Latest / Politics with Paul / A Project to Revolutionize Holding Government Accountable? w/ Ramon Perez | Politics with Paul #83
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Rader, and we have another great guest today.
- 0:10And for such episodes, I always add a disclaimer that I do not take a stance for or
- 0:15against a guest's political views or groups they support, but these episodes are for
- 0:18anybody of any political belief, and our guest runs a nonpartisan organization anyway.
- 0:24But government can feel and often is obscure and difficult to really keep tabs on.
- 0:30And that's not just because information can be hard or time consuming to research or we don't
- 0:36know where to look, but because officials, candidates and interest groups can also
- 0:40purposely make things harder to understand and hinder our ability to tell government officials
- 0:46what we want.
- 0:47And hampering government transparency and accountability is a major challenge in today's
- 0:52politics.
- 0:53But what if there is a better, easier way to hold government more accountable and make it
- 1:00more transparent?
- 1:01Well, that's where today's guest Ramon Perez comes in.
- 1:05Ramon is the executive director of the Digital Democracy Project, DDP, a mobile voting app and
- 1:11online accountability system that not only tells you how legislators vote on bills, but
- 1:16allows you, the citizen, to tell legislators how you want them to vote.
- 1:23He also concurrently serves as of AI solutions for Elder Research and the executive director
- 1:29of Rank My Vote Florida.
- 1:31And Ramon is also a military veteran, reaching the rank of captain in the US Air Force and
- 1:36major in the US Air Force Reserve.
- 1:38So now, let's get some insights into this digital democracy project and the wider field
- 1:44of government accountability and transparency.
- 1:46Please welcome Ramon Perez to the show.
- 1:49Ramon, thank you for being here.
- 1:51How are you?
- 1:51And also, thank you very much for your military service.
- 1:54Well, thank you for having me, Paul.
- 1:55I really do appreciate being on the show.
- 1:58And as fellow Floridian, you know, it's always good to talk to another Florida boy.
- 2:04Oh, yeah.
- 2:04Absolutely.
- 2:05Yeah.
- 2:05I I always get excited whenever I come across somebody in this work that's a fellow for
- 2:10Floridian.
- 2:10But let's I like to get back to the very beginning of things with my guests.
- 2:15So, let's get back to the work.
- 2:17Before all the work you are doing now, what got you involved in efforts in the first place to
- 2:22improve government transparency and accountability?
- 2:26I think I really Well, as you mentioned, I was a military officer for many years.
- 2:32Served in combat zones in Afghanistan, Iraq, South America.
- 2:37I did a tour in Korea.
- 2:39And I always saw service as just an important part of my life.
- 2:44I came from a military family as well.
- 2:47And after I left the military, I think that a big catalyst for me was probably January 6
- 2:55because it felt like you had a large group of people who were so feeling so dispossessed and
- 3:05feeling that the government was no longer accountable that they took it upon themselves
- 3:10to to basically storm the capital.
- 3:12And and I think I was a bit shocked by the whole scene, the whole experience because for
- 3:19me, I felt like we'd spent the last twenty some years trying to build democracies in The Middle
- 3:28East, and here we were watching it under strain in our own country, and that that really hurts,
- 3:36I think for somebody who's actually lost friends in in other parts of the world, it's
- 3:40it's hard to it's hard to swallow the feeling like we couldn't even talk to each other
- 3:46anymore.
- 3:46I think I saw I felt a similar way.
- 3:48Well, like, if you remember the situation in in Portland, Oregon during Black Lives Matter and
- 3:53COVID and and basically the city government just sort of evaporated and and let sort of an
- 3:59anarchist group, if you will, take over control of the city.
- 4:02And I had I visited Portland in 2021, and I was really quite shocked at what I saw there.
- 4:10It was reminiscent of a lot of war torn places I'd been to.
- 4:15It bombed out, boarded up, just in a complete state of disrepair.
- 4:19And I think it's told me that there is something deep that needs to be addressed in
- 4:25the structural problems that we have in our government, in this feeling that people have
- 4:29that the system is no longer accountable to them, and they have no say in the process and
- 4:34they're resorting to sort of violent activities or overthrow as their frustrations become
- 4:43insurmountable.
- 4:44Yeah.
- 4:44I I feel like, obviously, for me as a regular citizen, I was never cut out from the military.
- 4:49So I always have great respect for guys like you who get into that line of work.
- 4:54But, you know, especially as a veteran more so than just a regular citizen seeing, you know,
- 4:59you're fighting for all these freedoms that we have here at home and then, you know, sometimes
- 5:03feels like they're still under siege in some ways.
- 5:06And obviously, some of these are obviously, these you bring up January 6 and Portland.
- 5:13Obviously, that is not the way to handle things, but it does shine a light on the fact
- 5:18that we do have a serious issue with government transparency and accountability.
- 5:22That's Right.
- 5:23Even though, you know, ours where we think the source of that lack of transparency and
- 5:28accountability can be different, there is oddly enough sort of a unifying theme where people
- 5:34across the political spectrum feel like government is not working for them.
- 5:38Yeah.
- 5:39I think that's right.
- 5:40But, yeah, it's something that's particularly important to me too.
- 5:45And then, of course, for you with the work you're doing and being a military veteran, I
- 5:49imagine it's exponentially more important to you.
- 5:52So it's I can really appreciate why you came to do this work you're doing now.
- 5:58So let's go ahead and get into more of the specific work that you're doing now.
- 6:03So the Digital Democracy Project, I briefly described it in the intro, but obviously like
- 6:08to hear it in your own words.
- 6:10So why was it founded and how did you come to join it, and what exactly does Digital
- 6:15Democracy Project do?
- 6:17Yeah, the basic idea is that we're trying to use disruptive technology to give people back
- 6:22more control over their government.
- 6:23Because I've been now working in AI and machine learning for the last dozen years, having left
- 6:30active duty, I got connected to people working in various parts of the technology world, if
- 6:37you will, in blockchain and biometrics and cryptography, mobile authentication, things
- 6:42like this.
- 6:43Got introduced to the CEO of Voatz, and Voatz makes mobile voting software for military
- 6:51voters overseas to vote from their phone when it's very difficult to get an absentee ballot
- 6:56through the mail.
- 6:57And as you can imagine, if you're in a submarine under the water, it's kind of tough
- 7:01to get mail in Or and in, you know, the Horn Of Africa, you know, in a forward deployed
- 7:06location.
- 7:07I mean, it's tough to vote.
- 7:09And I've been in that situation myself.
- 7:10So I had immediately resonated with this particular use case.
- 7:15But I said, look, if you can securely guarantee that somebody is a voter because you you match
- 7:22their photo ID against the selfie scan, you find them on the voter file, you know they're a
- 7:26US citizen, you know they're a resident of the state, you have this whole blockchain back in
- 7:32so that a a vote token is cast.
- 7:34So you guarantee that a vote can't be manipulated.
- 7:37The vote that's cast is the vote that's countered countered in all this cryptography
- 7:41process in the middle to protect the secret ballot so the voter still has the right to
- 7:45privacy over their secret ballot.
- 7:47If you could do all of those things to let people vote from their phones, then why should
- 7:51we have to wait every four years, you know, to to engage or every, you know, two years with
- 7:56congressional to engage in our government?
- 7:59Why shouldn't we be able to build a system that's like the Netflix of government where
- 8:03government is on demand, and I can engage in government all the time.
- 8:06So that was the basic idea that we developed, and and we we stood up Digital Democracy
- 8:11Project, went into beta testing in 2022.
- 8:15But the premise is this, is we're using real mobile voting software that's being used in
- 8:20real elections in different parts of The United States and Canada right now.
- 8:23But we're loading bills that are being debated as they're going through the process in the
- 8:28legislative chamber so that people can weigh in on, you know, read the bills for themselves and
- 8:35make an informed decision on where they stand on that policy and weigh in using this election
- 8:40software, but we provide the results to their legislators in real time as the legislative
- 8:46chambers are proceeding with their debates so that so that our representatives can see what
- 8:51their districts want.
- 8:52They can trust that that's somebody who's actually in their district because we verify
- 8:55people against the voter file, and that they can use that to make a difficult decision in
- 9:01the capital so that they can best represent their districts.
- 9:05And at the end of the session, what we do is we compare what do the voters want in the app with
- 9:10what do the legislators do on the floor of the chamber so that the voters can actually see,
- 9:14well, okay, we provided our input.
- 9:18We took the time and energy to educate ourselves on these topics and let our
- 9:21legislators know how we what we believe, But now we want some accountability in return for
- 9:26our our efforts.
- 9:27Right?
- 9:27So we wanna be able to see how often are they doing what the district wanted.
- 9:31And every legislator gets a scorecard that compares over the over the all the bills that
- 9:36we've carried, which is hundreds of bills at this point for the Florida legislature.
- 9:40All the bills we've carried, what the voters wanted, what the legislators did, and how often
- 9:44they match.
- 9:44And for a single bill, you'd say, okay.
- 9:46Well, if a legislator goes against their district, you know, whatever.
- 9:50No big deal.
- 9:50It's one bill out of many.
- 9:51But over the course of a long time, you start to get a trend, and you'll start to see
- 9:56legislators separate from each other to see who's the most responsive.
- 10:00What we're ultimately after here is that voters can go to the polling place in November with
- 10:07some concrete data to use to decide, do I wanna reelect this person, or do I wanna give their
- 10:12competitor a chance to to maybe better represent me than the current guy who's in
- 10:17office?
- 10:18So that's the basic idea of what we're after here.
- 10:21We set it up as a nonprofit because we we want it to be clear that we don't take a stake.
- 10:25We're just building a platform.
- 10:27We don't have a position on these policies, and we don't put our thumb on the scales.
- 10:30We don't have, you know, some investor who's got some vested interest in whatever policy
- 10:35trying to manipulate data or sell people's data or sell the entire organization to Google or
- 10:41Facebook or whoever.
- 10:42So we intentionally established this as as a public service by being a nonprofit and by also
- 10:51using high grade, highly secure mobile software to do this in a way that we can have some
- 10:57veracity in the results.
- 10:59That is so fascinating.
- 11:00I mean, there's so many things I wish I could I could address that and what you just said
- 11:05there.
- 11:05Right?
- 11:05I think it's also really cool that you basically you already addressed a couple of, I
- 11:11imagine, like, immediate trying to think of pushbacks.
- 11:14I can't think of the exact word.
- 11:15But Yeah.
- 11:16Some of my critiques.
- 11:18Yeah.
- 11:18But they might say, oh, well, how long does it take for these legislators to see the
- 11:22information?
- 11:22You said it's it's updated in real time.
- 11:24And Mhmm.
- 11:26It's and is it secure?
- 11:28Is it easily manipulated?
- 11:29Well, no.
- 11:29Because of all these reasons.
- 11:31This information is out there already, but it's so hard and so time consuming to find all that
- 11:36information.
- 11:37You had to go all these websites, say, okay.
- 11:39How did they vote on this?
- 11:40But then also, you need to know, well, what does this bill say?
- 11:43Because these bills can be very Yes.
- 11:46Dense.
- 11:47Yes.
- 11:47And and we all have these different heuristics we use to try to think about who we're going to
- 11:53vote for in these polls.
- 11:54And a lot of times, we just fall back on, well, what's their party?
- 11:57Or Exactly.
- 11:58Are they an incumbent?
- 11:59And but this kind of thing can really change the game and say, well, no.
- 12:03All those specific bills you really wanted, well, here's what they voted on.
- 12:07And, you know, they can look at that easily regardless of what their political views are.
- 12:12So I think that's that's really incredible.
- 12:15Anything anything that makes you know, not not just for the sake of transparency and
- 12:18accountability, but just that anything that closes that ballot information gap is is
- 12:23something that automatically intrigues me.
- 12:25So that's that's really fantastic work to hear about.
- 12:28But Absolutely.
- 12:30I
- 12:30Oh, yeah.
- 12:30Go
- 12:31ahead.
- 12:31Paul, I wanna I wanna also echo a couple things that you just said because we we do work with
- 12:36another great group called Open States, which is an initiative to scrape the content of all
- 12:43the state legislative websites so you can actually get vote records on every bill.
- 12:49They've been a a fantastic partner, and that's how we you know, because you say you can go to
- 12:54the Florida senate website.
- 12:55You can go to the Florida house house, you know, .gov.
- 12:58The the challenge is that you have to sift through a mountain of data to actually figure
- 13:04out how your legislator voted on a specific bill.
- 13:07That's it's not trivial.
- 13:10The other thing too is that we're fortunate that we're we're at this you know, we've got
- 13:15this incredibly powerful new technology that we've been really been leaning on called AI,
- 13:20and it has the ability to take these complex pieces of legislation and really break it down
- 13:25into its component parts and make it understandable.
- 13:29So we've got a chatbot on our website where you can actually we we preload all the bill text
- 13:35itself so that if you go and you look at a specific bill and you want more details about
- 13:40the legislative language, you could read through the thousand pages if you want.
- 13:45We do provide links to the source, you know, so you can go to the Florida Senate.
- 13:48But we prefetch all that data and load it into the system so that the chatbot can actually
- 13:54say, yeah.
- 13:55In this particular section, you know, you can see how it affects privacy rights or you can
- 14:00see how it affects homeowners associations, whatever the case.
- 14:03And you can get the level of detail and understanding that you desire that's beyond
- 14:08just the summary and the surface level understanding.
- 14:11So AI has been a enormous game changer in just lowering that information barrier that a lot of
- 14:16people have because they'll often say to me, well, I hire a representative to really dig
- 14:22into the details so I don't have to.
- 14:24Basically, this person is is supposed to be really good at understanding these policies.
- 14:29And what I try to let people know is that now we have the technology so that you can become
- 14:34much more of an expert than you realized.
- 14:36And one of the things you gotta realize too, somebody like you, Paul, who's actually worked
- 14:40in government for quite a while, a lot of legislators don't actually read the bills.
- 14:44Like, they just don't.
- 14:46Yeah.
- 14:47There's Yeah.
- 14:48So many of them that they don't 2,000 bills get drafted in the Florida Legislature every year.
- 14:53Of those, maybe 50 will get a vote on the floor.
- 14:56They can't read all they're not gonna stay current on everything anyway.
- 15:00And they're so short staffed, most of them are sharing legislative assistance, so they don't
- 15:05even necessarily have enough staff to deal with the level of technical complexity.
- 15:09So a lot of lobbyists end up writing the bills, and people just vote on party lines for the
- 15:13most part.
- 15:14So I try to let people know that that barrier to entry is not as high as you believe it is.
- 15:21That's awesome.
- 15:22You bringing it up just made me think, shameless plug for one of the other things I do
- 15:26is I also, and I got to do this last year for a public affairs organization, I have a webinar I
- 15:33do about basically how to most effectively read legislation, especially if you're working for a
- 15:40a client in particular or if you wanna know it for yourself and your organization, how you
- 15:44read these bills and what are the what are the things that you need to know about when you're
- 15:50reading bills, like how people have interpreted them in the past and stuff like that.
- 15:54So that's something that automatically intrigues me too.
- 15:56And and any again, anything to make these things more accessible is something that
- 16:01automatically catches my attention.
- 16:03Mhmm.
- 16:04Course, it's not just about the idea of DDP and its noble ideals.
- 16:08People must actually use it.
- 16:10So what are some of the statistics on the usage of DDP?
- 16:13Whether it's how many people used it, how many states it's in, and what are some who are some
- 16:18noble notable political figures and organizations across the political spectrum
- 16:23that can vouch for digital democracy project?
- 16:27Yeah.
- 16:28So we've verified about 24,000 people against a voter file with photo ID match, about a 120,000
- 16:34or so ballots cast so far.
- 16:36A ballot in this case would be somebody says, I agree with this piece of legislation or I
- 16:41disagree with this piece of legislation.
- 16:43Right?
- 16:43So about a 120,000 of those cast so far.
- 16:46We've had if you if you go on digitaldemocracyproject.org and look at our
- 16:50supporters list, you'll see that there are legislators and candidates across the political
- 16:56spectrum.
- 16:56We had early support from Republicans in the legislature who actually drafted a and got a
- 17:03bipartisan appropriations request pushed through the legislative process.
- 17:08And so sponsored by a gentleman named Keith Perry, was a senior senator out of Ocala, Jim
- 17:13Mooney, who was a Republican out of the Keys, and then and then Rita Harris, was a junior
- 17:19Democrat out of Central Florida, and senator Torres, was a senior Democratic senator out of
- 17:24out of Central Florida as well.
- 17:26And so they they worked across the aisle and got an appropriation through the entire budget
- 17:32process.
- 17:32And I think it was important to us to see that they found, for one, that this was valuable to
- 17:39them as sitting legislators because for them, it's kinda like free public polling.
- 17:43They spend 30 to $50 to poll their districts, so they're not gonna do that every year, and
- 17:49they're certainly not gonna do it on every bill.
- 17:51They're gonna do it maybe once in an election cycle to get a sense from their district of
- 17:55what people's top three priorities are by running a poll or two polls or something like
- 18:00that.
- 18:00And because that's typically all they can afford to do with their campaign funds at the
- 18:05state house level or the state senate level.
- 18:07So they saw the value just as a way to keep the finger on the pulse of their district.
- 18:12And really, it's just a question of getting enough people within their district to actually
- 18:17use it.
- 18:18So you'll see, you know, we've had a few dozen now of sitting legislators or candidates
- 18:24endorse the project saying to their districts, Hey, this is a tool you can use to hear from
- 18:29me, and I will be taking this as input when I go to Tallahassee.
- 18:33We had a gentleman go even a step further who's running for US House in Florida's 11th
- 18:38District, a guy named Dan Williams who's running for congress, on the premise of going
- 18:43even further and saying, I'll actually vote the way the district tells me to vote on every bill
- 18:48bill that comes through the process in in DC.
- 18:52So you'll I will be almost he's a college professor who's a technologist himself who
- 18:57teaches computer science in a university setting.
- 19:00He said, okay.
- 19:01My job is now no longer to make the decision for you.
- 19:04It's to explain the legislation, give you as much information as possible, and present both
- 19:09sides factually, accurately as possible.
- 19:11Then I'll tell you what my opinion is on what you should do, but ultimately, then I'll leave
- 19:16it to the voters.
- 19:16The voters will vote in the app, and then I will then take what the voters tell me, and
- 19:20that's how I'll vote in congress.
- 19:22And I thought that was that's wild.
- 19:24Like, mean, that's way even further than what we had envisioned, but it's super cool as an
- 19:29idea towards more of a direct democracy, participatory democracy.
- 19:34You know, it's somewhere on the spectrum of which which what legislators which legislators
- 19:40sort of like this idea, which ones think it's crazy.
- 19:44I mean, I've been thrown out of the offices of both Democrats and Republicans, so I carry that
- 19:48as a badge of honor.
- 19:50So,
- 19:52you know, I think it just depends on the individual and their perceptions about their
- 19:56role as a representative and what are their responsibilities and who are they accountable
- 20:00to.
- 20:01And I think that's a really good example of this, I forget the exact terms for these ideas,
- 20:10but how when we talk about people representing you in office, there's this dichotomy between
- 20:17should they just vote basically how their constituents tell them or how or should they
- 20:24really vote how they really feel like like like, is their job to vote just according to
- 20:29what their constituents tell them, or do they have to sort of give themselves a level of
- 20:35conscience that says, I truly believe this is the way to go even if the electorate doesn't
- 20:41agree.
- 20:41I think that's kind of a really interesting example of that kind of philosophical tug, if
- 20:46that makes sense.
- 20:47But nonetheless, that's a really intriguing way to see somebody, you know, go about that on the
- 20:54campaign trail.
- 20:55But let's just say that somebody sees they hear what digital democracy project's all about,
- 21:01like, okay, great.
- 21:02They see the statistics, they're like, okay, yeah, that worked for them, but what about for
- 21:06me?
- 21:06So I know you kind of already talked about this, but maybe, I don't know, one or two more
- 21:13key examples of specific instances where DDP has helped make government officials more
- 21:19transparent and accountable?
- 21:21Well, I think it's I think it's okay.
- 21:25So if you recall, there was a special election in Central Florida in 2023 where Tom Keene
- 21:34actually flipped a district.
- 21:36Yes.
- 21:36So he actually was the first to endorse Digital Democracy Project in his primary, and he was
- 21:42not the party favorite in that primary.
- 21:46Sort of the party had a different perception of who they were gonna go with, and he said, Well,
- 21:52no.
- 21:52I wanna use this technology to be more accountable to voters, and then carried that as
- 21:56part of the campaign message, talked about it at the doors, and it resonated with a lot of
- 22:01people who feel the sense of being shut out of the process.
- 22:06And so he had a surprise victory in that primary and then ultimately went on to to flip
- 22:14the seat in 2023 in an off year off cycle election.
- 22:19Now so I think from from that standpoint, I think it would it became clear to us that the
- 22:25demand is obvious amongst voters, that voters wanted a better way, a more accountable way to
- 22:31have a say in the government.
- 22:33Once he was in Tallahassee, he actually did use the results in the app to inform his decision,
- 22:37especially because he was elected in a special election where he didn't come in with the with
- 22:43the the junior class and go through the process like a typical sitting legislator.
- 22:48He came in a week into the session.
- 22:50So he had to, like, hit the ground running and try to get caught up on all this legislation.
- 22:55Didn't even have a staff staff assigned yet or anything.
- 22:59So, you know, that I thought was a a really interesting use case where he was able to kind
- 23:03of get instant polling from his district that was helpful in in informing his decisions in
- 23:09Tallahassee right away.
- 23:11So I think that was the most exciting example for us of seeing it in action.
- 23:16And now now it's just a matter of, okay.
- 23:19Well, how do we scale it up?
- 23:20How do we go from 24,000 verified voters to 240,000 to 2,400,000 to 240,000,000?
- 23:28You know, we need to be at the point where this is this basically replaces the need to call
- 23:34your congressman's switchboard or send them an email.
- 23:37I mean, Paul, you know, you've spent enough time in Tallahassee.
- 23:39I I sit with legislators sometime.
- 23:41You look at their inbox, it is almost all astroturf campaigns of people filling out forms
- 23:47on a website.
- 23:48They can't verify that these people actually live in their district.
- 23:52They mostly just use I mean, I've I've been kinda shocked, honestly.
- 23:56Mostly, it's like email filtering on a Microsoft Outlook inbox to put to automatically
- 24:02just dump emails into folders by topics.
- 24:06Like, it's crazy.
- 24:07And most of that gets ignored because there's no veracity.
- 24:11And now because a lot of AI generated emails are flooding their inboxes, it's accelerated
- 24:16this problem.
- 24:17So for legislators, I think some of the staff of the house speaker, I think it was Paul
- 24:24Renner's staff, told me they get, like, 1,200 emails a day.
- 24:27So how do you even deal with that volume?
- 24:31I mean, the staff can't even keep up with it.
- 24:34And their full that's their, like, full time job is constituent engagement.
- 24:39It's it's it's a tough problem.
- 24:42So I think putting the verification on the front end is really valuable to legislators.
- 24:48I I just think we need to get to the point where it can replace the the switchboard.
- 24:54It can replace the email inbox simply because it's it's just a it's a more modern mechanism
- 25:00for engaging with your legislator.
- 25:02And that's kind of another front of this issue with election security.
- 25:06You just talked about how AI, and obviously we'll talk a bit more about that with your work
- 25:10in AI in general, just how much this is really wreaking havoc on the process.
- 25:16You don't know if these, like you said, if these emails are coming from legitimate people,
- 25:22are these even real voters?
- 25:24And there's all these other things.
- 25:25And then you gotta figure out how to sift through, okay, is this legitimate
- 25:30correspondence?
- 25:31And then, you know, sometimes you might think you're listening to your actual constituents,
- 25:36but you find out it's actually a bot, and then you actually don't do what your constituents
- 25:41want you to do.
- 25:42And it's just obviously, it just makes things a lot messier than they are now.
- 25:46So I I definitely wanna see what DDP is able to do in that regard.
- 25:50And something else with that I I really intrigued to hear you talk about with Digital
- 25:56Democracy Project.
- 25:57Something we mentioned in our correspondence was about this issue of participation versus
- 26:02apathy.
- 26:03And I've talked about it on several podcast episodes, especially, and I've written about it
- 26:08before.
- 26:08The big thing I stress in my work is how apathy is, while understandable to some extent, it's
- 26:15also a contributor to a lot of the problems we see.
- 26:18So how does DDP help tackle this problem of political apathy?
- 26:25Right.
- 26:25I think that if we look at the source of apathy, in my mind, the smoking gun is
- 26:30gerrymandering because the district boundaries have been drawn in such a way that actually
- 26:36intentionally carves out a lot of people from the process.
- 26:41Most legislators don't really, for all intents and purposes, they don't need to represent
- 26:46their districts.
- 26:47What they need to do is represent the interests of the eight to 10% of voters who will vote in
- 26:52a primary because their fear of losing a primary challenge is the only thing that keeps
- 26:59them accountable currently.
- 27:01Because if you look at 2024, for example, in Florida, 94% of legislative districts were
- 27:08completely uncompetitive.
- 27:10It not within a five percentage point margin of victory because they're so heavily blue or so
- 27:15heavily red in the way that they're drawn that there really aren't a lot of purple districts
- 27:19left.
- 27:20And we're gonna go through another round of that this session to make the federal districts
- 27:25even more gerrymandered potentially.
- 27:28Yeah.
- 27:28So the reason voters become apathetic is because they can sense they don't exactly know
- 27:34why it happens, but they get the feeling that nobody listens to them because nobody's
- 27:40knocking on their doors.
- 27:42Nobody's calling them.
- 27:43If you're not a primary voter, you actually don't hear from most election campaigns.
- 27:47You know?
- 27:47By the time the general rolls around, it's mostly locked up.
- 27:51So most legislator or most candidates aren't gonna spend a lot of campaign funds turning out
- 27:56people who are not in their core, you know, group.
- 28:00What they wanna do is win their primary by focusing on this tiny sliver of the market, if
- 28:06you will, wherein those people get 10 to 12 pieces of literature and dozens and dozens of
- 28:11phone calls and text messages because they're primary voters, but then come general election
- 28:16time, it's just to get out the vote amongst those people.
- 28:19Just make sure you turn out your base and then you'll you're way above the line because
- 28:25districts are so heavily unbalanced.
- 28:27So I think for a lot of people, a lot of legislators don't hold town halls.
- 28:32You call their switchboard.
- 28:33It's it's you get a voice mail.
- 28:35You send an email.
- 28:36You get a response.
- 28:37I just think that people feel like they are speaking into a black hole most of the time.
- 28:43And that's in a lot of ways by design.
- 28:46Yeah.
- 28:46That's that's another, you know, it's it's very not entirely overlapping, but still a core part
- 28:54of that accountability is that level of of representativeness that we just, you know, we
- 29:00don't see.
- 29:00And like you said, with primaries are really only they're only really accountable to, like,
- 29:07eight to 10% of voters, which, yes, they are the most commonly or they they participate the
- 29:14most by far because they're the most ardent partisans.
- 29:16They tend to be more ideological, but you're not getting the entire electorate.
- 29:22You're certainly not getting all the voters that are, you know, general election voters,
- 29:26and then that's not even including people who are either irregular or nonvoters who might
- 29:31still want to get involved to some extent, but they just feel like it's a waste of time
- 29:37because they're not gonna be listened to anyway.
- 29:38So Mhmm.
- 29:39Yeah.
- 29:39You're you're only being accountable to a very small segment of the population, which is not I
- 29:45mean, that's not real accountability.
- 29:46That's just you trying to do whatever you need to to appease the people that are going to be
- 29:52the most, you know, ardent in their in their advocacy for whatever it is that they're
- 29:58they're supporting.
- 29:59But I I I that that's a another really fascinating piece of the puzzle that I can
- 30:07really appreciate you guys are tackling.
- 30:09So I I do wanna move a little bit out of DDP, not entirely out out of DDP because I mentioned
- 30:16your work as an AI consultant outside of the Digital Democracy Project, and you you've
- 30:21mentioned it several times, so I wanna get a little more on that, especially because there's
- 30:26a lot of apprehension, understandably so, about the improvements in artificial intelligence
- 30:32over the last few years and, you know, there's a lot of people that are unfortunately using it
- 30:37for nefarious purposes, but it also has the power to do a lot of good in the right hands.
- 30:41So how has your work with AI enhanced the cause of transparency and accountability in general?
- 30:48I know you kind of talked about it a little already, but maybe a little bit more in-depth.
- 30:52And does DDP also use AI as well?
- 30:55Yes, exactly.
- 30:56I understand people's people's apprehensions about AI.
- 30:59I mean, I do think this is a groundbreaking technology.
- 31:02This is a pivotal shift in human history in a lot of ways.
- 31:05I think it's very similar to the advent of electricity or powered flights or the
- 31:12locomotive.
- 31:13I think it's gonna be transformative.
- 31:16And I'm excited about it because I've seen the kind of good we can do with it already.
- 31:22I understand people's fears of job losses or of everything on the Internet is fake or AI
- 31:29generated.
- 31:29You can't trust anything.
- 31:31I do completely understand all of those apprehensions.
- 31:33What I would say is AI is a tool.
- 31:37Just like any other tool, it is ultimately down to the human behind it who is using it either
- 31:43for good or for ill.
- 31:44And we have just as much capacity to use it for good as we do to use it for ill.
- 31:49We just have to show people that it can be a tool that in the right hands and for the right
- 31:53purposes, it can deliver incredible value to us.
- 31:56And I think that's one of the reasons why we have tried to use it initially to lower that
- 32:02cognitive barrier of understanding legislation and public policy more generally.
- 32:09I don't know what's going on in congress.
- 32:11What are these people doing on my behalf?
- 32:12Or what's going on in Tallahassee?
- 32:14What are these people doing on my behalf?
- 32:15Well, now we have tools that make it so much easier and simpler not only to to understand
- 32:22the framing of the debate, what is it that they're talking about, what legislative policy
- 32:29are they actually proposing to solve the problem that they have that they have
- 32:32identified, and how did my legislator, personally, the guy who represents me, how did
- 32:38he vote or she vote on each of these topics?
- 32:42AI gives us the ability to answer a lot of these questions that took enormous amounts of
- 32:47time and energy to get to before.
- 32:49And another thing, Paul, you'll I mean, you've probably seen this happen over the course of
- 32:52your time as you spent in Tallahassee.
- 32:55It used to be every local paper would have a journalist in Tallahassee.
- 33:00So I grew up in South Florida reading the Sun Sentinel or the Miami Herald, and they would
- 33:04all have a Tallahassee correspondent, especially during this session, but even off
- 33:10cycle as well.
- 33:10And a lot of those journalists don't exist anymore.
- 33:14They just they don't a lot of the local papers don't have the funding to continue to do this.
- 33:19They were they rely on, you know, floridapolitics.com or or others bloggers or
- 33:25others to follow this, and then they report because they don't have the the money to have
- 33:29full time staff.
- 33:30I think these tools are in some ways replacing what used to be done by your local paper, who
- 33:37would report out what happened in the session.
- 33:40And now you're just not getting that.
- 33:41You're not getting the level of insight that you used to get, and so we have to figure out
- 33:44how to still continue to provide people with the education they need in order to make
- 33:48informed voting decisions.
- 33:51The last part you brought up about the newspapers is something that I think about from
- 33:56time to time, not just for the general issues that newspapers have been facing over the past
- 34:02couple decades or so.
- 34:03But one of the jobs I do is a is a nonpartisan political news aggregator, SAYFIE Review.
- 34:09I don't know if you're familiar with it.
- 34:11S a y f I e, named after Justin Safie, who's was a longtime communications guy.
- 34:17He worked actually for Jeb Bush when he was governor of Florida.
- 34:22And so I've been doing that for in a couple months, it'll be eleven years now.
- 34:26But I I do remember when we started it.
- 34:29And for for those who don't know, it's a nonpartisan political news aggregator, so every
- 34:33Monday through Thursday morning, and then sometimes I do it during the weekends too, get
- 34:37all the big news stories about Florida politics and and political figures all into this one
- 34:43place.
- 34:44I can actually put a a link to that in the show notes for safetyreview.com.
- 34:48But I anyways, I remember because because of what you brought up.
- 34:51I remember when I started out doing that in 2015 right after I graduated from University of
- 34:56South Florida, Goebbels.
- 34:57The all the newspapers or a lot of them were you know, now are most of them are consolidated
- 35:04within a few companies, especially Gannett has a lot of them.
- 35:08They own Tallahassee Democrat, Naples Daily News, Florida Today, Pensacola News Journal,
- 35:13whole bunch of other ones.
- 35:14I think they actually have your neck of the woods, Ocala Star Banner.
- 35:17And I remember Star Banner in particular back then just looks it wasn't under Gannett at that
- 35:24point, but it just looks.
- 35:26Even just the look of it, you could see how these websites look so completely different to
- 35:30what they are now.
- 35:32And a lot a lot of those correspondents, like you said, that used to be for the the each
- 35:38paper's own correspondent in Tallahassee.
- 35:41They they just kind of went by the wayside, and now everything's being more consolidated.
- 35:45And you see some of the same stories be shared amongst different newspapers, especially like
- 35:50Gannett's.
- 35:51You'll sometimes see the same article that's from Tallahassee Democrat.
- 35:53It might be in the Palm Beach Post or how Orlando Sentinel and South Florida Sun Sentinel
- 35:59are under the same umbrella.
- 36:01So you you do see a lot more of that consolidation and, you know, usage of similar
- 36:06or same correspondence, and they might have bureaus, but there's, so few papers that can do
- 36:12that now.
- 36:12It is a shame, but that is really yeah.
- 36:15What you just said makes me really hopeful for what AI can do.
- 36:18And who knows?
- 36:19Maybe you can actually start to have more of these local correspondents that can use AI to
- 36:24their advantage, especially with what Digital Democracy Project is doing and say what they
- 36:31can report on, what all of these local and federal elected officials are doing and bring
- 36:37it back to to the people there.
- 36:39So I I'm really looking forward to see what happens there.
- 36:44But one of the other things so go ahead.
- 36:46I'm glad you bring that up, Paul, because I've always had this vision where we could try to
- 36:50have digital democracy projects serve as a a mechanism for citizen journalists to add to the
- 36:56either to the debate or to the facts of the debate.
- 37:02Because I think that is a real challenge is how do we get good, high quality data?
- 37:08And as I mentioned, we use open states to scrape data from the Florida Senate, Florida
- 37:13House websites.
- 37:14But when you try to get to local level data, you wanna understand what's happening in in
- 37:18your municipality or in your county or in your school board, it gets even more difficult to
- 37:23get high quality data at the local level, not only about what policies are being considered,
- 37:27but how did my local city councilman vote on each of these policies, and does it represent
- 37:32the needs of the community, things like this.
- 37:34It gets tougher and tougher to do the more local you get.
- 37:37And so, having some mechanism for citizen journalism to fill in that gap, I think, would
- 37:45be a really important way for us to go forward because we do see this being incredibly
- 37:50valuable at a local level at some point once we can try to deal with the data quality
- 37:55challenges.
- 37:56Yeah.
- 37:56That's another great point, too.
- 37:58As obscure as some state governments can be, I mean, local governments, a lot of them, you can
- 38:02just forget about learning about them.
- 38:04I've I've sometimes whenever this kind of thing comes up, I, you know, tell somebody like I
- 38:10used to work for Ballipedia, and sometimes I've had to look for local government information
- 38:15and stuff.
- 38:16And I see some of these that some of these really local level places that are much smaller
- 38:21counties, and their their websites look like they're still made with, like, early two
- 38:27thousands geo cities.
- 38:28And they're just they're just know, unfortunately, there's, you know, it they're
- 38:34already so obscure, and it's sometimes hard for them to make their information so publicly
- 38:39available for people too.
- 38:41So, hopefully, you talking about that really makes me excited to see where DDP goes from
- 38:45here, which I will ask about shortly.
- 38:48But first, I did want to ask, because we've mentioned several times we're both Floridians.
- 38:52You are also the director of Rank My Vote Florida.
- 38:55Now, obviously, this is for ranked choice voting, but could you go a bit more into detail
- 38:59on what it is you're trying to do for people who are not entirely familiar with ranked
- 39:03choice voting or if there's something unique about this system that you're going for?
- 39:07And with the general increase in interest in ranked choice voting, how do you see that
- 39:12helping to improve government transparency and accountability?
- 39:16Right.
- 39:16So, ranked choice voting is effectively an instant runoff election.
- 39:20So, if you remember, we used to have runoff elections in Florida.
- 39:23I think the last governor who was elected in a runoff was probably Bob Graham, I want to say.
- 39:29So, it's been a while now.
- 39:30And, we got rid of runoff elections because the supervisor of elections found it really
- 39:36difficult to stage an entire new election thirty days after the general election.
- 39:42So as a reminder, basically, the way it works in a runoff is if if nobody gets above 50% of
- 39:47the election results, then the top two, whoever's you know, the top two vote getters go
- 39:53to a runoff where one of them has to get above 50% in the runoff, and then they win the seat.
- 39:58And what that does is it means that you can't have it helps prevent the spoiler effect where
- 40:06you have a small you know, you have a lot of candidates potentially.
- 40:10You have, obviously, your two main competing candidates, but you have third party
- 40:14candidates, independent candidates that siphon off votes from some of the primary two parties,
- 40:20and then people end up feeling like they don't wanna vote for an independent or a third party
- 40:27because they're afraid to take votes away from one of the primary parties.
- 40:30With a runoff election, that wasn't as much of a risk because you could vote your conscience.
- 40:35If you wanted to vote for an independent, you wanted to vote for a third party, you could do
- 40:38that, knowing that, you know, ultimately, if they don't win, then the top two vote getters
- 40:42would you'll have another chance in the runoff.
- 40:45But the supervisor of elections said, okay.
- 40:47It's very expensive.
- 40:48It's difficult to get the ballots all printed in time, so it's costing the state a lot of
- 40:53time and energy.
- 40:54Let's get rid of runoffs, let's go to plurality voting.
- 40:57But and that's the situation we find ourselves in where you could if you have a if you have
- 41:01you know, we've seen this happen with presidential primaries, but you could have a
- 41:06dozen people on the ballot ballot and somebody ends up winning with, you know, 25% of the
- 41:11vote.
- 41:12And, yeah, you gotta ask yourself, like, is that really the best representative for the
- 41:16entire populace?
- 41:17So, ranked choice voting is designed to deal with that problem in an instantaneous runoff so
- 41:23that the supervisor of elections don't have to do another whole election.
- 41:27Essentially, you do it at the time of the of the of the regular November election.
- 41:31So you just fill out a ballot where instead of just picking who you want to be the next
- 41:36governor, you would just rank the order of the people you like for governor.
- 41:42And then if the person you're most interested in doesn't win, second choice, you know, your
- 41:49vote goes to your second choice and on down the list.
- 41:52So it's, you know, it's effectively, like I say, it's just a way to bring the runoff
- 41:56process into the November election.
- 41:59I think it's an incredibly powerful structural reform, and it's been used in Ireland for a
- 42:05hundred years now.
- 42:06It's actually not even really that strange or different.
- 42:12It's just that the concept is you shouldn't be able to represent a district unless you have
- 42:19more than 50% of the vote.
- 42:21No one should be able to represent the district if they only can speak to a smaller sliver of
- 42:28the electorate.
- 42:29They should be able to speak to at least 50 plus percent of the electorate in order to
- 42:33represent that district.
- 42:35And so, ranked choice voting makes legislators more accountable to the entire district,
- 42:40solving this problem we were talking about earlier where they're currently right now only
- 42:44have to speak to a very hardened group of primary voters and they don't really need to
- 42:49speak to the entire electorate.
- 42:50I really am intrigued to see where ranked choice voting goes here because now it's
- 42:55becoming a bit more high profile.
- 42:57You know, you talk about New York City using it, Alaska having something similar a little or
- 43:03do they yeah.
- 43:04Because I think they have ranked choice.
- 43:06They do.
- 43:06General.
- 43:07They use top five.
- 43:08The way they do it is their primary is an open primary.
- 43:12Anybody can compete.
- 43:14Whoever the top five voters are, top five vote getters.
- 43:17And in their last one, I think they had like 40 people on the ballot and whittled it down to
- 43:21five.
- 43:22Then of those five, those go on to the general election and you can rank them in order one
- 43:26through five.
- 43:27That's right.
- 43:27That's what it was.
- 43:28That's a that's a more unique version of it.
- 43:30I know there's some different ways that people use or different places use ranked choice
- 43:34voting.
- 43:35Seeing where that goes is gonna be just just from a, you know, outside point of view, just
- 43:40be really intriguing to see where that goes.
- 43:43Probably should have asked this a little bit earlier, but that's okay.
- 43:45I assume for digital democracy project, this is not gonna be the pinnacle of what it's doing.
- 43:51So where do you see DDP in two, five, ten years down the road, especially in terms of where it
- 43:57is used and what it can do?
- 44:00Right, so we're, you know, our immediate goals this year are to get into all 50 state
- 44:04legislatures because we have, we started in Florida, this year we expanded, so we covered
- 44:10seven states this legislative cycle.
- 44:12Arizona legislature will be the one that wraps up in April, otherwise the rest of them end in
- 44:17March.
- 44:18But Arizona, Utah, Michigan, Massachusetts, Virginia, Washington, and Florida.
- 44:23But our goal will be by twenty twenty seven's legislative session, we're covering all 50
- 44:29states.
- 44:29We're also covering federal, so Florida voters can actually vote on what's happening in
- 44:34Congress right now and keep track of how their federal legislators are representing them.
- 44:40Our goal, we've already introduced the ability for all US citizens who are on the voter file
- 44:46in their respective state to get verified for federal congressional, you know, participation.
- 44:52But our goal would be, you know, 2027, it's all all 50 states plus federal.
- 44:58And then, like I said earlier, in three, five years, we would like to be at the local level.
- 45:03We really would like to be at the point where you can get a sense of what your county is
- 45:07doing or what your school board is doing and weigh in using this technology to have a say in
- 45:13that process.
- 45:14So, yes, I mean, that we have pretty ambitious goals, and we're a nonprofit.
- 45:19We're all actually volunteering our time to do this.
- 45:22So we see this as a real community effort.
- 45:25This is not something we think is gonna be solved by Silicon Valley.
- 45:28This is not something we think is gonna be solved by the two political parties.
- 45:32This is something that we think we have to solve as a community of concerned citizens who
- 45:38volunteer time and talent and money to make this work.
- 45:44You know, I know you said it's quite ambitious, but in these kinds of cases, I think you need a
- 45:49little bit of ambition, right?
- 45:50This is something that is so critically needed that it's it's it's it is nice to see somebody
- 45:57push for it and not be shying away from like, woah.
- 45:59Well, this is a very tall order because it is a tall order.
- 46:01It is Mhmm.
- 46:02Anything that tries to close the ballot information gap is a tall order, but, you know,
- 46:07having organizations try to tackle it is always a very heartwarming thing to see for lack of a
- 46:13better term.
- 46:15It is.
- 46:15It's a tall order, but I think it's made possible in a way by these technologies where
- 46:21we could not have done this five years ago.
- 46:23I'm just I'm excited about what is achievable now that was not achievable quite recently.
- 46:30Like, the the mobile voting software itself wouldn't have been possible without blockchain,
- 46:35without homomorphic encryption, end to end verification.
- 46:38All of those are very recent.
- 46:40And then AI, you know, everything we've seen in the last, what, four years since ChatGBT became
- 46:47the hottest thing.
- 46:48But our our ability not to and then, of course, what OpenStates has been able to do with with
- 46:53scraping data in a habitual way that's that's easy to consume.
- 46:57But all of this makes possible things that we just could not have imagined before.
- 47:03It it really it can make us it gives us a chance to reimagine a better version of
- 47:08democracy for the 20 and I think be hopeful about a system that is ultimately more
- 47:16accountable to the people.
- 47:18But we have to take the choice to reengage in our government, to acknowledge our own agency
- 47:25in this system, and not be passive bystanders to the problem that we find ourselves in.
- 47:32I would like to be able to have confidence that my son will grow up in a functioning
- 47:39representative democracy and not feel like it's gonna descend into either authoritarianism or
- 47:46anarchy or pick your boogeyman, but that he will have the same rights and responsibilities
- 47:54as a citizen that I grew up with.
- 47:56And I think that these types of technologies do give me hope that it is achievable, and it
- 48:02really is now down to the willpower of all of us as voters to make it happen.
- 48:07Absolutely.
- 48:08And you know what?
- 48:08Since we are coming up on time, I think this is a perfect segue into this next question.
- 48:14And and I always like to have at least one question in my interviews that are focused
- 48:19specifically on what people can practically do, any advice that they can actually act upon.
- 48:25So in general, what are two to three practical pieces of advice you'd give regular citizens so
- 48:32that they can help improve government accountability and transparency themselves?
- 48:38Well, look, I mean, I'm gonna give a shameless plug.
- 48:41I would love everybody listening to this to go and vote on any piece of legislation that you
- 48:45care about.
- 48:47Go on to digitaldemocracyproject.org and have your say.
- 48:50Get verified in the app, vote in the app, tell your legislator what you believe.
- 48:54We're actually still in the session right now, so you still have a few more days before the
- 48:59end of the Florida legislative session, but then Congress is ongoing.
- 49:02We're currently in an active debate right now on should we be at war with Iran?
- 49:07I mean, to me, like, this this is exactly what we're building this project for.
- 49:12If we're gonna commit to another potentially open ended conflict in The Middle East where
- 49:18American lives and treasure are going to be spent, we ought to, as citizens, have a say in
- 49:24that process.
- 49:24We are the ones who are going to be committing our sons and daughters or our, you know,
- 49:29brothers and sisters or our tax our tax dollars to this conflict.
- 49:35We ought to have a say in deciding when to get into war and what to set the terms of
- 49:41engagement and to know when we've achieved our goals.
- 49:45Right?
- 49:46I mean, I think that this technology is built for this type of moment, and I only wish that
- 49:51we can move faster so that so that that, you know, the next time a president wants to invade
- 49:58a country or start a war, he basically goes to an address yeah.
- 50:02A white does a White House address behind the the resolute desk and says to everybody, pull
- 50:08out your phone and let's vote right now on this.
- 50:11And we do it just like oh, what is it?
- 50:13Oh, gosh.
- 50:14The Voice?
- 50:15Is it The Voice?
- 50:16Or Oh, yeah.
- 50:17Like, Voice, American Idol, the American Idol.
- 50:19Exactly.
- 50:20Competitions.
- 50:20Yeah.
- 50:21Same concept.
- 50:22Right?
- 50:22They've been using this technology for some time.
- 50:24If we can do it for silly reality shows, we ought to be able to do this in a way that it
- 50:30has a real impact on us, on our lives.
- 50:32But to answer your question more specifically, yeah, I would love for people listening to go
- 50:37and vote, to get engaged, to learn about the technology, to educate yourself on the bills
- 50:40and on the policies, use the AI tools, to have a chat chat, to to educate yourself on the
- 50:46policies, volunteer.
- 50:48You know, we can always use donations to pay for our server fees and things like that.
- 50:52So please just help us out.
- 50:54If if this is the kind of problem that you think you want to help solve, please engage
- 51:00with us and help us do that.
- 51:01Yeah.
- 51:02That's I think that's a very succinct way to put that and and, you know, especially with the
- 51:07Iran war and anything like that.
- 51:10Whether you agree with it or not, at the very least, we should be having our voices heard
- 51:14because, like you said, these are we're sending people to potentially die over in another
- 51:21country.
- 51:22At the very least, we should have some sort of say where we even if even if you don't
- 51:28ultimately listen to the people, you at least should hear what the people have to say so that
- 51:32you are ultimately accountable for what happens anyways even when you have all the information
- 51:37in front of you.
- 51:38So and Exactly.
- 51:39I I for my podcast, I I I try to keep myself out of my specific opinion about particular
- 51:46political issues.
- 51:47So it's not a matter of whether I support the war or not, but it is something that people
- 51:52need to be able to have their voice heard about.
- 51:55And I I I there's really no easy way to transition into this, but since we're running
- 52:01out of time, gonna go ahead to the random question of the day.
- 52:04So the random question of the day is something I like to do for those who are new to this.
- 52:07I like to end interviews with a fun, non political question.
- 52:12I know it's quite a bit of a shift in tone here, but I like to, you know, make things a
- 52:17little bit lighter because sometimes these things can be very feel very doom and gloom,
- 52:21but it does not always have to be doom and gloom, especially when we're making our voices
- 52:25heard.
- 52:26So all that being said, for you, Ramon, today's random question of the day is you get to
- 52:32immediately make one documentary and millions of people will watch it.
- 52:35What is that documentary about?
- 52:37And it doesn't matter if it's a topic that has had a documentary before.
- 52:40Maybe it's just one you wanna make specifically.
- 52:42Alright.
- 52:43Well, I'll give you another shameless plug for I wish I had recorded our entire process of
- 52:48building this project.
- 52:50In retrospect, it would've been nice to record the team going through trying to figure out
- 52:57what it is we're trying to build and how we're gonna stitch it together and record us spending
- 53:01time in Tallahassee talking to legislators.
- 53:03Legislators.
- 53:06We had had a documentary film crew, not just about the team, but about the reaction from a
- 53:15lot of legislators.
- 53:16Because like I say, I have been thrown out of people's offices before.
- 53:19That would have been fun to get on camera, especially to understand their rationale
- 53:24because some people have accused me of being some sort of stalking horse for Ron DeSantis.
- 53:29Other people have accused me of being like some sort of squishy lib.
- 53:33So it just I mean, that would have been fun to get on camera.
- 53:36So, yeah, I guess that would have been a fun documentary to make.
- 53:39But maybe there's still time.
- 53:40You know?
- 53:41We still got a lot of runway.
- 53:42There are plenty of problems to solve.
- 53:44Right?
- 53:44So we're not done yet.
- 53:46We've got a lot of we got a lot of work to do still.
- 53:48So maybe that's maybe that's the one we should be making.
- 53:52Yeah.
- 53:53It's just some people are just that averse to being accountable for their decisions.
- 53:58Mhmm.
- 53:58And, unfortunately, that's a that's a problem across the political ally.
- 54:02I know a lot of people like to think it's it's just quote unquote the other side, but, no,
- 54:05it's it's it's across a political spectrum problem.
- 54:09Mhmm.
- 54:09Now for for me, there's a whole bunch of different ideas I'd have because I have a bunch
- 54:13of different interests in sports and video games and and all this stuff.
- 54:18But maybe for something a little bit more relevant for for this, I would pick I kinda
- 54:23wanna do either a, the development of civics or the teaching of civics over the course of
- 54:31American history, or, and this would be like a 50 part series, it'd be like Ken Burns's
- 54:39Vietnam War on steroids.
- 54:40But something I want something I ultimately wanna do, you know, you know, later on down the
- 54:46road is I wanna do a political history of all of the states.
- 54:51So all 50 states because there's for as fascinating as federal government history is,
- 54:58there is some I won't I won't there's certain words I could say that I I don't I don't wanna
- 55:02say on the podcast, but it's insane things that that some of these states have had happen in
- 55:07their political history and just some of the ways that they have just shifted over time.
- 55:11Like, you know, you look at a state like Massachusetts, which is as blue as they they
- 55:16come, and Vermont is, with the exception of governor lately with Phil Scott, That's a
- 55:21pretty blue state too.
- 55:22Or you look at our state Florida or or Texas that are very red now.
- 55:27You know, seventy, eighty years ago, that was not the case at all.
- 55:32Like, I I actually remember a a couple years ago, it was my sister wanted us all to to watch
- 55:38it.
- 55:38My sister, my parents, and I, we watched White Christmas.
- 55:42Just the maybe I'm the one of the few people that find this joke really funny, but Danny
- 55:47Kaye's character says something the the context isn't important, but he says because they're in
- 55:52Vermont, and he goes says something along the lines of maybe we'll dig up a democrat, which
- 55:56is really funny to see now because it's like, wait.
- 55:59What are you talking about?
- 56:00Vermont's a very democratic state.
- 56:01This movie is from the fifties.
- 56:03Back then, Vermont was actually quite a republican state.
- 56:06All that to say, though, that just really I I I I do wanna do a book down the road about the
- 56:13political histories of the states and how those shaped over time at the state level as opposed
- 56:18to
- 56:18I just agree with that.
- 56:20I think we've we in some ways, we have made a mistake as a country by centering every
- 56:26political discussion in Washington.
- 56:28And I think that I think maybe for the first time, Democrats are coming around to the value
- 56:36of states' rights and federalism when now that Trump is in office.
- 56:40Also, along those lines, I think the the story about the political transformation of Florida
- 56:48as a result of the pandemic is a very, very interesting historiography that should be
- 56:53analyzed.
- 56:54I think there's been some early work.
- 56:56I I forget the professor at a UF who did some of the study, but it's very clear that there
- 57:01was a sizable influx of Republican voters as a result of the pandemic.
- 57:06Now granted, Republicans have controlled the state house since the midnight, but the
- 57:11statewide offices would go back and forth between Democrats and Republicans, and
- 57:15Democrats had a majority of the voter registration.
- 57:17But so there was a trend towards Republicans having greater control over the course of time,
- 57:23which the flood gets opened as a result of the pandemic.
- 57:26And I think that's a really interesting documentary to to because it has important
- 57:32ramifications elsewhere in the country.
- 57:35People sort of migrating for politics is I don't know that we've really seen that in a
- 57:42well, maybe Jim Crow would be the closest example Yeah.
- 57:46Of people leaving the South as a result of Jim Crow migrating for the great floods in
- 57:51Mississippi that that shifted enormous amounts of African American migration up to Chicago.
- 57:56But but otherwise, leaving the South as a result of Jim Crow, maybe that's the closest
- 58:01equivalent.
- 58:02Yeah.
- 58:03Otherwise, to think about people engaging in mass migration for political reasons inside The
- 58:08United States interior, that I think is a really undeveloped thesis for some kind of a
- 58:16documentary I think would be really interesting to discuss.
- 58:19Yeah.
- 58:19And it is it is unfortunate.
- 58:22Well, it's maybe not as much as some people make it out to be.
- 58:25There is this phenomenon where people are moving more and more to places that are like
- 58:30minded, which I think is a is quite a shame.
- 58:32I think it's much more interesting to live in a place that is more politically eclectic.
- 58:37Mhmm.
- 58:38That that professor you brought up from University of Florida, I can't say this with
- 58:43certainty.
- 58:44So I I did grad school up at University of Florida, but this is a professor that does
- 58:48teaches PhD students, not masters.
- 58:51So I'm I think they I'm gonna guess that the professor you're talking about is probably Dan
- 58:56Smith because that that is something that he he does a lot on.
- 58:59That or Michael McDonald, was who I did actually have a class with.
- 59:03Those were it's probably one of those two that did that study you were talking about.
- 59:08But, yeah, that that that's it's something I've gotten more and more into with this state
- 59:11government because, you know, we just talked about before how a lot of it is sometimes
- 59:15obscure or forgotten by the wayside as people pay attention to the federal level, but, you
- 59:20know, state and local level is even more directly impactful on us.
- 59:24But we can go on and on about about this all day, but I I gotta let you go.
- 59:29And before we go though, Ramon, any obviously, I'll share Digital Democracy Project's website,
- 59:35but is there any other are there any other links that you want me to share?
- 59:38No.
- 59:38I think that that's the number one and we'd love to have more of your listeners
- 59:43participating in in our project, especially since we started it in Florida.
- 59:47So, fellow Floridians, please keep the party going.
- 59:50Yeah.
- 59:51Absolutely.
- 59:52And for you that are not Floridians, you might it might already be in your state, and if it's
- 59:56not, it'll be there soon.
- 59:57So, Ramon, really wanna thank you for your time.
- 1:00:00So for my links to wrap things up, my LinkedIn, Facebook, medium.com profile, my website, Paul
- 1:00:07Raider dot org, my email, PaulRaiderWrights@Gmail.com, my five day
- 1:00:12education email course about how we can all better depolarize politics and be more
- 1:00:17effective in that and some of the mistakes we make and how to correct those, and my book on
- 1:00:22Amazon about political independence.
- 1:00:25And I believe that is it from my end.
- 1:00:27So that is gonna wrap things up today for Politics with Paul.
- 1:00:31Please like, comment, share and subscribe on YouTube, Spotify and Apple Podcasts and share
- 1:00:36with all the people you know.
- 1:00:38Thank you so much for all of you listening and we'll see you next time.