Latest / CreepsMcPasta Creepypasta Radio / "We always burn liars here" Creepypasta
Transcript
- 0:01Jackie was a werewolf, Pete was a vampire, though he kept referring to
- 0:07himself as a dracula just to annoy me, and I was a witch.
- 0:12Ooh. Admittedly, the outfit was just a half assed modification from my initial
- 0:17idea of girl Gandalf after my older brother Kevin set fire to my beard the
- 0:22week before. We were too old for drucker treating, and we knew it,
- 0:29but that was part of the point. After a five year hiatus on
- 0:34free candy because Halloween was for babies, we'd come back around to the idea
- 0:40that so long as we leaned into it being a prank slash game slash social
- 0:44experiment instead of just teenagers begging for candy, that we could just drive to
- 0:49the store and buy it was cool again. The idea was this, we
- 0:56would drive up to every house, not hiding the fact that we were enough
- 1:00to do so. Beat and I were seniors and Jackie was home from a
- 1:04first year of college, and between his beard hurt it to my height,
- 1:10no one was mistaking any of us for children. That being said, we
- 1:15had a rule that we had to dress up in legit costumes and couldn't act
- 1:19weird or ass wholey when we went up together candy just polite trigger treating as
- 1:26to do anything else would affect the bet. Because this is where the game
- 1:32park came in. Before we got out of the car, at each house,
- 1:38we would each bet whether that house would give us candy or not.
- 1:42The odds were always in favor of yes. Most people might get irritated had
- 1:47all the teenagers coming for candy, but so long as we were polite about
- 1:52it, it was hard for them to get past their default position of honoring
- 1:56hallowing customs. So the scoore work like this. If you bet a house
- 2:02would give us candy, you got one point. If you bet that a
- 2:07house wouldn't give candy and you were wrong, you lost one point. But
- 2:12if you bet a house wouldn't give us candy and you were right, that
- 2:16was worth five points. So long as he didn't do anything overtly rude or
- 2:22whatever. To make sure things went your way. Sarcastic tone of voice was
- 2:28okay, so were fake accents. But you couldn't say or do anything that
- 2:34was really impolite or highlighted our age beyond our obvious appearance and ability to drive
- 2:38up in the first place. No thanks, dude got to get back to
- 2:44the wife and kids now, or any kind of thing. In other words,
- 2:49reasonable lying was fine so long as it was done courteously. When we
- 2:54were done for the night, whoever had the most points got to divide up
- 2:59all the candy, and best of all, they got to pick the first
- 3:02three things. The other two eight didn't matter how gross or sketchy. They
- 3:07had to eat it. If someone gave it to one of us during the
- 3:10night had to have high stakes after all. So far, Pete was somehow
- 3:17ahead. He was a good guesser he always had been, and it was
- 3:23irritating. I was only two points behind, but it felt like we were
- 3:29running out of houses as we moved further and further out into the dark countryside.
- 3:36That had been part of our plan go out to places that had lights
- 3:39on but were more remote, as they were less likely to have many Trugger
- 3:45treaters. They'd also be less likely to have candy at all. But most
- 3:51of the houses with decorations and lights on gave up something, even if it
- 3:54was from their own private stash. Jackie was one point behind me, though
- 4:01I still thought her strategy for the evening was done. She was voting no
- 4:06candy on every house based on the idea that five points when she was right
- 4:12would override the one point losses. The rest of the time. I tried
- 4:15to point out that we were only stopping at a house that looked like decent
- 4:19candidates to begin with, and that always voting the same wasn't really playing the
- 4:25game. But she wouldn't budge. And I hate to admit it, but
- 4:31her strategy hadn't totally sucked so far, and one no candy house would put
- 4:38her back in the lead. That's why I complained. When she started turning
- 4:42onto the driveway at the end of CR thirteen, she giggled as she completed
- 4:47the turn and gave me a grin. Her fur covered face green and sinister
- 4:53in the meager light of the dashboard, it has jack a lantern's out the
- 4:58fence gate with candles in them. That counts as decorations in light. Pete
- 5:04gave a groan, Damn, Whinnie, she's right. Jackie had started down
- 5:12the driveway that was paved, but with thick hardwoods on both sides that obscured
- 5:16the way forward as the path curved to the right. Irritated, I shook
- 5:21my head it's supposed to be decorations in the house, not a mile away
- 5:27at the road. This doesn't count, Jackie shrugged. Well, we'll see
- 5:32then. If the house is dark or has no decorations, then we'll turn
- 5:36around and leave. I'm not trying to cheat, but I'm not turning down
- 5:41a good prospect either. Sighing, I slumped back in my seat. Fine,
- 5:47but I wouldn't be surprised if there's not even a house back. Oh
- 5:51my god, that last comment had been from Pete, and I didn't have
- 5:57to ask what he meant. We just rounded the last corner, and instead
- 6:02of more woods were just an empty, overgrown field. There was a large
- 6:08ante Bellum mansion with brick walls of dark gray and tall white columns that line
- 6:13the front like long teeth. We saw most of this from the sweeping light
- 6:18of Jackie's head lights, but they weren't the only things lighting up the night.
- 6:24Behind the hulking shadow of the house, I could make out the shifting
- 6:29orange glow of a fire, and up on the porch there were four more
- 6:33jack O lanterns to match the ones out on the road. Jackie turned and
- 6:40gave me a satisfied smile. As she pointed first to the glow of the
- 6:44firelight behind the house light, and then the pumpkins and the porch and decorations.
- 6:53I sniffed, I mean, technically, yeah, but does this place
- 6:58look like somewhere we want stuff from. It's dark and creepy. They probably
- 7:01have a bucket of razor blade candy in there. Pete laughed. It's Halloween.
- 7:09This is the kind of house we should be visiting, and it isn't
- 7:12the razor blade thing more of an urban legend. Jackie shook her head.
- 7:17No, that happened to my cousin once. But it's okay because I confidently
- 7:23bet we will get no candy here. I rolled my eyes. What a
- 7:29shocker, What old strategy there? She squinted at me. If you're scared,
- 7:34just say you're scared. I floated my middle finger around in front of
- 7:40her as I did a wave in ghost voice. Screw you, just don't
- 7:46come crying to me when I give you a poison candy bar covered in rat
- 7:49turts to eat. Snorting, Jackie turned off the car and got out.
- 7:56Come on, sure, losers, it's Jackie's tying to shine. I bet
- 8:01no candy too. I couldn't see her face as we approached the house,
- 8:07but I could still hear Jackie's smirking decided to back a winner. Huh,
- 8:13smart play. Won't help you in the end, but I respect you for
- 8:16acknowledging my awesomeness. Ah whatever, Pete, what's your bet? Mm?
- 8:24Candy? These people have to be loaded, right if there? Even the
- 8:30porch light came on as we started up the steps home, and then,
- 8:35under my breath, damn, Pete was already on the porch, grinning back
- 8:43down at us, always bet on the dracula turning, he walked over and
- 8:48rang on the ornate doorbell next to the equally intrigly carved black door. Far
- 8:54away. We heard a small bell chime. This was a weird house.
- 9:03Everything about this felt weird. Why couldn't they see that? I was about
- 9:07to suggest we just give up the game and declare Pete the winner. When
- 9:13the door's locked clicked and it swung open. On the other side, a
- 9:20dead woman stood smiling at us. Pete must have been right. Whoever these
- 9:26people were, they had to be kinder loaded because her costume was movie quality,
- 9:33not because it was over the top or really elaborate, but because it
- 9:37was so subtle. The blue dress she wore was faded and curled at the
- 9:43edges with what could have been age or rot, and her skin had a
- 9:48faint blue tinge that stood out in the porches overhead light, but wasn't cartoonish
- 9:52or overdone. The only other sign that she wasn't just an attractive middle aged
- 9:58socermon was he left ear. Her long, dull brown hair was artfully pulled
- 10:05over her ear on that side, revealing a gnawed stop instead of whole flesh.
- 10:11Damn, you look awesome. Pete was right, though it was hard
- 10:18to tell from his lingering gaze on her breast if he was talking more about
- 10:22a zombie outfit or her generally being kind of heart. Jackie apparently thought it
- 10:28was the latter, as she nudged him in the ribs and stepped forward,
- 10:31holding out her open briefcase shrik or treat Oh. I stifled a sudden nervous
- 10:41laugh the briefcase thing. Jackie had brought a briefcase instead of a normal trick
- 10:48or treat bag. At first, Pete and I hadn't understood why, but
- 10:52once I saw how she was betting against candy every time, it made more
- 10:58sense, she thought using something that wasn't halloweeny or immature would tilt the scales
- 11:03towards annoying someone, so they wouldn't give us anything. I couldn't say for
- 11:09sure if it had worked. But at the two houses that had told us
- 11:13we were too old, they both looked at that damn thing. Still,
- 11:18it didn't seem to matter as to this lady. She just gave a soft
- 11:22laugh as she looked at each of us in turn. Well, well,
- 11:26I appreciate the compliment, and I accept the commencement of bargaining as well.
- 11:33Still chuckling, she took a step back. I have all manner of treat
- 11:39in the kitchen, and will brook no tricks on this holy night. All
- 11:43I ask is that you tell me what you are before you pass my door.
- 11:48Suggested back down the hallway to a kitchen and was dancing with yellow candlelight.
- 11:56I shot Pete concerned. Look, ma'am, we don't normally go into
- 12:01people's houses. She nodded. I understand, but I just finished cooking,
- 12:07and I'm afraid I have too large a variety to bring out here. Shrugging,
- 12:13she started to close the door. But if you refuse the offered treats.
- 12:18We can close the back. Pete stepped forward. No, no,
- 12:22ma'am, we're happy to come in, he glared at me. Forgive my
- 12:26friend, she's just the sore loser. The woman smiled wildly at him as
- 12:31she moved the hair behind the other perfect ear so glad to hear it,
- 12:39her face suddenly became more serious. Now, what are you? Pete hesitated
- 12:48a moment, and then bared his plastic fangs. To be fair, they
- 12:52were expensive and looked good other than being a different shade than his actual teeth.
- 13:00Madame, I'm a dracula. I expected the woman to laugh or look
- 13:05angry, but instead she just nodded, very well, you may enter our
- 13:13home. Pete stepped in as she turned to look at Jackie, and what
- 13:18are you? Jackie had lowered a briefcase again, and even through the tufts
- 13:24of fake brown hair glued to her cheeks and forehead, I could tell she
- 13:30was worried too. Still, she wouldn't quit playing so long as one of
- 13:35us kept going either, so, giving another small howl, she stepped closer
- 13:39to the door. I'm awarewolf, ma'am, Very well, you may enter
- 13:46our home. The woman looked at me and you. I started to speak,
- 13:56but something held me back. This woman wasn't right. I couldn't say
- 14:03what the problem was with her, and I didn't know enough to make the
- 14:07others leave. But there was a weight to everything the woman was saying and
- 14:11doing, as though this wasn't some kind of campy Halloween role play but part
- 14:16of something real and serious. And she was still staring expectantly at me,
- 14:24heart hammering, I stepped forward. I am I'm a girl dressed up as
- 14:30a witch. I was supposed to be female Gandalf, but my jerk brother
- 14:33burnt my beard. The woman stooded me for several moments before smiling again,
- 14:41Very well, you may enter our home. Closing the door behind me,
- 14:48the woman led us back to the kitchen. It was massive, eight burners
- 14:52set into a large wooden island, and a long table along one end,
- 14:58filled with a variety of cooking and candies and muffins and cakes, along with
- 15:03candied apples and punkin tarts and other dishes that I didn't recognize. Holy crap,
- 15:09I mean, dang, you've got quite the spread in here. The
- 15:15woman chuckled. Thank you. We don't get many visitors out here, and
- 15:20my boys a finigy diet, so I always wind up overdoing it. But
- 15:24it is Halloween, after all. Please take what you'd like. I felt
- 15:31a stab of panic and leaned into Jack's ear. None of this stuff is
- 15:35wrapped up, you good of anything in it? You can't eat this stuff?
- 15:41Calling back, she gave me a frown. How's that different to anything
- 15:46else? You think someone can't rewrap candy or incheck something through a wrapper?
- 15:50And how often do you get to try fancy stuff like this? Pete leaned
- 15:56into the conversation. I don't think I didn't notice your whole I'm a girl
- 16:00dressed like a witch. Thing you've lost? Give it up, don't mess
- 16:04up the best meal I've had in like ever. He grinned at our host,
- 16:11So like, how much is okay for us to take? It?
- 16:14All looks so good? She beamed at him. As much as you want,
- 16:19of course, there are plates and balls at the end, so feel
- 16:22feared to sample here, and I can make you bags to take with you
- 16:26as well. As I said, I have far too much. The woman
- 16:33frowned as Pete reached towards some kind of potato fritter piled on a platter near
- 16:37the table's edge. Oh no, that's not for you, though, Pete
- 16:42pulled his hand back and looked at her questioningly. Oh sorry, she waved
- 16:48her hand. Not at all. It's just that I prepared those with garlic,
- 16:55and I wouldn't want you to get sick. Pete's dead at her blankly
- 17:00for a moment, and then let out a loud laugh. Oh right,
- 17:04yeah, I guess I should have a selective diet. He picked up a
- 17:10small crystal glass containing what looked like dark layers topped with whipped cream. Is
- 17:15this okay for me, you think? The woman nodded. Yes, of
- 17:21course, blood moose with a bit of caramelized baby fat for texture. She
- 17:26picked one up and handed it to Jackie. This should be good for you
- 17:30as well. Glancing between us, Jackie picked up a spoon. Sure,
- 17:37thanks, it looks delicious. The woman turned and patted my arm. All
- 17:45the food on the left side of the table is meat free, my dear,
- 17:49I gave a slow nod. Well, I mean, I'm not a
- 17:53vegetarian, but the cookies and muffins look great, I pointed toward Pete as
- 18:00he was eating the first bite of his moose. But those don't really have
- 18:03some kind of meat in beat spat a dark wad under the floor as he
- 18:10began to wretch, Lady, what the hell is in that? When he
- 18:15looked up, he didn't look at her but me, his eyes watery and
- 18:19fearful. She frowned, just as I've said, congealed blood quite the favorite
- 18:27of your kind. He was hardly listening, hocking and spitting as he tried
- 18:34to get the taste out of his mouth, without trusting any of the various
- 18:38drinks on offer as a way to clean his palate. On his fourth spit,
- 18:44one of his fangs flew out and landed in the middle of a plate
- 18:48filled with bat sugar cookies. What is that? The woman's tone was icy,
- 18:56Look at me, show me your mouth. Pete stared at her slight
- 19:00George, his lone fangs still dangling there. What the hell are you talking
- 19:07about? The woman's expression darkened as she turned to Jackie, who would set
- 19:12her own moose back down. And what about you? The treat not to
- 19:17your liking, ma'am, This isn't funny. We're just going to go out.
- 19:22Let go our host that grabbed Jackie's arm, gripping it hard as she
- 19:29pulled her closer. You answer me, now, are you truly aware?
- 19:33Wolf? Stepping forward? I tried to shove her away from Jackie, but
- 19:40she didn't budge or even look my way as she held my friend tight.
- 19:45Jackie was crying a little now as she shook her head. Of course not,
- 19:51it's a costume. It's not even a good one. And were wolves
- 19:53aren't real, you crazy woman, Let me go. The woman did as
- 20:00she was asked, after a fashion, slinging Jackie in Pete's direction and sending
- 20:04them both careening into the nearby wall before tumbling to the floor. I moved
- 20:11to help them, but then the woman was in my path. And you
- 20:15are you a girl dressed as a witch? I could barely breathe as I
- 20:21squeaked my words out. Why why are you doing this? And to me?
- 20:27Now? Yes, yes, I'm just the girl dressed as a witch,
- 20:33She nodded, giving me a satisfied smile. Very well, you have
- 20:38maintained the covenant that your companions have broken. You may pick any treats you
- 20:44like from the banquet table. We just don't want to go. Go.
- 20:51They can't go. They've broken covenant and on a holy night, no less,
- 20:56there would be no falsehoods in this house or in my family's bargaining.
- 21:02Her eyes went to jack in Pete even as shadowy figures began to approach between
- 21:06the flickers of candlelight. One looked like a dragon, another a twisted skeleton,
- 21:12while the third was a ruby mass thick with clawed tentacles. The woman
- 21:18looked at them lovingly before giving me a warm glance. My boys. The
- 21:25globe behind the house had been a large autumn bonfire, stacked high with wood
- 21:30and mounds of colored leaves that somehow never fully burned. More long timbers of
- 21:36wood lay to one side, and it was two of these that the monsters
- 21:40bound Pete and Jackie as they thrashed and screamed. I think I could have
- 21:45left before then, but I couldn't abandon my friends, even if the woman
- 21:49wouldn't let me intervene to save them. I did try once, but after
- 21:56that a firm but gentle grip bore down on me heavily, and that I
- 22:00knew there was little I could do but shake and cry and tell them I
- 22:04was sorry. This seemed to trouble the woman somewhat, and as a monstrous
- 22:11offspring finished lashing my friends down. She spoke to me again. I hope
- 22:17this doesn't seem cruel to you. My family passed through the omago some time
- 22:21ago, but we are still old fashioned. We keep to the ways of
- 22:26bargain and plava, and we especially revere Halloween as it's one of the few
- 22:30times the world drops some of its pretenses. I had no idea what she
- 22:37was talking about, but maybe if I talked to her, I could convince
- 22:41her to let us all go pretenses. She nodded that the world is safe,
- 22:49that monsters aren't real, and that the truth that lay in the dark
- 22:53can't hurt you. Despite my plan to calm down, I could hear the
- 23:00angry panic in my voice. We were just wearing costumes. That's what Halloween
- 23:04is about. Why are you punishing us for it, she frowned. Not
- 23:11you, just them. You are honest, and lying is certainly not what
- 23:17Halloween is about. That's just what fearful people have told themselves and taught their
- 23:22children another lie. Her lip curled, the gums around her teeth dark and
- 23:30withered in the bonfire's light. And we always burn liars here. I turned
- 23:37as I heard a fresh set of screams. The horrors of the bonfire had
- 23:42picked up the timbers. Pete and Jackie were tied to, effortlessly swinging them
- 23:47up into the dark October sky before pitching them down into the roaring heat of
- 23:52the flames. I let out one last scream, letting my painful cry fill
- 23:59the voice left by the fading of their dying breaths. Ey squeezed tight.
- 24:04I slumped to the ground, wanting darkness to take me, begging to wake
- 24:10up and realize this was all some terrible nightmare. I felt something shift,
- 24:17both in my head and the world around me, and when I opened my
- 24:22eyes, the night had turned a day. The remnants of the bonfire was
- 24:27still there, but no sign of any bones or bodies, and when I
- 24:33turned around, I saw the house was gone as well. Instead, it
- 24:40was just a large clearing, empty except for the large pile of smoldering wood,
- 24:45and next to me a large jacker lantern, painted black and made of
- 24:52some kind of red fired earth. Choking back a fresh sob, I reached
- 24:57over and pulled off the stem lid and looked down inside. It was halfway
- 25:04filled with candy, corn and chocolates, and resting on top of the suite
- 25:10was a small note on orange paper. Pulling it out, I read what
- 25:18was written there. Don't forget your treats, Happy Halloween.