Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / What Do Robert’s Rules Have to Do with Faith in Christ? A Conversation with Parliamentarian, Kirby Glad
Transcript
- 0:00Coming up on the Together for Good podcast, I'm talking with
- 0:02Kirby. Glad he's going to be the
- 0:04parliamentarian at the upcoming Rocky Mountain Synod Assembly.
- 0:08Please don't turn it off yet. I know that sounds boring, but
- 0:11Kirby's awesome and it was a delight.
- 0:13And we get into not only what a parliamentarian does and how
- 0:17Robert's Rules of Order works, all those fun things, but it's
- 0:19also a real faith conversation too, about our theme for the
- 0:22assembly, life in Christ, and the ways that we see some
- 0:25parallels between what Robert's Rules is trying to do and what
- 0:28life in Christ really it means. It's cool.
- 0:31Kirby's going to be awesome. I can't wait for you to meet
- 0:33him. Here we go.
- 0:34Welcome to the Together for Good podcast, a podcast created by
- 0:37Bethany Lutheran Church in Cherry Hills Village, Co and
- 0:41hosted by me, Pastor Nate Pricinger and Together for Good.
- 0:45Our goal is to provide practical, engaging content that
- 0:49supports you without expectations.
- 0:51Whether you're feeling disconnected from traditional
- 0:53religion or simply exploring what faith means in your life,
- 0:57we are here to walk alongside you.
- 0:59No matter where you are on your journey of faith.
- 1:02We're glad you're here. Welcome to Together for Good.
- 1:05Well, welcome everyone to another episode of the Together
- 1:08for Good podcast. I am on a call with Kirby.
- 1:12Glad he is going to be the parliamentarian for the upcoming
- 1:16Rocky Mountain Senate Assembly. Hi Kirby.
- 1:18Can you hear me OK? I can hear you fine and vice
- 1:21versa. Excellent.
- 1:22I'm so glad that we were able to figure out a way to make this
- 1:25connection. This is going to be a fun one
- 1:27and really different from some of the other conversations
- 1:29because the parliamentarian plays a very strange role within
- 1:33a Senate assembly. That's a good way of putting it,
- 1:36yes. So let's start right there.
- 1:38What do you even do? What's what's your role in this?
- 1:41That is such a good question. So parliamentarian parliamentary
- 1:46simply means meetings. And you know this like from the
- 1:51British Parliament, it's a, it's a deliberative body.
- 1:56So what the parliamentarian does is make sure that the meeting
- 2:00runs efficiently and smoothly. I like to say better, faster,
- 2:04more enjoyable meetings. And by that I mean that we're
- 2:09following the procedures. So not only obeying the
- 2:13constitution and the bylaws, but also making sure we're following
- 2:16Robert's Rules. And the reason for this is not
- 2:19just rule observance. So when people know that
- 2:24Robert's Rules is going to be used, they know what to expect.
- 2:27They know how to participate. Everyone's on an equal footing
- 2:30in terms of participating in the meeting.
- 2:32And that's what's important to me as a parliamentarian.
- 2:34Everyone feels like they can't participate.
- 2:37Everyone has the right to in discussion, to convince the
- 2:41assembly that their point of view is the one that they should
- 2:45hold. And then we have all vote and
- 2:48then we follow what the majority decides.
- 2:50And so to me, that's what a parliamentarian does, is just as
- 2:54an expert in the meeting and making the meeting better.
- 2:59Yeah, and I mean, I have so many.
- 3:01I've worked with Robert's Rules for a long time.
- 3:04I got uninvolved in church stuff from a young age and so was
- 3:07going to Senate assemblies and at like 14 and learning about
- 3:10Robert's Rules of Order. So I I have a familiarity with
- 3:13it and I like what you're saying about how it it just establishes
- 3:17a process and an order so that it's not utter chaos when we get
- 3:21there. Robert curious, let me just
- 3:26inject this one idea. Didn't mean to interrupt, but
- 3:28Robert's Rules is actually the purpose of it is to protect the
- 3:32rights of the majority, the rights of the minority and the
- 3:39rights of individual members. So it's really it's a it's a
- 3:42protection to make sure that everything is done with in
- 3:47observance of the rights of the participants.
- 3:49That's the whole real purpose of Robert's Rules.
- 3:52So. So who was Robert and what's it
- 3:55on now? Great question.
- 3:56So Robert was a, he was an officer in the Army about 150
- 4:03years ago, OK. And he was assigned to run a
- 4:07meeting, some kind of a organizational meeting or
- 4:10meeting with the town or something that and, and it went
- 4:13terribly. I don't know if anyone who's
- 4:16listening to us right now, Nate has been involved in meeting
- 4:19that was just off the rails. I just got done with one, did
- 4:23you? Yeah, I won't ask any more about
- 4:25that. They might be watching, but it's
- 4:28a meeting that, you know, people don't know what's going on.
- 4:31At the end of the meeting, they say, well, what did we decide?
- 4:33Or, and during the meeting they say, what are we deciding or
- 4:36what did we vote on? Or, you know, saying that, well,
- 4:39that wasn't fair. I mean, or a meeting where the
- 4:42the chairs railroading things. I don't know if you've ever seen
- 4:44that with the chair. We'll just ram things through by
- 4:47force of will. And he had this terrible,
- 4:50terrible experience, and he said there's got to be a better way
- 4:53now. In the same way that Webster did
- 4:57not write the English language, Webster compiled or gathered
- 5:02information about how the English language is used, and
- 5:06then he made the dictionary. That's what Robert did.
- 5:09He didn't just write the rules. He gathered the rules.
- 5:13What is this organization doing? He looked at Parliament.
- 5:16He looked at the House of Representatives.
- 5:17He looked at the Masons. He looked at other organizations
- 5:21in the United States, as he was in the United States.
- 5:24And then he compiled this book, which is basically a handbook of
- 5:29best practices for running a meeting.
- 5:31Yeah. Now since he has passed, it was
- 5:34150 years ago, there has been a a team of authors that have
- 5:39taken over that task. Every 10 years there's a new
- 5:43version. So we're not just working off of
- 5:45150 year old playbook, OK, They are collecting and I'm a
- 5:50professional parliamentarian and so there are several hundred of
- 5:53us in the United States. And so they collect input.
- 5:56Well, what is what are the best practices for the organizations
- 5:59that you're working with? So I do, I do probably 50
- 6:07meetings a year roughly. I'm going to guess about four a
- 6:10month or so, sometimes more, sometimes less.
- 6:13So I have a lot of experience with everything from churches
- 6:17such as yourself, dog clubs, homeowners associations,
- 6:21corporations, political organizations, labor unions, all
- 6:25these organizations that I work with as they're parliamentarian.
- 6:28And then I and other people like me, we say, well, here's what,
- 6:31Here's what, Here's a new idea that these people are using.
- 6:34Here's a new idea these people are using.
- 6:36Yeah, but it's. Evolving.
- 6:38It's always evolving because of just like the English language
- 6:41is always evolving. You know, people change.
- 6:43For example, we're much less formal now than we were 150
- 6:46years ago, right in our conversations, in our work.
- 6:49But for example, the lot, the most recent version of Robert's
- 6:52Rules, which is edition 12, had a whole new section on
- 6:57electronic meetings. And fortunately it just came out
- 7:01right before the pandemic. So, right, So, so they try to
- 7:04stay current, they try to, you know, keep up with things and
- 7:07things do change a little bit over time.
- 7:10The basic concepts of parliamentary law are pretty
- 7:13much established, you know, again, like back to Parliament
- 7:16or, you know, Greek times or Roman times, the basic
- 7:18fundamentals of of democracy, right, Because it's done by
- 7:22majority vote. So anyway, that's a very, very
- 7:25long answer to a short question. I, I really, no, I appreciate it
- 7:28too. And I'm sure, I'm sure the
- 7:29listeners appreciate too. Just kind of understanding.
- 7:31It's good to hear that it's always evolving that they're
- 7:33kind of trying to find ways to, because that's usually the
- 7:36critique you might hear is like, what do you mean 150 years old?
- 7:38What do they know about planning a meeting?
- 7:41Do they use Robert's Rules of Order when they come out with
- 7:44the different editions? Like do they do they have to
- 7:47have a meeting where they decide?
- 7:49What they're going to include? Well.
- 7:50That's a really good question. So it's an authorship team of
- 7:55three. They're basically, there's like
- 7:58an attorney and there's a professor and they're, I mean,
- 8:01they're, they're, they're steeped in this stuff and they,
- 8:05they basically come by unanimous agreement on what the changes
- 8:09should be made. So it's, and they're very
- 8:12circumspect. So they realize it's not their
- 8:15role to write rules like even if they have an opinion about it
- 8:18should be this way. They go by again, the principle
- 8:22that Webster uses, gathering data points.
- 8:26And then when they see there's like a, there's a move afoot,
- 8:29you know, there's a preponderance of the evidence
- 8:31that we're starting to move it this way.
- 8:32They'll start to introduce new things and then gradually it
- 8:36will will transition. What I appreciate about Robert's
- 8:42Rules and this whole process, it feels even when you're in the
- 8:46middle of it, right? Like, I know, I, I, I, you're
- 8:49going to probably be up there at Senate Assembly and you're going
- 8:52to have to walk us through and help us understand how this
- 8:54works. Because there's people who
- 8:55haven't ever heard of this before.
- 8:56And you'll talk to us about the red cards and the green cards
- 8:59and being recognized by the chair at the different
- 9:02microphones and all that good stuff.
- 9:04And it'll feel, I'm sure for people at first like what?
- 9:08Like what? Why does it have to be so
- 9:09official? Yes.
- 9:11And in the same sense, it's interesting for me to think
- 9:14about our whole assembly theme this year is life in Christ.
- 9:17And just this idea of, you know, scriptures telling us about life
- 9:21in Christ being a unifying experience there.
- 9:25There's so much written about the the unity that Christ
- 9:28creates and it really feels like that's the essence of what
- 9:32Robert's Rules is trying to do is like, we're not always going
- 9:35to agree, but we're going to try and come to the most cohesive
- 9:38whole we can through this process.
- 9:40Is it, is that fair as you hear me reflecting on it?
- 9:43Yeah, that's fair. Because so though if we if we
- 9:48look at the the message of Christ and the life of Christ,
- 9:53it's there was not when Christ was on the earth.
- 9:58It was not a deliberative process.
- 10:00No. Right.
- 10:02He said this is the way it is, and that's how it was.
- 10:07But since he's not here with us and we have only the Spirit, and
- 10:10each person receives the spirit individually, correct?
- 10:13Yeah. Like each person, you know, they
- 10:16have to receive what is their, what is their guidance.
- 10:21And that guidance I, I don't know if the guidance is
- 10:24different. I think the, my personal opinion
- 10:26is the spirit provides principles and then we apply
- 10:30those principles according to our own experience and knowledge
- 10:34and understanding. And so we come together with
- 10:37differing opinions and that's good.
- 10:40That is good for us because it allows us to learn from each
- 10:44other, allows us to discuss and receive inspiration from the
- 10:48words of others. Like you might have a, a
- 10:50perspective that I don't have, but by maybe by listening to
- 10:54you, I can share that perspective and learn from it.
- 10:56And then maybe I'll, you know, improve my own perspective.
- 10:59So that's the deliberative process.
- 11:01And that's what Robert's Rules provides.
- 11:03It's a it's a deliberative process where we, as I said
- 11:06before, we all have the right to to try to convince the body that
- 11:11our point of view is the correct point of view.
- 11:13And as it turns out, our point of view is never exactly right.
- 11:17It's, you know, we come up with this shared perspective.
- 11:20Yeah, that and you. I love that your name, your
- 11:24podcast is Better Together, right?
- 11:27Together for good. Together for good.
- 11:28Yeah. Yeah.
- 11:29Well, that's that's it. That's it is we we come together
- 11:32and. And even though any one of us,
- 11:34you know, may be deficient, as we come together in a body, then
- 11:39we can iron out those deficiencies and, and, and
- 11:42become become greater. Exactly.
- 11:44Yeah, I mean, it's it's the community coming together and
- 11:48and there's so much within our Lutheran tradition that reflects
- 11:50exactly like what you're talking about of Martin Luther.
- 11:54One in the Bible printed in the vernacular because it was only
- 11:57printed in Latin. He's like, no, let's try and get
- 11:58it in German so that we can read it and talk.
- 12:00About it so people can anticipate there exactly so we
- 12:03can participate and rather than having a an elite group of
- 12:08people whose job it is to interpret for us and instruct us
- 12:12now we become participants and that is the deliberative
- 12:16process. That's how we come together and
- 12:18and and share with each other. And I believe, you know, with
- 12:21the presence of the Spirit, we, we, we can learn and and and
- 12:27define and, and discern truth as, as we speak to each other.
- 12:32And so I want to go back to what you just kind of said too.
- 12:35There's not an elite individual who who we turn to.
- 12:40I don't exactly remember how you were saying it, but I just want
- 12:43to point out you as the parliamentarian aren't the elite
- 12:45one telling us how to do things. You're more of the referee just
- 12:49trying to help us. That's a good way of putting it.
- 12:51So, yeah, the, the parliamentarian, for example,
- 12:56doesn't make rulings. OK.
- 12:59The parliamentarian is not elected by the body.
- 13:02The parliamentarian really has no authority.
- 13:03The parliamentarian is strictly an advisor.
- 13:06So these are the ways that I advise.
- 13:08So for example, with Deacon Mary, we're doing training
- 13:14sessions for new assembly members.
- 13:17This is how Robert's Rules works and, and This is why we need it.
- 13:20I, I have a video that's available on the assembly
- 13:25website that's just kind of basics of again, so people can
- 13:28participate. I will check with the, the chair
- 13:32in advance of the meeting and we'll go through any elements
- 13:35training again, the chair probably want runs one meeting
- 13:38like this a year. I do 50 a year.
- 13:40So you know, it, it comes off the top of my head, but any, any
- 13:44one person you know, can be caught in the, in the
- 13:47headlights, right? So during the meeting and so,
- 13:52and also there's in this meeting, it's so formal there
- 13:55and it's so big that there's actually a script.
- 13:57Everything that is going to happen is scripted.
- 14:00And so I work extensively with the team on, on making sure that
- 14:05that script uses all the right language and is procedurally
- 14:09correct so that everyone knows what to expect.
- 14:12And then my what, what the success for me is if people come
- 14:15up to the Bishop after the meeting, say that was a
- 14:17marvelous meeting, that was so you did so good, and then they
- 14:21don't even know I'm there. That's successful.
- 14:23That's a good meeting. Okay, yeah, I'm.
- 14:25There to make the chair look good and there's nothing about
- 14:28the chair it's not that the chair is that important it's
- 14:31when the meeting is organized when the meeting flows smoothly
- 14:35when everyone realizes the chair is following the rules when
- 14:40people feel that they're their opinions are respected when the
- 14:44when their the rules are being followed that's when the chair
- 14:47looks good and that's my goal is to make it a great meeting that
- 14:51reflects well on the chair and then I go home and then I get
- 14:54paid so it's a it's a gig for me right so.
- 14:58And this is your professional career I.
- 15:00Did say I'm professional, Yes. Now there isn't.
- 15:03There's not enough parliamentary work to be my full time job.
- 15:08I also run a software company, but because I run the company I
- 15:12have flexibility of time so I can do the parliamentary work
- 15:15around and I really enjoy it. I had a similar experience to
- 15:18Roberts. I went to a political meeting
- 15:21about almost 18 years ago now and it was terrible.
- 15:27It was, it was painful. It was like I went, I left that
- 15:30meeting and I said, I never want to go back to that meeting
- 15:32again. There has to be a better way.
- 15:34And so that's when I learned that there's these rules.
- 15:37And it's not just, you know, rules made-up in a book.
- 15:40It's actually a book that you can reference.
- 15:43And it's, you know, it's not just people's opinion about what
- 15:46the rules are and, and that it is for people's rights and it is
- 15:49to make meetings better. And so I began to learn it.
- 15:51I learned there's an organization called the National
- 15:54Association of Parliamentarians. They have a, a credentialing
- 16:00process, They have a certification process.
- 16:02So there are three levels of certification.
- 16:06I, I went through all three of them.
- 16:08I'm now at the highest level of, of certification that's offered
- 16:12by them. You have.
- 16:12Your black belt in parliamentarians.
- 16:14I do. I'm a black belt
- 16:16parliamentarianism. That's how you need to talk
- 16:18about. Yes, that's what I should tell
- 16:19people. I'm a black belt parliamentarian
- 16:22and yeah, and so that's, and I've been a professional
- 16:27parliamentarian for about 1314 years now.
- 16:31And I was on, you know, the lower, lower grades earlier than
- 16:35that. And now I've forgotten totally
- 16:38the question you asked me. But we're having good, we're
- 16:40having good fun. Absolutely, Kirby.
- 16:43It's a sign it's going to be a good meeting too.
- 16:45I could tell as you think about this, those thirteen years in
- 16:49this and you, you know, you're doing 50 meetings a year or
- 16:52something like that. So you've done hundreds of of
- 16:56these meetings. Why do you think as you sit here
- 16:59today, right, knowing that the whole overall goal of Robert's
- 17:03Rules is like you said, to, to create equal footing so that the
- 17:06individual and the majority and the minority can all be be heard
- 17:12and participate. Is there anything you feel like
- 17:16or anywhere places where Robert's Rules falls a little
- 17:19short in that endeavor? Well, that's a good question.
- 17:23So in my practice, there's there's two areas that that
- 17:28Robert's rules is it has some assumptions which aren't always
- 17:33true. Let's say it that way.
- 17:34OK, The, the first assumption that Robert's Rules makes is
- 17:38that everybody knows and follows the rules.
- 17:41So it's kind of built for, do you remember who was the, the,
- 17:47the, the French observer who came to America and he said, you
- 17:50know, America is great because it is good.
- 17:52And when America stops being good, it will no longer be
- 17:55great. I'll, I'll think of it in half
- 17:57an hour. Yes.
- 17:58I've heard that's how my. That's how my mind works.
- 18:02So Roberts assumes that everybody has integrity and that
- 18:06we all want to follow the rules and protect everyone's rights.
- 18:10And so it it kind of assumes that everybody's going to make
- 18:14decisions on that basis and which isn't always true.
- 18:18It also, when I say it assumes we follow the rules, there are
- 18:23times when people will get into a problem because they didn't
- 18:26follow the rules. And Roberts doesn't always
- 18:29explain to you how to unravel it.
- 18:33It has some, has some basic principles of, of basic
- 18:38principles of, you know what, how, what's important, but it's
- 18:42kind of based upon the experience with the
- 18:44parliamentarian to figure out, OK, what's the, I'll give you an
- 18:46example. This is an example from a dog
- 18:48club. So president of the dog club
- 18:52calls me and this was a couple years ago.
- 18:53He says I have a problem. He says the bylaws are very
- 18:58specific about how you send out the, the elect their officers by
- 19:02mail. You're you're supposed to send
- 19:04it out a certain way. And then you know, they're in a
- 19:07way that the members of the dog club can vote without revealing
- 19:10their ballot, right? You send, it's like mail in
- 19:13voting. You have to have an outer
- 19:14envelope and envelope and all this.
- 19:16And, and he says, and he says, I did not do that.
- 19:20I didn't read the rules. I just didn't do it.
- 19:26My bad. He was very repentant.
- 19:28I'm sorry I didn't do it. The problem is I was elected and
- 19:33now it looks like I rigged the election and there are the group
- 19:39of dog members and doggy. Doggy owners love their doggies,
- 19:43OK? They do they.
- 19:44Do and they're a group who who say that that I'm no longer the
- 19:47legitimate president because I was not elected according to the
- 19:51right rules and they want to have somebody else be the
- 19:55president. What should we do?
- 19:57That's, that's the question. Oh my God, now what now?
- 20:00What do we do? So we worked out a solution that
- 20:02was, you know, good for everyone.
- 20:04And, you know, he had sort of a, an opposition group and I talked
- 20:08to the leader of their group and I talked to him and we kind of
- 20:10worked out a, a way that everybody felt comfortable
- 20:13moving forward. But that's, that's sort of the
- 20:18Robert's Rules is amazing and that it covers almost every
- 20:21situation you can possibly think of.
- 20:23It's 750 pages. And it covers really everything,
- 20:27but there's still things that you get in, you work yourself
- 20:30into these corners and there is no direct, you have to go kind
- 20:34of back to the principles of rights and and protection to
- 20:38come up with solutions to some of these really strange
- 20:40problems. But those are the fun ones.
- 20:43That's where you need the black belt to step.
- 20:44In yes. That's why you need, yes.
- 20:46And it's, it's, it's so interesting to think about this
- 20:49from a faith perspective too, in that like the, the scriptures
- 20:55give us the law and they give us a lot of details about like,
- 20:59this is what you should do. And it's there to like, help
- 21:01keep us on the straight and narrow.
- 21:03And we're always going to mess it up.
- 21:06Yes, well, here's my criticism. If I can say this is my
- 21:09criticism about the Bible, why is there no book of Jesus?
- 21:16We have, we have the book of John.
- 21:18We've got, you know, we've got Paul.
- 21:20We've got Matthew. Why didn't Jesus write a book?
- 21:24That would make things so much more clear, wouldn't it?
- 21:29And the book I'm looking for, I want to know.
- 21:32We have a little bit about when Jesus begins, when he goes and
- 21:38he teaches in the temple, when he's a young age.
- 21:40Yeah. Yeah.
- 21:41And then there's a big gap. And then he turns 33 and he
- 21:43begins his ministry. I wanna know what he was like as
- 21:46a teenager. I wanted to have the book of
- 21:49Mary. Well, this is what Jesus said
- 21:50today, or this is these are the things that are missing for me.
- 21:54Yeah, yeah, yeah. So if I'm ever in charge, we
- 21:59would have had the book of Jesus and.
- 22:01It's spoken like a true parliamentarian, though.
- 22:03You, you want to know like, yeah.
- 22:05What's the, what's the details? Jesus.
- 22:07Yeah. Like what constitutes the way a
- 22:10teenager should behave? Or his 20s?
- 22:12There's so much that of life that unfolds between 19 and 26.
- 22:18Yeah, right. And you there's, you know, we
- 22:22know he was a Carpenter, but I don't know what.
- 22:24I assume he went through an apprentice process, you know,
- 22:28did he make, did he make perfect shelving?
- 22:30I just, I would like to know these things.
- 22:33You know, was he was his work in demand or was he too was, did he
- 22:37price himself out? I would like to know these
- 22:39things. Yeah.
- 22:40But then how did he deal with the, the, the, the most
- 22:44difficult parts of life, like, you know, starting a family and
- 22:48having relationships and, and, you know, these are the things
- 22:51that we do day-to-day that yes, we have the principles and we
- 22:56know what, and I guess you could take the greatest commandment,
- 23:02love God and then love your fellow man.
- 23:05And you could probably extrapolate everything from
- 23:07there, but it's too hard to work.
- 23:09I would just like to have it explained to me but.
- 23:12It goes back to what you were saying earlier about the the,
- 23:15the spirit being the guide of us and.
- 23:17And there you go. There you right.
- 23:18Like you have from each other, because we're, because you're
- 23:21right, like there's, there's a whole bunch of gaps of things
- 23:22that we're not necessarily sure of some of the finer details.
- 23:25It says like, So what does this look like today?
- 23:27Like how does this work today, right?
- 23:29Yeah. Well, this is what I love about
- 23:31Lutheran's is we're the question I hear of most often is what
- 23:35does that mean? You know, right.
- 23:37So this is very good. I'm very good.
- 23:41And that's what they will be asking you a lot at this lot
- 23:43assembly, I'm sure. Well, that's one of the things I
- 23:46do is I sit next to the chair and, and some and if, if things
- 23:52are going off track, I will discreetly, you know, whisper or
- 23:56say, you know, make a correction to the chair or if the chair
- 24:00gets lost, you know, the chair can turn to me and and ask a
- 24:03question. I'm like the Spirit, don't.
- 24:06Let it go to your head. And the parliament,
- 24:10parliamentary spirit, OK, similar role.
- 24:15I won't, I'm not elevating myself, but I'm just saying but
- 24:19but here's what's an important point.
- 24:21The chair makes the rulings because the chair was elected by
- 24:25the assembly. So the chair has the authority
- 24:30vested by the body to make rulings and that.
- 24:33But here's the difference. There's a difference between the
- 24:35Bishop in her, in her pastoral role and in the chair role.
- 24:40So as the pastor and having this, this, this shepherd
- 24:48responsibility, you know, people might be very reluctant to
- 24:52disagree with the Bishop in her role as Bishop, in her, in her
- 24:57ecclesiastical position, right? Because right.
- 25:00But in the assembly she is lesser than the body.
- 25:08In fact, everything that the chair does can be appealed.
- 25:12All the rulings that the chair makes can be appealed and we
- 25:16decided by a vote of the body. So people should not be shy if
- 25:21they feel that the, you know, the chair is not performing the
- 25:24the the rules correctly, should not be shy about raising a point
- 25:28of order, which means I don't think the rules are being
- 25:30followed or appealing from the ruling of the chair if they feel
- 25:34like the chairs ruling. So it's a different role
- 25:36entirely. When we get to the Assembly, The
- 25:38Assembly is the highest legislative body of the Synod.
- 25:44And so in that role, the Synod is greater and, and I use this
- 25:48term very, very loosely, greater like because we have the
- 25:51principle, you know, let he who is greatest among you be the
- 25:54least right. But the so the Synod is greater
- 25:56in authority than the Bishop in that meeting, in that meeting.
- 26:00So I, I, I just, I like people to understand that so they they
- 26:04feel empowered to participate and to be bold and insistent
- 26:12when necessary. What do you think would be This
- 26:18is a personal question for me, the best way to take advantage
- 26:25of making a point of personal privilege at some point during
- 26:28the assembly. OK, is this a good, is this a
- 26:30good point for me to do like like tell some jokes?
- 26:36Not the jokes unless they're really, really good jokes.
- 26:39I mean, you would have to be a good joke.
- 26:41OK, yeah, if they're dad jokes like like a dad joke would be.
- 26:45I'm I'm saying that kind of tongue and cheek and like that's
- 26:47always the one that's that's befuddled me a little bit is
- 26:50like, when should you take a point of personal privilege?
- 26:53Good. So they're outside.
- 26:54The realms of the meeting itself.
- 26:56So there are two types of privilege.
- 26:57There's privileges of the individual and privileges of the
- 27:00assembly, and the privilege of the assembly is things that
- 27:06things are not allowing the assembly to do its work.
- 27:09For example, the I rise to a point of privilege.
- 27:13What is your privilege? What is your client privilege?
- 27:16There's so much noise in the hall, Madam Chair, we cannot
- 27:19hear. Could you please have the door
- 27:21shut and ask for order? Yes, the sound the the speaker
- 27:26above us here has gone out and we can't hear or things like
- 27:32that. Things that are it's too hot in
- 27:34here. It's too cold in here.
- 27:35We things that are affecting our our ability to do our work as a
- 27:39group. That'll be a valid question of
- 27:41privilege. OK, Personal privilege is less
- 27:47less called for. For example, can I be excused
- 27:51from the meeting? You know, I need to run to the
- 27:54boys room. Well, you don't need to raise
- 27:55your hand for that. Just go right.
- 28:00Sometimes people will use a point of personal privilege to
- 28:04make a, a, an announcement that's meaningful to the body,
- 28:09such as I just wanted to let you know I've just heard from my
- 28:14congregation pastor so and so has just passed away.
- 28:19And so, you know, may we observe this And that would be a point
- 28:24of personal privilege, but that sort of thing is very rare.
- 28:27So, so no, it's not just it's not an open mic night to stand
- 28:32up and say, you know, whatever you think, whatever you want to
- 28:35talk about, it should be something that's really kind of
- 28:38pertinent to the work of the of the assembly itself.
- 28:41Yeah, if that if that answers your question.
- 28:43Absolutely. No, No, I've just, I've actually
- 28:46been to a lot of Senate assemblies and there's a variety
- 28:48of reasons for that and I've seen it used in some of those,
- 28:54the ways that I was questioning, like, I don't feel right.
- 28:57That's what you should be doing. Here.
- 28:58Yeah, that's right. Well, and sometimes what I'll
- 29:00do, cuz, cuz the chair, here's the difference between me and
- 29:04the chair. I just worry about the rules.
- 29:06So, you know, if somebody stands up and starts talking like that,
- 29:09I'll just whisper to the chair. You know, that's out of order.
- 29:11That's not appropriate. But the but the Bishop is
- 29:15concerned about more than just the rules.
- 29:16She isn't concerned about the rules, let me just tell you.
- 29:20But she's also concerned about the heart, in the spirit of the
- 29:24meeting, and she's concerned about loving the people, which
- 29:26makes her a good chair. The best chairs I've worked with
- 29:29are those that love the people that are in the assembly.
- 29:32So I'll give you an example. Not at the Synod, but this was
- 29:36at a convention of 2000 people, OK.
- 29:39It was a large labor union in California.
- 29:41And a man stood up and an elderly man like, you know, he,
- 29:45he very painstakingly made his way to the microphone.
- 29:48There was a, it's a huge hall. Of course, there's 4-4 different
- 29:51microphones. And he painstakingly, you know,
- 29:55reached the microphone and he said a point of order.
- 29:58And so the chair said, well, what's your point of order?
- 30:01And he said, I just want to say that our, our brother so and so
- 30:09one of the greats of our union has passed away in the last two
- 30:14weeks. And I know that.
- 30:17And I'm and I'm saying to the chair, that's not a point of
- 30:21order, but the chair let him finish.
- 30:24Because if you say to the, you know, to the gentleman who
- 30:28clearly was respected and illness and you say to him, I'm
- 30:32sorry, that's not a point of order.
- 30:33Sit down. Well, that makes you a jerk.
- 30:35Yeah. Right.
- 30:37Yeah, it follows the rules, but you're still a jerk.
- 30:39So you have to temper, Yeah, the exact rules with the fact that
- 30:47she is elected. She is the, you know, the the
- 30:51pastoral leader and and she doesn't.
- 30:54So. So that's why she makes the
- 30:57rulings. Yeah, that's why I don't make
- 30:58the rulings. It makes it delicate.
- 31:00And I, I, I mean, I'm not, I'm also just hearing you tell that
- 31:02story, kind of reminded of multiple points in the
- 31:06scriptures where the Pharisees will come and they'll be mad at
- 31:09Jesus and they'll be like, why did you, why did you do this on
- 31:11the Sabbath day? And he's like, wow, like, but
- 31:13like, this person was in need, you know, like, yes, there's
- 31:15rules and yes, it's more important.
- 31:18Yeah, yeah. Well, we've done this on the
- 31:19Sabbath because you get your priorities straight.
- 31:21Yeah. Yeah, Right.
- 31:23I mean, yes, we have these rules and those are important, but
- 31:26there are other things that also come into play.
- 31:28And the Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath.
- 31:31Exactly. So yeah.
- 31:32Yeah, you have to, you have to figure.
- 31:35And that's why the chair makes the rulings.
- 31:38And I don't make the rulings. I just advise the chair.
- 31:41Tell me, I've been asking all the people that come on talk to
- 31:44me about this theme, Life in Christ.
- 31:45Where do you hear that? What does that mean for you?
- 31:47Isn't that the the central theme of everything that we do?
- 31:54Yeah. So, you know, and it goes back
- 31:59to I'm gonna, I'm gonna do the weirdest thing you've ever
- 32:01heard, which is I'm going to bring Robert's Rules into life
- 32:04in Christ. Excellent.
- 32:06Because Robert's Rules is based upon respecting the rights of
- 32:12everyone. So, so this is, you know, we, we
- 32:16treat people in a fairway. And I believe that's the
- 32:18Christian way. When we say life in Christ, we
- 32:22we live our own personal lives in a way that we try to if
- 32:28we're, if we are to be Christians, we take upon
- 32:31ourselves the name of Christ. And so we should be treating
- 32:36each other in a Christian way. And This is why all this shall
- 32:40men know that you are my disciples, that you love one
- 32:42another. So This is why the chair makes
- 32:44the rulings because of the love, right?
- 32:47Because we, we have to have the rules, but we also have to have
- 32:50the love. And to me, life in Christ is,
- 32:53you know, trying to and, and by the way, I'm probably a mediocre
- 32:57Christian. I would never claim to be
- 32:58anything better than a mediocre Christian.
- 33:00I think that's most of us. I.
- 33:02Think you know and and I. Said that to one of my friends
- 33:05once said he said you braggart. I would just love to be a
- 33:10mediocre. Christian so OK, I'm sorry I'll
- 33:13rephrase I'm striving to be a mediocre Christian at best.
- 33:18So, so, but, but I think the in fairness, you know, the, the
- 33:23rules provide us the fairness to have a meeting that here's what
- 33:27here's what I love about the, about the Senate meetings that
- 33:32doesn't happen and, and other venues is because we're
- 33:36passionate. I mean, that's good to having a
- 33:38passionate discussion is good. And, but sometimes the passion
- 33:42turns into a little bit aggressive and the, and the
- 33:48Bishop will say, let's have a prayer and have the, the, the
- 33:56one who's leading the prayers for the, for the Assembly come
- 33:58up and, and just invite the spirit back and just, you know,
- 34:03give us clarity, give us kindness, give us the ability to
- 34:08express clearly and we get back on track and continue the
- 34:11discussion. So, so I think life in Christ,
- 34:16of course, is something that we're all striving for everyday.
- 34:19As we've pointed out, we constantly need the, the, the,
- 34:25the spirit to guide us when we're off track, to let us know
- 34:29you're not on track, you're a little bit off.
- 34:32And so. And and then that's the.
- 34:37Goal. That's the goal, that we
- 34:39collectively as well as individually have that Christ's
- 34:43life. Now, I'm not Lutheran, but my
- 34:48friends asked me what do you think about the Lutherans?
- 34:51They said the Lutherans are awesome, that Lutherans are
- 34:55doing so much good in the world and there's so much good that
- 35:00needs to be done in the world. So let's not criticize others
- 35:06who are doing their best to have a life in Christ.
- 35:10Let's. I mean, I don't know about, I
- 35:12don't know very much about being a Christian, But what I do know
- 35:14is this. We don't judge each other.
- 35:17Yeah, we love each other. We leave the judging to God and
- 35:21we do our best to love and help one another.
- 35:24And that's what I see. I enjoy the Spirit when I, when
- 35:27I meet with this tenant. I enjoy the people.
- 35:30The people are tremendous. All the things that you know
- 35:33that that the church is doing are terrific.
- 35:36I, you know, who I really liked was who was the, the, the past
- 35:40Bishop of the church wine of the church wine was Elizabeth Eaton.
- 35:45Yes, I loved listening to. Her, I mean, she was so, so
- 35:49articulate about, you know, the following the path Anyway, so
- 35:52those are just my tiny opinions. I don't.
- 35:55Of course, none of those have to do with what I do with a
- 35:57meeting, but thanks for asking. Appreciate that.
- 36:00No. I love the way you're weaving in
- 36:02Robert's Rules to that and seeing it too, of yeah, we're
- 36:07just trying to do this the best we can.
- 36:09Yeah. And you're very kind to say that
- 36:12you love the Lutherans and that you think they're great.
- 36:14And, and I would say we're striving to be mediocre, right?
- 36:18Let's all be striving. That's the that's the point of
- 36:22it is the striving. I think so this is one of the
- 36:26things that you know, this is this is this is discussed in
- 36:30religions all over the world, you know, about faith and works
- 36:33and you know, and grace. Now, grace is, of course, how we
- 36:39and the meeting big on that. We Yeah.
- 36:41And that's great. And grace is so important
- 36:44because the only way we can have a life in Christ is through
- 36:48grace. I mean, it's by grace that we
- 36:51are saved. There's no question of it.
- 36:52There's no question of it, right?
- 36:55And but that doesn't mean we can't, we shouldn't strive.
- 36:57I think we, we strive. And then and then of course, you
- 37:01know, our striving is like this much and then the grace is this
- 37:03much, right? So the way I like to think about
- 37:07it. And this is not a Robert's Rules
- 37:09analogy. I wish I could make it 1, but
- 37:10I'm not as well versed as you. But I think about it as the
- 37:14order of operations in math class.
- 37:17Like 4th grade math class where you learn like hey, you got to
- 37:19do this stuff in the parentheses first and then you can do yes,
- 37:23that's everything outside. And so it's like, yeah, Grace.
- 37:26Is grace is what God does for us and we respond to it.
- 37:29That's the way. That's right.
- 37:30A Lutheran might talk about it. You don't.
- 37:32It's not that you work hard enough to then earn the grace.
- 37:36The grace is what comes first. You cannot earn.
- 37:38The grace, there's nothing you can do in your life that could
- 37:41possibly. So we're just coming off on
- 37:43Easter. Yes, we are.
- 37:45And. Easter is the.
- 37:46Time that we, we recognize the prize that was paid for the
- 37:52grace, you know, how, how the, how the grace was made possible
- 37:58through the atonement and the, and the sacrifice and the, and
- 38:02the resurrection and, you know, and, and that's, and yeah, so
- 38:08that, that is beautiful central, that's central.
- 38:11And then we just strive. We just do the best we can.
- 38:14And, and, and then grace is always the, and there, there'll
- 38:18be plenty of opportunities also for grace at the assembly
- 38:21because someone will screw up and something will go wrong and
- 38:24there won't be enough pizza or whatever is the problem, right.
- 38:27And then, and then what a, what a great opportunity for us to
- 38:30remember. Well, it's a good, good time for
- 38:33grace. There's grace for that, too.
- 38:35Grace abounds. Well, hey.
- 38:36You're you're a pretty good theologian.
- 38:38On top of a parliamentarian, if I do say so.
- 38:40Oh, you're very kind. You're very.
- 38:41Kind I do try to keep up so fun. Is there any?
- 38:45Like last points or little pieces.
- 38:47You wanna any any final teasers you want for us?
- 38:49Thank you. Thank you so much.
- 38:50I. Don't have any teasers except
- 38:51for if. If whoever's listening to this,
- 38:54make sure that you get the the instruction video.
- 38:58If you're a new delegate to the assembly, make sure you get that
- 39:02instructional video. It's only about 20 minutes.
- 39:04It talks about how to participate.
- 39:06We're having another live session, I think coming up soon.
- 39:10Get the, get the And if anybody has a question, please come to
- 39:15me, ask me, ask me in between meetings, text me, e-mail me.
- 39:19I, my, my goal is to help people to feel that they can
- 39:25participate, that they can make their voices heard, that their
- 39:28that their rights are respected. And so if anybody has any
- 39:31questions, don't be silent, even if you just have to go to the
- 39:35microphone and say, well, here's what I wanna do, but I don't
- 39:38know how to do it. We'll help you.
- 39:39The chair will help you. I will help you.
- 39:41We're here to help you participate.
- 39:44That's awesome. Thank you For what you.
- 39:46Do thanks for being a part of this coming up in April.
- 39:48I look forward to meeting you in person and shaking your hand.
- 39:51I'll be sure to track you down. And yeah, this thanks for making
- 39:54it such a, an open, uh, non scary experience for us because
- 39:59I think it can be a little intimidating, but you've done a
- 40:01great job of just, and all these additional resources help people
- 40:04feel so much more comfortable. So they can participate, which
- 40:07is the goal. Awesome.
- 40:09Well. Kirby, thank you for that.
- 40:10And listeners, thank you for tuning into this.
- 40:12We'll see you in April at the Assembly if you're going to be
- 40:15there. As always, stay in peace,
- 40:17everyone. Thank you for listening to the
- 40:19Together for Good podcast. If you'd like more resources for
- 40:22your walk of faith, please visit our website bethany-denver.org
- 40:27or download our mobile app by searching Bethany Connect in
- 40:31your phone's App Store.