Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Reference from a Former Boss Who Fired You
Transcript
- Lucas: So you got fired. It happens. Maybe it was a restructuring, maybe a personality clash, maybe you genuinely dropped the ball on something. And now you are applying for a new role and the application asks for references — and the most relevant person to vouch for your work is the very boss who showed you the door. Luna: I think most people hear that and assume it's a dead end. Like, there is no way that person is going to say something positive. Lucas: And honestly, sometimes that is true. But not always. I have seen cases where a former boss who terminated someone actually gave a strong reference — because the firing was structural, not personal. The key is how you ask, and what you ask for. Let me give you a real example. Luna: Please. Lucas: A marketing manager I know — let's call her Jen — was let go during a department-wide restructuring at a mid-sized tech firm. Her VP, the one who had to deliver the news, actually liked her work. But the company cut the entire brand marketing team. Jen was out. Six months later, she found a dream role at a competitor. The recruiter asked for three references, and specifically wanted someone who had supervised her directly. That was the VP who fired her. Luna: So she had to decide whether to even reach out. How did she handle it? Lucas: She sent a short email. Acknowledged the termination upfront — didn't pretend it hadn't happened — but kept it factual. She said something like, 'As you know, my role was eliminated in the restructuring in January. I am now a finalist for a brand director position at Company X, and they are asking for a reference from my most recent manager. I would be grateful if you felt comfortable speaking about my work on the Q3 campaign and the analytics dashboard I built. I completely understand if this isn't something you can do, and I appreciate you considering it.' Luna: I like that she gave him an out. That's important. Lucas: It is critical. You are essentially saying: I know this is awkward. You don't have to say yes. But if you can, here is exactly what I need you to talk about. Notice she did not ask him to say she was a great employee overall — she asked him to speak to two specific, verifiable projects. That is a much easier ask. Luna: And the VP said yes? Lucas: He did. He told her he was happy to confirm her contributions on those projects. And Jen got the job. The hiring manager later told her that the VP's reference was actually quite strong — he talked about her campaign strategy and her data skills. Luna: So that is a case where the firing was a layoff, not performance. But what about someone who was fired for cause — like a performance issue? Lucas: That is harder, but not impossible. The first question you have to ask yourself is: will this person say anything useful, or will they just confirm the termination and leave it at that? If you think they will give a balanced but honest account — including that you struggled with X but also that you were strong at Y — it might still be worth asking. Luna: But if they are angry or if the firing was really contentious, it could backfire. The reference call might turn into a recounting of everything that went wrong. Lucas: Exactly. In those cases, you are better off using a peer reference or a client. Let me give you another example. A friend of mine was fired from a sales role after missing quota for three quarters. The relationship with his manager was strained — lots of tense feedback emails. He knew that manager would not be a good reference. So instead, he asked a senior colleague who had been on his team — someone who had seen his work ethic and deal-closing skills, even if the numbers didn't show it. Luna: And that worked? Lucas: It did. The colleague framed it honestly: 'I worked alongside him for two years. He was great at building client relationships and negotiating contracts. His results in my last year were below target, but that was partly due to a territory reassignment.' That is a credible, contextual reference. It doesn't hide the firing, but it also doesn't make it the headline. Luna: So the strategy really depends on the nature of the termination and the relationship. If it was a layoff, the former boss is often willing to help. If it was performance-related, you need to gauge whether they will be fair — or if you're better off with someone else. Lucas: Right. And I would add one more layer: sometimes you can ask the former boss for a reference even if you are not sure they will say yes. The worst they can do is say no or give a lukewarm response. But you have to be strategic about how you position it. You don't want to put them in a position where they feel obligated to lie or to downplay what happened. Luna: Which brings up an interesting question — should you volunteer the context of the firing to the reference? Or just let them speak? Lucas: I think you should be transparent with the reference about what happened. They already know, so pretending it didn't happen is awkward. But you don't need to re-litigate it. Just say, 'My role was eliminated' or 'We parted ways in ' and then move to what you did well. And if you are worried they might say something negative in the call, you can ask them directly: 'Would you feel comfortable focusing on these specific strengths?' Luna: And if they say no, at least you know before the hiring manager calls. Lucas: Exactly. Better to find out early. Now, there is another scenario that comes up a lot: what if you were fired from a job that you held for a very short time — like three months? Should you even list that employer at all? Luna: I have heard mixed advice on that. Some people say leave it off your resume entirely to avoid the question. Lucas: I lean toward including it if the work you did there is relevant to the role you are applying for, and if you can frame the departure honestly. Three months is short, but if you accomplished something concrete — like closing a deal, building a report, leading a project — that evidence is still valuable. And gaps are harder to explain than a short tenure with a clear reason. Luna: But then you need a reference from that employer. And if you were fired, you are back to the same problem. Lucas: Yes, but you can also use a colleague or a client from that company. You don't have to use the manager who fired you. The key is to have someone who can verify that you actually did what you say you did. The hiring manager mainly wants to confirm that you are not exaggerating your contributions. Luna: So let me ask you this: if a listener is sitting there right now, dreading asking their former boss who fired them — what is the one thing you would tell them to do first? Lucas: I would say: write down the specific projects or skills you want that boss to speak about. Make it easy for them. And then send a very low-pressure email — one that acknowledges the situation, gives them an out, and asks for something narrow. That is your best shot. And if they say no, you have lost nothing. You have just confirmed that you need to find another reference. Luna: I think that is really actionable. And it reminds me — if today's conversation helped you think through a tricky reference situation, that is exactly why we do this show ad-free. The way it stays that way is listener support. If you found value here, you can buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It helps us keep these conversations going without any sponsor interruptions. Lucas: Yeah, it genuinely makes a difference. Even a small contribution adds up. So thanks to anyone who has ever thrown a coffee our way. Luna: Alright, back to Jen's story. She got the job, but what if the VP had said no? What is the backup plan? Lucas: She had a backup — she had kept in touch with a former peer who had moved to another company. That peer was willing to speak to her collaboration and project management skills. It wasn't a direct supervisory reference, but it was credible. And many hiring managers will accept a peer reference if you explain that your most recent supervisor is unavailable due to the restructuring. Luna: So the lesson is: cultivate your network before you need it. Don't wait until you are in a reference panic to reconnect with people. Lucas: Absolutely. And if you are currently employed and worried about a potential firing, proactively build relationships with colleagues and clients who can vouch for you later. It is insurance. I also think it is smart to have at least one reference who is not a manager — a client, a vendor, a board member, even a professor if you are early in your career. Luna: Let's talk about the actual phone call. If the hiring manager asks directly, 'Why did you leave your last role?' and you say 'I was let go during a restructuring,' they will probably want to call that former manager. How do you prepare for that? Lucas: You prepare by having a consistent story. Your resume, your interview answer, and your reference's account should all align. If you say 'restructuring' but the former boss says 'performance issues,' that is a red flag. So be honest with the reference about what you are telling the hiring manager. If the firing had a performance element, you might say something like, 'The role was a poor fit and my performance did not meet expectations, but I learned X and Y from the experience.' And then ask the former boss if they can speak to the positive aspects of your time there. Luna: And if the former boss says something negative anyway? There is no way to control that entirely. Lucas: That is the risk. But most former bosses will not go out of their way to sabotage you unless there is real animosity. And if you suspect there is, do not use them. Go with a peer or client. I would rather have a strong peer reference than a lukewarm manager reference. Luna: I think that is a good rule of thumb. One last thing — what about written references? Some applications ask for a letter rather than a phone call. Lucas: Written references are actually easier in some ways because you can see what they wrote. And you can ask the former boss to focus on specific achievements. I would still give them an out: 'If you are comfortable writing a brief letter mentioning the campaign and the dashboard, I would really appreciate it. If not, no worries at all.' Again, make it easy. And if they say yes, you get a document you can reuse for other applications. Luna: Good point. So to wrap it up: the key is to be strategic, be respectful, and give the former boss a clear, narrow ask. And if that doesn't work, have a backup. Lucas: Exactly. Being fired is not the end of your career. It is just a story you need to tell well — and a reference you need to manage carefully. Most hiring managers understand that people get fired. What they care about is how you handle it. Luna: And whether you can get someone to confirm that you did good work while you were there. Lucas: Right. So do the work upfront, ask thoughtfully, and you will be surprised how often people say yes.