Latest / Portfolio Talks / Ep 17 : Should I Incorporate?
Transcript
- Vishal Gill, CFP: Hey everyone, welcome to another episode of Portfolio Talks. Today we're gonna be talking about should you incorporate? Very simple. I think far too often when you're asking this question, the answer you get back is, well, it depends. Although that's not really the wrong answer, it probably doesn't help you all that much. And that's what we're aiming to do in this episode is not to give you a definitive answer, but to give you a definitive framework so you know if you can eliminate yourself from incorporating. If you're not gonna be able to eliminate yourself from incorporating, then it starts to make a whole lot more sense why you would want to incorporate. And what we're gonna lay out in the back half of the episode is the benefits and then the things you need to consider as you start accumulating wealth in your corporation. You also want to start planning for your de-accumulation. I will explain why, unless you like paying triple taxation potentially. If that's your MO, then don't even listen to episode. But you want to save money on tax and make your career more worthwhile, definitely tune into this episode and give us a share, give us a like. And subscribe if you haven't already done so. It helps us get these episodes to you faster and faster and faster. With that being said, let's jump into another episode of Portfolio Talks. All right, we're back. Another episode of Portfolio Talks. And you may wonder why we're launching this episode a little bit late. truthfully, we just got busy. busy with work. It was Remembrance Day. so hope you all celebrated in your own way and just remembering those who sacrificed so much for us. and then just the end of the year, you know, around November, it is our busiest time at the firm. Lots of client year ends, a lot of new clients being like, 2027 is right around the corner. And we want to make twenty twenty seven better than twenty twenty six was, or there's some, tax quagmires happening in April that they were just made aware of from their accountant. So all that included, it is a crazy busy time. And on top of that, I've been absolutely binge watching the internet invitational for for golf. So I don't know, Tesla, did you watch the five hour episode or any other ones? Tyson Nagasaka: No, I haven't. My son's really into it and I get updates from him. It's almost as good as YouTube clips. and I I will sit down sometime, probably over Christmas, and I'll go and watch the whole thing. But I think that's one of the benefits is it being on YouTube is you can always revisit it and watch the whole thing. And I almost never sit down and watch live TV. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, honestly same. I don't remember the last thing I've watched fully on live TV. I haven't really watched the news since I was in the grade six. It was just too negative then and it just got worse from from that point on. But even sporting events, I I don't remember the last full football game I've watched or the full basketball game. I'm I'm heavy into fantasy, so I got fantasy football, fantasy basketball. if any of my boys from the fantasy basketball league are watching, you guys suck. I'm beating you all right now. but it's I don't even get to watch the full full game, so I'll watch like Ten fifteen minutes here and there, but then I'll go into YouTube and I'll watch the nine minute clips of the games instead. So it just it makes consuming so much easier that I don't have to sit there and watch the ads and all the in between. It's just nine minutes I got the full football game or nine minutes I got the full basketball game. I can watch my highlights at the end of the night and that's basically it. But brother, I've been addicted to the internet invitational. I don't know what it is. It's I've been seeing a bunch of memes like it's reality TV for for guys or the Kardashians for guys, but it's been an absolute addiction. So I'm all caught up and the the finale is actually being live streamed right now. So I chose Tyson Nagasaka: Okay. Vishal Gill, CFP: I chose the audience, I chose all you guys instead of watching the internet invitational. So if you didn't feel important today, now you should because I chose you over that, but I'll watch it later on. yeah, so jumping into it, incorporation, it is one of the most important decisions you'll make in your career. Whether you do it or not, or when you do it, is is all very important. And what we usually hear from all the people that we talked to, and and this kind of came up from our new grad boot camp that we did, was it October or earlier than that? Tyson Nagasaka: Might have been September. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, what if it's September? So September, October, we did a new grad boot camp for optometrists just starting their careers for the first time. So it was anywhere from just about to start working to about two years in. And the question that they had was about incorporation. The answer from their accountants always seemed to be the same is well, it depends. and we can chat about it when tax time comes. Because again, we talked about this one of our other episodes, it's not that accountants do anything wrong, it's just the fact that their business is built as tax filings. They're not more or less built to accommodate full conversations of planning, they are volume businesses and they have a ton of volume because there's a ton of people like you that need their taxes done. So that answer doesn't really help them all that much. What we want to do is give you guys definitive frameworks. So it was actually funny timing. Tyson, you were actually just at a seminar, I think, for incorporating this morning, right? Or a workshop. Tyson Nagasaka: That's right. Yeah. I was at a tax seminar this morning, which is why I'm all dressed up. I'm not usually like this at home wearing a suit. but Vishal Gill, CFP: It's just the top audience. Don't don't don't don't believe him. It's just the top. He's probably wearing basketball shorts underneath. Tyson Nagasaka: yeah, so I was out on location today, tax seminar done by one of our company partners and just talking about the basics. And so a lot of financial advisors, it takes them time to get into dealing with incorporated clients and portfolio planning. We've been doing it for a few years and I was doing it for a few years before that. but it's really an extension of regular personal financial planning is now you have to take into account corporate financial planning and how the taxes are different. When do you want to pull on the different levers that you have access to? And then what are the different rules? Cause there's a lot of there's a lot of different rules that you have to be aware of so that you don't make things worse. Vishal Gill, CFP: Absolutely. So I guess to start, we've probably talked about this before, but for anyone who hasn't listened to our prior episodes, real quick, like 20 seconds in a nutshell, what is incorporation? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. So a corporation is creating a separate tax entity, whereas you have a personal social insurance number, your corporation would have a BIN number, a tax filing number, and it's like its own person. So you want your income to go to the company. Company's gonna have business expenses, it's gonna get a different tax treatment. Mm for most of our clients, they get a lighter tax treatment. So you get that what do we call it? Cor the small corporate tax. And then you decide what to do with the money. How do you pay yourself? You get a bunch of choices after that. So you create a separate entity. Your business gets its own number and then you get a different set of rules for it. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, perfectly said. And it really is about getting control of your income. So instead of having all your income tax in your own SIN number, your personal side, you get all your income tax on the business account or the corporate account. And then you choose to pay yourself how much you want, depending on what you need and and your other kind of planning needs. and depending what province you're in, it's gonna dictate what your percentages are. But a generalization is you're about 11% on your corporate tax for the small business limits, so 500k of net. Corporate income or business income, you'll be sitting at around 11%. And that could potentially leave leftover money inside that corporate account. So you can invest and grow and use that to build a lot of your wealth. A lot of rules have changed post 2018. back in the day, a lot of you listening to this podcast are probably thinking back to when your parents or your older colleagues started their corporation, like, just incorporate, defer, and they made it it seems too good to be true, the things that they're saying. It's because they incorporated and they did that whole journey prior to 2018. 2018 a lot of things changed. So we'll we'll kind of talk about that more as we get going on. so for starters, maybe you know, we should talk about what we see in practice. So Titus and I just kind of talked about what incorporation is, but there are some mistakes that people make because what they'll see or what they'll say is it's November twelfth right now. So in November 12th, know tax time is coming around the corner. I've already earned more money than I expected. So let me incorporate right now. And then all my income for 2026 is instead going to be in my corporation set of my personal side. I'm saving taxes. It's it's all good. That is not true. So maybe let's hammer out some myths right now and then we'll hammer out some myths that came to us from our Facebook group at the tail end of the episode. But I guess the first thing that we what we see in practice with mistakes is that first one let's tackle that. When you incorporate that calendar year's income goes into your corporate account and is no longer on your personal name. True or not true? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, not true. There is no retroactive maneuver that you can do tax wise in terms of incorporation or anything like that. that would fall under something that CRA calls GAR G A A R. It's general anti avoidance rules. They will not like that. So even your accountant should tell you if you think you're gonna have a really good income year or if you think that you're on track now that This year and going forward, you're going to be earning X amount of dollars. That should be part of your incorporation plan. And that's really where we want to come in and look at. now is the time. And so you do it now. So from the date of incorporation forward, all of that income falls underneath your corporation and the rules that go with that. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. I'll add another layer to that. So another thing to consider is what you were doing with your income. So one thing could be the accountants like, hey, you Vashal, your income is exponentially getting higher. So we should talk about incorporating now. Another consideration is your biggest expense or one of your biggest expenses is no longer here, aka student loan. So as your student loan starts to run dry and you're getting to pay that off at the end of the tunnel. That's one your biggest personal expenses that's no longer gonna be there. Now, how much income union is gonna change? So maybe that actually brings up that incorporation question a little bit more. or you're filling up your TFSA and now that is pretty much full. So you're it's gonna be a lot slower of a of a of a method of what you want to do with your money. so that's just one extra layer I've added to that. And then to Tyson's point, yeah, let's say 2026 is the year that we're in, which it is, and November 12th is our date of incorporation. So all the income from January to November 12th is gonna be on the personal side already. And then November, December will be on the corporate side, and then all of 2027 will be on the corporate side as well. So let's say that does happen. Another thing that we see in practice is mistakes regarding bank accounts and updating the bank accounts. if you want to talk about that real quick. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I think this is where logistical errors come into place. And so we talk about this a lot with especially brand new in incorporated employees. We work with medical practitioners and they work a lot of hours. So when they're not working and they're supposed to do all of this administration work, they might not necessarily have the bandwidth mentally to think about all the things that they should be doing. You wanna make sure your new paychecks your revenue that's coming into your corporation is going into a corporate bank account. And sometimes banks are not fast about standing up your corporate bank account. So you get your articles of incorporation, you get your license moved over there, maybe you get your insurances done under your corporation. And then you gotta get your banking done. everything else might be done in a day and your corporate banking might take a week or two. sometimes you have to make an appointment and the bank Set your appointment weeks out where you need action today. so those are some of the the barriers that we see to people making sure that administratively they have all of their ducks in a row. But if you incorporate, you want to make sure that you're using corporate banking, corporate credit card if you can, because it's gonna make your life and your bookkeeper's life so much better. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yep, absolutely. And I think the same thing can be said about your expenses. as much as people don't move over all their income, and a big part of this they they forget. And let's say, for example, you incorporate and you want to pay yourself, let's say you're earning four hundred thousand dollars inside your corp and you want to pay yourself $150,000. So you're gonna pay yourself with dividend salary, whatever, $150K throughout the year, in whatever installments you want to. But what you forgot is that there's a certain pay that you haven't. switched over. So you're also receiving income sporadically on your personal side throughout the year. And what if that's another $50,000 over the 12 months that you kind of didn't realize. And now your personal income is $200,000 instead of $150,000 and you didn't save enough taxes on the side to pay that tax installment. So now you have to pull more money from the corp and now you're in a shareholder loan issue and then you got to increase how much you pay yourself next year. So it's snowballs. It's very important that you get ahead of that and build a very, very strong plan. which a good financial plan can help you capture that. The other thing can be said about expenses. exact same point Tyson just made, but on the expenses side, there's oftentimes expenses aren't moved over. And we talked about this right at the very beginning of the episode. Is you create another entity and you can separate stuff. So all your corporate expenses are here and it's very clean and easy, but you gotta manually move those expenses over or start paying for them with your corporate credit card from that corporate account, not. Your personal credit card that was used for business deductions because that can be complicated and you have to get those moved over to the corporation. but there's manual error that can happen there. So just as important it is to move your personal income into the corporation, it's also equally important to move your personal expenses. Sorry, not personal expenses, business expenses that are paid from the personal side over to the corporate account so that you're getting deductions against that income. All that talks about bookkeeping. So, bookkeeping and budgeting is so important. it's one of those things that is another thing that we see in practice, is the bookkeeping doesn't fully get to the accountant. So you know, what do we see in that regard, Tyson? Tyson Nagasaka: Think it's it's mismanaged expectations. And so sometimes the client feels that because they see it and they're looking at everything, that the accountant is also seeing and receiving everything. And it's just like when you see errors in communication for spouses, this almost never happens. But just because one person's saying something doesn't mean the other person's receiving it. And so the the there has to be a system set up. So that you're confirming that the information that you're putting out is being received at the right places at the right times. and most of the time, the accountant does a really good job of ensuring that that is set up so that it's not a concern. It's not something that you need to worry about. I think when the client tries to DIY a lot of it and then just package it and give it to the accountant, that's where things get missed. And most CPAs are really good otherwise of saying, like, hey, we didn't get this information, these are deductions that we think we're missing. This is stuff that I knew from your previous situation. I don't think it got moved over. We need to look at that. So most professionals will catch that stuff. But I think when you're trying to save some money and do as much of it you c a as yourself as you can and then package it and send it over, that's where certain small things get missed. And those could be deductions that you, you know, could save you some tax dollars. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. And the only thing I'd add to that is the fact that you pay to be able to incorporate. So it's a it's a paid privilege there, I guess. and and you're really just wasting your money if you're not getting as much benefits as possible. So you want to make sure that you're running all the expenses and all the the things that could be done inside your corporation, actually through your corporation. The same kind of idea is paying, you know, you can get the American Express Cobalt cord or you can pay seven ninety-nine for the the platinum. And if you're not using the lounges, then you're not getting the benefits of the platinum. So why would you pay for the platinum? I'm like, no, I'm good. I'm it's gonna show up five minutes before my flight. And that's one of many reasons that that it's gonna make that flight stressful. but it's just a waste of your your Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. Vishal Gill, CFP: your points at the end of the day. So wanna make sure that's that's important. one question that we had, I think it's might as answer it now because it's kind of relevant here, was from our Facebook group. And the question was, I'm a new associate and everyone tells me to incorporate, you know, where do I even start? And I think it's good for us to answer that because our last point was gonna be those elimination gates and where you should disqualify yourself. so the answer is not gonna be it depends. We're gonna give you a definitive framework here, but let's kind of answer that question at the same time, which is I'm a new associate and everyone tells me to incorporate. Where do I start? Tyson Nagasaka: Yep. and this is one of our favorite topics. We do talk about this a lot. So we do have barriers to entry or elimination gates. And so I think the number one thing that we look at, especially with their new med like grad students, is you likely have student loans and student tuition credits. So if you have what have we seen? Five hundred thousand dollars of student tuition credits? Vishal Gill, CFP: National students big time. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. And so that's $500,000 of deductions or they're write-offs that go against your income that you'd be earning. So as an associate, you'll be self-employed or you'll be T4 employed under your current situation. And those student tuition credits can offset almost all of your tax that you're going to be experiencing in the first year or two or three sometimes. And so it really means like, why would you spend the 10 or twelve thousand dollars to incorporate, get your bookkeeping set up, get all the all the ducks in a row when you don't need to spend that money until year two or three down the road when your student tuition credits are running low. And that's really where the planning and integration of your financial team as well as your tax team come into effect and lay out a roadmap. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. Really well done. That's one of them. The next one is going to be, you know, is your income even eligible? and and this one is important because sometimes there's gonna be you know, hospitalists that are actually salaried employees. So let's say, for example, you're a hematologist and you're gonna be employed at one of the hospitals there, you're not actually self-employed. You're you're an employee of the hospital, you're you're part of perhaps a pension plan and things of that type. So you're being t paid T4 income, and because of that, you're not. Actually eligible to run that income through a corporation. So not all income types are going to be eligible for it. If you're a locum, you're more or less gonna almost always be able to run that through a corporation. If you're a full-fledged practicing physician and you're being given T4A income, you know, you can run that through a corporation. but mostly residents and hospitalists are are gonna run into that where they're not able to do a corporation run the income through it. So you want make sure you check with your your college and the nuances of your compensation to make sure that that is eligible. and another thing is going to be what if you have both? What if you are earning T4 income, but you also have some private work that you can do and you're earning some income that could potentially be eligible for running through a corporation? That doesn't automatically mean you should incorporate. And we've seen this a few times because clients will come to us and be like, yeah, this is why I incorporated, or this is the reason I did incorporate a couple of years ago. And if we look at the The amount of money that's going to be sitting and being a surplus inside the corporation, it doesn't really justify the extra costs associated with opening that corporation. You're almost better off just, yeah, paying a little bit higher tax on that, but at least that money is, you know, liquid on the personal side and you can use that to do whatever you want with. which goes to our next gate, which is do you have a surplus? if you want to tackle that one, if you have a surplus and what this means to eliminate you from incorporation. Tyson Nagasaka: Absolutely. So we see this especially with early stage businesses where you start earning eighty thousand dollars of revenue and then a hundred and fifty and then two hundred. And then there comes a point where all of a sudden I only need a hundred and eighty thousand dollars a year to support my lifestyle. Now I'm earning two hundred, two fifty, I'm on track for three fifty next year. Now when we have these conversations of surplus, it really starts to make sense that. That money that you don't need to draw out as income would stay in your corporation and get the benefit of the small business deduction limit, which could be 16 to 25% differences in terms of like money that's not being taxed inside your corporation, not being taxed going into your personal pocket. And that's money that now has more attached to it that you can invest and grow inside your corporation for disbursement later. so as soon as you start to make a lot more than you spend and you know you're on track to continuously do that, now it's like it's not really a question of incorporation. Now it's like what do you w what strategy do we want to attach to your corporation? Vishal Gill, CFP: Yep, yep, exactly. And then the last part of that is gonna be more of a qualitative side is can you live with the trade-offs? So there are trade-offs that come into the picture when you incorporate because it's more complex, there's more rules you gotta navigate around. So TOSI or tax on income splitting or splitting income. there is the GAR rules that Tyson was talking about. There is another bank account you have to have, there's more insurance you need to have, there's another tax deadline that you have to have. There's more accounting fees you have to incur. There's compliance costs. There's minutes books. There's potential financial statements that you need to get prepared from your accountant if you want to end up leveraging or things like that. So there's a bunch of things that come into play when it comes to opening the corporation. So that's another elimination gate you want to think about is am I okay with all the trade-offs that come with this? And just being honest about how much you're going save versus all the extra complications that come with it. An important thing to note is it's the irony is that just said how much are you going to save? But you don't actually save money by incorporating. And I think this is a huge misconception people have is incorporate and you'll save so much money because you pay the small business rate. You're not saving money. It's deferral. So what an incorporation allows you to do is decide when you pay the tax on the amount that you're not spending. Because when you spend the money, it's usually going to the personal side, you'll pay personal tax and you spend on whatever. But the amount that you're not spending is gonna be leftover. That's the surplus tysone was talking about. So, what a corporation allows you to do is decide when you're gonna pay the tax on the leftover or the surplus. You still got to pay the tax on it, whether it's when you're alive or when you pass away, that tax is still owed. So you're not saving tax, you're deferring the tax and allowing that money to sit there in a bigger pool and compound because of time value of money and things of that type. But important to note, remember this, you're not saving tax by incorporating. You're deferring tax by incorporating. And that's very important to note. Yeah, absolutely. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, absolutely. Vishal Gill, CFP: okay, so you know, a couple things to keep in mind is let's just keep running with that of what incorporation doesn't do. I think we we're on that note, so let's just keep on going with knocking us the mist here. So these are all questions that came to us from our Facebook group. so if you guys don't know, we have a close Facebook group for doctors in Canada. So whatever stage you're at in your career. it'll be in the show notes. You can join in there and then get your questions in for our next episodes. but let's kind of wrap rock these out one by one so we can kind of keep this episode on the shorter side, hopefully. But incorporating lowers my tax on money I spend. True or not true? Tyson Nagasaka: not true. you're gonna pay tax on the dollars that you spend now. You do get to kind of prioritize business spending and then you can use lightly taxed business dollars to buy business items, services, equipment. so there are some efficiencies that can be gained there. But if we're just talking about consumer spending, you wanna take a vacation, you need to upgrade your car. there are some semantics that you might say your car is owned by your business. That is it's not as clear cut in Canada as it is in the States in terms of your car how you're gonna use your car for business, you're gonna track your kilometers, you're gonna do a bunch of things with it. So it's not necessarily an easier route. but it's doable. These are conversations you want to have with your tax team. but the the there's definitions of Personal and corporate dollars and there are definitely some efficiencies to be gained. I think it's just like like we said earlier, there's levels of complications that are embedded in there. And you just want to make sure that you don't think your incorporation is the easy button to spending the money. I hope that answered Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. Tyson Nagasaka: the question. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, I have a bit of a different answer. I would say when it comes to that question incorporating lowers my tax on money I spend, I would say most likely not. what we see is most of the expenses people have are personal expenses, especially the big ones. Your your mortgage, paying off personal loans, shopping, traveling, all that kind of stuff. That's mostly gonna be on the personal side. So I would say almost definitively no, because most of that money is made personal. So it's gonna be onto the personal side. You're gonna pay dividend or salary on it, and then feel free to spend on whatever you want. So both answers are right, just depending, I guess, on your situation. next one. professional corporation protects me from malpractice claims. True or not true? Tyson Nagasaka: I know that some accountants will tell you to incorporate for liability reasons. your college rules will have some protections built into them, as we have talked about several times. most people will incorporate some type if they're really worried about liability and litigations and and people tracking you down creditors and whatnot, then you might want to have separate. companies like a holding company or a family trust or some some sort of dynamic in there, which is another layer of complication, you get some benefits of protection and other one, it's not an absolute blanket of protection. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yep. Yeah, really well said. okay, next one. I can incorporate my salary hospital employee physician. We already answered that one, so we'll skip past it. the answer was no, by the way, in case you missed the last one. But next one, I can invest a surplus in my corporation forever with no tax consequences. Tyson Nagasaka: no, the strategy there is deferral. And so a lot of especially old school accountants, their strategy is defer, defer, defer. And that is their financial plan for their client. However, you eventually need to get the money out of the corporation onto the personal side. So you can spend it, you can pass it down to other generations, you can do stuff with it. so you're gonna need liquidity somehow, and there's gonna be a tax consequence to all of those decisions. The big one that we see that a lot of people don't talk about is what happens if you defer, defer, defer. And then at age 80, you pass away and you have $10 million in your corporation. You could be subject to triple taxation. So if you had investments in your corporation and they're growing and they've done very, very well for a long, long time. Now those are deemed sold. So you're gonna pay capital gains tax on those investments in the corp. And then you have to flow that out to your estate. So there's gonna be a tax to get it out. And then your estate may also pay tax on those dollars from your corporation. And that is triple taxation, which could be sixty plus percent before your beneficiaries see a dollar. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. And that is the problem of defer, defer, defer, defer. So it's the same kind of thing as when people come to see the doctor, like I've got high blood sugar, I don't know how you know what they've been doing over the last years is smash smashing, you know, tidbits every single day. It's like, okay, well, you did that, and then this is the result. So it's the same kind of thing. If you just defer, defer, defer, that is what the path is that you're going down, is going to be having a massive balloon tax payment because again, it's not saving you tax. None of this is saving you tax. Everything ends up more or less being the same. It's more about the timing of tax and what else you want to do. What are the opportunity costs that you're allowing yourself to do or not allowing yourself to do? So we have countless meetings. This last week we had two meetings with two different doctors who are near-ish retirement, one's a year out, one's five years out. and they're both running to the same issue is they were deferred, deferred, defer, and now they have these massive, unrealized gains. they're they're they have no small business limit left because their portfolios are are returning too much and they're stuck because if they rebalance a portfolio, they're like, I don't want to pay tax on that. But if I leave it as is, I'm knocking my small business limit. And then also that unrealized gain is getting bigger and bigger and bigger. So you want to make sure that that you have a plan in place. It's not deferred save tax because you're gonna have a rude awakening at some point. okay, next one. My spouse can hold shares and receive dividends at their lower rate. So instead of me as a doctor earning, high marginal tax rate or the top marginal tax rate, I can send some to my spouse and they can earn it in the lowest marginal tax rate instead splitting income. true or not true? Tyson Nagasaka: That's a dark Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. Tyson Nagasaka: gray area. So depending on your college rules that you're under, your spouse may be allowed to hold shares in your corporation or not. but there'll likely be a different class of shares than you, the primary physician or optometrist or dentist. they're non-voting shares, and so the benefit of having a different class of shares is you could pay different dividend schedules. So the voting shareholders, which is you. Can pay yourself out a hundred thousand dollar dividend and you'll be taxed as the tax schedule goes. And then the non-voting individuals can also be elected dividends, but the the corporation is still gonna pay tax on those dividends and they're gonna pay tax on the personal side. There's there's no tax avoidance. there might be some what we call RDTOH or some refundable dividend tax. credits that are available there, but it it's not that it it's not a tax play where they're gonna get significantly more dollars in hand or in their personal pocket. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. Yeah. Perfect. And we'll we'll kind of circle back to the RD TOH. But yeah, for the most part, I would say you want to stay away from that income splitting, especially while you're working. You know, some differences as you retire now as you turn 65. or if you're pulling money out from the hold co that's you know, guys had surplus, you move that money from your professional corporation to the holding company. You guys have made decisions together to invest it, whether that be buying into real estate or whatever. and then those gains, you know, you want to compensate them that way, sure, all good. But you want to be very, very careful and almost lean towards not doing income splitting from the corporation because you can run into you know problems with TOSI tax on splitting income. And if you fall offside on that, your money that you're paying to your spouse is going to the top marginal tax rate automatically. so you want to make sure that you are very, very comfortable with the potential trade-offs. It's just not worth trying to save a little bit of money to potentially pay significantly more if you have to pay off offside on Tossi rules. Which is a perfect segue into Tossi. So tax on splitting income. So this was really huge on 2018, a big change because people used to split income. They'd have all 15 of their kids on their corporation and all this suit my floors and I pay them for 80k a year and and things of that type. So that is all pretty much done, especially for professional corporations. And why it's harder for professionals. Financial planners, physicians, dentists, optrists, many other professions is because there are rules around who can hold shares in your corporation. especially if there's, credentials or designations or or things like that that you need to hold in order to earn that type of income, you know, more or less you're not going to be able to have other people on that corporation. So it's a lot harder off the hop because now you're only left for the holding company. but let's say that you don't have someone. On your corporation, but you want to split income with your kids or your family. there are some exemptions that are okay for you to split income or pay family out of your corporation. And one of them is the work test. So if you have a family member who works an average of 20 hours a week in the practice, so this could be someone helping with being an MOA, it can be like an office manager, it could be social media marketing. cleaning, a bunch of stuff, event planning, whatever, whatever your your practice is. But if they're averaging 20 hours a week in the practice, in the current year any five previous, I'm pretty sure it's five, five previous years. maybe the five previous years, I don't remember exactly off the top of my head, but for sure in the current year and then previous years, you can actually send money to that person and it does not count as Tulsi because they are actually doing the work. You want to make sure you log it, you want to make sure you keep track of it. So if you have you know, a time card system or Excel or whatever you're using, you want to make sure that you can show it, you can prove it. And if they're asking, okay, this person does social media, what have they done? you can point to something. So just make sure that you are keeping your own records because you know, with a series, you're you're guilty until you prove yourself innocent. So you want to make sure that you're able to prove yourself innocent if that happens. But if you have a family member who's actually working 20 hours a week on average throughout the year. Or previous years, then yes, you can split income and you're not gonna fall offside with TOSI. the next one is the reasonable return if they're 25 or older. if you want to talk about that one, if if it's justified and and market value. Sure. Tyson Nagasaka: Sorry, what was the first part of that again? Vishal Gill, CFP: yeah, the one that's if they're 25 years or older. So if you're able to send money to to family members. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, and I think where a lot of this started was something it's it's called income sprinkling. And so professionals used to have their kids empty the garbage or do shredding, do vacuuming, and do tasks that is good. It's it's like doing chores, but Vishal Gill, CFP: That's a six figure toil. Tyson Nagasaka: but yeah, you're doing it in the business and you're flowing out a bunch of money to essentially these children that maybe they're they're under the age of majority or maybe they're young adults, but they're being overpaid to do a task. And the idea was that is a lower tax bracket than you, the primary incorporated professional, taking that additional hundred or sixty thousand dollars home and that would add to your tax and push you into another tax bracket. So you're gonna have your kids make they're all making eighty five thousand dollars a year. So they're they're paying a lower amount of tax. Well, they did away with that in the twenty sixteen budget or something like that. And now they want to the same thing. They want to know what are you doing? Are you paid appropriately? If you were to hire an outside person outside of your family, would you pay them the same amount? So there's a an income test. and then they wanna know, is that sort of the market value? Are you overpaying them as you should? They're your family members. But are you dramatically overpaying them? and and Hopefully you're overpaying your family members. sometimes you want your family members to do it for free. Yeah. Hey, do all this work Vishal Gill, CFP: It could go the other way around actually. Yeah. Tyson Nagasaka: and you're not gonna get paid anything. You're getting good work experience Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. Tyson Nagasaka: for your resume. so likely you're gonna be paying them a little bit above market rate. And so you just have to be able to prove that they're doing something, there's value, there's time logged, and you're working towards something. And I think if you have some sort of a career goal progression that's documented that really goes to help your case to say this is what they're working towards, this is how they're helping the family business. Maybe they're the next generation. We've seen several generations of optometrists in the last couple of years, which all work under one umbrella, which is kind of cool. and then it opens the door to a couple of other things, which are strategies that are for another episode. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, yeah, definitely. And again, same thing I would say you just want to make sure that you can prove your your case. So if you are hiring somebody, let's say we're gonna we're gonna hire a family member, it's very easy. Just go into indeed, search that job just job description and you're good to go. Just print it or copy it and put it into your file. So if you again you ever get audited or questioned about it, you can show that in November twelfth, twenty twenty-six, this was the market rate. And yeah, I paid them 10% for it. They're my family, and I don't really need to train them or I can expect more from them or whatever it is. All good and that's fine. but yeah, you can't have someone only run my social media and pay them 100k a year. what do they do? make some reels. It's like, okay, yeah, that that's that you can't really justify that. So you want to make sure you can justify it. And again, keep your records, keep your records, keep your records. All right, so we're doing good for time. the last thing we want to talk about is the exit. So winding of the corporation. So at this point, you're near the tailish end of your career. You asked us of hey, I should incorporate. Instead of saying it depends, we give you some framework to definitively eliminate yourself or qualify yourself. So you're like, you what? Yeah, my income is eligible. yes, I have a surplus. yes, I'm okay with the trade-offs, and I'm gonna move all my expenses and do all that kind of fun stuff. So yes, it all makes sense. I'm gonna incorporate. Boom, done. Years go by, you're investing, all that money's been growing inside your corporation, and now you wanna prepare to exit or okay, retire. and you want to wind up your professional corporation. It's not as easy as you may think to be like, okay, cool, I'm done. I'm done practicing. I'm gonna take all my money out and and I'm good. I paid the 11% tax once and I'm chilling now. I don't need to worry about anything else. That is not true. So why don't we break this up and talk about you know winding up your corporation and then we'll talk about the tax implications and then some planning stuff as well. So Winding up your corporation. Let's say they're not having a sellable business. It is just a corporation for tax deferral strategy. how how would that work? And what are some things I need to think of? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I essentially you gotta get the money out of the corporation onto the personal side so that you can disperse it or spend it or give your early inheritance to your beneficiaries. but you're gonna you're gonna be taxed on taking that money out of your corporation. And so some of the things that we've seen this year, huge real estate portfolios. man, if you do you wanna sell real estate in a market like it is in November of twenty twenty six, it's not a hot market, that's for sure. Can you sell it? and then if it's, you know, if it's just a regular portfolio of stocks, bonds, securities, whatever, then you can liquidate it. You're looking at how are we gonna get this money out? What are the capital gains gonna look like? Do I wanna do half now and half after my year end, which might be November 30th for a lot of our professionals? we would wanna have a strategy. So one of my favorite books is Think and Grow Rich. And one of the tenets of Think and Grow Rich is begin the end in mind. And not that you know exactly how you're gonna wind up your corp, but you wanna know what options are available to you and what are the off ramps, how are you gonna do that? So for our physicians that they don't even sell their business anymore, they just close up shop one day and they are retired. Are you gonna convert to a hold co? Is there a a road to precipitate that money out of the hold co onto the personal side? These are all strategies and things that we want to look at. Just like if you're a hundred percent invested in your R R SPs, you would want to probably have an RSP meltdown strategy, get that money out of the registered RSP on a stepped schedule so that you can kind of control how much tax you're gonna see year to year. because to do it all at once, you might be giving up sixty percent to tax, and that hurts. So, what was the point of deferring all those years if you're gonna give it all back? Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, exactly. So I like that line. You want to start with an end in mind. And you know, one issue that we see all the time is we ask these clients that come to us is have you ever thought of your exit strategy of how you want to start to pull this money out of my corporation? And they're like, No, not once. It's more so like people just invested and they think about how to spend their money, but they don't think about how to take care of that extraction when you do retire. And it's not like You're you're screwed and there's no other way to pull the money out. There's lots of strategies that that we can talk about in further episodes, but it's one of those things that you just really want to keep in mind of as you start accumulating your money in your corporation, you definitely at the same time wanna understand how to de-accumulate that money in retirement when you start working or even throughout your career. Things like realizing your capital gains throughout the years so that you're not having a massive difference of your book cost and then the market value of your portfolio. So you want to, you know, do that over over your career. capital gains or loss harvesting are are all really important. RDTOH is one thing to keep in mind. So little ways that you can start to use, especially in your retirement years, to take that money out onto the personal side. Capital dividend account or CDA is one of those things that accumulates throughout your career. And for the most part, people wait until they retire because it does cost you money to use it. So it's usually pooled and growing, and then you can use that in your retirement years. So a bunch of different things you can do, but it's important to keep in mind that you want to have a plan for that. And that's for the physicians that have no sellable asset. On the other side, you can have a a doctor, OD, DDS, like whatever, and they can have a sellable business. So their own private practice, and they're gonna sell it to somebody else, and that is gonna be a big nest for them retirement, and that's the money they want to get out on the personal side. Depending how you hold the shares of your corporation, depending if you haven't have had too much investment income inside that same corporation, there's a bunch of rules you need to qualify for. You could use your lifetime capital gains exemption as a share sale of your clinic. but you wanna keep in mind that that'll allow you to take the money under the personal side, but there's something called AMT that you may have to navigate around. You will eventually get all the tax benefits of using the lifetime capital gains exemption, but you might have to do it over several years. And keeping in mind as of now, November 12th, 2026, there are some potential changes that are coming out for everything to do with taxes, the administration of it and lifetime capital gains exemptions and even bigger ones as well, depending on the type of your clinic. so you just want to make sure that you are checking with your team and not just looking at an Instagram reel, I've okay, cool, this is what I need, or Chat GPT, then and then you're off to the races. It's a very important thing and you need to qualify. There's a lot of things you need to do to qualify for using your lifetime capital gains exemption. So you want to make sure you do that prior to you even thinking about selling your business because it's a few years you need to have it run and clean in order to qualify. But everything else is still the same. But if you're selling a business and you have a private practice, it you have the added benefit if you're able to sell it to use your lifetime capital gains exemption as well. the next thing is we talked about what reduces it and we already answered that is refundable dividend tax credit or RDTOH or your capital dividend account. so if you don't know what that is, talk to your team, they'll kind of run you through and you can check on your tax returns what's sitting in those buckets, which is which is all great. anything else to keep in mind with winding down the corporation? I know you kind of already talked about triple taxation before, but I don't know if you want to add anything else to it before we kind of wrap up the episode. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I a lot of the times what we see in especially in our industry is advisors and even the wholesalers. I mean, they speak in terms of a product to solve a problem, but it's not always it's not always that easy. And so a lot of what we see a lot of times is people are encouraged to use a life insurance product to store value money so that they could do something with it in retirement. And it is a strategy if You're gonna keep your corporation open until you pass away, which you have to understand the added cost of maintaining the corporation is always there. It's baked in. So the cost has to outweigh or the benefit has to outweigh the cost. The other thing that we can look at doing, if somebody's getting towards that time where they're gonna retire, they're gonna close up shop, and now they have all this money in their corporation. If they've paid themselves salary, maybe they look at doing an IPP. it'll be a little bit late in the game, but you get the benefit of past service contributions. So even if you've been doing RSPs, you could supercharge those RSP top-ups. And then you can do something called terminal funding, which sometimes allows you to suck a million dollars or more out of your corporation over the lifetime earnings. and and so to get that onto the personal side, and then the profile of your corporations lowered in terms of tax, and then you can start to make some decisions. So you do have options and availability, it's a planning conversation. And sometimes planning feels like two part technical and one part art. there's an art form to nuancing how you wanna live the life that you wanna do. And that's what a good team will do for you. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yep, a hundred percent. So on that note, we hope this kind of gave you a very strong definitive framework of incorporation and answers the question should you incorporate? there's a couple of things that you can do to eliminate yourself and just understand that there are some admin manual tasks that you need to do to make sure you receive all the benefits of the corporation. You definitely don't want to be one of those people that incorporates and then forgets to move all your income into your corporation and now you're surprised at personal tax time. You don't want to forget to move over your expenses and then you're leaving low-hanging fruit and missing out on potential deductions. And you want to make sure that you have a plan for deaccumulating your wealth just as much as you do for accumulating your wealth. It's just as important. So if all those things check out, then incorporating could be a really, really good decision for you. And you want to start that process by talking to your accountant, and then you'll get a lawyer to create the corporation, draft out the articles and all that kind of fun stuff. And again, it's very important that you keep in mind. what the plan is for deaccumulating. We see sometimes there are people that will have a corporation that can qualify for a left-hand capital gains exemption, but they have their shares owned by a holding company instead of themselves personally, which can run into problems as well. So always keep that end in mind and work backwards from there. If you need any support, feel free to reach out to us. But besides that, the last thing I'll leave you guys with is if you are part of our Facebook group, we are going live right after this episode in the Facebook group. To talk about the budget 2026 changes that were announced from the federal government, our opinions on them, what it means, what it doesn't mean, and things to be cautious of. a big disclaimer is nothing is really definitive yet. There's things offer consultation that haven't had answers back yet. And then not a lot of it has received royal assent. So until it does receive royal assent, it's not an actual change. And we saw this before with the capital gains increase. A lot of people panicked. A lot of advisors we saw in the industry were telling their clients sell stuff, rebalance stuff, and nothing ever ended up happening. So you want to make sure you take a cautious approach. It's very good to educate yourself, but nothing is really needing action right now, especially for the mega deduction. A lot of people were like, I can start buying equipment. we told them punt the brakes. We don't know if it's gonna be a capital expense, if they're gonna put it as a deduction, if you're gonna be applying the mega deduction and then selling your business in a couple of years, you could have huge recapture considerations. or it could just be a deduction and then you're not worried about it either. So we're gonna dump all that more in our Facebook group going live right after this. And if you guys want to join that, the link will be in the group. And we'll catch you next time on Portfolio Talks.