Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Diagnose Team Dysfunction in Five Minutes
Transcript
- Lucas: Luna, I want to start with a question. When was the last time you sat through a team meeting and just knew — something was off? Not a bad meeting, not a boring meeting — something deeper. Luna: Oh, I've been in those. The kind where everyone talks but nothing moves. Or worse, where only two people talk and everyone else checks out. Lucas: Right. And as a first-time manager, that feeling is dangerous because you can't always articulate what's wrong. You know it's not working, but you don't have a framework to diagnose it. So I want to share a tool today that takes about five minutes and can tell you a lot about your team's underlying health. Luna: I'm listening. Five minutes sounds almost too easy. Lucas: It's called the team meeting audit. And the premise is simple: your weekly team meeting is the single best proxy for how your team actually operates. It's the one place where communication, decision-making, trust, and energy all collide. If you know what to look for, you can spot dysfunction before it metastasizes. Luna: So what are we looking at? Give me the dimensions. Lucas: Four dimensions. First: psychological safety. Do people feel safe to disagree, ask stupid questions, or push back on a plan? Second: decision clarity. By the end of the meeting, does everyone know what was decided and who owns what? Third: action ownership. Are there clear owners and deadlines for each action item, or does stuff fall through the cracks? Fourth: energy. Is the room — or the Zoom — energized, or is it a dead zone? Luna: And you score each one on a scale? Lucas: Exactly. One to ten. If any dimension dips below a six, that's a red flag. And if two or more are below six, you've got a systemic issue. I've run this with about twenty managers over the past year, and the pattern is striking. Luna: What's the most common low scorer? Lucas: Psychological safety. Hands down. Most managers think their team is open, but when you actually score the meeting, you realize that people self-censor. They nod along, then complain in Slack later. That's a classic sign. Luna: That resonates. I had a manager once who said 'I want your honest feedback' but then shot down every suggestion. After three meetings, nobody said anything real. The meeting became a monologue. Lucas: Exactly. And the audit would catch that. But here's the thing — a single meeting snapshot isn't perfect. So I want to address the obvious pushback: one meeting might not be representative. Maybe it's a weird week, or someone's having a bad day. Luna: That was my first thought. A bad meeting doesn't mean a dysfunctional team. Lucas: Fair. But here's the counter: if you run the audit three weeks in a row and the scores are consistently low, that's not noise, that's signal. And even one bad meeting can be instructive. If you see a red flag, you investigate. You ask. You don't assume it's a fluke. Luna: So the audit is a starting point, not a diagnosis. Lucas: Exactly. It's a diagnostic tool to tell you where to look deeper. And I've seen it work in practice. Let me give you a real example. A few months ago, I worked with a VP of Engineering at a mid-stage SaaS company — about 80 people. He was frustrated because his team kept missing deadlines. He thought it was an execution problem. He ran the audit on his weekly staff meeting. Luna: And? Lucas: Psychological safety scored a four. Decision clarity scored a five. Action ownership a six. Energy a three. The only thing that scored high was... nothing, really. So we dug in. What we found was that the VP had a habit of asking for opinions but then overriding them. Not maliciously — he just had strong views. But his team learned that it wasn't safe to disagree. So they stopped bringing up risks. They said yes to everything. And then they couldn't deliver. Luna: Classic. The leader creates the pattern without realizing it. Lucas: Right. So the fix wasn't a new project management tool or a deadline reminder. It was changing how the meeting ran. We redesigned the agenda: the first ten minutes were a round-robin where each person shared one thing they were unsure about. No judgment. Then decisions were explicitly captured on a shared doc with owners and due dates. And the VP committed to not making a decision in the meeting unless everyone had spoken first. Luna: And did it work? Lucas: Three weeks later, they reran the audit. Psychological safety went from a four to a seven. Decision clarity hit an eight. Energy went from three to six. And the deadlines started getting met. Not because people worked harder, but because they finally felt safe enough to say 'we can't do that in two weeks' before they committed. Luna: That's a great example. It also shows that the audit isn't just about measuring — it's about intervening. You can use the scores to guide what you change. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the real power. It gives you a shared language. You can say to your team, 'Hey, our psychological safety score was low last week. What's one thing we could do differently to make it feel safer?' That's a much better conversation than 'Our meetings are broken, let's fix them.' Luna: I also like that it's quick. A lot of management frameworks feel like homework. This is something you can literally do in the five minutes after a meeting. Lucas: That's by design. I wanted something that a first-time manager could actually use without a binder. And if you're a listener who wants to try it, I'd challenge you: at your next team meeting, keep the four dimensions in mind. After the meeting, rate each one. Don't overthink it. Just trust your gut. Then ask yourself: what's the lowest score, and what's one thing I can do about it? Luna: Before we go deeper, Lucas, I want to pause for a second. We talk a lot on this show about practical tools for managers, and we've never run ads. That's a deliberate choice. We want these episodes to be useful — not interrupted. Lucas: Yeah, and we hear from listeners that they appreciate that. If you've gotten value from the show and want to support that choice, the simplest way is to head to buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No strings, no perks — just knowing that the show stays ad-free. Means a lot. Luna: Okay, back to the audit. One thing I'm curious about: you mentioned energy as a dimension. How do you score that objectively? Energy feels subjective. Lucas: It is subjective, but that's okay. The point isn't perfect objectivity — it's consistency. If you score energy a six this week and a four next week, that's a data point. You can ask yourself: what changed? Maybe the meeting was at 4 PM on a Friday, or maybe a tough topic drained the room. The score itself is less important than the trend. Luna: So you're looking for patterns over time, not a single grade. Lucas: Exactly. And if energy is consistently low, that's a symptom. It could mean the meeting is too long, too one-sided, or people are burned out. The audit flags it, and then you explore. Luna: What about teams that are remote or hybrid? Does the audit still work? Lucas: Yes, but you have to adjust. Psychological safety is harder to read on video. People might be muted, cameras off, or multitasking. So for remote teams, I'd add a fifth dimension: engagement. Are people actively participating, or are they just present? You can track things like how many people speak, how many use the chat, or how many ask questions. Luna: That makes sense. In a physical room, you can see body language. On Zoom, you have to look harder. Lucas: Right. And the fix might be structural. For example, one remote team I worked with started using a 'round robin' format where each person had to share one update. It forced participation. Their engagement score went up, and so did psychological safety. Luna: So the audit isn't just for in-person teams. It's a framework that adapts. Lucas: Exactly. The core idea is the same: use the meeting as a diagnostic. And the most important thing is to share the results with your team. Don't keep it a secret. Say, 'Here's what I noticed. What do you think?' That alone builds trust. Luna: That's a great point. The audit becomes a tool for transparency, not just measurement. Lucas: And that transparency is what actually drives improvement. Because when the team sees the scores and talks about what's behind them, they own the solution. The manager doesn't have to be the hero. Luna: Alright, let's wrap with a concrete challenge for listeners. What's the one thing they should do this week? Lucas: Run the audit on your next team meeting. Right after it ends, take two minutes to score each dimension on a scale of one to ten. Write it down. Then next week, do it again. See if there's a pattern. And if any dimension is below a six, have a conversation with your team about it. Ask them: 'What's one thing we could change?' You might be surprised at what you learn. Luna: I'm going to try it on my next team meeting. I already suspect my psychological safety score might be lower than I'd like. Lucas: Then it's working. That's the whole point. Thanks for the conversation, Luna. Luna: Thanks, Lucas. See everyone next week.