Latest / Retail Fast Five / Does Ulta Need to Get the Flock Out of Here? | Fast Five Shorts
Transcript
- 0:00Ulta Beauty is facing a social media backlash this week after an activist campaign went viral criticizing the retailer's use of Flock Safety's automated license plate reader technology at a small number of its stores.
- 0:13According to Retail Dive, social media users flooded Ulta's Instagram post this week after a campaign by activist group Ultraviolet.
- 0:20Cool name.
- 0:21Went viral criticizing Ulta's relationship with surveillance tech provider Flock.
- 0:26The technology is deployed at fewer than 1% of Ulta's roughly 1500 store fleet nationwide, and a source told Retail Dive the cameras do not use facial recognition.
- 0:37Flock has faced growing public criticism and vandalism of its license plate readers in recent months, with some state and local governments reconsidering the technology's use.
- 0:47Flock's website also lists organized retail crime as a use case, and Ulta's director of organized retail crime has said the retailer sought the technology to, quote, help bridged the gap, end quote, with law enforcement after a rise in
- 0:58store violence following the pandemic.
- 1:00Neither Ulta nor Flock, however, responded to Retail Dive's detailed questions about the relationship.
- 1:06Shelly Alta is framing this internally as an organized retail crime tool, but the online reaction is treating it as surveillance overreach.
- 1:14Is the viral backlash appropriate or is Ulta just an easy target amid the broader anti surveillance movement movement?
- 1:21Well, this is an interesting topic today, and I'll probably say this very directly.
- 1:27Yeah, a retailer should not deploy technology like this unless they can actually explain it.
- 1:33And I think this is an example of really bad external and internal comms where there should have been a strategy around how to talk to consumers about this.
- 1:42And so what is even more interesting is they had an opportunity to start that discussion with Retail Dive and then they refused to comment as well.
- 1:50So this is kind of leaving it very opaque for everybody to understand exactly what's happening.
- 1:56But a retailer does have a responsibility to protect not only the people that work at its retail locations, but also customers.
- 2:03And when we talk about surveillance, and I'd be curious about your perspective, Chris, is like, where do we draw the line?
- 2:09Because we've had cameras outside of malls during holiday times forever in order to protect people against theft.
- 2:16And so for me, this is not like a safety privacy question.
- 2:21It's what is being captured, what data is being captured, for how long, and how do you explain to your consumers and people shopping at your stores what is happening?
- 2:33And so, yeah, I think it's interesting because I think it's more of a communication problem than I think it is a surveillance problem.
- 2:42Yeah.
- 2:42And it's a tough Communications problem, too, right, Shelly?
- 2:46It's a hard one to know how to get out in front of from a communication standpoint, too.
- 2:50So my feel goes out to the PR teams as well, because it's hard to know how to couch this.
- 2:55Like, I think of.
- 2:56We had a similar conversation.
- 2:57Ben Miller, on Grocer Talk, he talked about Sainsbury's use of facial recognition, which is going, you know, a step beyond, because Flack doesn't apparently use facial recognition.
- 3:06It's just reading license plates.
- 3:07But, you know, Ben, you know, Ben was all for it for the reasons you said, because it was, you know, designed to help keep employees safer.
- 3:14But yet then they had a false positive where they accused somebody of shoplifting, and then social media blew up on it.
- 3:19And it was like one of those things where I was like, yeah, I personally, I don't know if I'd be.
- 3:24I'd be touching this.
- 3:25But then I come back on the flip side of it and go, yeah, but at the end of the day, I need to protect my store employees.
- 3:31Like, I need to do that.
- 3:32So I've got to figure out a way to do it.
- 3:35And so I think if you're.
- 3:36If you're going to deploy this type of tech, you either one, have to know your communication strategy to your point, or you've got to stand your ground and be ready for the backlash and give the rationale for why
- 3:48are you using it.
- 3:49But I think you have to tread cautiously still and dip your toe into it, which is my hunch.
- 3:56My hunch is that all these technologies are being deployed in this way.
- 4:02The question I have, too, is, are they really moving the needle and are they worth art?
- 4:07Is the juice, worth the squeeze on them?
- 4:09In terms of the social media backlash and the distraction for the comms teams internally in your organizations, I think those are the questions you have to ask, because detection and prevention are two really different things.
- 4:20And I'm still not sure I've seen a silver bullet on how do you actually prevent versus how do you just detect?
- 4:26But I don't know.
- 4:27What do you think, Shelley?
- 4:29I think that's right.
- 4:30I think technology is going to be deployed at a faster rate than ever in the past in retail.
- 4:36So the point is, be transparent about it and have a plan.
- 4:42In the age that we're living in now, we can't just deploy things and not communicate them and not be transparent about them, because there's too many of our consumer bases that are now in communities talking to each other,
- 4:55picking up on things.
- 4:56And so if you don't create your own narrative.
- 4:58The basics, right?
- 4:59If you don't create your own narrative, somebody else is going to create it for you.
- 5:02So I think the punchline here is the technology could be great.
- 5:06It needs to be tested more.
- 5:07There have been misuses of it.
- 5:10It's great that they're trying it out in 1% of their stores.
- 5:13They need to get more data on it, but they didn't have a plan.
- 5:16And so I think that's the big lesson here for other retailers that may follow suit in deploying similar types of surveillance technology.
- 5:23But Shelly, at the same time, like, and a former, as a former CEO, I'm curious, cause I don't know the answer to this question either that I'm about to ask you is like, what does that mean for pilot
- 5:32implementations?
- 5:32Like this is in 1% of stores.
- 5:34Like the comp scheme's gotta be very dialed in on what the innovation teams or the tech teams are trying to learn by executing small tests in stores too.
- 5:44Because it sounds like if you get that wrong, it can blow up.
- 5:48So are you saying then that the comps team's got to get more involved in innovation?
- 5:54I think one of the most strategic roles that companies have to have now is communications.
- 6:00And I think that those roles are starting to report directly to CEOs for that reason.
- 6:06Because you have two things kind of happening at once.
- 6:08You have a more rapid iteration of customer experiences which I think this falls into.
- 6:13Consumers are obviously experiencing this surveillance when they come into the parking lot.
- 6:17And then you also have a need for increased communication with your associates.
- 6:22So both internal and external comms have become so much more strategic, the need for those in recent years.
- 6:28And so I think that that role is so strategic, more and more reporting to the CEO and I think they absolutely have to be involved in every facet of the business and understand what's launching and if it's visible
- 6:40to a consumer, there should be plan around it.
- 6:43That's a really good point too.
- 6:44Like for those listening too, especially people gravitated with like what's next in my career with the dawn of AI, that seems like a, in some ways an AI proof job too.
- 6:52And a job that would require more knowledge of the hands on operations of how the retailer works day in and day out.
- 6:58So it actually may be a good way to transition for a career too as you're thinking about it.
- 7:02Like, you know, hey, do I start going into comms if I've been in merchandising at some point, you know, because I, I have the chops that help me understand what's actually being talked about here.
- 7:12That's.
- 7:13That's a really interesting insight, Shelly.