Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #No. 2 Save Our Sperrins Podcast Special: What Happened at the Public Inquiry January 2025
Transcript
- 0:10Hello there, and welcome to the latest episode of the Sperrins
- 0:14podcast. I'm Marella fyffe, your host, part of the Save Our
- 0:19Sperrins campaign team, and we're just a group
- 0:22of ordinary folk doing what we can to protect this beautiful
- 0:28place we call home from gold mining. In this podcast, I'll be
- 0:33sharing what's really going on, hearing from people on the
- 0:38ground, and keeping the story alive because it matters. Thanks
- 0:43very much for joining me. Save our Sperrins podcast special:
- 0:48What happened at the public inquiry? An overview of how it
- 0:53started, how it unfolded, and how it all came undone. Welcome
- 0:58to this special episode of the Sperrins podcast. I had
- 1:03intended to bring you daily updates from the public inquiry,
- 1:08but things didn't go quite to plan. As many of you now know,
- 1:13the inquiry collapsed only a few days after it began. Since then,
- 1:19I've had time to reflect, gather notes, speak with others who
- 1:24were there. This episode is my way of capturing what happened,
- 1:29start to finish. So that's on record, and we don't forget.
- 1:34This is a story of a process that was supposed to uphold
- 1:39democracy and accountability, but instead explores deep flaws
- 1:44in how our planning system works. Day one, what was
- 1:49supposed to be a public inquiry from the beginning, things felt
- 1:54off. Day one of the inquiry took place in the Strule Arts Centre
- 1:59in Omagh . It was supposed to be a public inquiry, yet there were
- 2:05significant limitations on access and technology. Members
- 2:10of the public, campaigners, and even some press struggled to get
- 2:15inside. The day's biggest takeaway was the dysfunction of
- 2:20government departments. The Department for the Economy
- 2:25didn't even bother sending a representative, though at least
- 2:30one employee was sitting in the audience and said nothing when
- 2:35questioned by the commissioner. The Department for
- 2:39Infrastructure (DFI) fared no better. Their response to basic
- 2:45procedural questions showed a lack of preparation, urgency, or
- 2:50understanding. Important concerns were raised by
- 2:54Fermanagnoma District Council's legal team, Save Our Sperrins
- 2:59and local residents. Some points: There was no updated
- 3:04economic feasibility study since the supposed removal of cyanide
- 3:09from the application. The Derry City and Strabane District
- 3:14Council judicial review had not been Adequately addressed, the
- 3:20precautionary principle and cumulative impact of mineral
- 3:24exploration had been overlooked. Dalradian had worked on an
- 3:29unauthorised site, breaching planning permissions. People
- 3:34came expecting answers. Instead, we got obfuscation. Day two, the
- 3:40day it unravelled. Day two should have been about expert
- 3:45testimony and public engagement. Instead, it turned into a legal
- 3:50and procedural quagmire, Doctor. Amy Strecker spoke on behalf of
- 3:55Save Our Sperrins about the project's failings under human
- 4:00rights law and the Arhouse Convention. Her testimony was
- 4:05powerful, raising issues of transparency, justice, and the
- 4:10public's right to be heard. Support also came from across
- 4:15the border. Residents of Donegal travelled to speak about
- 4:20transboundary impacts. This, it turned out, was the fatal thread
- 4:25that would unravel the whole process. The DFI admitted to
- 4:30technical breaches in their legal duty to consult properly
- 4:35with Donegal County Council, they had posted documents
- 4:40online, but made them hard to find and failed to provide clear
- 4:45planning references. The consultation process was deeply
- 4:50flawed. The commission. Press DFI's barrister. Did these
- 4:55failures represent an impediment to the inquiry continuing? The
- 5:00answer: It depends. The department hadn't even decided
- 5:05what to do yet. That indecision and the legal implications of
- 5:10their failure to consult properly across the border sent
- 5:15the entire process into limbo. Meanwhile, Dalreadian made some
- 5:20truly jaw-dropping claims that gold is fundamentally a benign
- 5:25product, that mining and quarrying are essentially the
- 5:30same thing, and perhaps most damning of all, their agent
- 5:34said, "If mining and quarrying were subject to this policy, it
- 5:40would never be permitted. That one statement said everything.
- 5:45Day three collapse. By Wednesday morning, it was over. The
- 5:50commissioner asked for clarity, the departments couldn't provide
- 5:55it. The legal basis of the inquiry had been undermined by
- 6:00procedural failings so severe that continuing would have
- 6:05rendered the process illegitimate. What was supposed
- 6:09to be a three-month democratic forum collapsed under the weight
- 6:15of its own mishandling, government departments out of
- 6:19their depth, legal processes not followed, and a planning system
- 6:25ill-equipped to deal with public scrutiny. What does it all mean?
- 6:30The collapse of the public inquiry isn't just a technical
- 6:35issue; it's a damning indictment of how decisions are made in
- 6:40this country. If the departments responsible for managing a major
- 6:46infrastructure and environmental case can't follow their own
- 6:51legal duties, how can we trust them to protect our land, water,
- 6:56and communities?
- 6:58It also shows just how powerful community voices can be. Save
- 7:03our Sperrins , local residents, cross-border allies, and legal
- 7:07teams were ready, informed, and compelling. That pressure
- 7:12worked. The cracks were already there, but our collective
- 7:17scrutiny brought them to the surface. What happens now? The
- 7:21future is uncertain, but here's what we do know: this
- 7:25application cannot be rubber stamped. The legal failings are
- 7:30now on record. Communities have shown they are not passive.
- 7:35We're watching and we're organised. Any future attempts
- 7:39to revive or repackage this project will be met with the
- 7:44same scrutiny and resistance. Final thoughts: This podcast
- 7:48episode is a record of what happened. For those who couldn't
- 7:53be there, for future campaigners, and for anyone who
- 7:57wants to understand how power operates behind closed doors,
- 8:02this is for you. We may not have had the full inquiry, but we do
- 8:07have each other, and we have the truth. Thank you for listening.
- 8:12Please share this episode, talk about it, and stay connected.
- 8:17We'll see you again soon.