Latest / The Vegan Report / Justice for the Voiceless! Animal Partisan is Suing Animal Abusers. With William Lowrey | Ep. 05
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you're listening to The Vegan Report.
- 0:05If you're vegan for the animals and you care to do more for animal rights, but you're not sure
- 0:12where to start, then this podcast is for you. Every week, let yourself fall in love with
- 0:18passionate animal rights leaders who will inspire you to find your voice, your own special
- 0:25contribution to the animal rights movement, however small or big it is. Today we are going
- 0:32to talk about justice for animals. To discuss this topic, I have with me William who works
- 0:39as legal counsel for Animal Partizan. And be careful listeners, because Animal Partizan
- 0:46has been labeled as, and I quote, a major animal rights extremist group by the Animal Agriculture
- 0:55Alliance. If you visit Animal Partizan's website, and the link is in the description,
- 1:01this is their mission statement. Our mission is to end the suffering of animals in slaughterhouses,
- 1:08farms, and labs by discovering, exposing, and challenging unlawful conduct in all its farms.
- 1:16We're small but tenacious. I love that. From bringing criminal charges against slaughterhouses
- 1:22to uncovering hidden cruelty in labs, to training the new generation of animal lawyers,
- 1:28we're becoming a thorn in the side for the animal agriculture and research industries. Wow,
- 1:35just reading that makes me feel motivated. You know, I want to stand up and make a difference.
- 1:41So William, I'm so happy to have you on. Welcome to the show.
- 1:45Thank you so much for having me, Ryan, and thanks for putting this podcast together. I think there's
- 1:50so much information on this topic out there, and I think any channels to get information to the
- 1:54public are valuable. So thank you for all your work. Of course. Amazing. So would you like to
- 2:01first introduce yourself, William? How did you find yourself working for Animal Partizan?
- 2:06Absolutely. So my path to where I am today was a little circuitous. I had actually started
- 2:14not even in law. I worked a corporate career. I had graduated from school here in the United
- 2:19States in Virginia. Wasn't quite sure what I wanted to do, and I ended up working for
- 2:24a very large financial corporation as a process engineer, and I was designing how the business
- 2:29worked and managing large projects. And at some point in probably 2002, I ended up getting a
- 2:36couple of pit bull type dogs from the local city shelter. And I always say that for me was Pandora's
- 2:42box, and it opened my eyes to sort of the plight those dogs experience, discrimination, dog fighting.
- 2:49And then that led to me just volunteering for every animal welfare, animal rights volunteer group
- 2:54that I could locally. I think there was a point where I was volunteering or running 11 different
- 3:00local organizations while I was working full time for the financial corporation. And at some point,
- 3:06I kind of just said, look, I want to do this for a career. And I had kept seeing this intersection
- 3:11of law and animals and decided to go to law school late in life to pursue animal law. I packed up,
- 3:18went to law school in Vermont, graduated, worked at a court in New Jersey for a little bit,
- 3:24was fortunate to end up at a great organization, Animal Outlook, was their legal counsel for three
- 3:30years, working on civil litigation, working with our undercover investigators. And then about a
- 3:36year ago, decided to branch out on my own and start Animal Partisan. And the driver for that
- 3:41was really just that there are so many legal theories and options available to try to help
- 3:48animals and compare that with the magnitude of suffering that's happening. It just felt for me
- 3:54like I needed to do whatever I could to maximize what I'm able to do in my time on this planet.
- 3:59And for me, that was going off to start my own thing and sort of pursuing some of these legal
- 4:03theories. Sounds like effective altruism. Do you follow that philosophy? I'm familiar, you know,
- 4:14definitely familiar with it. You know, it's not the way that I think of it, not to say it is
- 4:20either here nor there. But for me, it's just about, I have limited time left on this planet. I know
- 4:26there's suffering out there. I've seen it firsthand. I've seen it through others. And it's just a simple
- 4:31equation of the time that I have, the hours during the day, the days during the week, what can I do
- 4:37that's going to have a meaningful impact on that? So that's whatever label anyone wants to put on it.
- 4:43That's just the way I think of it. I mean, as you know this as well as I do, as we sit here now,
- 4:47animals are suffering. You know, probably miles from each of us, there are animals in factory
- 4:52farms, there are animals in labs. And there's just an urgency about the issue that I think we all need
- 4:58to do something about. So William, we don't know each other, but you don't sound like an extremist.
- 5:05I don't feel like I'm in the presence of Che Guevara. So what is the Animal Agriculture Alliance?
- 5:13And why are they calling animal partisan an extremist group? A major extremist group, sorry.
- 5:21Yeah, it's definitely not just animal partisan. I mean, the Animal Agriculture Alliance, to my
- 5:27understanding, is an organization that supports animal agriculture producers, at least here in
- 5:33the United States. And one of their big functions, at least that they advertise and they charge
- 5:39thousands of dollars from agricultural producers, is this sort of quote unquote monitoring of animal
- 5:44rights, quote unquote animal rights activist groups. And so, you know, they're purporting to be
- 5:50sort of the watchdog for what the animal people are doing and what threats might exist to the
- 5:55industry. And so, you know, they've often produced this large, very complicated, almost, I wouldn't
- 6:02say almost unreadable, it is completely unreadable diagram that alleges to show connections between
- 6:08the different animal groups. And, you know, animal partisan is one of probably 40 groups on there.
- 6:14To some extent, I think it's a badge of honor for these groups to say that, you know, the animal
- 6:18agriculture industry has taken notice of the work that's being done. But there are plenty of other
- 6:23groups that, you know, everyone is aware of. Your PETA's and the United States and animal
- 6:28equalities and all of the other groups doing wonderful, wonderful work. And so, I think the
- 6:33word extremist is easy to use and throw about if trying to alleviate, reduce and end exploitation
- 6:41and suffering is extreme. I just question what sort of world we live in. I think it's one of
- 6:47those terms that, you know, people know if you throw about you brand somebody with the term
- 6:51extremist, some people won't even read past that and they'll just think extremist means this
- 6:56person's ideology is nonsense. I shouldn't listen to that. I should discount them. And I'm sure that
- 7:02that's part, or I would suspect that's part of the strategy of the Animal Agriculture Alliance,
- 7:06is to brand groups in many cases who are, or in most cases, doing very, very reasonable things
- 7:12that the majority of the public would agree with if they knew about. So I, you know, I would take
- 7:18that term with a grain of salt. And if people want to have a look at that unreadable diagram,
- 7:25they can visit the Instagram account of Animal Partisan. You have published the diagram and
- 7:32it's quite fascinating to look at it. Let's get to the core of the topic. Can you draw for me
- 7:40a portrait of the legal situation of animals? What do I mean by that? Well, without getting
- 7:48into details, what is exactly the legal status of animals? Are animals considered sentient by the
- 7:55law? Are animals protected against cruelty and abuse by the law? Can animals have rights? So
- 8:02this is just a bundle of questions here. Yeah, it's definitely not an easy answer to that
- 8:10question, as you might expect. I mean, there's a lot tied up in that. And I can speak to the American
- 8:16system of law. I can't really speak beyond that. But in the United States, animals are really
- 8:22considered property. I mean, we have Supreme Court cases going back decades and decades about
- 8:27dogs on train tracks and others, where it's explicit that animals are considered property
- 8:32and that the state may regulate sort of the ownership control of animals in general.
- 8:37So animals are not human beings. I mean, it is plainly evident from reading any statute or law
- 8:43that in the law in the United States, animals are not considered on par with human beings. They are
- 8:48considered property, something less than human beings. When it comes to the question of rights,
- 8:53it's a complicated question. There's a lot of groups doing wonderful work in that. I would first
- 8:59give a plug to the Non-Human Rights Project, which is one of the preeminent groups in the United
- 9:05States working to obtain legal rights for animals. But animals do have some protections. It gets a
- 9:11little squishy when you talk about what's a right, what's a protection, like is the ability to be
- 9:16free from cruelty a right or is that just something else? And so I'm not sure I have the answer to
- 9:21that. But here's what I will say. In the law, animals do have certain protections written in
- 9:29the law. I'll add two caveats to that. One, it's not a lot. And for some animals like animals used
- 9:36in agriculture research, it is in fact very little, almost nonexistent. And two, I would caution any
- 9:43listeners that the fact that something is written in the law does not mean that it happens in
- 9:47practice. I think we get complacent in a lot of regards and people think that, oh, there's a law
- 9:52written, everything's going to stop, this will be wonderful. The enforcement of laws is a whole
- 9:57separate situation. So I would caveat when I say there are things written in the law, that doesn't
- 10:01mean that these always happen in practice. But regarding what is in the law, all 50 states in
- 10:08the United States have anti-cruelty provisions that prevent certain things like beating, abusing,
- 10:14overdriving, overloading, tormenting, torturing, these types of things. So there's a whole host of
- 10:21written protections. In most of these states, those written protections exempt certain conduct. So
- 10:28standard agricultural practices, common farming operations, or bona fide animal research are all
- 10:36excluded from those things. And so you have this scenario to your question, some animals have
- 10:42written protections that allow them or purportedly should allow them to be free from cruelty. Is that
- 10:49a right or not? I don't know. It's not the kind of right that you would think of where I'm the right
- 10:54to be free and I could go pursue my livelihood and I could go wherever I want and I can socialize.
- 10:59Those are the more substantive rights and I think that's what people generally talk about when they
- 11:03say rights. And so to summarize all of that, animals are considered in the law in the United
- 11:09States less than humans. They're considered property. They do have some written protections.
- 11:15Those protections generally are poorly enforced and they do not include largely certain common
- 11:23situations in agriculture research funding or those types of things. But animals don't have
- 11:28rights of autonomy, association, and those types of things. So the net net is it's a pretty lowly
- 11:34position for animals in the law, which creates lots of opportunity for folks practicing animal law.
- 11:39Hmm. And something I find truly mad about our laws is that there is discrimination between species of
- 11:49animals and that reflects our cultural discrimination. So for instance, there is a
- 11:56set of rules for dogs and cats and they're considered pets. They're more perceived as
- 12:06being sentient, but then there's another set of laws for farm animals, cows, pigs, chickens, and
- 12:15such. How do you explain that? How did that weird cognitive dissonance made its appearance?
- 12:29Yeah, you're absolutely right. I mean, there definitely are distinctions drawn in the law
- 12:34between types of animals and the distinctions are arbitrary. I mean, anyone who has spent time with
- 12:40any type of farmed animal, for example, would know. I mean, I'm fortunate enough to have on
- 12:47the property where I live, we have sheep and goats and chickens and I've spent decades with dogs. And
- 12:52I can tell you that take the goats, for example, the goats are every bit as cognitively aware and
- 12:58playful and affectionate and the sheep and the chickens as well. And the chickens, the complexity
- 13:03of their sounds and their social interactions. I mean, these are things that people don't realize.
- 13:07And so you start with this premise of it is an artificial dichotomy between these types of animals.
- 13:13But to your question, yes, it absolutely exists. I mean, we say on one hand, the law will say
- 13:19companion animal or domestic animal, and it will define animals such as dogs and cats and maybe
- 13:25horses and gerbils and those types of animals. And on the other hand, we have these exemptions
- 13:30that will say, if you are an animal being used in a medical research experiment, or if you are being
- 13:36used in agriculture, you're different. You're not that type of animal. You're this type of animal.
- 13:42And I think your question gets to a couple things. One is just, it's really, quote unquote,
- 13:48social utility. It's how people view these animals. I mean, people have lived with domesticated dogs
- 13:54for many, many years and they form bonds and they generally socially think of dogs in one category.
- 14:00This is almost part of the family. These are animals that live near the household. And then,
- 14:05you know, commercially, we have used and exploited other animals for other purposes.
- 14:10And so it gets to what is the benefit to society in the eyes of society, right? It's like, well,
- 14:16these animals can help us, quote unquote, make sure these products are safe or these animals can
- 14:22be food for the dinner plate. Therefore, they have less value. We should care less about them.
- 14:27And that's how the laws are written. And so in large part, it reflects how society views these
- 14:33animals. And I think it's largely directed to the perceived utility of these animals. It has nothing
- 14:38to do with the fact that these animals are one in the same. Like, they think, they feel pain,
- 14:44they suffer. Just like we do, they're no different. It, unfortunately, as with many things,
- 14:48you know, boils down to what society deems is useful for humanity. And that's the sad
- 14:54state of reality we kind of live in. It's even sadder for the animals that are stuck in the system.
- 14:59Thank you for this explanation. You know, it clarifies things for me, because I was thinking
- 15:04in terms of species. But yeah, it's better to think about it in terms of function, because
- 15:10you could have a dog in a lab, and then a dog as a pet, they have different functions. And so they
- 15:16have different legal standards applied to them. Yeah, thank you for that. So in preparation
- 15:27for this interview, I was thinking about a conversation I had with Dr. Jens Vult, who is
- 15:32the director of Fona Sanctuary, which is the biggest primate sanctuary in Canada. And that was
- 15:40actually episode one of the podcast. And she was explaining to me that the reason why we don't
- 15:45recognize chimps, and there are many good reasons to recognize them as people, in terms of in
- 15:54legal terms, because, you know, they are our closest evolutionary relative, they have faces,
- 16:02I mean, the resemblance with chimps, you know, between humans and chimps is truly astounding,
- 16:10is because the fact that we don't recognize them as people, in terms of the law, is because that
- 16:16would open the door to laws protecting monkeys. And there would be this snowball effect. And then
- 16:27at the end, we might be threatening the farm industry. So do you agree with that hypothesis
- 16:36from Dr. Jens Vult? Do you think that this is the obstacle that stops us from giving
- 16:45legal protection, legal rights to animals? Or do you think there are other reasons explaining why
- 16:53we are in 2023, and we haven't gotten to that place of, that good place of, you know, recognizing
- 17:05the sentence of animals, recognizing them as more than property?
- 17:12Yeah, yeah, I was excited to see Dr. Jens fold on your show, just as a side note, when I was in
- 17:17law school, we had her come and speak in one of our webinars, or not a webinar, a symposium,
- 17:22and she was great. It was very informative for the students there. To your question, is that,
- 17:28do I agree with that hypothesis? Yeah, yes, I do. There might be a lot more woven up into that. But
- 17:34at the highest level, I think there are a lot of people fearful of, you know, if we start granting
- 17:39rights for animals, where does that slippery slope, as people will call it, lead us? You know,
- 17:44does that lead us to a place where, and this can spawn 100 ridiculous arguments of, are we going
- 17:49to give the dog the right to vote? And can the cow drive the car? And all sorts of other absurd
- 17:54things like that. And so, you know, I think it's twofold, and they're kind of one and the same.
- 18:00And, you know, the argument will often be, it's a slippery slope, you know, we suddenly will have
- 18:04rights. And how do we accommodate rights for animals when we have all the people in the world?
- 18:09And how does that system work together? But I think the other part of that, that stems from that
- 18:14concern, or alleged concern, is that it goes back to the commercial utility that I talked about. So,
- 18:20if we start granting animals rights, then presumably, we wouldn't slaughter them and
- 18:26shackle them up and keep them in cages and separate them from their calves and those types of
- 18:32things. And so, then the question becomes, well, what do we do? What do people eat? I think the
- 18:37obvious answer is, eat other stuff that doesn't involve animals. But I do agree with that premise.
- 18:43I think that's a lot of what the resistance is, is just, this is the way society is. It's the way
- 18:48society has been created for decades and generations. And, you know, the population
- 18:54is continuing to grow. I don't know if we're over 9 billion now, but it is not slowing down. And so,
- 18:59such a massive population, you know, has a need for commerce and products. And people are so
- 19:05interwoven with, like, the way things are and how animals fit in that system and are afraid that if
- 19:10we dramatically change that, what happens to the system? Like, where do people get their commerce?
- 19:15Where do they get their money from? You know, I think that's the concern. I think you need to
- 19:22start with the more base fundamental of, does that matter? Is that enough to trump the rights
- 19:27of any animal? I mean, so, if you start with the animals are in such a place that, like, their
- 19:33rights can be suppressed if we have commercial concerns, I don't think that's a good premise to
- 19:38start your argument. I think you start the argument with, if you have an animal that is sentient,
- 19:42that feels suffering, that has relationships and has every bit of capacity that humans do,
- 19:47why start with any sort of prioritization? Why not start with the question of, like,
- 19:52what can we do to not do these things to this animal, just like we would not do these things
- 19:57to a human being? And then you start solving problems from there. So, I think it's premised
- 20:03on a faulty foundation. I think you need to start with the foundation of, like, let's not even
- 20:08entertain all this other stuff that we can deprioritize them. Let's start with the premise
- 20:12that we just shouldn't be doing it and now figure out how to get away from it versus, like, the
- 20:18alternative. The idea of a dog voting is ridiculous, but it's also so funny and cute.
- 20:26But that begs the question, where do we want to go with this? What is the ideal world in which
- 20:38animal welfare has fulfilled all its goals? What does it look like legally? Because I'm thinking,
- 20:48would that mean a future in which eating animal products is prohibited, is illegal?
- 20:58So, I don't know if you ever thought about this.
- 21:01Yeah, I mean, I think you, like I said, have to start with the premise of that future society
- 21:08looks like a place where we are not exploiting and using animals, just like we wouldn't do that to a
- 21:13human being. And so, then you have to kind of build around it. And so, if that's the case,
- 21:18then certainly we would not be eating animals, we would not be consuming them or raising them
- 21:24in massive warehouses and those types of things. And so, that's the idea.
- 21:29And so, that would all need to go away. It would need to be replaced by something else. Unfortunately,
- 21:35there are wonderful groups that are working on plant-based alternatives and those types of things
- 21:40to fill that void. And so, I think you can safely assume that the utopian world would not look like
- 21:48animals being exploited. And so, the law sort of operates to some extent, or the society to some
- 21:54extent operates on the law. So, you would need laws to implement that. You would need laws that say,
- 22:00these are the products that can and can't be created. You cannot slaughter an animal for food.
- 22:06That is, I don't want anybody to be illusioned that we are anywhere remotely close to that,
- 22:13honestly, because I think that sort of tempers some of the urgency that's needed. This, to me,
- 22:18is like 100 years, 200 years in the future, but we need to act now to get to that place. And so,
- 22:24you know, I don't know what that looks like. You know, for me, it's a matter of just like moving
- 22:28the needle forward day by day, but it's a system where the laws reflect that we should not be using
- 22:34and exploiting animals. So, there are not loopholes that say, you can slaughter a cow if X, Y, and Z
- 22:40happens, or for these types of products, you can test on this animal. Those are great steps along
- 22:46the way, but at some point, we just have to say, enough is enough. We're not going to do it. And
- 22:50then our society and our system of laws needs to reflect that. Yeah. Like you said, the current
- 22:56situation is far from that utopia image that we have. And actually, your organization was born
- 23:06with the premise that urgent action needs to be taken for the benefit of animals. And that sense
- 23:14of emergency translates into your actions. Animal partisan is six months old, yet you have accomplished
- 23:22so much and you are very bold. You are even suing the FBI of health institutions. And we will get
- 23:30to this later. So, why are we in a state of emergency? What is the emergency about?
- 23:38Yeah, I think the answer to that question is easy if you look at the suffering. I think a lot of
- 23:45people, this is a bit of a peeve of mine, a lot of people turn away from the suffering. And that's
- 23:52okay. And I understand that people need to protect themselves. But if you look at the suffering
- 23:57and you recognize that it is happening here and now and there and there and there and there and
- 24:03times a million times a billion, it is happening everywhere every day. I mean, somewhere as we sit
- 24:09here, there is a sheep having her throat slit and there are chickens being pried half alive out of
- 24:15battery cages. It's happening everywhere. And those are not random isolated incidents. And so
- 24:21the urgency comes from that situation. Society exists, society goes on. It is early morning
- 24:28here for us, but everywhere around the world, the world is operating. People are waking up,
- 24:32they are having their breakfast, people are going about business and producing products that involve
- 24:37animals and slaughtering animals. And so the machine continues to turn. Society gets bigger
- 24:42and bigger. As I mentioned, the population continues to grow. And I think we need to stare
- 24:48it in the face and we need to say, this is a dire situation. These animals are suffering.
- 24:52This isn't just a job. This isn't just like a pastime or something fun that we do or to make
- 24:58ourselves feel good. We need to get into the system and stop the system and stop the suffering and
- 25:05stop the slaughter. And so for me, that's where the urgency comes from. It just comes from recognizing
- 25:12the volume of the world today, the number of people, the number of business processes that
- 25:17exploit animals and just stop and grasp that and think about it for a minute. It's far beyond our
- 25:22own individual worlds. And then look at the suffering in its face, look at the animals,
- 25:27watch the videos, expose yourself to the suffering, and then pull all that together in your head and
- 25:32say, this little scene that I saw here is playing itself out millions and millions of times a day.
- 25:38I think that's where the urgency comes from. And I think it behooves each and every one of us who
- 25:44know about these issues and care about them to act and to act swiftly and to do whatever is in
- 25:49our capacity, whether that's signing a petition, donating, grassroots activism, protests, doing
- 25:56legal actions, policy changes, legislation, whatever it might be, everyone has a role.
- 26:02And I think it's critical that everyone jumps in. Well said. And let's examine those actions that
- 26:10you have taken, the cases, the legal cases you have pursued and you are pursuing right now.
- 26:17And let's start by the animal agriculture. Can you walk us through some of the cases you have
- 26:23fought against the animal agriculture industry? Sure. So this is animal partisan focuses on two
- 26:32areas, animal agriculture and research. We are mostly focused on animal agriculture. The vast
- 26:38majority of our work has been in this area. And that is largely because that's where the highest
- 26:43amount of suffering is. The number of animals impacted in the system far exceeds other areas.
- 26:49And that's not at all to say that other areas like wildlife law or animals in captivity are
- 26:55not important. It's just you have to pick and choose where you're going to allocate your time.
- 26:59And so we have, like you said, only been around for a bit. Animal partisan started late last year.
- 27:05As far as actions, you mentioned our most recent action, which is a lawsuit against the FBI,
- 27:11which in the United States is the Federal Bureau of Investigation, one of the top law enforcement
- 27:16agencies. This is in partnership with the Vermont Law and Graduate School Farmed Animal Advocacy
- 27:22Clinic, which is a new clinic at Vermont Law School. So excited to partner with them. My
- 27:27alma mater, they have great things going on there. Plus the Sorensen Law Firm, which specializes in
- 27:33these types of cases. This case is specifically about the Freedom of Information Act, which is a
- 27:39United States law that allows people access to certain records to get a look at the happenings
- 27:45of the government. So animal partisan had requested records from the FBI related to the FBI's
- 27:52participation in various animal agriculture industry conferences. These are conferences
- 27:58put on by the agriculture industry to talk about the business, talk about enhancements,
- 28:04ways to make more money, ways to exchange knowledge. And we wanted to know what was the FBI doing at
- 28:10these conferences? What is the relationship between this federal law enforcement agency
- 28:14and the animal agriculture industry? Are they talking about how to criminalize animal rights
- 28:21activism, how to better target animal rights activists? And we wanted to know that information.
- 28:27And so the FBI denied those requests and we believe those denials were improper. And so we've
- 28:32since sued over them. We believe that they are obligated under federal law to give us those
- 28:37records and shed some light on what their role is with the agriculture industry. So we have filed a
- 28:42lawsuit on that. We have a number of cases that I would say kind of classify as private criminal
- 28:49complaints. In the United States, most criminal complaints are brought by prosecutors or law
- 28:55enforcement officials. I will say that it is very, very, very hard to get a prosecutor or law
- 29:01enforcement official to bring a criminal complaint as it relates to cruelty to animals and agriculture.
- 29:08It would be easier if it were a dog or a cat, kind of back to our earlier conversation, Ryan.
- 29:12But when you go to them and say, this pig was abused or this chicken was abused, it is incredibly
- 29:18hard to get those prosecutions. And so Animal Partisan has taken to some of these private
- 29:24complaints that allow a private citizen to use different procedures to circumvent some of that
- 29:30unwillingness. And we have criminal complaints filed against a poor company for abusing a pig
- 29:37at slaughter, a Wisconsin meat slaughterhouse for breaking the tail of a steer at slaughter,
- 29:44against the Pennsylvania Turkey Company for abusing turkeys, being rounded up for
- 29:49slaughter. That one is in partnership with the Animal Equality, based on a great PETA investigation.
- 29:55So we are using a lot of those to sort of apply these state cruelty laws to animals and agriculture
- 30:01and try to circumvent some of this resistance that is really unfounded. So happy to go on more,
- 30:07but I would say those are some of the kind of primary cases and the stuff going on right now.
- 30:12Yes. Before that, I want to go back to the FBI case. Is it even legal for the FBI to accept an
- 30:21invitation from the agriculture industry to one of their conference? I feel like this should be
- 30:28a nonpartisan institution. So, yeah.
- 30:34Yeah. So I don't think there's anything illegal about it. I think what you're highlighting though
- 30:39demonstrates sort of the state of society. The private animal agriculture industry gets so much
- 30:46support from the government, both state and federal. And so the government is geared towards
- 30:51supporting these industries. I mean, the act of the government is not just a government,
- 30:58but it's a state of animal product consumption is so deeply woven into our society that it is
- 31:02taken apart of the government. So if you look at places like the USDA, the Department of Agriculture,
- 31:09there are huge partnerships going on between the USDA, state agriculture agencies, and private
- 31:15industry actors. We are funneling millions and billions of dollars in subsidies to the agriculture
- 31:20industry. And so it's not, we don't live in a situation, unfortunately, where the government
- 31:26should be a nonpartisan entity that should not be collaborating. Everywhere you look, the government
- 31:31is collaborating with the animal agriculture industry. And in some cases, suppressing the
- 31:36descent of others who are not favorable of animal agriculture. So it's really not a surprise that
- 31:41the FBI is engaged with that industry. You can go back through, there's plenty of cases and actions
- 31:49over the last two, three decades where the FBI has targeted animal rights activists. They've gone to
- 31:54people's homes, they pulled pigs out of sanctuaries that were allegedly stolen from factory farms by
- 32:01direct action everywhere and other groups like that. And so this is not a new thing. You would
- 32:06think it should be nonpartisan, but unfortunately, it's not. We live in a world where government is
- 32:11in bed with the agriculture industry, and that's part of the uphill climb that we have to fight.
- 32:15I feel like there are more urgent matters than going after pigs in sanctuaries for the FBI.
- 32:27Do we know if politicians are being lobbied and supported financially by the agriculture industry?
- 32:39Absolutely. Yeah, I mean, there are the ties between the political world and the agriculture
- 32:44industry are tremendous. I mean, you can look at some of the pieces of legislation that get proposed
- 32:50and the roots of those, where they come from, and even people getting on the floor of the house and
- 32:56talking about, I was approached by XYZ farmer in my community, and that's where this came from. I
- 33:00mean, we've had, I would say the current one is, there's a federal, what's called the EATS Act,
- 33:06which is a response to Proposition 12 and other laws that were prohibiting confinement of animals
- 33:12in cruel conditions. That is coming from agriculture interests. There are what's called ag-gag laws in
- 33:18the United States, which are intended to prevent activists from going into a farm and video
- 33:23recording or audio recording. Those are coming from agriculture interests. And so absolutely,
- 33:29there are tight connections between the animal agriculture industry and politicians,
- 33:33and that is often manifested in laws and bills and attempts to do things or attempts to influence
- 33:40the USDA. So yes, that is definitely the case. So when I hear vegans talk about the agricultural
- 33:49lobby, the animal industry lobby being this powerful, big, bad institution, organization,
- 33:57they write about that. This is not just, what's the word, conspiracy theory.
- 34:04No, not at all. I mean, I would be surprised that anyone would say that. I mean, the agriculture
- 34:12industry is huge. I mean, think of the amount of meat and animal products that are sold in this
- 34:18country. I mean, you can go to any grocery store and walk down the meat aisles and walk down any
- 34:24aisle, the dairy aisle, and it's right there in your face. And there are new products every day,
- 34:28and they fly off the shelves. And every one of those products is X number of dollars that is
- 34:33going somewhere. And the amount of dollars that are woven into that industry are massive. And
- 34:38these industries have trade organizations that they sit on top and say, we're the national pork
- 34:44board. We want to represent all of America's pork producers or the egg board or whatever the case
- 34:50might be. And they pool resources to some extent. They say, look, we have farmers all across the
- 34:56country. We want to have an organization that represents all their interests. They are, in many
- 35:01cases, funded by the member farmers. They're funded by the government. The government has things
- 35:05called checkoff programs where they're channeling money to these associations to promote pork and
- 35:11do certain things. And so, no, it is absolutely the case that these associations and these industries,
- 35:17they wield tremendous power. They wield political power. They wield financial power. That's just a
- 35:23reality of the world we live in. I think denying that puts you at a disadvantage. I think you have
- 35:28to accept it and say, these are the cards that are dealt. This is the mountain that we're up against.
- 35:34And then look at it and figure out how you can pick it apart. What are the laws that create this
- 35:40checkoff program? What can this association do? How are they allowed to spend their money? What
- 35:45can they say and not say? And that's where you start to get your power and you start to see,
- 35:49okay, this is the way it is, but I'm going to look at every one of those laws and I'm going to look
- 35:53at their requirements. I'm going to figure out what can they do? What can they not do? And where
- 35:57can I find something that they're doing that they should not do and bring that to attention? File a
- 36:02lawsuit, file litigation, expose it. That's where your power comes from by facing sort of the issues
- 36:07that are out there. It's the same as what I mentioned with the suffering. You just have to
- 36:11look at it in the face and you have to empower yourself and say, this is what I'm dealing with.
- 36:15Now, where can I go and what can I do to stop it? I can forgive the consumers for
- 36:21supporting this industry, consuming animal products. You can blame it on culture. You can blame it on
- 36:27cognitive dissonance and such, but the executives, the people running those industries,
- 36:35that I don't understand. Do you know if they are aware of the suffering they are causing?
- 36:43Yeah, I mean, I don't think you can not be aware. I mean, if you are an executive for a company that
- 36:53slaughters animals for a business, even if you are so far removed that you're not a part of the
- 36:59business every day, there is some point where you've seen the suffering. You've seen or you've
- 37:04heard the screams of the pigs as they come in on the trucks or you've watched a cow that's been
- 37:11stunned improperly stagger and fall down. There's no excuse for not knowing. I mean, that's the
- 37:16business and I think we have to acknowledge that the people that run these companies know that
- 37:21they're suffering. I think you probably get a lot of cognitive dissonance where these people think
- 37:26that animals are lesser and they don't have the capacity to suffer. Whatever I've just heard,
- 37:33the screams from the pigs, that's not as bad as the screams of a child or some human being.
- 37:37I think a lot of people have convinced themselves that these animals are more like widgets or
- 37:42commodities and that they don't have the capacity to feel and suffer like we do. That's probably
- 37:47what helps people get by. I think other people probably know and they acknowledge the suffering,
- 37:53but they just don't care because that's the business that they're in. They want to produce
- 37:57money. They might label it as they want to feed America and be patriotic or whatever the case
- 38:02might be. I don't think there's any of them that don't recognize that there's suffering happening.
- 38:08Some of them may obscure it behind, oh, it's not as bad as I think it is, but there's money involved
- 38:14and this is a livelihood for people. It gets back to the equation of money and the eyes of many
- 38:20weighs more than the suffering of a living conscious being. That's again, the unfortunate
- 38:25reality of the world we live in. Let's get back to David. David, you're a
- 38:30great speaker. Let's get back to those legal cases. What are some of the victories you've had against
- 38:37this industry on the court? Sure. Like you said, we've only been around for a short while.
- 38:45I will say even though in that short time, we already have multiple cases scheduled for trial.
- 38:53I can't say too much on one of them, but on our poor case, we have trial scheduled later this fall
- 38:59where an actual corporation has been charged with animal cruelty. That doesn't happen. In many cases,
- 39:05the cases where cruelty is charged, it might be an individual person is charged, but a corporate
- 39:11entity can be charged with cruelty for conduct that happens beneath the purview of that corporation.
- 39:17We have a trial scheduled. I think the fact that we have a trial scheduled, we had a judge review
- 39:24our complaint and realized that there's probably enough here to go forward and argue whether or
- 39:28not cruelty happened. That's significant. We actually have two of those. One of those I can't
- 39:32really get into, but there are two trials scheduled for corporations charged with animal cruelty for
- 39:37cruelty to animals and agriculture. That is huge. That just doesn't happen. In decades and decades,
- 39:43there have probably only been a handful of corporations charged, much less convicted.
- 39:48I would say that's been a victory. We've had a lot of wonderful partnerships in our short time.
- 39:54I mentioned Vermont Law School. We're partnering with Animal Equality on things. We've got a lot of
- 39:59other great partnerships building. We've got a lot of litigation ideas in development,
- 40:05cases that will be filed in the next two, three, four, five, six months that will be going out.
- 40:10Then one of the other things I would say has been a significant achievement is that we spend a lot
- 40:15of time trying to develop the field of animal law to help law students interested in this field
- 40:21grow to help attorneys who may be practicing in other fields get experience. I think since we've
- 40:27been founded, we've helped about 17 law students and eight attorneys get experience in this field.
- 40:33They've worked on projects for us. They provided invaluable support to animal partisan. At the same
- 40:38time, many of them have gotten coaching, mentorship, support, exposure to how to practice in this field.
- 40:44That is just going to grow the movement. The more people out there that know and care about these
- 40:48issues and can deal with them legally, the better. I would say the trials we have scheduled, we did
- 40:54get a conviction for animal cruelty for an individual that kicked a lamb in the face during
- 40:59slaughter. That was early on, so that conviction has happened. We've gotten some media coverage of
- 41:04our cases in local media where these slaughterhouses exist. That is helpful even beyond the criminal
- 41:11justice system for people who read these papers and these news sources to just see how they're
- 41:17doing in their community. That in many cases is more profound than anything else. Those would be
- 41:22some of the important things I would highlight. You said how you decided to focus on agriculture
- 41:28but also the research industry. What about the research industry? What is happening right now
- 41:37and what are you pursuing in terms of legal cases? Absolutely. Some of the research that we do is
- 41:47overlocked. There was a recent study that came out that speculated on the number of animals in
- 41:54research of being over 100 million. It is not an insubstantial amount of animals. Granted, when you
- 42:00look at animals in agriculture, we're talking eight or nine billion chickens every year. The
- 42:06numbers are smaller but it is not an insubstantial amount of animals. They are suffering in many
- 42:11cases in different ways. They are certainly kept in confinement, small spaces. I was just watching a
- 42:19video before this podcast of some sheep at a lactation experiment in upstate New York that were
- 42:26confined to probably four foot by six foot little metal kennels in a concrete room. I can compare
- 42:32that of the sheep that we live with who are roaming the pastures all day, forging in the grass,
- 42:38and so they are suffering in similar ways like that where they are being prohibited from
- 42:44expressing normal behaviors. They are being subjected to experiments. They are being
- 42:50drugged, strapped into machines, bred and kept in captivity, and then killed to have their brains
- 42:56dissected, their blood drawn. They are suffering in similar ways. They are suffering in different
- 43:01ways in many cases and not a small number of animals. Animal partisanship is a very common
- 43:07thing in our community and in our communities. We have been very active in this area. We have
- 43:12been working with the Department of Agriculture, the Department of Agriculture, the Department of
- 43:15Agriculture to get information about what is happening in the animals. Animal partisan, this
- 43:20is a smaller focus area for us but a lot of our early work here has been public records work to
- 43:26try to gain transparency into what is happening, to try to find information about what are these
- 43:31studies, what animals are being used. We have been on the search for videos of these experiments to
- 43:37a number of those videos to try to show people what is happening to animals behind the scenes.
- 43:42Public records work has been some of that. We did file a lawsuit early against a university.
- 43:47That case has since ended for various reasons but we are still focused on public records work,
- 43:53getting those records, potentially litigating some issues where records have been denied just
- 43:58like the FBI did. I would say the other area that is of interest for us is back to the state cruelty
- 44:05laws. We talked about how hard it is to apply cruelty laws to animals in agriculture. The same
- 44:11applies to animals in research but we are developing some case ideas to try to argue in various states
- 44:18that conduct committed to animals in research was cruelty and should be punished criminally.
- 44:24I cannot get into too much but I would say we probably have two scenarios where we are
- 44:28not far off from filing private criminal complaints related to animal research to try to
- 44:34set some precedent because you are in a laboratory and you have a lab coat. It does not mean that
- 44:39certain things that you might do to an animal are not cruelty and we want to use the legal system
- 44:44to demonstrate that. We have some cases lined up to try to explore that a little bit further.
- 44:50What do you say to people who claim that the farm industry is one thing but research is something
- 45:00else entirely. We are developing drugs against cancer. We need to do those tests on animals.
- 45:10Do you think they are right? Is it justified suffering?
- 45:18I do not think there is much difference to be honest with you. I think you have to start with
- 45:21the base question I asked earlier which is should we be doing this or should we just accept at face
- 45:28value that we should not do this to another being that is conscious and can suffer. I do not think
- 45:34you get into the justification like this is food and this is a drug. I think many people would say
- 45:40food is more important. You have a lot of poverty and starvation in this world and some would say
- 45:44food is more important than drug testing or pain medication or things like that. I think you can
- 45:50argue the relative importance of either one but I think you come back to the same conclusion and
- 45:55say regardless of which one you choose are either of them worth exposing an unwilling conscious
- 46:02sentient suffering being to these certain things. Then you have to stack that up with the alternatives.
- 46:07It is the same in the food space where you have plant-based alternatives and those types of
- 46:11things. There are alternatives to animal research and I am not going to claim to be the expert and
- 46:17there are plenty of groups doing good work in this space but it is not like a situation where we have
- 46:21no alternatives and it is just like all or nothing. I would argue that even if it were all or nothing,
- 46:26we still should not be doing it but it is kind of the same situation. You should not be doing it to
- 46:31begin with and there are alternatives and people need to be looking for ways to move out of that
- 46:37space. I think there are some that are doing that but there is just far too much research happening.
- 46:43There is money woven into that as well. If you explore the grants and if you explore
- 46:48the funding, there are people who are making their careers doing research that is funded by the
- 46:53government that has given them money to do a research experiment that has been done before
- 46:59and has been done before. People are making their livelihood over this. I do not think in short it
- 47:04is that much of a different question. I think you start with the should we be doing this to begin
- 47:09with and then you look at the alternatives and I think you have to acknowledge that
- 47:12probably not something we should do. We should be moving away from it.
- 47:15Yes, let me just mention that it is not always the noble image that is sold to us. Like you said,
- 47:23there is economic interest behind it. Let us start with cosmetics. I think you do not need to test
- 47:31your cosmetics on animals. Let us at least for a minimum agree on that. You walked us through
- 47:41some of your current and future cases. I want to know what can we do to support your mission,
- 47:50to support what you are doing and to have more victories against this industry to make it more
- 48:00accountable for its horrendous behavior and exploitation toward animals.
- 48:07Yes, I think one, support animal partisan but just support the cause in general. There are so many
- 48:17good groups that are doing this and I think the first thing I would say is just commit to doing
- 48:22something, whatever that is. I love support for animal partisan. I can talk about that in a minute,
- 48:27but just commit to doing something. Recognize that this is a problem and we each have 24 hours in the
- 48:34day and many of those hours are consumed by scrolling through social media, watching memes
- 48:39or videos or things like that that are not meaningful or not impactful. We each have the
- 48:44capacity to do something. That could be anything. Literally, get on your computer, search for a
- 48:50petition, go walk dogs at the shelter, whatever the case might be. Call your congressperson.
- 48:57Do whatever you want to do. The first thing I would say is do something. We are not in a situation
- 49:01where we can just say, other people have it, other people have got it covered. The individual
- 49:06people that step up and take action is what is needed. We need masses of people that are going
- 49:12to do that. I should give a plug. We often forget about the grassroots activists, the people out
- 49:18doing protests or disruptions or things like that. If that is your thing, look for groups in your
- 49:23area. Those groups are strengthened by more people out in the streets doing things. I would
- 49:29start with the premise of do something, whatever that is, and give your time and give your passion.
- 49:34Then second is, as far as Animal Partisan, we are a brand new organization. We would love any
- 49:39support that we can get. We are very small. The intent is to be lean and tenacious like you
- 49:45mentioned earlier. You can find Animal Partisan on Instagram. You can like the Instagram page.
- 49:50We are on Facebook. We are on LinkedIn. Any kind of support just through liking the page.
- 49:55Donations are obviously welcome as well. You can go on animalpartisan.org and there is a support
- 50:00tab. You can sign up for an email list. You can donate. You can spread the word. I work with so
- 50:07many other wonderful groups and I cannot help but plug them as well. There are plenty of other
- 50:11groups doing just as good work. Support them as well. I think my message would be do something,
- 50:19take your time, use it for something good. If it is just, I do not have much time, then support
- 50:25the groups that do have the time and do have the passion. Go on social media, like them, follow
- 50:30them, comment, subscribe. Fund, support, whatever you can do to support these groups would be very
- 50:37invaluable and we would appreciate it. It feels amazing to be an early supporter of an initiative,
- 50:43of an organization, of anything. It feels exciting. You are the first wave and you are looking at this
- 50:55organization and all its potential. I think there is something really exciting about it.
- 51:00But people will find links to your organization website but also to the donation page in the
- 51:08description below. Fantastic. I think you are right. I hesitate to use the word exciting because
- 51:17I would rather not be doing this work but we have to do it because the animals are suffering.
- 51:23I think it speaks to the opportunities to do something. It is not like you just look at this
- 51:29one legal theory and that is all you can do. No, it is every day. You can look at information,
- 51:34search for records, find out what the businesses are doing and explore all of these new legal
- 51:39theories and strategies. There is a sea of opportunity out there and that part is exciting.
- 51:46Where are the levers that we can pull to reduce suffering and animal exploitation, challenge these
- 51:52industries for what we are doing? There most certainly is excitement in that. It is what keeps
- 51:57me going every day. I think whatever we do is meaningful. Whatever we can do to impede the
- 52:03tide of what is being done to animals is meaningful. I appreciate the support.
- 52:11You know about it, this misanthropic sentiment in the vegan community and looking at other people
- 52:19making a difference and working hard for the cause of animal welfare just makes me have
- 52:28a new appreciation for humanity. I think we are not all bad. There are some very good people among
- 52:40us and you are part of them. Did you have anything more to add before we end this conversation?
- 52:50We do not. You have covered a lot of ground and I sincerely appreciate it. Like I said at the start,
- 52:54I would give a plug to you Ryan. I think what you are doing is a great example of what I just
- 52:59talked about. You are doing something. You said at some point this is an issue. I have the capacity
- 53:04to do this. You are clearly doing a wonderful job. Take a page for listeners and viewers. Take a
- 53:10page from Ryan's playbook and just do something. Whatever it is, whatever skills you have,
- 53:16put them to use. I do not have anything more. I think my last plug would be there is so much
- 53:22suffering in this world. Do not for a minute be appeased and think that the new plant-based burger
- 53:28came out and everything is good. No. If you look for it, it is out there. We have limited time on
- 53:33this planet. I think we just need to put our heads down and turn away. Whatever we can do to help,
- 53:38do it. You will feel more fulfilled. You will reduce suffering. I think it takes all of us
- 53:43and I appreciate the opportunity and I appreciate all the great questions.
- 53:46Of course. Thank you so much William for your work and for having accepted my invitation and
- 53:54for having taken the time to answer my questions. Thank you everyone for listening. More people
- 54:02deserve to know about animal partisan and their effective work. Make sure to share this episode
- 54:08with family and friends. Next week, we are continuing the veteran vegan series with Chris.
- 54:16Chris is a teacher by profession and he became vegan for health reasons. In my conversation
- 54:22with Chris, we talk a lot about food and strategies to advocate for veganism. And Chris is very good
- 54:30at that. I love his approach. Subscribe now and don't miss out on this episode. Finally, you can
- 54:37always reach me on Instagram at veganreportpodcast. Thank you again for listening. Take care and see
- 54:45you next Tuesday.