Latest / Blue Leader Nation Podcast / Episode 25: No Good Options
Transcript
- Ed Pallas: There were no good options. I can still remember sitting inside the mobile command bus during one of the most significant critical incidents of my career. Outside it was one of those nice fall afternoons, If I had to guess, probably somewhere in the low 70s. Inside the command bus, it was a different story. The bus had gradually become warm. Every seat was occupied, tactical commanders, negotiators, supervisors. radios crackled almost constantly, new information arrived every few minutes, and every piece of it had the potential to change the direction of the incident. It was serious, it was professional, but it actually started the way many police incidents do, with humor. If you spent any time in law enforcement, you know exactly what I mean. Humor isn't disrespect, it's how we manage stress. Someone makes a joke, someone else fires one back. It's a pressure valve. It reminds everyone to breathe. That despite the seriousness of the situation, we're still human. That's how this incident began. Then the joke stopped. Not because someone told us to. Not because anyone made an announcement. They just kinda stopped. And when they did, everyone in the bus understood something had changed. The incident we were facing wasn't unfolding the way we hoped. Welcome back to Blue Leader Nation. I'm your host, Ed Palace. For those who may not remember, this was the hostage situation at the Discovery Channel headquarters in Silver Spring, Maryland, September 10, 2010. The suspect, James Lee, had entered the building armed. He had taken hostages, and he appeared to have an explosive device strapped to his body, a suicide vest. Inside the building were innocent people whose lives depended on every decision being made outside. Surrounding the building were some of the finest public safety professionals I've ever had the privilege of serving alongside. Our Montgomery County SWAT team, our crisis negotiation unit, BombTechs from Fire and Rescue. You had FBI, ATF, an alphabet soup of other partners and agencies. Everybody from around the region was there. Every person had a role. Every person was focused. Everyone wanted the same outcome. A peaceful resolution. I was a member of the crisis negotiation team working inside the command bus. Our primary negotiator was sitting in his car, accompanied by his coach, speaking directly with James Lee. If you've ever listened to a hostage negotiation, it's difficult to describe. You don't hear dramatic speeches. You hear patience, carefully chosen words, long pauses, questions designed to build rapport, to understand, and to slow things down. Negotiation isn't about talking someone into surrendering. It's about finding a reason for them to keep living. It's about discovering what they value. Because in almost every successful negotiation, that's where it starts. What matters to this person? Who matters? What future are they still holding on to? Every negotiator is searching for what we often call the hook, the thing that keeps someone connected to life. Often it's a spouse or a child, maybe a parent, or even a pet. Anything that reminds them tomorrow is worth seeing. As the negotiations continued, intelligence kept coming into the command bus. One of the pieces of information available to us was James Lee's manifesto, which he published on his website. I remember reading through it on the tiny screen of my phone. I was looking for the hook. And the more I read, the less I found. At one point during the negotiations, James Lee referred to one of the hostages and said, This guy has two kids for crying out loud. When I first heard it, I remember thinking, What an odd thing to say. Then it hit me. He wasn't expressing sympathy for the hostage. He was condemning him because in James Lee's mind, having children wasn't something beautiful. It was part of the problem. Reading through his manifesto, I realized that he believed human beings were destroying the planet. To him, more people meant more destruction. This wasn't just another statement during negotiations. It was a window into how he viewed the world. And suddenly I understood something that changed how I saw the entire incident. There wasn't a hook. He didn't value things negotiators normally rely on. He wasn't worried about losing relationships. He wasn't thinking about going home. He wasn't talking about the future. He wasn't negotiating for money or freedom. He believed what he was doing was justified. And he even told us, this is the end. That realization settled over me like a weight. And it also explained why the humor had disappeared. Everyone in the command bus was arriving at the same conclusion. Not because someone announced it. Not because anyone wanted it to be true, but because the facts were pointing us there. This one was going to be different. I remember being in the command bus, you could cut the tension with a knife. It was just different. It was serious. At one point, our crisis negotiation team leader, Ron Smith, leaned into me and asked a simple question. What do you think? I remember taking a breath before answering. Every negotiator wants a peaceful resolution. That's always the goal, every single time. No one joins a negotiation team hoping a tactical resolution becomes necessary. Quite the opposite. We believe in communicating. SWAT often makes fun of us because we want to talk them to death and they want to take action. And the sweet spot is usually somewhere in the middle. But as negotiators, we believe in slowing things down. We believe people can change their minds. But based on everything I'd heard, everything I read, Everything I understood about the mindset of the man we were dealing with. I quietly answered Ron. I think this one's going to have to go tactical. They're going to have to put this guy down. Now, I'd never said that before. And I don't know whether my opinion counted any with Ron, maybe a little in the end. He was he was the team leader. But I think that's the recommendation he made to the command side of the bus. I didn't say it because I wanted that outcome. I said it because I I just couldn't see another outcome. In even saying those words, I hoped I was wrong. Here's something people often don't understand about leadership. Sometimes your experience leads you toward a conclusion you desperately wish wasn't true. I found myself that afternoon not certain, not confident, just increasingly convinced we were running out of options. And I didn't know what the answer was. I don't think anybody did. How do you handle a guy with hostages, a suicide bomber vest? and did I mention it looked like he had a dead man switch? Which meant that if he released his switch, if he released the trigger, boom. So that's what everybody in the command bus was faced with. We were dealing with someone who simply didn't see the world the way the rest of us did. And that changed everything. There was something happening inside the command bus. The clock never stopped. Every minute that passed changed the incident. The negotiator kept talking. The tactical team stayed in position, although I know they wanted to take action. Command staff was evaluating new intelligence. They were stuck between a rock and a hard place, but nothing was static. People often think leadership decisions happen in frozen moments, as if the world politely pauses while leaders figure things out. It doesn't. Leadership happens while everything is moving. The people you're leading keep thinking. The people you're trying to influence keep making decisions. The environment, it just keeps evolving, whether you're ready or not. And that's one of the biggest misconceptions about leadership. We imagine we get to choose between acting and waiting, but waiting isn't neutral. Waiting is happening inside a changing environment. And that distinction has stayed with me throughout my career. When I teach leadership now, I often hear supervisors say something like, I just need a little more information. And sometimes that's absolutely true. After all, good leaders don't rush. They verify facts, they challenge assumptions, they gather perspectives. They slow things down just enough to avoid making emotional decisions. If you've listened to this podcast for a while, you may remember the episode on the tactical pause. That lesson still stands. In fact, I believe in more today. The tactical pause is one of the most valuable leadership tools we have. But a tactical pause has a purpose. It creates just enough space. To make a better decision. And it has an endpoint. Indecision doesn't. One serves the mission, the other serves our discomfort. There's another reason leaders struggle in moments like this. Psychologists call it loss aversion. Simply put, human beings tend to work harder to avoid losses than they do to pursue gains. We fear making the wrong decision so much that sometimes we delay making any decision at all. We've all done it. I've done it. Maybe you've postponed addressing a performance problem because you didn't want the conflict. Maybe you delayed changing an assignment because you knew someone would be disappointed. Maybe you've waited to have a difficult conversation because you hoped the problem would resolve itself. And sometimes it does, but usually it doesn't. The reality is avoiding a decision doesn't eliminate the consequences, it simply changes who controls them. And as I sat in that command bus listening to the negotiator, I remember thinking something I couldn't quite put in the words at the time, but today I can. Leadership isn't choosing between good and bad. Most of the time, leadership is choosing between imperfect options. One path carries risk, another path carries different risk. Waiting carries its own risk. There isn't a safe square on the board, only different consequences. And that's why command can feel lonely. The higher you promote, the fewer decisions have obvious answers. When you're a young supervisor, you spend much of your day making operational decisions. Who takes what call? Who writes a report? How do you handle this complaint? And those decisions matter. But as your responsibilities grow, the decisions get heavier. Do we evacuate? Do we continue negotiating? Do we move in? Do we commit additional resources? Do we suspend the employee? Do we tell the family? Do we close the school? You don't make those decisions because you're certain. You make them because leadership requires someone to own them. One of the greatest myths about experienced leaders is that they become fearless. They don't. The best leaders I've known weren't fearless. They simply learned how to function despite uncertainty. Leadership isn't about eliminating uncertainty, it's about making the best decisions you can with the information available. And then adapting as new information arrives. That last part is critical because situations evolve, people evolve, and information changes. Good leaders evolve too. You know, thinking back to the discovery building incident inside the command bus, everyone was doing exactly what they should have been doing. Negotiators negotiated, command evaluated, SWAT prepared, intelligence kept flowing. Nobody was frozen, nobody was panicking, everybody was working. But While we were working, something else was happening inside the building. The hostages were watching, listening, thinking, processing the same reality from a very different perspective. And eventually they reached a conclusion on their own, one that changed everything. Not because command decided it was time, not because negotiators had reached a formal ending. Because the hostages made a decision. Without speaking, they silently signaled one another. Then almost simultaneously they ran in different directions. Everything changed in an instant. Hours of planning and discussion and disciplined patience suddenly gave way to seconds. The mission had changed, and the response had to change with it. Our SWAT team responded immediately. because the hostages' action created an immediate tactical necessity. This wasn't an opportunity. It was a rapidly changing situation that demanded an immediate response. The men on that team did exactly what they had been trained to do. Within moments, the suspect was dead. Every member of the SWAT team survived. Every police officer survived. When it was over, only one person had lost his life. The man who had created the crisis. For everyone who was there, it was an incredible relief. Families that could have experienced unimaginable loss were reunited with their loved ones. Officers who had prepared for the worst. We're able to go home. The negotiators, we packed up our equipment. The command bus slowly emptied. The radios grew quieter. And the adrenaline finally started to wear off. But the lesson stayed with me. Not because of how the incident ended, because of what it taught me about leadership. Before that day, I thought leadership was mostly about making good decisions. After that day, I understood leadership is equally about recognizing when the situation has changed. Those aren't the same thing. Because every decision changes the environment. The suspects' decisions, the negotiators' decisions, the command staff decisions, And finally, the hostages decision. And once the environment changed, everything else had to adapt. That's leadership. Not standing still until every answer becomes obvious, recognizing that the landscape has shifted, and then responding accordingly. That's true whether you're leading a tactical incident, a patrol squad, a detective unit, or an entire organization. Think about your own team. Maybe you've been waiting to address a performance issue, but while you've been waiting, the rest of your officers have been watching. They've been drawing conclusions. They're deciding what your standards really are. Maybe you've been avoiding a difficult conversation because you wanted a little more information. Meanwhile, the relationship has kept changing. The trust has kept changing. The problem changes. The environment doesn't pause because we haven't made up our minds, it keeps moving. I sometimes tell new supervisors that leadership would be easy if every decision came with a green light, if every call had a sign that said, that's the right answer. It doesn't work that way. Leadership looks more like a dimly lit road than a brightly lit highway. You can only see a little further ahead. So you make the best decision you can, and then you keep paying attention. You communicate and you adapt. Not because your first decision was wrong, but because conditions changed and good leaders change with them. As I look back on that discovery building, one thing stands out more than tactics or more than the command post. More even really, I think, than the outcome. It was extraordinary professionalism of everyone around me. Negotiators doing everything possible to preserve life. Tactical operators literally putting their lives on the line and risking everything for people they didn't even know. Commanders carrying the weight of decisions that most people will never have to make. Everyone working toward the same goal, protecting innocent people. And that's leadership. Not because everything went according to plan. But because everyone remained disciplined when nothing about the situation was simple. Here's the question you ask yourself. Am I actually gaining anything by waiting or just handing the decision to someone else? Because leadership isn't about eliminating uncertainty. It rarely disappears. Leadership is about making the best decision you can with the best information you have for the right reasons. And then having the humility to adapt when the situation changes. Because it will. I mean, it always does. And maybe that's the biggest lesson I took from that day. Leadership isn't choosing between good and bad. More often, it's choosing between imperfect options before time or someone else chooses for you. Hope you enjoyed this episode. I think it's a little different. Thank you for joining me on Blue Leader Nation. If this episode, I don't know, maybe challenged you or challenged the way you think about leadership, Share it with someone else who carries the weight of making difficult decisions. I'm Ed Pallas. Until next time, lead with courage, lead with humility. And remember, sometimes there are no good options, only the responsibility to lead anyway.