Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Promotion Without Waiting for Permission
Transcript
- Lucas: So we got a question this week from a listener named Maya. She's a marketing manager at a mid-sized tech firm — roughly 400 employees — and she's been in her role for about two and a half years. She says she's been performing at a senior level for at least the last twelve months, but her company doesn't have a formal promotion cycle. No annual reviews tied to titles, no quarterly calibration meetings. It's basically, 'We'll let you know when we think you're ready.' And she's tired of waiting. Luna: That 'we'll let you know' line is brutal because it puts all the power on the other side of the table. And I think a lot of people in flatter or fast-growing companies recognise that situation. Lucas: Exactly. And look, this is a careers show — if we've helped you think through a move like this, or if you've ever been stuck wondering whether to speak up or stay quiet, the most direct way to make sure we keep doing episodes like this is at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a low-key way for listeners who find value here to help us stay independent and ad-free. Luna: Yeah, it genuinely makes a difference. And honestly, if today's episode helps one person get a promotion they deserve, that feels like a good trade. Lucas: Alright, back to Maya. The first thing I want to say is: waiting to be noticed is a losing strategy. I know it feels more comfortable. You don't want to seem pushy or entitled. But the data is pretty clear — people who proactively manage their careers get promoted faster, on average, than those who rely on their manager's attention span. Luna: I've seen that too. There's a study — I think it was from the Harvard Business Review — that tracked about 4,000 employees over five years. People who initiated a promotion conversation at least once per year were promoted about 30 percent more often than those who didn't. Lucas: Right. So the question isn't whether to ask — it's how to ask. And the first step, before you even book a meeting, is to build a business case. Not a 'I've been working hard' case. A 'here's the value I delivered, and here's what I could deliver in a senior role' case. Luna: Can you give an example of what that looks like for Maya? Like, what would she actually write down? Lucas: Sure. Let's say she's managed the company's email marketing, and over the past year she increased open rates by 12 percent and drove $400,000 in attributed revenue from a specific campaign. That's a concrete number. Then she'd want to show that the senior marketing manager role — if there is one — typically oversees strategy, not just execution. So she could say, 'I've already begun drafting the quarterly content strategy, and I've mentored two junior team members. I'm ready to take full ownership of the channel roadmap.' That's not asking for a favour — it's demonstrating readiness. Luna: And I think that's the key distinction. You're not saying, 'Please give me a raise.' You're saying, 'Here's evidence that I'm already operating at the next level, and here's why it benefits the company to formalise that.' Lucas: Exactly. And then the second piece is timing. In a company without a formal cycle, you have to find a natural trigger. Maybe it's right after you finish a major project. Maybe it's during a quarterly planning conversation when your manager is already thinking about resource allocation. The worst time is during a crisis, or right after you've made a mistake. Luna: What about the end of the year? A lot of people think, 'I'll just wait until my annual review.' But if there's no formal review, that's just way too passive. Lucas: Yeah, I'd say pick a moment within the next two to four weeks. Don't wait for a 'perfect' window — there isn't one. And be specific in your request: 'I'd like 30 minutes next Tuesday to discuss my career progression and how I can contribute more.' Luna: That gives the manager a heads-up on the topic, so they're not blindsided. I'd add one more thing: ask for feedback first. It's a little counterintuitive, but when I've coached people on this, I've told them to start the conversation with something like, 'I want to be sure I'm on the right track for a senior role. Could you share your perspective on what gaps you see?' Lucas: That's smart because it disarms the defensiveness. If you just walk in and say 'Promote me', the manager's instinct might be to push back. But if you ask for their input, you're inviting them into the problem-solving with you. Luna: Exactly. And then once they've told you what they want to see, you can say, 'Great, I've already done X, Y, and Z. Let me show you.' Or, if there's a genuine gap, you have a clear action plan. Lucas: And that leads to the third piece: the actual ask. After you've laid out the business case and gotten their feedback, you say something like, 'Based on what I've delivered and the responsibilities I'm already handling, I'd like to be considered for a promotion to senior marketing manager. Can we discuss a timeline for making that official?' Luna: I like that language — 'timeline' instead of 'can I have it?' It frames it as a process, not a demand. Lucas: Right. And then you have to be prepared for the most common objection: 'We don't have budget right now.' That's a classic in companies without formal cycles. But instead of just accepting it, you want to ask a clarifying question: 'Is there a specific budget cycle or approval process I should be aware of? Could we revisit this in three months with a clear set of milestones?' Luna: That keeps the door open. And if you can get them to agree to a specific date — say, September first — then you've turned a vague no into a conditional maybe with a timeline. Lucas: Exactly. And one more thing — if they say no outright, or if they say 'We just don't have the headcount,' you have a decision to make. Do you stay and try again in six months, or do you start looking externally? That's a personal call, but I'd say if you've been performing at the next level for more than 18 months and there's no path, the market is probably your best negotiator. Luna: And that's not a threat — it's just reality. The best time to look for a job is when you already have one. And having a concrete offer from another company can sometimes unlock things internally, though you have to be careful with that approach. Lucas: Yeah, that's a whole other episode — we did one on counteroffers a few weeks back. But for Maya, I think the immediate next step is clear: build the case, pick a date in the next two weeks, and have that feedback-first conversation. Luna: I want to go back to something you said earlier about concrete numbers. Because I think a lot of people don't keep track of their wins. They think, 'Oh, my manager knows what I do.' But managers are busy, they forget, and they have biases. The person who comes with a written list of outcomes is already ahead. Lucas: Absolutely. And it doesn't have to be fancy. A simple document — one page — with three columns: what you did, the measurable result, and how it connects to the company's priorities. That's it. Luna: And if you don't have hard numbers, you can use qualitative wins. Things like 'Led a cross-functional team that reduced project turnaround time by two weeks,' or 'Resolved a recurring client complaint that had been open for six months.' Lucas: Right. And one subtle thing that a lot of people miss: when you present that document, don't hand it to your manager cold. Send it a day in advance with a note: 'I'm looking forward to our conversation Tuesday. I put together a summary of my recent contributions so we can have a productive discussion.' That sets the tone. Luna: And it also signals that you're organised and professional — which is exactly the kind of behaviour you'd expect from someone at the next level. Lucas: Exactly. So Maya, if you're listening: you've got this. The fact that you're even asking the question means you're already ahead of most people. The hardest part is starting that conversation — after that, it's just data and follow-through. Luna: And if it doesn't go the way you hope, you've still gained information. Either you know the path is real, and you have a timeline, or you know it's not, and you can move on with clarity. Lucas: That's a good place to land. Next episode, we've got a question about how to handle a colleague who constantly interrupts you in meetings — we'll get into some specific phrases you can use in the moment without escalating. Luna: Oh, that's a good one. I've got a few stories about that. See you next time. Lucas: Take care, everyone.