Latest / Comeback Files: Survival, hope & second chances / When the Experts Are Wrong: Trusting Your Gut Over the Guidebooks | Comeback Files
Transcript
- You know that sinking feeling in your stomach when a dozen so-called experts tell you exactly how to live your life, but your body is screaming that none of it fits? That quiet voice inside you isn’t being difficult; it’s trying to save you from a path that looks perfect on paper but feels like walking into a room where everyone is speaking a language you’ve forgotten. Let’s look at what we’re carrying today. Because I want to talk about the weight of advice. Not just any advice, but the kind that comes packaged in glossy articles, certified credentials, and confident tones. We live in an era where if you have a question, there are ten thousand answers before you’ve even finished typing the query. And for many of us, especially women who have been socialized to be good listeners, to be helpful, to be the ones who get it right, this abundance of expertise can feel less like a gift and more like a trap. I remember sitting at my kitchen table last year, surrounded by printed charts about sleep hygiene, productivity hacks, and meal prepping strategies that promised to unlock the version of me who was supposedly more efficient, more rested, more together. I had followed every instruction. I had optimized my mornings. I had aligned my nutrition with the latest scientific consensus. And yet, I felt exhausted. Not physically tired, but soul-weary. Like I was running a marathon in shoes that were two sizes too small, just because someone said they were the best running shoes on the market. It wasn’t until I stopped reading and started listening—to the slow drag in my limbs, to the irritation bubbling under my skin—that I realized something important. The experts weren’t wrong about the data. They were just wrong about me. Their models didn’t account for my specific history, my unique rhythm, or the invisible emotional labor I was carrying every single day. When we outsource our intuition to external authorities, we often lose touch with the very compass that keeps us grounded. Here’s where the turning point lives. It’s not in a book. It’s in the body. We tend to think of intuition as some mystical sixth sense, a magical whisper that guides us toward destiny. But really, it’s biology. It’s your nervous system processing thousands of micro-signals faster than your conscious mind can keep up. When you hear a piece of advice and your chest tightens, when your jaw clenches slightly, when you feel a sudden urge to leave the room or close the tab—that is not resistance. That is information. Think about it. How many times have you ignored that physical reaction? How many times have you told yourself, 'Well, but Dr. So-and-So says this is healthy,' while your body was quietly revolting against the idea? We have been taught to distrust our own senses in favor of external validation. We trust the thermometer over the fever. We trust the scale over the feeling of lightness. But the truth is, no algorithm can measure the nuance of your human experience. I used to think that trusting my instincts meant ignoring all guidance. But it doesn’t. It means using guidance as data, not as decree. If three experts say one thing and your gut says another, your gut usually knows something the experts don’t. Maybe it’s context. Maybe it’s timing. Maybe it’s simply that their definition of success doesn’t match yours. When you start to listen to that internal signal, you stop fighting yourself. You stop trying to force a square peg into a round hole because a diagram told you it would fit better. But let’s be honest about why this is so hard. Why do we so readily surrender our authority to others? Often, it’s fear. Fear of making a mistake. Fear of looking foolish. Fear that if we go our own way, we’ll end up lost, broken, or behind. There is a profound comfort in following a map drawn by someone else. Even if the map leads to a cliff, at least you aren’t responsible for navigating the terrain yourself. I fell into this trap deeply during a career transition in my forties. I had spent years climbing a ladder that seemed sturdy from the outside. But when I looked around, I realized I was leaning against a wall. The mentors I admired, the industry leaders I quoted—they were all climbing a different mountain. They were thriving in environments that drained me. Yet, I kept mimicking their routines, their habits, their definitions of ambition. I thought I was failing because I couldn’t replicate their success. In reality, I was succeeding at being miserable. It took a long time to admit that their path wasn’t a failure on my part; it was simply a mismatch. And admitting that meant facing the terrifying possibility that I might be wrong about what I wanted. But here is the secret: it is safer to be wrong about your own desires than to be right according to everyone else’s standards. Because if you follow your instincts, even if you stumble, you are learning about yourself. If you follow someone else’s script, you are only learning how to perform for them. So, how do we rebuild that trust? It starts with small acts of rebellion against the noise. It starts with pausing before you adopt a new habit, a new mindset, or a new goal. Ask yourself: does this resonate, or does this impress? Does this feel like nourishment, or does it feel like performance? It’s not about fixing it overnight. It’s about creating space for doubt. Allow yourself to sit with the discomfort of not knowing what the 'right' answer is. Let the uncertainty breathe. When you stop rushing to fill the silence with expert opinion, you make room for your own wisdom to speak. You might find that your instinct is quieter than you expected. It doesn’t shout. It doesn’t demand. It just nudges. A gentle pull toward rest when everyone tells you to hustle. A soft nudge toward saying no when everyone praises your ability to say yes. This process requires patience, which brings me back to something we discussed a few episodes ago about active choice. Remember how we talked about patience not as waiting, but as staying present? Trusting your instincts is the same. It’s an active choice to stay present with your own experience, rather than escaping into the certainty of someone else’s. It’s choosing to believe that you are capable of figuring things out, even if the path is unclear. Even if the experts disagree. There is a specific kind of courage required to disagree with the consensus. Especially when that consensus comes wrapped in love or concern. 'We just want what’s best for you,' they say. And maybe they do. But 'best' is subjective. What is best for your sister might not be best for you. What worked for your mother might not work for your daughter. We are not carbon copies of the people who came before us, nor are we clones of the influencers we follow online. I’ve learned that protecting my peace often looks like disagreement. It looks like declining the invitation that everyone else is excited about. It looks like choosing the slower route home because the fast lane makes my heart race. It looks like ignoring the trend because it feels shallow, even if it’s popular. These choices might seem small, but they are monumental. They are declarations of self-trust. Every time you choose your gut over the crowd, you reinforce the neural pathways that say, 'I can handle myself. I am reliable. I am enough.' And yes, sometimes you will be wrong. Sometimes your instinct will lead you astray. And that is okay. Failure is data. It’s not a verdict on your character. It’s just feedback. But failure born of your own intuition is infinitely more valuable than success born of blind compliance. Because one teaches you who you are. The other teaches you who they want you to be. So, I invite you to try something simple this week. Pick one area of your life where you feel pressure to conform to a standard set by others. It could be how you organize your home, how you manage your time, or how you approach a relationship. Notice the tension. Notice the voice that says, 'You should be doing it this way.' Then, ask yourself: who said that? Is it true? Or is it just loud? Give yourself permission to deviate. To try a different way. To see what happens when you listen to the quiet voice instead of the shouting crowd. You might find that the world doesn’t end. You might find that you feel lighter, more aligned, more alive. And if it doesn’t work out? Well, then you’ll know. And next time, you’ll know better. That is the beauty of trusting yourself. You are always learning. You are always growing. You are never truly lost, as long as you keep checking in with the one person who knows you best: you. Let’s look at what we’re carrying. Put down the heavy books. Put away the charts. Take a deep breath. Feel your feet on the ground. That is your anchor. That is your truth. And it is enough. Thank you for letting me into your space today. I’m Sherri Ruane, and I’ll be here next week, still figuring it out, still learning, still trusting the journey. Until then, take care of that beautiful, intuitive heart of yours. Bye for now.