Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Ohio State vs. Michigan - 2023 Tale Of The Tape
Transcript
- 0:02Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdeman
- 0:06here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going well, Tony?
- 0:13I was watching I don't know one of the football games on Saturday, and
- 0:18a commercial came on that you had the CBS Sports Music and Ohio State in
- 0:24Indiana kickoff Saturday three thirty pm. And I went, oh, crap,
- 0:28is that next weekend? Which seems like something that someone who has had a
- 0:31countdown to that game on his podcast since January would have a better grass bomb.
- 0:37But it was like, I thought I had another weekend before we were
- 0:40gone every weekend, But no, Tony, apparently not. Apparently football coming
- 0:44sooner than maybe expected. Yeah, I think after this show, I'm going
- 0:48to go ahead and set my DVR for this coming weekend and get all those
- 0:51games in, and I probably remove all of the games from last year.
- 0:56I don't think I need him anymore. I think it's safe to go ahead
- 1:00and delite Ohio State versus Rutgers. If I need to go back to that,
- 1:03I can perhaps just go back to my copious notes from my notebooks.
- 1:08Yeah, I think hopefully, you know, hopefully that's not a game we're
- 1:12talking about too much, at least for a while. Better clear off that
- 1:17DVR space for Michigan, East Carolina. Oh baby, it is? Is
- 1:22that where game Day is this week? I didn't. I forgot to look.
- 1:25Actually, I don't believe we can DVR that game. I believe it
- 1:27is on Peacock, So I guess that's good in that sense. I just
- 1:33hopefully this Peacock stuff is available on demand as well, and hopefully, you
- 1:40know what would be great if like NBC and I have no idea, if
- 1:42NBC and Peacock, like aren't militant about the games being on YouTube, when
- 1:47the people just throw the games up on YouTube, because that's the best way
- 1:49to watch Michigan if you're not watching it live. It's fast forwarding through the
- 1:55huddles and through the chit chat and things like that. Yeah, I'm I'm
- 2:00interested to see how this whole TV network impacts me personally with rewatching of Michigan,
- 2:06which we both do. So I just want to make sure I'm understanding
- 2:08this. So Michigan is going to be the first week game on a new
- 2:14network that has never shown Big ten games before, and they're playing a lower
- 2:17level team at home, and they're a big favorite, right, I just
- 2:20want to make sure I'm understanding the situation. Is that is that all accurate?
- 2:23What could possibly go wrong? Tom, Yeah, I believe that is.
- 2:29I believe that is accurate. I'm just looking scrolling here to see Yes,
- 2:34twelve pm Peacock East Carolina at Michigan. Now, I don't believe.
- 2:43I don't believe Michigan is. I don't think it's a concern. Also,
- 2:46I remember after that game, when everybody petitioned for Appalachian State, we should
- 2:51be allowed to give them a p votes. I don't think get to worry
- 2:54about that with East Carolina. I don't. I don't think that's going to
- 2:57be something whether no petition, no go fund to me, nothing like that
- 3:00is going to get them any AP votes. Well, yeah, well they're
- 3:05an FBS team, so that you won't need to petition. And also,
- 3:07I didn't even think about the fact of all this time. This is totally
- 3:08different from the other thing that I might have been implying earlier, because this
- 3:10team's from North Carolina, whereas the other time it was from oh somewhere down
- 3:17down in some holler down there somewhere. Uh yeah, No, I think
- 3:23I think there's nothing to worry about. It should be fine. Michigan had
- 3:25its head coach the last time, so it's really this is totally a different
- 3:29situation. As we wait for people to come in, we will. We
- 3:32are doing our welcome everybody, those of you have joined us. We are
- 3:36doing our Ohio State Michigan tailor of the tape, something we've been doing for
- 3:40the entirety of this podcast. So I don't know if it's like the seventh
- 3:44one maybe that we've done over the years, and so feel free to throw
- 3:49in your questions. You're super chats. We will get to them as probably
- 3:53after we do all of the comparison and the contrasting of Ohio State and Michigan
- 3:59position by position later in the season, we'll pit them against each other and
- 4:03things like that. This is just basically determining the rooms individually, who has
- 4:09the better rooms. But I don't know, we should probably save it for
- 4:13when we talk about the coaches. But Michigan crazy stuff going on with the
- 4:18lack of head coaches and the plethora of head coaches going on right now is
- 4:25interesting. Yeah, Harbaugh's suspended. He well, he there was going to
- 4:29be an agreement who was going to be suspended for four games and then no,
- 4:32no, no, that's totally out of pocket. That's totally unacceptable.
- 4:38We're going to self impose a three game suspension, which is totally different because
- 4:45of it's one game less, but because it's one game lesson we have four
- 4:48guys, we want to have the interim coaches. We're going to do this
- 4:51in the weirdest way possible, and we're going to have four interim coaches head
- 4:56coaches for three games. And I don't I want to like, I don't
- 5:00want to totally be bagging on this idea, because it is kind of a
- 5:02cool idea to give a bunch of different guys a chance to be a head
- 5:05coach for a game, and like Sharon Moore is gonna a head coach for
- 5:09a game, and they're gonna they're gonna sort of space it out and everyone
- 5:13will get the opportunity to then say, oh, you know, when you're
- 5:15looking for a job down the line, yeah, I have been an interim
- 5:17head coach and it was at Michigan. It's a big program, and okay,
- 5:19so this is great, And you know that was certainly something Ryan Day
- 5:23when he was the interim head coach when rban Meyer was suspended or unpaid administrative
- 5:28leave or whatever whatever the technical term was back in twenty eighteen. That was
- 5:31certainly, you know, a nice little dry run for Ryan Daide before we
- 5:34took over the program on the whole. So that's cool. But the UNLV
- 5:39game Tony first half interim head coach, Jay Harbaugh, second half interim head
- 5:46coach Mike Hart. Somehow, even when Jim Harbaugh is doing something, it's
- 5:51like, oh, that's kind of a neat way to do it, and
- 5:54it's kind of a nice way to, you know, maybe do it do
- 5:57a solid for some of your assistant coaches, He's still somehow finds a way
- 6:00to make it weird. And I just everyone's good at something, and making
- 6:04it weird seems to be his thing. I think that's his love language,
- 6:09basically, that's what he that's the way he gets through to people. Yeah,
- 6:14it is bizarre, but I do also think it's It's like when Bobby
- 6:18Bowd would have to suspend a bunch of players over the course of three or
- 6:21four games from previous season. This is essentially what maybe Jim Harbaugh is doing
- 6:26as well. Because around more I believe it's suspended for the first game,
- 6:29so I couldn't coach the first game. So you've got a got a piecemeal
- 6:31it here and there. When you're going to run agate program, Tim,
- 6:34you gotta do what you can. Well, remember Florida State FSU back then
- 6:40was Freeshoes University and that was why. And Tony U of m unallowed meat.
- 6:46I think that's got to be the the new like across deck for this
- 6:51And yes, just let's get this on the record. Yes, it turns
- 6:54out there was more than just Hamburgers. I know, I'm surprised too,
- 6:58but it turns out some of that was be being downplayed a little bit.
- 7:00But yes, there was a bunch of stuff involving COVID, which was Tony
- 7:03arguably serious, more serious than Hamburgers. I still wish. I wish two
- 7:10things, Sports Illustrated as a magazine was still around, and if it was
- 7:15then, like Michigan win's the National Championship this year, because you know,
- 7:18the cover would be it would just say Burger King with a picture of Hardbaugh
- 7:24holding a trophy, and it would be spectacular, maybe not for the Buckeye
- 7:28fans, but for those of us who appreciate a good Sports Illustrated cover.
- 7:32All right, yes, that would that would be great. And boy,
- 7:36you look back, I just saw someone tweeting about the like a non Ohio
- 7:40State affiliated person tweeting out the how deep it went Ohio State Jim Trestles Sports
- 7:46Illustrated cover, and it's like, you look at that now and it's like
- 7:49a guy failed to report a thing that's functionally now legal. Like, boy,
- 7:56that in terms of things that used to seem like a real big deal
- 8:00some people that not necessarily as much now that that's sort of towards the top
- 8:05of us, we do have a super jat Tony from Brann Laguerre. Not
- 8:09only is Jim Harball good being weird, he's good at being Ryan Day's daddy.
- 8:13I mean, and we'll get to we will get to the head coach
- 8:15rankings a little later on the show. I mean, he does have he
- 8:18does have scoreboard back to back years. I don't you know, I don't
- 8:22think that's an arguable thing, so thoughts, Yeah, no, it's definitely
- 8:26not an arguable thing. He is Jim Marball is two one and yeah against
- 8:35Ryan Day. So yeah, the two ones in the row undeniable. We
- 8:39will eventually get to the quarter to the head coach rankings, but let's go
- 8:41ahead and start with the quarterback rankings. Tom, and I'll even I'll give
- 8:46you first dibbs here to see how you think about how this thing is going
- 8:50to go. Well. I think you have to look at J. J.
- 8:54McCarthy being sort of a proven commodity at this point point. And when
- 9:01I say proven commodity, I don't mean he's incredible. I think J.
- 9:05J. McCarthy has stuff that he does really well. I think J.
- 9:09J. McCarthy has stuff that he stuff that he does where it's you know,
- 9:13you get the sense sometimes the coaching staff doesn't entirely trust him. But
- 9:16you've also seen it from J. J. McCarthy. And he went down
- 9:20to Columbus and beat Ohio State last year, and he won the Big Ten
- 9:22last year, and he got to the College Football Playoff, and then once
- 9:26he got to the College Football playoff, mumble mumble, mumble, voice trails
- 9:28off and then then they had an off season. And so I think you
- 9:33have to look at the proven commodity right now and say you probably take that
- 9:41over the two guys in Ohio State's quarterback room because I think we both have
- 9:46a sense that Kyle McCord and Devin Brown, whoever it ends up being,
- 9:50and we did a whole show about who we thought it was probably going to
- 9:52be a little earlier this afternoon, but who whichever one it ends up being,
- 9:58it's a five star quarterback. It's a guy being coached by Ryan Day
- 10:01in a Ryan Day offense and with a plethora of skill talent around them,
- 10:05and you get the sense they're probably going to be fine. And I would
- 10:09even say I am fairly confident that Ohio State's quarterback is going to have shining
- 10:13year statistics than J. J. McCarthy does. And it's quite possible if
- 10:16we revisit this by the end of the year, you know, if we're
- 10:18doing another one of these the week of the Ohio State Michigan game, that
- 10:22we're picking the Ohio State quarterback. But right now, you just I think
- 10:26I know what you're going to get with the Ohio State quarterbacks. But right
- 10:28now you kind of know sort of what the floor is with J. J.
- 10:31McCarthy, So I think you gotta go with Michigan to the quarterback room,
- 10:35at least for the moment. Yeah, I would agree with that,
- 10:39But even even Kaye mc maripeed Ohio State and check Michigan to the playoffs.
- 10:43So I mean that's that's no guarantee that J. J. McCarthy is all
- 10:46that good. But twenty two touchdowns five interceptions last year obviously a playmaker.
- 10:52Still you would expect him to be more consistent. Although, as we know
- 10:56here on the show, the theory is that the longer a quarterback is with
- 11:01Jim Harbaugh, the worst he gets. So it will be interesting interesting to
- 11:05see if J. J. McCarthy just blows that theory out of the water
- 11:09this year. I expect him to be just fine and really good and really
- 11:13productive. It is interesting to me that if you just look at the course
- 11:18of his season last year, completed eighty percent of his passes. In August
- 11:24and September completed seventy one point six percent of his passes in October, in
- 11:30November completed fifty percent of his passes. That's something that we used to see
- 11:33with Braxton Miller and J. J. Barrett. At J J. Barrett,
- 11:37the worst the weather gets, the worst, the accuracy gets. Things
- 11:39get a little out of whack, and then of course you get to the
- 11:43postseason, and he had three of his five interceptions and one in the Big
- 11:48Ten Championship game, two in the in the playoff game. I'm not sure
- 11:52what happened with those interceptions after they were picked off. Nobody knows. It's
- 11:54a long time ago. Who could possibly remember, But he's a playmaker.
- 12:00One of the things that I and again this is this is all we are
- 12:03are both saying that it's Michigan here. But the more he threw the ball,
- 12:09the worst things got for Michigan. Essentially, he threw the ball more
- 12:13than twenty five times in five games. Rutgers was the only time that he
- 12:18did that, and it wasn't a seven point game in the fourth quarter.
- 12:24So like, if he's throwing the ball, that's not always a great thing.
- 12:28If if he's throwing the ball a bunch, that's not a great thing.
- 12:31That includes the Indiana game, which was a seven point game, but
- 12:35of course we that was that was the Mike Hart Caesar game. So everything
- 12:41that happened there is you know, you don't hold that against Michigan, but
- 12:46I think there there's there's this is Michigan. I'm interested to see how much
- 12:50better. J. J. McCarthy gets in terms of Ohio State time.
- 12:52As I said last week, it's going to be there will be some irony
- 12:58and some interest, a bunch of stories written if Ryan Day ends up choosing
- 13:03Devin Brown to start over Kyle McCord, as Devin Brown is kind of the
- 13:07J. J. McCarthy of that quarterback room, the the the big arm,
- 13:13loose cannon mobile guy compared to kym m accord. And of course Ryan
- 13:18Date chose Kyle McCord over j. J. McCarthy in recruiting, so there
- 13:22will be a little bit of a story there if they go with Devin Brown.
- 13:28Yeah, and I think you know we I think we're both sort of
- 13:31still leaning McCord over Brown in terms of who that's more likely to be.
- 13:37And you know, the McCord McCord McCarthy discourse is going to be probably lively
- 13:43throughout the year if those guys are If those guys are both the starting quarterbacks
- 13:48for Ohio State in Michigan, because Ohio State basically chose Kyle McCord over JJ
- 13:54McCarthy, that's just kind of they were in the same class and Ryan Day
- 14:01had both of them wanted to go to Ohio State and Ohio State said okay,
- 14:05you know J J. McCarthy, you know, let us let us
- 14:09think about it, let us sleep on it, basically, and then McCord
- 14:11ended up committing. So you're going to have the discourse around that, I
- 14:16do you know, I think this is probably way too soon. Last year
- 14:20there were lots of Michigan fans who couldn't wait to tell you that, you
- 14:22know, Ryan Day very clearly got it wrong because J J. McCarthy was
- 14:26good, and no one thought, you know, it wasn't like J J.
- 14:28McCarthy didn't have an offer from Ohio State. Ryan Day just thought McCord
- 14:31was a better fit for his offense. So this year is the year that
- 14:35we will potentially find that out. One thing that I think is a huge,
- 14:39huge, huge issue for Michigan potentially is so who's behind J J.
- 14:43McCarthy, Because Kate McNamara is currently on pace to score exactly twenty five point
- 14:48five points with Brian Ferns in Iowa. And the answer, Tony, do
- 14:52you know Davis Warren was one of the backups last year and he really did
- 14:56not do a whole heck of a lot. He was had a fifty six
- 14:58yeard pass against Hawaii and then was four for eight for thirty three yards otherwise,
- 15:01so not exactly a proven commodity there. Do you know who else is
- 15:05in the battle for the backup quarterback job at Michigan right now? I believe
- 15:09right now is at Jack Tuttle and Alex Orgy. Yes. And you know
- 15:13it sounds like from the reporting out of Michigan that Tuttle was maybe the most
- 15:16likely guy to push Davis Warren right now. And if Jack Tuttle's name sounds
- 15:22familiar, he was a quarterback at Indiana. I think the last time my
- 15:24host it was at at Indiana, Jack Tuttle was the quarterback. If you
- 15:28remember how that game went. If Jack Tuttle starting for Michigan this year,
- 15:31that's probably not great news. And the other thing you might know Jack Dottle
- 15:35four is he was another quarterback who Ryan Day was looking at at one point.
- 15:39He did not end up offering Jack Tuttle, but he did end up
- 15:43offering Jack Tuttle's high school wide receiver teammate, a gentleman by the name of
- 15:46Chris Alave. So ready I'm going to do my Paul Harvey. Now you
- 15:50know the rest of the story one other quick thing about the quarterbacks and the
- 15:58All Big Ten nature of which of these guys is going to be getting that
- 16:02awards. As we've said, you have to go back to just once since
- 16:06two thousand and twelve, has there've been an All Big Ten quarterback that didn't
- 16:10come from Ohio State? And that was twenty fifteen with Connor Cook. Do
- 16:14you know the last All Big Ten first Team All Big Ten quarterback for Michigan
- 16:18Tom Did Chad Henny win it? At some point like two thousand four,
- 16:26Chad Henny? Maybe? How about two thousand seven? Chad Henny was the
- 16:30last time the coaches named a Michigan quarterback first team two thousand and ten,
- 16:34Denard Robinson. The media named him named But that two thousand and seven,
- 16:40Chat, Honey, They that must have been well before the Ohio State game
- 16:44where he could no longer throw the football. Yeah, that was that was
- 16:47your Chad Henny. Shoulder was just torched, and I mean he did what
- 16:49he could, but man, that was not That was not a good Chad
- 16:53Henny season. That might have been a little bit of coasting on your coasting
- 16:59on your previous reputation because he you know, even as a true freshman in
- 17:03two thousand and four, might have been a red shirt freshman. I think
- 17:06he was a true freshman either. Either he and Mike Hart were. Yeah,
- 17:07he Mike Hard, I think we're true freshman in two thousand and four.
- 17:11They had a heck of a year that year. That would have been
- 17:14the year, you know, I mean he was very good in two thousand
- 17:17and six as well. Obviously, Yeah, two thousand and seven that might
- 17:19have been a little bit of lifetime Achievement award. But yeah, Denard Robinson
- 17:23as a Big Ten quarterback of the year, that's I mean, that's interesting.
- 17:27He was. He was great in that in that offense. It was
- 17:30two thousand and tens. That would have been the last year of rich Rod.
- 17:33I guess so. Yeah, I mean he was great in that offense
- 17:37and really dynamic. I just don't I just don't think him of him as
- 17:41a I don't think of him as a quarterback because you think of him as
- 17:45a you know, extremely efficient rich Rod running the ball quarterback. Have a
- 17:51quick quick one from from Brian Lager who says Alex Orgy is an absolute freak.
- 17:56He is one of the Michigan backup quarterbacks we have seen him a little
- 18:00bit in the ends of the ends of games in previous years, but not
- 18:06really any kind of meaningful snaps. And he's someone that you've sort of seen
- 18:10it floated that he might be in like the kick return picture maybe for them.
- 18:15So he's you know, when you when you look at him as a
- 18:18quarterback, he's you know, think about the quarterbacks who have been in the
- 18:21kick return picture for Ohio State, Like the last one who can think of
- 18:22was Troy Smith. I guess, right, So you know, I mean
- 18:26that's You've got to be a pretty good athlete to both be a quarterback and
- 18:30also in that in that role. Didn't they use him as a goal line
- 18:33quarterback at times last season? Am I remembering that? Right? I don't
- 18:37recall that, but yeah, that might that might be right. But yeah,
- 18:41I've heard of other people talk about Alex Georgie howe know, all of
- 18:45the athleticism is there and the arm obviously not a Joe Milton arm. I
- 18:49mean, nobody has the Joe Milton arm. We know that. But yeah,
- 18:53we'll get to see I'm sure we'll get to see him quite a few
- 18:56times this year. Let's move to running backs, tom where there is absolutely
- 19:02no doubt in my mind that Ohio State has overall the better running back room.
- 19:07However, this is a lot like Thermopoli, you know, where only
- 19:14one of those guys can carry it at the time, only one of those
- 19:15guys can fit the narrow path between the tackles essentially and carry the ball.
- 19:21I think O High States five running backs could all start at Ohio State and
- 19:25be thousand yard rushers, and from one end to the other, they're better
- 19:30than Michigan's depth. But how far down the well are you going? Like,
- 19:36how far down the depth chart are you going? And how often do
- 19:38you need to get to that third running back? Because if we're just talking
- 19:41about the top two, Trevian Henderson and Mind Williams are fantastic, but Blake
- 19:48Korum trumps everybody, and Donovan Edwards what he showed last year may eventually outshine
- 19:55Blake Krum right, maybe not maybe this year, who knows. But I
- 19:57think when you're talking about the who's going to be carrying the ball, I
- 20:03think that's what you weigh here. And for me, I'm gonna go Michigan
- 20:07because Blake corm when he's at his best, is really stinking good. And
- 20:11I think he, along with any all big ttro face, he should also
- 20:15have his name on two Joe Moore Awards. Yeah, and he's He's someone
- 20:19who is as solid of running back as they have had up there in a
- 20:25long long time. And Edwards too, Edwards is you know, I'm sure
- 20:30I don't need to explain to a podcast full of Ohio State fans what kind
- 20:33of a potential big play running back Donovid Edwards is. This is again a
- 20:38little bit like the quarterback spot, where you've got to look at what do
- 20:44you really know? Because I think there's a possibility that Ohio State ends the
- 20:49year ahead of Michigan in this spot, or at least even with Michigan in
- 20:52this spot, if you have a healthy Cravy and Henderson. We've talked about
- 20:56this before. All the stuff you are hearing about Trevy and Henderson this year
- 21:00is all the stuff you were hearing about JK. Dobbins in twenty nineteen when
- 21:04JK. Dobbins ended up running for two thousand yards. He's not JK.
- 21:08Trayvan Henderson is not going to run for two thousand yards this year. But
- 21:11that's because they're going to be dividing carries a little bit more than they did
- 21:15back in twenty nineteen. Mine, you know, I think he could.
- 21:18I think you could very easily have a twelve hundred yards out of Trevy and
- 21:22Henderson, seven hundred eight hundred yards out of May and Williams, three hundred
- 21:26four hundred yards out of someone else, whether that's Chip trainm Dalin Hayden,
- 21:33you know, is Evan Pryor does Evan Pryor end up being that third guy?
- 21:37The depth in the Ohio state running back room is unquestionably better than Michigan's.
- 21:42And I think a year from now, and this is I think,
- 21:45as we're talking about this, pay attention to how many of the guys we're
- 21:48talking about for Michigan are draft eligible, because boy howdy, is it a
- 21:52lot. And I think the tail of the tape at the running back room
- 21:55is probably going to look pretty different a year from now. But right now,
- 22:00I'm with you. I think you've got to go with the top two
- 22:03guys are going to be. You know, if your top two guys are
- 22:06both in the eight hundred to twelve hundred yard range or potentially much more than
- 22:10that, And it was much more than that for Michigan last year. You
- 22:12got to kind of look at the top two and being better at the fourth
- 22:15running back spot. Yeah, that's that's great, but that's not a deciding
- 22:19factor to me. Yeah, I still think Ohio States two guys will be
- 22:25in the eight hundred to twelve hundred range. But right now, the most
- 22:29proven guy is Blake Korn. Now, what happens if one of their two
- 22:33top guys go down and then that number three guy shoots up? Is at
- 22:37CJ. Stokes? I don't you know? Is he there? You know
- 22:40Kaleen Mullings. We know he can throw the ball, and we know he
- 22:44can do other things like that. But I think it would take somebody to
- 22:48one of those top two guys to be injured for Ohio States to take this.
- 22:51But I do think these are I think this is a lot closer than
- 22:56maybe some people think in terms of everybody loves Blake corm Donovan Edwards, don't
- 23:02don't sleep on what's going on at Ohio State receivers. Tim, Yeah,
- 23:07did you have something last left on the Running the super Chat? Yeah?
- 23:11Well the Super the Super Chat was just Brian the Garret real quick saying that
- 23:15Alex Orgy runs like both Scarborough which is probably a little bit of hyperbole,
- 23:19but you know not you know, he runs hard, Uh Scarborough, we
- 23:26can we can only hope, uh. The you know, as far as
- 23:30the running back rooms, let's see what a healthy travy On Henderson looks like.
- 23:33Let's see what a you know, healthy Miyan Williams looks like. Because
- 23:37you saw flashes from both of those guys, but they were both hurt so
- 23:41much last year. They really they really went through their depth at the running
- 23:45back room last year. So, you know, a healthy travy On Henderson
- 23:48and uh and Miyan Williams, I think they could out rush Blake Korum and
- 23:55Donovan Edwards. I think it's a possibility. I'm not necessary, I'm not
- 23:56predicting that, but I'm saying that's that's a possibility. So you know,
- 24:00the idea that this is like far and away Michigan, absolutely, you know
- 24:04it's Michigan, but I don't know that. I'm you know, I wouldn't
- 24:08say one hundred percent chance that it's Michigan at the end of the year too.
- 24:11One place I would say I am one hundred percent confident of where things
- 24:15are going to be at the end of the year, Tony. Speaking of
- 24:18transitions, let's talk about wide receivers. And this feels like this doesn't need
- 24:22to even be a particularly long conversation, even if we include the tight ends
- 24:25in here. Yeah, and we will include the tight ends here we Yeah,
- 24:32if you the question that I have for you, Tom, and we
- 24:34don't even need to go through all of the names. You know, courtne
- 24:37Elias Johnson, Roman Wilson are back from Michigan. Looks like maybe Tyler Morris
- 24:41is their news z. He caught like three passes last year as a true
- 24:44freshman, if I maybe three for twenty two, which is the exact same
- 24:49that Michael Thomas had his freshman year. But of course as a sophomore,
- 24:53Michael Thomas red shirted, so this comparison is no longer valid. Very different
- 24:57players anyway, But those three guys and Cornelis Johnson had a great game against
- 25:03Ohio State. He basically had the same numbers that Julian Fleming had last year.
- 25:07And Ohio State fans are almost like Julian Fleming. I wish you would
- 25:11just slide over so Carneal take and play. You know that that sort of
- 25:15thing where people are are ready for the new thing, and Julian Fleming healthy
- 25:18this year should be in line for an even better year. But given who
- 25:25Michigan has at receiver, how many Ohio State receivers would start at Michigan this
- 25:30year? Boy? Are they're in a three let's say, or whether they
- 25:36in a three wide receiver set? Yeah? Yeah, Okay, So you
- 25:38got Cornelius Johnson, you got Roman Wilson, no more Ronnie Bell That that's
- 25:44going to hurt a little bit losing him. It sounds like Tyler Morris might
- 25:48be the next guy up there. Darius Clemens maybe like he's been banged up.
- 25:51I think a little term camp. So yeah, boy over Cornelius Johnson,
- 25:56Roman Wilson and let's say Tyler Morris. I've got Marvin Harrison Junior.
- 26:00I've got a Mecca Abuca, I've got Julian Fleming. I think I'm probably
- 26:07going to put Xavier Johnson in there. I'm probably gonna put Carnell Tate in
- 26:12the I mean, I think you're probably at least five guys, and then
- 26:17you know you're getting down to Jaden Ballard and guys like that, who you
- 26:21know, maybe where we're you know, maybe maybe maybe not but there's just
- 26:29there's not it's not a proven commodity yet, and that you don't have the
- 26:33people talking about them the way that they're talking about Cardinal Tate, and just
- 26:37you know, I'm sure there's a decent sized Michigan audience on this one as
- 26:40well. So in case you missed it last week, Marvin Harrison Junior was
- 26:42talking on Tuesday, last week, last last week, last Tuesday night after
- 26:47practice and said, very frankly, Cardinal Tate, who is a true freshman
- 26:52artistiver for Ohio State this year, is ahead of where Harrison was a year
- 26:59ago. And he said, do you mean two years ago when you're a
- 27:02freshman. He's like, no, this time last year. So that seems
- 27:07you know, you never this is a this is a great time of year
- 27:11for everyone to be very you know, happy talking everything and everyone's great and
- 27:14everything is awesome as the as the song goes. But that feels like you
- 27:19don't say that unless you mean it. And if they have a fourth wide
- 27:23receiver, you know, if the fourth or fifth wide receiver at Ohio State
- 27:26is in that kind of neighborhood, like oh boy, you know, no
- 27:32offense, we all saw what Michigan's did in the passing game against Ohio State
- 27:34last year, but you know they haven't done that very consistently. So yeah,
- 27:38I don't feel like this is a particularly long conversation. Yeah, I
- 27:44think you can even throw Jayden ballardin as a z over over Tyler Morris,
- 27:48and I would just ask you have a question. How many Michigan receivers would
- 27:52start for Ohio State? Tom uh mister Blue Tarski zero point zero. I
- 27:57mean, and you know there are guys who are probably in the rotation,
- 28:02but I don't you know, I don't think you're going to have too many
- 28:04Michigan fans going no, no, no, no no no. Marvin Harrison
- 28:07Junior and ameca Abuka would definitely sit the bench in an arbor. Absolutely.
- 28:14Yeah. I just this feels like this is a pretty easy one, you
- 28:18know, for me. Super chat from Jordan Kapler. If you are the
- 28:21OSU quarterback, what would be your win loss record? You must have a
- 28:25minimum of twenty pass attempts. To help you, I'll give you an offensive
- 28:27line of all Orlando paces. You know what, I can throw a bunch
- 28:33of fifty fifty balls with Orlando paces. But also, yeah, so twenty
- 28:38fifty fifty balls, and honestly, if you have all Orlando paces, you
- 28:42could just throw all of those passes into the sideline, out of bounds,
- 28:48into the ground. You can go over twenty every game and you're gonna be
- 28:51okay with that running game. Now, Tom, you do need to be
- 28:53able to keep the line to keep the defense from crowding and just expecting the
- 28:59round. So you do need throw downfield sometimes. But as long as those
- 29:02balls go out of out of bounds and nobody's in danger of intercepting them,
- 29:04I think you're gonna be okay. I think you just got to find yourself.
- 29:07I mean, if we're going back to the nineties for Orlando pace,
- 29:10I think we're going back to the nineties and find me up, find me
- 29:14and Michael Wiley who I can hand the ball to, and you can throw
- 29:15the ball downfield for me. I think that's I think that's my game plan.
- 29:19And you got to go east west a little bit, and you know,
- 29:22jet jet motion and that kind of stuff, you can you can use
- 29:25the whole field. That's I think that's I think that's where you know.
- 29:30I mean, it worked for Dwayne Haskins, those little those little pop passes
- 29:33and you know the ball goes forward, you know, six inches in the
- 29:37air and then you get a seventy yard touchdown out of it. So I
- 29:40can do that, I think the real I think the real question is behind
- 29:41an offensive line of Orlando paces, could I get a Heisman invitation? And
- 29:47the answer is maybe. I think the actual answer on this is, you
- 29:52know, you go through the Ohio State schedule, I feel like I'm Bowl
- 29:55eligible. You know, like you're you're winning, You're You're you're winning Youngstown
- 30:00State, You're winning Western, I mean Tucky, You're beating Rutgers, you're
- 30:04beating Indiana. Like just the talent around you is so good and the defense
- 30:08is going to be good enough that the defense is probably I mean this is
- 30:12this is basically what Iowa did last year. So they went to a ball
- 30:15game. So can you be Spencer Petris more even more than I even more
- 30:22than I'd want to? Yes? Yes, And then of course you know
- 30:29tight ends part of that receiver group. But obviously Michigan has two good ones
- 30:33coast and level in a J Barner. Ohio State has caged over so but
- 30:38overall as a group, you're not touching anything that Ohio State is doing with
- 30:44that time with the offensive line. Let me explore the room on this one
- 30:48for you for a minute, because on one hand, you've got a team
- 30:52that brings back a pair of talented guards but had to go into the portal
- 30:57looking for a left tackle, a center. There's questions about what's going on
- 31:03at right tackle and the left tackle that they went out west to get didn't
- 31:08play there last year. But then you also have Ohio State. These are
- 31:14the same teams. It's it's amazing, it is amazing, and you know,
- 31:18I think you've got to look at where they started. You know,
- 31:23you're feeling really good about both guard positions. Ohio State Donovan Jackson, Matt
- 31:27Jones. Michigan You've got Zach Zenter, You've got Trevor Keagan. Like those
- 31:30are four just rock solid, great guard spots you've got. You know,
- 31:37Drake Nugent is probably the starter at center. You get Hinton and Jones at
- 31:42the right, at the right tackle spot, Ladarius Henderson, maybe Carson Barnhart
- 31:48at the left tackle spot. And you know, I think Michigan is it
- 31:52feels like the reports out of Michigan camp are less certain than the reports out
- 31:56of Ohio State camp. Like, I think we kind of know who states
- 32:00starters are, and I think that's probably partly a function of we know because
- 32:05we know, and partly a function of you know, Michigan is basically like
- 32:10the Soviet Union in the nineteen seventies in terms of operational secrecy. You know,
- 32:15they call it Fort Schembeckler up there, and it's you know, you
- 32:19can, you can every once in a while get some information out, but
- 32:22you know, how how trustworthy is the information? How much are your people
- 32:25just kind of getting gassed up, Like, I don't know. One thing
- 32:30that I thought was really interesting looking at the offensive line was there were reports
- 32:35that I read about the interior of the Michigan defensive line really holding its own
- 32:40or doing pretty well against the interior of the Michigan offensive line. Which you
- 32:45know, you can look at that and say, well, they've got both
- 32:47of their guards back, so that's probably great news for the interior of the
- 32:51Michigan defensive line. Or you can say, well, they've got a new
- 32:53center, and sometimes if the new center is a little shaky, that might
- 32:58be a little bit of concern. On this one, I'm giving it to
- 33:01Michigan just based on last year. I mean, two years in a row
- 33:07they've won the Joe Moore Award, So you kind of you know, this
- 33:09is not a sure thing for Ohio State by any means this year, But
- 33:14this is one that I think is maybe closer than you'd think. I think
- 33:16if you go back and watch last year's tablet tape show, I think I
- 33:20basically said Michigan next, Like it wasn't It wasn't much of a conversation.
- 33:24This year, I think the Michigan offensive line is going to be good,
- 33:29but they might take a little bit of a step back. And then boy,
- 33:31Tony, they've got a lot of upperclassmen in that line this year too.
- 33:36And you know, I mean there's another team in the state of Michigan
- 33:39has tried to kind of rebuild itself to the transfer portal, and sometimes it
- 33:43works and sometimes it doesn't. The more I looked at this tomorrow is like,
- 33:46this is gonna be pretty good Michigan team. Boy, I wonder what
- 33:49the twenty twenty four Michigan team is going to look like, because it's going
- 33:52to be different. Yeah it is, and they'll just go get I don't
- 33:57know, four or five offensive linemen out of the portal. But the assumption
- 34:01here is that I'll go with Michigan as well. But it is an assumption.
- 34:06And if they hadn't won a Joe Moore Award the last two years and
- 34:08put everything together and brought everything together, you're looking at a team still trying
- 34:13to figure out who their two tackles are and they've got four guys that they
- 34:16think can do it. It's just it's a lot of a lot of options
- 34:22or a lot of possibilities, but where's the solidification, the solidification of who
- 34:28those guys are and Tom, if you have four tackles, do you have
- 34:30two? That sort of thing. And so I think I'm not going to
- 34:35make the argument for Ohio State. I think it can be made, but
- 34:37you go with the assumption right now, because again, as I've said,
- 34:40as we've said about Ohio State's offensive line, right now, they're going to
- 34:44be starting a left tackle who has never played a position and last year was
- 34:46a right tackle at San Diego State. Center is probably a redshirt freshman.
- 34:52Right tackle is Josh Friar, first time starter who has done well in spurts,
- 34:57but it's still he is the least unknown of the knowns, so I
- 35:01guess the most known of the unknowns, but it's still a question mark.
- 35:05So, but you're right, the momentum and the encouragement, the excitement coming
- 35:12from Ohio State about their offensive line is up here. The way you hear
- 35:16people say talking about Michigan, it's down here in terms of they expected more
- 35:22than I think they're getting. But we can all go ahead and assume Michigan
- 35:25will figure this out because they have, right, they have plenty of times
- 35:30in the past, and so you just sort of it's a little bit like
- 35:32Ohio State with quarterbacks, where it's Ryan Day, it's a five star quarterback.
- 35:37Whichever of the two guys, it is like, it'll probably be fine.
- 35:40That's kind of where I'm with Michigan. It's closer again, I'm picking
- 35:45Michigan. I know there are people calling us, you know, sunshine pumpers
- 35:50for Ohio State in the comments, and it's like, you must have just
- 35:52joined us because we've said Michigan a lot already, and that's on the offensive
- 35:55side of the ball. So you know, I do. I think there
- 35:59are questions this is probably a little bit of a step back from Michigan's offensive
- 36:02line from a year ago, two years ago. You know, it's entirely
- 36:07possible they don't win the Joe Moore Award this year. That's that's my saying.
- 36:10That's that's the extent of my hot takeness here. Brandon Garret says,
- 36:15Michigan right tackle as a starter last year and he started like half of the
- 36:19games, right am I remembering that, right? Yeah? And then was
- 36:21one of the best centers in the country last year. So yeah, I
- 36:23mean this is again, this is no one is saying this is going to
- 36:25be a terrible Michigan offensive line, but there's a big gap between where Michigan's
- 36:31offensive lines have been in the past and you know what the floor of this
- 36:36year's offensive line could be. I will say Drake Nugent, a two time
- 36:40Honorable Mention All Pack twelve player, and that's it. So one of the
- 36:46best centers in the country. I mean, it was was centered deep into
- 36:50Pack twelve last year. And I'm not putting any weight on a media vote
- 36:53because I've done it before. It's usually the coach's vote that carries more weight
- 36:59and me but you know, you just mentioned the difficulty that Michigan's interior offensive
- 37:05line is having So I think calling him one of the best centers in the
- 37:08country is the sunshine pumping in this conversation. Yeah, and it's you know,
- 37:15I mean, it's think he might yeah, he might be, but
- 37:17you know again, Ka McCord might go to the heisman ceremony or Devin Brown
- 37:22might go to the heisman ceremony. He might, but we're not picking them
- 37:25because we haven't seen it yet. So it's kind of okay, let's let's
- 37:30see it and then don't worry. We'll do the show again the week before
- 37:31the Odhi State Michigan game, and then we'll have a lot more data and
- 37:35we'll be able to give you much. You know, sometimes the answers end
- 37:37up being very different by the time we get there than when we're here.
- 37:42Brian says that Barnhart was a starter. He didn't split time last year,
- 37:45so all right, so there you go. So, yeah, it's it's
- 37:49a you know, I mean, I think this is going to be a
- 37:51good Michigan offensive line, but I I don't think. Might take a step
- 37:54back is exactly a hot take file, you know, in the same way
- 37:59that Ohio State might take a step back at quarterback after two years of CJ.
- 38:05Strap, Like, that's a possibility. Not guaranteeing it, but it's
- 38:07possibility. Barnhart started the second half of last year. Trent A. Jones
- 38:14started the first half. Just an FYI based on my Phil Steel start chart.
- 38:19All right, I thought I thought I remembered that, right, Yeah,
- 38:21I thought they because they had some injuries and split some stuff up.
- 38:24So yeah, yeah, okay, Tony, let's talk defense. What I'm
- 38:28sure Ohio State fans can't wait. Yeah, let's start with the defensive line
- 38:31and the way we're going to do this with Michigan's defense. Let's just consider
- 38:36both teams running a four two five, and so Michigan does their two interior
- 38:43too, you know, two edge and one of the edges as an outside
- 38:45linebacker. Everybody's everybody's a defensive end or a defensive tackle here. So for
- 38:51me, if you look at what's coming back, just to compare the tube
- 38:55two sides, Michigan is returning twelve sacks from the defensive line. O High
- 39:00States returning fifteen sacks. Michigan is returning twenty tackles for loss from the defensive
- 39:06line. Michigan. Ohio State is returning thirty one and a half. I
- 39:10think the Ohio State side of this, you have potential all Americans on the
- 39:15interior and Mike Hall if he can stay healthy. I don't know how many
- 39:21Michigan fans really know about him. He was injured for much of last year,
- 39:24but when he was healthy, he was outstanding. Tyleek Williams another defensive
- 39:30tackle next to him as solid potential, and of course defensive ends JT.
- 39:35Timolo, while Jack Sawyer, Kenyatta Jackson and as part of the depth and
- 39:40King Curry. The depth of the Ohio State defensive line, as we've said
- 39:44for every year we've done this, is always greater than Michigan's and I think
- 39:51that holds true once again. And I do like a lot of Michigan's pieces.
- 39:55Like Mason Graham last year was a fantastic true freshman defensive tackles pressive obviously,
- 40:00Chris Jenkins on the inside is really good as well. Brad McGregor and
- 40:07Derek Mora has had some good moments. I'll be interested to see what Josiah
- 40:12Stewart to transfer from Coast to Carolina can do. So they've got some good
- 40:15pieces, but honestly has great pieces. Yeah, you know, let's just
- 40:22look at where are we expecting these guys to get drafted this time next year.
- 40:25I mean, you talked about the returning production numbers and they all favor
- 40:29Ohio State. I don't think Michigan's got anyone who's gonna get picked ahead of
- 40:32JT. Twemloaw. I don't think. I mean, Michigan has some really
- 40:37good players, especially into the line. Chris Jenkins is real good. Mason
- 40:43Graham was very impressive last year. I don't think they have anyone with the
- 40:46ceiling of Mike Hall. I mean, for Michigan fans who might not know
- 40:51this, Mike Hall had what was it four sacks or four tackles for loss
- 40:55in seven snaps against Michigan State, and he was banged up and missed,
- 41:00you missed most of the game, and still was that kind of impactful there
- 41:07is. I think this is a Ohio State This is a generational Ohio State
- 41:12defensive line class. This is the class of twenty twenty one where you had
- 41:15Jackson Ry, you had J. T. Twe moloil pair of five star
- 41:16edge rushers, you had Mike Hall, you had tay Leak Williams, you
- 41:22got Ty Hamilton in there. You got a transfer in Taiwan Malone from Ole
- 41:24Miss who's going to be, you know, not necessarily a starter, but
- 41:28a very valuable rotational piece there. I think the top end for Ohio State
- 41:32is probably at Michigan's level or higher, and the depth is probably better at
- 41:37Ohio State. So I am going to go with Ohio State on the defensive
- 41:40line. Yeah, I would agree there, And honestly, I don't know
- 41:44how much more time we need to spend on that in the depth. You
- 41:46know, Michigan Kenneth Grant on a defensive tackle, Ray Shawn Benny still waiting
- 41:52for these guys to do something. They could do it this year. But
- 41:55I'll take Ohio State there on a defensive line linebackers, go ahead, Tom.
- 42:01I'm just looking at the comments and it's amazing how our intelligence or stupidity
- 42:07seems to swing depending on who we pick at any individual, any individual position
- 42:12group. We have gotten substantially smarter with Ohio State fans recently, and substantially
- 42:15dumber with Michigan fans. So I can't wait to see where were this all
- 42:19heads next. And I was going to wear a yellow shirt for this show,
- 42:22but I didn't know if that would be super bad or super good.
- 42:27So let's go with the linebackers. And again these teams basically playing two linebackers.
- 42:34We put Jayleen Harrold with the defensive ends, the whole thing with Michigan,
- 42:37and still wasn't enough for the Wolverines linebacker. Again, you've got Ohio
- 42:42State returning second team All American Tommy Eikeerberg. That's third year starter essentially in
- 42:46Steel Chamber, started towards the second half of the twenty one season, started
- 42:51all year last year. Cody Simon, who has started about eight or ten
- 42:57games in his career as a number three linebacker, the number four linebacker CJ.
- 43:00Hicks, who was the number one linebacker recruit in the twenty twenty two
- 43:05class. And you compare that to Michigan with Junior Colson the middle linebacker very
- 43:10good, Michael Barrett pretty good. The interesting guy there is going to be
- 43:15I think Ernest Houseman, the sophomore transfer from Nebraska. It's a good trio
- 43:21there. And Jimmy Roller. We saw him a little bit last year as
- 43:22a true freshman. But I'm still I'm still gonna go with the I think
- 43:28Tommy Eikenberg Steel Chambers are better, more productive than there are two counterparts,
- 43:36and I know everybody loves Junior Coulson, Tommy Eikenberg. I don't know.
- 43:39I had maybe forty or fifty more tackles. Yes, o High State was
- 43:43on the field, probably more defensively than than Michigan was, So yeah,
- 43:46you're gonna have more tackles. But you know, I'll take the I'll take
- 43:51the all American and right Ohio States linebacker group here in this one. Yeah,
- 43:57it seems like the top of Ohio States linebacker group is way better.
- 44:00This is one where the depth for Michigan, you know, it's probably not
- 44:02quite what it is for Ohio State, and the top for Ohio State,
- 44:07I think is better. Which you know, I think if you ask people
- 44:09beforehand, where are they going to pick, you know, just without thinking
- 44:12anything, where are they going to pick Ohio State to have the advantage.
- 44:15It's going to be all in the offense, and Michigan's gonna be all on
- 44:16the defense. And here we are and where two units in on the defense
- 44:19and Ohio State's gotten both of them, but Michigan got three or four on
- 44:21offense. So what a time to be alive? As I guess My big
- 44:24takeaway there it is, you know, this is this is one of these
- 44:28things where we're going to be talking when we talk about depth of a lot
- 44:30of these spots. And this is not specifically linebackers, this is kind of
- 44:32everywhere Ohio State. When you look at the recruiting rankings year over year,
- 44:37Ohio State is just every year ahead of Michigan. Ohio State is every year
- 44:40recruiting in the Alabama Georgia realm of the rankings, and Michigan is sometimes in
- 44:47the you know, six to eight range and sometimes in the eighteen and twenty
- 44:51three kind of range. And for whatever reason, and coach who's constantly batting
- 44:57his eyes at the NFL probably has something to do with this, Michigan has
- 45:00just not been able to capitalize. And for years and years and years,
- 45:02it was always, well, Michigan, everyone else is paying the players,
- 45:06and we're to a pure and YadA YadA YadA, and okay, now you
- 45:08can pay the players, and it still hasn't happened. So, you know,
- 45:12I think there's when you're when we are talking about the depth, it's
- 45:15because Ohio State has been bringing in consistently better classes overall, which means there's
- 45:20just you know that one or two extra good players in the class that adds
- 45:24up over time. And you look at the class of twenty twenty four.
- 45:28Someone sent me seving today and the top six players in terms of rankings are,
- 45:32you know, for Ohio State and Michigan combined are all Ohio State and
- 45:37three of them are on defense, including two defensive linemen and a cornerback.
- 45:40So you know, it's not just quarterbacks and wide receivers for Ohio State and
- 45:44recruiting. They've just they've consistently been recruiting better than Michigan over the years,
- 45:47and even though Michigan has won two years in a row, that gap hasn't
- 45:52really closed. And so at some point, you know, that's that's one
- 45:55of those things that at some point does catch back up with you. Yeah,
- 46:01it's just been the situation with Michigan four years as the depth and when
- 46:07you're recruiting the in the seven hundreds, you're gonna be missing out on a
- 46:12lot of those guys and then having to process process them, replace them with
- 46:15transfers, or or not replace them at all and just stay thin until they're
- 46:20gone. And so we've seen that all over the defense for Michigan through the
- 46:24years. Time, let's move to uh we we we both went linebacker or
- 46:30Ohio State there? Right? Is that correct? Yes? We did?
- 46:32Yes, So let's move to corner now and we'll separate corner and safeties and
- 46:37we'll put the nickel in with the safeties. Will Johnson, I think we
- 46:45both are very high on him. Denzel Burken, Ohio State, Jordan Hancock,
- 46:52Davidson, Nigma Nosen. They've got three there. I've seen stuff about
- 46:55maybe Mike Singer still being a starting corner and then on path on passing downs
- 47:00moving to nicol. But where are you on the Michigan corners compared to Ohio
- 47:05State. Well, I was reading this this week in the last week or
- 47:09so, that they want to Hardball has said he wants to play, saying
- 47:12we're still in the slot. Now. Does that mean that they are never
- 47:15going to play him outside? I don't know, but I think his preference
- 47:17would need to play him outside. The question is who is that second corner
- 47:22for Michigan. Because Will Johnson is Will Johnson is Will Johnson, and he
- 47:24is a five star and Ohio State wanted him very much, and he went
- 47:28to Michigan and he has lived up to the hype and so you know,
- 47:31set him aside. Okay, Will Johnson is a sure thing on one side
- 47:35of the field. The other side of the field is kind of question Mark.
- 47:38It's got I mean Murray and Walker sounds like he's been banged up a
- 47:40little during fall camp. The other guy, Josh Wallace, who's kind of
- 47:45in the running for that is they transfer from you mass, which is like,
- 47:47maybe maybe there's not a real sure thing on the other side. And
- 47:55if it's saying we're still, it's saying we're still. But then that's gonna
- 47:59you know, move, you know, that's going to create issues. Then
- 48:00when we have the safety conversation, I'm for the purposes of this conversation taking
- 48:06Jim Harbaugh's word that he wants to put Sandrastill in the slot, and so
- 48:08we're going to include him with the with the safeties, and I think Will
- 48:15Johnson and question Mark is probably going to fall behind Denzel Burke and Jordan Hancock
- 48:22and Davis Nicknossen and jayar Brown. I mean, this is an Ohio State
- 48:25corner room that was decimated by crappy recruiting a few years ago and then decimated
- 48:30by injuries last year. This year, they're deep, they're talented, They've
- 48:37every report we've gotten, everything we've seen has been this is a really good
- 48:40corner room. They're getting their hands on footballs, they're making plays. This
- 48:45is This feels like this might be the best Ohio State cornerback room since twenty
- 48:50nineteen at least, and that was the year they had Jeff Okuda, Sean
- 48:53Wade. I think this is I think even with Will Johnson, and Will
- 48:58Johnson might very well be the number an overall draft pick of any of these
- 49:00corners. But I think you're probably you know, number one is Will Johnson,
- 49:05and then picks two, three, maybe four, maybe five or all
- 49:09from Ohio States. So I'm gonna I'm gonna go with the you know,
- 49:14with the quality of depth here and go with Ohio State. Yeah, I
- 49:16don't I would agree. I don't think it's outrageous to think four of Ohio
- 49:21States corners start at Michigan this year, next to Will Johnson. Honestly like
- 49:25it could be any of the top three you mentioned in Jaire Brown as well.
- 49:30You throw any of those guys in there, and they're more known than
- 49:34what else Michigan has so we'll go ahead and as expected, just continue this
- 49:39clean sweep for the Ohio State defense, which as everybody knows, but we
- 49:45talked before the show like this is going to go away that people aren't expecting,
- 49:50and it's a way that is counterintuitive to how you think the seasons and
- 49:54how we both expect the seasons to go. But that's what happens when you
- 49:59just look at individually. Safety though this time for me is very interesting.
- 50:05I'll let you go first. I'll let you go. Well, Michigan just
- 50:07feels like you kind of know what you got there. It's Rod Moore,
- 50:10it's mccari page. We're putting Mike Sanders still, we're lumping him in there,
- 50:15like those are three really good, solid players Ohio State has. You
- 50:20know, I'm going to say sunny styles naw him and every Ohio State fans
- 50:22going to go oh and start clapping their hands. But you know, this
- 50:25is Lathan Ransom who's been good. It is Jahad Carter. Sounds like it's
- 50:31he's going to be the free safety right now. And that's a transfer from
- 50:35Syracuse, and I think that's you know, I don't have a super super
- 50:39super high level of confidence that He's definitely going to be incredible. He might
- 50:44be fine, he might be good, but I kind of want to see
- 50:46it. Lathan Ransom should be fine. Sunny Styles is going to be in
- 50:51that kind of nickel role, and I think is going to be really dynamic,
- 50:54But again, I kind of want to see it. I want to
- 50:57see can he track with a slot receiver, you know, running across the
- 51:01middle? Can he know? Can he hold up against all the different things
- 51:05he's going to be asked to do? And there's lots of happy talk out
- 51:08of Ohio State about how, yeah, absolutely can and Okay, maybe we'll
- 51:13see I just you know, this is another one of these I want to
- 51:16see it. So I'm going to go with Michigan because I feel like you
- 51:20kind of know what you got there with all three of their safety spots,
- 51:23and you don't necessarily completely know. Maybe a higher ceiling but lower floor for
- 51:30Ohio State. Yeah, I would agree with that. I think Mike Singer
- 51:35still was well beyond anything I could have imagined that or really anybody should have
- 51:39imagined last year after moving from receiver to nicol And I would not move him
- 51:45from that spot. I would keep him there and let him do exactly what
- 51:47he did last year and maybe add to it. And yes, he's probably
- 51:52the team's best pass rusher as well, so go ahead and have him do
- 51:54things there as well. But he was fantastic. And I really like Rod
- 52:00Moore has always been around the football. He finds the football. Karie Page
- 52:06is a bigger dude. I think it's it's an interesting comparison when you're talking
- 52:12about Mike sander Still and his counterpart on the High State defense is Stunny Styles.
- 52:17So you got this, you know, five ten, five eleven guy
- 52:21and his six four, two hundred and thirty pound guy, and they play
- 52:23the same position, and they'll do actually they they'll do all of the same
- 52:30pass rushing, they'll do some coverage, they'll do uh some very similar things
- 52:35despite looking very different. And I expect this to be Lathan Ransom's best season
- 52:42strong safety for Ohio State. But I'm with you. The three safeties from
- 52:46Michigan, you just know more. And honestly, I don't even care who's
- 52:51behind them. I don't even know who is behind them. You know,
- 52:52it didn't really go that deep with those ideas because they're so reliable there.
- 52:58You just they're there and they're he's present, and Ohio state safety situation has
- 53:04not necessarily been that way. And you know they've they've had some injuries that
- 53:07they've both had to deal with that they've all had to deal with. I
- 53:12do think, as you said, the ceiling is really high for the Ohio
- 53:15State safeties if everything breaks the right way, or if they make it break
- 53:20the right way, but for right now August twenty seven, Yeah, I'm
- 53:24gonna go ahead and side with Michigan on this one, and most especially because
- 53:30we couldn't just do an Ohio state clean sweeping on the defense. But I
- 53:32do really like the Michigan safeties well. And there's a comment here that the
- 53:36Rod Moore disrespect is astounding, and like maybe maybe I blacked out and don't
- 53:40remember what I said, but I seem to recall saying that I was picking
- 53:44Michigan and Tonty was picking Michigan and they were the safeties are pretty much a
- 53:47sure thing, like I feel perhaps there was the comments, perhaps in the
- 53:52comments, maybe he's getting some but not from us. He's great, Yeah,
- 53:54not from us, all right, super tap market, but he treasure
- 53:59the tour. Thank you as always. What's up, Tom? And Tony
- 54:00Ge just really hope the chemistry is there with the offense and it shows they've
- 54:05got really good chemistry. They're going to kick some tail this year. And
- 54:07on offense, yeah, I mean, chemistry on the offensive line is probably,
- 54:15you know, my biggest thing. I feel like the quarterback wide receiver
- 54:16chemistry is probably going to be fine. I mean where what element of chemistry
- 54:23on the offense do you think is maybe the biggest deciding factor for Ohio State
- 54:28this year? I think the chemistry between the quarterback and the clock in his
- 54:31head, that sort of thing that the timing, the feeling, the rush,
- 54:36that sort of thing where it's just natural things move well and it doesn't
- 54:42look like there's they're hearing seeing ghosts and hearing some knocking noises and things like
- 54:47that. Defensively, the chemistry between the defensive line and everybody else, that
- 54:52sort of thing where they're focused on stopping the run so the rest of the
- 54:55defense can be focused on doing their thing as well. That chemistry will be
- 55:00huge. But offensively, I think until we see otherwise, I'm going to
- 55:05an expectant of Ryan Day offenses to score forty points a game and to throw
- 55:08forty five hundred yards and all that good stuff, all right, and we're
- 55:15going to get to some questions in a minute, So if you have questions,
- 55:17please go ahead and throw those in the comments. We'll take a little
- 55:20time and run through some of this stuff we figured we might you know,
- 55:22well, we'll get through the tail of tape in thirty minutes or so,
- 55:25and then we'll thank you doucing questions for a little bit. And here we
- 55:28are fifty five minutes in so, right on time as always. But and
- 55:31also if you can take a time, take a second on YouTube and hit
- 55:35the thumbs up button that helps other folks find these shows. I don't really
- 55:37understand how. It doesn't matter, they just take They just say that's how
- 55:42it works. So therefore it would help us if you do that. And
- 55:45we're gonna be doing a bunch of live shows this week and then coming up
- 55:47this weekend live postgame show after Ohio State Indians, So make sure you were
- 55:52subscribed to our channel on YouTube and hit the bells you get notified when we
- 55:55do these live shows, because sometimes we have lots of notice. Notice we
- 56:00did today, and sometimes it's kind of you know, especially the end of
- 56:02a you know, postgame show is going to be kind of end of the
- 56:05game, but a lot of these, you know, a lot of these
- 56:07road trip weekends, we will end up just kind of doing spontaneous live stuff.
- 56:10So make sure you were subscribed to our YouTube channel and also consider subscribing
- 56:15to bucke Huddle dot com. Well said, Tom, let's move to special
- 56:21teams because this is an area where a ton of changes for Michigan losing both
- 56:25their kicker and their punter. They do bring in James Turner from Louisville,
- 56:30I believe, who has been like a three year starter, four year starter
- 56:32essentially, and I think he's got a COVID year that he's using this year.
- 56:37Punter Tommy doman kick returner, you know, I mean when you're talking
- 56:40about putting a quarterback there, you know you don't, you know, you're
- 56:44not really solid there. We'll see what they do at punt return. But
- 56:49I think for me, I'm going Ohio State here, even not knowing who
- 56:52the kicker is going to be. If it's Parker Lewis, he's been an
- 56:54established starter at USC. If it isn't, then that guy beat out and
- 56:59established starter from USC. Hunter from Australia I don't think we need to go
- 57:05any further than that. The return game at this point, I don't even
- 57:09know what what kind of a factor it is anymore for most teams because they're
- 57:13not trying to do anything with the return games. So I'm going to protest
- 57:16by not even ranking it. I am going to go with Ohio State here,
- 57:22just because Michigan's replacing both their kicker and their punter. And you know,
- 57:25I mean the same people who were in the comments last year telling us
- 57:30about how Jake Moody was the greatest weapon in the history of football, and
- 57:36you know, we would be idiots that even consider not picking Michigan on that
- 57:38one. Are now going to be telling me, oh, no, James
- 57:40Turner, he kicked at Louisville, so he's fine. It'll be a real
- 57:44smooth transition. Like maybe Jake Moody was four or for four or better three
- 57:50times in twenty twenty two, and those were not you know, this was
- 57:53not doing that against Hawaii. That was not doing that against who do they
- 57:58play last year, Yukon. This was Penn State, Michigan State, Illinois.
- 58:01And the Michigan State game wasn't super close, but it was close.
- 58:05For a while, and that was because they were kicking a bunch of field
- 58:07goals. But Penn State Illinois, you know, Penn State, they were
- 58:10i think trailing nearly in the third quarter or at halftime something like that,
- 58:14and Illinois was a close game throughout, and so they were really leaning on
- 58:19Moody to be able to make field goals. Maybe Turner is at that level,
- 58:24maybe, but maybe not. And Brad Robbins was twenty do you know
- 58:30the first season that Brad Robins was a punter at Michigan, it was like
- 58:35twenty seventeen or so, twenty sixteen, twenty seventeen. Yeah, Brad Robbins
- 58:40punted in a game twice or he was on Michigan's roster twice against Urban Meyer.
- 58:46Yes, it has been a minute. He punted in a game that
- 58:51JT. Barrett played in. Uh, yeah, it is a you know,
- 58:54those are those are big losses for Michigan and maybe they pick up,
- 59:00you know, maybe they just pick up right where they left off. But
- 59:01those were two guys who were very good, very consistent players from Michigan.
- 59:07And that's not just it's not just automatic. It feels automatic when you got
- 59:09guys like that. Who have been around forever Moody. I think Moody's career
- 59:13started in twenty eighteen or something like that. Those guys were just there four
- 59:15ever, and it is not always automatic. Just task Ohio State fans.
- 59:22So now we go to the final tail of the check on the tail of
- 59:28the tape, which is the head coach. Tom. If we're just talking
- 59:32about week one, or are week two or a week three, I think
- 59:37you got to give the advantage to Ryan Day. But it kind of depends
- 59:40on which week because you know, Sharon Moore, maybe Jay Harbaugh, I
- 59:45don't know, but that's only half a week, which yeah, yeah,
- 59:49it's this is one where I think when we start. You know, when
- 59:53we were doing this in twenty eighteen, I think we probably said hardball because
- 59:59you didn't have any or twenty nineteen, twenty eighteen, we definitely had sent
- 1:00:01urban Meyer. Twenty nineteen you probably said Harball. Twenty and twenty you said
- 1:00:06Ryan Day, twenty one you said Ryan Day, and then I don't remember
- 1:00:09what we said last year. But this year, Jim Harball has beaten Ryan
- 1:00:13Day two years in a row, So okay, it's Jim Harbaugh until Ryan
- 1:00:16Day beats Jim Harball. And there's a lot of areas where Ryan Day I
- 1:00:20think is ahead of Jim Harball. But on the field is the one that
- 1:00:23really counts, and he has been behind Jim Harball for a couple of years
- 1:00:27in a row. So I think you pretty much have to go with Harball
- 1:00:29here, right, Yeah, No, I agree, he's he's ahead of
- 1:00:31Jim Harbaugh in a lot of ways, just not on the scoreboard. And
- 1:00:36so that's the one that matters most. And so yes, I think you
- 1:00:38have to go Jim Harbaugh here. And who knows what it will be next
- 1:00:42year, but right now you can only go Harbaugh for Michigan. And even
- 1:00:46that's just a seventy five to eighty five percent Harball, you know, because
- 1:00:52he's not going to be there for every game. So Tom has I tally
- 1:00:55these up? We did. We did ten categories. It ended up five
- 1:01:02five. It ended up five five. Three of the four categories on offense
- 1:01:08went to Michigan. Four of the five categories on defense, well, three
- 1:01:15of the four on defense went to Ohio State. Then you had special teams
- 1:01:19which went to Ohio State head coach, which went to Michigan. I guess
- 1:01:22actually, if we do an eleventh and take schedule. Oh boy, well
- 1:01:30that's uh, this might be less competitive than wide receivers if we're doing strengthens
- 1:01:36comparing schedules this year. Yeah, yeah, no, this is this is
- 1:01:39I think very reflective of where the rivalry is right now. And you know,
- 1:01:43I know, I free Michigan fans going. Ye know, they beat
- 1:01:45them by three touchdowns last year. Yeah, and they beat them by a
- 1:01:47bunch of the year before that. Uh huh. And I think, how,
- 1:01:52I mean, how confident are you really that Michigan's going to beat Ohio
- 1:01:53State by three touchdowns this year? It's in n arbor, so how hard
- 1:01:57can it be? I you know, you look at all the advanced analytic
- 1:02:00systems. Our buddy Tyler Shoemaker, who does his own advanced analytic systems,
- 1:02:05he just did one of his one of his podcasts and was talking about that,
- 1:02:09and he said his numbers have the Ohio State Michigan game like in terms
- 1:02:14of power rating like dead tide like in in our Birth of the Game.
- 1:02:17I think it was like thirty one thirty one or something like that. I
- 1:02:21mean, it is like an absolute dead heat there are This is this is
- 1:02:25good for the rivalry. This is very healthy for the rivalry. I'm sure
- 1:02:29Ohio State fans have not enjoyed the last two years, but going what did
- 1:02:32Ohio State go? It was nineteen years and they lost twice, So seventeen
- 1:02:37and two, like, that's not great for the rivalry long term. And
- 1:02:43you know, having Michigan be you know, to the point where they're not
- 1:02:45just beating Ohio State and you know, like the nineties where they beat Ohio
- 1:02:50State and then they go to the Holiday Bowl or whatever. They're beating Ohio
- 1:02:53State and they're winning the Big Ten. They've won the Big Ten twice.
- 1:02:55Now they haven't done that since two thousand and four. This is all good
- 1:02:59for the rivalry. This is a game. This is how you keep your
- 1:03:01game from becoming Florida Florida State or you know, I mean what Alabama Auburn
- 1:03:07is a lot of years where it's like one team's good and one team's not
- 1:03:10Florida Florida State. If you remember the nineties, there was this whole conversation
- 1:03:14about oh this is replaced Ohio State. Michigan is the best rivalry in the
- 1:03:16country because it means so much. And then you look at the last twenty
- 1:03:20years and it's like, well less so. So this is good for Ohio
- 1:03:25State and it's good for Michigan that this rivalry is competitive again. It's good
- 1:03:29for the Big Ten, it's good for college football. Yeah. Absolutely,
- 1:03:32So there you have the tail of the tape. We have settled absolutely nothing
- 1:03:37for you, so fantastic. Thank you for tuning in. Yeah, I
- 1:03:42kind of thought that's how things might go. And honestly, having Michigan offensively
- 1:03:49as the pick and Ohio State defensively as the pick is it's going to be
- 1:03:54interesting to watch because I think everybody just you just assume High State's off and
- 1:04:00I think obviously the system that Ohio State runs, they're going to they tend
- 1:04:03to score more points. But do you think Michigan offensively is going to be
- 1:04:09more aggressive through the air this year with the eight second year starting quarterback returning
- 1:04:15receivers or do you why would you go away from that running game? Right?
- 1:04:20This is a Jim Harbaugh team. This is a Boschembeckler disciple, and
- 1:04:28I think the way they have found success is by zagging while everyone else is
- 1:04:33zigging. The whole sport is going towards in the direction that Ohio State's going
- 1:04:38you're spreading it out, You're you know, fast guys in space, all
- 1:04:43that kind of stuff throwing the ball, and Michigan is kind of just Okay,
- 1:04:45we're gonna throw a rock. We're gonna throw a rock. We're gonna
- 1:04:47throw a rock, and that has worked so well for them. I'm gonna
- 1:04:51be interested to see what the carry numbers look like for Blake Coreum this year,
- 1:04:56because he really ran two hundred and forty seven I think carries last year
- 1:04:59in base the first eleven games of the season. So I don't think you're
- 1:05:03gonna I don't think it would be smart for them to run him into the
- 1:05:05ground like that this year, again against the kind of schedule that they're gonna
- 1:05:10face. But my tendency is that is to think that they're if they throw
- 1:05:17more, that's probably good news because for Michigan because it means they trust J.
- 1:05:20J. McCarthy. But I'm not really expecting that. I think you've
- 1:05:25got to throw to win a national title in terms of at the at the
- 1:05:29end of the season. And we went through and watched all of those Georgia
- 1:05:31games last year and people are like, George is just like Michigan. They'll
- 1:05:34just run the ball and run the ball, and that's not who they were
- 1:05:35at all. They throw the ball all over the place. To throw it
- 1:05:38short, they throw it long, they get the ball out quickly, they
- 1:05:41run around, and I think you need to let J. J. McCarthy
- 1:05:45cook. As we've said before, it's just last year he burned a lot.
- 1:05:49And of course, yes, yes he also burnt Ohio State. Yes,
- 1:05:53I get the joke. But obviously we're all looking forward to that.
- 1:05:57And we will have a Michigan Monday Show every Monday this season during the show
- 1:06:00recapping what we saw on Saturday, so from from the Michigan Wolverine, So
- 1:06:05everybody tune in for those I I normally look forward to those shows that you
- 1:06:12look at the schedule this year and it's like, oh, it's terrible,
- 1:06:15Like we just did this last year and you went through like the whole month
- 1:06:19of September and it was like, well, what have we learned? I
- 1:06:26know, what more of the players look like, you know, like facially
- 1:06:30I know that, and it's just that's gonna be this year as well.
- 1:06:33There's just there's just nothing there on the schedule. The first the first month
- 1:06:38is what East Carolina UNLV, Bowling Green and Rutgers I think so, I
- 1:06:46mean, boy, Rutger is clearly the best team on that of that group,
- 1:06:49I'm gonna guess maybe, I mean, I have not done a deep
- 1:06:53dive in East Carolina. Maybe this is I think they lost a bunch after
- 1:06:56off of last year's team. So yeah, it's we're gonna be in October
- 1:07:00and not know anything more from Michigan unless someone gets hurt. I don't think
- 1:07:04there's any data we're going to really have on Michigan that's going to be meaningful
- 1:07:08between now and mid October, and yeah, I'm gonna have to write about
- 1:07:12it and we're gonna have to talk about it as if. Boy, did
- 1:07:15you see what Donovan Edwards did against those Bawling Green Falcons. He really showed
- 1:07:20them as So yeah, it's gonna be it's gonna be a long, a
- 1:07:26long month. But hey, there's also other college ruble going on. All
- 1:07:30right, everybody that is going to do it for the first half of this
- 1:07:32episode. That's the annual tale of the tape. The next half of this
- 1:07:36episode is gonna drop tomorrow and we'll be the viewer questions from the rest of
- 1:07:44this two hour session talking mostly Ohio State and some Michigan stuff in there as
- 1:07:48well, so give that a listen when that drops. I also want to
- 1:07:53invite you to listen to all of our podcast at the Buckeye Huddle Network,
- 1:07:58including Tom's Buckeyes Tomorrow Morning, which we'll be dropping every day. We also
- 1:08:02have a new daily college football show called The Daily Huddle, which is hosted
- 1:08:06by Garrett Seawright. Also, you can check out Calculated Risk. That's college
- 1:08:12Football by the Numbers. That's Tyler Shoemaker and Kelly Ford talking about the power
- 1:08:15rating side of college football. That's a fun show. Check that one out.
- 1:08:19Of course, Mark Giveler and Tyler Shoemaker also do the College Football Playbook,
- 1:08:24and Mark Giveler also has the Skull Session. We'll have a state recruiting
- 1:08:28podcast as well, so just go ahead and if you if any of that
- 1:08:31interest you, go ahead and search for that on any of those on any
- 1:08:34of your podcast platforms of choice. You'll find them there. Would also invite
- 1:08:41you to become a member at Bucket Huddle dot com if you have not done
- 1:08:43so. If you have, thank you very much, and you can find
- 1:08:45us also at YouTube dot com. Slash bucket Huddle, Facebook dot com slash
- 1:08:49bucket Huddle and that will do it for this episode. Want to thank you
- 1:08:54all for tuning in and we'll talk to you guys tomorrow