Latest / DiveIn: Diving into Special Education's Most Complex and Pressing Debates / Zero Reject: An interview with Anya Kamenetz' new podcast
Transcript
- 0:05From the Division of Research of the Council for Exceptional Children.
- 0:09This is Dive in, the podcast where we ask difficult
- 0:13questions about the education of students with disabilities and occasionally we
- 0:18pretend we have the answers. I'm your host, Federico Vitolo,
- 0:22professor at the University of Illinois, Chicago. So are you
- 0:26ready? Let's dive in.
- 0:29Welcome, welcome, welcome welcome to another welcome to another episode of Dive In.
- 0:33I'm Federico Weitholler, your host and favorite wannabe comedian journalist
- 0:38slash. I haven't figured out what I want to do with my life when I
- 0:40actually grow up. Today my guest is Anya Kamenetz,
- 0:45an award winning journalist, author and former education
- 0:48correspondent for NPR. She joined us to discuss her podcast from
- 0:52Understood.org 0reject the Uncertain Future
- 0:56of Special Education now, interviewing someone who
- 1:01asks questions for a living comes with a little pressure, but during
- 1:05our conversation, Anya responded to some of
- 1:08my questions, asked great questions several times.
- 1:12Naturally, I took that as an invitation to join npr,
- 1:16and in another moment when I asked her a question, she said,
- 1:19exactly. That's when I thought I was ready for
- 1:23the Ethna Clan show and started practicing. My thoughtful
- 1:27pauses I know
- 1:31still work. My thoughtful pauses still need a little bit of work, but you
- 1:35still can hear the potential. You can still hear the potential of my thoughtful passes
- 1:39and my capability to be in the ESRA claim show. Anyway, I haven't received
- 1:43the paperwork yet, but I know the ESRA must be very busy. Same thing
- 1:47for the NPR they're busy people. I'm sure the invitation
- 1:51will come any moment and you will find me in those shows very soon.
- 1:54But anyway, going back to our podcast for today,
- 1:58zero Reject Anya's new podcast arrives as the Trump administration
- 2:01works to dismantle the Department of Education and shift responsibilities
- 2:06to federal agencies. A few weeks ago, Kuna Tavalin
- 2:10helped us unpack the partnership between the Office of Special Education and Rehabilitation
- 2:14Services, OSERS and the Department of Health and Human Services,
- 2:18or hhs. Education retains statutory responsibilities,
- 2:22but major questions remain about who will do the work and how students rights will
- 2:26be protected. What drew me to zero Reject is
- 2:29that connects these national policy changes to everyday experiences.
- 2:33Anya bring us into the lies behind those questions.
- 2:37Across six episodes, she follows families seeking services,
- 2:40educators trying to solve problems, and advocates fighting
- 2:45to make educational rights meaningful. She connects those experiences
- 2:50to the history of special education and asks what it will take to build
- 2:54something better. I do want to offer one brief editorial
- 2:59note. When I interviewed Anya, only four episodes were
- 3:03out. In episode five, Anya interviews Ashley
- 3:07Hakim about rethinking special education.
- 3:10Interestingly, I review Ashley's coauthor report Outmatch,
- 3:14where she advance the same ideas as in the podcast.
- 3:19I posted a link to my review of her work. In the episode's description,
- 3:23though Ashley and her co author raises important
- 3:26issues and proposes brave and interesting solutions, its conclusion
- 3:30goes beyond what the evidence establishes, that it gives
- 3:34insufficient credit and attention to decades of scholarship, debate on inclusive
- 3:38education and specialized services, debates that are at the heart of what she's
- 3:43proposing. Ashley's proposals for change also need to
- 3:46explain how they will preserve enforceable rights and specialized expertise.
- 3:52To Anya's credit, she challenges Ashley and the suggestion that
- 3:56exclusion is behind us and that we can dismantle idea,
- 3:59citing accounts of children that still are denied a full school
- 4:03day. That exchanges captures why this series
- 4:07is worth hearing. It opens difficult conversations
- 4:11that we need to continue to grapple with with regards to the teaching and learning
- 4:15of students with disabilities. And that's also what we're trying to do
- 4:19here at Divein. So while the NPR process
- 4:23of my appointment is still going on and Ezra cleaned
- 4:27his schedule for me, are you ready? Let's dive into my conversation
- 4:31with Anya Kamenet.
- 4:36Well, Anya, you have spent many years covering
- 4:39special education. What prompted zero
- 4:44reject and why are you doing it now? I mean, there was always been inequities,
- 4:48right? And you this just happened now? Yes, it's true that the,
- 4:52the stories, you know, throughout my career I have pursued stories of families
- 4:56fighting really hard for their children's civil
- 5:00rights. And I have observed how tough and how adversarial
- 5:05it can be for families who are trying to get the free, appropriate public education
- 5:09that the federal law says that they should have. What's new
- 5:13is the, the changes at the federal level and the
- 5:17announcements being made about dissolving the federal Department of
- 5:21Education. And many, many advocates kind of raising the alarm
- 5:25to say that without the enforcement at the federal level,
- 5:29while it has been imperfect, there is a danger of
- 5:33making a bad situation. Even.
- 5:36So this prompted because. Well, just to remind the audience, we have some episodes
- 5:41reviewing these with some policy analysts from the Council for Exceptional Children,
- 5:44that parts of the Office
- 5:49of Special Educational Rehabilitation Services have been moved to the Department of Human Health
- 5:53and Services and the Office of Civil Rights, which is usually
- 5:57in charge to follow up and keep schools accountable
- 6:01for civil rights violations under IDEA or ADA or
- 6:05FIFO or Section 504 has been moved to the Department
- 6:10of Justice, correct? Yes. Well, there's a, there's a sort of a joint
- 6:14task force, joint agreement. They let go a large number
- 6:18of the attorneys who were working on enforcing students rights with the
- 6:22Office for Civil rights. They closed seven of the 12 regional offices.
- 6:25And then even when you talk about the cooperation with the Department of Justice,
- 6:29we have to understand that first of all, the Department of Justice has its own
- 6:32firings and its own, you know, decimation in terms of the workforce,
- 6:36demoralization in terms of the workforce. And also too,
- 6:40the Office for Civil Rights enforces a broad range of different statutes
- 6:45that protect students. So we have title nine for sexual assault
- 6:49and gender discrimination. We have, you know, title four for racial
- 6:53discrimination. And even though a majority of the complaints that have come in have been
- 6:57about students with disabilities for. For almost the whole time that it's been
- 7:01around 60 to 70% of those complaints concern students,
- 7:05students with disabilities. But in recent times,
- 7:08since the new administration, there has been
- 7:12a big emphasis from that department, from Department of Justice and officer
- 7:16civil Rights, focusing almost entirely on cases that have to do
- 7:20with students, transgender students with DEI policies that
- 7:24are being, you know, attacked, as well as anti Semitism investigations.
- 7:28So it's not only that they've changed their administration of the office, but they've changed
- 7:31the of it a lot, which could affect the work
- 7:36that they do. Following out those complaints for students with disabilities.
- 7:39I imagine some of the things you have found your show so. So talking about
- 7:43your show first, congratulations on Zero Reject. I have listened
- 7:47to the four episodes that are out. I don't know if there is. When are
- 7:50the next ones coming up? I think there might be. I think this week we'll
- 7:54hear episode five and then episode six will be finally. Yeah, those six
- 7:58episodes. That's okay. Great. And one of the things that
- 8:02strokes me the most, one of the things that I like the most about the
- 8:04episode is that you got to talk to a wide range
- 8:08of stakeholders. You talk to people at different levels of the system. You talk
- 8:13to people in the civil rights office, you talk to parents, you talk to administrators.
- 8:17You talk to a wide range of people that experiencing these changes and
- 8:21experience special education with very different perspectives.
- 8:24As you engage with this work and you listen from the different perspectives and
- 8:28different stakeholders, what challenged you the most? Your understandings
- 8:33of special education that you priorly had. And now you'll hear all these
- 8:36different voices and something challenged. That's such a wonderful
- 8:40question. I think that what I'm still sitting with as
- 8:45a paradox is the split between the
- 8:49incredibly good intentions of making sure that education is
- 8:53a civil right that must be protected under the law and
- 8:57the outcomes we often see where there is so much of a
- 9:01fight to get students identified. There isn't always access to
- 9:05the kinds of services that would actually enable them to reach what
- 9:09they need. And then there's, you know, there's a disconnect in terms of who
- 9:13actually gets identified because we have a lot of students who don't necessarily
- 9:17meet standards for being able to read and write and do math,
- 9:21for example, but they don't all get the designation of special education. So I'm left
- 9:25kind of wondering whether, you know, and, and as some of the,
- 9:29the critics of the system ask in the podcast whether we're giving too
- 9:33much of the emphasis and the energy in the system into identifying
- 9:37students and to going through these adversarial processes of,
- 9:41of getting them what they need, rather than taking a
- 9:44step back and saying how could we design the system to meet more students needs
- 9:48from the get go. Right. Because I think about the analogy of,
- 9:53you know, if you think about a student, let's say you have a health issue
- 9:55with your child, right? And you go to the, and you say, these are the
- 9:59symptoms that we're having. The doctor says, okay, here's a prescription and here's the treatment.
- 10:02But if you make the analogy to the education system, oftentimes what happens is
- 10:06you go to the, you go to someone, you say, this isn't working for my
- 10:10child. And the answer is, it's fine, wait a while, it will
- 10:14resolve. And they're resistant actually to giving you the services
- 10:18that you believe that your child needs. And then there's a phenomenon that's
- 10:22sometimes called wait to fail. Right. If we did that in the doctor's office,
- 10:26we'd be having, you know, wait to go to the emergency room. Oh, you have
- 10:29a cold now. But it's not until you get the flu that we're actually going
- 10:32to give you some treatment. So you can see how it's kind of a backwards
- 10:36model. And why can't we have a system that is meeting everyone's needs without
- 10:40this fight and without this adversarial nature? Yeah,
- 10:44that's great. That's something that we've been struggling with since the inception,
- 10:48I think, of special education going back to 1975. I mean, there were being critics,
- 10:52I mean, I see some critics, some critiques that are being co opted
- 10:56right now by certain groups in society that are trying to dismantle
- 11:01maybe special education or trying to move it to a more choice base,
- 11:05put down, push down the accountability to states kind of model.
- 11:08But those critiques have been even within our field, right? We have a
- 11:12field that it's also divided as special education people think it's one thing,
- 11:16but it's actually we have our factions within the field, like Eddie Field.
- 11:20We had people, you know, more thinking about in those terms. It's like,
- 11:25why do we have to identify to serve, why we don't do more universal
- 11:29systems of support that I can acknowledge the needs and
- 11:33the educational support needed for different kinds of students and provide that. But then
- 11:37we have also, which rightly so, and I understand why,
- 11:41but there's another faction within our, our field say no, no,
- 11:45if we do that, all our funding and money that is
- 11:48protected within special ed is going to get, get commingled with all other funds
- 11:53that's going to be spent in many other ways that may not serve,
- 11:57particularly those who have more severe needs.
- 12:01Yes, I, I absolutely acknowledge that tension and thank you so much for bringing
- 12:05it up. But we have to understand that the changes that are taking place right
- 12:08now within the Department of Education are coming from a very specific
- 12:12place that is not necessarily honoring the legacy of civil rights.
- 12:16So, you know, I, I got a chance in the podcast to speak to Jonathan
- 12:20Butcher, who is one of the authors of the education sections of Project 2025.
- 12:24And this has been essentially the administration's blueprint
- 12:28for what's happening across every policy domain.
- 12:32Asked him point blank if he believes that public education should exist at all
- 12:35public schools in America. And his answer was really evasive.
- 12:40You know, he said many of you remember that moment in the
- 12:43podcast, but he said basically it would be very difficult to dismantle it,
- 12:47not that it would be a bad idea. So he thought
- 12:51it was more, more of a hassle, a hustle, sorry to dismantle it.
- 12:55That actually was not a good idea. It was like, oh, it could be too,
- 12:58too much work. There is no point to do that right now. And I think
- 13:02what their view might take is that their
- 13:06expansion of school choice through expanding school choice does not have to deal with
- 13:10the dismantled part of public education because slowly it's
- 13:14going to be like the frog that is being on the hot pot. Right?
- 13:18You don't understand. You're burning until it completely.
- 13:22It's boiling. Well, that's exactly right. And I mean, I just want to point out
- 13:25that not to diminish what you're saying at all, but school choices is their euphemism,
- 13:29right? I mean, everyone likes choices and choices are great and, and certainly students
- 13:33with, with different disabilities and needs have deserve options.
- 13:37But what they mean by school choice is privatization. And what they mean by privatization
- 13:41is withholding Funds from the public system. And when that happens,
- 13:45private schools are not required to accept our students with
- 13:49disabilities. They're not required to offer a free, appropriate public education. Without the public
- 13:53in free, appropriate public education, there's very little vision
- 13:57for meeting the needs of students. So that is the defensiveness
- 14:02that comes in when people start talking about universal design for learning or,
- 14:06you know, making schools better for all students. I believe
- 14:09there has to be a way to thread the needle on this, but not by
- 14:12giving up students rights. Yeah, no, totally. And we know that
- 14:15for decades of research that we know private schools totally struggles to
- 14:19serve students with disabilities, even much more so than public schools. They don't
- 14:23have the services, not the specialists, not the capacity to recruit special education students,
- 14:27teachers. Same things have happened even with sort of public schools
- 14:31like charter schools. We have decades of research looking at not all
- 14:35charter schools, but a large majority struggling to serve
- 14:40those who have more severe needs. And there are some changes on the charter
- 14:44section, I know that. But still the proportions, if you see still the
- 14:48proportions of students with disabilities in charter schools and public schools are
- 14:52quite lower in charter schools, particularly those who demand more extensive support
- 14:56needs. And the same things happen with Catholic schools too. When you look at the
- 14:59research on Catholic schools, they are struggling. And as
- 15:03you say, once you go to a private school, those civil
- 15:08rights protections doesn't follow you anymore. Particularly if you go to a
- 15:12Catholic religious schools that may even be not required
- 15:16to follow AADA because of religious exemption. Yes,
- 15:20yes, exactly. So, yeah, so it's a really complicated
- 15:23point. And the reason that the title of the podcast is Zero reject is because
- 15:27that might be the most important fundamental principle in the law.
- 15:31A school of choice is a school that has the ability to reject.
- 15:35Yeah, and that's. That's exactly the problem.
- 15:38Absolutely. You know, one of the things that strokes
- 15:42me also about the. Your show is like, because you talk to
- 15:46different points of views, different stakeholders. I think these, those different stakeholders
- 15:51has also different views of what it means equitable or a just education
- 15:55or an equitable or an effective education or
- 15:59a quality education. I see different stakeholders bringing. With their perspective,
- 16:04they're defining that in different ways. And I think that brings tensions.
- 16:08Did you find that in your show that there are different perspectives or that people
- 16:11have different ideas of equity? Yeah, different ideas of equity. Different people.
- 16:15That interview had different ideas of what it was, let's put it what it was
- 16:18good for that particular child. Well, it's certainly true that people
- 16:22have. People can disagree about what is the best for a particular child.
- 16:26I think that the most poignant or emotional contrast comes when
- 16:31you talk to a parent. And the parents I spoke to, without exception,
- 16:34they want the best for their children. They want. They. They want their.
- 16:38They believe that their children deserve to be seen as having infinite
- 16:42potential and not being limited by whether it's a diagnosis or
- 16:46an identification or a genetic background or class or
- 16:50race or anything. They want their kids to be seen as someone of infinite possibility.
- 16:55But that desire which I share as a parent comes up
- 16:59against the reality of limitation, limited resources, limited time.
- 17:03And the really hard one, I think the one that feels hard to
- 17:08me to hear about but also maybe feels like it can be addressed is
- 17:12attitudes. So students for teachers and
- 17:16administrators. Too many times parents told
- 17:20me they heard a teacher or administrator say your child is stupid, your child is
- 17:24bad. Oh yeah. And that should never happen.
- 17:27Those are, those are limiting beliefs. That's ableism.
- 17:30And those beliefs and those attitudes can be overcome with
- 17:35a growth mindset if you have coaching and you have the right kind of edu.
- 17:37I believe in education for educators as well. And I think that focusing
- 17:42on that part of it because the negative self talk comes into the child's mind
- 17:46and as a very young age they start to internalize that. And that
- 17:50is limitation. Limiting. Limiting. So yeah,
- 17:53no, absolutely. And not only they're teaching that student
- 17:57about internalizing those feelings and thoughts that are hidden from astols,
- 18:01but they're also teaching the other students in the school. Right. Where is the
- 18:05position and identity of that particular student? Right.
- 18:10Maybe not willingly, but they are teaching ableism to
- 18:14the other students of the schools and putting
- 18:19themselves in that contradiction of trying to help the student. But as I say,
- 18:23also having those prejudices.
- 18:26That brings me another question. One of the most
- 18:31fascinating tensions that I found in Zero Reject
- 18:35is that how the characters
- 18:39of the show, for example, Alison described fighting to
- 18:43have her children's needs recognized. Karina describes trying to meet students
- 18:47needs with an overwhelming workload. Karina was a teacher. So we have this parent and
- 18:51a teacher teacher. A parent who's trying to fight for services. A teacher who is
- 18:55like overwhelmed by all the work that she has. Every year has more
- 18:59like a bigger caseload, IEP caseload.
- 19:02So it seems that we're putting parents and
- 19:06teachers in situations that they become adversaries. And I
- 19:10feel that was very well reflected on the show. Thank you. I mean one
- 19:14of the things I regret about the show is that I wasn't able to speak
- 19:18to a teacher and student pair. I mean I did so Karina
- 19:21in Fact, I should rephrase that. Karina, in fact, is the teacher
- 19:25at a school where I did talk to the mom, Christina, so that's in Denver,
- 19:29you know, so that, that little boy got, because of his successful office
- 19:33for civil rights complaint, he got transferred into a much better fit school. And this
- 19:37is his, his school. But, you know, when you, when you hear Alison's saga
- 19:42and the amount that she spent fighting with two kids with special needs,
- 19:45it was very hard because, I mean, for example, she reported on this moment
- 19:50where she was in a, in a, in a, an IEP
- 19:53conference, and the teacher said to her, according to her, your kid just can't learn.
- 19:58What am I supposed to do? Yeah. And you know, and she clapped
- 20:02back, as she says, at the teacher, and there's, there's more to it that we
- 20:05didn't put into the podcast. But, you know, it was very emotional moment and I
- 20:10couldn't, I couldn't speak to that teacher because the schools, you know, FERPA and other
- 20:14things, they don't make the teachers necessarily available for that conversation. So I
- 20:18only could go and talk to, you know, another teacher at a different school to
- 20:22get that perspective. But you really do want some reflection on those moments.
- 20:26And I mean, I think, you know, understanding that this is your day in,
- 20:30day out, and you have 30 students like this and you see them all the
- 20:33time. But also it's not helpful to have that kind of attitude about a child,
- 20:37let alone to verbalize it to a parent. So, yeah,
- 20:40it's, it's very, it's really unfortunate because these are the people who are supposed to
- 20:44be working together for the best interests of children, and if they're pitted against each
- 20:48other, it's, it's going to waste that energy. Absolutely.
- 20:52You know, did your series leave you thinking that
- 20:56we need stricter accountability supports or different ways to
- 21:00deliver and think of the teaching and learning of students with disabilities?
- 21:04I mean, I think we need both. Right. I think it's sort of a,
- 21:07it's sort of a false choice because on the one hand, you need things to
- 21:11work better within the schools. And I think that would, that might be the
- 21:14area I would look to first, is really thinking hard about the interventions we are
- 21:18offering because it doesn't do any good to fight for a better
- 21:22placement for your kid if the better placement doesn't exist. So understanding
- 21:27that, you know, what needs to be available for different kinds of kids and making
- 21:32sure that it is available, I think that's probably the baseline. And that also has
- 21:35to do with hiring and Support. Right. So there's
- 21:39a deep connection, I believe, between the burnout that is reported by special educators
- 21:43and paraprofessionals and their lack of access to,
- 21:48you know, correct supports and also the mindset.
- 21:52Right. So I learned a lot by talking to Stephanie Cozy, who is a coach
- 21:55for teachers, because she says she really has a growth mindset with those teachers and
- 21:59she makes sure that they have the support that they need for them to become
- 22:03better. Because if you have a teacher sitting there saying your child can't learn,
- 22:06you know, they're not in a growth mindset. They're not really approaching the job,
- 22:09believing that it's doable. And of course you're going to experience burnout if you think
- 22:13you're coming to school every day with a room full of kids who can't learn.
- 22:16So we need to support. But then on the other hand, we absolutely
- 22:20need accountability because I firmly believe after doing the research
- 22:24for this podcast, that children's civil rights are being violated every single day in this
- 22:28country. There are coast to coast. There are schools that are not providing
- 22:31what students need and what they not only need, but are entitled to.
- 22:35Absolutely. You know, teachers are. And teacher training in particular
- 22:39is an interesting topic. I think it's highly related to this. 0 reject,
- 22:43of course, cannot do embrace every single topic in
- 22:48special education. But teacher training, I think is highly related to this. I mean,
- 22:51if you think about a lot of general educators that goes into the classroom that
- 22:56will have students with disabilities in their classroom have very little training about inclusion
- 23:00of students with disabilities. If you look at university programs around
- 23:04the nation, I would dare to say most of them maybe have one,
- 23:08maybe two classes separate from their curriculum.
- 23:12How to include students with disabilities with mostly those classes are understanding
- 23:17the disability of the weak. Unfortunate. And then special
- 23:21education teachers, I mean, we are. Well,
- 23:24special education teachers are completely, not just under resourced, but also schools
- 23:29have a huge shortages of people with the expertise. I mean,
- 23:33there's a huge amount of vacancies that are not able to
- 23:37to being fulfilled every year. On regards to special education.
- 23:42Yes, but you also talked what you mentioned to
- 23:47Jonathan Butcher from the Heritage Foundation. I was very surprised that he answered
- 23:51the phone and contacted you. I don't think if I call him, he's going to
- 23:55answer. But the interesting
- 23:59thing is probably you and him agree on the problems,
- 24:03I think. Yeah, but the solutions are completely
- 24:07different. Why do you think that is? Well, I think it comes down
- 24:12to ideology. Right. So it's a baseline test of whether you
- 24:15think the public sector has a role to play in providing public goods
- 24:19like education or if you only believe that the market can do it.
- 24:23And so, you know, I understand the frustrations, of course, and I,
- 24:26I'll say this as well. You know, I do feature in the podcast the story
- 24:30of a family that goes to a private school that's very specialized,
- 24:33and it seems to be the best option for them in that situation.
- 24:37It's kind of a rare situation. It's a very severe form of dyslexia.
- 24:41However. So it's not that I don't think there should be private sector innovation or
- 24:44private sector choice, but if you, you know, it's really. Do you, it comes down
- 24:48to, from the dialogue with the Heritage foundation, do you believe in strengthening
- 24:53the public sector or do you believe in abandoning. Abandoning it? Yeah,
- 24:57yeah, absolutely. And it seems there's been a strong
- 25:01agenda, I think, from the 1980s to try to privatize and
- 25:05try to dismantle public education and rely
- 25:09on a private system. And this is
- 25:13related to my other question, because all these stories,
- 25:17I mean, like Zero Reject, the stories in Zero reject, where stories
- 25:21about exclusion, inequities, I mean, we need to come into lie, right?
- 25:25We need to bring them to light because there are students who are not being
- 25:29served and as you say, their civil rights are being violated.
- 25:32But there is a tension there, I think, because those stories
- 25:36are also being used to argue against public education.
- 25:40Right? I mean, if you think about your conversation with
- 25:44Jonathan Butcher from the Heritage foundation, he used those stories,
- 25:47I mean, those think tanks, those advocacy
- 25:51organizations use those stories to then say, well, see, it's not
- 25:55working. We need to send them to, we need to use the private sector to
- 25:59deliver those services. So how do you navigate those tensions as
- 26:03a journalist trying to bring these inequities and
- 26:07violations of civil rights to light, but at the same time knowing
- 26:11that that message can get co opted to put
- 26:15forward a set of solutions that you will not, probably you will not agree
- 26:19with. It's impossible to have full control over the stories
- 26:23as they're, as they're, you know, once they kind of escape the production.
- 26:28But I, I hope that by presenting the totality of the
- 26:32system, we can start to understand its values. So the reason that we started
- 26:36with the federal enforcement of civil rights is to make this baseline point
- 26:41clear that the reason that special education exists in this country is because
- 26:45coalitions of families over generations fought at the
- 26:49federal level, in state court, in the Supreme Court, in order
- 26:53for this to be guaranteed. And the, the mechanism for guaranteeing a civil right in
- 26:57this country is federal law and to a lesser extent state law. Without that,
- 27:01you don't have anything. And so in the private sector, these guarantees
- 27:05don't exist. And as much as we are, you know, pointing to the failures
- 27:09of the public sector, if it weren't for the guarantees, there'd be no basis to
- 27:12complain in the first place because before the law was passed,
- 27:16what is now Idea 1975, it was completely legal for public schools
- 27:20to deny entrance to students that they considered ineducable.
- 27:24So, you know, you might not be able to defend the performance
- 27:28of every public school in every case. And I, I'm not
- 27:32in that position. But you, you have to understand that there is a structure
- 27:36here that we would lose a lot if we walked away from.
- 27:40Absolutely. And that has a flip question or a
- 27:43related question which is have you find or is CDRO rechecked
- 27:48in the last episode will highlight some public schools
- 27:51that are doing a great job serving students with disabilities because I
- 27:55can guarantee you that I know they are there. We train teacher at the university,
- 27:59we work with schools, we have grants and partner with schools to help
- 28:03them out. And I know there is some stories
- 28:07like yours in Zero Reject. There was a lot of good stories and a
- 28:11lot of good that is being done to students with disabilities within special
- 28:15education services and inclusive services. And parents are also very happy what they're
- 28:19receiving. Are we showing some of that in Zero Reject on what's coming up?
- 28:23So in episode five, we sort of had the flip because we have a family
- 28:27that the woman, the mom, considered herself an education expert.
- 28:31She was an education policy researcher. She put her child into a
- 28:35very high end, appealing private school with a lot of outdoor time and unstructured
- 28:39playtime. And her child was diagnosed with severe learning disabilities, lost a
- 28:43lot of ground. And so she, she went into the public school system because she
- 28:47came to understand that the public school system was the only way that her child
- 28:50was going to get the services that they needed. And now
- 28:53that that child is in a school that is a public school,
- 28:58a school of choice within the public school system that is absolutely specialized and
- 29:02absolutely the right setting for that child. So there is that example
- 29:06and I wanted to make sure that I showed both sides of it because that
- 29:09was a person who considered herself an education expert but really
- 29:13had never given any thought to special education until this happened
- 29:17to her own kid. Well, that's great. That's great that we highlight in good stories.
- 29:20I think that's, that's very important, particularly with the kind of debates that are
- 29:24going on right now that we highlight that yes, there are some struggles and
- 29:28there are some challenges and there are stories in in that you highlight 310
- 29:33reject where civil rights have been violated. But there's a lot of good
- 29:37stories to highlight to show that there
- 29:41is a lot of benefits to how public
- 29:45schools are working. So we always
- 29:49like to finish our interviews with dreams and hopes.
- 29:53We ask our interviewees to help us to dream
- 29:57big. What would you like to see in five to
- 30:0110 years regarding the teaching and learning of students with disabilities?
- 30:05I am excited and interested in the conversation about
- 30:10changes to teaching and learning that are evidence based that are beneficial
- 30:14to all students. I think that there's a lot to learn not only on
- 30:19the basic skills side but also on the behavioral side. And it's
- 30:22benefited me to learn more about the ways that special educators approach
- 30:27their teaching and learning and approach child. I think in the age of AI
- 30:31and you know the choose to what is the
- 30:35human contribution in society generally we have to more
- 30:39understand that who we are as human beings and how we show up is the
- 30:43basic line of our contribution. And I think that leaders who are civ
- 30:47and caring and see the best in every individual can
- 30:52really teach a lot of us about that. Well, thank you very
- 30:55much and for ever since you don't Reject sponsored by Understood.org
- 31:00what are you waiting for? Just go and listen to it. Thank you for being
- 31:03with us. Thank you Federico for having me. It's a great conversation.
- 31:10Thank you for listening to dive in. I hope you
- 31:14learned from this episode as much as I did. Please help us
- 31:17to spread the word about the show. See you next time.