2:35:25insurance company is not working with you that's where people like Stacy come in and there's many
- 2:35:28great attorneys out there but we just want to give you the tools to help you get back on track
- 2:35:35because from the bottom of our hearts we we truly are so sorry for whatever one is dealing with and
- 2:35:41want to do whatever we can to help you get on the road to recovery so thank you for tuning in
- 2:35:46any last comments no all right well um so with that we will end this webinar thank you for tuning
- 2:35:54in I know the Beverly Hills Bar Association will be coming out with many more to help people through
- 2:35:59this really tough process right now so thank you for tuning in take care this program and the
- 2:36:07associated written materials are provided for informational purposes only and are not intended
- 2:36:12and must not be taken as legal advice on any particular set of facts or circumstances you
- 2:36:17should not act or refrain from acting on the basis of any content included in this program
- 2:36:22without seeking legal or other professional advice on your specific matter this program contains
- 2:36:27general information and may not reflect current legal developments or address your specific
- 2:36:32situation this program and the associated written materials are not intended as a solicitation