Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #229 - Rachel Gilmore
Transcript
- 0:02Check Podcasts. Welcome back to this as van color. Earlier this year,
- 0:10the World Economic Forum released its Global Risks Report, listing disinformation as the biggest
- 0:16global risk in the short term, while the Eurasia Group of Political Risk Consultancy,
- 0:22headed by American political scientist Ian Bremer and former Principal Secretary Prime Minister Justin
- 0:27Trudeau Gerald Buttz, listed disinformation as a key factor in three of its top
- 0:33five global risks. So how is disinformation putting global stability at risk? And
- 0:39how is Canada affected? Here to discuss is one of my favorite follows on
- 0:43TikTok. An award winning journalist and investigative reporter Rachel Gilmore Rachel, Hello,
- 0:51thank you so much for having me on. Well, thank you so much
- 0:54for being here. Oh, of course, thanks so much for being here.
- 0:56Now, the terms misinformation and disinf information are often used together or sometimes
- 1:02even interchangeably. But what is the difference between misinformation and disinformation? The difference
- 1:10there is is so disimation. This is how I kind of remember the difference
- 1:15in my head. It's kind of like a grammatical trick or something. Disinformation
- 1:22is deliberate. Misinformation can be mistaken. So if I'm spreading a falsehood,
- 1:27or but I genuinely believe it's true, that would likely be misinformation, or
- 1:33is disinformation is more of a deliberate effort. It's when I know I'm saying
- 1:37a falsehood. And so this is more of the kind of thing you'll get
- 1:41rifters who are trying to profit off of f your actors who are knowingly spreading
- 1:46profit begans like that. Now, why is disinformation a global threat? Oh
- 1:53my god, I mean, especially this year, it's huge because its your
- 1:57ability to adequately pulling I guess responsibly or to the full. You need to
- 2:08be able to have all of the facts at your disposal to make a fair
- 2:13informed choice about who you want to elect. And this year there are more
- 2:17elections taking place around the world than in a very long time. I think
- 2:22it's something like sixty one different elections. I might have that figure slightly wrong,
- 2:27but there's a lot of them this year specifically, people are calling it
- 2:30the year of elections, So there's a lot of damage that can be done
- 2:34this year if people prayed on through disinformation or misinformation, not only in the
- 2:39sense that they might not actually elect the person who they would choose to support.
- 2:44If they had the full facts at disposal, but also because they might
- 2:46not trust the results of elections themselves, which is an extremely destabilizing factor if
- 2:52people no longer have trust in our institutions. I mean, we all saw
- 2:57what happened on January sixth and the taste right, So then how is disinformation
- 3:02a threat to Canada specifically? I mean, I don't think we've had the
- 3:06same type of election doubts that our neighbors to the south have had. We
- 3:09haven't yet, but I wouldn't be surprised if we start to see some of
- 3:15that. I mean, I every time I think, oh, we won't
- 3:19go there, at least we're not doing this, give it like to end
- 3:23up doing it too. So I'm unfortunately not super in that respect. But
- 3:28I mean we're seeing conspiratorial rhetoric take hold. I mean, that's kind of
- 3:32the wave that have pushed the Freedom Convoy to Autawa there and that was extremely
- 3:38disruptive. I wouldn't be surprised if we see a lot of that sort of
- 3:43gathering. Well. I mean, actually we are already seeing that kind of
- 3:47continuing to take place based on conspiratorial rhetoric. We've seen sures gather around,
- 3:53justin Trudeau whenever he hasn't said they get win and they're carrying flags like US
- 4:00legs Trump. Their grievances are just massive but not actually tied to reality.
- 4:06There are plenty of real reasons serious with Trudeau or any other political leader,
- 4:13but what's distinct here is that they're sort of fueled by conspiracies that you encounter
- 4:18in dark corners of the Internet that have kind of increasingly ballooned into a mainstream.
- 4:25So those can really affect people's democratic participation because if your concerns are being
- 4:30so polluted by falsehoods, it kind of deprives you of the time and energy
- 4:35and capacity to look into the things that actually genuinely impact your life and participate
- 4:40fully in that democratic process. And then there's the whole issue of it not
- 4:44actually the result of that democratic process not being trusted. I feel like part
- 4:49of the issue also is, you know, it's fine to have agreements,
- 4:53but if you're working on the same set of facts, at least you're in
- 4:56the same realm of reality. But if people are working off different quote unquote
- 5:00facts, you know, how do you even come to any sort of compromise
- 5:04or agreement or consensus, right, No, exactly. I mean that was
- 5:10actually a really interesting experience I had when I started speaking to one of these
- 5:15sort of anti vaccine, anti mandate but primarily conspiratorially driven protesters in front of
- 5:21Parliament. It wasn't during the convoy. It was I think the Canada Day
- 5:25iteration or one of another one of the demonstrations that were kind of tied to
- 5:29that whole freedom movement, and I tried to just fact checked what the guy
- 5:33was saying to me. But it's this whole idea of having alternative facts.
- 5:38I mean, if someone genuinely doesn't operate on the same plane of reality to
- 5:43you, how can you fact check them? Everything you say is sort of
- 5:46fruit of the poison tree in their mind. And it's difficult to have any
- 5:51sort of eide about the substance of the issues or the best way to handle
- 5:55an issue if you can't even agree on the issue itself. And now,
- 6:00at its core, I feel like we've always had disinformation, right, whether
- 6:03it's political spin or corporate messaging, or moral panics like the Salem witch trials,
- 6:09to just straight up propaganda. So why is disinformation so much of a
- 6:14threat now? I mean, aside from the fact that there's elections happening all
- 6:17over the world, social media, say, is the huge thing here.
- 6:24I mean, it's just supercharged to our ability to disseminate disinformation disinformation. It's
- 6:30also created somewhat of a profit motive information. I mean through the ad tech
- 6:38industry, especially where there's very little oversight and very little regulation, you see
- 6:42people who are able to profit off of getting the kinds of clicks and attention
- 6:46that you get from spreading disinformation because often things that aren't true are also going
- 6:51to be the same things that elicit a really strong emotional reaction. That's one
- 6:55thing BacT checkers always tell you is if you see something that makes you feel
- 6:59really angry or really upset at take a beat and breathe and fact check it,
- 7:02because disinformation often is supposed to elicit that kind of reaction. And that
- 7:10makes sense when you consider the fact that that is what social media algorithms reward.
- 7:14So we're kind of living in this era where there's not only the ability,
- 7:17but the monetization and the motivation to engage in disinformation is bigger than ever,
- 7:24and that just creates the kind of chaotic like soup of lies that we
- 7:29see all over the internet these days. It's it's just like a minefield and
- 7:33you have to try not to step on one so really quickly. As you
- 7:38just said, I believe this too, that social media is super charging disinformation
- 7:43overall with social media just a bad idea for us. I don't think so.
- 7:48I love social media because I think that what's great about social media is
- 7:53it also democratizes the dissemination of act information. So we're seeing people able to
- 8:00share stories about their communities and also just connect with loved ones we're on the
- 8:03other side of the world. There's so many upsides to use responsibly and properly.
- 8:09It's just unfortunate that the same tools that give us so much power to
- 8:13inform and converse and build movements and you know, protests and change and all
- 8:18of that good stuff also comes with this horrific, toxic underbelly. We are
- 8:24now in the podcast extension part of my chat with Rachel Gilmour. Rachel,
- 8:30I'm a big fan. Thank you so much for sticking around. Of course,
- 8:33it's my pleasure when we talk about misinformation and disinformation here in Canada.
- 8:39Is the call coming from inside the house or is it foreign actors like Russia
- 8:45and China, or Iran or North Korea that are actually disseminating this disinformation and
- 8:50sewing division amongst Canadians. We give the foreign actors way too much credit for
- 8:56things that we are extremely capable of doing our elms. Actually, one thing
- 9:01that I found really fascinating. I went to a conference like a year ago
- 9:05where there were a lot of disinformation and extremism experts speaking, and one of
- 9:09the things, I believe it was Stephanie Carbon who's a political science expert and
- 9:15profit Carlton, and she was discussing the fact that Russian disinformation efforts don't actually
- 9:22have to see that much in terms of new ideas. They just take the
- 9:26divisions that are already happening within our information environment and just like dial it up
- 9:33a notch so they can take advantage of the ways that we're already fighting with
- 9:37each other, the ways we're already making stuff up, trying to not swear
- 9:41as much as I normally do, so that they can take advantage of that
- 9:46and just use that to their benefit. Because we're already fighting each other,
- 9:50we're already spreading business and disinformation. And one thing that is fascinating to me
- 9:54is that if you actually look at a lot of the biggest you know,
- 9:58sort of of right wing disinfo griftshire sphere people in the States, a lot
- 10:05of them are actually Canadian go down there. Yeah, So that's always been
- 10:09something that stood out to me. Now, regardless of the source, what
- 10:13is it that makes Canadians or I guess anyone so vulnerable to disinformation? You
- 10:22know, I think it's a variety of factors. A sort of pet theory
- 10:28that I think is also born out by some of the research is the fact
- 10:31that people want answers, simple answers to big, scary things. So disinformation
- 10:39often offers a villain or that sort of archetypal mythic narrative where there's a clear
- 10:48evil and a clear good and if you do this, this and this and
- 10:52oppose this, this and this, you know you're going to be on the
- 10:54right side, on the righteous side, on the side of good. And
- 10:58when you know, and it's a very kind of simplistic way of viewing the
- 11:03world that allows you to avoid the sort of existential anxiety that is elicited when
- 11:09you think about, you know, climate change or the ways in which capitalism
- 11:16has exacerbated wealth inequality to a point that is difficult for many people to endure.
- 11:20But instead of looking at the really complex, nuanced solutions to those problems,
- 11:24if you have a boogeyman like the WEF and Klaus Schwab, for example,
- 11:30maybe showing my brain worms a bit too much right now, you can
- 11:33actually kind of latch onto that and feel like a sense of control. So
- 11:37I think a lot of it is about finding control in situations where there isn't
- 11:41much, which is why COVID was such a huge sort of breeding ground for
- 11:48conspiracism, because it was so out of our control and so scary. I
- 11:52mean, is it Mother Nature, you know, just doing her thing and
- 11:56coming up with the ability to kill us, which she could do at any
- 11:58time, Or is it all a big conspiracy and a bio weapon by a
- 12:05specific bad actor that you can point as the villain. You know, Nature's
- 12:07a lot scarier than a specific bad guy. So it's having easy answers.
- 12:13It's what it's all about. Is part of the problem that, for better
- 12:16or worse, we all used to rely on the same source material, Like
- 12:20everyone was kind of limited in terms of what you could watch on TV,
- 12:24what news you could consume. So now the culture of entertainment, news,
- 12:30politics, even is very atomized, and we're all susceptible to falling into echo
- 12:35chambers that just confirm our own bias, no matter how detached from reality.
- 12:39And even more than that, you know, differences of opinion were discussed on
- 12:45the same set of facts and information as we touched on earlier, but now,
- 12:48like, how do you even have a dialogue with someone who believes the
- 12:52earth is flat? And that's sort of the heart of the right. And
- 12:58there's a lot of people who are way smarter than who spend a lot of
- 13:01time studying how to bring people back from the brink, you know, people
- 13:05who really have fallen into these rabbit holes. And a lot of what I've
- 13:09read is that there's a huge amount of value in prevention, you know,
- 13:15just pre bonking misinformation or common conspiracies, by getting the actual factual dissection of
- 13:24a falsehood they might encounter out there, so that when people encounter that falsehood,
- 13:28they already know, oh, this is false because I know this,
- 13:31this and this, but you know it is just it does make it really
- 13:37hard to have a conversation with people, and I think that that is such
- 13:39an isolating thing. I mean a lot of these rabbit holes that people go
- 13:45down are in part because they cut off so many of their loved ones because
- 13:50they believe a conspiracy. You know, like people you hear these really sad
- 13:54stories about people whose loved ones have gone down the QAnon rabbit hole, or
- 13:56people who became anti vaccine during the pandemic, and that might have initially just
- 14:01been a bit of fear about the vaccine that could have maybe been countered if
- 14:07they had fallen on the right sources, but they fell on the wrong ones,
- 14:09and then their family went, you know, I don't want you around
- 14:13me because you could be more likely to spread this virus, which is you
- 14:18know, fair on the family's part. But then that person becomes more isolated
- 14:22and seeks out other like minded people who are also isolated, and they cling
- 14:26to that community, even if that community starts to descend more and more into
- 14:28a more and more conspiratorial place. It's like the fundamental kind of human desire
- 14:33for connection and being around people who make you feel loved and seen and heard.
- 14:41And I think that that's where a lot of people actually end up becoming
- 14:45quite radicalized in their conspiracism. Or fall really deep down rabbit holes is where
- 14:50they have a certain loneliness and it can get really dark really fast. And
- 14:56that's why I get really angry at some of these grifters that send people down
- 14:58these rabbit holes, because they're taking advantage of people. It's like someone who's
- 15:01the head of a pyramid scheme or an MLM or whatever who's like, hey,
- 15:05you can become a millionaire overnight if you just take my course or whatever.
- 15:11That's the same kind of vibe with these grifter conspiracists. And they're taking
- 15:16lonely people or people who feel like they are super depressed or having other mental
- 15:20health issues and have a desire for answers, and they say they're giving them
- 15:24to them, and it's just really messed up. I mean, it's interesting
- 15:28you're talking about these disinformation grifters and MLM schemes and you have Andrew Tate basically
- 15:37doing both of those things simultank Yeah, I mean, and the descent that
- 15:41you're describing of the person that falls into it, I mean, that's the
- 15:46same journey that someone takes when they get into a cult. It starts with
- 15:48something small or some sort of skepticism, and it slowly ratchets up right Like,
- 15:54it's not like they're sold on the big thing right away. It is
- 15:58kind of a process that someone goes through. Oh absolutely, I remember this
- 16:03is a story I always pitched a global and I never had time to really
- 16:07dig into it was I wanted to dig into sort of the cult of conspiracism
- 16:11and the I wanted to speak to experts in cults, like people who really
- 16:15understand how cults function about, you know, the degree to which these conspiracy
- 16:21conspiracy communities are cults. There's it's funny, there's a lot of different I
- 16:26just I read this book by Amanda Monteal called Cultish, and there's a lot
- 16:30of different there's a lot of disagreement about what is and isn't a cult,
- 16:36and it's it's fascinating actually when you go into the debates. But I really
- 16:41do think that there's so much overlap there between what could be considered a cult
- 16:45and what these people are falling prey to. Right now, speaking of cults,
- 16:51let's talk about political parties for a second. I believe that even if
- 16:56politicians aren't disseminating disinform directly, they're not quick to call it out. If
- 17:03it's benefiting them, and in fact, I think some will leverage disinformation to
- 17:07their political advantage here in Canada. What role do you think our leaders have
- 17:12in tacitly consenting to the spread of disinformation? Oh, it's massive. I
- 17:19mean, I think you made a really good point about I think every single
- 17:25political leader is guilty of not correcting the record when the record is beneficial for
- 17:30them. You know, don't interrupt your enemy when he's making a mistake or
- 17:33something, you know. But I will say that there is one party that
- 17:40is actively spreading disinformation to a degree that is not taking place in other parties
- 17:48unless you count the PPC, which is kind of a non factor at this
- 17:52point, even though that would probably make Maxime Burnie shake his fist at me.
- 17:56But it's the Conservatives, I mean, care Polya explicitly using like dog
- 18:02whistles for I mean, I just did a TikTok on this because Alex Jones
- 18:07is saying that peer Paulyev is saying the same things a great endorsement, what
- 18:12an awesomement wild And you know, Paulyyev could deal with that in a heartbeat
- 18:19by just saying I do not accept the endorsement of this man, which should
- 18:26be quite easy to say. But the difficulty is is when you have appealed
- 18:30to people who believe the same things that Alex Jones is saying, and increasingly
- 18:37the things that Peer Paulyev is saying, how do you walk that back?
- 18:41How do you then turn around and condemn or disavow someone who is saying the
- 18:45things that you've been trying to appeal to the adherents of for so long.
- 18:49I mean, it's it's really problematic, and it's it's hard to put the
- 18:56toothpaste back in the tube once you decide that legitimizing conspiratorial rhetoric is a part
- 19:03of your political strategy, because that's you're grabbing hold of a very powerful thing
- 19:07that is very hard to control. And I think what you're describing then gives
- 19:12a lot of power to the quote unquote fringes, right, because even though
- 19:18they may not be represented by the mass population, they will have tacit consent
- 19:22from larger leaders who don't want to lose their support. Well, and that's
- 19:29something that you see. I mean, you know, we're chatting about this
- 19:32a little bit before the show. The Fringes feel in bold when they see
- 19:38their rhetoric paraded by the more mainstream, they think that they're having a degree
- 19:45of control because they see that that mainstream actor wants to appeal to this fringe,
- 19:51and so they feel as though they can kind of shift that overtin window,
- 19:53which if people aren't familiar with the concept, it's sort of like this
- 19:56idea that there's a window of what's acceptable in political discourd so public discourse,
- 20:00things that you can say without being immediately like smacked down, and so like
- 20:06these guys on the fringes are constantly trying to move that window of acceptability,
- 20:11and that's like, I mean, we saw the members of the Forest Group
- 20:15Diagalon discussing and I watched this video and I think I clicked it at the
- 20:19time, discussing the ways that they could use Pierre Paulyev's willingness to appeal to
- 20:25the PPC supporters and the sort of same rhetoric that PPC folks are supportive of.
- 20:30They thought they could use that to push for more of the kinds of
- 20:34things that they want to see done in politics. So even though those guys
- 20:37aren't supporters of the conservatives, they're supporters of the PPC. They saw an
- 20:42inroad there, and that to me is concerning because those are That means that
- 20:48people who I also watched interview in neo Nazi, and I'm not mischaracterizing that
- 20:53this guy when you google him, it literally says I'm Wikipedia. Like the
- 20:57Google frame that comes up for you says neo Nazi. I watched a guy
- 21:03interview one of these dude. He thinks that he can then turn around at
- 21:08the politics of someone who very well could be our next prime minister. So
- 21:14you know, whether he's right about that is one thing. Had that conversation
- 21:18and it seems like he really believed it. That's a bit of a red
- 21:22flag to me. Yeah. Absolutely, It's interesting because you're right, it
- 21:26does sort of empower not just these groups, but let's I mean, look
- 21:29at the PPC for a second, right, Like it empowers them, and
- 21:33I think people are too quick to dismiss the PPC like, oh, well,
- 21:36they didn't win any seats, they only got x amount in the popular
- 21:38vote, they don't matter. But then their influence is weighed in different ways,
- 21:44right yeah, yeah, sorry, no, go ahead, go ahead,
- 21:48go ahead. I was just going to say, you see it in
- 21:51the degree to which conservatives feel as though they have to get back that tiny
- 21:56percentage that the PPC stole, and the thing to say and do to get
- 22:00that percentage back now, when people's material needs are met, like I'm thinking
- 22:04about stable housing, affordable groceries, healthcare, schooling, childcare, are we
- 22:11less prone to falling for disinformation or does disinformation destabilize our trust in institutions that
- 22:18can cultivate the conditions to have those material needs met. I guess what I'm
- 22:22asking is, you know, is it the chicken or the egg here?
- 22:25What comes first? It's definitely they're kind of it's a bit of an araborous
- 22:33situation, like the snake eating its own tail, because it definitely when you
- 22:41don't have the things that you need to survive. That gets back into those
- 22:45big, existential, scary questions where you want an answer. You want someone
- 22:51who's going to tell you that they're going to fix this, and there are
- 22:52people who might actually have answers that could fix it. Also, so a
- 22:56lot of people who will use that fear in them, feeling of lack of
- 23:00stability to their benefit and will lie to you. And I mean that's just
- 23:06like politics. One O one You've seen this for forever, and it's like
- 23:08the thing you always hear politicians will promise everything and do like a quarter of
- 23:12it, not even. But there's certainly a feeling of antistment anti establishmentism.
- 23:23I guess yeah, But that takes root when the publishments are feeling you.
- 23:33When you feel as though these these systems that were supposed to be in place,
- 23:37supposed to keep people, and you know, you're supposed to be able
- 23:41to access healthcare, you're supposed to have safe housing, you're supposed to you're
- 23:44paying so you think that you're going to be supported in that society to a
- 23:51degree. When that social contract isn't upheld, people get really angry for good
- 23:59reason. With that anger takes root and the things that it fixates on.
- 24:04That's where conspiracism can really get a foothold, and I don't know, it's
- 24:12definitely something that then fuels more lack of because of all the things that we
- 24:19discussed in the TV segment that we did talking about how people won't trust the
- 24:26democratic process. They have that anti establishment that grabs a hold of them,
- 24:32and they might not trust the resultion that mental polyolence that might turn into a
- 24:37January sixth, but maybe successful this time. So there's it's it's really something
- 24:42that fuels itself once it gets started. It's interesting because, like I'm a
- 24:48materialist in the sense that I think when you have a dissatisfied populace, they're
- 24:53almost more likely to look for that scapegoat that we see in disinformation, right,
- 24:59and that that scapegoat can be the mainstream media, or trans people,
- 25:03or drug users or immigrants. And I feel like oftentimes our governments do a
- 25:07lot of symbolism, and I think that's great, but you know, people
- 25:11need to put food on the table, they need services, they need access
- 25:14to housing. And I want to say that someone who is satisfied in their
- 25:18life is less prone to disinformation. But then I've personally seen people who are
- 25:22doing pretty well materially but they fall into the rabbit holes of disinformation. So
- 25:30I also feel like it's not like one leads to the other. There's a
- 25:33whole myriad of factors, right ots you know, there's plenty of wealthy people
- 25:42who I mean a lot of the conspiracism and the conversations that we're seeing in
- 25:48these sort of more extreme communities have to do with not only it's not only
- 25:56disinformation about you know, not being able to trust the system, but you
- 26:00mentioned you know, driving kind of paid against these vulnerable groups and implying that
- 26:06these immigrants are going to take your jobs or are going to take you know,
- 26:10the reason you're having to pay so much in taxes is to deal with
- 26:12a climate crisis that isn't real, and things like that, you know,
- 26:17so and and those are things that can appeal to people even with a higher
- 26:21income bracket because they don't want to pay taxes or like they if they feel
- 26:25as though their money isn't being well spent, that can That's all stuff that
- 26:27can appeal to them, right. And then there's also just like a genuine
- 26:33undercurrent of racism in a lot of this and transphobia that can't be discounted.
- 26:37I mean, I don't want to say, I don't want to diminish it
- 26:41all to people who are feeling disaffected and who are maybe have various qualms or
- 26:47existential anks that isn't being properly channeled. It's also some of it is genuine
- 26:55racism. I mean, I'm seeing conversations in these communities about especially immigrants from
- 27:00India that is just harrowing. Like it's the kind of racism that you see
- 27:08like you'd see it in a TV show and think it's too cartoonish to be
- 27:11real, you know, like it's beyond And I think that I also don't
- 27:17want to kind of discount the fact that people can be quite tribal and quite
- 27:19uncomfortable with things that are different or people who are different to them, or
- 27:23they perceive as being different, and that can bread a lot of hostility.
- 27:29So I don't want to discount the degree to which that's a factor in people
- 27:33falling into these kind of rabbit holes. Now, and I think you touched
- 27:41on this earlier when you were talking about prevention, but ultimately, when we
- 27:44talk about disinformation, is this a personal responsibility issue or is this a structural
- 27:51systemic issue? Am I worry with it being a systemic issue? Is that
- 27:55then it needs a systemic answer and then those same people who buy into it
- 27:59are going to say, oh, see, here's the state censoring us or
- 28:02you know, oppressing us or whatever. So how do you frame it is
- 28:04Is it a personal thing or is it something where larger institutions need to intervene.
- 28:11Unfortunately, I do think a lot of it is systemic you know,
- 28:15these hard, big issues often unfortunately have hard big answers. But there's a
- 28:22few things that are kind of at play here. I mean, I think
- 28:26that one of the issues at hand is that people need to be taught to
- 28:30critically and to assess information properly. I think that that's something we need to
- 28:33make sure is being taught in school, and you know, people know not
- 28:40to believe everything they read online and to you know, what is a good
- 28:44source and what is not. Like that super basic stuff, right. But
- 28:48also there's other bigger things at play here. I mean I alluded to this
- 28:55before, but with the ad tech industry, there is this monetary motivation for
- 29:00people to engage and disseminate disinformation, which can that can catch anyone. I
- 29:03mean, if there's enough of this out there, all someone has to do
- 29:07is click on the wrong meme or the wrong web page or the wrong account,
- 29:11and they could be exposed to stuff that they could go oh that,
- 29:14and then you know, fall down a whole rabbit hole and you could lose
- 29:17them. And these kind of grifters, the perpetuators of this disinformation are often
- 29:23able to make money because there's no oversight and no regulation or at least nowhere
- 29:30near the sufficient nowhere near a sufficient level of the ad tech industry, like
- 29:34Google has a massive monopoly, which means that they don't really have to be
- 29:37held accountable for failing to enforce their own rules for where ad money goes,
- 29:47which they fail to enforce a lot, like I have found ads for the
- 29:49Church of Jesus Christ Latter day Saints on a porn website, Like, that's
- 29:55probably not where they're intentionally putting their money, right, So, and that
- 30:00was because of Google. So there is an issue here where there's a lot
- 30:03of money being funneled into various websites that advertisers don't know their money is being
- 30:08funneled towards because of the way the antech system is set up and the opacity
- 30:12and lack of regulation. And this is an industry that I think within the
- 30:17next two you projected to be worth a trillion dollars worldwide. So that is
- 30:21a lot of money and a lot of motivation to then engage and disseminate disinformation
- 30:26because if you know how to game the system, because there's basically no rules
- 30:30and no one enforcing them, I mean, the sky's the limmit, right,
- 30:34Yeah, No, for sure. I almost feel like, especially in
- 30:37Canada, I feel like we need more media criticism and well founded media criticism.
- 30:45And I say that as someone you know in the media, but I
- 30:48do think that sometimes, Like I'm thinking about things like police accountability right where
- 30:53a police press statement comes out and the media just takes it on face value,
- 30:59but there's no not enough criticism of that, and I think, you
- 31:02know, people should look to the media and say, hey, why aren't
- 31:04you looking at this in a more critical eye? And I understand that obviously
- 31:07newsrooms are shrinking and they have their own challenges, but I do feel like
- 31:11we need to cultivate a proper culture of media criticism because the reality is is
- 31:15that oftentimes the media doesn't get it right. And oftentimes I think people have
- 31:21fair answers or sorry, fair questions, but they're not being reached with answers
- 31:27that really break it down for them. And I think we definitely saw that
- 31:30in COVID, where on the on the surface, people had fair questions about
- 31:34whether it was the vaccine or mandates or whatever, and there was almost like,
- 31:40ah, you just have to do it for everyone, as opposed to
- 31:41really trying to explain to people why the gyms are closed or whatever, you
- 31:45know what I mean, No, exactly, it's I think that there's going
- 31:52to be I mean, with the pandemic specifically, there's going to be a
- 31:55lot of debriefing, and there should already be a lot going on. But
- 32:00like, there's things I regret. There's things that I wish I had characterized
- 32:02differently or worded differently, because I don't think it necessarily was like the most
- 32:07accessible or the most helpful, such an unprecedented situation and happening so fast.
- 32:14And then that comes back to the resources issue, right, so it's like
- 32:17kind to do so much for shit pay. Sorry I dropped it, but
- 32:23you're you know, you're being underpaid, you're being overworked, and you're just
- 32:27doing your best while living some conditions. Is everyone else. And but then
- 32:31on the flip side of that, that is where that media criticism is so
- 32:37needed, because when these mistakes are being made, there needs to be if
- 32:42they've been going to catch them themselves, and we're not always we may call
- 32:47all us out. And you know, I think that one thing that I've
- 32:51been really struck by since leaving my jobs in the sort of mainstream has been
- 32:57recognizing the ways in which me can really sort of manufacture or I guess,
- 33:07the proportion of coverage that media outlets afford to a specific issue versus another can
- 33:13really shape national conversations, and the things that the premises that are accepted versus
- 33:17the ones that are not can really shape a lot of policy and things like
- 33:24that, because politicians are reading these papers and if all they see is like
- 33:30fifteen conservative, white male National Post calumnists writing the exact same opinion about something,
- 33:36they might get the misguided idea that that's how everyone in the country feels.
- 33:39And so you know, it's like, we need more media criticism and
- 33:44more of a diversity of voices, and more money in media so that more
- 33:47people can do it and do it better and do the kinds of deep dives
- 33:51we need instead of just shoving out content. But we don't have that right
- 33:54now. And I think what scares me is not just that issue, but
- 34:00it's the degree to which I think a lot of people in positions of power,
- 34:06whether it be in the halls of Parliament or within newsrooms in upper management,
- 34:10don't understand how in the current information environment, outrage can be manufactured and
- 34:16gamed and created and so you can't respond to every scandal and take it at
- 34:23face value, do you know what I mean? And that's sort of what
- 34:27we're seeing. We see that happen sometimes it's it's easy to fall into,
- 34:31I mean, in defense of the media, like it is something that's you
- 34:37I have to It's interesting because I think if we look at the history of
- 34:42moral panics, so even you know, outside of our era, moral panics
- 34:45have always had a partnership in media, right, Like media was the one
- 34:51that pushed the satanic panic of dungeons and dragons. They pushed kind of a
- 34:55false narrative about frivolous lawsuits when that woman's spilt hot coffee on herself at McDonald's
- 35:01or whatever. And so, you know, I do think that it's easy
- 35:06to say, oh, well, just focus on mainstream media, but I
- 35:07think there are issues within sort of news culture as well that need to be
- 35:13addressed if they are to be trusted by people who currently don't trust them.
- 35:19Yeah. I think one thing I think about a lot is the ways in
- 35:22which newsrooms frame objectivity and bias versus lack of bias. And you know,
- 35:30I do really find that what newsrooms consider to be objective is objective from a
- 35:38sort of subjective standpoint of a you know, white straight cis upper middle class,
- 35:47like middle aged man, and that is sort of the baseline for what
- 35:54is objective, and then anything that deviates from that is biased. And you
- 35:59see this in like there's all kinds of stories you hear, like I have
- 36:02friends you have mentioned that, you know, people are brought in to bring
- 36:07diversity into a newsroom, and they've told me they're like, yeah, I
- 36:09knew I was that hired to actually say something about the coverage that I felt
- 36:14like was not actually objective and was actually a bit racist. Then they didn't
- 36:21want to hear me. So it's like, you know, there are serious
- 36:23issues with I think the what is considered objective versus what is considered subjective,
- 36:29and there's a lot of kind of prejudices built into that that need to be
- 36:34interrogated for us to be able to serve the public better. So I don't
- 36:37know, I'm kind of just rambling, but no, no, I that's
- 36:40a huge problem with our media right now, is like we need we need
- 36:45to interrogate that within ourselves and try to try to make sure that we're covering
- 36:49issues actually fairly, not just objectively according to whatever that definition of objectivity is.
- 36:58Going back to following down into the disinformation rabbit hole. I feel like
- 37:02we all have someone in our life who is like a bit out there and
- 37:07personally, I kind of cringe at the idea of like deprogramming loved ones or
- 37:13cutting them out of your life because they believe something crazy but not hurting anyone.
- 37:19What can people do as individuals if we have people in our lives who
- 37:23repeatedly fall prey to disinformation. Oh, it's such a hard one. I
- 37:32mean, I think to the extent that you can, because I don't want
- 37:37to sit here and like tell people to have conversations that are really really difficult
- 37:45for them, especially like I'm like a white woman, so a lot of
- 37:49these conversations are easier for me to have because they're not invalidating like my very
- 37:53being and existence. So but you know, to the degree that you're comfortable
- 38:00doing so, I think sitting down listening and hearing what the heart of their
- 38:05grievance is and trying to understand like what it is that they actually fear that
- 38:12has sent them down this rabbit hole, and then maybe you can kind of
- 38:15build a baseline of empathy that can help you to reach them from a place
- 38:21that they will sense is a good place. Like I One thing I think
- 38:27would surprise a lot of people is when I cover some of these conspiracy issues,
- 38:31I don't actually, for the most part, have a ton of Like
- 38:36I have disdain for the grifters at the top, you know, but I
- 38:39actually have a lot of sympathy for the people who go and pray to them,
- 38:45because I think that they just want answers to really scary things. And
- 38:49I think that if you are able to kind of reach those people from that
- 38:53place, in the sense that you're coming at them from a genuine place of
- 38:58you know, understanding that they are afraid, or that they have genuine concerns
- 39:04that are valid, but they're just maybe going about them in the wrong way,
- 39:07I think you might have a better chance of reaching them. I think,
- 39:12No, No, I love that. I mean, I also think
- 39:14that you have to approach this from a place of empathy. And I think
- 39:16sometimes what you call it the lefts just to be easy, But what the
- 39:21left sometimes does is just dismiss swads of people. And I don't think that
- 39:24that's the most productive approach either, Right, Like I think individuals do have
- 39:30to be approached with some sense of empathy, So I absolutely agree. Last
- 39:34question, maybe the hardest one. Are we at the precipice? Are we
- 39:38at the precipice of civilization collapse? Because I feel like the COVID pandemic was
- 39:44a test run, and I think there's an argument that we failed that test
- 39:47run. Like maybe there's a lot of really big things that are knocking at
- 39:55our door, like the climate crisis. I mean, Jesus, don't get
- 40:00me started on biodiversity, because that's that gets scary, like there's crises there,
- 40:06and then you know, we're just seeing incommune equality like enter the stratosphere,
- 40:10and I don't know. It all does make me a little nervous about
- 40:15where we're all headed. But I feel like that's why we need to kind
- 40:19of look out for each other and not give in to that very human impulse
- 40:23that we've seen over history to retreat into like tribal, you know, hyper
- 40:29partisan, hyper identitarian groups. Because if we're going to get through these huge
- 40:34existential challenges that are facing humanity right now, we have to do it together,
- 40:39and we have to not like fight each other in the way that we
- 40:45currently are where we're demonizing anyone who we perceive to be other, or we're
- 40:50blaming the wrong people, or we're you know, taking easy outs and easy
- 40:57answers to big issues and big proples. We have to try to work together
- 41:02towards doing the difficult things that actually solve these big crises because our future does
- 41:09depend on it. So absolutely, I don't know that's hopeful or terrifying,
- 41:15No, I think it's I think it's a great reminder for everyone, right,
- 41:17even if you do think that you are not falling prey to disinformation,
- 41:22I think that that's ultimately, along with empathy of course, you know,
- 41:24a great lesson to learn, because if we're divided, how can we possibly
- 41:30solve these big existential crises. And there's certainly many of them on the horizon.
- 41:35And I think COVID, at least for a period, presented such a
- 41:38crisis as well. So I think that that nailed it. Oh, thanks,
- 41:45it is, Rachel, It's it's honestly being a pleasure. I'm so
- 41:47glad that we could connect. Keep up your great work, and whenever you're
- 41:52in Vancouver, drop by the studio and we'll have to do a sequel in
- 41:55studio awesome. I would love that. Thank you so much for having on.
- 42:00This is super fun. Thank you, folks. That was award winning
- 42:04investigative journalist Rachel Gilmour. Find her on ex Instagram, TikTok. She's always
- 42:08pumping out incredible and accessible content. Of course, this is Van Kuller and
- 42:14I'm moamir telling you that in a province where you can be anything, be
- 42:17colorful peace,