Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #88 🎙️|Public Inquiry Break – Before We Get to Water 11th Aug 2026 Part A|
Transcript
- 0:05Well, as you know, the public inquiry is having another one of
- 0:09its breaks, and I have to say I'm not exactly complaining. But
- 0:13just before we all disappeared, there was something that
- 0:16happened in the inquiry that I think is worth coming back to,
- 0:19because while it occupied only a relatively small amount of time
- 0:23in the hearing room, have a feeling it could prove
- 0:26considerably more important when we eventually get to the
- 0:29evidence about water. The topic of water, water ecology, and
- 0:34non-water ecology is scheduled for 11 days at the end of
- 0:38September and the beginning of October. Those who were present
- 0:44at the PI last week heard the barrister for the applicant
- 0:48making a request that a recently published European document
- 0:52should be put before the inquiry. We subsequently
- 0:57witnessed the PAC admit that document the following day.
- 1:02Document in question has a long and rather unthrilling title:
- 1:08Guidance for the Implementation of the Water Framework Directive
- 1:12during the permitting of new projects and existing
- 1:16activities, with a particular focus on the mining sector. I
- 1:21know, try containing yourselves. It's exactly the sort of
- 1:25chicklet one would read during an inquiry break. But bear with
- 1:31me. In this podcast today, I will endeavour to explain what
- 1:34this document actually says. Because, having read it several
- 1:39times now, I think understanding this document before the water
- 1:45evidence begins might be rather useful for all of us. And then,
- 1:53in the follow-on podcast from this, I want to turn the whole
- 1:56thing around and ask what communities protecting water
- 2:00might need to do in response. First, what exactly is it? It
- 2:08was published by the European Commission on 26th of May this
- 2:11year, 2026, and it is guidance. This document is not itself a
- 2:18new law. The European Commission actually says so quite
- 2:24explicitly. It says the guidance does not replace, add to, or
- 2:30amend the existing legislation. So before anybody runs off
- 2:34saying Europe has changed the law so that the mining companies
- 2:38can pollute the rivers, no, not true. Earlier this year, the
- 2:43underlying European Water Legislation itself was amended
- 2:47by something called Directive 2026 Forward Slash 805. The
- 2:54guidance document itself is the European Commission explaining
- 2:59how it believes those rules may be implemented, and the title
- 3:05also tells us something rather important. It isn't general
- 3:10guidance, which just happens to mention mining somewhere on page
- 3:1414. Mining is right there in the title, with a particular focus
- 3:21on the mining sector, and when you read the opening pages, you
- 3:26begin to understand why the European Commission talks about
- 3:32Europe's need for critical raw materials, reducing dependency
- 3:37on imports, and supporting the energy transition. It also says
- 3:43that inconsistent implementation of the Water Framework Directive
- 3:48affects both the cost and the likelihood of obtaining a
- 3:53permit, particularly for critical raw material projects.
- 3:59That sentence caught my attention because we often think
- 4:03about the Water Framework Directive as something designed
- 4:06to protect water. At least I do, and of course it is. But here we
- 4:12have guidance partly concerned with making the operation of
- 4:16those protections clearer and more predictable for people
- 4:20seeking permits for mining companies, occurs to me that
- 4:25these two objects aren't necessarily compatible. But you
- 4:31can probably see where the tension begins. Europe wants
- 4:36water resilience, and Europe also wants more of its own
- 4:39minerals, and these two ambitions are going to meet each
- 4:43other in a river near you at some point. So let's get back to
- 4:49first principles. What does the Water Framework Directive
- 4:54actually try to do? At its heart is the principle that water
- 4:59bodies. Should not deteriorate, and that good water status
- 5:03should be achieved. And this isn't merely some aspirational
- 5:08sentence buried in European legislation. There is an
- 5:13important European court case called the Weezer case. I
- 5:18probably have mispronounced that, which wasn't actually
- 5:22about mining at all, it concerned plans to deepen parts
- 5:26of a German river, so the larger ships could use it. An
- 5:31environmental organisation challenged the approval, and
- 5:34eventually a really important question about the Water
- 5:37Framework Directive reached the European Court. In very simple
- 5:42terms, were these environmental objectives simply something
- 5:48governments were expected to aim for, or did they actually have
- 5:52to be applied when an individual project was being considered for
- 5:56approval?
- 5:57The court made it abundantly clear that the obligation to
- 6:01prevent deterioration also applies when individual projects
- 6:06are being authorised, and where a project may cause
- 6:11deterioration of the water body status, it cannot simply be
- 6:15authorised unless it qualifies for one of the specific
- 6:19exceptions allowed under the law, and the conditions for that
- 6:23exception are met. And importantly, this new European
- 6:29Commission guidance doesn't do away with that fundamental
- 6:33protection; it repeats it. It also says something else which
- 6:38will be worth remembering. Before authorization, the
- 6:42competent authority has to establish with sufficient
- 6:46certainty that the project will not cause deterioration or
- 6:51compromise achievement of good status or potential. Sufficient
- 6:57certainty is a key phrase here, and the guidance goes further.
- 7:03It says that decisions should be based on soundly documented
- 7:07evidence in advance of the start of the project, and even at the
- 7:13earlier screening stage, when they are trying to establish
- 7:16what effects a project might have on the water, the
- 7:21precautionary principle has to be taken into account. So,
- 7:25coming back to that phrase, sufficient certainty. Hold on to
- 7:30it for a minute, because it may well turn out to be two of the
- 7:33most important words in all of the 18 pages. Now we get to the
- 7:39interesting bit, because having restated these protections, much
- 7:45of the document then explains the different flexibilities that
- 7:48exist within the system, and this is where I started
- 7:52scribbling in the margins. The first thing to understand is
- 7:56that the assessment is generally about the status of a water body
- 8:01as a whole, not simply what comes out of a particular pipe,
- 8:06or what happens at one point in a stream. The guidance explains
- 8:11that when they assess whether the water meets the required
- 8:15chemical standard, they're looking at the water body as a
- 8:18whole, not simply at what is coming out of one particular
- 8:22discharge pipe, and the pollution standard set for that
- 8:26water body doesn't automatically become the limit that an
- 8:31individual mine or factory is allowed to discharge. And then
- 8:37the European Commission gives a hypothetical example involving
- 8:41PFASs, the so-called forever chemicals, and I'm not
- 8:47suggesting PFAS will be discharged from the proposed
- 8:51mine here. It's simply the example the European Commission
- 8:54itself uses to explain how this approach could work. Imagine a
- 8:59river already affected by the industries discharging PFAS, and
- 9:04the new metal processing operation wants to discharge
- 9:07wastewater containing PFAS into the same river. The guidance
- 9:13says the authority could potentially review the permits
- 9:16of the existing industries and require them to reduce their PFA
- 9:21discharges. If those reductions create enough room so that the
- 9:26additional discharge from the new activity does not result in
- 9:31deterioration of the chemical status of the water body, the
- 9:35new activity could potentially proceed. Now, technically, that
- 9:41is an integrated approach to pollution control. Reduce
- 9:46pollution somewhere, avoid increasing the overall pollution
- 9:50status. But I have another way of thinking about it. If one
- 9:57industry reduces the amount of pollution it puts into. River,
- 10:01and that improvement then makes it possible for a new industry
- 10:05to discharge into the same water body. Does that improvement
- 10:09actually leave us with a cleaner river, or does it simply create
- 10:13room for another source of pollution? And if it does create
- 10:18that room, who gets the benefit of the improvement? The river or
- 10:24the next development? Does cleaner water become an
- 10:28environmental gain, or does it become capacity for someone else
- 10:33to discharge something else into the system? And then we come to
- 10:39something called mixing zones, and this is one of the sections
- 10:45I think everyone following the water debate needs at least to
- 10:49understand. A mixing zone is an area adjacent to a discharge
- 10:55point, where concentrations of a pollutant can excel the relevant
- 11:00environmental quality standard, subject to conditions, while the
- 11:04rest of the surface water body remains compliant. The European
- 11:09Commission explains that dilution occurs after discharge,
- 11:14and acknowledges that some industrial activities may not be
- 11:17able to reduce the concentration of particular pollutants in
- 11:23their effluent below the relevant environmental quality
- 11:26standard before discharge, so that means they they really
- 11:30can't deduce what's coming out from their processes. European
- 11:33legislation therefore allows member states to designate
- 11:37proportionate mixing zones around discharge points. And the
- 11:43phrase that the European Commission used rather jumped
- 11:45off the page at me. It describes mixing zones as powerful tool to
- 11:51address new pollution sources.
- 11:55But you will be relieved to hear that there are safeguards. It
- 11:59isn't simply a free for all around the discharge pipe. The
- 12:03guidance talks about mitigation, best available techniques, and
- 12:08protecting sensitive areas such as drinking water, but it does
- 12:12not talk about designing the risk out the equation
- 12:15altogether. I suppose that would be too much to ask for. Anyways,
- 12:20it says that creating a mixing zone is an option available to
- 12:24member states, and not something every authority is compelled to
- 12:28do. And the European then gives a specific mining example, where
- 12:34mining wastewater could cause an exceedance of an environmental
- 12:39quality standard near the discharge point, it says the
- 12:44competent authority is encouraged to consider
- 12:47establishing a mixing zone, subject to ensuring that the
- 12:52status of the water body as a whole does not deteriorate. Now,
- 12:57to bring that out of the legal jargon for a minute, if I were
- 13:02living beside that water and that mixing zone, I would want
- 13:05to know what exactly is that mixing zone, how far does it
- 13:10extend, and what lives in it? Are there spawning grounds
- 13:15there? What happens in summer when the river flows are low?
- 13:21What happens during drought? Where exactly are the monitoring
- 13:25stations? And perhaps most obviously, if an environmental
- 13:31quality standard can be exceeded in one part of the river, which
- 13:35part of the river is it? Because you know, saying the water body
- 13:40remains compliant sounds rather different when you're actually
- 13:44standing beside the particular section in which the exceedance
- 13:47occurs, and the monitoring itself turns out to be rather
- 13:52interesting. The guidance says member states have relatively
- 13:57wide discretion concerning things such as number and
- 14:00location of monitoring points, monitoring frequencies, and even
- 14:04grouping of water bodies, which means we shouldn't simply ask,
- 14:10"What did the monitoring show? We may also need to ask, "Where
- 14:17did you monitor? How often? What did you monitor for, and why did
- 14:24you monitor there? Might sound a bit pedantic, but when legal
- 14:29compliance has been judged from monitoring data, the
- 14:34architecture of the monitoring really counts. Then there's
- 14:39another tiny sentence which carries quite a lot of weight.
- 14:43The guidance discusses how member states identify
- 14:46individual water bodies, and it acknowledges that the size of
- 14:51the water body can have an impact on the assessment. Stop
- 14:56and think about this. When somebody in the hearing room.
- 15:00Talks about the water body. They won't be necessarily using that
- 15:04phrase in quite the same way that you or I might say the
- 15:07river. A water body is a defined regulatory unit. There are rules
- 15:16governing how those units are identified, and because status
- 15:22is assessed at water body level, the definition of that unit
- 15:26matters. So I think when the water evidence begins, we should
- 15:31train our ears to listen, and when we hear this will not
- 15:36deteriorate the water body, our next thought should be, which
- 15:41water body? What are its boundaries? What tributaries are
- 15:46included? What's not included? Because before reading this
- 15:52guidance, I know I would never have thought to ask that. Next
- 15:59come natural background concentrations. Here, we're
- 16:03talking about a proposed mine in an area where mineralization
- 16:07occurs. So, understanding what is naturally present in the
- 16:12rocks, soils, and waters before any mining takes place becomes
- 16:18extremely important. Certain metals occur naturally in rocks
- 16:23and soils, so finding a metal in water doesn't automatically mean
- 16:29that industrial pollution has caused it. That seems perfectly
- 16:32reasonable, and the European Commission guidance recognises
- 16:37this. It says that for naturally occurring substances such as
- 16:41metals; those natural background levels should be taken into
- 16:46account. And this is where it gets interesting. For surface
- 16:50waters, the guidance says that natural background
- 16:54concentrations can actually be subtracted from the measured
- 16:58concentrations before they are compared with the environmental
- 17:01quality standard. So, in very simple terms, if some of a metal
- 17:08found in the water was already there naturally, that natural
- 17:14amount can be taken into account when deciding whether the water
- 17:18meets the required standards. Which brings us straight back to
- 17:23the baseline. If we're going to subtract what was there
- 17:26naturally, surely we need to know with some confidence
- 17:30exactly what was there naturally before any mining begins,
- 17:34because once development has taken place, establishing
- 17:38exactly what was there beforehand becomes a
- 17:41considerably more difficult argument, and immediately it
- 17:46creates more questions. How do we know what the natural
- 17:50background was?
- 17:52Not what somebody estimates it might have been. What was
- 17:56actually there, in that stream, in that spring, in that
- 18:00groundwater, before mining across different seasons, during
- 18:05high flow, during low flow, because once developments have
- 18:11taken place, reconstructing what came before becomes considerably
- 18:15more difficult. And I suspect that word baseline is one we're
- 18:20going to hear quite a lot of when water comes before the
- 18:23inquiry, and then we arrive at two genuinely new exemptions
- 18:29introduced by the directive, and these are worth understanding
- 18:35properly because the European Commission explicitly says they
- 18:40are intended to reduce administrative burden and
- 18:43facilitate the authorisation of projects, particularly mining
- 18:48and metal processing projects. The first concerns short-term
- 18:53impacts. Under the new Article 47A, subject to the conditions
- 19:01in the legislation, certain short-term impacts can be
- 19:04treated differently for what the legislation rather grandly calls
- 19:09physicochemical quality analysis. Basically, things like
- 19:13temperature, oxygen levels, acidity, and nutrient conditions
- 19:18of the water, the impact must no longer be detectable after one
- 19:23year. For biological quality elements, in other words, the
- 19:28living part of that water system, the maximum period is
- 19:32three years. There must be a reliable assessment beforehand,
- 19:38and subsequent verification afterwards. The European
- 19:42Commission says this might be relevant, amongst other things,
- 19:46to exploration activities or testing new technologies
- 19:50associated with mining. What I am saying is that the EU
- 19:56legislation now expressly provides a route for. Certain
- 20:00genuinely short-term deteriorations, where quite
- 20:04specific conditions are met, and that makes the prediction of
- 20:09recovery from the pollution absolutely central. If somebody
- 20:12says the effect will have disappeared within 12 months,
- 20:17then surely the next question must be: How do you know? Where
- 20:21is the model? Where is the comparable evidence? What
- 20:26happens if the hydrology behaves differently? What happens if the
- 20:31biological recovery isn't as predicted? And what happens
- 20:36after 12 months if the effect is still detectable? They seem
- 20:41perfectly sensible questions to me. The second new exemption is
- 20:46probably a little harder to explain. It concerns the
- 20:50relocation of existing pollution. Under Article Four
- 20:547b, particular projects can potentially relocate already
- 20:59polluted water or sediments, for example, from one water body to
- 21:03another, without an overall increase in pollutant load, but
- 21:08only where a set of conditions is satisfied. Amongst those
- 21:13conditions, the receiving water body must already not be in good
- 21:17status for most of the pollutants being moved,
- 21:20particularly the most persistent and bioaccumulative ones, and
- 21:25the ecological status or potential must not fall to a
- 21:29lower class as a consequence. Practical steps must be taken to
- 21:34minimise impact, and there are safeguards around the drinking
- 21:39water abstraction points. So again, not a licence simply to
- 21:45move pollution where anybody likes. The European Commission
- 21:49is quite explicit that this new exemption could be used in
- 21:53certain circumstances to facilitate mining projects. And
- 21:59once I'd understood that bit properly. Another uncomfortable
- 22:02question occurred to me: Can being polluted already make a
- 22:06water body a more legally available destination for the
- 22:11relocation of of existing pollution? Carefully stated, the
- 22:17answer appears to be that in certain tightly defined
- 22:20circumstances, its existing poor status is one of the conditions
- 22:26that can allow such relocation, and that troubles me at a
- 22:31philosophical level, because then there is the question of
- 22:34environmental justice hiding underneath. At what point does
- 22:39previous damage become part of the justification for asking a
- 22:43place to carry more burden. It is a question communities have
- 22:49every right to ask. And then there are the provisions dealing
- 22:55with existing activities. The Water Framework Directive has
- 23:00long contained mechanisms allowing extensions of time for
- 23:04achieving environmental objects, and under Article Four, Number
- 23:10Five, the setting of less stringent environmental objects
- 23:14in particular circumstances where achieving the normal
- 23:18object is infeasible, disproportionately expensive.
- 23:23The new guidance spends quite a bit of time explaining how those
- 23:27provisions can operate in relation to existing mining
- 23:31activity, and once more there are conditions. The authorities,
- 23:37you'll be glad to know, don't simply shrug their shoulders and
- 23:39say, "Ah, well, the river's ruined now. Permits and
- 23:44mitigation have to be reviewed, feasible measures taken, and the
- 23:49highest status reasonably pursued. And again, there's no
- 23:54such thing as designing out the risk before any talk of
- 23:57mitigation or conditions.
- 24:00So this, nevertheless, raises another question: when a water
- 24:04body has been damaged for long enough, and a restoration
- 24:08becomes technically difficult or enormously expensive, can the
- 24:13difficulty of repairing that damage eventually become part of
- 24:16the justification for accepting a lower environmental objective?
- 24:21And the answer under Article Four, Number Five, is under
- 24:26specified circumstances, yes, a less stringent objective can be
- 24:30set, and this tells us something obvious. Preventing damage in
- 24:38the first place is considerably more important than waiting
- 24:41until everybody has to argue about whether restoration has
- 24:43become too difficult or too expensive. Now, there's one
- 24:49final complication I need to acknowledge. This guidance comes
- 24:53from the European Commission, and we're sitting at a public
- 24:56inquiry in Northern Ireland post Brexit. Northern Ireland has its
- 25:01own water environment regulations implementing the
- 25:04water framework approach. The Department for Infrastructure
- 25:08itself continues to describe the Water Framework Directive as the
- 25:12basis of a wide-ranging system covering rivers, lakes,
- 25:16estuaries, coastal waters, and groundwater. But what exactly?
- 25:21But exactly what legal or interpretive weight this newly
- 25:25published European Commission guidance and the 2026 EU
- 25:29amendments underlying parts of it should carry this particular
- 25:33Northern Ireland planning application is not something I
- 25:36am able to solve from behind this microphone. Perhaps when we
- 25:40get to the topic of water, it may be that we hear legal
- 25:45arguments about precisely this matter. What we do know, because
- 25:49we were there, is that Dalreadian considered this
- 25:52document sufficiently relevant to ask for it to be put before
- 25:57the inquiry, and the P.A.C. admitted it. That alone makes it
- 26:02worth understanding. So where does it leave us all? Strangely
- 26:08enough, after 18 pages, which at times seem to explain
- 26:12increasingly ingenious ways through the Water Framework
- 26:15Directive, I come back to the part near the middle: two words,
- 26:20sufficient certainty, because whatever flexibility exists,
- 26:25European Commission guidance itself says that before
- 26:28authorisation, the competent authority has to establish with
- 26:32sufficient certainty that a project will not cause
- 26:35deterioration or compromise the achievement of good status or
- 26:39potential, unless the relevant legal route permitting
- 26:43deterioration is properly engaged, and that conclusion has
- 26:47to be founded on soundly documented evidence beforehand.
- 26:53So, when the topic of water eventually comes into that
- 26:55hearing room, perhaps we need to listen differently. What counts
- 27:00as deterioration? What is the water body being assessed? Where
- 27:05has it been monitored? What has been measured? What is regarded
- 27:09as naturally occurring? Is a mixing zone involved? Are
- 27:15impacts being described as temporary? What evidence says
- 27:19they will actually be temporary. Is pollution being moved? Is
- 27:25pollution reduction somewhere else being relied upon to
- 27:29accommodate something new? Underpinning all of these
- 27:34questions, where is the sufficient certainty? In the
- 27:40follow-on podcast from this, I want to talk about what
- 27:42communities can do who care about water, and I think that
- 27:47conversation will bring us into a much bigger arena. It will
- 27:51take us to the headwaters and the watershed of the Onray and
- 27:54the Oonkaloo. It will take us into every community living
- 27:58downstream of these water bodies, regulatory definitions,
- 28:02and eventually to one last simple question: Who speaks for
- 28:07the water?