Latest / The Film Hobbyist / Little Women (1994): The Grief of Growing Up
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:31We're here in my attic room. You're sitting on
- 0:36a forest green Walmart futon with a black metal
- 0:40frame. I'm sitting in an old desk chair with
- 0:44cracks in the pleather lining. The floor beneath
- 0:48us is hardwood with worn patches where feet have
- 0:52frequently paced over the last 50 years. In between
- 0:56us is a round, faded blue braided rug. It's a
- 1:01wonderful place to sit and lay out the pieces
- 1:04of what I'm working on. skeins of yarn in a rainbow
- 1:08arc, or books and pages of research for my novel.
- 1:14It's been over a year since you first came to
- 1:16visit me, and to honor the occasion, I thought
- 1:19I'd discuss with you one of my favorite films,
- 1:231994's Little Women, directed by Gillian Armstrong,
- 1:28starring Winona Ryder. This film is an adaptation
- 1:32of Louisa May Alcott's novel, or rather, novels.
- 1:37What we call Little Women in the U .S. is actually
- 1:40a collection of two works, Little Women, published
- 1:44in 1868, and its second volume, sometimes called
- 1:49Good Wives, published in 1869. You are probably
- 1:54familiar with this story, but if not, I'll sketch
- 1:57out some details. Volume 1 begins at Christmas
- 2:02and takes place over the course of a year. Following
- 2:05the life of a family of four sisters, 16 -year
- 2:09-old Meg, 15 -year -old Joe, short for Josephine,
- 2:1313 -year -old Beth, 12 -year -old Amy, and their
- 2:17mother Marmee, while their father is off serving
- 2:20as a chaplain in the Union Army during the Civil
- 2:23War. Each character has distinct interests and
- 2:27personalities and faces many challenges that
- 2:31help them grow and mature. they also become close
- 2:34with the wealthy neighbor boy laurie his elderly
- 2:38grandfather mr lawrence and his tutor mr brooke
- 2:41tomboyish joe and laurie are especially good
- 2:45friends and mr brooke has a romantic interest
- 2:49in meg Volume 2 takes place three years later
- 2:54and picks up with the characters' forays into
- 2:57marriage and adulthood, particularly Jo as she
- 3:00moves to New York City to be a governess and
- 3:02pursue a career as a writer, becoming friends
- 3:05with a German professor named Friedrich Baer.
- 3:09Volume 2, essentially a sequel, was written very
- 3:13quickly after the publication and wild success
- 3:15of the first, and was in conversation with that
- 3:18success. If you've ever felt confused as to the
- 3:23structure of this story, its character arcs,
- 3:26and seeming repetition, if you've ever felt like
- 3:29the first half is where all the good stuff happens,
- 3:32except a famous death, then this might be why.
- 3:37I like the book. I was 12 or so when I read it
- 3:41for the first time, and I enjoyed it. I've reread
- 3:44it a couple of times since. But I love this movie.
- 3:51It might be tempting to lay that at the feet
- 3:53of nostalgia. I saw this film in theaters with
- 3:57my family as a preschooler, too young to be quite
- 4:00familiar with movie theater etiquette. In the
- 4:03family lore, this produced several full -voiced
- 4:07comments my mom still laughs hysterically over,
- 4:10most notably, she got a pear in the mail? And
- 4:14is it 1997 yet? I was old enough that I remember
- 4:20that the context of that last question was the
- 4:23four years later text in between part one and
- 4:26part two. I knew that time was progressing. I
- 4:31was just too young to understand the concept
- 4:33of history, or math, apparently. It might be
- 4:39tempting for you to believe that this is my favorite
- 4:41version of Little Women because it was my first
- 4:44Little Women. But the 1994 film isn't the first
- 4:49adaptation of the book, nor was it the last.
- 4:52There have been five separate stage plays, at
- 4:55least 15 TV movies, shows, and miniseries, a
- 4:59musical, two operas, six audio dramas, and seven
- 5:03films, the first of which was produced in 1917,
- 5:07less than 50 years after the publication of the
- 5:10book. My First Little Women was an anime TV special
- 5:15adaptation of Volume 1 that we owned on VHS.
- 5:20There have been enough anime TV adaptations that
- 5:24I have to specify that it was not the one produced
- 5:27by Nippon Animation, the precursor to Studio
- 5:30Ghibli. This one was sort of a pilot launch to
- 5:35a series that didn't really have much to do with
- 5:38the books other than the use of its characters.
- 5:41Though this special is actually not too bad of
- 5:44an adaptation of part one, holding on to several
- 5:48plot points that don't appear in the 1994 film,
- 5:51like the girls using their personal Christmas
- 5:53money to buy presents for Marmie, and Beth's
- 5:57having to face the possibility of scary Mr. Lawrence
- 6:00in order to play his piano. Though it does add
- 6:04a wild sequence where Joe and Laurie rescue a
- 6:07rather offensively drawn runaway slave from a
- 6:11river raft. This VHS was one of a handful that
- 6:15existed in my house before the 1994 movie that
- 6:19I know I watched regularly, to the point that
- 6:22I might subconsciously view it as the source
- 6:26material from which the 1994 film is adapted.
- 6:30But I will concede that my love for the 1994
- 6:33film is somewhat due to childhood nostalgia.
- 6:38I am also one of four sisters, all of us of literary
- 6:43and artistic persuasion. Two have degrees in
- 6:47visual art and pursued art -related careers.
- 6:50The other is a writer and editor. All of us acted
- 6:54in plays in high school. We all studied musical
- 6:58instruments, most into college. We all sang in
- 7:01choirs, and when we go Christmas caroling, we
- 7:04sing different vocal parts. We are also very
- 7:08different people. That mishmash of difference
- 7:12of personality delighting in similar interests
- 7:15is the background noise to this film specifically.
- 7:20In the 1994 film, the March sisters are introduced
- 7:24as a unit. They come barreling down the stairs
- 7:28and hallways to embrace their mother, only Amy
- 7:31standing out because of her youth and blonde
- 7:34hair, but everyone works together to warm up
- 7:37their mother and bring her to the fire. They
- 7:40don't actually get introduced as individuals
- 7:43until the next sequence, as Marmee gives them
- 7:46a candle and their own personal Christmas greeting.
- 7:51Though, as in most of the adaptations, Joe is
- 7:54the clear primary protagonist, towards the beginning
- 7:57of this film, the girls are almost always together
- 8:01in some capacity, in their camaraderie and their
- 8:04squabbles. Greta Gerwig's 2019 adaptation expands
- 8:09on this, with the girls literally speaking over
- 8:13each other, tumbling on the floor. But Gillian
- 8:16Armstrong brought a warmth and an affection not
- 8:20seen in previous films, particularly the 1949
- 8:23adaptation, where the girls don't actually seem
- 8:27to like each other much at all. The March sisters
- 8:31are all pretty close in age. My sisters and I
- 8:34span 16 years. But there is something about belonging
- 8:39to a group. making silly radio stories together
- 8:43into old tape recorders, performing together,
- 8:47doing each other's hair, that I find captured
- 8:51in this film. It's become a rite of passage that
- 8:54men marrying into our family watch it to understand
- 8:58a bit of our family dynamic. There's also something
- 9:02pretty amazing about this distinct relationship
- 9:05each sister has with each other. Beth's the only
- 9:10one who gets along perfectly with everyone, but
- 9:13she bonds with each sister over different things.
- 9:16Meg over their domestic interests, Amy with their
- 9:20position as the youngest sisters, and Joe over
- 9:23mutual delight. Beth loves Joe's stories, and
- 9:28Joe loves who Beth is. This film has Joe and
- 9:33Beth sharing a room, which builds an extra special
- 9:36connection. Meg and Joe are often together as
- 9:41the older two siblings, doing big girl activities
- 9:44like attending balls and working grown -up jobs,
- 9:48sharing responsibility for the family, experiencing
- 9:52tension over their disparate priorities. Meg
- 9:56and Amy bond over their love of beautiful, fine
- 10:00things, their desire to be like other girls in
- 10:04their community. Meg famously giving hard -earned
- 10:07money to Amy to buy the trendiest status symbol
- 10:11in school, a reality that continues to be relatable
- 10:15today. Joe and Amy mostly don't get along. Joe
- 10:20sometimes finds Amy's childish expressions and
- 10:24desires amusing, sometimes annoying, and Amy
- 10:28has the jealousy of a younger sister, wishing
- 10:31she could do all the fun and interesting things
- 10:34that the big girls get to do. These dynamics
- 10:38are a deeply personal part of my family as well.
- 10:42Each of us has had things we bond over and places
- 10:46of tension, and I love to see those dynamics
- 10:50mirrored through these fictional sisters. It
- 10:54makes the joy they share more alive, the sorrow
- 10:57more painful, the disagreements more potent.
- 11:01There's a particular fight between Joe and Amy
- 11:05that I know rings far truer because of how it
- 11:09echoes out of personal experience, which I've
- 11:12lived as both girls at one time or another. Every
- 11:17girl of literary aspiration and dramatic temperament
- 11:21identifies with Jo March, but this is especially
- 11:24true of those who also have a big temper and
- 11:28tomboyish inclinations. I've never been exactly
- 11:32a hyper -feminine person, and spent my young
- 11:35girlhood exploring the desert barefoot and scrambling
- 11:38up any tree I could. As an imaginative person,
- 11:42I found far more interest in playing baby godzillas
- 11:46with the boys at school than hair salon with
- 11:49the girls, and was never much interested in boy
- 11:52bands and crushes as a tween. I spent most of
- 11:56my first 17 years of life fending off accusations
- 12:00that my male friends were my boyfriends, and
- 12:03lived in dread of the idea of one of them ruining
- 12:06the friendship by saying they liked me. There's
- 12:11a long -held contingency of Little Women fans
- 12:13throughout history that hold fast to the idea
- 12:17that Joe and Laurie ought to have been romantically
- 12:20paired. Fan mail written to Louisa May Alcott
- 12:24in 1868 begged it to be so. Alcott invented the
- 12:30character of Professor Bear merely to spite them.
- 12:34He's the opposite of Laurie in nearly every way.
- 12:37Middle -aged, discerning, Steady and poor. This
- 12:43film does its best to beef up Joe's relationship
- 12:46with Professor Bear. But casting young Christian
- 12:50Bale to play Laurie did nothing to quell the
- 12:53long -running ship. He and Wynonna Ryder have
- 12:57such good chemistry. They match each other's
- 13:00energy in such a delightful way. You absolutely
- 13:03believe them as the best of friends, thick as
- 13:06thieves. But I agree. especially in this adaptation,
- 13:11that they work best as family. He belongs with
- 13:17this group, but not, romantically, with Joe.
- 13:23All of those are unsophisticated, mere experiential
- 13:28reasons why I love this film. But as I grew up,
- 13:32I began to appreciate what this adaptation does
- 13:35that is distinctly different than other versions.
- 13:40It's no secret that Little Women was heavily
- 13:42inspired by Louisa May Alcott and her family.
- 13:46Jo is very clearly a self -insert character,
- 13:49and the other sisters are also clearly inspired
- 13:53by her real -life siblings. The four of them
- 13:56were very close, and like the Marches, used to
- 14:00put on plays for the neighborhood children. her
- 14:03youngest sister may was an artist just like amy
- 14:06and her pencil sketches of the greek pantheon
- 14:09grace the walls of her old bedroom little women
- 14:13has continued to remain popular with the understanding
- 14:17that it's an exaggerated portrayal of all american
- 14:20girlhood The March's social position, as once
- 14:24wealthy, now fallen on hard times, is nearly
- 14:27middle class, interacting with the wealthy but
- 14:30still having to worry about money. The girls
- 14:34hold romantic and career aspirations that wind
- 14:37up in largely socially acceptable places. The
- 14:42Alcotts, in contrast, were very, very far from
- 14:46normal. Most of this has to do with Louisa May
- 14:50Alcott's father, Bronson Alcott. It's rather
- 14:54telling that she kind of writes out the March
- 14:56Patriarch as a distant, vaguely moral presence
- 14:59rather than a real character, because anything
- 15:03close to Bronson Alcott would take up too much
- 15:06energy from the story. He was a proponent of
- 15:10experimental schooling methods that moved away
- 15:13from rote schooling to conversational teaching
- 15:16out of the children's experience. He was against
- 15:19corporal punishment in schools, was an abolitionist,
- 15:23often tried to stick to a plant -based diet out
- 15:26of concern for animal welfare, and was the one
- 15:30who helped Louisa May Alcott get in touch with
- 15:32the editor who suggested she write a book for
- 15:34girls. This all makes him sound like a man before
- 15:39his time. He was actually much more of a mess,
- 15:43probably a lot closer to Viggo Mortensen's character
- 15:46in the film Captain Fantastic. He tried starting
- 15:50a utopian society at one point, like a proto
- 15:54-commune, based on agrarian society, but didn't
- 15:58actually know anything about farming. He was
- 16:01part of the Transcendentalist movement in Concord,
- 16:04Massachusetts, and wrote an important book on
- 16:07it that is largely incomprehensible. But you
- 16:12don't get a Louisa May Alcott without a Bronson
- 16:16Alcott, or an Abby May, on whom Marmy is based.
- 16:22She joined him in his educational reforms before
- 16:25they fell in love. And she did join him on all
- 16:29of his ideological forays, although when they
- 16:33were starving on the commune, she did threaten
- 16:36to leave for the sake of the children. Robin
- 16:39Swycord, screenwriter for the 1994 adaptation,
- 16:43decided to let all this historical context in.
- 16:48The marches are toned down from the Alcotts,
- 16:51but are still progressive for their time. Their
- 16:55father lost the family fortune when the school
- 16:58he was running was shut down after he admitted
- 17:01a black student. This is a detail from real life.
- 17:05Bronson Alcott did this twice and lost the schools
- 17:08and the money both times. Meg doesn't own a silk
- 17:13dress because silk mills employ child labor.
- 17:17The Alcotts did actually try to abstain from
- 17:20cotton and silk because of the textile industry's
- 17:23relationship to slavery. In the book, Amy leaves
- 17:27school out of shame and vanity. In the movie,
- 17:31Swycord has her withdraw because of corporal
- 17:35punishment, Marmee writing a scathing letter
- 17:38to such effect, repeating points that Bronson
- 17:41Alcott would have approved of. Jo explains to
- 17:44Professor Baer that her family grew up among
- 17:47transcendentalist circles, which she recognizes
- 17:50as coming from German philosophy, something they
- 17:53bond over. Jo and Meg's relationship to alcohol
- 17:57is discussed as her family are temperance people,
- 18:01just like the Alcotts, common for abolitionists
- 18:05and suffragettes of the day. Swycord also expands
- 18:09Marmy's ideals to be proto -feminist while still
- 18:13era -appropriate. She gives a long rant to Mr.
- 18:17Brooke about how girls are just as physically
- 18:19active as boys if not restrained by corsets.
- 18:23And while it's obvious by their silhouettes that
- 18:26the March sisters are wearing corsets, they might
- 18:29be wearing health corsets or other similar garments
- 18:33championed by various points during the 19th
- 18:36century. Amelia Bloomer's rational dress was
- 18:39contemporaneous with Marmee, and she was part
- 18:42of suffrage and temperance circles Marmee might
- 18:45have encountered. It is also worth pointing out
- 18:49that in the book, Marmee's attitudes toward her
- 18:53daughters are on the progressive end of things
- 18:55in her context. Girls marrying for love with
- 19:00no thought toward economic prospect. Having no
- 19:03plans or schemes to get her daughters married,
- 19:06but caring more about their character and place
- 19:10in the world. Her supporting of Joe as an unmarried
- 19:14woman, never pressuring her to marry Laurie.
- 19:18If there is one thing I wish Swycord had kept
- 19:22from the book, it would be Marmee's revelation
- 19:25that she is angry every day of her life, but
- 19:29has learned to master her temper. The idea that
- 19:32a proper woman could be angry and yet wise and
- 19:36lovely is something I miss. But instead, we get
- 19:41a conversation about women's suffrage, the ideas
- 19:44that women shouldn't vote because their husband
- 19:47would vote for them, or that women should vote
- 19:49because they are more moral than men, both which
- 19:53Joe refutes by pointing out that women should
- 19:56vote because they are humans and citizens. historically
- 20:00contemporary feminism. And hey, thank you Robin
- 20:05Swycord for doing the research to make this movie
- 20:08more closely aligned with late 20th century values
- 20:11by looking to the actual historical context rather
- 20:15than just shoehorning in modern ideas. I love
- 20:20this movie for its care for historicity. Seen
- 20:24in the script, the production design, and the
- 20:26fabulous costumes, and the wigs, I love how they
- 20:31capture the 19th century frizz. I love this movie
- 20:36for understanding little women's place in the
- 20:39literary works of the time. And now that I'm
- 20:43an adult nearing middle age, I love this movie
- 20:47for completely new reasons. Little Women is a
- 20:52buildings Roman, a coming -of -age story. It
- 20:55is about the transition from childhood vice and
- 20:58selfishness to mature womanhood. And the truth
- 21:02about growing up is that it usually isn't an
- 21:05easy or happy thing. Early in the film, Joe and
- 21:10her sisters share their Christmas wishes, how
- 21:13they hope their lives will pan out. As Amy says,
- 21:18we'll all grow up one day. We might as well know
- 21:21what we want. But their simple wishes go on a
- 21:25far more complicated journey. Every adaptation
- 21:29has to deal with this sadness, especially in
- 21:33how the tone differs from part one to part two.
- 21:37The 2019 version frames the entire story with
- 21:40it, flashing back from the gray, empty world
- 21:44of Part 2 to the golden, laughing days of Part
- 21:461. What that film does with structure and color,
- 21:51this film does with the magical score of Thomas
- 21:55Newman. Newman is particularly skilled at portraying
- 22:00complicated emotions in his scores. He captures
- 22:04tragic victory and the Shawshank Redemption,
- 22:07poignant fatalism in The Road to Perdition, humanizing
- 22:11satire in American Beauty. His orchestrations
- 22:15involve what I can only call thick chords, where
- 22:20lots of instruments follow the same rhythm in
- 22:23different registers, almost as if it was a four
- 22:26-handed piano duet. This creates a really luscious
- 22:31feel with loads of atmosphere. But here, he crafts
- 22:37a melody, a remarkable, versatile line that,
- 22:42depending on the speed, instrumentation, and
- 22:45rhythm, captures heartbreak, triumph, and the
- 22:49warmth of home. In the opening credits, he pulls
- 22:54this off twice, beginning with an oboe solo over
- 22:57soft tremolo strings, a heartbreaking plaintive
- 23:02melody, before transitioning to a lush, warm
- 23:06string rendition sprinkled with a trumpet and
- 23:09horn countermelody that evokes mid -19th century
- 23:13composing. And it is this duality that rivets
- 23:18me every time I watch this film. Being an adult
- 23:24is a hard -won reality. Growing up hurts. You
- 23:31have to lose things. Yes, your childhood selfishness
- 23:36and pride, but also your easy joy and sense of
- 23:40the world. Your relationships with your family
- 23:44will change. Your friendships will change. Your
- 23:48pursuits of your ambitions will not be easy.
- 23:52You may have to lay your dreams aside as priorities
- 23:55shift. And you will know loss. Growing up is
- 24:02a kind of grief. And yet, oh the warmth of that
- 24:08childhood. Oh the joy of remembrance. And now,
- 24:12how many good things there are in that change.
- 24:16In spite of that grief. Or maybe because of it.
- 24:22This Little Women embraces those realities fully.
- 24:28It isn't afraid to make emotional beats breathe,
- 24:32to let us sit in sadness and heartbreak or anxiety.
- 24:39There's a lot of story to pack into a Little
- 24:42Women movie, and if you watch the other film
- 24:45adaptations, of which I have seen the three most
- 24:48prominent, they do tend to rush the grief into
- 24:52the triumph, into the conclusion. But this adaptation,
- 24:57this 1994 film, lets us be sad. So that when
- 25:04the conclusion comes with a peal of Thomas Newman's
- 25:08triumphant trumpet descant and horn counterpoint,
- 25:12I can't help but smile with a shaky breath. And
- 25:18a tear stained face. And that's why I love this
- 25:24film. Thanks for coming.