Latest / Flagged for Content / Utah Livestream
Transcript
- 0:00Connecting streaming software and go live viewer as well. Okay, so I think
- 0:04what we're gonna see is like there's gonna be a slight delay on whatever version
- 0:09of the YouTube link that you watch. But other than that, I think
- 0:14we're I think we're set. And uh with that, I think we're also
- 0:19live. So yeah, thank you so much everyone for joining us. We
- 0:24have a very very exciting thing going on today. As you can tell,
- 0:28you wouldn't have clicked on this link if you didn't know. But we've got
- 0:30Terra Stark, We've got Eric Neistel, Michael Green, and Senator Dan McKay
- 0:37from Utah. Well two of those are from Utah, and we're gonna be
- 0:41talking all about the adoption process, especially now that it's finally through for the
- 0:47Utah flag. And I think, like as last time, we should probably
- 0:52give like a little just brief introduction of who we are and what we do
- 0:57in the flag space here. So on my screen it starts with Tara,
- 1:00So Tara, go ahead and take it away as far as Yeah, my
- 1:06name is Tara Stark, born and raised here in Pennsylvania, the Keystone State,
- 1:11A big proponent of the Keystone Flag. Behind me, I guess my
- 1:19biggest thing is just honestly talking about the ways in which a good flag can
- 1:26bring people together, ways in which good flags can bring community, and bringing
- 1:30a good flag to Pennsylvania. Yeah. Absolutely. Next on my screen is
- 1:38Eric, Eric, what's your whole deal? Hello? I am Eric,
- 1:44And maybe just here will be a good chance to explain how I even know
- 1:49Dan McKay. When I was working at the capitol a couple of years ago,
- 1:53there was an event with the governor and a lot of people were there
- 1:57and I saw him walked up and said, hey, listen, we're going
- 2:01to accomplish some great things this legislative session. But I've had a dream of
- 2:07a flag for Utah since I was in elementary school, and he said,
- 2:12hey, hey, let's be in touch, and ever since then, I've
- 2:15kind of snuck in the back foot, in the door of all the proceedings.
- 2:20However, one claim to fame is lately I was recently invited to a
- 2:24new commission called the Utah Symbols Commission. So I'm going to do with state
- 2:30flag, state everything that is a symbol of Utah. So life lesson.
- 2:37If you love flags, just kind of put your name out there they'll think
- 2:39you're weird for a little bit and then they'll learn more about you. I
- 2:45mean, we're still weird, but yeah, it was I'm happy to be
- 2:49here, and yeah, this was a great opportunity to meet him and get
- 2:53involved right on. Yeah, I am super happy to have you here.
- 2:57And also I do remember talking with you about, you know, like very
- 3:01early age desire to see a Utah flag. You could be a little bit
- 3:06more excited about anyway. Michael Green will go to you next. Yeah.
- 3:10Hey, I'm Michael from Flags for Good. I am a big enough flag
- 3:16nerd where I get to make it my full time job, which has been
- 3:20fun for the last four years, almost four years now. I've been to
- 3:27Utah quite a bit. I love going out there snowboarded there some of the
- 3:30best snow on earth, as they like to say. And so I had
- 3:35made a design for a new Utah flag as part of a series that I
- 3:38was doing as just sort of a joke, and you know, submitted it
- 3:44like to the contest like everybody else. And yeah, I'm just a big
- 3:47fan of flags. We sell the new Utah flag obviously, and lots of
- 3:53versions of it as well, like Pride versions and things. So that's why
- 3:58I'm here. I'm get I guess, and of course I bankroll the pod,
- 4:02right right right? I mean you're here because like contractually, you're obligated,
- 4:06like I have to have you here otherwise like I don't get funding.
- 4:10But no, no jokes aside, Michael is here because he's yeah, been
- 4:15like in it from the start, as you mentioned, and as we'll go
- 4:17more into and last, but definitely not least, Senator Dan McKay is here
- 4:23as well. Thanks for having me. Andy. Let's see, I'm a
- 4:28state senator in Utah, but I really work for Michael Green. He tells
- 4:33me what to do, and I do exactly what Michael Green tells me to
- 4:38do. That's pretty much like my life objective is how can I do whatever
- 4:44Michael Green tells me to do? I am a hapless victim, really a
- 4:48drone bought for Michael's string pulling. So there you go. I mean,
- 4:56is there anything else anybody needs to know? Really, this interview could have
- 4:59just included Michael and not really me. But all right, seriously, I've
- 5:04been a state I thanks. Yeah, I've been a state senator for let's
- 5:09see, I've been a state senator for six years now, and then before
- 5:13that, I was in the State House of Representatives for seven years. Totally,
- 5:15I've been thirteen years on Utah's Capitol Hill. Like I love the office
- 5:20jokes where you know, Oscar constantly reminds Angela that he's just a state senator.
- 5:27He's not really like a senator. And I think there's I think there's
- 5:30a healthy amount of you know, self deprecation that probably needs to come along
- 5:34with the job. But but you know, I got interested really in the
- 5:39flag issue by accident, and you know, we can talk about that more
- 5:43later. Yeah. Absolutely, Yeah, you and I are not so different
- 5:48in those regards, because again, like I would not be here if it
- 5:51weren't for Michael, and I do pretty much everything he says as well.
- 5:55He set this up, he said to you know, specifically and vite these
- 6:00exact people, and uh, you know, here we are. So I
- 6:04love how uncomfortable he's getting and that's actually making it better. I was gonna
- 6:08say that will further some you know, some theories with people that don't have
- 6:14great senses of humor anyway, Okay, so introductions aside. I think the
- 6:19best place to start, as always is with the start of this. So
- 6:26yeah, I mean Utah had had basically with some minor changes, the same
- 6:30flag for a lot of its existence. And I think I'll go to actually,
- 6:38I think I'm gonna go to Michael first on here, like, what
- 6:41was it that made Utah specifically kind of something that you wanted to to help
- 6:47out to make better for lack of a better way to put it, Oh,
- 6:53I didn't. I so I had started flags for good, right,
- 6:59yeah, I mean you really shouldn't start with this because this is completely tangential
- 7:02to the entire process. But okay, well you tell me how to moderate
- 7:05and I'll tell you no, no, no, no. So I'll tell
- 7:09I'll tell my side of the timeline because it was really actually coincidental that I
- 7:15had. I did a ted X talk at USU, and literally the day
- 7:20before my talk was the day that they announced that they were going to do
- 7:25the commission, and my whole talk was about, you know, hey,
- 7:29states could have better flags because I had done this whole project of like,
- 7:33you know, redesigning all the not all only the easy ones that were easy
- 7:38to redesign. So I did this ted X talk about this project that I
- 7:43was doing and Utah was the one I showed because I was in Utah,
- 7:46right, like, it was just one of many, and I didn't really
- 7:50think it was even the best one of the set. And so yeah,
- 7:56that was the reason that I guess I got all swept up in this because
- 7:59of just some coincidental timing. And yeah, I mean I think my other
- 8:05redesigns are also good, and I don't know why I don't get as much
- 8:09shit for those two. But all right, there are Mormons watching. We
- 8:13can't be oh sorry, but uh yeah, I mean, like I don't
- 8:20know, we can get into the other stuff, right, Okay, yeah,
- 8:24that's like I guess my mind. In my mind, the reason I
- 8:26wanted to start there was the three billboards outside Salt Lake City kind of ah,
- 8:33well, here's the thing. They made billboards too cheap, like digital
- 8:39billboards you can buy for twenty five cents. I mean, it's way too
- 8:43cheap. And so I saw that and I was like, well, this
- 8:46is a maybe this is a funny And honestly, I did it so that
- 8:50I can make a TikTok about doing it, Like I knew nobody was going
- 8:52to see it, like seriously, but like you can make a TikTok about
- 8:56how you put up billboards and that got way more views than the billboard itself.
- 9:01But apparently Dan McKay did see it, which is just blows my mind
- 9:07right right, And let's go there next. Actually, Eric, I want
- 9:09to get to your like childhood thing as well. But before we get to
- 9:15that, let's go to Dan seeing those billboards and kind of like what crossed
- 9:18your mind? Or were you already kind of thinking it could use a change.
- 9:24Yeah? We so I think, Michael, did you put the billboards
- 9:26up? Were they in twenty twenty if I remember right, something like that?
- 9:31I guess just before COVID, if I remember right, But it was
- 9:33after COVID because I started Flugs for Good during Oka. It was later.
- 9:37Yeah, okay, so we uh so really the flag redesign process started in
- 9:43Utah in twenty eighteen. Representative Steve Handy and Representative Kevin strattonh they they came
- 9:52up to the hill. Steve Handy is a process guy. He loves process.
- 9:58Stratton repsent of Stratton of outcomes, and so he showed up typical.
- 10:03Stratton showed up with the process and or sorry, Handy showed up of the
- 10:07process. Stratton showed up with a final result and said, you know,
- 10:11here's the flag, and it was you know, they both got sent to
- 10:15the same committee. They both presented in the Republican Caucus like here's this idea,
- 10:20and it kind of went over like a lead balloon, and they got
- 10:24sent to the same They got sent to the same committee. And you know,
- 10:28back then I was in the House of Representatives, I was one of
- 10:31the tying but or was one of the votes that like said no, we're
- 10:33not doing a new flag in twenty eighteen, and so you know, killed
- 10:39it successfully, I guess on both accounts. And so then it was then
- 10:46they get to the interim and shortly after that, I can't I don't remember
- 10:50what came first, but I went to Mount Rushmore shortly after the legislative session
- 10:56from yeah, yeah, and you walk down the Avenue of Flags and you
- 11:03know, and it's just this thing, and unbeknownst to me, in the
- 11:07midst of my kids bickering after a long car ride, I was looking for
- 11:11the Utah flag and you know, I didn't know this, but they have
- 11:16it organized alphabetically and so you have to like walk in Utah is not at
- 11:22the beginning of the alphabet, right, So I got through almost twenty four
- 11:26twenty five blue flags with a seal in the middle of and I'm like,
- 11:31oh, it is a lot of flags that were blue with the seal in
- 11:33them. And then like shortly after that, I went to a conference.
- 11:37It was a national conference of state legislators. They hold host these conferences every
- 11:41year. It's a non partisan thing and they're focused on policy, and I
- 11:46tend to get into the tax related issues. But one of the open one
- 11:50of the open meetings, somebody I think at the at the hotel that was
- 11:52hosting the conference, or maybe at the conference center, they had the flags
- 11:56lined up in the room. On one side was the blue flags with seals
- 12:03and other things, and then on the other side of the room was like
- 12:05this interesting I just call it the interesting group of flags. And sure enough,
- 12:11Texas and you know, those are over there, and there's like a
- 12:15crowd of people kind of looking at them like oh, hey there's Texas,
- 12:18Hey there's you know, and then you know, then everybody's pointing over not
- 12:22really looking at the other side. So I go to hang out the lonely
- 12:26blue flags, and I got to pull out like four or five of them
- 12:30before I get to Utah, and I'm like, all right, maybe maybe
- 12:33there's a problem, right, And that was kind of you know where it
- 12:37was. And then shortly afterwards, like around that same time, somebody sent
- 12:41me the Roman Mars talk about about you know, good flags and that kind
- 12:46of thing, and so I start digging, you know, I'm into that
- 12:48thing. I'm into that thing like five or seven minutes and I'm realizing,
- 12:52okay, it's a big problem. Then we get to the end of the
- 12:56video and I'm like all fired up. I call Representative Handy and I said,
- 13:01dude, I'm in how do we do this? And where do we
- 13:03when do we go? And that was you know, that was really the
- 13:07beginning of the suffering. I mean excitement of getting a new flag, right
- 13:13right right, Well, I guess in your case a little bit of both,
- 13:16which again we will get to as most things here. But yeah,
- 13:20no, good to hear and good to hear that, like yeah, at
- 13:24at Mount Rushmore where they are alphabetical, it's I mean, maybe this is
- 13:28my bias, but you're gonna go from Tennessee, which has a great flag,
- 13:33then Texas, which has a great flag, and then you're gonna hit
- 13:35Utah and you're gonna be like, h, there's, as you said,
- 13:39an issue here that we need to maybe correct for. Luckily Pennsylvania was right
- 13:46before it, though, Andy, because I did feel better because you know,
- 13:48I had Pennsylvania right before it, so I did feel somewhat better.
- 13:52Yeah, I'll learn the alphabet at one of these points, but right now
- 13:58we should probably move on. So Eric, like, as you mentioned,
- 14:01you have had a long standing interest in changing this flag or like I guess,
- 14:07like and you can put it better, but like kind of like a
- 14:09flag that you really wanted to have pridened. Like take us through a little
- 14:13bit of that. Yeah. I actually driving into work this morning. It
- 14:18was fun because the effective date of the flag was Saturday, and so now
- 14:22all the government offices and agencies are putting them up. On my way to
- 14:28work today, I passed my old elementary school and they had the new flag
- 14:33flying, and it was like a full circle moment because that's where it started
- 14:37for me. Two memories come to mind. One was we did like a
- 14:43cultural thing where students each held a flag, and I just I fell in
- 14:48love. I'm like, So there's so many different ones. They are all
- 14:52different colors and designs and symbols, and I just I learned that my ancestry
- 14:58has served flags and got really into that. And then later on in when
- 15:03we were learning Utah history, we were talking about the state seal, talked
- 15:07about the seagull, lilies, the bees, the arrows, what everything means,
- 15:13and I was into it. I was like, man, work,
- 15:15this is cool. And then they're like, and then this is the state
- 15:18flag and I'm like, oh wait, it's just the same thing. I
- 15:22don't hate the seal, but I'm just like other states get a seal with
- 15:26full of symbolism and a flag full of symbolism. So Ever, since that,
- 15:31like third fourth grade time, little Eric has been excited for a flag
- 15:39for Utah, and I kind of come at it from a different direction than
- 15:43Tara does. Tara is like, I have a flag and it's better than
- 15:46what y'all have. I was going to be happy with whatever the result was
- 15:52of this. Of the committee. I submitted a couple I liked the hexagon
- 15:58ideas, so I guess I got my way in that regard, But yeah,
- 16:02I was going to be happy with anything besides just our seal. I
- 16:06love our seal, but seals aren't flags. Yeah. Yeah, And by
- 16:12the way, he said little Eric. The guy is six foot five,
- 16:15six foot six. Maybe Eric, there's no little There was never a little
- 16:21Eric. I've never met him, nor have I ever seen him directly standing
- 16:25next to you, Dan, Otherwise I would probably, Uh, it's always
- 16:29this Eric. You mentioned something I want to touch on really well. Yeah,
- 16:33I think what we'll pair into things rather nicely. So you mentioned like,
- 16:38oh, I have a flag and it's better. Honestly, if we
- 16:42get a commission they come up with something that people like better, then by
- 16:45all means absolutely, I'm here for it. Utah on Minnesota have both proven
- 16:51that committees can be hit or missed depending on who you have on them,
- 16:53how those committees go through their selection process, who you're consulting or not consulting.
- 17:00There's so many different factors that can go into that. I'm not gonna
- 17:03say a committee's better. I'm not gonna say my solution is going to be
- 17:06better, because we can't know that until all of those pieces are in place.
- 17:10What I will say is, from what y'all have described, it sounds
- 17:14like things really kicked off in Utah when you had a visual example. I
- 17:19think about Michael's example from the Ted talk and the billboard that Dan Drove passed,
- 17:25and then suddenly the Senator's like, okay, maybe this works, and
- 17:27then sees Roman Mars like okay, yeah, no, these are good examples
- 17:30of things we could be doing. I think about Utah's commemorative flag in twenty
- 17:36nineteen. I want to say, and how much resemblance that commemorative flag bears
- 17:40to what y'all wound up with, right. I'm not saying it's the Keystone
- 17:45flag or nothing. The Keystone flag, in my mind, is something that
- 17:49exists as an example of what you can do. It's an example of,
- 17:53you know, how can you balance history and tradition and bold design in a
- 17:59way that that's people excited, right? And I think that's a huge thing
- 18:03that doesn't get brought up in abstract conversations about well, should we have a
- 18:07new flag, because the second people have a new flag, they're like,
- 18:11oh, hell yeah, this is great, right, But you don't get
- 18:15that from should we replace our flag? What's the point of that, right?
- 18:22Right? So like asking it to open ended rather than yeah yeah,
- 18:26those are the I guess the only two approaches that really. But yeah,
- 18:30that's kind of like what I've said. The purpose of my Better State Flag
- 18:34series that I had done it was it's not I mean literally, if you
- 18:37watch the end of my ted X talk in Utah, I said, I'm
- 18:41not saying this has to be the flag. I'm just trying to show that
- 18:45you can have something better and that the states that have something better benefit from
- 18:51it. And Tara's doing the exact same thing. And that's why we sell
- 18:55the Keystone flag because it is a bastion of what could be and it's just
- 19:00it's there to inspire. And so we I know, we disagree on Minnesota's
- 19:06final outcome, and I don't know how we feel about Utah's final outcome,
- 19:11but uh yeah, I think it's it's no Tennessee. But I like it.
- 19:18You are a dan. You are muted if you're trying to Yeah,
- 19:23I muted myself because you know, my kids walked in for a second.
- 19:27You know, it's interesting the visual side of things are really it does really
- 19:33help capture the imagination because shortly after, you know, we we then proposed
- 19:37the bill in twenty nineteen again, so rap Handy had a bill represent Stratton.
- 19:41You know, kind of had his bill, but they both died again
- 19:45in twenty nineteen. Because you know, we just hadn't really captured anybody's imagination.
- 19:51We had one option at the time, which was the commemorative flag,
- 19:53and so we hadn't really captured anybody's imagination. And I think it was I
- 19:57don't know where I was when I I when I came up with this idea.
- 20:00But one of my friends is you know, was the is the general
- 20:04manager of the Utah Jazz and they have a large, you know, community
- 20:10component, and I went and talked to them and said, hey, would
- 20:14you and your graphics team ever be interested in a boring summer project while you're
- 20:18done with you know, basketball and branding, you know, could could you
- 20:22come up with some state flags? And it caught the imagination of he's one
- 20:26of my neighbors actually worked on the graphics team, but I didn't know a
- 20:30guy the name of Ben Barnes, and Ben spent I don't know how much
- 20:33time putting it together, but he came up with sixty different flags based on
- 20:41inspirational pieces from from the current state flag. And those sixty flags, I
- 20:47then, you know, and this is kind of part of the lore but
- 20:51I kidnapped my colleagues, which at the time was the Lieutenant governor. Well,
- 20:56yeah, I held him. I made sure they paid it tension,
- 21:00But I had I had my I had the lieutenant governor. She was formerly
- 21:06a senator and served in the Senate with me at the time, and she
- 21:08was one of the big no way, we're not touching the flag. Just
- 21:11it's dumb, don't bother blah blah blah, interesting wrinkle. And so she
- 21:18sits in this meeting we had in September, which is, you know,
- 21:22like four or five months before Michael's Green before Michael's presentation at Utah State,
- 21:27and we you know, she she sits in this presentation and it was nineteen
- 21:33minutes of the Roman Mars, of the Roman Mars video. I had them
- 21:38all watch that and then we get done with that. And then and then
- 21:42a month later in November, we had the Jazz guys come up and present
- 21:48literally their flag ideas basically as a rebranding concept for the state. And now
- 21:56all of a sudden, everybody with the Roman Mars kind of concept. It
- 21:59was short, it was digestible enough. They could get the rules, they
- 22:03can get some of that stuff and then we could shift in November to these
- 22:07concepts that really captured everybody's imagination, and you know, didn't really We were
- 22:14insistent that we not get down to one flag, that this be a commission,
- 22:18be an open process. But to Michael's point, Tarif's point, like,
- 22:23if you don't have something visual to catch people's attention, you're not going
- 22:29to make it very far. And yet, like Eric to that point,
- 22:34like it looks like you had something else to say at the last point.
- 22:37But also I mean, just speaking to that, like you said, for
- 22:42example, you didn't have anything specific in mind, just like I want this
- 22:47to be better, something I can be proud of, et cetera. And
- 22:49then obviously these things do start to come up in whatever Dan said was twenty
- 22:53eighteen with the commemorative flag, and I guess your brain's kind of been turning
- 23:00that direction for a while. But does that like kind of re start things
- 23:03a little bit or as far as like the visual aidness of it. Yes,
- 23:10yeah, Actually, my barber in his shop he had he had a
- 23:15big four x six version of the centennial flag. I will say, like
- 23:22right now, just before we get into that, your barber earns his keep
- 23:25oh go on I'll give him a shout out. Look up roughing up Barber,
- 23:32He's Josh is awesome and he had that up there, and I just
- 23:36so it kind of stayed top of mind, and I asked him. I'm
- 23:41like, hey, I like that you have the centennial flag. I'm kind
- 23:44of interested in getting Utah on new flag. And he said, yeah,
- 23:47I I've always wanted something to rep Utah pride, but the seal feels like
- 23:51government and I'm not pro government, so and I like that. I'm like,
- 23:56people want something else. There's a lot of people who are speaking for
- 24:03the population of Utah and saying actually, no, nobody wants this, but
- 24:07the silent majority. And I'm always humbled when I I have conversations with my
- 24:15friends and we're like, we love the flag. It's the best thing ever.
- 24:18And the other side is we hate this. This is literally the worst
- 24:21thing to ever happen to Utah. And about ninety eight percent of people in
- 24:26the middle are like, oh, that's a new flag. Oh that's cool
- 24:29anyways, right right, Yeah, So it kind of makes me like check
- 24:33myself, but yeah, that I would say that centennial flag. You really
- 24:40saw the train pick up speed at that point right, and like, tera,
- 24:45I want to get to you next, but like really quickly for the
- 24:48folks that are like so for Dan and Eric who are in Utah, proper
- 24:53what you just touched on? Eric, did the commemorative flag? Just did
- 24:57it like kind of ignite a. I guess I'm trying to think a good
- 25:03way to put this, but like, did it get a lot more people
- 25:04just interested in flags in general in Utah and then get them by proxy of
- 25:10that looking at the old one and being like kind of scratching their heads or
- 25:15or do you do you see that as a turning point? I guess is
- 25:18a better way to put it? Senator, do you want to go first?
- 25:22Nope, it's all yours. Okay. I will say he gave him
- 25:26by the way he gave me a hard time earlier today He's like, you
- 25:30know, what was the analogy you used? Eric? You said, what
- 25:33was your analogy? Asking me and Dan McKay to be on the same show
- 25:37together is like asking Ben affleck and the actual Batman to be on the same
- 25:42show. Like like I can say, yeah, yeah, it's cool being
- 25:48Batman, but I'm like you, actually you have the actual Dark Knight here,
- 25:51and so I'm I'm all, my stuff is just parenthetical. Okay.
- 25:56I saw more stickers, minutes, flags, full sized flags of the of
- 26:03the commemorative flag in that short period of time then I ever saw people utilizing
- 26:10the the old flag, and that just that really kind of confirmed to me.
- 26:15I'm like, people want to show something. I'm sick of seeing Colorado
- 26:22stickers on people's cards in Utah, and I'm like, we need something else.
- 26:26And now my another dream has been accomplished. I have a trout outline
- 26:30because I'm a fisherman, a trout sticker with the Utah flag inside of it,
- 26:37and I'm like, I'm like, you know what, up yours Colorado?
- 26:41We have a cool symbol. Now. Yeah, I will admit that
- 26:45I do have one of those same trout stickers with the uh Colorado flag on
- 26:49it, but only honestly, I'm not even a fisherman. I just really
- 26:53liked the way that it looked. And to your point, I'm sure if
- 26:57I go to Utah, I will just really like the way that that looks
- 27:00as well, and probably buy it on a hat to But but the tips
- 27:04of the sea touched the white line. That's all I want to know is
- 27:10like Michael far behind me to get you missed it. I just so you
- 27:14know, Governor Poulos from Colorado did tweet about the new Utah flag on the
- 27:18four corners. I sent him a d M with your video and he watched
- 27:25ses clothing. Oh you kid, you tell me to Oh yeah, he
- 27:30watched it, okay, And I watched it before I was. I was
- 27:33in Colorado a few weeks ago and he had tweeted something and I sent him
- 27:37the video and then he then tweeted without referencing me the whole thing. And
- 27:41I'm just like, you're trolling me at this point. But he hasn't sat
- 27:45down with me yet. But they need to fix it. Anyway, Let's
- 27:48go back to Utah. Yes, so well, actually funny enough, I
- 27:55was actually gonna move briefly off Utah, but only like kind of piggybacking on
- 28:00what Eric and Dan were saying. Is so Tara, like you are behind
- 28:04the Keystone flag, which like for those who don't know, is a better
- 28:07flag for Pennsylvania and kind of spinning it into the Utah flag, which has
- 28:15that like beautiful like hexagon with the B in the middle of it, which
- 28:19is in some ways already used like highway signs things like that. You know,
- 28:22it's a version of that, it's not the exact thing. But in
- 28:26Pennsylvania, like the Keystone is everywhere like already, you're not having to fight
- 28:32as hard to kind of get that in the popular imagination or the you know
- 28:36whatever. Do you think that that's like helped hindered or do you think that
- 28:41that's just kind of like, I don't know, I'm trying to think of
- 28:44a good way to put this, but do you think that that may help
- 28:48you in future efforts to get it adopted, The fact that it's already out
- 28:52there, It was that for me, Oh, to me, I'm sorry,
- 29:06sorry, somebody asked me a question. Okay, I'm sorry. I'm
- 29:11sorry. No, that could have been to anybody, really, I'm sorry,
- 29:14yeah, no, Tarah. I just meant like, the Keystone is
- 29:15already popular in the Keystone State, and I'm wondering if you can kind of
- 29:21like parlay that the same way that the Beehive has been. I mean,
- 29:26it's a pretty obvious comparison to me, right, Yeah, I'm not a
- 29:32journalist. Well, journalists have actually tackled the subject of a new Pennsylvania flag
- 29:37in the past, notably Keystone Newsroom, Spotlight PA. I was actually just
- 29:45looking this up and over and over and over. I see just slap a
- 29:48keystone on blue. Done easy, gold, Keystone on blue. You got
- 29:52it, And it's like, that is the that is the imagery that people
- 29:56think of. You ask people to talk about the current flag, which which
- 30:00I have hanging behind me. I don't know if people can see it on
- 30:03YouTube or not without me turning the angle a little bit, I can it
- 30:07winds up looking like well, I don't know what you can see on that
- 30:10with with if it's only hanging from a flagpole. You tell me. The
- 30:14thing is, that's the only thing that people ever seem to remember about this
- 30:18flag. Somebody on Twitter a couple of years ago posted up said, you
- 30:23know, without looking, describe the Keystone flag, and State Senator Tim Kearney
- 30:27responded with a tweet that was one word courses right. There's so much packed
- 30:33into that flag and all of it does have meaning and it remains in the
- 30:37seal. But yeah, I mean, it's the Keystone State, a keystone
- 30:41on the flag, whether it's weird and stretchy and allblong, or whether it's
- 30:47a tiny little seal on just blue. It's just such an obvious symbol to
- 30:51go for, and I think I can't speak to this. I'll toss this
- 30:53one Eric and Senator McKay, But just how much did having the beehive iconography
- 31:00already around you make adoption easier? Right? I'll be honest, it's saved
- 31:07our bacon. I can honestly tell you without the beehive iconography as part of
- 31:15our state talk because I look at like Illinois, Okay, Senator Doris Turner
- 31:22is working on a flag in Illinois, right, and I feel bad because
- 31:29what is Illinois's iconography, right, other than like they kicked the Mormons out?
- 31:33So I guess you know, we know that. I'm just kidding.
- 31:37Obviously everything revolves around our history, but you know, it's it's like this,
- 31:41it's like this interesting story that they're trying to discover who they are or
- 31:45what their symbol is that's going to be their piece, and that is really
- 31:51really hard to do in a way that is cohesive because it's a start over.
- 31:56Right. The thing I love about the keystone and I do have like
- 32:00I thought about you a lot, Tara, and about like the issue for
- 32:02the keystone because It broke my heart a little bit during the legislative process,
- 32:07just because one, you have been so kind and so supportive throughout this whole
- 32:13process, and honestly, I mean, I love you for it. It
- 32:16has been so great for you to be so supportive. And just like when
- 32:21people were trolling one thing or another, you would jump in and say,
- 32:24well, couldn't you think of this? And I'd say, honestly, you've
- 32:28been fantastic. And the piece of my heart that broke a little bit was
- 32:34the uh was it we When we were working getting down to the final designs,
- 32:39I kept throwing the commemorative flag into the conversation because I wanted people to
- 32:45be aware it is a very solid flag, right, And there were people
- 32:50that were complaining that because it's, you know, because it's a what it's
- 32:53a Saint George cross that goes you know that that makes the X. And
- 32:57as a result of that, it's it's like this this callback to the Confederate
- 33:05flag. And I'm like, guys, that's not really what that's doing.
- 33:07But I get it. But you had people who were concerned because that argument
- 33:10or that discussion was going on about the Confederate flag while we were you know,
- 33:15kind of it was kind of at its end when we were getting into
- 33:19ours. And so the commemorative flag came up while Mississippi was doing its thing
- 33:23right and getting rid of the getting rid of the compeditate flag. And so
- 33:27maybe maybe that's the one little couch I can put in it. But every
- 33:30time I tried to put the commemorative flag into the conversation, it was clear
- 33:37from the design committee and from stakeholders that we weren't going there. And I
- 33:43don't know if it was the X question, if it was the Mississippi problem,
- 33:49if I don't know, if it was already present and therefore there was
- 33:52a bias against it, or there's another thing that is a phenomena which is
- 33:58true, which is if you put together a commission of people and they just
- 34:01adopt what was there before, then what was the purpose of the commission right?
- 34:07And so I that's the fear I have for the Keystone flag, because
- 34:10I love it. I've grown to really like what you've come up with,
- 34:14And it's my fear for that thing because I just know of those biases I
- 34:20worry about. If there's a commission organized, I think the greatest hope for
- 34:23the Keystone flag is. And you saw this happen with Minnesota. With Minnesota
- 34:28as well, right, Minnesota, they organized a commission. The commission basically
- 34:32disrespected like the north I can't remember what we call the north Star flag.
- 34:37North Star flag, Yeah, Lee, Harold and you know, and Lee
- 34:40called me like after and I talked to Lee after the presentation of things because
- 34:47I think he was saddened a little bit by the outcome, but he was
- 34:52he was quick to jump on board, just like you would be at Pennsylvania
- 34:54did the same thing. But there's just a little bit of mourning. And
- 34:59my heart broke a little bit when everybody was so dismissive of the commemorative flag
- 35:02during the design process. And then I saw Minnesota that if Pennsylvania did it,
- 35:07I just I just worry about that, oh creation. And Ted Kay
- 35:12was in touch with me like way way back in late twenty twenty two,
- 35:16if I'm remembering this right, And I mean we had talked about that exact
- 35:22issue, like you know, this is probably not gonna be what makes it
- 35:23to the end, and I've had time to grapple with that already, and
- 35:27I'm like, you know what, that's it's gonna be what it's gonna be.
- 35:30Let me ask you a question, though, do you think a moderator
- 35:35off with do you think, well do you, Senator? Do you think
- 35:39and maybe I'll pose this to ever Terris, do you think you'd be better
- 35:44off with the commemorative flag or do you think you're better off with what you
- 35:47wound up getting overall? Let's let's have let's have Ben Affleck answer that first.
- 35:58I would say it's hard to say hypothetically, but when we got to
- 36:04the idea of like when the bill passed to get a task force together to
- 36:09start talking about new flag crickets, When when the public input design? When
- 36:19Eric, if you if you don't mind if I bought in there, Like
- 36:22when was that during the timeline that you that you formed that Senator? When
- 36:27did the task force bill get done? Twenty twenty? It was right before
- 36:31COVID, I know, because I had to extend its authorization in November.
- 36:35So it was so I remember I looked it up Michael Michael's screen. He
- 36:39Mike, you spoke at you spoke at UTA st eight in March of twenty
- 36:44twenty, So it was literally right before the adoption of the bill or days
- 36:49after it was. It was on either side of that and then anyway,
- 36:52so that's that's the timing. Okay. Yeah, sorry I didn't I didn't
- 36:57want to interrupt you too much there, Eric, But yeah, you're because
- 37:00I'm very interested in this. Yeah. However, when we got down to
- 37:06like finalists, then then some people started to pay more attention and they're like,
- 37:12oh, wait a minute, this isn't just like a fun project,
- 37:15this is like actual legislation. And that's when some people got I don't know
- 37:21if nervous is the right word. Some people got upset that exercised. Yeah.
- 37:27Yeah, and that's when the conversation like, oh, if something's changing,
- 37:31that must mean it's like Mississippi and they hate our flag because it's okay,
- 37:38there's something wrong with it, okay. Yeah. And I had an
- 37:43argument with with a guy who's on the other side of this issue here in
- 37:46Utah, and I'm like, you realize that we're not changing the flag in
- 37:50Utah because it has a it's the Confederate flag, right, We're just it's
- 37:54our seal, so we're doing another thing. And he said, no,
- 37:58no, it's it's actually erasure and you're ashamed of our history. Yeah,
- 38:07it was as soon as that kind of that kind of caught fire amongst the
- 38:13like anti communist, anti Marxist, which I want to go into too,
- 38:20but there's so much to go in. I've been called a degenerate Nazi and
- 38:25a communist more than I can count, enemy of Utah, child of darkness,
- 38:31that was one nobody. I've been called the progressive anti Christ. Yes,
- 38:44yeah, everyone lists your nicknames. Oh and all of us who like
- 38:49the flag are actually just Senator McKay's burner accounts. Oh right. That is
- 38:53a very popular theory, despite the fact that I've had like conversations with all
- 38:59of them and they are clearly not Dan anyway. Yeah, so it's hard
- 39:05to say if the commemorative flag would have done that. It's kind of funny
- 39:09how I thought that a flag with a big religious symbol and red, white
- 39:14and blue, I thought that'd be kind of innocuous. But unfortunately a lot
- 39:21of people misunderstand the bill and the legislation behind it, and they're like,
- 39:25oh, you you erased the tribes, and I'm like, actually, no,
- 39:30we made that part even bigger. Then they're like, oh, you
- 39:34erased our pioneer heritage, and I'm like, no, we made that part
- 39:37three times bigger. So somebody said the comment, all the symbolism on the
- 39:42old flag, you can find it on the new one. It's just done
- 39:45in a simpler way that is more attractive to use. And it's when they
- 39:51say, who's asking for this, and I'm like a lot of people are
- 39:54asked for it by not using the current flag, right right, That's I
- 39:59think something to really hone in on. That's important because it's the voting with
- 40:05your wallet's you know, like to a t, it's that exactly. I
- 40:10know not everyone trusts these studies that have come out and whatever, but I
- 40:15like to think that they're pretty accurate. Nobody really owned the old flag before
- 40:20now. Granted obviously a lot of people have been buying it up now that
- 40:22it's changing. But that's a literal reactionary thing. I mean that, you
- 40:29know, it just is. I wanted to because, like Michael's been not
- 40:34had a question in a minute. I wanted to ask Michael specifically, like,
- 40:37as far as like these flag changes that go, or as far as
- 40:40these flag changes go state by state, have you found any any state a
- 40:47little bit easier to deal with a little bit more difficult to deal with.
- 40:51You don't have to, you know, mention names or any well state named.
- 40:54But uh, like, do you think there's any process that's better necessarily
- 41:01than another? Because I know Maine is about to go on. What we
- 41:05all assume is I think kind of a route to nowhere, and maybe I'm
- 41:08speaking out a turn. I don't know, man, So this is I'm
- 41:13glad you asked because I was gonna pose this kind of question to everybody else
- 41:16and take your job again. But no, it's fine again. I don't
- 41:21need to be here anyway. Well, because I think I disagree, Well,
- 41:27I'm gonna say something controversial, which is, you know what's hard for
- 41:30the Yeah, but all right, I'm gonna go out and say that design
- 41:37committees like what happened in Utah, what happened in Minnesota, Uh, are
- 41:43the wrong way, not the wrong way. Yeah, they're always going to
- 41:46get a mid flag because of what Dan had said. It's you're gonna have
- 41:52to compromise, you're gonna have to make somebody happy, you're gonna have to
- 41:54put a stupid date on it or whatever, and like you're not gonna get
- 41:59the perfect because it's a Committees are great at finding the average, finding the
- 42:05middle, and so if you do a design committee, you're gonna find the
- 42:08middle. In terms of a good flag, You're not gonna get a keystone
- 42:12flag like we talked about, right, And so in some ways I'm totally
- 42:16Maybe this is completely against apparently what I've been called a communist and a Marxist,
- 42:21but I think there should be design dictatorships where you trust professionals to do
- 42:27their damn job, and you trust of exillologists to do their job and you
- 42:31let I don't know, that's just me. It's never going to happen.
- 42:35And I know that because we live in America and that's beautiful. And that's
- 42:39why I'll never be a politician like Dan, because I, you know,
- 42:44I think I can look at compromise and go, you know what, that's
- 42:46actually worse. That's a worse design. And circling back to something we were
- 42:52talking about is the symbol of the beehive. I remember being in the design
- 42:55review committee meeting where somebody said, you know, and maybe we don't even
- 42:59need beehive on it, and like everything ground to a halt, and those
- 43:05of us who were kind of in the know were like, that's going to
- 43:09take our small chance and make it minuscule if we go that different and that
- 43:15unrecognizable. Right, Like with all the hat and judgment and false stuff we
- 43:22got about the Bee High flag, I can only imagine what would have been
- 43:25behind something more abstract. For sure, Yes, absolutely, because like the
- 43:32only few finalists that I remember, like to my memory, they were the
- 43:37arch They kind of had like a pretty unique design element about it, I
- 43:43thought about halfway through, and then most of them were beehive based. I
- 43:47can't think of one that wasn't arch or beehive based that made like the kind
- 43:53of final few And it was clear to me even as a non Utah And
- 44:00just like looking at all those, I was like, they're gonna pick a
- 44:02beehive design. It's just that, you know, they couldn't say that or
- 44:07what. And that's my biggest argument to the people who are trying to say
- 44:10that I had something to do with it, like because you now will never
- 44:14have let someone put a big religious symbol in the middle of a flag,
- 44:17like right, But and that's it's a beautiful flag, Dan, I'm sorry,
- 44:22I love it. It's great, But like that is I mean,
- 44:24that is proof that I had nothing to do with this final design, Like
- 44:28that's ridiculous, right, it's proof of that, and it's proof of like
- 44:31I mean, not that I'm going to convince anyone right now right here,
- 44:36but you know, uh, a Marxist leftist flag would not have any kind
- 44:42of religious symbol on it. I think I'm pretty comfortable saying that this one
- 44:51gets and yeah, let it go. I'll jump in there just real quickly
- 44:55and say, like, you know, I know that people look at the
- 45:00beehive and say it's like religious per se, right, And I get that
- 45:05historical significance, whether we like it or or not. Like how this state
- 45:10came about and became like a state with you know, in the midst of
- 45:15Western expansion, in the midst of all the things. And you know,
- 45:17we don't really have to come in on like the social issues as a result
- 45:22of it. But look, you know they came when the Mormon LDS pioneers
- 45:27came to Utah and you know, declare that this is the right place.
- 45:31You know, it became the Beehive state after Brigham Young and several others liked
- 45:37the productivity component of it. The hard part is if you take away the
- 45:42beehive, we have some geography components maybe to you know, to your point
- 45:50about the arch. I mean, this was this is the Illinois problem.
- 45:53I mean, if you took away the beehive, you have an Illinois problem.
- 45:58And then I think you have an even bigger issue trying to bring everybody
- 46:01else along, which which kind of gets down to, you know, to
- 46:07the root of of Andy and and really Michael's point, and I have to
- 46:12agree with him. Unfortunately, he's right. You know, the the commission,
- 46:17like having a commission and designing things by committee is really hard to do.
- 46:24I would say, could the result have been better? Probably, like
- 46:29if I just said, designers will make us something, you know, go
- 46:32for it and we'll will tell you like when you get there. My problem
- 46:37is that's still designed by committee, and you know, with with less with
- 46:40less angels, And the problem really becomes, how can you check in with
- 46:47the people and check in with the designers so that they're together and like have
- 46:53a final design. It's really really hard, is all I can tell you.
- 46:58Because we looked at I mean, Eric was there, we looked at
- 47:01in our final design meetings. We looked at removing the entire background really,
- 47:06which is a blue you know, it's the blue background, the white mountains,
- 47:09and the red rocks. We looked at removing that all together and just
- 47:13having a blue a navy blue flag with the beehive seal and putting those you
- 47:21know, putting those there and letting that be what kind of commands it.
- 47:24And the problem we ran into was there were plenty of people who said,
- 47:30we just went from a blue flag with a seal in the middle of it
- 47:32to a blue flag with a blue flag with a CeAl in the middle of
- 47:36it, and so it was boring, right, and so people are like,
- 47:40so, really, we just met so that we could make the beehive
- 47:44larger. It seems like a lot of time and effort to make the beehive
- 47:46bigger's and that's kind of how you know, we get the background, so
- 47:52to speak, because it makes it interesting. I guess, I don't know,
- 47:57gotcha. Yeah, you did the right thing by going to the designer
- 48:02of the Utah Jazz and saying like, you started it the right way,
- 48:07and I think, yeah, face the reality that people have to be involved,
- 48:12unfortunately, and I say that I say that with all love to people,
- 48:15because like, here here's two humans that are terrible human beings. But
- 48:20I will bring up in a good light. Steve Jobs always said, the
- 48:23customer wants what I tell them that they want, because Henry Ford, another
- 48:30terrible human, was like, if you ask them what they want, they
- 48:32will say a faster horse carriage. The people will not think of the next
- 48:38thing. Designers will think about it and then they will show them this is
- 48:43better. Right, That's what designers do. And if you ask the people
- 48:47what they want, they're gonna they're gonna get it wrong, unfortunately, and
- 48:52that's just the power of the masses. So anyway, No, I mean,
- 48:58that's why I asked about the whole like main issue in Illinois and like
- 49:01every other state that's one of the Dakota's, South Dakota, I think is
- 49:07thinking of it. And like, I mean, Dan, like we've had
- 49:10a lot from you, but like, is there anything that you would change
- 49:15about the process, like or I guess the better way of asking it is,
- 49:19what would you recommend to another state that is about to go through a
- 49:23similar thing? Man? That is it's a long lift, but yeah,
- 49:30it depends, Yeah, it depends. Because you asked earlier, is are
- 49:36there some states that have an easier path? Or is there a type or
- 49:38those kinds of things. I you know, I talked to I talked to
- 49:42Minnesota, I've talked to Illinois. And it's funny, but I think their
- 49:47process is easier because they're a Democrat controlled legislature. And I don't want to
- 49:53make this like a partisan thing, but Democrats tend to be more on the
- 49:59progress orggressive side of things. Let's change everything, throw everything out right,
- 50:04which can be dangerous in and in and of itself if they lose a portion
- 50:07of their population. Because believe it or not, you know, as we
- 50:09saw with polling, there were a third that really cared about the old flag,
- 50:14there were a third that were indifferent, and then there were a third
- 50:15that really wanted a new flag. And what we've found is that if you
- 50:20have the wrong symbols on your flag, that third that is indifferent will flip
- 50:24on you quick and and that's the that's the that's the concern. But if
- 50:30you look at the process side of things, and I'd say the easier side
- 50:35of things, the less, you know, one lesson I remembered I remembered
- 50:38is you know I turned we turned over that we were the first, really,
- 50:45I guess outside of Mississippi, which kind of changed its flag for different
- 50:49cultural reasons. Yeah, but ours was ours was a different question. It
- 50:54was, hey, the design could be better, Right, It's not about
- 50:58getting rid of our past. It's not about denying all these other things.
- 51:00It's how do we And so attacking things and convincing people that a design can
- 51:07be better is really really hard also, and so trying to walk that fine
- 51:14line of making sure that you get the right people on the committee, because
- 51:19you know, I don't know how you do this without a committee. We
- 51:22ended up, you know, originally Rips of Handy had a smattering of people
- 51:27from all over the you know, different stakeholders and communities and that kind of
- 51:30stuff, and we eventually, after a bunch of conversations, just eliminated everybody
- 51:36from the outside and just said this is going to come down to a legislative
- 51:38vote. And if if it's going to come down to a legislative vote,
- 51:43if you don't have enough legislators on the committee, then you're gonna you're gonna
- 51:47run into trouble. And so I would say one thing I didn't do well
- 51:52is I thought, I want a legislative committee, but I don't want it
- 51:53too big. So we had we had three and three and then the governor
- 51:57and lieutenant governor on the committee and high site. I should have had more
- 52:00legislators and even some dissenters potentially on there, which is what Millis Minnesota did.
- 52:07They got a minority report out of there. So I would say the
- 52:09makeup of the committee is super important and making sure that you're getting lots of
- 52:14different people's opinions. That's that's one big lesson that that I think someone should
- 52:19really think about as they're putting this together. Okay, yeah, no,
- 52:22that makes sutal sense. Eric. I was going to ask you, so
- 52:27as far as the you know, the the flag has already been pushed through
- 52:30everything like that, and there are you know, these signature gathering things that
- 52:37we've you know, talked about on and on, like not on here,
- 52:40but on Twitter elsewhere. And you were asked to say, well, I
- 52:45don't know, if you're asked you can tell me. But you sat on
- 52:47the pro side basically of the change, and you can probably put it better
- 52:52than that. But and had to kind of speak in front of the board
- 52:55and say, well, these are the reasons that I believe should go through.
- 53:00I'm just kind of wondering, like what's the like, Like I guess,
- 53:06like I want to really know where your head's at, like when you
- 53:07get asked to do that, when you're preparing yourself to do that. I've
- 53:13never spoken in front of a committee other than of my peers on a joke,
- 53:17So I'd love to hear like kind of like what goes like, like
- 53:22did you coordinate with other Well, tell me as much as you want to,
- 53:27but I do wonder if there's a multi pronged attack or like kind of
- 53:30where your heads at going in I'm gonna disappoint you and a lot of you
- 53:36yet a lot of my enemies. Sorry, there there's very little deep seated
- 53:42corruption and coordination on this part. Whenever there was a committee and I could
- 53:49make it, I didn't get to all of them, Okay, but yeah,
- 53:52my my strategy was just to be not be like you better change the
- 53:58flag or else I hate you. It's like, hey, we're keeping the
- 54:02seal. That's and even the governor sign an executive order to keep the historic
- 54:07flag flying at the Capitol. This is just a chance for something else and
- 54:14like to that point, and Senat McKay can vouch for this we made this
- 54:19lapel pin, and it's been the most popular thing that we've ever given out,
- 54:27and I'm giving out fifty more to a group that asked for them.
- 54:30And it's just there's not a lot of people like me or people on the
- 54:35other side that are vocal and are going to attend committees about this thing.
- 54:38But most people just they see it and they're like, huh, that's cool,
- 54:43And especially when I tell them if they prefer the old flag, I'm
- 54:45like, actually, we're keeping that. It's still in code and the seal
- 54:50which it's based on is still the same, even people who signed the referendum.
- 54:54I kind of told that to Hi'm like, just so you know,
- 54:58we are keeping the old flag. We're keeping this is just something in addition,
- 55:00and they're like, oh, then I'm actually okay with that. So
- 55:07I just kind of wanted to speak the truth and kind of get all points
- 55:13of view out there. Yeah. Yeah, no, I mean, like
- 55:15honestly, like that was going to be my next question to you, was
- 55:19like had you and you covered it, but like spoken to any people on
- 55:22the that had signed it that maybe well, maybe there's not a good way
- 55:27to ask this that doesn't sound kind of whatever, but that seemed maybe they
- 55:31were a little bit misled by the question or kind of agreed with you more
- 55:37than you would have thought. Yeah, I just I don't take issue with
- 55:42anybody who prefers the art flag and the historic flag. I do take issue
- 55:46when someone says about me that I'm like a progressive insurgent and that I have
- 55:53money vested in this when it's at hominem like that, and if anybody is
- 55:59a progressive insurgent that has money in this, never mind, Michael, I
- 56:05did have a few I did have before we I will be I want to
- 56:09start making those pins though, Eric, if you want to send me that
- 56:12file because I can make some for you. Yeah, I love a beehive
- 56:16flag pen that also says progressive insurgent at the moment. But I did have
- 56:22a few, Like if you guys have a little bit of time, I
- 56:24had a couple questions from Instagram here literally just a couple. I think we've
- 56:31kind of covered this one, but this is kind of more pointed toward Dan.
- 56:36Are your constituents happy with the redesign and was there any major criticism.
- 56:40I think we've been over a lot of the criticisms, but have you talked
- 56:45to you kind of like people, you know, people on the streets kind
- 56:50of thing that that have pretty strong opinions either direction. Yeah. So you
- 56:54know, it's funny. I was, I've gotten it from different directions.
- 57:00On one occasion, I was, uh, you know, in our in
- 57:04our church congregation, we all speak on occasion and I they rarely do I
- 57:09ever get asked speak on anything political. But this year I got to speak
- 57:13on like the Constitution, and you know, I talked about you know,
- 57:16everybody talks about why you know, the Constitution answers all questions. I'm like,
- 57:21well, not really, because I believe that the Constitution was really a
- 57:25founding document that was intended for us to fight for the rest of our lives
- 57:30about you know, our republic and that kind of thing. And and anyways,
- 57:36I was talking about that and this this person came up to me after
- 57:38I'd given this talk and said, oh, what you said. That was
- 57:43so perfect, thank you. That's exactly you know, if they were obviously
- 57:45coming at it from the right, uh, from the right political persuasion,
- 57:50and that was perfect, just what I wanted to hear. That, thank
- 57:52you, thank you, thank you. It's like, oh, now,
- 57:54if only you could talk sense to these people that are bringing the new flag.
- 58:01And I said, I said, you are clearly, and so I
- 58:07I was like, so, you know, tell me about this new flag
- 58:09thing. And they started to recount all the conspiracy theories about Michael Green and
- 58:15some guy from Ohio taking over the process and and we just did his bidding
- 58:21and yeah, that's exactly right. Uh yeah, and so uh you know,
- 58:27well, I trust me. He's been from he's been from Russia as
- 58:30well, So you know, it's Michael. Really, he's a figure.
- 58:32He's a figure that will live, that will be ignominious certainly in Utah's history.
- 58:38But it's it's it's funny that that, you know, this person was
- 58:42kind of into me. Yeah, but it just shows you like they were.
- 58:45So there was such a juxtapos juxtapost conversation to watch it shift and this
- 58:51person be so anti flag but agree with me on something. And and I
- 58:55heard that from a few people, but for the most part, like the
- 58:59people around me, I mean, when I was getting discouraged about the flag
- 59:04or discouraged about adoption or any of those other things, you want to know,
- 59:07who gave me the most hope of this whole process is my you know,
- 59:10my eleven and nine year old daughter, daughters, both of them,
- 59:15and they were they were just so emphatic and so excited. I mean they
- 59:22were drawing stuff. I mean I could show you. You know, they
- 59:24get a school project. I were doing one of the things that good flags.
- 59:30Yeah, they're doing school projects to paint a rock. And my eleven
- 59:35year old likes the red background, and the nine year old wanted an orange
- 59:38background. And so there's always this internal thing. But that's that's what my
- 59:44house became. And I knew, I knew I had to get this done.
- 59:47And so long story, you know, long story short, it was,
- 59:52I get it from all sides. But for the most part, I
- 59:54would say it's seventy percent positive and thirty percent negative, at least when I'm
- 1:00:01just people on the street, and most people that are just like I do
- 1:00:05not understand why this is such a thing, you know, And and and
- 1:00:09people signed the initiative or the referendum because it was a really easy conversation point,
- 1:00:15which is, hey, just let us vote, which is really interesting
- 1:00:20for me to hear. You know, people of the right persuasion, you
- 1:00:24know, Republican or whatever, arguing for popular democracy, you know, which
- 1:00:30is not traditionally you know what, where they came from or where that republican
- 1:00:36party element. I think the strict definition of republican yes, right, And
- 1:00:42so it's really interesting to watch the the mental gymnastics people have to go through
- 1:00:50to convince themselves of one point or another. I get it flags what I
- 1:00:54learned, and I did not fully appreciate this when I met with When I
- 1:00:59met Ted K the first time, he came into town to have some design
- 1:01:02meetings, and I just wanted to pick his brain. So I decided to
- 1:01:06take him out and get an ice cream and just kind of pick his brain
- 1:01:08on a bunch of stuff. And we're sitting there eating ice cream and talking
- 1:01:13about flags. You know, yeah, I'm not sure, by the way,
- 1:01:19that it's legal to fly to cold Beer's flag close to the Utah flag.
- 1:01:22By the way, I'm pretty sure there's rules. It's old beer.
- 1:01:29It's old beer, flat beer. But but you know it, sat with
- 1:01:32Ted and I did not fully appreciate the time. So we were getting ready
- 1:01:37to announce, like here's our finalists and here's our six designs that are going
- 1:01:39to be the end, and that kind of thing. And he said something
- 1:01:44that has just captured my just captured my mind so many times late at night.
- 1:01:47And his response was he's like, you know, I don't know that
- 1:01:52you realize how political this is going to get. And I said, what
- 1:01:58do you mean? And he began to just tell me that people, whether
- 1:02:02they admit it or not, they really care about their flag, and they
- 1:02:06really care about flags. And if you ask people, they're going to tell
- 1:02:08you it's the least important thing, and then they're going to spend an hour
- 1:02:13telling you why it's the least important thing. And I cannot tell you how
- 1:02:17many conversations I've had like that where somebody said, why doesn't the legislature spend
- 1:02:22some do something more important and then proceed to tell me. An hour into
- 1:02:28this conversation, I will literally turn to him and say, you realize this
- 1:02:30is not important, but we've spent an hour on this, and then they
- 1:02:36stop and they think maybe it is more important than I realize. And that's
- 1:02:39something just Ted gave me that, and I reflect on it on all the
- 1:02:45time, just on how important flags are. But it's something that legitimately is
- 1:02:49important to all of us, because I don't know, you know, maybe
- 1:02:53I'm I don't know. I'm not sure whereverbody's political persuasions are, but I'm
- 1:02:57probably the only republic and potentially on this call or on our on our podcast
- 1:03:02here, oh we got Eric. Okay, I don't want to judge,
- 1:03:06right, but I at the end of the day, I'm one, probably
- 1:03:08one of the only ones. But yet this is one topic we can all
- 1:03:12sit in a room and debate over design and their meanings and all this other
- 1:03:16stuff. And this was a world that was completely unknown to me five six
- 1:03:22years ago, right right, Yeah, no, it's uh, it's been
- 1:03:29good having you in the game, despite you know, the actual political things
- 1:03:32that admittedly we do strongly disagree on. But yeah, I think we can
- 1:03:38appreciate, like I said, the I don't even agree politically with the people
- 1:03:42sitting at my at my Thanksgiving table, Andy, I don't know why we
- 1:03:45would ever expect all of us to agree on something, right, We've briefly
- 1:03:49talked about that. Yeah, yeah, no, and we don't have to.
- 1:03:51And I think like this is to the credit of that is that we
- 1:03:54can agree, as you said, on on this if nothing else, and
- 1:04:01I'm sure there are a few other things, but like if nothing else.
- 1:04:03We can agree on this and it doesn't matter like who brings it up,
- 1:04:09who whatever, Like, Yeah, I'm gonna lose myself if I keep talking
- 1:04:15about it. I did want to ask Eric one more question, at least
- 1:04:17one more question, but from somebody who's been kind of on the sidelines but
- 1:04:23also very much in the mix as well, maybe not politically, but again
- 1:04:29sidelines. What's kind of your favorite part of this process? If if I
- 1:04:35can, like, what's been the thing that's kind of given you the most
- 1:04:40joy or the most maybe surprised. I'll do two quick and one segue is
- 1:04:45just what we were just talking about, should Design Review Committee. I could
- 1:04:48go and say, like, that person is scary conservative. That person is
- 1:04:54frighteningly progressive, even for me who's a little more on the moderate side.
- 1:05:00That room was filled with various viewpoints, and I appreciated that it wasn't It
- 1:05:04wasn't one kind of it's not a monolith. Yeah, And then the other
- 1:05:12thing is actually an image, and I if I can find it, I'll
- 1:05:15send it to you and maybe you can share it on Instagram. But it's
- 1:05:18of it's a it's a grid of images ten wide, seven down of flags
- 1:05:27that feature a mountain background and a beehive and some nod to red rocks,
- 1:05:34and it's just so cool and kind of it's kismet. It's it's spiritual that
- 1:05:42everyone kind of knew that this was what Utah was going to look like.
- 1:05:46They were going to have a beehive. We wanted to acknowledge the greatest snow
- 1:05:50on Earth. We wanted to some some acknowledgment of southern Utah and their red
- 1:05:56rock It's it's awesome to see how many designs in that committee had mountains and
- 1:06:02beehives. It's just, oh, that's yeah, Okay, that's more than
- 1:06:08I was. Yeah, I use this all the time. Yeah, it's
- 1:06:14just that it was meant to be. That image kind of shows me.
- 1:06:17I'm like that this, even though it's not the best design, it's the
- 1:06:21most Utah design. And I feel that because I just realized Michael's not on
- 1:06:27this. But you know, but anyway you can leave me off. I
- 1:06:31would love to be out of the Utah discussion for the rest of my life.
- 1:06:38I honestly, I don't know if I can travel there safely at this
- 1:06:41point. Do you My next question was going to be to you, do
- 1:06:45you want to talk any on that or is it better just kind of left
- 1:06:47unsaid. No, it's it. I think it just echoes what Dan was
- 1:06:54saying, Like it's crazy that people care this much. I mean the when
- 1:07:00I do stuff. I mean, the only threats that I've had at Flags
- 1:07:04for Good, which is a company that is built to piss off half of
- 1:07:08people in this country, right it Also the only threats I've had have been
- 1:07:14on state flags, like not the Black Lives Matter stuff, not any of
- 1:07:17the Pride stuff, Like it's truly the state stuff, and like that's just
- 1:07:24nuts, and uh, constantly fascinated by flags and just very cool. It's
- 1:07:30been cool to meet Eric and Dan through this and get to know Tara through
- 1:07:35you know this tangentially and you know that came out of it at least,
- 1:07:42right, And of course a new flag for a beautiful state, which I
- 1:07:45love and would love to call myself a Utah one day and get some more
- 1:07:49of that best snow on earth. Yeah, right on, man, Like
- 1:07:53I just kind of like piggybacking off of that. Have you I'm wondering obviously
- 1:07:58you're uh, You're Utah redesign got the most probably I think safe to say
- 1:08:03the most traction. Uh and indirectly in a sense led to this, but
- 1:08:10like or maybe directly we can debate that. I would honestly say not like
- 1:08:15it sounds like from all the timelines that they've been saying like this was happening
- 1:08:19outside of what I was doing and they just kind of coincided at the same
- 1:08:25Yes, yeah, yeah, they did say that. But I love I
- 1:08:28will say this. I love that Michael an outsider who've been to Utah,
- 1:08:32like he knew enough about Utah and knew enough about like who we were that
- 1:08:38literally he came up with a flag that was really close. I mean it's
- 1:08:42and it's very well done and the only thing he left out is something that
- 1:08:45he just underappreciates about our culture, which is how important the beehive is.
- 1:08:50And you know, if you look at that, I'd say, you know,
- 1:08:54while while while I will not, I it is there was no cause
- 1:08:58and effect, but I can honestly say it is hard to not appreciate what
- 1:09:03Michael came up with and see it and say, you know, I get
- 1:09:06it. And the one thing and I'll just because this came up the one
- 1:09:11thing, you know, Michael said it earlier online, which I really appreciate
- 1:09:15because people just don't get it. Like Michael and I never really talked until
- 1:09:20the final design was out. And the funny thing is, and I can
- 1:09:25say this, I reached out to him because one i'd seen the billboard,
- 1:09:31like during the legislative session, was like, oh, that's cool. But
- 1:09:33it quickly was bleached from my mind as I'm dealing with seven thousand designs and
- 1:09:39trying to figure stuff out that way. But it wasn't until like we had
- 1:09:42a final, final, final design and we pull it up and we're getting
- 1:09:45you know, we're getting ready to print out some test copies and all this
- 1:09:48other stuff, and one of the designers says, you know, that looks
- 1:09:50a little bit like this other flag, and that literally that's how it came
- 1:09:56up. And I'm like, oh, wow, that's kind of cool.
- 1:09:59And so I direct messaged Michael on on Twitter and said, hey, uh,
- 1:10:05get a second, And so I called him and I had just gotten
- 1:10:09off of a I had just gotten off of a vacation and I called Michael
- 1:10:13and I said, dude, your design is really close, and I just
- 1:10:16want to say thank you for caring and like thinking it was awesome, and
- 1:10:20and we have. We have a bunch of other designs that were certainly part
- 1:10:24of it as well. And you know, there was a conversation whether or
- 1:10:27not, and Michael, you'll laugh at this, there was a conversation as
- 1:10:30to whether or not, like we should allow out of staters to win,
- 1:10:33you know, is when they had like this the winning sort of the winning
- 1:10:38thing, and I said absolutely not. No. Michael probably wishes I would
- 1:10:42have said yes, because then it would have saved him a bunch of heartache,
- 1:10:44sorrow probably, but like, but they said, I said absolutely not.
- 1:10:48Like our rules did not say you couldn't submit, or you couldn't win,
- 1:10:51or we couldn't appreciate your art if you're from out of state. We
- 1:10:56also didn't, you know, in our in our design criteria, we did
- 1:10:59not ask anybody's party affiliation. We didn't ask anybody how they felt about a
- 1:11:03specific issue or another that was never part of it. Because it's what this
- 1:11:09crowd appreciates, probably more than anybody else, is that maybe you could disagree
- 1:11:14on a thousand of the things, but like we could all get in the
- 1:11:16room and we could fight about a state flag or we fight about a design,
- 1:11:20and we can appreciably come together on a good design or whatever it may
- 1:11:26be that has nothing to do with our politics, has nothing to do with
- 1:11:29our background. And I feel like, and I mean this in its truest
- 1:11:32sense. I know Michael probably has some regrets. He'll get over it.
- 1:11:35I have, but you know, I'm really glad that people like Michael were
- 1:11:42interested in the process and jumped in. I mean, I wish, like
- 1:11:45anything, we could have done away with the conspiracy parts of it and all
- 1:11:48this other stuff. But I'm really glad that there are people like Michael who
- 1:11:51love Utah, wanted to participate, and wants to like say something positive about
- 1:11:57our state. Like I love all of that, and the more I can
- 1:12:00get of that, the better. And I know, maybe being you know,
- 1:12:04I've been an over includer in my life anyways, but maybe being over
- 1:12:09inclusive that way of just saying, hey, all ideas and we'll pick the
- 1:12:12best of those. I don't ever feel like the government, or society or
- 1:12:16anything else is any worse off because we take that approach. So thank you,
- 1:12:20Michael. Despite the pain that has come as a result of dabbling,
- 1:12:26I guess in that world I appreciate you and others who there were other people
- 1:12:30from out of state who also submitted. We had people as far as Slovenia,
- 1:12:34you know, and Turkey, and like that's looked like, which is
- 1:12:40awesome. So yeah, sorry, I finish up if you had one.
- 1:12:47I say, if I'm going to get burned down politically for having associated with
- 1:12:51people like Tara and Michael and Andy, you know, or no one's going
- 1:12:57to give me a hard time about Eric. Everybody loves that guy. But
- 1:13:00as soon as going to burn me down for an association, like, I
- 1:13:03can't pick better people to like associate with, and I'm all in, Like
- 1:13:08if people want to have a different opinion, I value that. I love
- 1:13:12it, and I love I love the value of the arena, so to
- 1:13:15speak of ideas, and so let's fight about our ideas. Let's make America
- 1:13:19better by fighting. And I know that sounds crazy, but I think that
- 1:13:24fight is absolutely essential to who we are and maybe FLAGS is just a microcosm
- 1:13:29of it. But I really want us to continue fighting. And I don't
- 1:13:31want anybody to check out of the debate because they don't agree with something or
- 1:13:35that kind of thing, like let's keep fighting. There you go, Yeah,
- 1:13:40yeah, no, I mean, well said and to that point,
- 1:13:45I think it's incredibly invaluable to have out of staters at least way in if
- 1:13:50not, you know, submit their own design like whatever. This is maybe
- 1:13:54a special case, but like I think what out of state or see in
- 1:13:58your state is incredibly valuable. What out of state or see in East Tennessee,
- 1:14:03for example, Like they come here, they're like, the mountains are
- 1:14:06are unlike anything I've known, and I just like it. It sticks in
- 1:14:11their head. The same thing with Utah. It's like the snow that you're
- 1:14:14talking about. It's like if you're from there, you start to not in
- 1:14:17every case, but a lot of times you can take things for granted,
- 1:14:21whereas if you come from somewhere else and you see like the natural beauty that's
- 1:14:25in Utah or in Tennessee or wherever, it sticks with you. And I
- 1:14:30think it's I think it's vitally important that we have both the local views and
- 1:14:35the out of state views kind of coming together on that design. And that's
- 1:14:43my piece. And I'm going to go back to being a moderator because I
- 1:14:45did have I did have one more question for Michael Head. I want to
- 1:14:50hear from Michael. Okay, yeah, no, Mike, you're no.
- 1:14:54I just wanted to echo what you're saying because you're so right. Like,
- 1:14:57a flag is a piece of design, and when you when you talk about
- 1:15:00designing a logo or something, you have to think about your audience. And
- 1:15:03a lot of times a flag has an internal and an external audience. And
- 1:15:08to say that somebody who doesn't live here can't design can't design our flag,
- 1:15:12that's like, oh, well, oh, you can only use internal employees
- 1:15:15to design a company logo. That's ridiculous, right, Like people have a
- 1:15:19experience and a training to do something like that. Like the father of exillology,
- 1:15:25Whitney Smith designed the flag for uh Guyana right in South America. Right,
- 1:15:30Like you can be a flag designer, but ship, where was your
- 1:15:34point? Where's the point going? Oh? Thinking of flags like brands,
- 1:15:41I mean, they truly are the brand of that place. And I think
- 1:15:45it's good to think of them like that and treat them like that because in
- 1:15:48the end, that is the logo in which someone will remember Tennessee. Right.
- 1:15:54It's also where you get the pushback is the thing as I'm sure like
- 1:15:59you guys and ly all four of you have, I've definitely dealt with much
- 1:16:04more than well, I would add to Michael's point, just underlining it right,
- 1:16:08I love you know when people would come at we were with, oh,
- 1:16:12you can't mess up our sacred seal, I say, well, our
- 1:16:15seal was designed assing it. Our seal was designed by a gentleman from Edmonton,
- 1:16:21Canada who moved here to work on the railroads. And he was a
- 1:16:27part timer in a bar all the livelong day. And he was a part
- 1:16:33timer working as a bartender. And he also knew metal work, you know,
- 1:16:36like pioneers knew how to I mean people who came here and came from
- 1:16:40all over the place, they knew stuff and like just had all these like
- 1:16:44this guy knew how to do metal artwork. And so he came up with
- 1:16:46the state seal because we needed one in eighteen ninety five, because it was
- 1:16:50literally the very first bill that the legislature adopted was adopting a state seal.
- 1:16:56And so this guy from Edmonton, Canada had moved here in eighteen ninety three,
- 1:17:00he designed the seal in eighteen ninety five, he moves away to California.
- 1:17:05In eighteen ninety seven. This guy was not from Utah. The Utah
- 1:17:11state Capitol was designed by Richard Kletting. Richard Kletting was an architect who did
- 1:17:15live in Utah at the time, but he grew up and you know,
- 1:17:17his architectural days were in Germany and in you know, in pre war Europe.
- 1:17:24And he was the one who really designed and brought the Utah State Capital
- 1:17:28to life from its design. And he's the one who incorporated the beehive and
- 1:17:32the hexagon throughout our state capitol. And so to your point, outsiders do
- 1:17:40bring an important perspective of how we're viewed or the things that are important.
- 1:17:44And it also gives us a great sense of who we are and also can
- 1:17:48tell us where we can how we can do it better. Right, We
- 1:17:51learned a lot from Mitt Romney run running for presidential candidate. Right he became
- 1:17:57the Republican nominee, and people said all kinds of stuff like and it was
- 1:18:01crazy to us, like you look at like the Bible Belt which includes you
- 1:18:05know, your town Andy, Tennessee. But you look at the Bible Belt
- 1:18:09area, and you know, Rodney pulled really poorly in the beginning in Tennessee,
- 1:18:14eventually one Tennessee. But poll questions and poll comments said a lot learned
- 1:18:20a lot really that old biases or old thoughts about who lds or Mormon people
- 1:18:27were still held true in a lot of those places, and you know they
- 1:18:30there were things that you know, You're like, well, I guess we
- 1:18:33get to learn a lot about ourselves and how we can pivot from that point
- 1:18:38to tell our story better or tell who we are differently. And if we
- 1:18:42don't like it, if we don't like what other people are saying, then
- 1:18:45I think one of the best things we can do is try and shape who
- 1:18:49like tell our story better. And that's an invitation in some ways more than
- 1:18:55it is condemnation. But yeah, yeah, no, I absolutely agree with
- 1:18:59that. And like kind of again piggybacking, like back up that point,
- 1:19:02like Tara to rope you back in here. Like the keystone flag itself was
- 1:19:06designed by you, a long time Pennsylvanian. But when you designed it,
- 1:19:12or maybe before you, I don't know the timeline here, but when you
- 1:19:15started talking to Michael, like it became apparent that Michael had designed a very
- 1:19:18similar flag with a keystone in the middle and two stars for the second state
- 1:19:24to join the Union. So it's very interesting to both a long time Pennsylvanian
- 1:19:30and someone who's been there but not you know, from there, came up
- 1:19:33with such a similar design. And I think that speaks to pretty much the
- 1:19:38point that we've been going around on here. Did that like, did that
- 1:19:42surprise you? Are there any other like Keystone designs that you've been like,
- 1:19:45Oh wait, did you crip for me? Or did I crip? Like?
- 1:19:49Oh yeah, no, somebody actually came to me. I think this
- 1:19:54was in late twenty twenty two, when when the Keystone fly kickstarter was taking
- 1:19:59off. Hey, I think this flag's for good. Guy ripped off your
- 1:20:01design. Okay, interesting. But here's the thing though, Here's the thing
- 1:20:08we've talked. Michael had no idea. Right, If you want to go
- 1:20:13in the other I designed this in almost its current form in twenty seventeen,
- 1:20:17but Michael had never seen it. If you want to take the story backwards
- 1:20:20in the other direction, there's another flag that was designed in twenty twelve that
- 1:20:27was then entered into a Reddit competition for New state flags that also looks almost
- 1:20:31exactly like the Keystone flag in blue, white and gold, stolen from the
- 1:20:35license plate. I think the license plate is an interesting thing to take your
- 1:20:40flag colors from But sure, let's make a vase of logo flag. Why
- 1:20:44not? But just the idea that you know, when you look at these
- 1:20:47forms of people who have designed these flags, and so many of them hit
- 1:20:51on so many similar subjects. Senator and Eric, both of you were talking
- 1:20:57about how many designs looked so similar, with the beehive, with the red
- 1:21:01rocks, with the blue skies, with the white mountains, and over and
- 1:21:04over. I see a couple of recurring themes with Pennsylvania flags. I see
- 1:21:09keystones, some small sums stretching the whole way. I see many with blue
- 1:21:15and gold, some with red, some with green. I see a bunch
- 1:21:18that tried to incorporate William Penn's coat of arms. But over and over,
- 1:21:23these common themes keep popping up, and I think being able to see all
- 1:21:27of those and distilling what is best here right, I think the fact that
- 1:21:31so many different people can, independently, without seeing each other's work, come
- 1:21:38to the same idea speaks to can speak to the value of an idea,
- 1:21:44and can speak to the power of what symbols just occur naturally. And I
- 1:21:49think that is probably the way I would say a new state should do that
- 1:21:57is, like, let it come organically. Like main, which flag do
- 1:22:00they use up there? They use the old flag. So just choose between
- 1:22:04the one that's already there and the old one. Milwaukee, they have a
- 1:22:09flag that all the people use. You don't need a design committee. Just
- 1:22:13choose between the thing that's already in use, the thing that just continues to
- 1:22:15come up and come up and come up, and the old Right, maybe
- 1:22:19that's the best way to do it, is let it over time design itself.
- 1:22:25Well, that's been one of my philosophies too with this is you know,
- 1:22:29I've I've looked at this as a kind of a people's flag, as
- 1:22:33you've mentioned, right, even if it's not the symbol of a government,
- 1:22:36that's fine. There are a lot of people who would prefer the government are
- 1:22:40nowhere near their lives, right. There are a lot of people who,
- 1:22:44you know, even the people who want more government are like, oh,
- 1:22:46in this aspect of my life, you stay off right, And so it's
- 1:22:54it's I'm trying to remember where I started with this to where I was going
- 1:22:59here, but just the ut here we go. So just thinking about how
- 1:23:04you know, the Keystone flag has kind of taken off as a people's flag.
- 1:23:09Flags for Good is not the only group making the Keystone flag. Kiwe
- 1:23:14Vexart has made it. I've talked to a couple other people about independent production.
- 1:23:17I'm thinking, you know, I'm thinking about other pins and patches that
- 1:23:20have come out those aren't coming from Flags for Good. Right, this is
- 1:23:25something that that is taking off in an organic sense. It doesn't have to
- 1:23:30be the flag of a government if the people agree, just through common consensus.
- 1:23:35Yeah, this is this is what it is. We've already got it.
- 1:23:39You know. My dream is someday people go, wait, that's not
- 1:23:42the state flag. You know that's clear. Yeah, well, shoot,
- 1:23:49I don't This might be a good time to wind down, unless anyone has
- 1:23:53any closing remarks. Eric, it's been a sec I think you've been the
- 1:23:57longest since. Have you had anything to maybe kind of close us out with
- 1:24:00on your end? I saw in the chat thoughts I saw in the chat
- 1:24:08Tara brought up kind of we have the two flag solution here. Yes,
- 1:24:13in Utah, I was. I was actually at the Capitol today and they
- 1:24:18have in front we have the American flag and the new Utah flag. However,
- 1:24:26on top of the building we have an American flag and the historic flag.
- 1:24:30And I feel like when we said no, we're keeping the old flag,
- 1:24:35people like didn't believe that, and so I appreciated that as kind of
- 1:24:42like a show of good faith. We're like, see, it's not about
- 1:24:45like trashing history. It's not about it's not a Mississippi situation. It's just
- 1:24:54did you see that r UF cropped it out of the image that they posted
- 1:24:58on Twitter. I didn't on Twitter because they have to fit that narrative,
- 1:25:03but I mean, you're you're correct, and please continue. Yeah, And
- 1:25:08so as far as the two state there there may two flag two state solution.
- 1:25:13That's a different that's a different conversation. As far as two flags out,
- 1:25:17maybe there's a day when one like becomes more popular than the other,
- 1:25:21but until then, it's kind of like free market. And it's to the
- 1:25:27people that say like, well we should vote on which one, I'm like,
- 1:25:30well, you know, the way we vote now is everyone can fly
- 1:25:32what they want and then we'll just kind of like see what happens. But
- 1:25:36to those like I think I shared on Twitter, like a study that said
- 1:25:41like the older you are, the more you prefer the old flag. And
- 1:25:45to those people. It's still codified. There is still a flag of Utah.
- 1:25:49So go ahead, like knock yourself out. I love the new one,
- 1:25:55but I respect somebody who likes the old one. And we'll see where
- 1:25:58it goes. Yes, can I and I can this, This will this
- 1:26:02will be an interesting aside. You know. Again, there are just lessons,
- 1:26:08right, there's all these lessons and the one thing I you know,
- 1:26:12you bring up the two flag solution, Tarra, and it reminds me of
- 1:26:15one of my lessons, right, It's like, beware of compromise. And
- 1:26:21I know that's I know that that's uh, you know, maybe a loaded
- 1:26:26That's something Michael would say up front, you know, because it's very controversial,
- 1:26:29you know, but beware of beware of compromise. And the reason I
- 1:26:32say that is unless unless you have a defined group to compromise with, if
- 1:26:41you compromise once over the lengthy process, that compromise may not be effective to
- 1:26:49keep the next group that pops up afterwards, to keep them on board.
- 1:26:56And so the two flag solution came up in November of twenty twenty, when
- 1:27:01you know, we'd heard in the first bill that we could we could we
- 1:27:04could set up a task Force, and we said, we, you know,
- 1:27:06we'll consider ideas. We were looking at maybe the governor's flag. We're
- 1:27:11trying to figure out how we memorialize and keep our existing are the existing or
- 1:27:15the historic state flag? And legislators and others who came and complained about the
- 1:27:20process, we said, look, we came up with this where we weren't
- 1:27:24going to do away with the historic state flag. We were just going to,
- 1:27:28you know, give it a different role. And we actually have a
- 1:27:30history of doing that in Utah. We we have an old state hymn that
- 1:27:33was adopted in the early nineteen hundreds and it's extremely complicated, hard to play
- 1:27:41and hard to sing. You know, it's not playable on my guitar.
- 1:27:46So like things that like you just can't do. And so we came up
- 1:27:51with a new state song. It was easy for kids to sing, easy
- 1:27:55to play. And so we did was a created a state hymn, and
- 1:27:58we moved the other song it was or complicated, made it the state hymn,
- 1:28:01and then we have the state song which then replaced it. So that
- 1:28:04was kind of the model we were looking at. We adopted that compromise with
- 1:28:09everybody else kind of on board, we thought, and then and then along
- 1:28:15comes like after we had the final design, up comes a new group of
- 1:28:18people who are you know, who are mad and frustrated and you know,
- 1:28:25ready to burn the place down. And unfortunately or fortunately, you know,
- 1:28:30depending on how you look at it, we had compromised so early that there
- 1:28:33was nothing left to compromise other than just say, hey, this is the
- 1:28:41you know. One guy said, hey, let's just make that new logo
- 1:28:45the state shield instead of like the state flag, which was absolutely ridiculous,
- 1:28:50but that was, you know, that was his idea, and and and
- 1:28:55then others were like, well, let's just let's just not adopt it and
- 1:28:58we'll just start flying at the capitol. I'm like, that won't work either,
- 1:29:00because you've got to have something that's not confusing to the rest of the
- 1:29:04world. And so that's that was an interesting lesson and compromise for me in
- 1:29:10the legislative process was just trying to figure out when you compromise and make sure
- 1:29:15that when you compromise that it's enough to get everybody there. And I'm afraid,
- 1:29:20you know, the two flag solution. I love it. I think
- 1:29:23it's distinctive. I think it's you know, makes us unique a little bit,
- 1:29:28and it does tell the story that we do still like our state seal,
- 1:29:31we haven't thrown it out, and so having that be a component of
- 1:29:35that conversation as well. But there are some who are just convinced that that
- 1:29:41we our whole goal, our whole absolute deal here is to get rid of
- 1:29:45the seal from the guy from Edmonton, uh and you know, and and
- 1:29:50get rid of his work. And that is not that was not our attempt,
- 1:29:55that was not our goal. And and it's just hard to tell the
- 1:29:59story any other way. And that's one, you know, one of the
- 1:30:01other lessons is lies spread so much easier than the truth, and it's really
- 1:30:08unfortunate it happens. It doesn't matter your political persuasion one way or the other.
- 1:30:13But lies spread there's so much easier, there's so much more convenient,
- 1:30:16and they're just quicker to spread. It's easier to otherise somebody based on you
- 1:30:23know, one thing you've heard, And that's exactly what happens in this process
- 1:30:27on several occasions, was just they decided it was a Michael Green conspiracy.
- 1:30:33And you know, I'm working with all these outside people and they're leftist lobbyists
- 1:30:40who are taking over the state of Utah. And you know that that isn't
- 1:30:44what had happened at all. It was really just an organic thing that the
- 1:30:45people grew into and it just the lie spread so much faster than I could
- 1:30:50actually ever tell the truth. And everybody's like, well, you should have
- 1:30:54told more. I said, well, I tried. But we spent five
- 1:30:58hundred thousand dollars and you know, on the rebrand or on the on the
- 1:31:01flag design process, and most of that was public opinion gathering. I mean
- 1:31:04two thirds of that was gathering public opinion. Can I throw in there that
- 1:31:09that is a shockingly low number if you really get down to it anyway,
- 1:31:16considering everything. But we could have spent a lot more, right, We
- 1:31:20could have spent a lot more in social media and advertising all that stuff.
- 1:31:25We didn't because we were sensitive to the budget, right right, which was
- 1:31:30the argument against you, which billboards are really cheap though against you with the
- 1:31:36plum so you know, and yet they don't stop. So but I would
- 1:31:44say the two flaged answer taris question. I do think the two flag solution
- 1:31:46is helpful in our in our case where we're not I wouldn't recommend it for
- 1:31:50Mississippi. Mississippi had a totally different motivation for why they were doing what they
- 1:31:56were doing right and and their motivation, you know, if you talk to
- 1:31:59the speak or the House Phil Gunn in Mississippi. I've had a lengthy conversation
- 1:32:02with Phil about how they got where they did, how they got the votes,
- 1:32:06you know, all the community and church leaders that got involved. Like
- 1:32:10it was amazing to hear their story. I would say, Andy, that's
- 1:32:14a that's another conversation worth having on your podcast. But but their process was
- 1:32:19a totally different element and how it happened and how it failed and how it
- 1:32:24then succeeded totally different story. Ours was where we want to make sure that
- 1:32:30we respect and honor our heritage and adopt something that could be more easily recognizable
- 1:32:35for design purposes. And so when you when you have that, I think
- 1:32:40the two flag solution can work, you know, And and that's I guess
- 1:32:45that's really That's really all I could say about that. Yeah, no,
- 1:32:49I'll thank you again at the end, but yeah, thanks for being here
- 1:32:51and thanks for that. Michael. Did you want to have any closing remarks
- 1:32:57to your own? No? Okay, cool? His light has gone from
- 1:33:04his the light has gone from his room, and now it's in mine.
- 1:33:09I was gonna say, yeah, the sun is literally yeah, we can
- 1:33:12track it basically because I'll say something controversial again, the earth is round,
- 1:33:18So that's I can put up with a lot on this show. But okay,
- 1:33:26dude, I guess if you say so, But no, I would
- 1:33:30love a closing from you if you have anything separate to add or anything,
- 1:33:34or if not, we can move on. No. I I think I've
- 1:33:40said this to Dan personally, but I mean, congratulations, You've done something
- 1:33:45that I did not think was possible. And that's one of the reasons I
- 1:33:50did my project is I was like, there's no way a state, a
- 1:33:54city, any politician would take up this charge because it is a lose lose
- 1:34:00situation, like you're gonna piss people off. And so yeah, you did
- 1:34:05it, and it's amazing and hopefully as a model for a lot of states
- 1:34:12to come and hopefully we see a lot more better flags out there. And
- 1:34:17some people will say that there's no point, like it's just whatever, but
- 1:34:20I think, you know, in fifty years, there'll be a lot of
- 1:34:23people who will have, you know, state pride because now they have a
- 1:34:27symbol to attribute how they feel to their states, so or cities or whatever.
- 1:34:32You know. I think this will be a model for a lot of
- 1:34:34states to come. So congrats you did it, and cheers to you with
- 1:34:43a non alcoholic beer, I guess cheers to you with an alcoholic beer.
- 1:34:47But also yeah, I mean, like, like, well just to I
- 1:34:53think I've used the word piggyback more today than I ever have with like any
- 1:34:56of my cousins, but our nieces or nephews to piggyback on that, Like,
- 1:35:02I am so excited for Utah to get that, Like not just the
- 1:35:06beehive. The beehive is you know, like a little bit pervasive, but
- 1:35:10like the already pervasive in a good way, but the beehive with the hecks,
- 1:35:15Like I cannot wait for you guys to get that everywhere because the amount
- 1:35:17of times I see the tri Star like the Tennessee tryst around here, it
- 1:35:24it brings out the state pride that I otherwise don't normally have as like you
- 1:35:29guys have touched on. I mean, we haven't really gone too much into
- 1:35:31politics, but I am a lot more left, but I still which makes
- 1:35:36me like not automatically associated with the South in every sense. I do love
- 1:35:44the cooking, though, and we'll say that. But seeing that TriStar,
- 1:35:47it brings me right back as a Tennessee boy, like, regardless of my
- 1:35:50thoughts on like anything else. And I can only imagine it's gonna be the
- 1:35:55same with the beehive. It already is the same with the keystone, which
- 1:35:58we'll touch on. And yeah, I could not be happier for you guys.
- 1:36:00But Tara, do you want to kind of close us out with a
- 1:36:03little bit of well, a little bit of whatever you get. I guess,
- 1:36:08just coming from somebody who's seeing the very early, early early stages of
- 1:36:14this in Pennsylvania, and I mean the earliest of stages, it has been
- 1:36:20an honor and a joy to watch this process from the outside, and to
- 1:36:24be able to talk to some people on the inside too, an honor,
- 1:36:29joy and a privilege, honestly, just knowing that it is possible to change
- 1:36:34a flag for pure design reasons, right, not to get rid of something
- 1:36:40bad, but to have something good. And I'm watching so many parallels.
- 1:36:45I'm watching the introduction of bills that fail and then fail again. HR six
- 1:36:50one sixty three has yet to get a committee assignment nearly a year later.
- 1:36:55Right, But I'm watching, you know, the Keystone flag go up the
- 1:36:59way Commemorative flag did. I'm seeing the introduction of that bill suddenly bringing resurgence.
- 1:37:03Years I've lived a couple of blocks from the Capitol, I've gone in
- 1:37:08through. I had never seen a Pennsylvania flag in the gift shop until HR
- 1:37:12one sixty three. I had never seen a Pennsylvania flag hanging from the rafters
- 1:37:16the way they do in Colorado until HR one sixty three. By the way,
- 1:37:19to anybody listening, House Resolution one sixty three, call your representatives and
- 1:37:25state senators here in Pennsylvania. You know it doesn't have to be the Keystone
- 1:37:30flag, but if you're here, you probably want a better flag for Pennsylvania,
- 1:37:34and you should tell them that you do. You should be clear about
- 1:37:36that because they need to hear that support. Not only that, but seeing
- 1:37:42folks defend themselves from slings and arrows and having an idea of what to expect,
- 1:37:48understanding you know, correct me if I'm wrong. But I feel like
- 1:37:54this comes back to something I've had as kind of a personal mantra when it
- 1:37:58comes to disagreements, we don't compromise. We find common ground, and I
- 1:38:01think y'all have done a really good job in Utah of doing that. I
- 1:38:05don't think that the design has so much compromised as found common ground, right,
- 1:38:12and that I think is a key to bringing folks together as well.
- 1:38:15Governor Cox says, disagree better, but it's true you find common ground,
- 1:38:24and I can only hope that things go as well for us here as they
- 1:38:28have for y'all. I applaud and congratulate you, and while certainly on many
- 1:38:34other issues we disagree, I thank you for your work on this issue.
- 1:38:40Yeah, I think I think that's a pretty good place to leave it.
- 1:38:45Congrats to everyone who was literally any part of this, including a ton a
- 1:38:50legion of people that are not on this call. It was not possible without
- 1:38:55all of you. And yeah again, well and to the people here,
- 1:39:00thank you so much for coming on. Tara, Eric Dance, Senator Dan
- 1:39:04McKay, and Michael, do you mind if I add one thing real quick?
- 1:39:09May only a little bit, I only mind a little bit one second.
- 1:39:14I'll just say that no politicians speaks in less than a second, but
- 1:39:17you get it. I'll just say that I get you know, bill failures,
- 1:39:23other things like those things happen to legislators all the time. There is
- 1:39:27something you have to be aware of before you start this process. You know,
- 1:39:30any legislator listening to this or whatever, you have to be aware that
- 1:39:34if you jump into this and you decide to do it, it could be
- 1:39:39the last thing you do. And I decided early on, like once I
- 1:39:45was in and I was making a point of like we're doing this and ran
- 1:39:49bills and that kind of thing, I decided early on that that that something
- 1:39:57that Roman Mars said that stuck with me. Ted Kay is emphasized I've heard
- 1:40:00Michael here as well, in all of us. It is living with bad
- 1:40:05design is a cost that we don't realize how expensive it is. And it
- 1:40:13isn't until you have better design that you realize what value you have lost.
- 1:40:19And that's honestly been that kind of thing is important enough to me that I
- 1:40:27decided that if this was it, and I was like, this is going
- 1:40:30to be the hill I was going to die on, I decided this was
- 1:40:33the hill, and I don't know if I will. I was up for
- 1:40:36election after passing the Commission bill, and I survived that one. I'll be
- 1:40:42up again in two years. I'll know you know whether or not I'm former
- 1:40:45senator in our next conversation. But it's one of those things that you have
- 1:40:49to be aware. It is more politically charged than you realize it's going to
- 1:40:53be. But good design is worth it people. It just is. And
- 1:40:59people are not going to appreciate it. They're not going to respect it.
- 1:41:01They're going to trounce on it. They're gonna call it cartoony, they're going
- 1:41:04to toilet like a third grader could do it. They're like, go down
- 1:41:08all the reasons and all the terrible insults. You know. Unfortunately, the
- 1:41:12flag is me in some ways, and I've kind of taken I guess,
- 1:41:15that level of ownership of it. But I know, and I knew when
- 1:41:18I started this that if that was the cost I had to pay, it
- 1:41:23was one I was willing to pay. And I would just make sure anybody
- 1:41:28else that picks up this idea just recognizes it could be them too. Maybe
- 1:41:33that's leak, okay, good, But also he passed a lot of legislation
- 1:41:40this past session, so he he didn't acts his political career completely, but
- 1:41:45he is known as the Flag guy. Now, yeah, I'm already known
- 1:41:48as the flag person along the flag person in our varying groups, some with
- 1:41:59much more high stakes than others, as Dan just pointed out. But yeah,
- 1:42:03unless anyone can top that, I think now is probably a good time
- 1:42:08to to go ahead and head out. And again, I can't thank all
- 1:42:13four of you enough for being here. As Dan alluded to, hopefully,
- 1:42:17yes, we will chat again in the future, whether it's about this,
- 1:42:20hopefully something else, but you know, we'll see uh kind of what the
- 1:42:24future brings as far as flags, and we can just bet that the next
- 1:42:29state that doesn't Andy, let's all get together and have another party. Absolutely
- 1:42:33even if yes, okay, I'm not going to caveat that, We'll just
- 1:42:40say yes either way, whether we like it or don't. Michael, please
- 1:42:45come back to your stream so I can there we go. Yeah, it
- 1:42:48was to a point. Yeah, for a purpose, absolutely, Yeah,
- 1:42:54really hoping for that made one anyway, Thank you guys so much for joining
- 1:42:58us, both you guys for being on the stream, and thanks for everyone
- 1:43:00who streamed this. It will obviously be up soon on the actual part of
- 1:43:04YouTube as well. And yeah, unless anyone has a good close out here,
- 1:43:10like the normal show. Then I think we can probably just go ahead
- 1:43:14and shut this thing down. Anyone got anything, No, Sarah, Some
- 1:43:17kisses, kiss kisses all around. All right. Well again, thank you
- 1:43:25guys so much, and we will talk to you soon. Catch you on
- 1:43:29the fly side.