Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #67🎙️ |Public Inquiry Road Abandonment Week Beginning 26th May 2026 Day 2 morning |
Transcript
- 0:00Today's discussion was predominantly about the
- 0:02abandonment of the old road and the design of the potential new
- 0:06haul road, which will be masquerading as an alternative
- 0:10via pretensis for the old abandoned road. Now it is meant
- 0:15to be an alternative road, but to all intents and purposes it's
- 0:18a hall road straight into the mining compound, we were hastily
- 0:22assured by the dormant part of the Hoy Dorman Company. You
- 0:26remember the folk that had come up with this tragic design of a
- 0:29substandard road that site traffic will not use the hall
- 0:33road. No mention at all of other traffic that will be coming and
- 0:37going every day from the mine. This will be the road that all
- 0:43staff use, coming and going to the mine. Imagine this: there's
- 0:47a change of shift, workers each driving their own car, say just
- 0:5150 cars going in and 50 cars going out on a single track
- 0:55road, and then a tractor comes along, the whole thing will be
- 0:59blocked from end to end. The question is, in a scenario such
- 1:03as this, how long will local vehicles have to wait to travel
- 1:08from east to west or north to south, bearing in mind this will
- 1:12happen twice a day, 365 days a year. Or imagine this: 44,000
- 1:19tonnes of explosives will be delivered over the course of the
- 1:22lifetime of the mine. These deliveries will have to be on a
- 1:27very regular basis, because of the stringent laws associated
- 1:32with explosive storage, which do not allow huge amounts of
- 1:35explosives to be stored. And imagine how easy it would be to
- 1:40block off each end of the road, essentially trapping a lorry
- 1:44carrying explosives. What an invitation to those who would
- 1:47like to use explosives for nefarious purposes, and I don't
- 1:52mean Halloween. The traffic lights at each end would have to
- 1:57be permanently on green to allow the free movement of these
- 2:00explosive trucks, and then the road from north to south would
- 2:04be blocked, as this scenario is played out every couple of days,
- 2:08creating yet more inconvenience and annoyance for the locals.
- 2:14Cormac McAleer spoke movingly about the comparison between the
- 2:17two roads, the one to be abandoned and the new one, the
- 2:22old road bounded by heather, alder, and willow, the song of
- 2:26the cuckoo, the sighting of the hare, framed by the softness of
- 2:31the surrounding tree, and the light of ages, the new road,
- 2:36regulated by traffic lights, security fencing, constant
- 2:39noise, and dust from the mine, and probably lit up at night. He
- 2:45referred to Dal Radian's fondness for continually using
- 2:48bespoke models, this time in the road design. He pointed out that
- 2:53yet again information was incomplete on every level, and
- 2:57especially on assessment safety. He referred to the cutting of
- 3:01corners and to the certain knowledge that all of this will
- 3:04be waived through by relevant departments, this time DFI
- 3:09Roads. He pointed out once more that the road designs company
- 3:14Hoy Dorman is engaged on behalf of the applicant and is funded
- 3:18by the applicant and is not an independent assessor. He went on
- 3:22to say that the public inquiry, Rhodes inquiry, is unfit for
- 3:26purpose, and if it wasn't within the confines of the inquiry, it
- 3:31would be considered a joke. He spoke the truth that the
- 3:35community was wholesale being abandoned to a sacrifice zone,
- 3:39and declared, "We, the people are not going to be a sacrifice
- 3:42zone for the sake of this company. He pointed out that the
- 3:47departments who are supposed to be taking care of the health and
- 3:50safety of the public are the very same ones who are
- 3:54undermining the process, and that this was the tragedy of the
- 3:58elephant in the room at this point. His frustration with the
- 4:02process and the mythology that DFI roads are using to avoid
- 4:06some of the most basic safety concerns associated with the new
- 4:10road literally boiled over, and he was asked to leave the room
- 4:14or sit down and be quiet, but Cormac had removed himself
- 4:17before the Riot Act was read out by the commissioners, Alvin
- 4:21Council for DFI refuted Cormac's statement, saying BMRB standards
- 4:25for road safety were not applied strictly because of the nature
- 4:29of the road, and reassuringly added that the road would have
- 4:32to get through all sorts of road safety audits before the DFI
- 4:36would adopt it. I was able to ask at this stage, what happens
- 4:40if it does not pass all the DFI safety audits? Thinking to
- 4:44myself, well, then it would be left to the company to maintain
- 4:47the road and keep it up to a standard, and one can see where
- 4:51this is going now. It's a private road, and there's no
- 4:54public access, as well as been miserably below spec, Beattie
- 4:59County. Are that is council for Dalradion that east to west is a
- 5:05public road, which will be adopted, and north to south is a
- 5:10private road owned by the company. The conversation turned
- 5:15to the Mass Rock, and Beatty intimated that the Mass Rock has
- 5:20only recently presented self as a problem for Dalradion. Could
- 5:24it be perhaps seeking again to actively underline the validity
- 5:28of the concerns of the people in relation to access to mass rock?
- 5:33Nah, couldn't be. It was only a few days previously with a
- 5:37senior member of the Greencastle Parish fondly recalling how she
- 5:41remembers her uncle bringing her to the Mass Rock over 60 years
- 5:44ago, it occurred to me listening to the Del Radian Council, he
- 5:49sought to cast doubt on this very real lived experience.
- 5:55Nevertheless, he was at pains to indicate another route to get to
- 5:58the Mass Rock at the back of the GPO site, up a hill, over hedges
- 6:03and ditches and barbed wire fences. Fedelma O'Kane explained
- 6:07to us she had explored this alternative route over the
- 6:10weekend. She said anyone would find it difficult to travel this
- 6:14way to the Mass Rock, never mind a woman of her age. She said
- 6:18this was not a mitigation for access to the Mass Rock, and
- 6:22Connor Fagan counsel for FODC to the commissioner said to think
- 6:26very carefully about the recommendations of access to
- 6:29mass rock as a mitigation, as it wouldn't be good to rely on a
- 6:33promise from a private company not necessarily backed up.
- 6:37Ferdinand went on to say that the proposed abandonment of the
- 6:41old road is not just a planning issue, it raises serious human
- 6:45rights concerns around access, religion, property, safety, and
- 6:49community life. In rural areas, these roads are often the only
- 6:54access to historic fate sites, turf cutting rights, farmland,
- 6:59and community facilities. Simply telling people to cross fields
- 7:03is neither practical nor rights compliant, particularly for
- 7:07elderly or disabled residents. The DFI transport must prove the
- 7:13road is genuinely unnecessary, and that any alternative access
- 7:17fully protects the rights of local people, not just the
- 7:20interests of the developer under article 68 a road simply cannot
- 7:27be abandoned because a developer owns the land around it the
- 7:31department must prove the road is no longer necessary or that
- 7:35proper alternative access exists and that includes for walkers
- 7:40pilgrims landowners and local communities, not just vehicles.
- 7:46Mary Brawley followed with, "I submit that this road is too
- 7:49narrow and this will carry real-world consequences. That
- 7:54the DFI has insufficiently engaged with other users,
- 7:57farmers, rivers, agencies, sports clubs, walkers, that
- 8:03there has been an underestimation of road safety,
- 8:06that the replacement route does not meet technical standards,
- 8:11that there is a lack of socioeconomic analysis, a lack
- 8:15of appreciation of farm operations, land severance,
- 8:20property access, an over reliance on external advice from
- 8:24applicants, and that the conclusion is predetermined,
- 8:28that the cumulative rural impacts are not genuinely
- 8:32assessed. All of this brought us up to lunch time, and at this
- 8:37point I'm going to leave it here. After lunch was all about
- 8:41planning conditions, and I will put that in the podcast tomorrow
- 8:45evening, as I feel I will go way beyond 10 minutes if I keep
- 8:48going. By the bye, quoting the day had to come from Pat Haughey
- 8:54when he announced to the commissioner, "I'll finish up
- 8:57there now, as I can see you're looking bored. To be fair to
- 9:01Pat, it was the shortest and most popular statement he made
- 9:05all morning. I'll be back tomorrow with the conditions.
- 9:08See you then. And, as usual, a reminder: if you're listening on
- 9:12Spotify or Apple, help us get these voices out by following
- 9:16the podcast or hit the star buttons and review us. It really
- 9:20helps the algorithm.