Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Making Trouble with Brian Kramer in Palm Beach on a Monday Just Because We Could
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] It is Monday, November 15th. I hope you're ready for a week where we do have some news, but we have something much better than the news. We're in Palm Beach, Florida with the one and only Brian Cramer.
- 0:12Get ready to bounce. Here we go. Everywhere I go, the people really wanna know, who I is and who I be. They stop and stare when they see me. They consider once, no need to repeat.
- 0:21Whoops, sorry for the hard cut in the music. It was supposed to fade out. That's a bad way to start a Monday. [laughs] It's okay. That's what happens when I DJ. Train wrecking. Yeah.
- 0:29Brian, Brian was on the ones and twos. [laughs] So we're, we're here right now in Palm Beach, Florida at the AAAS conference. It's the, a conference that Brian Pash puts on. Beautiful Palm Beach.
- 0:40We are sitting in the fifth floor of a former Ritz Carlton hotel, and we've somehow convinced Brian Cramer to come to the room and record a podcast with him. We told him there was breakfast up here. Sorry about that.
- 0:50Wouldn't have it any other way. [laughs] No place I'd rather be right now. So, um, the- The look in someone's face when you ask them what they're doing at 7:30 the next morning. And, and you give them a room number...
- 0:59and then you tell them, and then you give them a room number. [laughs] You know, we, we were joking that we're just gonna, you know, we're gonna give him a different room number. And we're like, "Look, knock.
- 1:07If they don't answer, be persistent. Don't take no for an answer. If security shows up, it's all part of the show." It's just like working the service drive. Yeah, [laughs] exactly.
- 1:16[laughs] We'll find a solution one way or another. Exactly. So, um, Brian is...
- 1:20If you don't know Brian, why don't we give you 60 seconds to introduce yourself and, uh, tell us why you love the auto business too, why you're in there. So my name's Brian Cramer.
- 1:29I'm the, uh, general manager over at Germain Toyota Naples. I love this business, been in it for 26 years. Started off as a lot porter and worked my way up.
- 1:39And just, uh, you know, been through a lot of ups and downs in this business, good times, bad times. And right now is nirvana.
- 1:45It's the best time we've ever seen, and I think that we've got an obligation, a duty, responsibility to, uh, to make sure that we preserve this business and, and don't let go of, uh, you know, how, how amazing it could be.
- 1:58I love that. Yeah. That's, I, I love that, the, it's, it's, uh...
- 2:04You know, you said the word preserve, but it's, there's, there's like another level of that that I think that you talk about, which is more like thrive, right?
- 2:12It's, it's not just like holding onto everything that we've had. It's, it's actually another level.
- 2:17Uh, so when, when, so when we think about not just like holding on and, and, and making sure we pres- preserve and protect what we have, like protect the good parts, protect the fact that we have the franchise retail system.
- 2:28Uh, but at the same time, like there's another level, there's a step up that even from where we're at right now, the, this, this feeling of nirvana is actually in, in my opinion and from what we talk about a lot, is there's, there's a whole nother level of experience both from a, a dealership side and a customer side that we can get in this, in this business.
- 2:47No, and right now there's a lot of people that are living in a straw house while some of us are building, you know, get mortar, bricks.
- 2:54And, and a lot of people are, you know, at the golf course asking, you know, "What are you doing? Why are you picking up all these bricks?" Laying, you know, "Don't worry about it.
- 3:01The good, you know, the, the times are great right now. You need to enjoy it."
- 3:05And I would highly encourage everybody to be building a brick house because whenever it comes, and it probably isn't coming any time soon, but it, the more fortified you are with your processes, your systems, your people, your culture, which is really what the foundation needs to be right now, the, the more when the supply comes back, it's gonna be exponential in terms of, uh, the payback.
- 3:25Ab- you know, the factories are gonna fire up again. I think that's one of the things that you hear so many people talking about. "Well, I don't know what OEMs are gonna do. Are they going to...
- 3:34You know, are we gonna have big inventories again or not?" I don't think it matters in the sense of like how big the inventory's gonna be, but you just know the nature of OEMs.
- 3:43And once it gets rolling, the temptation to keep making and keep pushing, like, I think it's gonna migrate in the direction of too much inventory again at some point. It'll probably happen sooner than later.
- 3:54You really think that? Yeah. We're gonna be at 80% of where we were in December, in January. So you're hearing indicators that are, are saying like- Extremely positive. Yeah.
- 4:04So this time, well, like six months ago it was a very different story, right?
- 4:09Six, just six months ago it was like, especially, you know, some of the Toyota dealers that I know, like you being one of them, are like, "Yeah. Well, they gave us an allocation.
- 4:18Now we're selling out of our allocation," right? "We're selling out of incoming," which was a new thing. And then everybody had the meeting where it was like, "Hey, yeah. Remember those cars that you knew were coming?
- 4:29Well, they're not coming anymore. Or actually, like 20% of those." That wasn't that long ago. That was in October. Wait a minute. September, October. Yeah. [laughs] Is when it happened- It's only November.
- 4:38Man, my- I know... my sense of timing- But it-... is way off these days. [laughs] But it, it was, uh, it was painful and it, and it took forever.
- 4:45And, and everybody had a lot of downtime unexpectedly, and not everybody used it in the same, the same way. And it's gonna rebound in like a rubber band.
- 4:53But when it does, I don't think you're gonna see the day supply on the ground that much. I mean, we're sold out through November into the first week of December already, and we've got 230 sold inbound units.
- 5:03Had to retool all of our processes. We had to rework our CRM workflows, how we communicate with customers, the slow drip to keep them, uh, you know, tuned in with videos and all the different things.
- 5:16And we had to rethink our whole business and get everybody in a room, as always, and ask, you know, what's the best way to do it? And we're still, it's still an ongoing thing, but I don't think that's going away.
- 5:24And even when we sell more cars, which we're projecting March of 2022 to be our all-time record best month ever, you know, straight up.
- 5:32Even though Octo- October was our worst volume month in 15 years, we're gonna go from that to that, and it's all based on supply, demand, and, but the demand is there.
- 5:41And I don't think that even when we sell, you know, 600 to 650, maybe 700 cars in the month of March, that we're going to have more than, you know, 30 cars on the ground at any given time.
- 5:52'Cause I think that's the new normal for the foreseeable future. It's gonna seem like there's no inventory, but, uh, but the sales are, are gonna, the velocity's gonna increase. Right.
- 6:00So it's gonna be just like a regular flow coming in.
- 6:03It's- And our, I think the sales staffs a- across the whole country have gotten more disciplined about selling inbound unitsThey just can't get away from that, what, what got them to that point, 'cause it's a lot of, it's a lot of evolution.
- 6:14Yeah. Yeah, d- I, I, I think that's an interesting thing, you know, a- as we look at the, the cycle of the last two years, right, and what people have grown attached to and then moved away from,
- 6:26I, I, our, our minds are so forgetful, right? When, when COVID first hit March of 2020, right, everybody dove in, said, "We have to be able to deliver vehicles to people. We have to be able to transact online.
- 6:37We have to be able to have these conversations when people aren't in the showrooms across the country," right?
- 6:43And then, uh, th- there's, there's a, there's a wide swath of the automotive industry that's forgetful about that time, right? And so, the warning- Majority...
- 6:52the warning is, is don't be forgetful about the time that you learned how to sell inbound units, right? And that's what you're saying, is we, we retool- we, we didn't just, like, put a Band-Aid on it.
- 7:04We actually, we, we dug deep. We retooled knowing that the better trajectory is a retool so that we can continue that trajectory with our teams and with our customers, right? Oh, for sure.
- 7:16And it- it's go- and a lot of people are gonna get away from that. When there's inventory on the ground, we're gonna start getting less discipline in our pricing and all the disciplines that got us to this point.
- 7:24But it, you know, a lot of people also say, well, this, the, they're on, you know, never before times.
- 7:30But I'll also say, when I was selling Lexus back in the '90s when the RX 300 came out, you know, back when there was wagon wheels- [laughs]... the, there was a 18-month waiting list, you know?
- 7:41Six, or 18 month on SC 430s in '01, and LS 430s, and whenever new models come out, the Bronco's a great example. Mm-hmm.
- 7:49You know, like, I, I had a, uh, friend of mine, my daughter's, uh, friend's dad, he went over to order a Corvette and they took the order. Had a very defined process for ordering Corvettes. No problem.
- 8:00He goes, "Hey, I also wanna get a Tahoe." "Oh, we don't have any Tahoes." "Well, can I put a deposit on one?" "No, we don't take deposits." "Well, what was that whole thing about the Corvette?"
- 8:08Well- It's just for the Corvette. [laughs] Right. What was that deposit talk? The same company makes this, right? Yeah, what was all that deposit talk? [laughs] So they're like, "Well, no.
- 8:16I mean, if it's here when it's here." He goes, "When's the next one coming in?" I, you never know.
- 8:19Well- You know, the shipments, they come in, you know, here and there, and they don't, management doesn't communicate that with us because they won't give them access to GM Global Connect, and they won't empower, enable their people.
- 8:28"But, oh, but you do know the Corvette?" "Well, we don't, we don't have any allocation, so yeah, it's just an order." "Well, can I order a Tahoe?" "No, we don't hold cars."
- 8:36[laughs] This sounds like a Saturday Night Live routine. [laughs] This is- Like a Who's on First? Yeah. And it happens every day in car dealerships, you know? Yeah.
- 8:43We got a, you know, in a Nissan dealership- So we're not forgetful, like, one year over one year. We're like v- we're like 10 minutes over 10 minutes, really. What are you talking about? Right. Right.
- 8:51We, we don't do that. You just did it. And think about how many- It was a Corvette... Nissan dealers will take a order on a GT-R, but they won't take one, uh, when they don't have any Altimas in stock or any Rogues.
- 9:00You know, order, order culture is much more advanced in Europe. People are much more, um, used to ordering a vehicle three months before they need it.
- 9:09Um, and I've always been fascinated by the difference between that culture and the culture as it's been in the US, where we just sit on thousands and thousands of vehicles just sitting on the ground.
- 9:19I wonder if this is going to be the thing that changes it forever. I hope it is. I think, uh, let's think about who doesn't hope it is. Who, who would, who would have a vested interest in dealers holding floor plan?
- 9:30The only thing, the only people I can think of are the banks. Yeah. Especially, and, and interest rates right now, it's not even that- It's not looking-... wise of an investment... but it, but it- Yeah...
- 9:39but it probably will change. But banks that floor plan are the only ones really making money on a dealer having inventory sitting.
- 9:45Well, in a, well, and the OEM, because they make the money at the wholesale, not the retail, right? So that's why, that's why inventory is consistently pumped down, um- But they have to have more incentive.
- 9:55Their incentive spending is- Right. Yes. As that car gets older, right- Yep... the incentive spend goes up and up. And then just think of all the friction that adds into the relationship, right?
- 10:04'Cause then you have, you know, the inventory manager's pushing inventory.
- 10:07Everybody, now everyone's trying to do this back-end dealing to try to, like, not get cars, get the right cars, ship the crap cars to the other guy, and there's just... I don't see anybody that wins.
- 10:17I'm trying to think of it. The only- Think about this. I think about this in terms of, like, the restaurant industry, right?
- 10:22The restaurant industry keeps the supply that they need when they need it for the time that they need it, right?
- 10:29Like, they- they [laughs] a small industry like that has, like, supply chain management and- Well, it's just in time-... and inventory-... because it's perishable. Right. Right? That's right.
- 10:37That's what Dale Pollak's like, "Think of it like, you know, a bunch of bananas." A fish market. Yeah. Yes. Fish market, right?
- 10:41Like, the longer you have that, the more it starts to stink, and it, it loses value and dies. Yes. There's a health issue there, though, right? Yep. Like, that's why- Especially in a wet market. Yeah. [laughs] Oh, gosh.
- 10:51[laughs] Hold, uh- So I'm- [laughs] I don't even know what sound effect to play for that.
- 10:56[record scratching] [laughs] But I'll say this, the same people that want to have a lot of new car inventory are the same people that feel that they need to have 200 used cars to sell 100 a month.
- 11:07Or you gotta have, you know, a, a 60-day or a 90-day supply when it, when it's flat-out- Right, that's, that's-... just not the case... gone. That's gone.
- 11:14Now, now Brian Stock has been showing us that for a long time, 'cause he's limited in space. But now it's like all s- He's like a European dealer. He is. He is in, in a lot of ways. [laughs] In a lot of ways.
- 11:26Um, but if you think about that mentality, the smaller stores all of a sudden have a really big opportunity to compete now.
- 11:35Because if you're no longer gonna be competing on availability and inventory size because it's more just in time as it's coming through, if you're a store that has been struggling or that's been one of your challenges, is having a neighbor or a competitor that has a huge inventory, now's the time where if you have an amazing process and experience, you can all of a sudden be the place because you're all playing on a level playing field with an inventory.
- 11:56Big time. And right now, all the, beginning this month in- specifically, everybody's 12-month allocation, which is what every manufacturer went to instead of a 90-day, everybody's still on that 12-month roll.
- 12:08So s- when everybody dipped, they-Right now, anybody who has an unfair, unfair share or competitive advantage by doing things transparently, that they turn, you know, 80, 90% of their inventory and they don't revert to charging over MSRP and going for gross over new car velocity and just maintaining that balance.
- 12:24And I'm not saying to give cars away. I'm s- you know, I'm saying that MSRP's a fair price, but it should be as close to that as possible.
- 12:31It doesn't need to be a lot over, 'cause your day supply, the turn rate has to increase 'cause you can gobble up somebody else's market share. And this is a, for the smaller stores, it's a huge market share grab. Yes.
- 12:41Yeah. And, and I think market share is the real win here, right? 'Cause if you can increase market share- Yeah...
- 12:46both, uh, i- in your OEM and outside of your OEM, then you g- it, it, it's, it's a r- it's, it's really, it's a land grab. It's, it's, it's the same as the, uh, you know, as, uh, buying land or buying real estate.
- 13:00Beachfront property. Right? You're buying beachfront property. They just, all the houses just got knocked down- Exactly... and it's like, who's gonna build the best house for this right now? Yeah. Who's gonna do it?
- 13:09And if you care, and, and if you put a good care system in place for that beachfront property, the beachfront property will continue to produce revenue for you over the time.
- 13:16So if you think about the, the clients and the customers that are engaging with you in this, if you, if you gain their trust, gain them in, in the market share, then- You're building a sea wall...
- 13:24then you're being, yeah, being- [laughs] There you go. That's, woo-hoo-hoo. [laughs] He tell you, he, he took the- [laughs]... the metaphor and just, like, pushed it to the edge. Yeah. [laughs] Literally. Brick by brick.
- 13:32All right. So we have, like, a minute and a half left. Brian, you were here two days ago for the CXO Summit, which was a very small, like, super 20 group that Brian put to- uh, Brian Pash put together.
- 13:43You were there, Brian Stock was there, some other big players were there. Um- Tom Moore from the Mor- Morgan Auto Group and- So tell us what happened inside that room that we weren't there for. What can you tell us?
- 13:54It was, uh- What were you talking about? I'm always fascinated. Like, what was the top- what were the topics of conversation when you get that level of people in the room?
- 14:01Okay, that's a great question, 'cause I'll tell you what, that room was, was straight fire. And, and every single person in that room was contributing and, and adding value.
- 14:09And I mean, I took pages and pages of notes and learned a, a ton, and Ben Stock was saying the exact same thing. So they were talking about very high level, different KPIs that we had never considered, and why.
- 14:20Like what? Mm. Give us some examples. Um, that we're talking about what percentage of your sale, uh, what percentage of your appraisal's on site unseens, on remote, uh, appraisals. [laughs] Oh, boy.
- 14:32V- virtual versus in showroom. What, um... DG, DG was talking about... I mean, they had metrics, three pages of, and I, I forget exactly what all they were, but sales- Well, DG, DG has built a whole data lake- He-...
- 14:46and they're building into just technology and, and, and resourcing that most dealers couldn't, uh, uh, and not even dream is possible for, for the automotive industry. PVR per click. I mean- Oof. [laughs]...
- 14:57just crazy, like, like, stuff that it- it's just hard for you to wrap your mind around. I mean, yeah, they're g- they're trying to leverage sales force and- Yeah...
- 15:05and, uh, uh, stuff that I've never even, you know, considered. I mean, that's- Yeah... that's a lot of the stuff that was going on.
- 15:10But then Tom Moore brought it back, a- and Joe, uh, Lampiere, they both brought it back down to keep us grounded, 'cause you can very easily go up into the clouds in those types of situations. Yeah.
- 15:21And I, I'll tell you something else that was interesting. Uh, Nick Sabella was talking about, they got 19 rooftops, and then, and all, everybody was talking about the different levels of buy-in for, in the same group.
- 15:33You know, I experienced the same thing in my group- Mm... from myself to other people that aren't as bought in.
- 15:37There's a lot of different ways, but I think that the biggest takeaway, 'cause Tom Moore was talking about Carvana and we should have a competitive advantage, which he's right, you know. And- I agree. Yeah...
- 15:47and if you think about Instacart and grocery stores, people still wanna buy from their local. We're pushing them away to go buy somewhere else. And a- as he s- he said, he goes, "There's more than the"...
- 15:58The, um, the young lady from Walser was there talking about single point of contact, one price, and there was a, uh, obviously a lot of debate about that, and it w- and it got very- Oh, yeah...
- 16:07passionate and between all of us. [laughs] And Ben Stock myself. Passion is a good word for it, right? [laughs] I can't imagine that. But it was, it was lively.
- 16:13But Tom Moore said, he goes, "You know, the one thing that I'll take away from this is that there's no one way to skin a cat, and there's no one way to do it, because everybody in that room does things completely differently, but they all are successful- Massively successful...
- 16:25in many different ways." Yeah. Absolutely. Well, Kyle, bring us home for today. It's all the time we have. I think that that's the, that's the key.
- 16:32That's the k- that's the kicker, is, is whether you're going to a conference or sitting in a room with your, with your team, figure out the best way to do business for the people in your market, and win at that, and you'll be successful.
- 16:42Everywhere I go, the people really wanna know, who I is and who I be. They stop and stare when they see me. If I said it once, no need to repeat. Run up on me, watch you fall to your knees. Tip your-