Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Tesla and the Long Road to 400,000 Kilometers
Transcript
- 0:10You know the drill. Your two year old smartphone
- 0:12dies at 20% and you think, am I really going to drop massive
- 0:17money on an EV if it's just, you know, a giant degrading iPhone?
- 0:22Welcome to the deep dive. Yeah, I mean, that's such a
- 0:24common fear to have. Right.
- 0:26So today our mission is to cut through those EV battery
- 0:29degradation myths. We are looking at what actually
- 0:32happens when electric vehicles are pushed to the absolute
- 0:35extreme. We're pulling insights from EV
- 0:38Central, Tesla, Roddy and Italian Auto Report, and this
- 0:41detailed breakdown of a huge IC car study.
- 0:45Exactly. We're giving you the bottom line
- 0:47on the true cost and lifespan of EVs compared to traditional gas
- 0:51engines, so. You can see if these cars are
- 0:52actually built to last, but let's start with that analogy.
- 0:55Is a car really just a giant iPhone?
- 0:57Well, no. I mean, the analogy makes sense
- 0:59on the surface, but it completely ignores how EV
- 1:01batteries actually function. Like, your phone sits in a Hot
- 1:04Pocket, right? Or on a sunny dashboard.
- 1:06Which is baking in the sun. Right, and it charges to a true
- 1:09100%, which effectively just cooks the lithium ion cells to
- 1:13death. But an EV, on the other hand,
- 1:15carries around its own dedicated liquid cooling HVAC system.
- 1:19Wait just for the battery. Yeah, just for the battery.
- 1:22It actively manages its own temperature.
- 1:24Plus it uses software buffers, so you never actually hit those
- 1:27true 0 or 100% limits. OK, so it's actively protecting
- 1:31itself from the kind of degradation a phone goes
- 1:33through. That makes sense.
- 1:36But to really answer that assumption, we need to look at
- 1:38real world extreme stress tests like ride shares and taxis.
- 1:43Oh yeah, the 400,000 kilometer club.
- 1:46There's this Australian Uber driver who just hit 410,000
- 1:50kilometers in a 2021 Model 3. 410,000 in just a few years.
- 1:55That is insane. It is.
- 1:56And the wild part is, after all that mileage, the car still
- 1:59retained around 88 to 90% of its original battery hell.
- 2:03Wow, that's honestly be hard to believe.
- 2:05Well, there's another case, a 2014 Model S taxi in Finland.
- 2:08That one hit 400,000 kilometers, with about 93% of its capacity
- 2:12remaining. 93% but wait, didn't that finished driver utilize the
- 2:17warranty for some motor and battery servicing?
- 2:20He did, yeah. But what's crucial to understand
- 2:23is how that servicing actually works.
- 2:25They aren't just throwing away the whole battery pack, they
- 2:27usually just swap out individual degraded cell modules within the
- 2:31pack so the core architecture survives.
- 2:34Gotcha. OK, let me push back here
- 2:36though, because EVs are incredibly heavy.
- 2:40Oh, absolutely. You've got this massive battery
- 2:42pack and the aggressive instant torque of an electric motor
- 2:46tearing at the chassis every time you accelerate.
- 2:49Even if the battery survives, doesn't the physical car just
- 2:52sort of rattle apart under all that stress?
- 2:54I mean, the sheer weight and torque definitely accelerate
- 2:57wear on certain things like suspension components and tires.
- 3:00Yeah, going back to that Australian Uber driver, he
- 3:02actually did develop a really severe juttering issue.
- 3:05Oh see, so the car was rattling apart.
- 3:07You'd think so, but the diagnosis wasn't some
- 3:10catastrophic structural failure, it was just worn motor mount
- 3:13bushings. Really just the bushings.
- 3:15Yeah, because of that instant torque, those rubber and metal
- 3:19mounts take a serious beating. But he took it to a specialist
- 3:23and they swapped the parts for $130.00. $130.00 after 400,000
- 3:29kilometers of hard driving. About 7 hours of Labor and the
- 3:32car literally drove like new again.
- 3:35That is massive for you as an owner when you factor in relying
- 3:39on electricity rather than gas. That driver pocketed an
- 3:42estimated $37,000 in fuel savings alone.
- 3:45It fundamentally changes the math on vehicle ownership.
- 3:48OK, individual anecdotes are fascinating, but a couple of
- 3:52lucky taxi drivers don't prove a global trend.
- 3:55To prove this isn't just a fluke, we have to look at big
- 3:58data. Right, which brings us to the IC
- 4:00car study. They analyzed a massive 174
- 4:03million vehicles to see which ones actually hit 250,000 miles,
- 4:07which is about 402,000 kilometers.
- 4:09That's a huge sample size. So who took the crown?
- 4:12Toyota reigns supreme, hitting 17.8%, but Tesla impressively
- 4:16hit 4.6%. 4.6%. Yeah, beating out 26 legacy
- 4:21brands, including luxury giants like BMW and Audi.
- 4:25It literally mathematically double S the chances of a Subaru
- 4:28reaching that mileage. OK, but here's my question.
- 4:31The global average for all cars hitting 250,000 miles is 4.8%
- 4:36right? So if Tesla's at 4.6, why should
- 4:40we celebrate them getting a slightly lower score than the
- 4:43global average? Because of fleet age, that 4.8%
- 4:47average is heavily skewed upward by giants like Honda and Toyota.
- 4:51They have millions of 20 year old cars on the road.
- 4:54Oh see yeah, the Tesla fleet is incredibly young.
- 4:56It's mostly built in the last four to six years.
- 4:58They literally haven't had the time to rack up 250,000 miles
- 5:01yet. So we're comparing a fleet of
- 5:03toddlers to fleet of marathon runners.
- 5:06That's exactly it. And remember, traditional
- 5:08internal combustion engines face catastrophic failure points at
- 5:11those extreme mileages. You know, timing chain stretch
- 5:14head gaskets. Blow right and EVs just
- 5:16completely lack those specific failure points.
- 5:18Exactly. So without those IC E failure
- 5:21points, as this young EV fleet ages, we are mathematically
- 5:25bound to see that 4.6% just skyrocket.
- 5:28That really completely dispels the myth of the fragile EV
- 5:33battery. Their simplified Dr. trains
- 5:35really do offer serious long term mechanical robustness.
- 5:39I absolutely do. Well, thank you so much to
- 5:41everyone listening for bringing your curiosity and joining us on
- 5:44this deep dive today. Yeah, thanks for hanging out
- 5:46with us. But before you go, we want to
- 5:47leave you with this thought to ponder.
- 5:50If an E VS battery and motor can theoretically outlast the
- 5:53physical chassis of the car itself, Will the future of auto
- 5:56ownership mean simply extracting your million mile battery and
- 6:00dropping it into a brand new car body every decade?