Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 162: On the art of French chocolate with pastry chef and educator Lisa Allen
Transcript
- 0:07You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:09I'm your host, Linda Trimuta. There are two things I love to
- 0:14consume in Paris. One of them is coffee.
- 0:17The other is chocolate. And yet I have never done an
- 0:20episode on this show about chocolate.
- 0:23I went back and looked through more than 100 episodes, and
- 0:26while chocolate gets a mention here and there, it has never
- 0:29gotten its due as the primary subject of a discussion, so I
- 0:33hope I will make up for that shortcoming with today's
- 0:36conversation. As you may know, chocolate isn't
- 0:39created equal, and French style is very different from, say,
- 0:42Belgian or Swiss. There are chocolate shops and
- 0:45pastry chefs who dabble in chocolate all over Paris, but
- 0:48within that network, there are clear differences in quality.
- 0:52Lisa Allen, a chocolate educator, pastry chef and guide,
- 0:55joins me to talk about some of these distinctions, what she's
- 0:58learned from running tasting workshops, and where she
- 1:01recommends you go for all your chocolate needs in Paris.
- 1:05And by the way, if you're enjoying the show but aren't yet
- 1:07subscribed, hit that follow button wherever you're listening
- 1:10to be notified as soon as a new episode is released.
- 1:15Lisa, welcome to the show. Hi, thanks for having me.
- 1:19Lisa, you told me some interesting stories about
- 1:22yourself, which is that you were in education.
- 1:25You taught for a very long time. You taught all over the world.
- 1:28I did. And then kind of a massive about
- 1:33face and you went to pastry school at Ferrandi in Paris and
- 1:37that led you to the thing we all love.
- 1:40Although I shouldn't say all, there are people who don't like
- 1:43chocolate and I simply do not understand them.
- 1:45But into chocolate. Yes, Your love of chocolate
- 1:49predated that pastry training. Yes, I'm pretty sure my love of
- 1:54chocolate started in the womb. I was always into chocolate and
- 1:59baking. I was always the one wanting to
- 2:01make birthday cakes and cookies for my friends, and when I was
- 2:03teaching overseas I was making people cakes and treats.
- 2:07I even remember once calling in sick to work when I was teaching
- 2:12in Switzerland because I had in my head this cake that I wanted
- 2:15to make for a friend for her birthday and I wasn't done.
- 2:18And so I literally stayed home from work to work on the cake.
- 2:22Gosh, hope nobody who I worked with at that time heard that,
- 2:26but it was actually in that time when I was living and working in
- 2:29Zurich. So that means around 2010 that I
- 2:34started experimenting with chocolate making myself, started
- 2:37tempering by hand. It was around that time that I
- 2:40started experimenting, making my own bonbons, making a lot of
- 2:44fillings, tempering by hand, creating shells, bring.
- 2:47I remember bringing my first batch of handmade chocolates
- 2:50into my colleagues, oh, nice, in Switzerland and trying to sort
- 2:54of weasel my way in to the kitchen at Honnold, which is
- 2:57this incredible smaller Swiss chocolate chocolatier company up
- 3:02in Kuznak that I used to go to and sort of buddied up with the
- 3:05chef to learn from him. And so then I consciously or
- 3:10unconsciously kept moving closer to the source, right?
- 3:13So then when I left Switzerland, my next cheating job was
- 3:16actually in Venezuela. And so it was there that over
- 3:20the course of those two years that I was in Venezuela, as
- 3:24people familiar with Latin American politics might
- 3:26remember, it was a very unstable time, 2014 to 16.
- 3:30And so as the zeitgeist was moving towards, I'm going to
- 3:33have to leave the country soon, I also started thinking about
- 3:37alternatives because it was a difficult post, to say the
- 3:40least. And so that's when I said, hey,
- 3:42I can take a break. And since I, you know, I don't
- 3:45see a job opening in Paris, I'd always wanted to come to Paris.
- 3:47I don't see a job to teach in a school, but I could actually go
- 3:51as a student. And that was what gave me the
- 3:53idea to come and enroll in pastry school, kind of like a go
- 3:56hard or go home. If I'm going to study pastry, I
- 3:59might as well study the best pastry, which is of course
- 4:01French. If I want to study French
- 4:03pastry, I might as well go to Paris.
- 4:05And so in that time, as I was sort of preparing for this
- 4:08shift, which was supposed to just be a one to two year break.
- 4:11Interesting, from my teaching career through a friend of a
- 4:14friend, I basically got connected to some cacao
- 4:17exporters who were managing what turned out to be some of the
- 4:22most highly respected cacao in the world at the time,
- 4:26Chihuahua. There are these family run
- 4:29cooperative plantations that in order to get there, you've got
- 4:32to, you know, drive an hour and a half to two hours, sometimes
- 4:36forward depending on traffic or other issues, up and over the
- 4:39mountains to get to the coast, to stay at Chorani, to get in a
- 4:42tiny boat. And that is where.
- 4:44In Venezuela. In Venezuela.
- 4:46OK. Yeah.
- 4:46So you have to go from the Bay of Chorani in a little dinghy
- 4:49boat that you're not sure is going to make it anywhere and
- 4:52you can only access at the time, you could only really access
- 4:55these cacao plantations by basically by waters.
- 4:58Then you get to the Cove of Chiwao, and then you have to
- 5:00take another truck up through the jungle, and then you get to
- 5:04this clearing in front of this church and you're in the little
- 5:06village of Chuau. And that it's really to make
- 5:08sure you want to be there. You really you really want to
- 5:12visit? Yeah.
- 5:13And so I was just so lucky. I didn't realize how lucky I was
- 5:18to get invited on this trip, which was actually a sort of
- 5:21piggybacking on a sourcing trip for dandelion chocolates.
- 5:25Oh, I know them. Yes, we talked about this in
- 5:27California. In California, and I actually
- 5:28got to hang out with Greg, who was one of the original founders
- 5:31at the recent chocolate festival in Bordeaux.
- 5:34Still a super cool guy, still really involved in cacao and
- 5:37chocolate. And so I got to sort of
- 5:39piggyback and be a family in the wall on this this origin
- 5:42sourcing trip out to Chihuahua. And my friend Pat, who was the
- 5:47guy who was sort of running the fermentation and everything
- 5:49there also really just a has the magical touch with not just the
- 5:55farmers, but the plants and everything.
- 5:57And he just has a way with people that I now really
- 6:00appreciate as a super important part of the the chain of, of how
- 6:05good chocolate and good cacao happens.
- 6:07But so, and he is also an excellent teacher.
- 6:10And so while we're walking through the fields, he's picking
- 6:13these beautiful little white creo flowers and showing me with
- 6:16his pocket knife and explaining everything.
- 6:18And he had studied the agronomy and he knew how to, you know,
- 6:21really tease the best out of the plants and really work with the
- 6:24cacao in a lot of special ways to develop this fine flavor.
- 6:28And So what I didn't realize that I was getting this very
- 6:32special origin experience, understanding where chocolate
- 6:35really comes from, that usually people have to work 10-15 years
- 6:38in the industry before they have a chance to go out to origin.
- 6:41And I started there. And so that experience really
- 6:44shaped and informed everything that I have done since when it
- 6:50comes to chocolate and cacao, because I, I was at the source
- 6:54from the beginning. And so I really understood how
- 6:57it's all connected in a way that I think, you know, like a lot
- 7:00of. Coffee farmers, too.
- 7:03Yeah, I've met Coffee. But what's what's coming to mind
- 7:06is that that moment in the film Madagascar, the the animated
- 7:11film Madagascar, when the the lion is hungry and he's dreaming
- 7:17of a steak. And because he's grown up in a
- 7:20zoo, when he dreams of a steak, what you see is this like the
- 7:23picture of a fabricated shape of a slice of a steak.
- 7:27And that's what he thinks of when he's hungry.
- 7:29And he doesn't realize that, like, the animals around him are
- 7:32meat, right? Right.
- 7:34And so he doesn't connect the animal to the food.
- 7:38You know, I could argue that most of us are disconnected from
- 7:42where our food comes from. Exactly.
- 7:44And, and unfortunately for coffee and chocolate, they come
- 7:47from, you know, when you live in America or in Europe, they come
- 7:51from very far away, right? And so it's very hard to keep
- 7:54that connection alive in people's minds.
- 7:56And you think of it as a either a luxury or a commodity.
- 7:59Right. And people think of, oh, where
- 8:01does chocolate? And this is something that, you
- 8:03know, when I do my family tours and chocolate tasting classes
- 8:07and stuff, when I first say to people like, OK, when you think
- 8:10of good chocolate, where does good chocolate come from?
- 8:14Their first answer is usually going to be like France or
- 8:18Belgium or Switzerland or Germany.
- 8:20It's the Finnish product. Right.
- 8:22And so they only think of chocolate as the Finnish project
- 8:24and they have very little understanding, you know, even
- 8:29even the fact that chocolate comes from a fruit, right?
- 8:31The cacao is a fruit, that it's a plant that grows in the ground
- 8:35just like your tomatoes, your carrots, your oranges, from from
- 8:39different parts around the world that at the end of the day, it's
- 8:42an agricultural product. And if you start to really think
- 8:46about chocolate and understand it from that angle of like, this
- 8:52is something being produced for me to eat, but it's coming from
- 8:54a plant being grown in a place far away.
- 8:57And you start thinking about, oh, well, the chocolate that I
- 8:59like comes from Peru. It doesn't come from France
- 9:03because it's the person in France who maybe transformed the
- 9:05bean. But in order to do that work,
- 9:07they had to find these great beans coming from a completely
- 9:10different part of the world. Now, do you think that the
- 9:14average Parisian or French consumer of chocolate, who I
- 9:18would argue is more educated than Americans, and correct me
- 9:23if I'm wrong, but you probably grew up like me where you talked
- 9:26about baking, right? You like baking cakes and
- 9:29cookies and these sorts of things.
- 9:30And, you know, I would try my hand at baking brownies.
- 9:34Did it come from a box potentially?
- 9:36I was very disconnected from what chocolate was.
- 9:39Chocolate was Hershey's and Reese's cups.
- 9:41And, you know, as someone who has now become very demanding
- 9:47and, you know, exacting in what they're going to consume, it's a
- 9:51far cry from where I started. Oh yeah.
- 9:55I mean, I definitely when I first started baking when I was,
- 9:58what, 8 or 9 years old, it was definitely blueberry muffins
- 10:02from a box mix with a plastic packet of blueberries preserved
- 10:07in syrup, right? You know, and to clarify, the
- 10:10French have their own boxed brownie and garbage ghetto
- 10:13chocolate. So it's not that they don't have
- 10:16the same inclination toward convenience.
- 10:20But you, you have gift giving many times a year that involve
- 10:24chocolate, right? You see chocolate prominently on
- 10:28display, at least in a big city, but even in small towns.
- 10:31Yeah. And I think, I think part of it
- 10:34is really about, and this is something that I, I do end up
- 10:38talking about a lot with my American clients, is that, you
- 10:42know, in every culture, in every country, in every strata of
- 10:47society around the world, the balance of respect and prestige
- 10:54for different professions and different types of Craftsman or
- 10:58artisans is very different of what, what people value
- 11:02societally. And which doesn't necessarily
- 11:04translate to like how much you get paid to do that job, right?
- 11:08But like, for example, when I lived in Switzerland, local
- 11:10Swiss teachers, school teachers, you know, and I might be wrong
- 11:14at this, but I, I remember being shocked, like they get paid more
- 11:17than some doctors, right? Like education was considered
- 11:20super important and the teachers were really well paid.
- 11:23Whereas in the US, teaching is kind of a thankless profession
- 11:27and it's really generally poorly paid, right?
- 11:30So in France, gastronomy and food have a really, really high
- 11:37place on the chain of respect and I feel like.
- 11:42But they're not necessarily well paid.
- 11:43But they're not necessarily well.
- 11:44Paid, unfortunately, but they're valued.
- 11:46They're valued, just not in monetary helpful terms.
- 11:50Right, right. So, you know, you can have the
- 11:53the most renowned Michelin starred MOF pastry chef working
- 11:58at a palace hotel in the Champs Elysees who's walking around
- 12:01like the king. And if people see him on the
- 12:03street, they fall all over him, like, Oh my God, it's that chef,
- 12:07you know? And it's like, he's got fame,
- 12:10but he's still not breaking more than €3500 a month, right.
- 12:15You know, And that's a top salary.
- 12:16Yeah. At least it was 10 years ago.
- 12:18So it's an interesting distinction to make.
- 12:19But that being said, French culture really, and again,
- 12:25there's something that I talk about a lot with my tour
- 12:26clients. There is a high respect for
- 12:30food, for eating, for the culinary arts as an art form,
- 12:34respecting the ingredients, respecting the techniques,
- 12:39respecting the fact that, you know, a croissant which only has
- 12:44what, four or five ingredients? There are so many subtleties and
- 12:47how well it tastes based on what kind of butter you're using.
- 12:50How are you treating the butter, what kind of flour you're using?
- 12:53How are you treating the flour? And it doesn't taste different
- 12:56because different chemicals are added and because different
- 12:59raising agents and and accelerators are added like
- 13:01might what might happen in the US, But it's because they're
- 13:05being very respectful of the base ingredients being used and
- 13:09the techniques and also the the respect for eating as an
- 13:13important part of daily life. Yeah.
- 13:15Here in France, you sit down at the table, you drink your coffee
- 13:18from a real cup. You don't walk down the street
- 13:20with a paper cup of of espresso sloshing around.
- 13:23Not espresso, although the the matcha.
- 13:26Yeah, the matcha latte. You know all those all there you
- 13:30see it to a degree, but it is still a sliver of what it is in
- 13:33the US and and then also I'm sure in in the UK and everywhere
- 13:37else. So, So what you're saying is
- 13:39that there's exposure to all of these things from such a young
- 13:41age? There's Expo, well, exposure,
- 13:43but also a sense of respect, right?
- 13:45So like, and it's hard for me to ever do anything without talking
- 13:48about my daughter because I'm just so in love with her.
- 13:52But you know, I remember being so impressed and almost shocked
- 13:56when, you know, my daughter started going to was in the
- 13:58French crash like a daycare. And by the time they're 2 1/2,
- 14:03when it's lunchtime, the kids are serving themselves and each
- 14:07other. They sit down at the table.
- 14:08They're using forks and knives. They're not allowed to use their
- 14:10hands to eat after a certain age.
- 14:12They bust their own tables. But they they sit and have a
- 14:15meal together and they all eat the same food.
- 14:17And so it's a respect. The respect for this is a
- 14:19communal experience. And it's part of the respect for
- 14:24each other, respect for your own body, your own health.
- 14:27You sit down, you have a warm meal, right?
- 14:30You talk to people, you engage, and when it's done, you get up
- 14:33and the meal is over and you clean up and you put it away.
- 14:36Even the fact that, you know, all French schools have a
- 14:40kitchen and the kids eat a hot meal at lunch that has several
- 14:43courses. You know, it's there's none of
- 14:45this like, oh, bringing your paper bag with your PB and J and
- 14:49your and your apple and eating it in 20 minutes running from
- 14:52one class to the other, right. And so I did you talk.
- 14:54To my mother before this podcast, 'cause that's exactly I
- 14:57had that lunch with ya. Yoohoo, which is?
- 15:01AI remember yoohoo. Chocolate.
- 15:03It was a They had to call it a chocolate drink because they
- 15:06couldn't call it chocolate milk. Nope, exactly so.
- 15:10Anyway that that like segwayed perfectly.
- 15:12Yeah, but like all of that, you know, dancing around this idea
- 15:16that the French really respect food.
- 15:19They respect chocolate as an art form.
- 15:21They respect pastry as an art form.
- 15:24They respect the idea that taste and enjoyment of your food is a
- 15:28full, a full, all the senses experience.
- 15:32You have to appreciate the food, you have to anticipate it.
- 15:36You have to see that the visual aspect is very important.
- 15:40It's beautiful, it's clean, it's well organized.
- 15:43When you go to buy a chocolate or a pastry and you see that the
- 15:47respect and the care has been put into creating a beautifully
- 15:50presented product where all of the piping is even and there's
- 15:55no crumbs on the plate and there's no dust under the
- 15:57counter. Like that is all part of the
- 15:59experience of this is an item to be respected.
- 16:03And I will respect it as I bring it into my body right as I eat
- 16:07it. And so I think a lot of
- 16:10Americans coming to Paris, they'll always say, like even my
- 16:13friends who are visiting this week, I just can't get over how
- 16:16stylish everything is and how well dressed people are.
- 16:19And every restaurant we go into and every cafe, it's like a work
- 16:22of art. And it's like, well, yeah, it
- 16:25is. But aesthetics?
- 16:26Aesthetics. More points here.
- 16:28Yeah, exactly. Because aesthetics really do
- 16:31affect how you experience things.
- 16:32And if you want to fully appreciate and experience a
- 16:35culinary experience, the aesthetics are part of it.
- 16:38We, we do eat with our eyes. We do feel more comfortable and
- 16:41well organized calm spaces. We do feel that, you know, then
- 16:45there have been lots of studies done about this, that the, the
- 16:49lighting, the the size and weight of the fork that you're
- 16:51using, all of these things affect how you perceive how good
- 16:54something is as food, right. Because all of those things
- 16:57affect how your brain is processing the information of
- 16:59what it tastes like. And also this goes back to the
- 17:02Royal Court and how they use some of these culinary arts and
- 17:07table scaping and all of these aesthetic details as part of
- 17:11their soft power. It's soft power and it's still
- 17:15happening today. So would you say then that there
- 17:19is a noticeable difference between the chocolate that is
- 17:24most sold and enjoyed by the French versus Belgian style?
- 17:28Now working with the obviously the cacao from far reaching
- 17:33places and then transforming it as well as Switzerland?
- 17:36Because I always found one of the big questions is, well, what
- 17:40makes the chocolates sold in France so different?
- 17:42What are the chocolatier doing different here than they do in
- 17:45neighboring countries? So there's a lot of things, you
- 17:48know, a lot of sort of classic, more obvious and then some more
- 17:52subtle differences. Like for example, the French
- 17:54really do tend to value dark chocolate much more highly.
- 18:00So most of the focus that chefs are putting onto into their
- 18:04chocolates or chocolatiers, if they're making a series of
- 18:08bonbons, it's mostly dark chocolate with a couple of milk
- 18:10thrown in there just to like appease the masses or to appease
- 18:13to say like, oh, there's going to be the one person at the
- 18:15table who doesn't like dark chocolate, but they don't really
- 18:18put a lot of respect into it because they feel like the milk
- 18:20kind of disrupts the flavor. French chocolate tends to have a
- 18:23much deeper, more complex cacao flavor to it, whereas Belgian
- 18:29chocolate and the in its, you know, as we were talking about
- 18:31before, the French concept of what chocolate should be is
- 18:35about elegance, about refinement.
- 18:37If you have a filled bon bon, the shell is nice and thin and
- 18:40crispy. Whereas in Belgian style
- 18:43chocolates, they classically are focusing on milk chocolates.
- 18:47It's about indulgence. It's about generosity.
- 18:49It's about like a kind of a big heavy, like you feel like you
- 18:53ate a sweet treat. Yeah.
- 18:55Whereas in France, it's like, oh, I had a tasting of
- 18:58something, something well made. And so Belgian chocolates tend
- 19:02to have a lot more added cocoa butter to make that sort of
- 19:06smooth, creamy mouthfeel. They tend to have a lot more
- 19:08sugar. A lot more of, you know, a lot
- 19:13higher percentage of the chocolates in that box are going
- 19:15to be praline base where it's almost always the same blend of,
- 19:19of mostly, you know, hazelnuts, milk chocolate, maybe almonds,
- 19:24but it's usually fairly smooth, whereas the French ones tend to
- 19:26be crunchier. For the praline, the pieces are
- 19:29bigger. They have like the little shell
- 19:31shapes, stuff like that. But it's much more about sweet
- 19:37common indulgence in Belgium. Whereas in France it's really
- 19:40more about this is a tasting experience and you want to
- 19:43really taste the cacao. The there's a lot less cocoa
- 19:46butter added here. And what and as you were saying,
- 19:49that's that tends to be added to create that silky mouthfeel that
- 19:54is not naturally a you know that the pure cacao bean does not
- 19:58give you when you transform it. It depends, right?
- 20:01So, and this is something people don't realize is that a cacao
- 20:04bean is naturally anywhere from 40 to 60% cacao butter to begin
- 20:09with. It has to be like that's, that's
- 20:11what you're tempering when you temper chocolate.
- 20:12That's that's the fat that bounces out the cocoa solids.
- 20:16But depending on the bean itself, you can have more or
- 20:19less cocoa butter. And the more cocoa butter you
- 20:22have, the more fat, the silkier it is when you put it in your
- 20:26mouth. But that also means it's more
- 20:28fluid and easier to work with. So classically cuvertur
- 20:32chocolate that like people would use to cover bonbons and that
- 20:35kind of thing, it needs to be smooth and fluid and easy to
- 20:38temper and easy to work with. And so it's, you know, it's
- 20:41always been a practice to add a little extra cocoa butter for
- 20:44chocolate that's going to be used in that way, right?
- 20:46Because you need that fluidity. If you a lot of origins when
- 20:50you're dipping towards the lower end of cocoa butter content
- 20:53naturally occurring, those chocolates can be really hard to
- 20:56work with because they're hard to get through the machines.
- 20:58They tend to set really fast. They tend to be too thick to
- 21:01mold, you know, the amount of tapping you have to do to get
- 21:04the air bubbles out. It's just insane.
- 21:06And so like, you know, we're talking about dandelion earlier.
- 21:10Dandelion is 2 ingredient chocolate, and they don't add
- 21:12cocoa butter. And so I was doing a project
- 21:15last year actually, where I was invited.
- 21:18I don't know if I told you about this before.
- 21:20One of these things that happened in my life, the French
- 21:24Consulate in San Francisco invited me to come teach
- 21:29chocolate workshops and tasting introductions in French to the
- 21:33children in the French bilingual and immersion schools in the Bay
- 21:37Area. Wow, that's so.
- 21:38Cool. Thanks.
- 21:39Yeah, it was cool. So and I and I got contacted as
- 21:42a Ferronzi alumni because. Aha.
- 21:44Right because the French consulate can contacted Ferronzi
- 21:48alumni office and said we would like one of your alumni who can
- 21:52do this this this this this, you know notably things like
- 21:56comfortable teaching in French, but also comfortable in English
- 22:00doesn't need a fancy visa to go be in the US and work for a bit
- 22:03free to travel willing to do this for you know, as a benevol
- 22:10as we say in. French, a volunteer.
- 22:11Volunteer and working in the field, but also with the
- 22:17flexibility to like just fly to San Francisco for 10 days sure
- 22:21and of course be comfortable working with children, have some
- 22:24education background, et cetera. So I.
- 22:25So not many people were going to tick all those boxes.
- 22:28Right. Not many people ticked all the
- 22:30boxes the way I did. So they were like, we need to
- 22:32send you Lisa. They're like, yes, Lisa's
- 22:34perfect, send her along. But in order to do that, it's
- 22:37not like I could just pop 50 kilos of French chocolate into
- 22:43my suitcase. Right.
- 22:45So I partnered with Dandelion in order to run these workshops and
- 22:49they were very generous. That's why I keep mentioning
- 22:51them because they have been, they're lovely, they're lovely,
- 22:54and they really have been very formative and helpful, knowingly
- 22:57and unknowingly, right in my whole journey since the
- 23:00beginning of all this. They keep cropping up, right?
- 23:03They were probably the first craft chocolate that I tasted 20
- 23:06years ago or whatever in, in San Francisco before this all
- 23:08started. And so they were able to sell me
- 23:12and ridiculous amount of of their chocolate to use As for
- 23:17teaching with right, And I borrowed equipment from them.
- 23:20They were very generous, but their chocolate is not meant to
- 23:24be tempered by hand and certainly not meant for molding
- 23:28because it's exactly what the beans give you, right?
- 23:31And so the the flavor profile and the beans that we're going
- 23:34to be the least difficult to work with and the most sort of
- 23:40middle of the road tasting wise to be using with the children
- 23:42was their Columbia 70% Tumaco, which I just love.
- 23:47Ironically, I don't love other people's tumaco.
- 23:49I love their tumaco. So even chocolate made from
- 23:52beans from the same region, when other people work with it, I'm
- 23:55like, yeah, but no. Well.
- 23:57It's the same with wine. Yeah, it's the same with exactly
- 23:59so, but that's a whole different tangent.
- 24:02And so I probably saw about 300 students over the course of four
- 24:05teaching days and had to give like lectures in front of
- 24:08gymnasiums full of 300 kids that had to, you know, give talks and
- 24:11be it culture days and stuff like that was it was very
- 24:14intense. But so for each school that I
- 24:17went into, I would have to go in the day before, plug in the
- 24:20chocolate machine so the chocolate could melt overnight.
- 24:23And I used two different machines because for every hour
- 24:28that I had a group of kids, I would temper it and have it
- 24:30ready right before the kids came in.
- 24:33But by the time we got to the end of the class working with it
- 24:35with those kids, it would start to set.
- 24:38And so for the next class that was going to be start an hour
- 24:41later, I would have to retemper another batch of chocolate
- 24:44because what I was using in that first class, it's, it's no good
- 24:49anymore. I, I can't use it.
- 24:50I couldn't keep it liquidy enough to work with.
- 24:55It was still in temper, but it was just starting to set on
- 24:57itself. But what I'm hearing is also
- 24:59that so Dandelion will work with a chocolate that is not for
- 25:04molds, not for Bonbon, that is purely for tablets, right bars
- 25:09and then has something different that they work with for their
- 25:12other products. No.
- 25:14They don't. They don't.
- 25:15They're still purist. They're still using two
- 25:17ingredient chocolate and giving you the tablet or the OR the
- 25:21chocolate the way that you know, the way the bean intended it.
- 25:25They just have machines to do it.
- 25:26Oh, I see what you're saying. Right, right, right.
- 25:28OK. Even we're even in those
- 25:29machines, it can be hard and they have to really fiddle with
- 25:32the temperature and the timing and work fast.
- 25:35And like when they're, when they're pouring it into the
- 25:37tablets, they have machines that help agitate and shake the mold
- 25:41so that the chocolate gets into every little corner, which is
- 25:44it's a lot harder to do by hand when you're surrounded by a
- 25:46bunch of eight-year olds, right? And is that something that would
- 25:50be the same here with one of the chocolate makers that we know?
- 25:54Yes, yes. And so that's, that's the other
- 25:58thing that people don't realize that there are pros and cons.
- 26:01And it's definitely not easy to work with craft chocolate in a
- 26:05pastry setting or or whatnot. But like, you know, you and I
- 26:08always talk about plaque and how much.
- 26:09So when you're saying craft chocolate, you mean bean tabar
- 26:11or not necessarily? Yes, OK.
- 26:13Yeah, When I say craft chocolate, I mean bean tabar.
- 26:16And part of what's happening in the industry is people are
- 26:18starting to make a conscious effort to say Kraft chocolate as
- 26:22opposed to just saying bean to bar, because so many large
- 26:26companies now are capitalizing on this concept and on this this
- 26:30catch phrase. And so now you have even
- 26:32enormous industrial chocolate companies who are claiming to be
- 26:36bean to bar. It's like, well, yeah, obviously
- 26:40you're taking beans. But it has, you know, it has
- 26:44nothing to do with the same implication of a craft chocolate
- 26:47maker who is literally flying out to Peru twice here to meet
- 26:51with their farmers and test the chocolate and develop a
- 26:53relationship and working with small batches of no more than 65
- 26:57or 130 kilos of chocolate at a time.
- 27:01You're not to mention like small makers like me, I'm working with
- 27:04two kilos at a time. That's not the same as like
- 27:07Valrona claiming to be being to bar when they're purchasing 5
- 27:10tons at a time, right? You can't really.
- 27:13Do you know what this reminds me of in for my first book when I
- 27:17had a whole section on beer and craft beer and what constitutes
- 27:21craft or not Right. And the the definition is so
- 27:26nebulous, partially because there's no codified rule, but
- 27:29also in the US, when you look at they've decided that what is
- 27:34craft beer has to do with volume.
- 27:37And by that definition, Samuel Adams is a craft beer, which we
- 27:41know, right still versus just as much as the little small shop,
- 27:45you know, in some small town who's making their own beer.
- 27:48So the problem is when these terms are not regulated or at
- 27:51least have a parameter that's far too wide, you've get, you
- 27:56know, corporations that, you know, seize those terms and then
- 28:00it confuses the consumer. Right and we have the same.
- 28:04I even got into an argument with my my teacher at the i.e.
- 28:07CCT recently. Which is what, an international?
- 28:11It sounds great when you say it. You're ready.
- 28:13I love saying all the words. The International Institute of
- 28:16Chocolate and Cacao Tasting. Just rolls, right?
- 28:19Off the tongue just rolls right off the tongue.
- 28:21But that is the currently the most sort of standardized sort
- 28:25of regulating body for chocolate tasting certification.
- 28:28So I've done up to level 2 of them, hoping to do Level 3 with
- 28:31them in Peru this summer at Origin.
- 28:33Finally getting back to Peru, which will be exciting.
- 28:35But yeah, so we had this argument at Chicoa in February
- 28:40about what still counts as Kraft chocolate.
- 28:42And to me, I have this feeling of like, to me, Kraft chocolate
- 28:47is a little guy. It's, it's Ara and last one
- 28:49cacao and even plaque where they're working in these tiny
- 28:52spaces, they're working with very small quantities.
- 28:55They only have, you know, maybe 2 shops.
- 28:58They have a very controlled production couple of machines.
- 29:01But then the problem was, well, you can't, you can't fault
- 29:04people for getting successful. So like there's another craft
- 29:08chocolate maker, which, you know, Martin still considers
- 29:11craft. And I'm like, I have a really
- 29:14tough time still calling them craft.
- 29:16And they're in India and they're lovely people, but they're so
- 29:19big now and they're, they're processing tons of chocolate
- 29:22every year. And they have a bunch of shops
- 29:24and different, different factories and they, you know,
- 29:27and they've become a big company.
- 29:29And to me, you can't put them in the same category as like
- 29:33Alistair of the, of the, the chocolate tree in Scotland where
- 29:36he's got his, his modest little factory and he goes to the
- 29:40festivals himself and he's there, you know.
- 29:43But then is there another term for when you get sort of to a
- 29:45mid range like Alan Ducasse, who's obviously a big guy, but.
- 29:50Didn't start that right anymore. Yeah.
- 29:52What do you call them when it's not a bad product?
- 29:54I mean, it might not be the pure form you prefer, but it's
- 29:58arguably not a bad chocolate, right?
- 30:01And it's not a supermarket chocolate and it's not an
- 30:05industrial. Chocolate.
- 30:06And it's like I don't have an answer to that question.
- 30:08We lack the words. It's hard because you don't want
- 30:11to start feeling like you're putting people into categories
- 30:15or passing judgment on people, you know, basically faulting
- 30:19them for becoming so successful that they then now have a bigger
- 30:22factory. But for me, I think part of it
- 30:24is really, there's got to be something in there that has to
- 30:27do with how much the original founder and chocolate maker is
- 30:31actually still implicated in the process.
- 30:32And still, if the person who started the company and is the
- 30:36the chocolate maker is not in the factory every day sticking
- 30:42that tasting spoon in and deciding when it's done, that's
- 30:45when it's that's when it starts to stop really being Kraft
- 30:48chocolate. When it's so big that they've
- 30:49got a team of so many people and there's chocolate still spinning
- 30:53and other people are roasting for them.
- 30:54Other people are doing all the work actually, and they're not
- 30:58really hands on making their own chocolate.
- 31:00So that's founder driven then? Yeah.
- 31:03I mean, I think part of it is, is quantity driven, part of it
- 31:06is founder driven. Part of it also has to do with
- 31:09this connection with the supply chain.
- 31:12Like are you really, are you really connected?
- 31:15Are you getting out there and meeting the people supplying and
- 31:18and cultivating your beans? Or if you're working with a
- 31:19middleman, are you, do you know who your middleman is?
- 31:23Like if you're working with Kate with cacao latitudes and you
- 31:27know that Kate is out there in the fields, you know, 8 months
- 31:31out of 12 meeting with them, you know, overseeing the
- 31:33fermentation processes, creating educational spaces for the
- 31:38people working there. Making sure that those people
- 31:42who are harvesting and doing the post harvest processing, that
- 31:45they're getting paid enough to pay attention to what they're
- 31:47doing properly and that they're not asking their kids to get
- 31:50pulled out of school to help them in the fields.
- 31:53You know, there's, there's a responsibility.
- 31:57And this is also part of like what makes a craft chocolate and
- 32:00why these are the, the chocolates that we want to
- 32:02support. There's the social impact and
- 32:05there's the health impact, right?
- 32:06And the social impact is really, really important that, you know,
- 32:11you want to make sure that you're not.
- 32:12Supporting something horrific. I mean, we know that some of the
- 32:15big companies like Nestle, among others, Lint, which must be
- 32:20owned by Nestle. Or I don't know.
- 32:22Yeah. Boycott list.
- 32:24There we go. I mean they.
- 32:25Work, as we say, something less. Child labor in in Africa and.
- 32:31And even even the companies that say, oh, look, you know, like,
- 32:34like Tony's gonna say, oh, look. Oh.
- 32:37We can prove that our, our chocolate is child labor free.
- 32:42And then, you know, you have people out there in the fields,
- 32:44one who are basically documenting the fact that the
- 32:47people who signed the papers saying, Oh, no, kids were
- 32:50working here today. They've gone around and like
- 32:52shuttled the kid like it's, it's they have a week's notice.
- 32:55And so they're organizing it so that the papers can get signed
- 32:59off. But even still, it's like, OK,
- 33:02fine, you might be able to say that these cacao beans have been
- 33:05farmed more or less ethically, but it's a 60% chocolate bar.
- 33:09And the 40%, you know, the 25% that's sugar that's coming from
- 33:15some crazy farm, some, you know, sugar farm in Brazil or India,
- 33:19that's all being run by children.
- 33:20How can you call it child labor free when 30% of the product is
- 33:24actually being created through through child labor?
- 33:26So you know. No, you bring up a really good
- 33:30point. I forgot about that particular
- 33:32company as an example of how I mean.
- 33:35God, this sounds so much like fashion and green washing.
- 33:37Exactly, you know. And and even with coffee, which
- 33:40I talk about so much with my clients and, and on this show
- 33:43because I love it so much, coffee and chocolate.
- 33:47Lily Gray Coffee place, the Other.
- 33:48Day right and you want to know that you're not drinking
- 33:51something every single day that is harming people every second
- 33:55of every day you know but so you mentioned three places I you
- 33:58know plaque, which is bean to bar very pricey, very good, but
- 34:04they're obviously, you know in two very expensive neighborhoods
- 34:07of Paris. They are at small shops, a team
- 34:10last ton Cacao. And then the third one you
- 34:13mentioned was Ara. Ara, you told me about that
- 34:15recently. Yeah.
- 34:17Are there others that may not fall within that?
- 34:20Very, very. Small beef.
- 34:22Small beef category. Category that you would be like
- 34:25you know what if you're coming to Paris and you know these are
- 34:28some of the the chocolatiers that I.
- 34:31Respect, Respect and want to eat.
- 34:33Yeah. I mean, that's a very valid
- 34:36question because you know, with the exception of plaque, you
- 34:40know, and this is always, what do you say them the catch 22,
- 34:45even even for myself trying to open my own space, the profit,
- 34:49like if you're really doing the good work, creating amazing
- 34:52chocolate from amazing beans, doing it yourself, etcetera, the
- 34:56margin is minuscule and you're still working within a very
- 35:00labor intensive process that takes a lot of time and space
- 35:03and machines. And then you want to be paying a
- 35:06fair price for the beans, making sure you're getting good beans.
- 35:09At the end of the day, that means you can't really afford
- 35:11rent in you, you can't be spending €5000 a month on rent
- 35:17if you're going to have a little chocolate shop somewhere in
- 35:19Paris in the middle of this, the areas where all the tourists get
- 35:23too easily, right? So the people who are doing that
- 35:26work for the most part are a little bit on the fringe, right,
- 35:30in terms of where they're located.
- 35:33And your typical food tour through the Maray, you're not
- 35:36going to pass a bean to Bar Chocolatier because a chocolate
- 35:39maker because no one in their right mind can afford €11,000 in
- 35:42rent to do that in the Maray, so.
- 35:44But there are non bean to. Bar there are non bean to bar
- 35:47places that are definitely delicious and worth going.
- 35:50And I still have a lot of respect for Patrick Roje.
- 35:53I love his chocolate. I've met him a few times.
- 35:56His parkour, as we say in French, his, his professional
- 36:00trajectory is just so unexpected and, and, and incredible that I,
- 36:06I have a lot of respect for what he's built.
- 36:08And his chocolate has always been so beautiful, and his
- 36:12bonbons have always just been so, so well balanced, so
- 36:15powerful, so, so flavor forward. And he makes his.
- 36:19He produces his own almonds now in.
- 36:22France, you know, Amazing. Doesn't have to come from super
- 36:26far away. Yeah, so now he's got his own
- 36:28almond farms. That doesn't surprise me at all.
- 36:30But of course, like my, you know, fascination and kind of
- 36:34like, oh, he's the chocolate God.
- 36:37With Patrick Roget started long before this journey Like I when
- 36:41I lived in Zurich and I would come to Paris as a visitor and I
- 36:45first discovered Patrick Crochet.
- 36:46I was just like jaw on the ground because I was an art
- 36:49teacher. And when I saw the big orangutan
- 36:52sculpt, life-size orangutan head sculpted out of chocolate in the
- 36:56window, I was like, Oh my gosh, my dreams come true.
- 36:59And so I had a lot of respect for him as a visual artist as
- 37:02well. Sure.
- 37:02And just daring to work with chocolate as a sculpting medium
- 37:05that way and bringing those two worlds together.
- 37:08But that being said, you put one of his fresh lime salted caramel
- 37:13bonbons in your mouth and it's just like, you know, Explosion,
- 37:18right? So.
- 37:19Which is how I feel about Jack Shannon, right?
- 37:21We've talked about that. Talked about that before.
- 37:22Yeah. So Jack Shannon, I also love his
- 37:25chocolate. I would say if I'm going to go
- 37:27visit a shop, I definitely prefer the one on Rudu Bach.
- 37:32Oh real. Oh, because of just the just
- 37:34chaos. Of the yeah, you could call it
- 37:35the chaos. I'm going to say my my
- 37:38experiences as a customer, right?
- 37:41And Rudu Bach have been much more pleasant and welcoming
- 37:43there. So I definitely like that that
- 37:47shop. But every time I go to Jackson
- 37:49off for chocolate, I get distracted by the patch of free
- 37:51because this patch of free are so amazing.
- 37:53It's true, there's a lot to look at there.
- 37:55A lot, a lot to look at and a lot of deliciousness there.
- 37:59I'm also still a fan of Jean Paul, FL.
- 38:01I knew you were going to go there, yeah.
- 38:03Yeah, I mean old school. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
- 38:06He's another going to say it. He's another old white guy, you
- 38:10know another it's true, another old French guy.
- 38:11But but he's doing good work and he has started working with
- 38:14them, trying to be a little bit more Antlique, as they say,
- 38:18working with the the plantations in Cameroon and trying to, you
- 38:23know, help develop better flavor cacao and help support the
- 38:26communities that are producing the chocolate that that he works
- 38:29with. And the boutiques are beautiful.
- 38:32Sure, the packaging is beautiful.
- 38:33The flavors are interesting. And to be honest, if you're
- 38:36someone who likes macaron, you can try his macaron, which I do
- 38:40only with clients who like, really like macaron because then
- 38:43they can compare it to the ones that everybody else knows,
- 38:46right? And it usually holds up their
- 38:49smaller batch, you know? Yeah, they're much denser, his
- 38:52macaroni, but they're obviously very chocolate heavy, which is
- 38:55great. And of course, I love that he's
- 38:56still making pastries with the chocolate, right, And creating
- 38:59those little cakes that are very chocolate forward, very origin
- 39:02forward like. Like the potato?
- 39:04Right, the potato. Still making the potato.
- 39:07It literally looks like it's called potato and looks like a
- 39:09potato and has, I mean, it's dusted chocolate, right?
- 39:12Right. It does kind of also look like
- 39:14other things. Yes, we're not going to name
- 39:15those on here, but you can decide for yourself.
- 39:18I don't buy that one usually with clients, but like, you
- 39:21know, making them the entrepreneur that pairs the, the
- 39:24Venezuelan chocolate with the Tonka and with the and the one
- 39:27with the Raspberry and and really showcasing for people who
- 39:32normally wouldn't think about it.
- 39:34Even in pastry, the chocolate that you choose the origin and
- 39:39that particular bean has a specific flavor profile.
- 39:42So the Venezuelan chocolate might pair better with a Tonka
- 39:46cream. But then if you are working with
- 39:49a chocolate from Honduras, well, no, we're going to, we're going
- 39:53to put a Peach compote in there because that's going to that's
- 39:55going to complement it better or you know.
- 39:58Like that's where your pastry training comes in quite nicely
- 40:03to complement what you know about chocolate, then to you
- 40:06know what works texturally, flavor wise.
- 40:12And I think that's, that's also one of the the biggest things
- 40:15that we're finally, I think, starting to get starting to
- 40:18shift the paradigm, right, shifting the mindset of how
- 40:21people think about chocolate. So industrial revolution, when
- 40:25chocolate was finally, you know, able to start being something
- 40:27produced for the masses that could be affordable, not just
- 40:30for the high courts, but also for your everyday people and all
- 40:33that history stuff, which we don't need to talk about.
- 40:35But like, you know, between the UK and New York and Holland and
- 40:40France and everybody was kind of in Switzerland and, you know,
- 40:43all these people were sort of trading around machines, right?
- 40:45And so when you finally started having machines, they could help
- 40:48produce chocolate, the chocolate industry joined the industrial
- 40:51revolution, meaning the idea was like, oh, cool, wow, we can
- 40:57finally create a consistent product.
- 40:59And so this idea of chocolate having a consistent taste and
- 41:02flavor from batch to batch, from year to year, that was
- 41:06considered a good thing. And so a lot of the products and
- 41:08things that we grew up on, no matter how much the harvest has
- 41:11changed, where they got their beans has changed.
- 41:14Nobody ever thought to be suspicious that a Hershey bar
- 41:16still tasted like a Hershey bar 20 years later.
- 41:20And that was because all of these additives are different,
- 41:23different kinds of vanilla or different kinds of blends where
- 41:25they were reconstructing a specific flavor profile.
- 41:29And then also going into, and this starts to get into
- 41:32genetics, but, you know, pushing these plantations to sort of
- 41:35over overstrip the soil, replanting and cloning and, you
- 41:39know, in a monoculture to get that CCN 51 flavor because
- 41:43that's what enstroghini, that's what chocolate tastes like,
- 41:47right? And that that's what people want
- 41:49because that's what people get used to.
- 41:50What is chocolate actually? What is chocolate taste like?
- 41:52This is chocolatey, right? But that was just one or two
- 41:56specific genetic profiles of specific cocoa beans that had
- 42:01been cultivated for productivity and yield and not necessarily
- 42:04for fine flavor because, you know, we'll just fix it in post.
- 42:07We're going to add chemicals, sugars, vanilla, whatever to
- 42:10create that chocolatey flavor. And so we started to really lose
- 42:14all of this incredibly rich biodiversity possible of the,
- 42:19you know, 10s of thousands of different genetic profiles that
- 42:21you can have in chocolate that give it different flavors.
- 42:24So what that meant was that the chocolate people were using to
- 42:27bake with and to make other things and to make a chocolate
- 42:30mousse and to make a chocolate cake or to make your chocolate
- 42:33chip cookies. It was that specific chocolate
- 42:35flavor, right? So it meant that when chefs were
- 42:38developing recipes, bringing lots of ingredients together,
- 42:41whether it was raspberries or this certain kind of cream or a
- 42:45molay sauce or whatever it was, they only had one.
- 42:49Like they had blinders on. Well, this is what chocolate
- 42:51tastes like. And then they could, they would
- 42:54explore like if they're making a truffle pasta, they might go and
- 42:59taste 25 different types of truffle mushrooms to get just
- 43:03exactly the flavor they want for their pasta sauce.
- 43:06But if they're making a dessert, they'd be like, well, chocolate
- 43:08is chocolate, you know, which is totally BS, you know?
- 43:11And So what that meant was that those dessert recipes were built
- 43:15around chocolate only having one flavor, right?
- 43:18Right. And now we know and that we've
- 43:20relearned, right? We've unlearned and relearned.
- 43:23There is such a huge variety of flavor that you can get out of
- 43:27chocolate, different cocoa beans from different plantations, from
- 43:30different altitudes, from different parts of the world,
- 43:32fermented differently, processed differently.
- 43:35All of those things affect the final flavor.
- 43:37And then you should be building the dessert recipe around that,
- 43:41not the other way around, right? And so.
- 43:43Super interesting. Yeah.
- 43:44So like, you take the flavor that's present in the chocolate
- 43:48itself, and then you showcase it by building something around it,
- 43:52not the other way around. So let me know, is this
- 43:55something like what you talk about in your workshops, 'cause
- 43:59that was the other point I wanted to make sure listeners
- 44:01take away from this is that you lead workshops, chocolate tours,
- 44:06and you're an educator, you know, writ large on the subject
- 44:10of of chocolate. So is this something that you
- 44:14find people want to know about? Well, they're going to learn it
- 44:18anyway as. They as they should.
- 44:20That's a that's a good strategy. Actually, so, so yeah, I mean,
- 44:22obviously coming from a background of 20 years as an
- 44:25educator, no matter what I've done in my life, whether it was
- 44:28dancing or painting or whatever, like I want, like I'm more
- 44:32interested in teaching people how to do it and appreciate it
- 44:35than having people appreciate what I do, you know, like I'm,
- 44:38I'm not as interested in making my own chocolate and selling it
- 44:42and having people say like, oh, look, she knows how to make
- 44:44really good chocolate. That interests me way less that
- 44:47being able to teach 10s of thousands of people over the
- 44:50course of time how to appreciate better chocolate and buy
- 44:53different, better chocolate and use different better chocolate
- 44:56in their own baking and being able to support this this wider
- 45:00network. Well, chocolate fans, you've
- 45:02heard it all here first. Lisa, I'm sure you'll be back
- 45:05again. Thank you so much with.
- 45:07Pleasure. Thank you for having me.
- 45:10That's the show for today. If you're listening on Spotify,
- 45:13be sure to check out the poll related to this episode by
- 45:16scrolling down in your app. There are more exciting
- 45:18conversations to come this season, so I hope you'll
- 45:21subscribe or share the show with a friend if you've been enjoying
- 45:24what you've heard so far. As always, you can find more
- 45:27from me at lindsaytremuta.com and at the New Paris Dispatch on
- 45:31Substack Atreliento.