Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Handle a Lateral Move That Feels Like a Demotion
Transcript
- Lucas: Luna, I want to start with an email we got from a listener named Priya. She's a marketing manager at a mid-size consumer goods company. She took a lateral transfer from brand strategy to internal communications, thinking it would broaden her skill set. Six weeks in, she says, quote, 'I have half the team, zero direct reports, and my title is technically the same, but everyone knows this is a step down.' Luna: Oof. That title equivalent but everything else feels worse situation is brutal. It's a lateral move that smells like a demotion. Lucas: Exactly. And I think a lot of people have been through something like this. Maybe you took a role that was supposed to be a 'strategic reset' or a 'broadening assignment', and instead you're doing work that feels two levels below what you were doing before. So today I want to talk about how to handle that first 90 days — when you're in it and it stings. Luna: Right. Because Priya's question is essentially: Did I make a mistake, or is this a slow-burn opportunity I'm not seeing? Lucas: And the answer is: both are possible. The first thing I'd say to Priya is: do not judge a lateral move by the title or the headcount. Judge it by the scope of decisions you influence. So if she's now crafting messaging that goes to the entire company, that's a different kind of leverage than managing a brand campaign. It might be bigger, just not in the way her old peer group measures. Luna: But how do you know if it's actually bigger or if you're just rationalizing? I've seen people stay too long in a role that was genuinely a demotion, convincing themselves it was a strategic step. Lucas: That's a real risk. So here's a concrete test: within your first two weeks in a new lateral role, map your stakeholders. Write down every person who depends on your output. If that list is shorter or less senior than your previous role's list, that's a yellow flag. If it's longer or includes new senior executives, you're probably in a role with more hidden influence. Luna: That's smart. So Priya should look at who she's working with now versus before. If she's suddenly emailing the CEO's office regularly, that's not a demotion. Lucas: Right. The second thing is: negotiate a 90-day check-in with your manager before you accept the role. If you're already in it, do it now. Say, 'I want to make sure this role is delivering value for both of us. Can we set a conversation for week twelve to assess how it's going and what adjustments we need?' That forces your manager to articulate the upside they see. If they can't, you have your answer. Luna: And if they can't? What's the move then? Lucas: Then you start treating the role as a temporary assignment. You update your resume, network internally for the next thing, and you set a hard deadline — say six months — to either see real growth or start looking externally. The thing is, a lateral move that truly is a dead end usually reveals itself by month four. The work is repetitive, the stakeholders are the same, and nobody is asking for your perspective in meetings. Luna: I want to push back on one thing, though. Some companies do use lateral moves to quietly sideline people — especially if there's a performance concern or a personality conflict they don't want to deal with directly. How do you tell the difference between that and a genuine development opportunity? Lucas: Great question. The difference usually shows up in the first month. In a genuine development move, your manager should be checking in proactively, asking what you need, and connecting you to new people. In a sideline, you get handed a list of tasks and then you're left alone. So Priya should look at the pattern of attention she's getting. If her manager is absent, that's a signal. Luna: And what about the team size? She mentioned she went from having direct reports to zero. That's a big psychological hit. Lucas: It is. And it's worth asking whether the loss of direct reports is permanent or structural. Some organizations are flattening hierarchies, and a manager role one year can become an individual contributor role the next with no negative connotation. But if the culture still values headcount as a status symbol, then yes, it's a downgrade in how you're perceived. In that case, you need to build influence through expertise, not authority. Become the go-to person on a specific topic — maybe internal comms metrics or employee engagement surveys. Luna: So become indispensable in a narrow area. That gives you leverage to either reshape the role or have a strong story for your next move. Lucas: Exactly. And that brings me to a broader point: a lateral move is only as good as the story you can tell from it. If you leave in a year and say, 'I ran internal comms for a 5,000-person company and increased employee engagement scores by 15 percent,' that's a powerful narrative. If you say, 'I took a lateral move and it was a mistake,' that's harder to sell. So your job in the first 90 days is to gather data points that will become your story later. Luna: I think that's really actionable. Priya should start tracking wins now, even small ones. A new process she improved, a campaign that got positive feedback, a new relationship with a senior leader. Lucas: Right. And one more thing: don't complain to your old colleagues about the move. It's tempting to vent to people who knew you in your previous role, but that creates a narrative that follows you. Instead, find a mentor outside your chain of command, someone who can give you objective feedback on whether you're growing or stagnating. Luna: Let me ask you this: what if Priya realizes in month three that this was genuinely a bad move? She's already there. Is it too soon to start looking for something else? Lucas: Not at all. In fact, the sooner she knows, the better. The mistake is staying two years out of loyalty or fear of looking like a job-hopper. If you know by month three that the role has no future, start networking quietly. The rule of thumb is: one lateral move that doesn't work out is a learning experience. Two in a row is a pattern. So don't let one bad decision define your career. Luna: I think that's fair. And it's also worth saying: sometimes the lateral move that feels like a demotion is actually a test. Some companies use them to see if you can handle a different kind of pressure before promoting you into a broader role. Lucas: That's true. I've seen cases where a high-potential employee was moved into a 'fix-it' role — a troubled division or a neglected function — and after turning it around, they were fast-tracked. The key is whether the move comes with a mandate to fix something, or just a mandate to maintain. If you're asked to maintain, that's a red flag. If you're asked to transform, that's an opportunity. Luna: So Priya should ask herself: am I here to keep the lights on, or to rebuild? That will tell her a lot. Lucas: And she should also ask her manager directly. Say, 'What does success look like in this role in six months? What would constitute a home run?' If the answer is vague, like 'do a good job,' that's not a good sign. If it's specific, like 'reduce email open rates by 10 percent' or 'launch a new intranet,' that's a clear goal she can work toward. Luna: That's the kind of clarity that turns a lateral move into a stepping stone. Lucas: Before we wrap up, I want to mention something. We do these episodes every day, and we deliberately keep them ad-free. No sponsors, no commercials. It's a choice we made because we think career advice shouldn't be interrupted by ads for things you don't need. If that model works for you, and you want to support it, there's a link in the show notes — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small way to keep this going without selling your attention. Luna: Yeah, it's a direct way to say this content matters to you. No pressure, just if you find value in it. Lucas: Exactly. So back to Priya's situation. The last thing I'd say is: don't forget to assess the culture. A lateral move in a company that values learning and mobility is different from one in a company that sees it as a demotion. If the culture around you treats the move as a step down, that perception can be a self-fulfilling prophecy. You might need to change the narrative by delivering visible results. Luna: And if the culture is toxic about it? If people keep making comments? Lucas: Then you have a culture problem, not a role problem. And you might need to leave the company altogether. Because even if you succeed, the stigma might stick. So Priya should keep that in her back pocket as an option. But I'd give it the full 90 days before making that call. Luna: Good advice. So to sum up: don't judge by title, map your stakeholders, negotiate a check-in, track wins, and give it three months before deciding. Lucas: And above all, trust your gut. If after three months you still feel like you're being sidelined, act on it. Your career is too long to spend in a role that doesn't grow you.