Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / Asking for a Raise Without a Formal Review Process
Transcript
- Lucas: So we got a question this week that I think hits a nerve for a lot of people, especially those in startups or smaller teams. A listener named Priya writes in: she's a marketing manager at a seventy-person tech company, been there eighteen months, consistently hitting her goals, but there is no annual review process, no promotion track, nothing formal. She wants a raise but has no idea how to even start the conversation. Luna: Yeah, that's tough. When there's no structure, you're basically creating the process from scratch. And that can feel really awkward. Lucas: Exactly. And Priya's not alone. A lot of fast-growing companies — especially in tech — skip formal reviews until they hit maybe two hundred people. So the burden falls on the employee to advocate for themselves. Luna: So what's the first step? Before she even talks to her manager? Lucas: Document everything. Not just a list of tasks — she needs to tie her work to business outcomes. For a marketing manager, that could be something like 'generated 400 qualified leads in Q2 that contributed to $1.2 million in pipeline, and here are the three campaigns I ran to do it.' Specific numbers, time-bound. That becomes her case. Luna: And then she needs market data, right? To show what her role is worth externally. Lucas: Right. She can use Levels.fyi, Glassdoor, or even ask colleagues in her network. She should find three to five comparable roles at similar-stage companies and in similar locations. The goal is to show that her current compensation is below the market median for someone with her impact. Luna: I like that frame — it's less 'I deserve more' and more 'the market says this role is worth X, and I'm delivering that value.' Lucas: Exactly. Then she schedules a dedicated meeting — not a quick chat after stand-up. She should ask for thirty minutes, and she can even say 'I'd like to discuss my contributions and compensation.' That sets the tone. Luna: What about timing? Is there a good moment to request that meeting? Lucas: Great question. Ideally after a recent win — maybe the campaign she led just closed a big deal, or a project she owned got positive feedback from the CEO. She wants to strike while the iron is hot. Also, avoid end of quarter when everyone is scrambling. Luna: Okay, she's got her document, her market data, and a meeting on the calendar. How does she actually open the conversation? Lucas: I'd suggest something like this: 'I've really enjoyed my time here and I feel my role has grown significantly since I started. I put together a summary of the impact I've had, and I also want to share some market benchmarks I found. I'd like to discuss how we can align my compensation with the value I'm delivering.' Then she hands over her one-pager. Luna: And if the manager says 'we don't do reviews — we just give everyone a standard adjustment once a year'? Lucas: Then she can acknowledge that, but point out that her role has expanded beyond what she was hired for. She can say, 'I understand the company's approach, but given that my responsibilities now include X, Y, and Z, I believe a market adjustment is warranted before the next cycle.' It shifts the conversation from a review to a role redefinition. Luna: That's smart. Because if the role itself has changed, that's a stronger argument than 'I've been here a year and a half.' Lucas: Exactly. And if the manager says 'budget is frozen,' she can ask, 'What would it take to unfreeze it? What milestones or metrics would make this possible in the next quarter?' That gives her a roadmap to revisit. Luna: So she's not just asking once and walking away — she's creating an ongoing conversation. Lucas: Right. And she should follow up in writing after the meeting with a short email summarizing what was discussed and any agreed next steps. That creates a paper trail. Luna: I have a friend who did something similar at a startup with no formal reviews. He created his own 'annual review' document and sent it to his manager quarterly — just as a self-assessment. Eventually, management adopted it as the company's review template. Lucas: That's a great example. Sometimes the lack of process is an opportunity to build the process yourself — and that shows leadership. Luna: Exactly. And for listeners who are in Priya's shoes, it's also worth checking if there's any equity or bonus structure that could be adjusted instead of base salary. Lucas: Good point. A lot of startups are more flexible with equity grants or one-time bonuses than with base comp. So she could negotiate for both — a modest salary bump plus additional stock options. Luna: Alright, let's take a quick pause here. If this conversation is helpful — if we've helped you think through a tricky career move or even just gave you the confidence to ask for what you're worth — that's why we do this show. Lucas: Yeah, and listener support is what keeps Office Hours ad-free and focused on your actual questions. If you find value in these episodes, you can buy us a coffee — it genuinely helps cover production costs and keeps the lights on. Luna: That's at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, but if you've ever gotten a raise or a better job because of something you heard here, that's the kind of feedback that keeps us going. Lucas: Now back to Priya's situation. She's had the meeting, got some pushback — maybe the manager said 'I need to talk to HR' or 'let's revisit in six months.' What should she do in that waiting period? Luna: She should keep documenting. And make sure her wins are visible to the decision-makers above her manager. Lucas: Exactly. She can start a monthly 'impact summary' email to her team or her manager, highlighting key metrics. That way, when the topic comes up again, the evidence is already there. And she should set a calendar reminder to follow up in two to three weeks if she hasn't heard back. Luna: And if the answer is still no after six months? At that point, she may want to explore outside options. Lucas: Right. Even if she doesn't want to leave, getting an external offer can reset the conversation. But that's a whole separate episode. For now, the key takeaway: if there's no formal process, create your own. Document, benchmark, schedule, frame it as role expansion, and follow up. Luna: And don't be afraid to ask. The worst they can say is no, and then you have clearer information for your next move. Lucas: Exactly. Priya, good luck — and let us know how it goes. We'll be back tomorrow with more answers to your workplace questions.