Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Buffett Indicator at 206%! Shiller PE 37.6 Sounds the Red Alarm! Is the 2025 Market a Bubble?
Transcript
- 0:00So have you ever looked at the stock market recently and just
- 0:04felt like, well, like things are really booming?
- 0:08Yeah, it certainly feels that way for many people right now,
- 0:10doesn't it? A lot of upward momentum it
- 0:12does. But is that the full complete
- 0:15picture you always wonder? That's the key question.
- 0:18Today, we're taking a deep dive into, you know, the fascinating
- 0:21world of market valuation We're peeling back.
- 0:23The layers, looking at some of the big respected gauges out
- 0:26there. Exactly.
- 0:28Our mission today is to dig into a stack of critical reports,
- 0:32some fresh insights on the famous Buffett Indicator and the
- 0:35Schiller's JPE. And we're using data right up to
- 0:39Friday June 27th, 2025 S pretty current.
- 0:43Very current. We'll pull out the most
- 0:44important Nuggets, really, to help you understand what these
- 0:46numbers might truly mean for the future.
- 0:48And that core question, are stock valuations stretched right
- 0:51now? And what does that actually mean
- 0:53for you, whether you're an active investor or, you know,
- 0:55just someone trying to understand the economic
- 0:57landscape? That's exactly what we're here
- 0:58to try and unravel. Right, we're going to look
- 1:00beyond the sort of daily headlines and see what the
- 1:02historical data suggests, give you some.
- 1:04OK, let's dive in. Let's unpack this with, well,
- 1:07what I sometimes think of is the markets, ancient oracles, the
- 1:10two Titans evaluation. Good.
- 1:12Way to put it. First up, the Buffett indicator.
- 1:15Now this gauge famously favored by Warren Buffett himself.
- 1:19It compares the total U.S. market cap to nominal GDP.
- 1:23Right, the value of all stocks versus the size of the economy.
- 1:26And as of June 27, 2025, it stood at approximately 206%.
- 1:30206% wow. Yeah.
- 1:32To give you a sense of scale, that means the total value of
- 1:35all U.S. stocks, roughly $61.6 trillion, is now more than
- 1:39double the size of our entire annual economy, which is around
- 1:4230.0 in dollars. Double the economy?
- 1:44That sounds big. It is.
- 1:45And what's truly striking about that 206 percent is, well, where
- 1:49it's historically it places it at the 94th percentile. 94th
- 1:52percentile, so very, very high compared to history.
- 1:55Extremely high, about 1.9 standard deviations above its
- 1:581970 to 2024 trend. Yeah.
- 2:00What does a reading like that usually signal?
- 2:02Well, when the Buffett indicator has been this elevated
- 2:05historically, it typically signals extreme overvaluation.
- 2:09That's the common interpretation.
- 2:10OK, extreme overvaluation, but what's the implication?
- 2:13And here's the crucial resection.
- 2:14So what the real annual returns for the S&P 500 over the next 10
- 2:19years? They've historically been less
- 2:21than 2%. Less than 2% per year.
- 2:23Per year, in real terms, after inflation.
- 2:26Think about that. For an entire decade, your
- 2:28equity investments might barely outpace inflation.
- 2:32That really challenges the whole buy and hold mantra, doesn't.
- 2:34It it certainly makes you think harder about valuations and
- 2:36future expectations. It makes every decision about
- 2:39where you put your money feel, well, critically important.
- 2:41That's a powerful historical precedent for sure.
- 2:44OK. Next, let's turn to the Schiller
- 2:45KPE. That's the cyclically adjusted
- 2:47price to earnings ratio. Right, Robert Schiller's metric
- 2:50uses 10 years of inflation adjusted earnings.
- 2:52And this indicator also on June 27th, 2025 stood at 37.65. 37.65
- 2:59And much like the Buffett indicator, the Schiller KPE is
- 3:02also way up there, also the 94th percentile historically.
- 3:05Same percentile. That's uncanny.
- 3:07It is quite striking and to give you some maybe killing context,
- 3:10only two periods in history have seen higher KP readings which
- 3:14were 1929 right before the Great Depression and the infamous 1998
- 3:192001.com bubble. Not exactly comforting
- 3:22comparison. Not at all.
- 3:23And this current reading it implies A10 year real return of
- 3:27maybe about 2% to 3%. So again.
- 3:30Very low single digits. Very similar.
- 3:32Both these major gauges are pointing in a very similar, very
- 3:35cautionary direction right now. It's really striking how aligned
- 3:38they are, these two distinct indicators.
- 3:41When you see such a strong overlap, both flashing
- 3:43expensive, what does that really tell you more than just one
- 3:46indicator alone? Well, I think it tells you that
- 3:48the market's exuberance or perhaps its pricing is broad and
- 3:52deep. It's not just one aspect that
- 3:53looks stretched, OK. You see, the Buffett Indicator
- 3:55measures market value against the size of the economy using
- 3:59nominal GDP. Right.
- 4:00Stocks versus GDP. It's take away now is that
- 4:03stocks are priced at about two times the size of the economy, a
- 4:06level, as we said, eerily similar to dot com extremes.
- 4:10The Schiller KP, though, measures price against 10 year
- 4:13earnings power, adjusted for inflation.
- 4:15Price versus long term earnings. Exactly.
- 4:18Its current take away is that these earnings multiples are
- 4:20back at late 1990s highs, even though EPS growth seems to be
- 4:25generally slowing down. Interesting.
- 4:27So while the mechanics are different, one looks at the
- 4:29economy, 1 looks at earnings. Their message today is
- 4:32harmonious. This market is very expensive.
- 4:35And where do they differ, though, in their approach?
- 4:38Even if they're arriving at the same place today?
- 4:40Understanding those nuances can be helpful, right?
- 4:42Absolutely, it's important the Buffett indicator uses nominal
- 4:45GDP. Meaning not adjusted for
- 4:47inflation. Correct.
- 4:49So this means if we get a burst of fast inflation, it can
- 4:52actually help keep the ratio in check, simply because the
- 4:55denominator GDP grows faster in nominal terms.
- 4:58OK, inflation makes the economy look bigger, faster.
- 5:01Right. The KPE, however, strips out
- 5:04inflation from the earnings side, so it's less sensitive to
- 5:07those nominal GDP swings. Makes sense.
- 5:09But the KPE can stay elevated if long term bond yields are very,
- 5:13very low because that makes future earnings seem more
- 5:16valuable today. So different sensitivities.
- 5:18Exactly. Different sensitivities, but
- 5:20arriving at the same conclusion today, which as you said, makes
- 5:23their current alignment even more compelling, I think.
- 5:25Yeah, it really does. And it's not just these two, is
- 5:28it? It feels like when we listen
- 5:30closely, there's almost a whole orchestra joining this chorus of
- 5:34caution. That's a good analogy, yes.
- 5:35What other indicators are singing that same tune about the
- 5:38market's current valuation? Yeah, when we look at a broader
- 5:41ensemble of metrics as of June 27th, they largely echo the same
- 5:45message. It's quite consistent.
- 5:47Like what? For instance, the plain old
- 5:49trailing PE ratio price divided by the last 12 months of
- 5:52earnings. It's at 29.4 now.
- 5:54Where does that stand historically?
- 5:56That's the 90th percentile compared to its history going
- 5:59back to 1960. So another clear signal of high
- 6:02valuation, OK. What about looking forward the
- 6:05forward PE? The Forward PE, which uses
- 6:08analysts estimates for the next year's earnings.
- 6:10That's at 21.3, which is the highest it's been since January
- 6:142022, also pointing firmly towards expensive.
- 6:17And then there are things like price to sales and price to
- 6:19book. They often give a slightly
- 6:20different perspective, don't they, based on assets or
- 6:23revenue, not just earnings. They do.
- 6:25And right now they're reinforcing the same message,
- 6:27maybe even more strongly. Really.
- 6:28Yeah. The price to Sales PS ratio
- 6:31stands at 3.14. And the significance of that.
- 6:34That is a new record, a new all time high.
- 6:37The long run median is only about 1.5.
- 6:39Wow, more than double the median.
- 6:40Exactly. And the price to book PD ratio
- 6:43that's at 5.24, also an all time high.
- 6:47Goodness. So across the board on these
- 6:49price metrics, it really. Makes you wonder, doesn't it,
- 6:51how much future growth is already baked?
- 6:53OK. That's pretty clear on the
- 6:54valuation side, but then there's the equity risk premium ERP.
- 6:58This one always feels, I don't know, crucial because it speaks
- 7:01directly to how much reward you're actually getting for
- 7:04taking the risk of owning stocks versus something safer it.
- 7:07Absolutely is crucial. And this is where I think a
- 7:09really critical red flag is waving right now.
- 7:12OK. The ERP, specifically the 1
- 7:15based on the KPE yield compared to bond yields is near 0% zero.
- 7:20Zero. What does that even mean?
- 7:21It's profound, really. It means stock earnings yields
- 7:24at the inverse of the PE ratio, basically barely.
- 7:27However, what you can get from safe Treasury yields so.
- 7:30Stocks are essentially no longer compensating you for the added
- 7:32risk compared to bonds. Pretty much, yes.
- 7:34That's what a near 0 ERP implies.
- 7:36And this isn't just some, you know, technical financial point,
- 7:39it's a warning sign. Historically this kind of set up
- 7:41a very low or zero ERP preceded significant bear markets like in
- 7:46196673 and again in 2000 O2. That's sobering.
- 7:50It is. And just to reinforce that
- 7:51message, another related measure, the excess Cape yield
- 7:54is only 1.25% compared to its twenty year average of about
- 7:573.3%, so well below average, again reinforcing that expensive
- 8:03message, that lack of compensation for risk.
- 8:05So we have this nearly unanimous chorus from the valuation
- 8:08metrics, all pointing towards an expensive market, little reward
- 8:12for risk. But what about the broader
- 8:14economy, the macro signals? Are they in line with this
- 8:18caution or we may be hearing some different notes being
- 8:20played there? That's an important question
- 8:22because the macro picture offers well, it's a bit of a nuanced
- 8:25blend, actually, not quite as uniform.
- 8:27How so? Well, first the big one, yield
- 8:30curve, specifically the three month Treasury bill versus the
- 8:3410 year Treasury note yield. Still inverted.
- 8:36Still inverted? Yes, by more than 90 basis
- 8:38points as of June 26, 2025. And that's significant because?
- 8:42This is the longest period of inversion we've seen since the
- 8:441970s, and historically this kind of inversion has a
- 8:47recession hit rate of over 80% within the following 6 to 18.
- 8:50Months over 80%. That's a powerful signal.
- 8:52It is. It's a powerful, fairly
- 8:55unambiguous signal of macro caution, and it strongly
- 8:58supports the idea of lower future returns aligning
- 9:01perfectly with what the valuation metrics are telling
- 9:03us. OK.
- 9:04So that yield curve inversion is a big check mark in the caution
- 9:07column, but you said the picture was nuanced.
- 9:10As we know, markets are rarely that simple.
- 9:12Exactly. There are some mixed signals.
- 9:15What are some of those things that might be, I don't know,
- 9:17adding to the confusion for investors right now or maybe
- 9:20offering a counterpoint? Right.
- 9:21For example, look at margin debt, the amount people are
- 9:24borrowing to buy stocks year over year, It's basically flat,
- 9:27which is neutral. It's not flashing the kind of
- 9:30extreme speculative greed, that huge surge in borrowing that we
- 9:34saw back in, say, 2021. OK.
- 9:36So no wild leverage building up right now.
- 9:38Not in the same way, no. Similarly, things like the VIX,
- 9:41the volatility index, and junk bond spreads, they're also kind
- 9:44of neutral. So credit markets are panicking.
- 9:46Volatility isn't spiking. Exactly.
- 9:48These risk indicators seem pretty complacent.
- 9:51Maybe not euphoric, but certainly not signaling major
- 9:55stress yet. Huh.
- 9:57So how do you square that high valuations, inverted yield
- 10:00curve, but low volatility and neutral margin debt?
- 10:03Well, this kind of mixture often appears late in an economic
- 10:07cycle. The lead cycle behavior.
- 10:09Right Investors feel relatively calm, may be lulled by recent
- 10:12returns even as underlying value becomes scarce and macro risks
- 10:16like the yield curve are flashing.
- 10:18It creates the sort of macro divergent.
- 10:20Where valuations are screaming danger, but the immediate
- 10:24cyclical stress gauges aren't quite flashing red yet.
- 10:26Precisely. It's often described as the calm
- 10:29before a potential storm, rather than the storm itself having
- 10:31already arrived. That complacency can be fragile.
- 10:34OK. So bringing this all together,
- 10:36then we've got the Titans, the Buffett indicator and Shiller
- 10:38shaped be screaming expensive. We've got the broader valuation
- 10:41metrics, PSPB forward PE largely agreeing.
- 10:44We've got a near 0 equity risk premium saying you're not paid
- 10:47for risk. A big one.
- 10:48We have an inverted yield curve warning of recession, but then
- 10:51we have these calmer signals from margin debt and VIX.
- 10:55So what does this whole ensemble mean for you, the listener?
- 10:58The investor looking forward? I think the consensus message,
- 11:01despite those mixed signals on the risk front is pretty clear.
- 11:04The market looks stretched, very stretched.
- 11:06And that translates into. Lower expected returns, yeah,
- 11:09Both the Buffett indicator and the CPE, based on their current
- 11:12levels, they map historically to projected real annual S&P 500
- 11:17returns of only about 1% to 3% over the next decade. 1 to 3%,
- 11:21just to reiterate that. Yes.
- 11:23And to put that in perspective, that's significantly lower than
- 11:26the average since 1980, which has been closer to 6.5% real
- 11:30return per year. So the data strongly implies a
- 11:33distinctly lower forward return set for the coming years, less
- 11:36reward ahead. That's the primary message from
- 11:38these long term valuation tools, yes.
- 11:40And what about the risks we talked about the low ERP, How
- 11:43does that skew the potential outcomes?
- 11:45Absolutely. The risk profile looks skewed.
- 11:46We often talk about it as right tail down, left tail fatter.
- 11:49OK, translate that for. Us.
- 11:50In simpler terms, it means the chances of a significantly
- 11:54negative market outcome, a big draw down a bear market, appear
- 11:57higher than usual. That's the fatter left tail, OK,
- 12:00and the chances of unusually high positive returns are
- 12:02diminished. That's the compressed or lower
- 12:04right tail. So more chance of bad stuff,
- 12:06less chance of exceptionally good stuff.
- 12:08That's the gist. And with that equity risk
- 12:11premium near 0 and the yield curve inverted, any kind of
- 12:14unexpected shock, maybe an earnings stumble that surprises
- 12:17people or a sudden policy change, it could trigger a
- 12:21faster than normal repricing in the market, a sharper drop
- 12:24because there's less of a valuation cushion and less
- 12:27compensation for holding stocks already built in.
- 12:30That's a key risk to be aware of.
- 12:32Given that outlook, lower expected returns, higher
- 12:35downside risk, are there any alternatives that look more
- 12:38attractive right now, especially for someone trying to balance
- 12:41that risk in return? Well, comparatively speaking,
- 12:43yes. Things that offer safety and a
- 12:46clearer return profile look better than they have in a
- 12:48while, such as T-bills still offer decent yields and TIPS
- 12:52Treasury inflation protected securities are interesting.
- 12:55For instance, 30 year TIPS are offering a real yield above
- 12:59inflation of about 2.7%. 2.7% real guaranteed by the
- 13:03government. Exactly which when you think
- 13:05about those projected one 3% real equity returns we just
- 13:09discussed looks pretty competitive, doesn't it,
- 13:11especially given the lower? Risk.
- 13:12It certainly does. And quality bonds like
- 13:15Treasuries might also regain their traditional role as a
- 13:17hedge if that equity risk premium starts to mean revert,
- 13:21likely through lower equity prices.
- 13:23Bonds could do well if stocks fall.
- 13:25OK, that makes sense. Now the big question maybe Could
- 13:28anything invalidate these warnings?
- 13:30What could make these indicators, which seems so
- 13:32compelling based on history, actually be wrong this time?
- 13:35It's always the this time is different question isn't.
- 13:37It always. Is there a scenario where this
- 13:40expensive market is actually justified somehow?
- 13:42There are a couple of theoretical possibilities,
- 13:44though they seem like high hurdles right now.
- 13:46One would be a significant sustained productivity
- 13:50renaissance may be driven by something like artificial
- 13:54intelligence really boosting corporate efficiency and profits
- 13:57dramatically. So real earnings grow much, much
- 14:00faster than expected. Exactly.
- 14:02If real earnings could somehow surge far above the historical
- 14:05trend baked into this IPE denominator, that could
- 14:08potentially justify higher valuations than history would
- 14:11suggest. A massive productivity boom.
- 14:13OK, what else? Another possibility could be a
- 14:16period of sustained disinflation, maybe even mild
- 14:19deflation, followed by significant interest rate cuts
- 14:21from the Fed. Who would that help?
- 14:23Lower rates generally expand the fair multiple for stocks because
- 14:27future earnings are discounted back to the present at a lower
- 14:30rate. So lower rates could
- 14:31theoretically support higher PE ratios.
- 14:33There's always. A but.
- 14:33But even in that scenario, for stocks to be truly attractive
- 14:37compared to bonds, the equity risk premium would still need to
- 14:40rise. Meaning stock yields would need
- 14:41to go up relative to bond yields.
- 14:43Right, either stock prices would need to fall or earnings would
- 14:47need to grow exceptionally fast to make stocks genuinely more
- 14:50appealing than safer bonds. Even if interest rates were
- 14:52lower overall, that ERP needs to offer some compensation. 0 isn't
- 14:58sustainable long term. Got it.
- 15:00So even the potential outs have caveats.
- 15:03They do. So, you know now the bottom line
- 15:05from this deep dive really seems to be that the Buffett Indicator
- 15:08and the Schiller KP are singing in harmony right now.
- 15:11Cautionary Harmony. Definitely.
- 15:13They along with price to sales, price to book and that vanishing
- 15:16equity risk premium are all at levels that historically have
- 15:19preceded pretty anemic 10 year returns and frankly higher
- 15:23drawdown risk. And the main counterpoint we
- 15:25discussed that sort of calm surface in credit markets and
- 15:27volatility. Yeah, the mixed signals from
- 15:29margin debt, VIX, junk spreads. Right.
- 15:32But as we've seen, that calm often breaks after valuations
- 15:36peak, not necessarily before. Exactly.
- 15:39It can be a sense of complacency that exists right up until a
- 15:41significant shift occurs. History suggests you don't wait
- 15:44for the VIX to spike before you get cautious about valuations
- 15:47this high. So a lot to think about there.
- 15:49What stands out to you most from today's deep dive?
- 15:52As you are listener, consider your own financial landscape.
- 15:55How might these signals influence your perspective on
- 15:58where the market might be headed?
- 15:59Yeah. And what does that phrase a risk
- 16:02premium drought truly mean for the value and the potential
- 16:05future returns of your investments?
- 16:07Something to definitely Mull over.
- 16:08Absolutely. OK, a quick but important note
- 16:11before we sign off for today. Yes, all the analysis we shared
- 16:14is based on publicly available sources as of late June 2025.
- 16:18And of course it could be subject to revisions or
- 16:21different interpretations. And crucially, this content is
- 16:23purely for educational and informational purposes.
- 16:26It does not constitute investment advice.
- 16:29Please always conduct your own thorough due diligence before
- 16:31making any investment decisions for yourself.
- 16:34Definitely. If you enjoyed this deep dive
- 16:36and found it useful, please do like and subscribe to us.
- 16:38You can find us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, our YouTube
- 16:41channel to search for deep value investing.
- 16:43And don't forget to check out the episode description.
- 16:45We've put together a curated book list on value investing
- 16:49that you might find interesting. Great resources there.
- 16:51Thanks for tuning in. We'll catch on the next deep
- 16:53dive.