Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / First Principles on Gold
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the deep dive. This is where we take those big
- 0:02enduring subjects, pull together the key sources and really try
- 0:05to give you the essential knowledge you need.
- 0:07And today we're tackling a fascinating 1 gold.
- 0:10We're looking at the science, the symbolism, and maybe most
- 0:13importantly, the financial strategy behind what is probably
- 0:16the world's most persistent asset.
- 0:18OK, so let's unpack this a bit. We need to go way beyond just
- 0:21thinking about, you know, jewelry or bars locked away
- 0:25somewhere. Our mission here is to
- 0:26understand the the enduring power of the single element AKU,
- 0:31atomic number 79. Why does it hold such universal,
- 0:34almost non negotiable value even though it doesn't generate any
- 0:36yield? We've got sources covering
- 0:38everything from it's like cosmic birthright up to its role in the
- 0:422025 financial outlook. It really is one of the great
- 0:45paradoxes in finance, isn't it? We see gold as this ultimate
- 0:49store of value, the bedrock of wealth.
- 0:52But strategically speaking, it's kind of a lazy asset.
- 0:56It doesn't pay you anything, no dividend, it doesn't house
- 0:58anyone, and it doesn't really contribute to industrial
- 1:01production like, say, copper, iron does.
- 1:03So is this value truly inherent? Does it come from its physical
- 1:07stuff? Or is it more like what some
- 1:09critics say, just a massive self fulfilling historical agreement?
- 1:13The sort of tradition we really have to look past the shiny
- 1:15surface, I think, and analyze both that deep cultural mandate
- 1:18and the strategic financial job it does today.
- 1:21Yeah, I agree completely. And to start getting at that,
- 1:23let's jump right into the fundamentals part one, the first
- 1:26principles before we even touch on markets.
- 1:29Why is this metal physically special?
- 1:31What made it so irresistible to ancient people and, you know,
- 1:34still makes it utterly reliable for modern tech?
- 1:37Well, the physical properties are really the foundation for
- 1:39everything else that came later. Gold is uniquely workable.
- 1:43It's actually the most malleable and the most ductile metal we
- 1:46know. It's extraordinary.
- 1:47Right. And that's where you get those
- 1:48incredible facts you see in the sources.
- 1:50I mean, think about this for a second.
- 1:52A single ounce of gold that's only about 31 grams can be
- 1:57hammered out into a sheet that covers 9 square meters.
- 1:59That's so thin you can practically see through it.
- 2:01It's wild. Exactly.
- 2:03Or if you prefer wires, that same little oz can be drawn into
- 2:07a thread 80 kilometers long. That's what, a 50 mile drive?
- 2:11And the wire is only 5 microns thick?
- 2:13Just incredibly fine. This ability to be shaped so
- 2:16easily without breaking meant that even ancient civilizations
- 2:20with fairly basic tools could take a raw nugget and turn it
- 2:23into, well, exquisite art or coins.
- 2:26And beyond being workable, it feels substantial, right?
- 2:28It's extremely dense, 19.3g per cubic centimeter, that's nearly
- 2:32twice as dense as lead. And the color that bright
- 2:35lustrous yellow, it's really unusual among common metals only
- 2:38copper has a distinct non silvery color.
- 2:41Our sources actually point out something pretty amazing, that
- 2:42gold unique color is due to relativistic effects and it's
- 2:45electron structure. Yeah, That term relativistic
- 2:48effects, it often sounds like pure jargon, but it's
- 2:52fascinating stuff. Essentially, in heavier elements
- 2:56like gold, the electrons are orbiting the nucleus so
- 2:59incredibly fast that the laws of relativity, you know, Einstein's
- 3:03theories, actually start to influence their behavior, sort
- 3:06of tightens their orbits. And this changes how the atom
- 3:09absorbs and reflects light. So it's actually physics, not
- 3:12just chemistry, that gives gold that distinctive, warm and,
- 3:16crucially, incorruptible yellow color.
- 3:17OK, so physics makes it look good, but it's the chemistry
- 3:20that makes it last forever. Exactly right.
- 3:22Gold is what we call a noble metal.
- 3:24That means it's almost completely chemically inert.
- 3:26It just doesn't react easily. It won't oxidize.
- 3:28It weren't rusted, weren't tarnishing air or water, not
- 3:30even if you leave it exposed for, well, millennia.
- 3:33This is the really crucial property.
- 3:34Which explains why those, you know, 3000 year old Egyptian
- 3:37artifacts still shine like they were buried yesterday.
- 3:40Amazing. You need something incredibly
- 3:42aggressive like that potent acid mix Aqua regia just to get it to
- 3:46dissolve. And that chemical stability
- 3:48translates directly into modern usefulness because it never
- 3:52corrodes and it's a fantastic conductor of electricity.
- 3:55It's absolutely essential in high performance, high
- 3:58reliability electronics. Think about critical contacts,
- 4:01circuit boards, places where failure just isn't an option.
- 4:05The electronics industry actually uses around 300 tons of
- 4:07gold every single year purely for that reliability factor.
- 4:11And we shouldn't forget those other modern uses too, like an
- 4:13aerospace. They use gold coatings to
- 4:15reflect infrared radiation. You see it on astronaut helmet
- 4:17visors, and it's biocompatible, right?
- 4:19So it's valuable in things like advanced dentistry and even some
- 4:22cutting edge drug delivery research.
- 4:23But beneath all these practical applications lies the real
- 4:26foundation of its price scarcity.
- 4:28Ah yes, that's the real kicker, isn't it?
- 4:31We love it because it lasts forever, but we prize it because
- 4:34it's almost impossibly rare. Gold atoms.
- 4:37And actually all the other heavy elements, they aren't made
- 4:39inside ordinary stars like our Sun.
- 4:41They're only forged during the most cataclysmic cosmic events,
- 4:45like massive supernova explosions, or maybe even more
- 4:48dramatic, the collision of neutron stars.
- 4:51It is quite literally Stardust. And when you add up the total
- 4:54supply ever mined, that scarcity becomes really tangible, almost
- 4:58visceral. All the gold ever extracted by
- 5:00humans and all of history is estimated at only about 200,000
- 5:04tons. Now try to picture that entire
- 5:06global stock. All the bullion involves, all
- 5:08the jewelry, all the gold in our electronics melted down into one
- 5:11single block. It would form a cube just 21
- 5:13meters on each side. You could fit the whole lot
- 5:15inside a single Olympic size swimming pool.
- 5:17That's it. Staggering when you think of it
- 5:19like that. And that small quantity is
- 5:21effectively the base against which so much global wealth is
- 5:24implicitly measured. Which leads us perfectly into
- 5:27Part 2, the human element. How did this small, dense,
- 5:32permanent cube of metal go from being just a shiny curiosity to
- 5:36becoming the ultimate symbol of value?
- 5:38Well, it seems to be a story that blends psychology and
- 5:40history, right? Those inherent properties we
- 5:42just talked about, the sun, like shine.
- 5:44The fact that it doesn't decay made it really easy for early
- 5:46civilizations to sort of imbue it with this mystical, almost
- 5:49divine status. Absolutely.
- 5:51You look at the ancient Egyptians going way back to
- 5:53maybe 3000 BCE. Gold was directly associated
- 5:57with eternity, with divinity. It was seen as a physical
- 6:01representation of the sun God rise immortal flesh, so using it
- 6:05for the Pharaoh's funeral mass, like to tank a moon's wasn't
- 6:08just about decoration, it was about ensuring their eternal
- 6:10permanence, their connection to the divine.
- 6:12And that deep trust in its permanence made gold the natural
- 6:15choice when economy started needing a universal trusted way
- 6:19to measure value. The Kingdom of Lydia over modern
- 6:22day Turkey around the 6th century BCE, is famous for
- 6:25minting some of the very first standardized gold coins.
- 6:28They established it as a medium of exchange that basically
- 6:30everyone trusted because while it was rare, it was durable and
- 6:33it was universally desired. Easy to reckon A it's hard to
- 6:35fake. And the desire for this metal,
- 6:38the pure lust for it, has literally reshaped maps and
- 6:42sparked centuries of conflict. I mean, you think about the
- 6:45Spanish conquistadors in the Americas ruthlessly dismantling
- 6:49entire empires like the Aztec and Inca, primarily for their
- 6:53gold and silver wealth that fueled Europe's rise.
- 6:56And then later you have events like the California Gold Rush in
- 6:591849 that didn't just make a few people rich, it fundamentally
- 7:03reorganized populations and economies across continents, all
- 7:06chasing gold. It's definitely more than just
- 7:09money, though. Gold functions is this profound
- 7:11human symbol. It represents wealth, sure, but
- 7:13also achievement. Think about Olympic gold medals,
- 7:15trophies, and commitment of the tradition of wedding rings.
- 7:18It carries status precisely because it's rare, but not
- 7:21impossibly rare. It's obtainable setting a sort
- 7:23of physical standard for excellence or significance.
- 7:26Yeah. And the really fascinating part
- 7:28maybe is how that value system seems entirely self reinforcing
- 7:32overtime. We hoard it not just for its
- 7:34industrial uses, but because we collectively believe in its
- 7:37enduring value. It's that shared belief passed
- 7:40down across cultures for millennia that really fuels its
- 7:43non material value, maybe even more than its physical
- 7:46properties. Which forces us right into Part
- 7:483. Gold is a financial asset.
- 7:51How does this metal, rooted in ancient beliefs and cosmic
- 7:55rarity, actually function within today's ultra modern, highly
- 7:58digitized global financial system?
- 8:00Well, the big historical turning point, obviously, was 1971.
- 8:04That's when the US officially severed the dollars linked to
- 8:06gold, ending the Bretton Woods system and the last real
- 8:09remnants of the official gold standard.
- 8:10And yet, even today, central banks around the world
- 8:13collectively hold something like 1/5 of all the gold ever mined.
- 8:16That's around 35,000 tons sitting in their vaults as
- 8:19foreign exchange reserves. That's a huge ongoing
- 8:22commitment. It is, and that strategic
- 8:24holding really defines its modern function.
- 8:26Gold is seen as the ultimate safe haven asset, the currency
- 8:30of last resort, you might say. Crucially, it carries zero
- 8:33credit risk. It's not someone else's
- 8:35liability or promise to pay, unlike a bond or even currency
- 8:38deposits. And perhaps most importantly, no
- 8:41government or central bank can just decide to create more of it
- 8:44out of thin air like they can with Fiat currency.
- 8:46It can't be debased by policy decisions in the same way, so
- 8:50fundamentally it acts as a kind of insurance policy against
- 8:53those very policy decisions against instability.
- 8:56And that long term stability is just astounding.
- 8:58When you look back. There's that famous anecdote
- 9:00which holds up surprisingly well, that an ounce of gold
- 9:03could buy a Roman senator a fine toga back in ancient Rome.
- 9:06And today, that same Oz will buy you a pretty high quality
- 9:09tailored suit. Its purchasing power has
- 9:11remained remarkably stable across centuries, even
- 9:13millennia, in a way that no paper currency is ever managed.
- 9:17Exactly, and that inherent stability explains why gold
- 9:21tends to perform best, or at least becomes most attractive,
- 9:24when real interest rates are low or negative.
- 9:27That's the interest rate you get after you account for inflation.
- 9:30If you can't get a decent, secure return on government
- 9:33bonds or cash that outpaces inflation, then the opportunity
- 9:37cost of holding gold, which pays you nothing drops dramatically,
- 9:40becomes much more appealing. That's why you typically see
- 9:43huge surges in gold demand during periods of major
- 9:45financial turmoil, like after the 2008 crisis, or during times
- 9:49of high inflation and low growth, like the stagflation of
- 9:52the 1970s. OK, but this brings us right
- 9:54back to that core debate about valuation.
- 9:57We've established its unique physical trades, its deep
- 9:59history, its modern utility in tech.
- 10:01But we still have to tackle the critics.
- 10:03If it doesn't pay interest and its industrial used only
- 10:05accounts for a fraction of its price, is it intrinsically well
- 10:09worth or at least overvalued? This is where that famous Warren
- 10:12Buffett critique always comes up.
- 10:14Ah yes, his analogy is brutally effective, isn't it?
- 10:17He pointed out quite vividly that gold gets dug out of the
- 10:21ground in Africa or someplace. Then we melt it down, dig
- 10:24another hole, bury it again and pay people to stand around
- 10:27guarding it. He concluded it has no utility.
- 10:31Anyone watching from Mars would be scratching their head.
- 10:33It's a powerful image. It really is, and it sounds like
- 10:36a pretty strong argument against holding it right.
- 10:38If one of the world's most respected investors basically
- 10:40calls it a pointless exercise, why do we continue to value it
- 10:43so highly? Because I think we have to be
- 10:45careful to distinguish between different types of value, we
- 10:48need to separate its use value from its exchange value.
- 10:52Now, if gold were priced purely on its tangible use value for
- 10:55electronics, dentistry, maybe some jewelry, its price would
- 10:58almost certainly be far, far lower than it is today.
- 11:01Buffett is right about its limited productive capacity.
- 11:04But it's high market price, it's exchange value, isn't really
- 11:07based on that. It's sustained almost entirely
- 11:09by that collector trust we talked about.
- 11:11Combined with its undeniable, unforgeable scarcity and
- 11:14permanence, you could almost argue that gold's inherent
- 11:17properties, it's durability, it's rarity, the difficulty of
- 11:20faking it, give it a sort of natural fitness to be money, as
- 11:23economists used to say. It's the closest thing humanity
- 11:26has ever found to a monetary asset that isn't dependent on
- 11:29the promises or the stability of any single government or
- 11:32institution. It acts as a kind of universal
- 11:35hedge against human error, political instability, and
- 11:38currency debasement. And that, you could argue, is
- 11:41its intrinsic monetary value. Its value is trust.
- 11:44That makes a lot of sense. So it's an asset of last resort
- 11:46because it sits outside the direct control of anyone
- 11:50government's fiscal or monetary policy.
- 11:53OK, let's pivot then to the market dynamics right now.
- 11:55Part 4. What's driving the gold price
- 11:58today and what's the general outlook as we look towards, say,
- 12:012025? Well, the first thing you always
- 12:03have to remember with gold is its unusual supply situation.
- 12:07Unlike oil or corn or other commodities, new mining only
- 12:11adds maybe 1 to 2% to the total existing above ground stock each
- 12:14year. It's a tiny addition, so shifts
- 12:17in demand from investors, from jewelry buyers and really
- 12:20crucially in recent years from central banks tend to have an
- 12:23oversized impact on the place. Supply is relatively fixed in
- 12:26the short term. And our sources consistently
- 12:28point to two major inverse drivers of that price, right,
- 12:31the strength of the US dollar and the level of interest rates.
- 12:34Exactly. Gold is priced globally in U.S.
- 12:38dollars. So all else being equal, when
- 12:41the dollar strengthens against other currencies, it takes fewer
- 12:43dollars to buy an ounce of gold, which tends to push the dollar
- 12:46price of gold down. Conversely, a stronger dollar
- 12:49makes gold more expensive for buyers using other currencies,
- 12:52which can dampen demand. And we already touched on
- 12:55interest rates. When real interest rates rise,
- 12:57holding a non yielding asset like gold becomes less
- 13:00attractive compared to earning interest on bonds or cash.
- 13:04That increases the opportunity cost and usually puts downward
- 13:07pressure on the gold price. Gold tends to thrive when rates
- 13:10are low. But the factor that seems to
- 13:12have been absolutely crucial in recent years, the one that's
- 13:15provided A consistent floor under the price even when rates
- 13:18were rising, has been this extraordinary wave of central
- 13:20bank buying. We saw a record purchases back
- 13:22in 2022 / 1100 tons and then continued massive buying in
- 13:262023, again exceeding 1000 tons. This isn't just routine
- 13:30portfolio tweaking, is it? No, absolutely not.
- 13:33This appears to be quite strategic.
- 13:34These huge purchases driven largely by central banks and
- 13:37emerging economies, think China, India, Turkey, Poland seem to
- 13:43reflect a deliberate long term shift.
- 13:46They're clearly seeking diversification away from
- 13:48perhaps and over reliance on the US dollar in their reserves.
- 13:52They might also be hedging against the risk of global
- 13:54sanctions, building resilience against geopolitical pensions,
- 13:57and just generally wanting a larger holding of a neutral
- 13:59reserve asset. This continuous strategic demand
- 14:03from powerful sovereign entities provides a massive, fairly
- 14:06consistent pillar of support for the gold price, independent of
- 14:09short term investor sentiment. And you couple that with gold's
- 14:12traditional role as the ultimate crisis commodity.
- 14:14Any flare up in geopolitical tensions, whether it's conflict
- 14:17like the war in Ukraine or rising trade friction between
- 14:20major powers like the US and China, tends to spur automatic
- 14:23safe haven buying. People just reach for gold when
- 14:25they're nervous. And it seems like all those
- 14:27factors really came together strongly in 2024 gold surge to
- 14:31hit new nominal all time highs, briefly breaking above $2265 an
- 14:36ounce. And interestingly, this surge
- 14:39was driven primarily by that relentless central bank demand
- 14:41and safe haven investment flows, even while consumer demand for
- 14:44things like jewelry actually cooled off of it because the
- 14:46price got so high. So looking ahead now into 2025,
- 14:50where does this leave the gold market?
- 14:52Is there still more room for it to run or is it maybe reaching a
- 14:55kind of peak after that big move?
- 14:56Well, the current consensus outlook seems to be leaning
- 14:58towards consolidation perhaps Gold has been trading on a
- 15:01historically high plateau generally hovering in that range
- 15:04between say 2000 down $2100 an ounce, maybe a bit higher
- 15:08recently. The sort of base case scenario
- 15:10might be for range bound movement, maybe drifting
- 15:13sideways if we see a period of relative global stability
- 15:16return. That would involve balancing the
- 15:18current headwind of still relatively high real interest
- 15:21rates against that ongoing tailwind of central bank demand
- 15:24and underlying geopolitical uncertainty.
- 15:27However, and this is important, the risk seems skewed
- 15:29significantly to the upside. Any major unexpected negative
- 15:32surprise like a deeper than expected economic recession
- 15:36forcing rates down, or a sudden major geopolitical flare up, or
- 15:39perhaps most critically, a clear and decisive pivot by the Fed
- 15:42and other major central banks towards cutting interest rates.
- 15:45Any of those could likely trigger a substantial investor
- 15:47rush back into gold, pushing the price significantly higher as
- 15:50that opportunity cost of holding it suddenly evaporates.
- 15:53That really paints A comprehensive picture.
- 15:55So gold, when you boil it all down, remains this truly
- 15:58timeless asset. Its value seems constantly
- 16:00reinforced by these dual forces. On one hand, it's fundamental
- 16:04physical scarcity, literally forged in dying stars incredibly
- 16:07resistant to decay, and on the other, this powerful collective
- 16:10human belief system that sees it as a universal symbol of wealth,
- 16:14status, and enduring stability. Absolutely.
- 16:17Gold stays resilient precisely because it occupies this unique
- 16:20space. It manages to straddle the line
- 16:23between being a tangible physical commodity with real
- 16:26technological uses and being an essential, globally recognized
- 16:30monetary reserve asset held by nations and individuals alike.
- 16:35It's both profoundly physical and profoundly symbolic.
- 16:38And maybe here's a final provocative thought for you, the
- 16:41listener, to Mull over something that ties back to that core
- 16:43paradox we started with. Gold's price is often described
- 16:46as being set by the market's constant tug of war between two
- 16:49powerful opposing forces, Essentially, hope versus fear,
- 16:53economic optimism versus financial anxiety.
- 16:56So if the price of gold is currently sitting at or near
- 16:58historically high levels, what does that really imply?
- 17:01Not just about gold own enduring worth, But perhaps more
- 17:03tellingly, what does this suggest about the global
- 17:05financial systems collective level of confidence, or maybe
- 17:07lack thereof, in the long term stability of our Fiat currencies
- 17:10and the governments that stand behind them?
- 17:12Viewed that way, the price of gold isn't just a measure of its
- 17:14own value. It might be one of the most
- 17:16potent barometers we have for gauging the world's underlying
- 17:19uncertainty.