Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA's New Exam Entry Letter: What Changed and What It Means for Your Exam
Transcript
- 0:00Mark Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Trakel with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03Today we are going to be talking about NCUA's new exam entry letter that they
- 0:08issued late July, early Auglu- August that goes out for all of their exams.
- 0:13I'm excited to be back with Todd Miller and Steve Farr.
- 0:16Guys, how you doing today?
- 0:19Steve Farrar: Good ⦠enjoying that we now have a, a fall coming through.
- 0:22Cooler mornings, cooler evenings
- 0:25Mark Treichel: That's fantastic.
- 0:26Hey, I did a short podcast this week talking about the podcasts
- 0:30that we've got coming up.
- 0:31We did a pre-game to this one.
- 0:33I think we added maybe two or three that I'm gonna have to that list.
- 0:36I'm not gonna talk about them here for obvious reasons, but it's gonna
- 0:39be exci- an exciting fourth quarter of of content coming up here.
- 0:42But I'm excited about the exam entry letter and for a if someone hasn't
- 0:47listened before, why don't you give your backgrounds at NCUA before, before
- 0:51you changed teams and started helping me a few years back what was going on.
- 0:56So who wants to go first today?
- 0:58Steve Farrar: Go ahead, Todd.
- 1:00Todd Miller: This is Todd.
- 1:01I was with NCUA for just a couple months short of 34 years, from
- 1:051987 through 2021 when I retired.
- 1:09During my tenure at NCUA, I spent a lot of it as a problem
- 1:11case officer and an examiner.
- 1:14I spent a decade as a regional capital markets specialist, and spent just
- 1:18a little over a decade as a director of special actions in the western
- 1:22region supervising problem case officers, capital markets specialists,
- 1:26regional lending specialists.
- 1:28Very enjoyable 34 years.
- 1:30Learned a lot, dealt with a lot of troubled credit unions, had a lot
- 1:34of rewarding experiences, involved in quite a few conservatorships.
- 1:38Returned a couple of those to the members, which were probably highlights
- 1:42of my career, and both of those credit unions are still in existence today.
- 1:46All in all, met a lot of people, enjoyed my entire tenure with
- 1:50the NCUA for the whole 34 years.
- 1:55Well- And then I retired in 2021, and Mark let me have a vacation for
- 2:00about 45 days, and then he called me.
- 2:02"So you wanna have dinner?"
- 2:04And he said, "Do you wanna come to work for me and help out credit unions?"
- 2:07And I said, "Sure, sounds fun."
- 2:08And it has been.
- 2:10Mark Treichel: It has been fun and the that was about five years ago.
- 2:13I had some memories that popped up from from my trip out west when
- 2:16that happened and time flies, guys.
- 2:20Steve.
- 2:22Steve Farrar: Yeah.
- 2:22My, much of my career is a lot like, like Todd's.
- 2:25So I was ⦠H- he said they were all enjoyable.
- 2:28He didn't even say any complaints about the year of the corporate
- 2:32crisis- ⦠which was not quite as much.
- 2:34But except for that, everything was good.
- 2:36I was in for 30-plus years.
- 2:37First 15 years was out in the field, primarily as a problem case
- 2:41officer, and like Todd, involved in conservatorships, liquidations.
- 2:45Work- workouts were the best.
- 2:47The liquidations were not so fun.
- 2:50And then I followed Mark when he went into the central office and went into
- 2:53the Division of Risk Management and s- spent another basically 15 years there.
- 2:58And that one was a great job because it just changed all the
- 3:01time in what I was working on.
- 3:03And I got involved in the calculation of the reserves for the insurance
- 3:07fund for losses and the enforcement manual, which was fun to do.
- 3:13My favorite thing was I did a training for a week for problem resolution that
- 3:18all examiners went through, and a big part of that was we worked on communications,
- 3:22and that's what we'll be talking about today, is how communications is the key.
- 3:27And then towards the end of my career, I worked on risk-based capital and
- 3:30that, that burned up a few years.
- 3:32And then ended up as the vice president of the CLF and at the end of their career,
- 3:36and then, we've been enjoying this now.
- 3:38We were talking about how long we've been doing this, Mark.
- 3:40Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 3:41Steve Farrar: It's, we're at year six now.
- 3:42Mark Treichel: It's in year six.
- 3:43Yeah, it's amazing.
- 3:44It's simply amazing.
- 3:45And you said a week long, it was a week-long class.
- 3:48Not that you did that one week, but that was a week-long class
- 3:50on problem resolution where you essentially would train everybody
- 3:54that came through the door, right?
- 3:56Todd Miller: Yeah.
- 3:56For multiple years he did that.
- 3:57Mark Treichel: Yep.
- 3:58Steve Farrar: Yeah.
- 3:58Todd Miller: Steve threw a dig about corporate, so I did
- 4:01have a lost year at WestCor.
- 4:03Steve never mentions this, but he was a corporate examiner
- 4:06for a short period of time.
- 4:07Were you not?
- 4:08Steve Farrar: Yeah, I, when I was in that WestCor, I looked at their
- 4:11IT, which was not the problem.
- 4:14Mark Treichel: Steve and To- Todd, you both said that you
- 4:16mostly enjoyed all of your time.
- 4:19I enjoyed all my time except for the time that I didn't, and I won't go into
- 4:22that, all right I digress a little bit.
- 4:24So we're gonna talk about the exam ent- entry letter which gets
- 4:28into communication and they made a substantive change to this.
- 4:33Guys, where do you wanna start o- on this?
- 4:35Is there one particular topic?
- 4:37Do you wanna walk through the letter?
- 4:38Do you wannaâ¦
- 4:39i've got some ideas on how to drive this, but I like to let you guys go first,
- 4:43Steve Farrar: you can be the driver
- 4:44Mark Treichel: Okay.
- 4:45All right You're fine.
- 4:46Very good.
- 4:46So I'm gonna pull up one more document here.
- 4:50So E- notes that I had tied to the exam focus now being defined business decisions
- 4:57limited questions not equaling concerns.
- 5:01This is just a highlight.
- 5:02On- only final report is actionable, which is a loaded statement.
- 5:06Agreeable corrective actions, which is interesting.
- 5:09Compensation contracts and pricing off limits.
- 5:12And a hint there will be that might be one of our future podcasts.
- 5:15Exit meetings being recording voluntary VPN access, CUSO records
- 5:21director audit context spelled out privacy and secure portable.
- 5:25Por- portal, excuse me.
- 5:27But let's go back to the first one I mentioned there.
- 5:29The exam now has a stated focused, focus.
- 5:33The prior template said something like, "It did not define or limit
- 5:37the substantive focus of the exam.
- 5:39Scope was whatever the exam team decided it was."
- 5:43The new template says, "The exam will focus on safety and soundness and on
- 5:46compliance of credit union operations, significant compliance with applicable
- 5:51laws and regulations, and whether there is a material financial risk."
- 5:55Thoughts on that particular side of this.
- 5:59Steve Farrar: That, that statement, material financial risk, is the biggest
- 6:03one and it's also really predominant, and you'll see it in the other regulators.
- 6:09That's really been a, a shift and change of defining what the exams are trying to
- 6:15do to focus on material financial risk.
- 6:17And it's an offset from the Silicon Valley Bank failure in that, they had
- 6:22the examiners in there, and they were all ⦠they were writing things up about what
- 6:27was going on there and missed the boat
- 6:31Mark Treichel: Makes-
- 6:32No that, that makes perfect sense.
- 6:33And Todd, any thoughts on that specific change?
- 6:37Todd Miller: Yeah.
- 6:38It's somewhat interesting.
- 6:40You can drive a truck through, the barn door of what is material, because it's
- 6:47not really defined by NCUA or anyone else.
- 6:51So what's material?
- 6:53That's a-- it's a big decision.
- 6:55But I think some of this is just comes back to the reorganization.
- 6:59NCUA lost 27% of their people.
- 7:02I think the FDIC lost roughly a third.
- 7:04I don't know what the number is for the OCC, other than I talked to a
- 7:08banker recently here in Montana, and his OCC examiners came from seven
- 7:13different states, and they said they were all young people who knew nothing.
- 7:18But I think it's just down to the fact that they have limited staff and
- 7:22they're trying to play triage, and then they don't really have time to be
- 7:26looking at things that are not material.
- 7:29It's an offset to that.
- 7:30But we've seen this from all three regulators, over the last couple
- 7:34years, where there's a whole focus on anything brought up in the exam, in
- 7:40the case of a credit union, a document resolution or exam finding has to
- 7:44be tied to a specific regulation.
- 7:47And NCUA used to have a specific reg just on the insurance agreement
- 7:51that would be a catch-all.
- 7:53Examiners have been told not to cite that other than in extremely
- 7:56rare conditions, where it used to be their most common citation.
- 8:01But I think, this whole thing focusing around material, it's, let the industry
- 8:05move and adapt, and it's a fallout of the fact that they have limited time.
- 8:12They have to limit that focus to just material stuff.
- 8:16So a lot of different things coming into play there with that
- 8:19Mark Treichel: And along those lines you highlighted limited limited
- 8:25use of the safety and soundness.
- 8:26What, like you said it used to be the main crux.
- 8:29Everything would drive back through the safety and soundness rule
- 8:32because they were told you can't cite guidance and you can't cite sound
- 8:37business practices, but you could use the safety and soundness link.
- 8:41And we're gonna ha- L- later this week for future release the FDIC and OCC
- 8:45came out with a definition of safety and soundness which my guess is probably
- 8:50talks about material financial risk there.
- 8:53And then also material financial risk, if I remember right, I'm almost certain
- 8:58I am, the proposed CAMELS rule that has been put out by the FFIEC for all banking
- 9:04regulators incl- including NCUA, relies heavily on the material financial risk.
- 9:09So this this rewrite of this letter I think also positions them so
- 9:13they don't have to rewrite it when that, that- New Campbell's Rule is
- 9:19finali- finalized by the FFIEC after they take their comment period.
- 9:24Does that make sense?
- 9:25Todd Miller: Yep.
- 9:26I think there's a couple other things in the letter too.
- 9:28So NCUA had unwritten rules and things that were buried in different versions
- 9:33of their national supervisory policy manual that now they've made explicit
- 9:38in this letter to the credit unions.
- 9:40And one of those is on the significant issues.
- 9:44Examiners will work with credit union management, and that's always
- 9:48been an unwritten rule, that as you figure out corrective actions, you
- 9:51should sit down with management.
- 9:53What are they capable of doing?
- 9:54You're not supposed to give them doors that they absolutely cannot
- 9:58meet and fail on, and that's always been an unwritten rule.
- 10:02The reality is, in most cases, examiners write up a draft door
- 10:06without even talking to management, and then that discussion occurs.
- 10:09This is more explicit, saying, "Hey, this is the way it is supposed to happen.
- 10:13You're supposed to come to agreement on this stuff right up front."
- 10:17And so I think it's interesting that they put that in there very specifically.
- 10:23And then in the same paragraph they say the sup facts and informal
- 10:27discussion items should not be construed as actionable concerns.
- 10:32That's interesting because usually examiners throwâ¦
- 10:35They've used supplementary facts for lots of different things and,
- 10:38but a lot of times it was a check mark, fix this or next time it
- 10:41will be an exam finding or a door.
- 10:43Mark Treichel: Yep.
- 10:44Todd Miller: And then here, this letter says your examiner can put those things
- 10:47in there, but you don't have to do anything about them, which is interesting.
- 10:51It took a tool away from examiners basically.
- 10:54That- That's the way I would see it as an examiner is it's like, hey,
- 10:57there's an easy way to do this, and you just said I can't do the easy way
- 11:02anymore with cooperative management.
- 11:05Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 11:06And I've got a couple thoughts on that, but before I, I share it, Steve,
- 11:10any thoughts on what Todd just said?
- 11:12Steve Farrar: No, I share with him.
- 11:14Having that written is super important 'cause we do have a number
- 11:18of our clients and we're like, "What was your input on that?"
- 11:20"I didn't have any."
- 11:23That was always a really terrible response when, when Todd and I would hear that.
- 11:27And we definitely think, in, in, in the right situation, they're
- 11:30actually the lead in the, here's the problem we have identified.
- 11:33Tell us how you wanna, how you think you guys should fix it,
- 11:37and that's how it should start.
- 11:39Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 11:39And I think the agreeableâ¦
- 11:41Th- them highlighting that they're gonna work with management on agreeable
- 11:45corrective actions is fabulous.
- 11:47I think it's, to me, it's one of the best thing that's in this write-up.
- 11:51But it's something that was alwaysâ¦
- 11:53if you think back to, so w- itâ¦
- 11:56Goin' back to the, the problem resolution training t- Steve, that you referenced,
- 12:01you've got the subfacts, you got the findings, you've got the door, you've got
- 12:03a letter of understanding and agreement.
- 12:06In that phrase is agreement, right?
- 12:08So you can't agree with something if you can't participate in the development of
- 12:12it, which goes back to how this door is.
- 12:14So it's always supposed to have been there, but I think it sends a message
- 12:18that either the board or the executive director or just the way things are
- 12:24happening under this administration, they want to make sure that th- that
- 12:29ins- that the examiners don't just ram something down their throat,
- 12:32and that there is a dialogue on it.
- 12:34I think that's huge.
- 12:36Now Todd, you al- so y- so th- that ticks off one of the boxes,
- 12:40the agreeable corrective actions.
- 12:41That I'm glad we jumped to this one 'cause it's so important.
- 12:44But then on the subfacts being an, an informal, informal not being bound by.
- 12:51So they're still able to use the sup facts, it just it just isn't something
- 12:56that the credit union has to agree to do.
- 13:00Is that a true statement?
- 13:01Don't
- 13:01Todd Miller: have to do it at all, is the way the letter says.
- 13:03Mark Treichel: So bef- but before, sup facts was less than a finding,
- 13:06so it didn't say you have to do this by this point in time.
- 13:10It was, it, so it's still an in- To me, it's still an informational ⦠As NCUA
- 13:15is being told to write less and less about issues and only write about significant
- 13:20issues, when you're faced with that, you have to say, okay, if I'm, if I am sensing
- 13:27that I can't have significant issue that I have to be more careful about what I
- 13:30cause, call significant, you're gonna shoehorn that somewhere else, right?
- 13:35So that, to me, that's the loophole, that's the truck you can drive through
- 13:38that hole, is you're still gonna use the sup facts to say, hey, I wanna make
- 13:42sure they're aware that they're doing A, B, and C, and if they don't get it
- 13:46under control, it could create a risk.
- 13:48And it's a little bit of that, that old CYA of the examiner wanting to
- 13:51make sure that they don't get accused of missing something later, right?
- 13:54So they'll start documenting, to me, more on the sup facts.
- 13:58It has no teeth.
- 13:59It has less teeth than before, but I, theoretically, I think you could
- 14:02see the sup facts getting longer.
- 14:04And then of course, the, what the credit unions don't see
- 14:06is the close section, right?
- 14:08What goes in the close section?
- 14:09If there's things you can't do because you used to be able to do them, but you
- 14:12can't do them now because you're supposed to only highlight significant issues
- 14:16a- and be li- have a lighter touch.
- 14:18I think the, the heavier touch is in the close section, which gets reported back
- 14:24Todd Miller: I see it potentially going the other way, too.
- 14:26Prior to 2005, somewhere in my tenure as a capital markets
- 14:31specialist, NC used to actually have a document called informal discussion
- 14:35items that went in their report.
- 14:36Mark Treichel: Yep.
- 14:37Todd Miller: Somewhere around my tenure as a capital markets specialist between
- 14:402000 and 2010, they removed that.
- 14:43It went away.
- 14:45I do think by having a letter here saying that, "Hey, these are not actionable
- 14:50concerns," there are gonna be some examiners that's "I'm just not gonna take
- 14:53the time to write it up in the report."
- 14:54And, and- They'll probably put it in the scope workbook.
- 14:57So they fill out a very detailed scope workbook.
- 15:01They'll probably put those things in the scope workbook that, hey, we looked at it.
- 15:04The credit union can improve their definition of trade area
- 15:07on commercial loans or whatever.
- 15:09They'll put that in the scope workbook, but it's not gonna go
- 15:12in the exam report to the credit union because it's not an actionable
- 15:15item, and it may not be material.
- 15:18Mark Treichel: And the key, I think the key word you said there is, "I'm not
- 15:20gonna take the time to write it up."
- 15:22And why won't they take the time?
- 15:23They don't have the time because they don't have the same amount
- 15:26of staff they had before.
- 15:27So that's a good point.
- 15:28I
- 15:28Todd Miller: think it could go either way.
- 15:29Some examiners will use stuff like that more.
- 15:31Yep.
- 15:31Some are just gonna say, "Why bother?"
- 15:33Mark Treichel: It'll be- And of course, the way you know that works is it's
- 15:36driven by the examiners, and it's driven by the supervisory examiners.
- 15:39And, they ha- they have their own, I don't wanna s- call them
- 15:42fiefdoms, but they have their own influence on what their group does.
- 15:45And there's always this natural tension of the, the board wants it
- 15:48to be done X, and it's the executive director's job to make sure it's done X.
- 15:52But then it, as it's more nuanced than that, and this is part of that nuance.
- 15:55Some will do it a little bit more, some will do it a little bit less,
- 15:58but it won't be binding on the credit union i- in most of those instances.
- 16:02Steve Farrar: We'll find out i- once they start doing the exam reviews looking
- 16:07at this new thing and see if the o- the regional offices kind of change in
- 16:13what they write in their comments and what they agree is put in there and
- 16:17what they don't agree is put in there.
- 16:20Because that, that will probably have a lot to do with where that ends up.
- 16:23Mark Treichel: And you think about that the review process.
- 16:25So it goes into the office.
- 16:26Every, every report has to have re- review.
- 16:28If it's large and it has a bad code, it goes all the way to the RD down to if
- 16:32it's small and it has a good code, it's just probably the supervisory examiner.
- 16:37But as they write less and have less time, h- how exceptions are taking
- 16:43at every one of those l- levels, I'm sure is ca- causing debates
- 16:47and angst as they're trying to figure out that, that new normal.
- 16:51Todd Miller: A couple weeks ago, I was actually talking to the current employee
- 16:55who's still out in the field, and that person said, "Hey, they're still trying
- 16:59to figure out, how to write reports under the new formats and the new
- 17:03directives that they've been giving."
- 17:05So they're still working on it, and they get some conflicting advice here
- 17:08and there, or conflicting messages from their supervisors in the
- 17:13Washington office and other folks.
- 17:15One thing, examiners they're bright.
- 17:17They're trying to do the job to the best of their ability.
- 17:20Exactly.
- 17:20They'll get it figured out.
- 17:22There- It will ⦠might be some things that fall by the wayside, and a
- 17:26problem will get missed here or there.
- 17:28But in the long term, they will figure it out.
- 17:31It's just the way it goes.
- 17:32I do find it's interesting that, examiners won't comment on employee
- 17:36compensation, vendor contracts, and pricing issues unless they're material.
- 17:41The vendor thing is really interesting 'cause, we know over the last basically
- 17:4710 years, NCUA just seems to be upping their attention and requirements on
- 17:54vendor due diligence and third parties.
- 17:57And now we say, "Okay, you won't comment on vendor contracts," but you're looking
- 18:00at them more and more over all the time.
- 18:03A lot of times you have insurance issues are related to third-party vendors,
- 18:07especially third-party loan programs.
- 18:10And, you, part of your exam is making sure you have good contracts.
- 18:14But now you're saying, "Oh, examiner, you don't get to comment on that."
- 18:18It's kind of a disconnect.
- 18:20That's a huge insurance thing at times.
- 18:22And then we give them an exam letter that says examiners won't contact them, con-
- 18:27or comment on them unless it's material.
- 18:30Now you got that whole big definition of what's material or not.
- 18:33But it just seems like a Jekyll and Hyde kind of approach to things.
- 18:37And, historically, you get credit unions like, say, ALM, they'll have a model.
- 18:42It just, they've grown more complex.
- 18:44It doesn't work.
- 18:45Examiners could say, "Hey, you could look at ABC."
- 18:48Or a lot of times credit unions would ask examiners.
- 18:50It's like, "Hey, we're looking for a vendor for this."
- 18:52And you give a suggestion, and there's an unwritten rule of you probably shouldn't,
- 18:56but if you do, give them multiples.
- 18:58And now you're almost saying, examiners, you stay out of that entirely unless
- 19:03there's an insurability issue.
- 19:05Mark Treichel: So that was one of the other ones.
- 19:06The comp contracts and pricing off limits I'm g- I'm checking that off
- 19:10my box, make sure we cover all these.
- 19:12But, y- th- thinking about being at NCUA for 34 years and now having changed
- 19:17teams and helping for the last six years, helping credit unions, I could see, credit
- 19:21unions going, "Yeah, it's great they're not gonna ask about the compensation.
- 19:25It's great they're not gonna ask us about vendor contracts and loan pricing."
- 19:29And i- it does fly in the face of the third party due diligence, which is still
- 19:35one of the letters that's out there that's very important to mitigate the risks.
- 19:39And I I w- I'm trying to choose my words carefully.
- 19:42This almost reads like something that some heavy hitter vendors came in and
- 19:47complained and that before helpâ¦
- 19:50and this is all p- so if you're from NCUA and you're listening,
- 19:54this is just pure conjecture.
- 19:55I have no inside information, haven't talked to anybody.
- 19:58But having sat on the seventh floor and seeing how things happen, seeing something
- 20:04in here that vendor contracts can't be talked about, to me means some heavy
- 20:09hitter vendors or a trade association came in, complained to the chairman, the, who
- 20:14was the only board member and then that's how this drop, got dropped in there.
- 20:18S- he says, "Dang it, I want the new thing to say we're not gonna look at
- 20:21that because we're getting in we're getting into areas that we shouldn't."
- 20:24And I disagree.
- 20:25Not looking at it is foolish.
- 20:28But as a consultant helping credit unions, some of our clients will
- 20:31be glad that those aren't being looked at, but for an insurer to say
- 20:35they're not gonna look at it across the board, I think is just it's not
- 20:38Todd Miller: good.
- 20:38I think it hurts small credit unions, and they're not our clients, but I think
- 20:42it's damaging to small credit unions because- Great point ⦠they're the
- 20:46ones that need your examiner advice and help with those kinds of things.
- 20:50And to say, "Hey, you're not gonna talk about it," I think it's harmful
- 20:54to small credit unions specifically, because they got a lot of advice
- 20:58from credit unions over the years.
- 20:59Or it used to be when, I was an examiner of smaller credit unions.
- 21:03That was a long time ago.
- 21:04But, they learned a lot from examiners, especially about vendors
- 21:08and things to look for in contracts and whatnot too, and, subtle suggestions
- 21:13of what can help you out next.
- 21:15And so I don't think it really, that applicable or moves the needle with
- 21:22our large billion-dollar credit unions.
- 21:25But those smaller credit unions under 50 million, under 100 million, saying
- 21:29examiners that you can't talk about these types of things with them, I think it
- 21:34takes away a, a source of information for those smaller credit unions.
- 21:38Mark Treichel: That's a great point.
- 21:39The consulting side of helping small credit unions is gets a little bit
- 21:43harder under, under this scenario.
- 21:45Steve, any, anything you wanna add on-
- 21:49Steve Farrar: No, nothing more on that
- 21:50Mark Treichel: Okay, cool.
- 21:51So my next note has a quote, "Business decisions are reviewed only to ensure
- 21:55they do not compromise these standards."
- 21:58So the old template had no express limitation on
- 22:01reviewing business decisions.
- 22:03And I guess this gives management a basis to push back on an examiner
- 22:07preferences that are not actually tied to material risk or law.
- 22:12Make sense?
- 22:14Am I reading that right?
- 22:15Todd Miller: I think so I think it's interesting, the material thing,
- 22:19and Steve and I, we could probably name you a whole bunch of people
- 22:23that we've met over our careers.
- 22:26You could be in $100 million credit union and they'd be worried
- 22:29about something that's, 700 bucks.
- 22:31And it's like- ⦠who, who cares?
- 22:34And there's always been, some examiners out there that are trying
- 22:38to tick and tie things to the penny.
- 22:40We had a client that was four or five billion and, they were talking
- 22:42about $1,000 thing between their loan system and- ⦠their trial balance.
- 22:47And, that's a third party risk measure.
- 22:49And it's like, $1,000 is not worth spending 10 seconds on, and that
- 22:53credit union got findings on it.
- 22:55In some ways this is helpful to some of those supervisors.
- 23:00Hey, watch your people and, change that behavior of some of them.
- 23:04And there's a few of those out there that just, they just get caught up
- 23:09on, a little mushroom growing in the forest, and they can't tell-
- 23:14Mark Treichel: Yeah everybody has their pet peeves, and this makes it
- 23:16harder to put them in the report.
- 23:18Todd Miller: So in some ways that's good.
- 23:20So they've made explicit things that are, always been somewhat of an
- 23:23unwritten rule in the credit union.
- 23:25Here's our guidelines as an agency.
- 23:28And in the past that wasn't always explicit, although it generally
- 23:34was what was expected of examiners.
- 23:36Mark Treichel: Yeah, great point.
- 23:37There are, and there are definitely some positives in this change.
- 23:40Next up questions does not equal concerns.
- 23:43Examiners may ask questions and request follow-up exam- follow-up
- 23:46information, but this alone does not mean the examiner has concerns.
- 23:50The old template had no clarification at all.
- 23:53A question theoretically landed with the same weight as a finding.
- 23:58I guess this prevents preliminary discussion from being mistaken as a
- 24:01finding by staff or board or counsel.
- 24:05And then when you contrast this with you're not suppo- So I guess one
- 24:09thing as w- I'm thinking out loud, questions don't equal concerns, and
- 24:14you're not supposed to raise you're not supposed to dig into compensation
- 24:17contracts or pricing off limits.
- 24:19Or does that are you not supposed to put compensation contracts and pricing
- 24:23in the exam report, or are you not even supposed to do questions on it?
- 24:28Steve Farrar: It's all in how you ask that question, right?
- 24:32Mark Treichel: And then we're back.
- 24:33Okay.
- 24:34Steve, you pulled it back to communication.
- 24:37Love it.
- 24:38Todd Miller: I think it is a communication thing.
- 24:40Yeah.
- 24:40Some, some credit unions, they get nervous when examiners start asking questions, and
- 24:44most of the time examiners ask questions, they're just trying to understand.
- 24:48Mark Treichel: Seeking to understand, yep No, great point.
- 24:52Great point.
- 24:54Anything else on questions and concerns?
- 24:57Steve Farrar: No
- 24:58Mark Treichel: Ð-а-а Actionable issues, only the final report requires action.
- 25:04This kinda goes-- I think we've talked a little bit about this already.
- 25:07We may have.
- 25:07But issues documented in the final re-examination report
- 25:11req- are actionable.
- 25:13Required corrective actions stated in the report are actionable.
- 25:19Not actionable, supplementary facts, informal
- 25:21Todd Miller: discussions with examiners.
- 25:21Anything to add on that nuance, or did we already cover that prior?
- 25:23It's, again, it's an unwritten thing.
- 25:25I dealt with a lot of trouble credit unions.
- 25:26This wasn't one of my cases, I'd seen it happen with other times
- 25:29where, Actually, I will just bring it up because it no longer exists.
- 25:33For a while, we had these national exam teams around the corporate
- 25:36failure and, they brought people in and said, "Okay, you're gonna be our
- 25:42super national problem case officers."
- 25:45Those guys would go visit credit unions couple, every couple month.
- 25:48Didn't have written policies, procedures.
- 25:50So they were telling credit unions things, but they weren't giving them
- 25:53exam reports And then they wanted to conserve one of those credit
- 25:57unions that they'd been visiting every other month for a whole year.
- 26:01And general counsel said, "No, you never gave him an exam report
- 26:04or told him to do anything.
- 26:06You have no grounds to conserve these guys 'cause you haven't documented anything."
- 26:12Mark Treichel: And y- Steve, thoughts on that?
- 26:15Steve Farrar: No, just agree.
- 26:16S-
- 26:17Mark Treichel: so my thoughts would be that's longer term
- 26:22where the issue's gonna be.
- 26:23As NCUA writes less and less can-
- 26:27Todd Miller: And exam periods get longer
- 26:30Mark Treichel: can ask you to doâ¦
- 26:30c- yeah, and exams get longer and they're, y- they're ⦠In their eyes
- 26:35an examiner is going, "Gosh, I can't say this, I can't say this, I can't say this.
- 26:39I can't fence in the risk as, as much as I would want to."
- 26:43And the, the individual credit unions are happy that NCUA can't go on these
- 26:47wild goose chases, and that's all good.
- 26:50But in that everything's a bell curve, right?
- 26:53And when you take the ones where maybe there are issues and maybe s- staff
- 26:58wasn't up to the task of what they were doing and they got into new programs
- 27:01but NCUA didn't accept, take exception.
- 27:04There are gonna be some situations where losses be- come from that.
- 27:09Or they wanna take administrative action, but the report doesn't document
- 27:13it, and it goes from 0 to 60, and then they have to start building that
- 27:17administrative action before they can, take those additional actions.
- 27:20Which a- as soon as some of those end up hitting, y- hitting material loss
- 27:26reviews which will take one, two, three, four, five years a- and then
- 27:30there's changes in administrations.
- 27:32This is a great time to be a credit union to not have to have onerous, overly
- 27:37onerous exams in most instances, but the pendulum will swing, and it'll swing in
- 27:42some of, in, in this area in particular.
- 27:45Todd Miller: We were all around 30 years, and we've seen different times where they
- 27:48extended exam cycles and, they've done it a couple different times in our careers
- 27:53where they've extended exam cycles.
- 27:55And th- there's, they end up missing one or two credit unions, and it
- 28:00ends up costing them more money than they save by extending exam cycles.
- 28:04And then they go back and it's like, no, okay, the big folks,
- 28:07we do have to see once a year.
- 28:09And this pendulum, it will swing that way again.
- 28:12Mark Treichel: And along those lines, it's alleg- allegedly former Chairman
- 28:16Hauptman said when he heard about the Jackson area loss,, "That wipes out
- 28:20my entire savings from the reorg."
- 28:23And it's those kind of things when they hit that get the
- 28:26board to say, "Not on my watch.
- 28:27I have to report this to my s- in my semi-annual report to Congress."
- 28:31And the credit unions get upset if they have ⦠If the credit unions end up
- 28:34having to have two or three big losses hit, let's say, five years down the
- 28:37road and then there's them having to recapitalize the insurance fund there
- 28:41will be an attitude to get tough again.
- 28:43But again, I don't wanna imply that- That there aren't things here that are
- 28:47good for credit unions, 'cause there are, but they're every action has,
- 28:51has a, a consequence intended and then und- unintended consequences, right?
- 28:56Todd Miller: For most of your well-run credit unions- Exactly ⦠getting
- 28:59this breathing room and longer exam cycles, it gives them more
- 29:04time to innovate, to, right now interest rates are really stable.
- 29:08They're catching up from other things.
- 29:11Mark Treichel: Yep.
- 29:11Todd Miller: When we talk to clients, a lot of them are
- 29:13looking for new revenue sources.
- 29:15You got the whole fintech thing out there.
- 29:17But for the well-run places, getting these longer exam cycles and stuff,
- 29:21and without having examiners around their necks all the time, it gives
- 29:25them a little bit of time to expand and move forward and try new things
- 29:30and, It just saves them a lot of energy in not dealing with your examiner.
- 29:35So for most of the industry, some of this is probably good.
- 29:39Mark Treichel: Yeah, I,
- 29:40Todd Miller: I would- Not that there's- Right.
- 29:41⦠reduced exam staff, there's longer exam periods.
- 29:46It's just the one or two that cost you 90 million that it's not good.
- 29:49Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 29:50And that's the 60 to 80% in the middle of the bell curve that it's good for,
- 29:53and that aren't gonna cause a risk no matter what they do or what NCUA says.
- 29:57So it is good.
- 29:58For the greater materiality of of the 4,000-some credit unions, this
- 30:03is a definitely a good thing for what NCUA can and can't do, for sure.
- 30:08Todd Miller: So- To digress- I'm sorry ⦠just a second on this, 'cause we talked
- 30:11about risk management and reduced staff, and I said examiners will figure it out.
- 30:16At the national level, NCUA's risk management systems drag
- 30:20a lot of false positives.
- 30:22But it is really interesting.
- 30:23Almost all the regions come up with their own little risk management reports
- 30:26to try and isolate things for their regions, and that's usually good, and
- 30:31you'll see more of that as they try and figure out, where is that one or two
- 30:37credit unions that are really a problem?
- 30:40Mark Treichel: Yep.
- 30:40Todd Miller: Yeah.
- 30:41Mark Treichel: Said.
- 30:41Todd Miller: There'll be more innovation along the lines with
- 30:44that at the regional level.
- 30:46The national level just historically has moved very slow, and their risk management
- 30:51systems are just not as good as what the region builds around it to make it better.
- 30:56Mark Treichel: They're less nimble than the regions, for sure.
- 30:59Another item, next item on the list I ran through.
- 31:02The, y- the, the letter references that y- they can record the joint
- 31:05conference and exit meetings.
- 31:07This has been in the priority letters since Hauptman had it
- 31:11put in when Harper was chair.
- 31:14But this codifies it here in, in the exam letter.
- 31:17Anything to add there, guys?
- 31:19Todd Miller: Do you think they're taking a jab at the state supervisors?
- 31:23Now, they're, they do have a thing in the letter, says, "Hey, you need the
- 31:25consent of the state supervisors."
- 31:27And I don't know how many states it is.
- 31:30Most states do let people record meetings, but there are a
- 31:33number of state supervisors out there that say absolutely not.
- 31:37And I almost wonder if this is NCUA central office kind of taking
- 31:41a jab at some of those state-
- 31:44Mark Treichel: I think it's probably I- it's probably that NASCUS and the
- 31:49states pointed out ⦠'Cause I think what happened is when they started
- 31:52doing it, they said you could do it in a state charter, and it worked its way
- 31:56back through the state to NASCUS, and it was pointed out, "Hey, you gotta be
- 32:00Y- you're treading on state law here."
- 32:02And you know what, though?
- 32:03I will tell you, I know that there are some states that the law doesn't say
- 32:08it but like the what does an examiner make an issue that they may or may
- 32:13not really have the authority to.
- 32:15There are states, I believe, that, that say, no, you can't record it, but
- 32:20they don't have a law that says it.
- 32:21NCUA's just being careful not to tick the states off.
- 32:24But you could look at it as a jab saying, "Hey if you can't do it in a state
- 32:28charter, it's not 'cause we won't let you.
- 32:30Talk to the state."
- 32:31So good point.
- 32:33Todd Miller: I do think, credit unions should do that,
- 32:35especially the joint conference.
- 32:37Maybe not at their exam meetings.
- 32:39I sat on NCUA Supervisory Review Committee, and there was appeals
- 32:44and let's just say in some of those appeals, the credit unions having
- 32:47recordings of the meetings was actually very helpful to their case.
- 32:51Mark Treichel: I could imagine.
- 32:52Yeah.
- 32:52If I was in, and we advise our clients, do it, 'cause then you can't
- 32:56get into a he said, she said, right?
- 32:58You have the actual recording.
- 32:59And it might not be clear it, and it could be, not said artfully or,
- 33:05as you're talking you think it means X and you go back and you say, "Oh,
- 33:07no, we did commit to this," or, "NCUA did say we could do it this way."
- 33:11It's a great record to have.
- 33:13Todd Miller: And most of the time you probably never, ever play it again, but
- 33:16it's nice to have should you need it.
- 33:18And I don't know if it affects all examiners, but I suspect there are
- 33:22some examiners will choose their words a little bit more carefully
- 33:26if they know they're being recorded.
- 33:28Mark Treichel: Absolutely.
- 33:29Absolutely there's a requirement two weeks notice before an exam begins.
- 33:36If your credit union has a virtual private network, NCUA may be able
- 33:39to use it to access information needed to complete the exams.
- 33:42Providing access is your choice, but you must tell NCUA at least two weeks
- 33:46before the exam is scheduled to begin.
- 33:49Steve Farrar: That, that one's interesting when we've had our clients that when
- 33:54they use their own network to, to, for putting the documents up there for NCUA,
- 33:59if they have that way of knowing if they were ever accessed is pretty powerful
- 34:03because if NCUA requests a bunch of stuff and then nobody downloads it-
- 34:08Mark Treichel: Yeah, absolutely.
- 34:09Yeah, we, we- It's,
- 34:09Steve Farrar: it's a point you can bring up and say you wasted a lot of our time.
- 34:13We, you requested all these documents, and you never even looked at them."
- 34:16Mark Treichel: Great point and I think not part of this document, but
- 34:19I think NCUA has standardized what they can actually ask for, right?
- 34:23They trimmed the list back.
- 34:25Todd Miller: They've been told to trim it.
- 34:26Examiners have been told to trim it back.
- 34:29The VPN thing is somewhat interesting 'cause NCUA computers historically when
- 34:34you turn them on, it starts NCUA's VPN.
- 34:37And I know to do off-site exams in the past look at commercial loan portfolios,
- 34:42a lot of credit unions, it's like, okay, to do that, you're gonna do it
- 34:44on our VPN if you're off-site and want access to our loan origination systems.
- 34:49It used to be those always had to be set up specifically by IS&T people at
- 34:55NCUA, and they were reluctant to do it, and they would only do it, I'd probably
- 35:00send in three, four requests a year, and they'd say yes to one of them.
- 35:04Mark Treichel: Wow.
- 35:05Todd Miller: They were always reluctant to alter NCUA's security structure to
- 35:09access a credit union's VPN, and now they say, "Absolutely, we will do it."
- 35:15So obviously technology has changed a little bit, or NCUA's
- 35:19got other systems that allow that as an easier operational activity.
- 35:25'Cause before it was just operational.
- 35:27They just-- It was difficult to do.
- 35:29Mark Treichel: Tongue in cheek, I hope they ask the chief information officer
- 35:32if they can buy they can live with this.
- 35:35Sometimes what happens is these go out and, all the towers of information
- 35:39within each office, there, there's not always the optimal perfect communication.
- 35:44But I'm sure that they've got all those bugs worked out in in
- 35:47the world we're living in today.
- 35:50So there's a prominent reminder on CUSO access.
- 35:54Coord- coordinate with CUSO so requested materials are produced.
- 35:58I'm guessing maybe they've had some issues where getting CUSO
- 36:01documents was a challenge.
- 36:02Any thoughts on a reminder that we have access to the CUSOs and make sure they're
- 36:07aware that we may be asking for stuff?
- 36:10Todd Miller: Probably.
- 36:10There's been challenges, especially in some state charter credit unions about
- 36:14whether they should give access to NCUA about their CUSO stuff, especially when
- 36:20there's not a clear majority owner.
- 36:24Mark Treichel: Correct.
- 36:24And as you mentioned that, I remember one of those exact situation based
- 36:28on that fact pattern and the CUSO was not going to allow them access.
- 36:35And I remember the RD, who's no longer at NCUA, saying, "That's fine.
- 36:41When anybody ever asks me about your CUSO, I'll say that you
- 36:43wouldn't let us see the records.
- 36:45So if you're okay with me saying that, I'm okay with you not giving me the records."
- 36:48And they got the records the next day
- 36:50Todd Miller: I might have threatened to cry one time with a code
- 36:53four if they weren't gonna give us access to their TSO record
- 36:57Mark Treichel: And the RD I was referring to is someone you two
- 36:59know I'll just put it that way.
- 37:00It's a West Coast, one of the West Coasts that's no longer around
- 37:04Steve any more on the QSO side?
- 37:07Steve Farrar: N- no.
- 37:08Todd Miller: Some of this, I wonder if they're just a greater concern with
- 37:11CUSO and they want examiners to spend a little bit more time with- A little bit,
- 37:14yeah ⦠especially all the lending CUSOs.
- 37:16'Cause with the reduced staff, they're probably gonna do
- 37:20less CUSO-specific exams.
- 37:22'Cause there was always exams where, especially if you had a CUSO working
- 37:25with a lot of credit unions or did a lot of especially business lending,
- 37:30you know, across different states.
- 37:32NCUA would go look at the CUSO and just have a CUSO exam.
- 37:35And I wonder if reduced staff, if they're gonna do less CUSO exams
- 37:39and throw more of that on just exam teams is why it's in here.
- 37:42That's pure speculation on my part.
- 37:44Yeah.
- 37:44I don't know anything but- could be.
- 37:46Mark Treichel: Could very well be.
- 37:48So auditors.
- 37:49The last template said the credit union was told to make audit work
- 37:52papers available and to notify staff that examiners could access internal
- 37:56audit and compliance materials.
- 37:59The new template says the credit union must advise the supervisory committee
- 38:03and external auditors that NCUA may contact them directly for the audit
- 38:08report, member account verifications, management letter, engagement
- 38:11letter, and related work papers.
- 38:13I'm wondering if this, you know, ties to a fraud case like Jackson Area
- 38:17or something, but thoughts on this?
- 38:19Todd Miller: I went back and looked at some old exam request
- 38:22letters from some of our clients.
- 38:24That wording was actually there in 2024, exactly like it is today,
- 38:29and I don't know when it changed.
- 38:30Mark Treichel: Okay.
- 38:31Todd Miller: I know when we retired it was, you went and got audit work
- 38:35papers through the credit union.
- 38:37So that language has changed over the years, but it changed before this
- 38:40year just on that specific thing where examiners can go right to the auditor
- 38:45for work papers and, it probably is related to some fraud-type case.
- 38:51Yeah, and actually- Either way- I'm sorry.
- 38:54Go ahead.
- 38:55Either way, the CPA is gonna want, authorization from the
- 38:58credit union before- Sure
- 38:59they do it.
- 39:00They will let the examiners have it.
- 39:01So functionally, I don't know if it changes anything.
- 39:05Mark Treichel: It probably helps an IG audit where we say we see, we clarified
- 39:09that we do have access to these things, so we can get them and we are getting them."
- 39:12So it's probably papering the trail so NCUA makes it clear if they get audited
- 39:19that they have the ability to do it.
- 39:21There's gotta be a little bit of that to this.
- 39:22Or maybe not.
- 39:23Again, speculation I, there's a pi- I've talked about this maybe once or twice.
- 39:28There's a, a Minnesota Vikings podcast I listen to that every Wednesday they have
- 39:33an episode they call Reckless Speculation, and they talk about, we're gonna trade
- 39:36all three of our quarterbacks for-
- 39:38a, a six-pack of Budweiser.
- 39:40Those kind of things.
- 39:41But I don't think I've hit the reckless speculation, but
- 39:43it's definitely speculation
- 39:45Let's see.
- 39:47New transparency, narrower transfer options.
- 39:51Point it, so data transmission points to NCUA secure fire- file transfer
- 39:56portal or encrypted transmission.
- 39:59Prior allowed encrypted transmission or media, plus a detailed process for
- 40:03handling over encrypted media in person.
- 40:07It narrows how they can give us, how they can give NCUA data.
- 40:11The unencrypted media alternative is gone, and when I see that,
- 40:16thinking out loud, that's gonna be harder for small credit unions maybe
- 40:20Todd Miller: So under the old letter, they had this whole thing, that you could give
- 40:23them like jump drives and things like that with chain of custody documents and stuff,
- 40:29and they removed that from the letter.
- 40:31I don't know if they'll still allow it internally, but they've
- 40:34taken it out of the letter.
- 40:36This whole sign the chain of custody document as a way to physically
- 40:41transmit information to the examiners that have PII in it anyway.
- 40:46Interesting ⦠I just wonder if they want a better audit trail, if
- 40:48we didn't have some more, they did that before because there was a data
- 40:53breach somewhere along the way, and I wonder if this is like, okay, we're
- 40:57just gonna not have any possibility of data breaches, end of discussion.
- 41:04Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 41:04I think you're right.
- 41:05I think you nailed
- 41:05Todd Miller: it.
- 41:05'Cause there was an instance where a USB drive with PII got lost somewhere
- 41:10between an examiner and a credit union.
- 41:12Mark Treichel: Yes.
- 41:13Yes, I've lived through some of the communication efforts
- 41:15on those kind of things.
- 41:17Todd Miller: And I wonder if this is just NCUA mitigating it.
- 41:20It's like- yeah ⦠we're just gonna eliminate- You want
- 41:22the possibility of that happening again.
- 41:23I,
- 41:24Mark Treichel: I think that's exactly right.
- 41:27Document requests and the exit meeting.
- 41:29So document organization, the new letter links to NCUA's page of tips for
- 41:34organizing and saving documents intended to cut duplicate requests, which is great.
- 41:39The prior template gave only general direction.
- 41:41And then there's exit meeting language which is interesting.
- 41:45Prior officials would have an opportunity to participate.
- 41:48New language, NCUA will hold an exit meeting with credit
- 41:52union officials and staff.
- 41:55That's how it used to be, right?
- 41:56Back 20 years ago, you will have a joint conference.
- 41:59So it's not, so code one, code two doesn't have the option of saying,
- 42:03no, we don't need to have the meeting.
- 42:06It's a big change.
- 42:08Todd Miller: For a while, examiners could, they wouldâ¦
- 42:11So in code ones and twos, the examiners didn't have to.
- 42:14They had to offer it to the credit union.
- 42:16Of course, most of the credit unions are gonna say no if
- 42:18they don't have to have one.
- 42:20And I think this is probably part of, for those ones and twos, they're getting
- 42:24this really extended exam cycle, and so now it's wait, we want the board
- 42:29members and examiners in front of each other with this extended exam cycle.
- 42:33Mark Treichel: A- and it's possible that-
- 42:35Todd Miller: No, I'm in your wild speculation phase.
- 42:37Yeah, speculation.
- 42:37Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 42:37Yes.
- 42:38Yep, exactly.
- 42:39But it's also possible Jackson area opted out, or they didn't have
- 42:43joint conferences at Jackson area.
- 42:45'Cause again, this is an example of when a ba- big loss happens, NCUA looks at
- 42:49what they could've done better, and they immediately start putting things in.
- 42:52But I think it's a, I think it's good 'cause it goes back to what, Steve?
- 42:55Communication.
- 42:57Exactly.
- 42:58If you don't have the meetings you can't say that we talked
- 43:00about it at the meeting.
- 43:01So forcing there to be a meeting and then giving the option to
- 43:05record it, I think that's all good.
- 43:07Todd Miller: And it's back to your Fryzel comment.
- 43:11Quote
- 43:13Mark Treichel: Which quote was Faisel?
- 43:15Todd Miller: Familiarity.
- 43:16Mark Treichel: Oh no.
- 43:17Th- that was Mike Waters.
- 43:19Oh, I
- 43:19Todd Miller: thought it was Faisel.
- 43:20Damn.
- 43:20Yeah.
- 43:20Mark Treichel: I've got some other Faisel quotes, but some of
- 43:22those th- don't fit the podcast.
- 43:24But both great board members, by the way.
- 43:26Familiarity breeds consent.
- 43:28Exactly.
- 43:29No, ex- I'm glad you brought that up.
- 43:31I hadn't used that one in a while.
- 43:32But if you have the meetings, you get to know each other better,
- 43:35and then you get to be a little bit more agreeable Awesome, guys.
- 43:38This was a, a meaty one.
- 43:40Any, any last thoughts before
- 43:42Steve Farrar: we wrap?
- 43:42I just wanted to go through just o- one thing, okay, y- your entry letter
- 43:46arrives, and then you've looked at it.
- 43:49There's just some few, guide- guidelines that we should have in there, y-
- 43:53the assigning of a point person-
- 43:54Mark Treichel: Yep,
- 43:55Steve Farrar: awesome ⦠is really key.
- 43:56That l- liaison between the credit union and the examiner.
- 44:01The other thing is you need to go through that list of what's requested
- 44:04and make sure that you understand.
- 44:05If something's ambiguous, you need to get back ahold of the examiner
- 44:09to know this is what we want.
- 44:12And then you need to, of course, know that, yes, we can do that.
- 44:16If you're going to have to request an extension of time on, on that,
- 44:22those need to be addressed then, and they should be specific as to
- 44:26why you can't provide that data.
- 44:27It could be because a merger or the availability of personnel.
- 44:32But you should be able to say, "We can get this to you at when."
- 44:37Then there's that quality control, just don't willy-nilly upload the, up-
- 44:41upload the policies and those types of things without somebody making
- 44:45sure, was that the current version?
- 44:46I think so, but we worked on that a couple months ago.
- 44:49Somebody has to be in charge of quality control.
- 44:53And there's that just, if you organize that data well and y- they have
- 44:56some things in naming conventions and all, make it easier for the
- 44:59examiner to know what they have.
- 45:01All of those are keys that kinda line up with this entry letter, I think.
- 45:06Mark Treichel: That's a great point is controlling the narrative, controlling
- 45:09the documents, having that point person.
- 45:12Boy, ha- we, thinking about the six years of consulting, we can think of a lot of
- 45:16situations where that, where things have gone awry because they've lost control
- 45:19with some of those those key principles.
- 45:22Todd Miller: Yeah.
- 45:22In the letter itself, there's a link to some guidance about putting things
- 45:26together, and that, you actually click on that link, it covers about, just
- 45:31about everything Steve just said.
- 45:34Mark Treichel: Fantastic.
- 45:35And if I remember, I'll put that link in the show notes.
- 45:38All right, guys, any, any last thoughts before we we say goodbye and get ready
- 45:42to record another podcast tomorrow?
- 45:44Todd, did you have any final thoughts?
- 45:46Todd Miller: Just one observation, which I think this is a good one.
- 45:49NCUA has lost staff and they're ⦠So we've got credit unions, they're
- 45:53getting their exam letter eight to 10 weeks out to prepare stuff.
- 45:58So they're getting lots of lead time, but sometimes at the time they get the
- 46:02exam request letter, they don't even know who the exam team's gonna be yet.
- 46:05Yeah.
- 46:05They're still figuring that out.
- 46:07But on NCUA's side, the examiners in charge and stuff, they seem to
- 46:12be doing the best they can to give these credit unions as much time as
- 46:17possible to get this stuff together.
- 46:20And that's a good thing for credit unions.
- 46:23Obviously, they've been told that, "Hey, let's make this as smooth as
- 46:26possible," and you make it smooth as possible by giving credit unions
- 46:29adequate time to get this stuff together.
- 46:32Mark Treichel: Great point.
- 46:33Another, another positive of this le- this recent trend.
- 46:37Very good
- 46:38Todd Miller: guys.
- 46:38At least what we've seen with our clients- Yep ⦠they're getting adequate time.
- 46:42Mark Treichel: Yep.
- 46:42Todd Miller: So if you're not, maybe give Mark a call.
- 46:44Mark Treichel: That's right.
- 46:45That's a good, that's a great place to end.
- 46:46Yeah, give us a call.
- 46:47If you like what you heard here and like to figure out how we help
- 46:51credit unions, of course, we'll have our little jingle at the end
- 46:53here, which will say the same thing.
- 46:55But Steve, Todd great to get back on, do a podcast.
- 46:58I know we're doing another one tomorrow.
- 47:00Thank you for your time, and listeners and watchers, I wanna
- 47:03thank you for listening or watching.
- 47:05I hope you will do again soon.
- 47:07This is Mark Trakel signing off with Flying Colors.