Latest / Microsoft Cloud IT Pro Podcast / Episode 380 – The future of AD FS is cloudy
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to episode 380
- 0:05of the Microsoft
- 0:07It pro podcast recorded live on 07/12/2024.
- 0:12This is a show about Microsoft 3 65
- 0:14in Azure from the spec to of It
- 0:16pros and end users, where we discuss the
- 0:18topic or recent news and how it relates
- 0:20to you. With the recent news about the
- 0:22At and T data breach or data league
- 0:25we start, top off talking a bit about
- 0:28security identity protection into recent security alert in
- 0:31Ben's Microsoft 3 65 tenant.
- 0:34Then staying along the lines of security, we
- 0:37discussed the recently released Ad ass
- 0:40migration tool in some of our thoughts around
- 0:42migrating from Ad fast to Microsoft Enter Id.
- 0:48Wow. It's a Friday. Scott. It is... Run
- 0:51the right microphones phones for recording, I'm using
- 0:53the right camera, And if you're on At
- 0:55and T your data has been stolen.
- 0:58If you're on any United States carrier, date
- 1:01has been stolen and at some point. Heck,
- 1:03if you live in the Us, actually, I
- 1:04think if you live anywhere in the world
- 1:06at this point, your data has been stolen.
- 1:08Yeah. I saw 1 the other day it
- 1:09was, like, the largest
- 1:11credential dump is floating around, like the Dark
- 1:14web and it's, like billions of records. Have
- 1:16you had this issue? I've had this issue
- 1:18in Teams. Then we'll go back to At
- 1:19and T where it just randomly switches to
- 1:22a different audio source while you're using Teams.
- 1:24Is that what just happened? I don't know.
- 1:26Like, my speaker went from my ding to
- 1:29my speakers. Which was weird. Got it. Anyways,
- 1:32Okay. So back to At and T, Yeah.
- 1:34I can't remember if we talked about this
- 1:35or at this somewhere where
- 1:37realistically, you should
- 1:39operate on the assumption that your data has
- 1:41been stolen versus that you're trying to protect
- 1:44your data at this point in time. So
- 1:46there is another article this week. I'll pop
- 1:48a link in the the chat and Show
- 1:50notes for everybody. So the largest password database
- 1:53leak was also this week. So that was
- 1:569 point 948
- 1:58million unique plain text passwords. Wow. Released by
- 2:01the threat actor dubbed Obamacare
- 2:04as part of the ro 20 24 dot
- 2:07TXT file. Can't make that stuff up. So
- 2:10creative.
- 2:11It's wild. This 1. I don't know did
- 2:13you see this At and T 1. Apparently
- 2:15it came from snowflake. So I'm curious to
- 2:18see more too if this was, like, At
- 2:20and T cr that were compromised to get
- 2:22into snowflake kinda like did they go through
- 2:24At and T to get to snowflake? Or
- 2:26was there a breach in snowflake? Because there
- 2:28been a bunch of
- 2:30stolen records that have come out of
- 2:32Snowflake. This article talked about...
- 2:36Who was it ticket master lending tree
- 2:39and some others that have all data stolen
- 2:42from snowflake
- 2:44specifically. So it's, like, was there issue. Snowflake.
- 2:46I don't know. It doesn't it doesn't really
- 2:48say, but a hundred and 10000000 At and
- 2:50T customers
- 2:51and it was, like, not just their information,
- 2:54but
- 2:55who they texted in who they called. So
- 2:57it was records of who called who who
- 2:59texted who didn't contain time date or the
- 3:03data of those, but still being able to
- 3:05draw a bunch of connections between different people
- 3:08based on who they're calling and texting. This
- 3:11is not an insignificant
- 3:13breach.
- 3:15No. It's not. So snowflake
- 3:17had
- 3:18a breach over the summer. And, like okay
- 3:22I guess, we're still in summer so. So
- 3:23this summer. It's snowflake kinda a breach. There
- 3:26there were, like, a hundred plus customers
- 3:29that were potentially leaked out in that breach,
- 3:31and, if I'm remembering great, it was actually,
- 3:33like, an ex campaign
- 3:35that kinda brought it all to bear. But
- 3:38you'll be happy to know
- 3:40that
- 3:41as of this week, what we're
- 3:44July 12. What is? Today's July July 12
- 3:47So as of July eleventh, Snowflake has decided
- 3:50to
- 3:51enable and enforce Mfa.
- 3:54Ironic that that came out the day before
- 3:56this did.
- 3:59Yeah.
- 4:00The, you know, the the the hits just
- 4:02keep on coming. I think it's a good
- 4:04lesson that none of us are
- 4:07actually in control
- 4:09of a lot of the data about our
- 4:11lives once it gets out there,
- 4:13you said, you kinda think about ways to
- 4:16mitigate that and
- 4:19kinda
- 4:20work through it. So I don't know how
- 4:22it works outside the Us, typically with a
- 4:24lot of these breaches in the Us like...
- 4:26And I imagine this will happen in the
- 4:27case of At and T, like, as a
- 4:29major provider with hundred million plus customers.
- 4:32Usually, they'll reach out, offer you some form
- 4:35of monitoring. So, like, for a credit card
- 4:37beat preach that could come in the form
- 4:39of
- 4:40credit monitoring
- 4:42for things like your credit score and maybe
- 4:44through, like Trans,
- 4:45or Ex ex or or some of the
- 4:47companies that monitor and watch that stuff could
- 4:50be other protections that are out there, like,
- 4:53I don't know. I've had, like, free ex
- 4:55experience and Trans,
- 4:57whatever premium monitoring for what feels like, the
- 4:59past, like, 5 years. Just because there's always
- 5:02another breach, and I just keep upping it
- 5:04for free.
- 5:05That makes sense. I've done identity theft insurance.
- 5:07So I actually went and bought identity theft
- 5:09insurance for, like, the entire family, and it's
- 5:12relatively
- 5:13inexpensive. I wanna say I pay, like, a
- 5:15hundred and 40 bucks a year or something.
- 5:17It's like 12 bucks a month. And
- 5:19they will monitor a bunch of that stuff
- 5:22as well so that if I didn't actually
- 5:24have free which. I'm like, you. I feel
- 5:26like, I've had free forever. But then if
- 5:28there is a case where, like, me or
- 5:301 of the kids or my wife or
- 5:32we have
- 5:33identity stolen, they are also
- 5:36will help resolve it, take care of any
- 5:39issues,
- 5:40get identities back, all of that. And again,
- 5:42kinda operating on the assumption that it's out
- 5:44there. And if it happens,
- 5:46it's a relatively
- 5:48small price to pay. Because everything I've heard
- 5:50that if your identity does get stolen, it
- 5:53can be a nightmare to get everything un
- 5:55entangled by yourself. Yeah. So I've never done
- 5:58identity theft in insurance. So last time I
- 6:01looked into it, and again, this could be
- 6:02Us specific. The
- 6:04insurance
- 6:05was very, like
- 6:07specific in the legal east in that they
- 6:10would provide you coverage,
- 6:12but the coverage around costs
- 6:15was related to the recovery process.
- 6:19After you've become a victim of Vice theft,
- 6:21it's not
- 6:22the
- 6:24recovery of funds
- 6:25prior,
- 6:27we which is a little bit weird. So
- 6:29say somebody spending money on a credit card
- 6:31for
- 6:32illegally for, like, the past year, and they've
- 6:34rung up, like, 50 k and in fraudulent
- 6:36purchases.
- 6:37The 50 k in pro fraudulent purchases
- 6:40isn't what's covered.
- 6:41What's covered is the time and the money
- 6:44to
- 6:45get that fixed. So you're still on the
- 6:47hook for the fraudulent service or you still
- 6:48need to go and work that out with
- 6:49your financial provider. And I couldn't find any...
- 6:53So so maybe you and I left to
- 6:54chat offline. Maybe you found a better option
- 6:56or maybe you found 1 that did kinda,
- 6:57like, work through this. But it seems to
- 6:59be a pretty big loophole in coverage in
- 7:02that, like, you're effectively still on the hook
- 7:04for the fraudulent purchases. It's more about, like,
- 7:07recovery afterwards.
- 7:08Which in my mind, I'm like, hey, recovery.
- 7:10Wouldn't does that mean covering the fraudulent purchases?
- 7:12It does not... I'd have to look at
- 7:13when this starts. The 1 I have
- 7:16is
- 7:16up to 2000000 dollars for stolen funds and
- 7:20expenses. So again, when that starts if it,
- 7:23like, is retroactive to
- 7:26when it was originally started or once they
- 7:29discover the fraud, if it's only stolen funds
- 7:30and expenses after you discover it, but, yeah,
- 7:33we can talk more about this 1. And
- 7:35maybe throw some links in the show notes
- 7:36if other people are interested. So 1 other
- 7:39security topic, unless you wanna talk more about
- 7:41identity theft and data breaches I had an
- 7:43interesting 1 in my Microsoft 3 65 tenant
- 7:46today. Actually. Are you spam again? I am
- 7:49still absolutely getting spam Although I finally got
- 7:52the first 1 to go to quarantine, I've
- 7:54had a crazy spam problem coming from a
- 7:58dot on Microsoft dot com account Neither here
- 8:00nor there, but this is 1, I got
- 8:02an alert Microsoft defender, and I'm not gonna
- 8:04share this 1 because of information that's in
- 8:06it, but essentially,
- 8:07I got an alert this morning that 1
- 8:09of my
- 8:11guests users
- 8:12in my tenant
- 8:14that
- 8:15I had shared something with that Truth told
- 8:17it was like 5 or 6 years ago.
- 8:19So this is a lesson learned. 5 or
- 8:216 years ago that I shared
- 8:23I invited them to a team channel. The
- 8:25team channel has long. The team has gone,
- 8:27I think the team has gone or archived.
- 8:29The channels got her archived,
- 8:31It was for some training stuff so nothing
- 8:33in there, but I got an alert that
- 8:35I had a user account in my tenant,
- 8:38accessing my tenant from tour Ip address. And
- 8:42when it it looked in, I will say
- 8:44defender did a good job, like it picked
- 8:45it up pretty quick based on all the
- 8:47audit logs, like, within
- 8:49seconds
- 8:50of the first activity. And actually went in
- 8:52and deleted the guest user.
- 8:55Just remove them from my tenant cleaned it
- 8:57all up. I didn't even recognize the username.
- 9:00So first I was like, oh, who is
- 9:02this guest username my tenant? I did some
- 9:04searching figured out when I had interacted with
- 9:06them when I had invited them, good thing
- 9:08is again, It didn't have any access to
- 9:10anything in the tenant because everything is long
- 9:12since come gone. But
- 9:14It appears because this
- 9:16credential was also used like, 4 different times,
- 9:19and this is part of why I got
- 9:20picked up to 4 different times in the
- 9:22course of a few seconds,
- 9:24to
- 9:25access my tenant
- 9:27as a guest, and it looks like it
- 9:28was probably in teams from, like, 4 different
- 9:31countries. Welcome to the fund that is be
- 9:33being on AAA tour. Right? And Right. The
- 9:36layers of the onion and and how all
- 9:37that comes together. It's an interesting thing. So
- 9:40so it's funny you bring this up. We
- 9:41do annual security training. And part of... Well,
- 9:45I mean, we do it more manually. But
- 9:47part of the latest round of security training.
- 9:50Actually had a section in there that talked
- 9:52about guest users.
- 9:54And
- 9:55actions that we as employees need to take
- 9:59when we're dealing with guest users and things
- 10:03like teams.
- 10:04So it's a very manual process. Right? Like,
- 10:07if you finished a project, like, you said,
- 10:08you've done all the things. You've archived the
- 10:10team, you've archived the channel. Like, it turns
- 10:13out you actually do have to go and,
- 10:15like, explicitly revoke access from those users to
- 10:19kinda clean it all up. Feels like a
- 10:21great space for, like, an Is or somebody
- 10:23to step in. Just have, like, the tenant
- 10:26monitoring blah blah blah. I'm surprised Microsoft doesn't
- 10:29have it and, like, some kind like, built
- 10:31in life cycle management for guests, but a
- 10:35lot of the onus is still on individuals
- 10:37who are spinning these things up. Have the
- 10:39context. Like, I get why it's hard automate.
- 10:41You don't know. Like a guess Google dormant
- 10:43for 2 months, and it turns out maybe
- 10:45they're needed later kinda thing, whatever. Yeah. Well
- 10:47it's a hard problem. It feels like a
- 10:49sol 1 as well. May maybe an Ai
- 10:51could solve it for us who knows. Yep.
- 10:53And I haven't not done this in mind.
- 10:55Maybe we should do a podcast on this.
- 10:57They have, like, their life cycle
- 11:00workflows in their identity governance, and the access
- 11:03reviews, which I would say get close. I
- 11:06don't know that you could build a full
- 11:08life cycle
- 11:09workflow. Because life cycle workflows are usually more
- 11:13onboarding new hires
- 11:15group membership changes,
- 11:17off boarding employees,
- 11:19off boarding employee, off boarding employee. It doesn't
- 11:22look like And I've looked at these some,
- 11:24you can do it for guest users.
- 11:25Access reviews, I know you can set up
- 11:27for guest users that are guests of teams
- 11:30and groups.
- 11:31Where
- 11:32it would, like, every 3 months that essentially
- 11:34goes through a team in or a Microsoft
- 11:363 65 group, re really? Because that's the
- 11:39identity structure under the team. And you can
- 11:41set those up for guests and say, every
- 11:45so often looks roll my teams with guests
- 11:47and send notifications to the owners,
- 11:49Does this guest delete access to this team
- 11:51group? If not, like, by default, delete them
- 11:54or by default, leave them or after the
- 11:58owner hasn't set it for so long or
- 12:01responded for so long, escalated it to somebody
- 12:03else, but it isn't
- 12:05necessarily
- 12:06I think it falls a little short, and
- 12:08then it doesn't have that ability to necessarily
- 12:10delete the guest from your tenant. Kinda like
- 12:13mine was. The team was gone.
- 12:15An access review could cleaned them up from
- 12:16the team, and I think I may even
- 12:18manually cleaned them up from the team, but
- 12:20they're still stuck in intra, and even you
- 12:23like At Microsoft, you're not gonna have the
- 12:25ability to go into entrant and delete remove
- 12:27users. So it does have to fall to
- 12:30an admin. Yeah. You really need like, holistic.
- 12:34You almost want like all the life cycle
- 12:35management components to come together. So, like, life
- 12:38cycle for my team, life cycle for the
- 12:41data and the
- 12:43That exist in there. Life cycle for the
- 12:45users, all the way back down to the
- 12:48identity store, be it And and Id or
- 12:51or whatever kind of thing. Especially for like,
- 12:54these more, like, project driven workflows, like you
- 12:57really would wanna. I think, like, you know,
- 12:59it'd be an interesting world where you come
- 13:01in and you say, hey, I'm spending up
- 13:02a new project and that thing automatically creates
- 13:05a team, and it has some metadata that's
- 13:06says here's the start date. Here's the end
- 13:08date. And then once you hit the end
- 13:10date, if you haven't extended it, then it
- 13:11goes and kinda runs the machine and does
- 13:14all the other stuff behind it, but it
- 13:16says humans are bad at managing information. I've
- 13:18learned that very well over the course of
- 13:20my career,
- 13:21myself included. You know, sometimes you need, like,
- 13:23the state machine to come and kick things
- 13:25and move it forward and get it going.
- 13:28So... Tl, these things are gonna continue to
- 13:30happen. They'll continue to be an
- 13:32issue, be vigilant even in your own tenants.
- 13:35Yes. And I will give props to defender.
- 13:38It did a good job. It caught it.
- 13:40It deleted it, and then right from within
- 13:42the incident that it generated. I was able
- 13:44to go,
- 13:45I reviewed all my logs. I'm like, okay.
- 13:46Did this user...
- 13:47Is there data? This guest account accessible. It
- 13:50was in there? Was there data that was
- 13:52still shared with this guest account. Like everything
- 13:55came back,
- 13:56like, there was nothing there. For all I
- 13:58knew it was still the user that happened
- 14:00to be on a to network with his
- 14:02company account, and
- 14:03opened up teams and hit my tenant because
- 14:08once you're a guest, you have, like, a
- 14:10gazillion different teams, in your tenancy and all
- 14:13it does is just taking it opening up,
- 14:15trying to re in teams to. Yep, pop
- 14:18that up. But yes, Looks like have a
- 14:20safe, but it... It's a new 1 for
- 14:22me. I had not ever seen that before.
- 14:24So like you said, be wary with guest
- 14:26accounts. And their life cycle and how you
- 14:29manage them? Be beware with your own user
- 14:31accounts too. No Limited it to guests. That
- 14:33as well. Be wary with all the accounts.
- 14:35Yeah. I think people forget about guest accounts.
- 14:38An easy 1 to slip your mind especially
- 14:40when you just shared an document with 1
- 14:41and didn't, like, that whole process of now
- 14:43they're guest accounts. I do like the 1
- 14:45time passcode stuff from that perspective where there
- 14:48is some sharing now you can do where
- 14:50it doesn't create a guest account. It's just
- 14:52like a 1 time Act. Cisco code, you
- 14:54get it and that also can help with
- 14:56some of that. So with that, 20 minutes
- 14:59later, good conversation. Should we jump into our
- 15:02topic that we had planned for today? Jump
- 15:04into this 1 a little bit? You put
- 15:05all this work into planning. We should get
- 15:07to it. We should get to it. And
- 15:08it's still kinda released. To this.
- 15:13Do you feel overwhelmed by trying to manage
- 15:15your office 3 65 environments are you facing
- 15:18unexpected issues that disrupt your company's productivity?
- 15:21Intelligent is here to help much like you
- 15:23take your car to the mechanic that has
- 15:25specialized knowledge, how to best keep your car
- 15:28running, intelligent helps you with your Microsoft cloud
- 15:31environment because that's their expertise. Intelligent keeps up
- 15:34with the latest updates in the Microsoft cloud
- 15:36to help keep your business running smoothly and
- 15:39ahead of the curve. Whether you are a
- 15:40small organization with just a few users up
- 15:43to an organization several thousand employees. They want
- 15:46to partner with you to implement and administer
- 15:48your Microsoft cloud technology
- 15:51of Visit them at intelligent dot com slash
- 15:54podcast that's INTELLIGINK
- 16:00dot com slash podcast
- 16:02for more information or to schedule a 30
- 16:04minute call to get started with them today.
- 16:06Remember intelligent jake focuses on the Microsoft cloud,
- 16:09so you can focus on your business.
- 16:14So this was an article, take from Tech
- 16:17nut that popped up, and it brought up
- 16:19an interesting conversation. It was from June 26.
- 16:22So this was few weeks ago now, but
- 16:25it's moved to the cloud or move to
- 16:26cloud
- 16:27authentication with the the Ad
- 16:30or active directory
- 16:32Federation services,
- 16:34migration tool. So this was an announcement that
- 16:37the migration tool for Ad fast,
- 16:39to move their apps to Microsoft Enter. Id
- 16:43is now generally available. They can update identity
- 16:46management,
- 16:47they announced
- 16:48the Efs application migration moving to public freebie
- 16:51back in November, all of that. We can
- 16:53talk about the tool, But what I think
- 16:55is interesting about this, Scott. And we talked
- 16:57about this a little bit is further down
- 17:00in this article, they have a diagram with
- 17:03Ad efs,
- 17:04and
- 17:05enter Id in highlighting
- 17:08limitations of not transforming
- 17:11to
- 17:12and try Id and benefits moving to Id,
- 17:15but then they also label Ad is the
- 17:17old way in try Id as the new
- 17:19way, and
- 17:21this
- 17:22spurred a very immediate comment on the article.
- 17:25Given this new tool, the age complexity, security
- 17:28limitations of ad fast and improve technology being
- 17:31available, Do you consider a road map on
- 17:33Ad s d fabrication? And we started talking
- 17:36a little bit? Or 1 about this tool
- 17:38but too about Ad efs and try,
- 17:42comparing them as 2 different ways of
- 17:45authentication, especially in old way in a new
- 17:47way, And I would say even more so
- 17:49that in my head, this triggers eye old
- 17:52way new way, but it's also...
- 17:54Is Microsoft saying on prem is the old
- 17:57way cloud is the new way versus some
- 17:59of these where it's... They're still providing an
- 18:02on prem solution. This is almost starting to
- 18:04say, and I think where this comment is
- 18:06coming from is, is the on prem
- 18:09identity for something like Ad efs or a
- 18:12lot going away and interest going to be
- 18:14the only way forward or there's a lot
- 18:16of questions, I think. Around
- 18:19just the way some of this was labeled.
- 18:22And I still have customers on Ad s
- 18:232, which makes me think about it. I
- 18:25don't think this is
- 18:26too different than what everybody's been hearing for
- 18:29years now. In that there's a focus on
- 18:32the cloud and cloud services. And, you know,
- 18:35it's kind of a a funny list if
- 18:36you go and and look at their they're
- 18:39framing for old way in new way, like,
- 18:41you could apply just about any of these
- 18:44benefits
- 18:45to any cloud solution.
- 18:48Over to, like, remove Ad fast from it.
- 18:51Right and so, like, they talk about, like
- 18:52the new way and the benefits. So benefits,
- 18:54more agile than responsive Ai future ready. Whatever.
- 18:58We'll throw the Ai thing out the window
- 18:59for a second, but more agile and responsive,
- 19:01sure. Like, if there's an evergreen service that's
- 19:04constantly being updated in the cloud, that's gonna
- 19:07be more responsive. That could be
- 19:09ent, that could be exchange
- 19:12that could be your toaster fridge in the
- 19:14corner and it's firmware, like, like, whatever it
- 19:16is. Right? Like, like those things. If they're
- 19:19running and somebody else responsible for running them
- 19:22in their data center. Like, they're gonna be
- 19:24more agile more up to date. Reduce costs
- 19:26and operational complexity. Again, that's not Ad efs
- 19:29specific. It's you're just removing the costs and
- 19:33the Capex and Op associated with running on
- 19:37prem kit. So, hey, I don't need to
- 19:39lease new servers. I don't need to worry
- 19:42about getting the latest
- 19:44version of that load balance or or whatever
- 19:47it happens to be those kinds of things.
- 19:50Requirements around
- 19:51where data is home.
- 19:53So you know, if you think about, like,
- 19:55try
- 19:56versus on prem. Well, on prem. Everything's gotta
- 19:59be an active directory. And then you go,
- 20:01well, Great Scott, Like, everything's gotta be an
- 20:03intro Id in in in the cloud. Isn't
- 20:05it the same.
- 20:06Yeah, kinda sorta of not really though because
- 20:09entry Id is more than 80 domain accounts.
- 20:13It's
- 20:14devices. It's this whole other world of like,
- 20:17constructs and personas and and types of things
- 20:21that
- 20:22exist out there. And then in the last
- 20:24benefit they had was eliminating vulnerable assets. I
- 20:27kinda put that back under the hidden costs
- 20:30of maintenance of on prem things. Benefit you're
- 20:32moving at a different pace. Somebody else is
- 20:34responsible for the the security and all the
- 20:37other things around it. So in Ad s
- 20:39Land, like, you're like, well, Microsoft is still
- 20:42responsible for the security either way, whether it's
- 20:44Ad efs or whether it's enter in the
- 20:46cloud. Yes and no. Like, they're responsible for
- 20:49the software, but you're responsible for deploying the
- 20:51software. You're responsible for deploying all the,
- 20:55surrounding kit on those things. Right? Because it's
- 20:57not just an Ad f server. It's usually
- 21:00multiple Ad f servers. Usually those sit behind
- 21:03a load balance. There's probably also, like, firewalls
- 21:06and Ips, Ids, things like that in in
- 21:09line in there that all need to be
- 21:11updated and
- 21:13configured as well. How I think it was
- 21:15interesting just to kinda see the
- 21:17framing
- 21:18of this. But clearly, there's a desire to,
- 21:21you know, shift customers away.
- 21:23From on prem. And then the reality is,
- 21:25like, once you're in enter in the cloud,
- 21:27like, you're probably not going back the other
- 21:29way either. I would agree on those benefits
- 21:30and how they framed it It's an interesting
- 21:33comparison to make and. I have started having
- 21:35these conversations with some of my customers that
- 21:38are like, we wanna start getting off of
- 21:39Ed efs. But I've also had conversations. I
- 21:43don't know that I have any customers
- 21:46that I've had it with that I have
- 21:47Ad fest today, but there is... Also still
- 21:50a few feature gaps. I would say between
- 21:53Ad ass and and try d. I don't
- 21:55know what all of them are because I
- 21:57don't do a ton with Ad ass, most
- 21:59of my customers that have it. I know
- 22:00it's there and we've done some work with
- 22:02it. But I do know 1 that. This
- 22:04is an interesting 1 that comes up over
- 22:06and over and over again is customers limiting
- 22:09the
- 22:11time
- 22:11that people can log in to a service.
- 22:15Like these employees are only allowed to log
- 22:18in between 8AM and 5PM.
- 22:20And there's been various requirements that make valid
- 22:24sense for that. It actually makes sense from
- 22:26a security perspective. Right? Like, some of my
- 22:28workers that are maybe scheduled to
- 22:31work a particular
- 22:33shift or
- 22:35work certain hours and should not be accessing
- 22:38company data outside of those hours, Some of
- 22:40that I've heard around
- 22:42need to pay them over time if they're
- 22:45accessing company data outside of work hours. Some
- 22:47of it could be a security thing. If
- 22:49they're on the clock, they can access data,
- 22:50but I don't want them logging in anywhere
- 22:53else when they're not at work. You could
- 22:55argue well you can do device join and
- 22:57some of that. But that's 1 that has
- 22:59come up a lot. And I'm like, yeah.
- 23:00There isn't the way to sell that right
- 23:02now and enter. And I do know that
- 23:04can be solved with Ad s.
- 23:07Because that's been the answer for a long
- 23:09time. So...
- 23:10Again, maybe some of these will start coming
- 23:12to Intro. If anybody's listening on the enter
- 23:14team and wants to add a new feature
- 23:15to Enter, you need something to add in
- 23:17this next fiscal year. Time bound logins to
- 23:20enter would be on a list of things
- 23:21that I've been asked about. That's an interesting
- 23:231. So you're 1 of the few people
- 23:26who
- 23:27I've actually heard frame it as a
- 23:31business problem versus a security problem. So, like,
- 23:34if you go out and you'd look,
- 23:36We talked about this like, last week when
- 23:37we we're going it. So III was kinda
- 23:39looking around. I was like, you know, it's
- 23:40like, it makes sense. Like, why isn't it
- 23:42there? I can see it, like, based on
- 23:44the way you framed it. And everything that
- 23:47I saw, every time somebody asks about this,
- 23:50they often frame it in context of security.
- 23:54Where they're like, oh, this person not being
- 23:56able to log in at this time is
- 23:59more secure, or I only want admins to
- 24:02be able to log in into these times.
- 24:03Like, And from that lens, it's like, well,
- 24:05no. Not really. It's more like security through
- 24:07obscurity. Right? Because once you're in with the
- 24:09access rates you have, it doesn't matter if
- 24:11you're doing that at 12AM or 12PM,
- 24:13like, in is in kind of thing. Right.
- 24:16So from a security lens, like,
- 24:19yeah. It probably doesn't make a ton of
- 24:21sense Like, I'm I'm sure there's somebody out
- 24:23there who can rationalize the way into it.
- 24:24But, like, it's just soft to cough, Like,
- 24:26doesn't make a ton of sense from a
- 24:29security perspective. Like, it's more a
- 24:31a piece of business
- 24:33functionality.
- 24:34And then that actually makes it I think
- 24:36harder to prioritize in today's world, So, like,
- 24:40you know, we opened with the whole credential
- 24:41theft thing. So with
- 24:45And Microsoft being the provider of that service.
- 24:49Do you want them to spend time on
- 24:52a
- 24:53user nice, like, time based to access control?
- 24:56Or do you want them to focus on
- 24:59better audit logs and better restrictions and being
- 25:01able to catch people on to networks or
- 25:04the traffic from
- 25:05China or rogue actor, things like that. Like,
- 25:08most people are gonna say, like, no. I
- 25:10actually wanna focus on the security stuff. So
- 25:12that's where the time, like, continues to go
- 25:16and lean into. Maybe this manifests in other
- 25:18ways. Like, I I don't know if it
- 25:20ever becomes, like, a core intra thing. Maybe
- 25:22it shows up as
- 25:24you know, something inside of conditional access. Like,
- 25:27they used to have the
- 25:29configure... What were they, like, the adaptive session
- 25:32lifetimes and things like that. So they've had
- 25:35kind of ish features like this, but they're
- 25:37like, all almost not quite kinds of things.
- 25:40We'll see. And I think to thing for
- 25:42you to do as customers to, like, frame
- 25:44that out and think about it too is
- 25:47what's the Roi?
- 25:48Am I getting it out of it. You
- 25:51know, you're using Ad efs for this thing
- 25:52today, is the writing on the wall that
- 25:54eventually Ad efs goes away. I don't know.
- 25:57But Ad efs also isn't getting meaningful improvements.
- 25:59So at some point you're gonna kinda be
- 26:02left behind. And this same thing has happened
- 26:04with, like, Sharepoint, with exchange, with all these
- 26:07other things. You're just seeing it on kind
- 26:09of a a different timeline
- 26:11and
- 26:12potentially a different scale depending on your organization
- 26:16and and kinda your applications you host in
- 26:18your company and and the way you do
- 26:20business. So
- 26:21we'll see
- 26:23where it bake out.
- 26:24I don't know. Maybe somebody will step in
- 26:26at some point, like, even if Ad f
- 26:28goes away. I don't think the ability for
- 26:31ent intro to be a modern identity provider
- 26:34and support things like Sam off and replying
- 26:37parties. Like, I don't think that goes away.
- 26:39So maybe there's an opportunity where even like,
- 26:41another 1 of, like, the cloud vendors picks
- 26:43it up, like, say, like, an O or
- 26:45something like that. So if you maybe fed
- 26:47through O,
- 26:48Oracle Id,
- 26:50maybe, you know, say there's a theoretical world
- 26:52where Ad goes away. Does that mean, everybody
- 26:55goes to oracle Id or sale pointers. Something.
- 26:57I don't know. You know, we'll see. It's
- 26:58interesting And does that mean...
- 27:01I mean, I feel like almost every organization
- 27:03has something in the cloud But does it
- 27:05also mean for, like, companies that have been
- 27:08purely on prem if this goes away and
- 27:10stops being supported, something like an authentication server,
- 27:13You shouldn't run any software out of support
- 27:15for security reasons. I feel like authentication servers
- 27:18or maybe on another level? Kind of a
- 27:19important. Right. Is it gonna start pushing some
- 27:22companies?
- 27:23Dan. Like, are they gonna get some kickback?
- 27:25I know at 1 point in time, there
- 27:27was, like, this is the last version of
- 27:28Sharepoint on prem ever.
- 27:30And then there were a bunch of customers
- 27:32that said, can we rethink that? And low
- 27:35and behold we had Sharepoint.
- 27:37Subscription edition, I can't remember if there was
- 27:39even like a Sharepoint 20 19 and then
- 27:41Sharepoint subscription edition after that, how the timing
- 27:44of that worked, But I would
- 27:46imagine that. And again, this is not... Don't
- 27:49interpret this as Ad s is going away
- 27:51because there has been no announcements about it.
- 27:53But it definitely feels like it's Microsoft trying
- 27:56to push
- 27:57everybody to the cloud for authentication, which good
- 28:00or bad. I mean, space at Microsoft was
- 28:02also in the news for security stuff over
- 28:04the course of the last 6 months. So
- 28:07I don't know. Definitely an interesting discussion and
- 28:09I say especially if you do have an
- 28:11ad f server. And again, I've had these
- 28:13conversations already with my clients is,
- 28:16do you need to start thinking about... Let's
- 28:19enter in replacing Ad s with Ent. And
- 28:22they're all already in the cloud. This has
- 28:24already been conversations that have come up for
- 28:25that reason because as they've migrated work workloads
- 28:28to the cloud, and
- 28:30there are challenges that have also come up
- 28:33with Ad aws from their perspective where their
- 28:35like it probably is smart, for us to
- 28:38look at getting rid of our Ad f
- 28:39servers and migrate to
- 28:42given that we're already in the cloud already
- 28:44doing a bunch of stuff for Azure well,
- 28:46Azure ad with Id, all of that. But
- 28:49I will say, well we have a few
- 28:50more minutes, this also led us to
- 28:53this tool, I gotta find it. And I
- 28:56was trying to remember if I've seen this
- 28:58website before Scott. It is set up dot
- 29:01cloud dot Microsoft. And then in this tool,
- 29:04there is a migrate from Ad to my
- 29:06Microsoft and Id for identity management, and this
- 29:09is the website. And the sub site within
- 29:12the website that this blog post redirected us
- 29:15to where it's like a
- 29:18it's an interesting tool We'll put it at
- 29:20that. It's not necessarily a
- 29:22click through and go connect to my tenant,
- 29:25like, maybe I anticipated it was,
- 29:27but it's a guide where, like, on the
- 29:31first page, it's
- 29:32for all types of migrations. The following Ad
- 29:35scenarios can't be migrated to end. So it
- 29:37does start right off with
- 29:40certain
- 29:41cases and it gives you a bullet list
- 29:42there of,
- 29:44these can't be migrated to Ad s and
- 29:46then some stuff are on staged rollout. And
- 29:48if the too select to none of the
- 29:49scenarios apply to my org and I'm ready
- 29:51to move forward, then you can go to
- 29:54the next page, which then walks you through.
- 29:57It's almost like a questionnaire of, then what
- 29:59types of apps are using. They're using office
- 30:01apps, non Microsoft apps
- 30:03Based on those it's an conditional checkbox
- 30:05of
- 30:07Is your Ad efs
- 30:08implementation integrated with Microsoft Enter multi factor authentication
- 30:12server, which has been d by the way.
- 30:16And based on what you select there. So
- 30:19it's it's like a walk through of
- 30:22getting you ready for it. And then I
- 30:25believe once you get far enough we found
- 30:26it, does
- 30:27provide,
- 30:29like, some scripts you can run links out
- 30:31to different
- 30:32documentation
- 30:33to
- 30:35begin your... Some actual migration. And,
- 30:38again, not necessarily the tool I was thinking
- 30:40where it's gonna, like, do a bunch of
- 30:42migrations of apps for you and grab all
- 30:43the metadata,
- 30:44and copy it from your Ad f server
- 30:46maybe into entrance and start creating applications there
- 30:49and automate the migration, but walks you through
- 30:54I would say better than maybe the Microsoft
- 30:56learn documentation does around some of the steps
- 30:58and what you need to think about to
- 31:01actually manage this migration and go forward with
- 31:03that.
- 31:04Migration. I think it abstracts away just like,
- 31:06on the front, like some of the complexities
- 31:09of thinking about, like, sam assertion,
- 31:12Ad what are the
- 31:14potential, like, claim rules that need to be
- 31:16augmented?
- 31:17Like, how do I swing things? How do
- 31:19I roll back? Like, it's not the most.
- 31:21Like un complicated scenario to swing your identity
- 31:25from 1 side to the other and get
- 31:27it to where it needs to be. So
- 31:29it's know I think it depends on the
- 31:30kind of admin you are, like, hopefully, if
- 31:32you're maintaining Ad fast infrastructure, like, you know
- 31:35all this stuff and you know how to
- 31:37go in and like, augment claims roll with
- 31:39your eyes closed. If you don't, then, you
- 31:42know, wizards like this are kind of nice
- 31:44for you to keep you there. Like, maybe
- 31:47somebody else set it up, and it's just,
- 31:48like a piece of infrastructure to your portfolio.
- 31:51You need to go back and maintain it
- 31:52and get it to where it needs to
- 31:54be. So I kinda go both ways with
- 31:56it. Like, 1, it's nice to have to
- 31:57wizard, but the other... The reality is, like,
- 31:59you're gonna end up in those deep dive
- 32:01docks anyway.
- 32:02At the end of the day to get
- 32:03to get where you need to be. This
- 32:05site, the the whole setup dot cloud dot
- 32:07Microsoft dot thing. Set up dot cloud dot
- 32:10Microsoft was interesting me. Like, I never really...
- 32:12I mean, maybe at some point, like they
- 32:14announced this thing or somebody knew existed. I
- 32:17couldn't remember it existed or that it was
- 32:19out there but there's just all sorts of
- 32:21different
- 32:22kind of migration guides. They're they're all in
- 32:25these, like, wizard driven interfaces, right. And so
- 32:28it's like, weird stuff, like, configuring high mode
- 32:31for Microsoft edge. There's a 0 trust setup
- 32:34guide. You can do things by categories.
- 32:37So you can go in and look at
- 32:38like, hey. I wanna look at, like a
- 32:39guide for identity, which would be things like
- 32:42Ad cleanup, so wanna do security. You mentioned
- 32:46defender, like, kudos to defender, Like, hey, Guess
- 32:49what? There... There's a guy. There's a scenario
- 32:51guide in here. For
- 32:53defender for identity, for defender for Office 3
- 32:5565,
- 32:56defender for cloud apps. There's a bunch of
- 32:59intune stuff with Md. There's per stuff for
- 33:02compliance.
- 33:03There's team stuff for
- 33:06collaboration and voice Right? So, like, how do
- 33:09you configure teams for a frontline workforce? As
- 33:11a guide that they they have in here.
- 33:13They have a bunch of employee experience stuff?
- 33:15Like, don't think I've ever seen engage insights
- 33:18goals, like, Fifa engage, insights, v insights, Vivo
- 33:21goals, all that stuff, like wrap together in
- 33:241 place like this, product driven guides it's
- 33:26a really kind of a weird site, and
- 33:28then it replicates
- 33:29some other functionality as well and potentially
- 33:34strange
- 33:35ways. So, like, 1 of the ones you
- 33:36and I were talking about when where we're
- 33:38really looking at this previously was when you
- 33:39do office deployments with the office deployment tool
- 33:42in O t, you have to create some
- 33:44xml to pump into your Ot t file
- 33:47that Xml defines configuration for your office client.
- 33:50Like,
- 33:51what are the things that I'm saw? I'm
- 33:52oh, I'm only gonna saw,
- 33:54excel and word here? And I'm gonna have
- 33:56this turned on. I want a 32 bit.
- 33:5864 bit architecture, blah all those things. So
- 34:01usually, the way you would do that is
- 34:02there's actually an entire, like, setup and provisioning
- 34:05engine. That's part of the admin center,
- 34:07the interesting thing about the 1 that sits
- 34:09over here is this 1 sits outside the
- 34:12admin center, and you can do it all
- 34:13una a authenticated. Right? Just come in and
- 34:16spin up the Xml and get it out
- 34:17the other side. But then it not only
- 34:19gives you the Xml. It gives you a
- 34:20whole other set of, like, powershell scripts that
- 34:22are bespoke, for you to actually go and
- 34:25do the Odd deployment, it's really kind of
- 34:27a weird
- 34:29du
- 34:29thing.
- 34:31I don't know. But if nobody's seen it
- 34:32I did like, like, the wizard driven interface,
- 34:35the next next next, like, hey, Explain it
- 34:37to me as I go kind of thing,
- 34:38like some of that was nice. Again, It
- 34:40felt like... Even though it duplicated it it
- 34:42puts some of that in, I would say
- 34:44more logical order if you're brand new to
- 34:46it. To your point if you've been doing
- 34:47this for a while, I don't know. Like
- 34:49you and I how beneficial this really is
- 34:52because it does... I would say it tends
- 34:54to focus on a little bit more of
- 34:56the basic stuff. Deployed the Microsoft 3 65
- 34:58apps, I didn't know look what was in
- 35:00there like for defender. Set up your 0
- 35:02Trust security model. That 1 be interesting to
- 35:05walk through to see how detailed that 1
- 35:06gets.
- 35:07Deploying configure defender for endpoint, defender for Office
- 35:103 65,
- 35:11analyze security posture. And like you said, some
- 35:14of the stuff that's in here, then you
- 35:15have that mixed in with die mode for
- 35:17edge. I don't
- 35:19I don't know, Scott. You know, you gotta
- 35:21sprinkle the legacy in there with the new
- 35:23stuff. It's it's it's 5. To play and
- 35:25configure edge with a step by step experience.
- 35:28Microsoft search setup guide is somehow under edge.
- 35:32Don't know that I would consider Microsoft search
- 35:34setup up got under edge, but we'll go
- 35:36with it. Yeah. I would say worth exploring.
- 35:39There's... 61 different guides in here, so it
- 35:41is not gonna be
- 35:44all inclusive.
- 35:46Tell me everything I need to know about
- 35:48deploying Microsoft 36C5?
- 35:50There might be couple in here that you
- 35:51find interesting. Preview security are the big ones,
- 35:54V. Yeah. There's 9 of them for Viva.
- 35:56C There was a bunch of. Is it
- 35:58insights goals,
- 36:00engaged that they were all there. There's 1
- 36:02for Am 2 Scott, which technically isn't even
- 36:04a product anymore. Just in case. I mean,
- 36:07just in case someone's still using the upper.
- 36:08Yes. Which has steve engage. Just think we've
- 36:11engaged. Let's just rec categorize it. Yeah. So
- 36:14nifty tools.
- 36:15If you are still any D ass, you're
- 36:17looking to migrate. There's a click through to
- 36:21maybe help you, I would say to help
- 36:23you think through it. But given some of
- 36:25these, I would also say if you're on
- 36:26Ad ass, and especially if you're already using
- 36:29Ent for
- 36:31identity, this is probably something you wanna start
- 36:34thinking about doing. Or even start to think
- 36:36about, like, how you scope those things down
- 36:38and segment them to? I think... Some folks
- 36:41view,
- 36:42identity is, like, an all or nothing scenario.
- 36:45And, you know, so, like, all my users
- 36:47are in the con
- 36:49domain. Therefore
- 36:50everyone has to authenticate through 3 D efs?
- 36:52Well, maybe maybe not. Right? Like, you might
- 36:55want more security for, like, your admins and
- 36:57your admin accounts and maybe that actually requires,
- 37:00like, a different
- 37:02tenant with a different configuration and maybe the
- 37:04that stuff does go through Ad efs or
- 37:06it goes through some other
- 37:08security token service. Right? That can just sit
- 37:10out there as a relying party and and
- 37:12do what it needs to do. I live
- 37:14in that world for sure. I have multiple
- 37:17Pcs for my employer. Like, I have basically,
- 37:20like my prod identity. And then I have
- 37:23another, like, admin identity, and that's the thing
- 37:25that gets me into the admin stuff. But
- 37:28the admin stuff actually happens on, like, at
- 37:30this point, a dedicated machine. It flows through
- 37:34its own dedicated identity provider, like, all, all
- 37:36these different things. Like, it is truly, like,
- 37:39segmented.
- 37:40And I think that's kinda funny too. Like,
- 37:41that very much reminds me of, like, the
- 37:43old school worlds. We're like, hey, we used
- 37:45to have separate, like, user Ids and admin
- 37:47Ids and then for a while, we've... Floated
- 37:48back. And we said, well, why do you
- 37:50really need an admin id when you can
- 37:51just pi in and you can do all
- 37:52this other stuff. Right? And it turns out
- 37:54that III now live in a world where
- 37:56I still have separate Ids floated I still
- 37:58have to pi in, but when I pi
- 38:00in, I'm not only logged into my admin
- 38:02account, but then I'm still pi or doing,
- 38:04like, just in time,
- 38:06request or things like that. Even on that
- 38:08admin account for the additional layer that goes
- 38:11in there. It's all just very cyclical. Right?
- 38:13We always come back around.
- 38:15Yes.
- 38:16And then you set up different authentication or
- 38:18different Mfa options for your admin account that
- 38:21to make Mfa more secure for admin versus
- 38:24normal user and there's all. Kinds of things.
- 38:27And I've started doing some of that too.
- 38:29I've seen some of the security stuff, and
- 38:30I now have 2 accounts, my end and
- 38:321 has Pam it requires strong Mfa. My
- 38:35normal 1, not quite as.
- 38:37Not quite the same level of Mfa requirements.
- 38:41It's a thing. So, like, separate identities, separate
- 38:44devices.
- 38:45I saw the other day that
- 38:48it looks like Microsoft is position for, like,
- 38:51employees in China that they can only use
- 38:53iphones
- 38:54due to security threat. I saw that. So
- 38:57it's even coming down to potentially
- 39:00that point as well. Not only, like, do
- 39:02you have to use this identity in this
- 39:04thing? You also have to
- 39:07potentially use this device from this manufacturer, which
- 39:11is kind of funny as well, like, not
- 39:13like, funny sad, but more like, funny, like,
- 39:16That was come all the way back around
- 39:17to, like, you can use any device to
- 39:19access anything, and now we're into, like, oh,
- 39:22you must use this device kinda thing. Yeah.
- 39:24This was I've mean, here's a news article
- 39:26for it. I'm sure there's a better 1
- 39:27out here because I think this came from
- 39:29somewhere else. But Msn... Yeah. Microsoft employees in
- 39:32China. Now have to use authentication apps installed
- 39:35exclusively on iphone devices. Part of Microsoft secure
- 39:39future initiative announced last year. We'll that 95
- 39:42Mac reports. 9 to 5 Mac has some...
- 39:45It's interesting what shows up on 9 to
- 39:465 Max sometimes go with that. So interesting.
- 39:50Lots more always
- 39:51always
- 39:53something new to talk about with security and
- 39:55authentication.
- 39:56You know, it's... Just keep on coming. With
- 39:58that,
- 39:59I have
- 40:00meetings, I actually have a presentation coming up.
- 40:03Ironically enough. I have a presentation like 2
- 40:05hours today, Scott. On Ad...
- 40:08Id. No. Id best practices
- 40:11or security best practices an Id. That is
- 40:13some I have to spit into like, Step
- 40:151 do Ad efs? What what which which
- 40:18way you lean in? No. My... Slide 1
- 40:19is turn on Mfa. Slide 2 is turn
- 40:22on Mfa. Slide 3 is... Turn on... No.
- 40:25Sounds about right. Yeah. No. Mfa,
- 40:28secure off,
- 40:29or anti phishing Mfa because I have also
- 40:32seen a lot of... Articles recently and how
- 40:34actually scar easily it is to bypass,
- 40:38certain M mfa methods. Oh, yeah. With the
- 40:41can't... It's it's not
- 40:43it's not called man in the middle, but
- 40:44it's essentially a man in the middle and
- 40:46stealing the session token and
- 40:49the need for the anti phishing
- 40:51Mfa. So I'm dying some about anti phishing
- 40:54Mfa, the guest access thing I talked about
- 40:57reviewing guests,
- 40:58how long they've been in there who has
- 41:00access. So Can't remember. And pull up my
- 41:02slides. We can turn this into a future
- 41:04podcast topic. Maybe, adjusting
- 41:07authentication methods. Yeah. Limits me your admin roles,
- 41:09some of the Pi stuff we talked about
- 41:11auditing and alerting.
- 41:12I might bring up, like, I'm borderline, like
- 41:15some of the global secure access stuff, senior
- 41:17best practice,
- 41:19maybe borderline,
- 41:20but
- 41:21beneficial from a security perspective, probably. So I
- 41:24have way more slides that I'm gonna cover
- 41:26so I may kinda just pick and choose
- 41:28through my slides as well as I. So
- 41:30that's the rest of my Friday. And with
- 41:31that, I'll let you go enjoy your Friday.
- 41:33Sam like a plan. Thank you, Ben. Alright.
- 41:36Thank you, and we will talk to you
- 41:38again soon.
- 41:41If you enjoyed the podcast, runs go leave
- 41:43us a 5 star rating in itunes. It
- 41:45helps to get the word out so more
- 41:46It pros can learn about Office 3 65
- 41:49in Azure.
- 41:50If you have any questions you want us
- 41:52to address on the show, or feedback about
- 41:54the show, feel free to reach out via
- 41:56our website, Twitter, or Facebook.
- 41:59Thanks again for listening and have a great
- 42:01day.
- 42:02On