Latest / Gaming The System - The Feminist Gaming Podcast / Girls Sports and P.E Part 01 - Our School Sports Origins (Episode 278)
Transcript
- 0:06Det skjønner du Hello, everyone.
- 0:15Welcome back to another episode of Gaming the System, the podcast where three intersectional feminists examine gaming and games through a feminist lens.
- 0:24Today, I am your host, Matt, and I'm joined by my friends Alex and Jem.
- 0:29Before we get started, if you want to support us, you can subscribe to our Patreon at patreon.com/gamingthesystem for some exclusive content, or you can send us a one-off donation via PayPal to our email address, wearegamingthesystem@gmail.com So today we are going to be exploring the world of sports specifically for girls, so those in childhood and adolescence.
- 0:57We tend to focus on adult sport for, in the women's game, so Alex and I have talked a lot about tennis, but, and also about, it's normally about professional sports when I don't think there is enough detail and attention paid to how sport is engaged with by children.
- 1:24Because when you're an adult, you can, you can basically choose whatever you, you want that you've got access to.
- 1:30But as a child, you are hemmed into the system.
- 1:34And is it, is the system good?
- 1:38Is it getting better?
- 1:39What needs to change?
- 1:41Hopefully, we'll explore what that's going to be.
- 1:44So we'll start off by looking at the current state of girls' sport and look at some of the, the cultural impact and cultural and practical barriers that girls face that boys and otherwise may not face.
- 2:03So Alex and Jem, what were your experiences at, at sport as children?
- 2:13Who wants to go first?
- 2:15I can start if you know.
- 2:17I have a kind of mixed feelings, I suppose you could say.
- 2:22I think a lot of that is largely down to growing up with cerebral palsy.
- 2:28Often I did not enjoy PE very much at all because I was...
- 2:35Well, I was in mainstream schools in primary school and secondary school, so when I did PE, it was with a whole set of other children who did not have cerebral palsy.
- 2:46And so I often felt like sort of the odd one out, I suppose, in a lot of group activities because...
- 2:53And often incredibly frustrated because a lot of the other kids would be able to do whatever activity it was, and I would not, um, by comparison, or be limited in my ability to do certain activities.
- 3:05So I often felt very frustrated because we've discussed how competitive I am generally.
- 3:11It would be a great source of frustration and shame for me that I wasn't able to do, um, hurdles, for example, or climb a, a ladder or climb a rope or jump off the, the, the gym course, whatever you call it.
- 3:26You know, like the, the vaulting thing.
- 3:28And often, of course, I'd find it incredibly tiring as well.
- 3:32Um, I never, never looked forward to PE at all really.
- 3:36And oftentimes outside of the school environment, any sport that I did undertake, for example, swimming, and I did have a period of time where I was having judo classes as well.
- 3:49That was through the, the lens of it being an aid to my physiotherapy, so my physical conditioning and my ability to walk, you know, more than, more than perhaps my body would have been able to if I wasn't staying active.
- 4:05So I always sort of viewed sport through that medicalized lens, that it was a means to an end to improve my, my physical conditioning rather than something I was choosing to, to do for fun.
- 4:18Although I really enjoyed judo.
- 4:21I quite, I quite liked it, which was good because, you know, otherwise I don't, I don't want to paint a relentlessly negative picture here.
- 4:29I obviously also enjoyed swimming as well, but there was that medicalized aspect to it where it was doing things for my body that my physios had in a plan for my, for my sort of, um, my therapy, my physical therapy as it were.
- 4:47Um- But yeah, but it's, it's an interesting one as well'cause the mainstream school can only support disabled children so far.
- 4:56Um, I remember having a conversation with my secondary school PE teacher, he said about the bleep test,"Have you done the bleep test?" Jem, do you remember the bleep test?
- 5:06Yeah.
- 5:06Yeah, remember as well.
- 5:08It was my most hated thing'cause obviously after about two or three goes, I would be like,"No, can't do it anymore." So I'd just sat and watched everyone else.
- 5:16It felt like a massive waste of time.
- 5:18And my, my PE teacher was like,"Oh, wouldn't it be good if we could try it with you, but on a treadmill so I don't have to stop and turn?"'Cause I was losing my balance, and then obviously slowing down the more and more faster it got.
- 5:31And I thought it'd be really great, then I could see actually truly how well I can do the bleep test.
- 5:38But of course then she said,"But that's too expensive for us to get a treadmill, so we won't be able to do it.
- 5:44But wouldn't it be good if we could?" You know?
- 5:47Oh, God.
- 5:48So there was a lot of things,"Oh, well, we don't have the funding for X, Y, and Z." So yeah, it-- And of course, you know how much I love to watch sport.
- 5:57I would love to be able to, uh, have had the opportunities to try, I suppose you'd call them Paralympic sports, so sports tailored for disabled people, designed for disabled people to take part in.
- 6:12That is something I've always been curious about, but never had the opportunity to partake in, um, as a younger person, as a young, young woman and a, and a girl.
- 6:23Because obviously, um, it depends, obviously, if you're lucky, you've got maybe some places nearby.
- 6:31But don't think-- I don't know if that was the case necessarily.
- 6:34And of course, we were quite happy with swimming and judo where we were, but those were kind of the things that were open to us.
- 6:43But yeah, but it's an interesting topic, definitely, and I'm sure I'll think of plenty more examples while we're talking as well.
- 6:50But yeah, Jem, I'd be interested to hear how things were for you as well.
- 6:56Yeah, so I'm, I feel like I'm quite cliche in the way that my, that my experience went with sports, because at primary school I was really interested in sports.
- 7:10I did...
- 7:10I was in the netball team, and I just really enjoyed that.
- 7:14I loved playing all the, the games and the competitions, and really enjoyed it.
- 7:20And then I went to high school, and I went to try out for the, for the netball team.
- 7:29I mean, this wasn't a massive school.
- 7:31It was, like, just over 1,000 students or something, so you know, we're not talking about, like, a, a big pool of students to choose from really.
- 7:41And the whole attitude when I got there was so negative and competitive and mean, and there was no, like...
- 7:52I- bear in mind that I'm, like, just into high school, so I'm just little year seven, and you know, it's a little fish in a big pond and all of that.
- 8:01And I go along to this thing to, to try for the netball team, having been really, like, told that I was a valuable part of my primary school team.
- 8:16And they basically were like,"Well, you know, that's where you used to play at primary, but you can't play there.
- 8:22You have to go and play over there.
- 8:23You have to do this.
- 8:24You have to do it like that.
- 8:25We're not gonna..." And it, it just, it literally, that one session completely turned me off of, off sports.
- 8:34And from that point onwards, my engagement in sports at high school just was on a massive downward trajectory.
- 8:43I was the student who refused to even move faster than a slow walk on the co- cross country, despite the fact that I would have teachers shouting at me or trying to encourage me along.
- 8:56I'd be like,"No, I'm walking around the whole thing.
- 8:58I'm not running.
- 8:59I'm not interested in that." I remember I had a friend who was, like, really into her sports, and she would do cr- cross country racing.
- 9:07She was a horse rider.
- 9:09She was just, you know, she was just aver- she would compete with the school all the time.
- 9:13And I remember one time coming back from the cross country and just sort of, like, ambling back in with all the bad girls at back.
- 9:20And walking in, and she was there going,"Come on, Jem, you can, you can..." Just like off.
- 9:27I don't want to do it.
- 9:29Why would I want this?
- 9:31So it was just, my whole attitude was so negative to sport, and at, to the point that when it came to athletics, which I absolutely hated because I, I didn't like running, I was rubbish at throwing, like- And I couldn't do any of the jumping.
- 9:53So, so it got to the stage where my mum actually wrote a letter to the school, and she said,"You need to give her something else to do during this time or she is going to skive off, and there is nothing I can do to stop her." She's that, that adamant about this.
- 10:10And so they just basically let me sit out, and I never had to do athletics.
- 10:14They didn't find anything else for me to do.
- 10:16They just let me sit out.
- 10:18Um, and it I think, you know, this went on until we got to our GCSEs, so I was like fif- 14, 15 at this point.
- 10:29And then I'm not sure why, but they suddenly said,"You can decide what you want to do." And they gave us an option, and a group of us had been going, had started going to Mhm.
- 10:54That doesn't sound good No, it doesn't.
- 10:56It's funny, I think I was offered a choice really late on in secondary school as well.
- 11:02They suddenly decide you're, I guess, mature enough to decide what you want to do.
- 11:06They should be offering that choice all the way through.
- 11:08And I always thought it would've been make, made it at least a bit more enjoyable.
- 11:12But then I guess if there was like one kid who wanted to do one thing and everyone else wanted to do another, then braver Yeah, so this went on until we got to about 14 or 15, and then for some reason the school suddenly s- decided they were going to allow us to choose what we were gonna do.
- 11:39This was when we were doing our GCSEs.
- 11:41And I think maybe because it wasn't an actual class anymore, so they had that flexibility.
- 11:49But so what, so at that same time, a couple of us has, had recently started going to aerobics classes up at our local swimming pool that was relatively newly opened, so it was a, a, a very exciting place to be.
- 12:04And so we said,"We'll do aerobics." And they actually set that up and organized it for us, and a group of us would go and do an aerobics class during the PE sessions.
- 12:14And that slowly got me back into ha- having some interest in, in some sort of activity.
- 12:23But I never got back into sports after, after losing, losing my interest in that first week or first few weeks at school, and it was such a shame.
- 12:37And I was, I've, I've always struggled with visualizing myself doing physical activity.
- 12:47So, like, I was the, I was the person who would stand on a wall and, like, that was just a couple of feet high and be like,"Oh, I can't jump off it." My brother used to tease, tease me a lot about that.
- 13:00But I just couldn't visualize myself jumping off.
- 13:04I couldn't see it happening.
- 13:05So it's very difficult, I think, with physical stuff, to do it if you can't see it.
- 13:10And I think, you know, that's a point that we'll probably come onto later in the episode.
- 13:14It's just so important to be able to visualize and imagine yourself doing these things in order to actually put the work in that you need to do to do them.
- 13:22So but I always used to have struggle with the idea of jumping.
- 13:26Like, so for me, something like the hurdles or the high jump was just crazy impossible for me to even imagine that I would do that.
- 13:36And I remember getting completely humiliated in, um, and humiliated is absolutely the right word, in, in one of the PE lessons where they, we were doing the high jump in, in the hall.
- 13:51And I just would run up to it and then just'Cause I just c- I couldn't imagine what I needed to do with my body to get over the pole.
- 14:00I just couldn't conceive it.
- 14:02And they basically made this massive deal about it.
- 14:06They made me do it multiple times in front of the whole class, and then they made me stay after to, to practice.
- 14:14And of course I didn't.
- 14:16I couldn't do it.
- 14:17That's awful.
- 14:18It, it was awful.
- 14:19It was horrendous.
- 14:20And I think, you know, my adult self looks back at that- Yeah situation and that's such bad teaching, such bad, you know, education.
- 14:28But it- It was so humiliating that I did actually go home and I didn't learn how to do the...
- 14:36I didn't go ho- I didn't learn how to do the, the high jump because that was too difficult.
- 14:41I couldn't practice that at home'cause I didn't have a big mattress.
- 14:44But I did spend a lot of time in the garden with my dad practicing hurdling because I was like, if I can at least do that, then I can get them off my back.
- 14:57And so yeah, so basically I just...
- 15:00And, and we had some, we had some horse jumps because family things.
- 15:07S- my mum ran a, ran h- a show jumping thing.
- 15:11But we had some show jumps.
- 15:12So we would so put m- put them up at a certain level, and then I would practice jumping over them at the low level.
- 15:19And then we just slowly got higher and higher, and that was how I, I learnt to d- to be able to do the hurdles.
- 15:25And I think I did it, like, once.
- 15:28And it was very, I was very pleased that I'd done it, but, you know, it wasn't like in a movie.
- 15:33Nobody really gave a crap about the fact that I'd done the hurdles.
- 15:37Y- you know, least of all me, really.
- 15:39And it, it, it felt like huge amount of effort to do this thing that nobody cared about because I wasn't, I wasn't good enough that I wasn't gonna compete for the school, so nobody cared about the p- the, the kids that weren't going to do that.
- 15:53So I think, you know, it was, it was the'90s, and it was all about jocks and, you know, the cool kids and the jocks and all of that was very much in the psyche at the time.
- 16:03Um, and I think the schools kind of took that on board.
- 16:08But what it then, what it did is it fundamentally took a- away any love that I had for competitive sports or for team sports or for any of those things, and just kind of throw, threw it out the window.
- 16:24So it was really sad and a, a complete failing.
- 16:28And, and I think, you know, in a lot of ways it's quite typical of, of kids, of girls who end up in that situation these days.
- 16:38You know, they find so many girls, once they hit 13, AKA high school age, there's, their, their engagement with sports drops right off Yeah.
- 16:51So interesting when you talk about humiliation as well.
- 16:54I think that is unfortunately a really common experience, particularly in PE.
- 17:00Um, especially if you're, you feel you're not very good.
- 17:04I can totally relate to the feeling emerging of not visualizing yourself being able to do something.
- 17:11I used to get really heavy feeling in my body, and I was just, I just would completely lock up.
- 17:16And of course, that exaggerated with cerebral palsy because I get very tight muscles, so I physically cannot actually move.
- 17:24And often, I had a particularly nasty year six teacher who I think felt that, like he could shout my disability away.
- 17:34So it was generally quite a traumatic experience.
- 17:37Oh my gosh.
- 17:37You know, he'd sort of say,"Well, there's no such thing as can't," you know,'cause I'd say,"I can't do it." Um, and you know, he'd make me do, try and do things.
- 17:47I tried to do hurdles.
- 17:49I'd sort of go-- They were like these weird plastic ones that were like sort of folded.
- 17:55They were like this sort of shape.
- 17:57I don't know how else to describe it.
- 17:59But basically, I'd go to the edge of one and sort of whip one of my legs around the edge to jump and use my stronger leg to go over and then do the other one around the edge, like a weird sort of puppet or something.
- 18:12But I ended up falling over naturally and scraped my knee, and it was bleeding, and I said,"Sir, I'm bleeding.
- 18:17I can't do this." And he was really quite angry and said,"Oh, for goodness sake, well then, go.
- 18:23Then you can stop then, obviously, because you're bleeding now." And I was like,"Well, if it takes me to start bleeding to stop doing something, then it's not a good sign." But he used to yell at me quite often also for, um, holding on to...
- 18:38Do you know the, like collapsible gym equipment that they used to have in primary school halls that they would like force up against the wall?
- 18:44Mm-hmm.
- 18:45And then you'd have a series of bars, and all of the kids in year six would have to stand on benches in assembly.
- 18:53This is something, again, I don't understand.
- 18:55But basically, whenever I stood on a bench, I would lose my balance and feel like I was gonna fall off.
- 19:00So I'd hold onto a bar behind me to steady myself, and he used to shout at me during assemblies and say,"Stop holding onto the bars" In front of everyone.
- 19:12Alex, that's horrendous.
- 19:14Um, so it was pretty awful.
- 19:16So I had quite a lot of bad associations- Mm you know, PE and, and physical capability in general, and I think it just made me feel like, yeah, pretty awf- pretty awful about my physical capabilities.
- 19:29Um, and it did, it was quite, quite a difficult experience when I, you know,'cause I wanted to be able to do a lot of things,'cause I loved watching sport, watching sport, and I wanted to be able to do stuff.
- 19:44But it made me feel like it was my fault that I wasn't good enough or not capable enough and, you know, it was pretty difficult.
- 19:52We're getting into deep therapeutic therapy, therapeutic territory here.
- 19:58But yeah, we're-- It's interesting, and I will talk about obviously how my relationship to physical activity has changed since, but there was also that association with physio as well.
- 20:09But I don't think that primary school teacher helped it in any way whatsoever.
- 20:14He, he was generally pretty horrible to a lot of us as children.
- 20:17But yeah, his approach was not the way.
- 20:22Definitely not.
- 20:23So this further, like, it, it has exponentially consolidated my opinion that the education system is utterly unfit for the purpose of educating someone as to how the world works and how to make your way in it.
- 20:42Because none of those, those awful experiences that were inflicted upon you have, have any, like, basis in, in, like, studied-- How education should be the result of endless studies on the best ways to educate people and go from, go from that and- The, the...
- 21:17And there's the classic phrase of those who can't do, teach, and those who can't teach, teach PE.
- 21:25That's the classic.
- 21:26So, uh, so, and a- and again, teachers are terribly trained and terribly treated today.
- 21:36And so the job of being a teacher, it doesn't get the respect it deserves, but it also doesn't get the training that it needs to get to be the kind of people that, that, that does that.
- 21:50'Cause it's not, it can't just be any other job.
- 21:52You are, you are, you are forming people's perception of the world.
- 21:59And when, when you are treated as appallingly as that year six teacher treated you, that is just And s- I can, I, I can't speak from, like, your, s- seeing it from your, s- your, the, that particular relation you had there.
- 22:21But the, like, equivalent, that, that experience of being attacked by an adult who has power over you- Mm is one of the, the, the most devastating things that can happen for children,'cause it's going, the, this is, this is how the world works.
- 22:43And what children are trying to do is trying to work out how the world works.
- 22:46Yeah.
- 22:46And the only way that they can, they can come to those conclusions is the way that they are treated and the ways that they see people being treated.
- 22:54Yeah.
- 22:55And when that isn't, when the child doesn't get what they need from other people to help them understand the world, then the child's, the, is naturally gonna go,"There must be just, there must just be something wrong with me then.
- 23:13He must be shouting at me'cause-" Yeah.
- 23:14Essentially- Yeah it taught me to mask my disability as much as possible or I'd be told off.
- 23:21That was the lesson I took from that time.
- 23:23Taken a long time to unlearn that, and that's one of the first important lessons I learned from my very first sessions of therapy that I had, you know, back in 2020.
- 23:34And it was a real light bulb moment to suddenly realize, actually, this, this is where it stemmed from.
- 23:39This is why I felt like this a long time.
- 23:43But can really have a really formative impact on you.
- 23:47And I think, you know, at the end of the day, sport should be fun, shouldn't it?
- 23:54And if you don't have, if you can't buy body brace of- You know, here you are, be in that position where you can find a sport that you can do for fun without any barriers in your way, whether they be other people or, or, you know, other things like that.
- 24:17I've forgotten the thread of my point, but yeah, I think there's a lot of barriers in the, in between women and the purpose of, of, of sport for the, for the, for the masses, which is to have fun, I think.
- 24:32And it start, it starts off again the, the...
- 24:36If you, if you try, like, like with, with you Jem and your, after you, you, you seem to, if you, if you don't understand why someone, if someone doesn't explain to you exactly why you should be doing something and you don't think you should be doing it, you go,"Then why, why, why should I do it?
- 24:54What, you're telling me, you're not, you're telling me to run around.
- 24:58I'm at school.
- 24:59You're telling me I'm learning, I've got English before this and biology after this.
- 25:05I have no interest in," maybe, I don't know if you have interest in either of those things.
- 25:08Maybe you don't care about either of those things.
- 25:09"And you're gonna make me run around for an hour." And they go,"Why am I doing this?
- 25:14Explain to me why I'm doing it, and if it's a good explanation, then I'll do it.
- 25:19And even if it is a good explanation, I might choose I don't want to do it, whatever." Then- It's a really good point actually, Matt, becau- And, and I know that when I was at school, one of the things that I was really frustrated by, and I remember talking to people about it all the time then and, and not long after, was that p- physical education should have been exactly that.
- 25:39It should have been educating you about how to stay fit.
- 25:43It should have been educating you about all the things that are important and why it matters to do exercise, why team sports are beneficial, which they are.
- 25:54Why, you know, what, what foods we should be eating, why it matters whether we have chips and pizza at lunchtime, you know, which is what they were serving in the canteen at the time.
- 26:03Now, I, they have come a long way, but they're still treating PE in schools, in, in my experience with my daughter, they're still treating PE in much the same way as it, as it always has been.
- 26:15That it's just an opportunity to get the kids out and run around, and ideally to find some that are good enough that you can use them to compete with the other schools in the area.
- 26:25Um, and so yeah, y- for me, definitely I needed to understand why it mattered in order to put the effort that was needed in The goal of any kind of, like, adult who could-- adult, adult who has chosen to be in a role of responsibility over children needs-- it needs to be finding what that child will-- might enjoy doing and to give them that opportunity to do it.
- 27:00'Cause children don't, especially the younger they are, they don't, they don't understand the world, and plenty of people into their adulthood don't fully understand the world because it is being warped by patriarchy and capitalism.
- 27:15That is the thing-- that's the, the thing that benefits from education not working is so that you don't understand why the world is the way it is And to be able to go to a child with cerebral palsy and go,"Th- this is understanding." A teacher to go,"Right, understand I've got a child with cerebral palsy in my class.
- 27:42I have done research in cerebral palsy.
- 27:44I've got a good idea of where to start, and I will make sure that I communicate with them well." And then you force them to stand on a bench and say,"Don't hold onto that." And, and that, that is, that is just appalling.
- 28:02And it's funny that you bring up the, the wooden shit on the walls.
- 28:08Yeah.
- 28:09Yeah.
- 28:09Just going into any- It's awful any, any gym, any secondary school sports hall, and you see these things that look like they're from the 1800s are just...
- 28:22My entire, like, young life up until very recently as I'm, as I'm trying to...
- 28:30The, the point of childhood is that you sh- it should prepare you for life so that then when you get to the world, you're ready to go.
- 28:39You go,"Right, I understand the world.
- 28:40I understand where I am.
- 28:41I have an idea of where I want to go, and I've got the tools to go and do it." When it...
- 28:50Oh, shit, I've forgotten the first half of going, of, of it.
- 28:54When, when, uh, the entire, the entire journey up to that point is going,"I don't understand this.
- 29:02I don't understand this.
- 29:03I don't understand this.
- 29:04No one's explaining this." And so when you get to real life, it, the, that not understanding just is bewildering and holds you back even further.
- 29:20This, so we're coming to the end of our half hour, and we've only done the first question.
- 29:27So what I think we'll do is we'll, we'll stop here, and then we'll do our second episode on the- Mm-hmm say, the infrastructural barriers and institutional barriers.
- 29:39'Cause the, the first thing that f- fascinated me about, so I'm, I'm glad that I, I'm, I'm chairing this and just ask the question and let you go, is'cause I assumed that your, your experiences of shaping it would be from how you felt about yourself And so, like, we'll come onto this in a later episode.
- 30:05But immediately your key things were adults did this.
- 30:09It was adults that...
- 30:11It was teachers that shattered your experience of sport when I w- I would've assumed that it would be you going,"Oh, maybe th- I'm not necessarily wanting to do this anymore for a number of reasons." But that's just really interesting.
- 30:31And that, that, that shattering of your ability to have a relationship with something is one of the, the most damaging things that can happen for children'cause it, it, it shapes their adult life to the extent that most people don't even realize it.
- 30:51So, like, it takes until going to therapy for the first time for you to go,"Oh, yeah, that, that...
- 30:58I feel like that now because this happened then.
- 31:01And then as a child I thought that happened because there was something wrong with me, but it was actually that there was an adult who, who treated me terribly and it had nothing to do with me." And just, yeah, we've still got a lot of work to do and hopefully...
- 31:18I don't know what the answers are, but maybe we'll, maybe we'll, maybe we'll have some hopeful things to say in the next, in the next episode.
- 31:25But thank you both for sharing that.
- 31:27That was...
- 31:28It's an intense topic and I think we, we do a good job of, of digging into them and having conversations that, that matter and that, that are important to have.
- 31:41Everyone, thank you for watching or listening.
- 31:44We have been...
- 31:45We do have fun as well.
- 31:46We've been having a tremendous amount of fun doing some streaming on our Twitch channel, which is just Gaming the System Podcast, and we upload those videos to our YouTube channel as well, and I've been putting together a few cheeky highlight reels.
- 32:01So if you want to have a palate cleanser after some of our more intense episodes, just head there and have some fun with us.
- 32:08So until next time, bye-bye.
- 32:12Bye.
- 32:12Bye.