Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E053: Educational Empowerment with Paul Nylen
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous extra
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1970. 419-8790,
- 0:16297-2000 and whatever we want to call this, it's all just the
- 0:20same thing over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when. We sell.
- 0:26Hey, OK, so I'm behind, I say when we sell.
- 0:32Thank you for joining us for this week's episode of The Last
- 0:35Trade, a podcast from On Ramp Media.
- 0:37On today's show, we're joined by Paul Nylan, Accounting and Tax
- 0:40Professor at the University of Wisconsin Whitewater.
- 0:43Paul details his journey into Bitcoin and the establishment of
- 0:46the Blockchain and Cryptocurrency Institute at the
- 0:48University of UW Whitewater. He shares how he introduced
- 0:52Bitcoin education to students and faculty and highlights the
- 0:55transformative impact it had on his students.
- 0:58To then shift to the recent allocation of Bitcoin by the
- 1:00Wisconsin State Pension Fund, with Paul discussing the factors
- 1:04that may have influenced the decision and the potential
- 1:06impact it could have on other pensions.
- 1:08We also discussed the cultural acceptance of Bitcoin and the
- 1:11importance of doing thorough due diligence before making
- 1:14investment decisions. Paul also explores potential
- 1:16catalyst for inflows to Bitcoin, particularly from institutional
- 1:20investors such as pension funds. And we touch on the importance
- 1:23of custody solutions and the role of multi institution
- 1:25custody in helping institutions secure Bitcoin allocations.
- 1:29And now, time for the show. We're going this is this is
- 1:32weird, Paul. I'm in a far away studio,
- 1:36disconnected from Logan, our producer, and he usually gives
- 1:38me the we're live and I'm just seeing it here on ECAM.
- 1:43But we are live and really excited for this conversation.
- 1:46Paul Nylan, assistant professor in the Department of Accounting
- 1:50at the University of Wisconsin Whitewater, Also the faculty
- 1:54director of the Blockchain of Cryptocurrency Institute,
- 1:57faculty advisor of the UW Whitewater Blockchain of
- 2:00Cryptocurrency student Organization, and somebody who
- 2:04had some some thoughts on the recent allocation to Bitcoin by
- 2:08the Wisconsin Pension Fund, which we're here to talk about
- 2:12today. But before we hit record, we
- 2:14were just talking about David Kraus and his appearance on PBS
- 2:17earlier this week, talking about the allocation.
- 2:20And we were laughing about how people who begin commenting on
- 2:25Bitcoin aren't really prepared for how much it will get echoed
- 2:30and blasted on Bitcoin Twitter as people are excited that
- 2:35institutions and people who've been waiting to come to Bitcoin
- 2:38are here and they're talking about it.
- 2:40And it's really exciting, particularly right now post
- 2:43having post ETF launch. So, Paul, welcome to the show.
- 2:47Thank you for joining us. Yep, thanks for having me.
- 2:51Guys, so I think to jump into this, let's learn a little bit
- 2:55more about you, how you got into Bitcoin and how you came to
- 3:00become the faculty director of the Blockchain and
- 3:02Cryptocurrency Institute at UW Whitewater.
- 3:06So I think, you know, I think I've heard 1000 people's
- 3:09journeys on how they got started in Bitcoin.
- 3:12I think everyone's almost the same, maybe outside of a few
- 3:15cypherpunks, but you know, I pretty confident I read about it
- 3:21or a little bit about it in 2013, 1415 and just dismissed it
- 3:26like probably everyone did when they first got into this, before
- 3:28they got into space. I had a good friend, you guys
- 3:33may or may not know him, Austin Wilcox, who's been kind of in
- 3:36the Bitcoin space now for a number of years.
- 3:38I grew up with him and he actually was the one who sent me
- 3:41some stuff to read about it and and sort of insisted that I
- 3:45hadn't really done the necessary homework to start with on the
- 3:49topic. And so actually, so the Bitcoin
- 3:52Standard was probably the first book I read on it.
- 3:55And gold, gold always sort of made sense to me as a investment
- 4:00proposition. Although I will say as someone
- 4:03who liked gold in sort of the early 2000s and mid 2000s, it
- 4:06drastically underperformed I think what people thought it was
- 4:09going to do. But yeah, I would say for me,
- 4:13that was probably the starting point.
- 4:14So 2019-2020 was kind of when I first got into space, I was
- 4:20already teaching at University of Wisconsin Whitewater, my
- 4:23background as a lawyer in CPA. And as I was getting more and
- 4:27more into the space, it seemed pretty crazy to me.
- 4:29Whitewater didn't have any hub or any system set up for
- 4:35teaching students this stuff, getting them exposed to like all
- 4:41the different interesting Bitcoin areas, ways to accept
- 4:45Bitcoin donations, all all these sort of things.
- 4:47And so a couple years ago, I just went to our, you know, the
- 4:51Dean of our college and said, hey, we really should start an
- 4:53institute on this kind of a launching pad for students and
- 4:57companies to come hire our students, that sort of thing.
- 4:59And so we have a very, I think a very smart College of business.
- 5:04We do a biggest College of business in the state.
- 5:07And so they're willing to sort of what seems like take risks
- 5:10and try new things. So that's what we did and that's
- 5:13what to decided to put some money behind it and give some
- 5:16resources and put some student workers and that sort of thing.
- 5:19And so, yeah, for that for the past couple years, I've taught a
- 5:23class on Bitcoin here we have student workers doing research
- 5:27on different things. We're in the process of trying
- 5:31to get mining going on campus. But as you can imagine, that's a
- 5:34whole nother animal because the people that are otherwise on, on
- 5:39campus and would help us with this, you know, they, they have
- 5:42all the different, they have all the, the typical FUD concerns
- 5:45about, you know, the energy use and things like that.
- 5:47So we're, we're trying to cross that stuff off off the list
- 5:50also. But yeah, that's kind of where
- 5:51we're at now. And we, I'll actually be in
- 5:55Nashville in July and I got a bunch of students coming with me
- 5:58too. So that'll be fun for them to
- 6:00sort of hear from people and network and hear different
- 6:03speakers and stuff like that. Yeah, UW Whitewater students are
- 6:07lucky. And it's funny that Austin is
- 6:09the guy that got you into this. I know Austin well from down in
- 6:12Texas. Michael, you too.
- 6:15He's he's doing great stuff out of that, out of Austin.
- 6:19And it's been, it's been funny developing a relationship with
- 6:22him over the years. And to learn that that's how you
- 6:24got introduced to Bitcoin is great.
- 6:27And I think This is why I'm, I'm actually writing a, a newsletter
- 6:32on this today. Like I think this is the most
- 6:33bullish 90 day period that we've had in Bitcoin over the last 15
- 6:39years. Maybe potentially with the
- 6:41announcement from the Wisconsin pension fund, you have a bunch
- 6:45of publicly traded companies, you had a healthcare related
- 6:49company and a coal mining company within the last three
- 6:52months come out and say, Hey, we're going to use Bitcoin as
- 6:55their treasury asset. Obviously the ETF launch has
- 6:58been the most successful in the ETF history.
- 7:02And then on top of that, like just learning stories like
- 7:05yours, Paul, where people like you have been doing a lot of
- 7:09work behind the scenes and have not really been too public about
- 7:13it or on on the radar many of us Bitcoiners.
- 7:15But just what you just described, like you're you're
- 7:18working on a mining initiative, you've got the Dean bot in
- 7:21you're one of the most prestigious business schools
- 7:23within the University of Wisconsin, excuse me, State
- 7:28University system. Like there's a lot of stuff that
- 7:32many bitcoiners who are focused on the space 24/7 365.
- 7:36There's a lot of stuff going on that even we don't realize.
- 7:39And it's just an incredible time to do in the space.
- 7:42At Onramp, we believe that Bitcoin will be the most
- 7:44important asset to own in the 21st century.
- 7:47Our Multi Institution custody solution is the safest and most
- 7:50secure way to ensure that your Bitcoin remains in your and your
- 7:53family's possession for decades to come.
- 7:55Multi Institution custody maximizes security and minimizes
- 7:58counterparty risk, leveraging Bitcoin's native properties to
- 8:01eliminate single points of failure that have historically
- 8:04complicated Bitcoin ownership. Onramp provides Peace of Mind
- 8:07for your Bitcoin journey. For more information, check us
- 8:10out at onrampbitcoin.com. Yeah, to to expand on that, I
- 8:14mean, Paul, when you were talking about was kept striking
- 8:17me was four years ago this would just not have happened.
- 8:21Like you would not be in this position of, of being able to
- 8:25bring students to Nash Nashville for the Bitcoin conference and,
- 8:29you know, spearhead some initiatives on campus around
- 8:33raising business students understanding and awareness of
- 8:37Bitcoin as part of the landscape that they need to be familiar
- 8:42with and know how to navigate to succeed in their careers.
- 8:45Like that, that, you know, I'm, I'm, I'm putting words in your
- 8:49mouth here, but I think that's probably part of the mandate and
- 8:51part of probably part of what Whitewater is trying to do.
- 8:56And that just would not have happened four years ago.
- 8:58And so Paul, you're like a, a perfect microcosm of adoption in
- 9:03Bitcoin. Like, you know, we, we, we
- 9:06always get caught up in, in the day-to-day and then thinking
- 9:10like, where are the institutions?
- 9:12Where is the next wave of adoption?
- 9:15You know, I'm not seeing it. It's not, it's not beating me
- 9:18over the head, but it's examples like yours, Paul, where you you
- 9:23are seeding this idea really in the minds of of the next
- 9:28generation, but also in the institutional fabric of the
- 9:34university system. And, you know, these little
- 9:37colonies of activity propagate and spread and normalize Bitcoin
- 9:44as a whole. And then suddenly it becomes a
- 9:46part of the fabric of business education and, you know,
- 9:51learning about finance in general.
- 9:54Yeah, no, yeah, that's a great point.
- 9:56And, you know, so it's interesting like in the academic
- 9:59world. So at a school like Whitewater,
- 10:02you know, every school has like a mission statement and they're,
- 10:04they're trying to set themselves apart from other universities.
- 10:07You know, Whitewater, one of the sort of core things that we try
- 10:11to do, and this is plastered all over our campus is we're trying
- 10:15to transform students and to every professor on campus,
- 10:19that's going to mean something different when I take a step
- 10:24back. So when I started, when I
- 10:26started going down this path a couple years ago, I actually was
- 10:29able to take two students down to Miami last year for the
- 10:34conference. And at the end of the year, you
- 10:37know, we write reports about, you know, how our students did
- 10:39and all the stuff we did and activities.
- 10:42And underneath all of that, you sort of have to ask yourself,
- 10:46you know, how did I transform students?
- 10:47So, you know, I teach tax law here at the university, some
- 10:50financial accounting, I teach blockchain.
- 10:53You know, it's a Bitcoin class. It's called blockchain, but it's
- 10:55mostly Bitcoin. And you know, when I, when I was
- 10:59writing that report, what really dawned on me was transforming
- 11:06that when I, when I think about the most transformative things I
- 11:09did for students over the past year, it was pretty clear that
- 11:14taking the two students down to Miami was it by far.
- 11:19Now they had learned a lot of other, you know, my students had
- 11:21learned a lot of other stuff this year, right?
- 11:23I mean, tons of fun tax laws and we've done all types of things,
- 11:27right? But when I take a step back and
- 11:29I say, what students came to me after certain experiences and
- 11:33said, wow, that blew my blew me away.
- 11:35You know, when I took two students to Miami and they saw,
- 11:39you know, 4 Brown, how many presidential candidates were
- 11:42there at the time? They saw this, you know,
- 11:44hundreds of companies and all this discussion about, you know,
- 11:49energy and and, and you know, last year in Miami, there was a
- 11:52lot of stuff going on with, you know, ordinals and any of the
- 11:55with the wizard folks are down there and stuff.
- 11:57And so the, I think you have to put yourself, you know, back in
- 12:02the seat of someone, you know, a student who's 19/20/21 and all
- 12:06the stuff you're learning at the time, right?
- 12:08You're taking English and philosophy and accounting and
- 12:11you're taking all the stuff and the Bitcoin stuff of it by far.
- 12:17What? Was to me was pretty clear was
- 12:19the most transformative. And so that was, I think kind of
- 12:23a confirmation from my perspective of like, OK, let's
- 12:26do more of this. This is the stuff that's like
- 12:29pushing the needle with the students.
- 12:31And interestingly enough, you can learn lots of other things
- 12:36as you're along for the Bitcoin ride.
- 12:37So like we can learn about taxes and accounting and all these
- 12:42other topics through the context of Bitcoin.
- 12:44And so I actually bring a lot of that stuff into my other class
- 12:47too. So the sort of orange Pilling or
- 12:49orange Kool-aid is like trickling its way into like
- 12:52other topics. I think in the university, which
- 12:54is great. But you know, at a school like
- 12:57Whitewater, we'll probably, we'll probably never have the
- 13:00publicity of, you know, school like UW Madison, like a Big 10
- 13:03school. But over time, I think if, you
- 13:08know, I think we're getting the momentum going and over time, if
- 13:11we're graduating 203040 students a year who all have sort of a
- 13:17core educational background and some Bitcoin stuff, you know, if
- 13:21we get a 5-10 year head start, we're going to have several
- 13:24hundred students from Whitewater who understand how this works.
- 13:28And by my estimation, the other schools aren't going to be able
- 13:31to catch us. We're going to have built this
- 13:32lead so far up that like a lot of the intellectual firepower
- 13:35will be coming out of Whitewater.
- 13:37And so for me, it's hard to be more transformational.
- 13:40Than that yeah that's it's incredible I mean for everybody
- 13:43that's not watching listening Paul behind him has AI think
- 13:47it's I know it I don't know what cartoon it is I know I'm going
- 13:50to. Miss it?
- 13:50It's a little. Hobbler with AB but like really
- 13:55stands out because Jesse and I have been on calls with schools
- 13:58and pension faculty and they'll take a call very different.
- 14:00It'll be dark and the lights will be off and they won't feel
- 14:03very comfortable in their faculty knowing that they're
- 14:06talking about, you know, maybe an allocation or how they're
- 14:08thinking about Bitcoin. So it makes a lot of sense.
- 14:12It seems it's in the culture. I'm curious, like any anecdotes
- 14:16you can share from either the classes or from faculty that
- 14:19you've naturally been able to help see this because that's
- 14:23really fascinating. Like it makes sense that
- 14:25students would go to the conference or be interested
- 14:28because it's just so real and, and different than anything they
- 14:31hear about. And so you're naturally going to
- 14:33gravitate it because gravitate towards it because the energy's
- 14:35there. So just curious like how like
- 14:36that's actually transformed a conversation.
- 14:39Yeah, so I have, if you can see behind me, I, I have a, you can,
- 14:43I see part of it. I, I have a stack of Bitcoin
- 14:45books back here, right. And so I think in the, in the
- 14:49academic world, you know, knowledge is, is power.
- 14:54And sometimes even like, you know, the physical book is, is
- 14:57powerful. And so I have a lot of people
- 15:00come to my office across campus and ask me about this, right?
- 15:03They, they've heard about Bitcoin in some context and
- 15:06they've got some association with it.
- 15:07And So what I try to do is actually steer them to, I
- 15:12actually, I actually tried to take Jameson Lopp's advice on
- 15:14this, right? You know, he, I think he's
- 15:17always said something like he's not trying to convince people to
- 15:20buy Bitcoin. He wants people to convince
- 15:21themselves to buy it. And so I try to take that
- 15:24approach just in general with Bitcoin.
- 15:26So when people come to me with a, you know, a neutral or it's
- 15:33called a neutral view, what I try to do is figure out like
- 15:36what world view they're coming from and which kind of book or
- 15:41author I think would be most helpful to them.
- 15:43And if they don't have the sort of patience or diligence to sit
- 15:49down and spend, you know, 10:20, 30-40 hours reading a book, then
- 15:54Bitcoins probably not for them. But if they do have that
- 15:57patience and want to, you know, want to learn, I usually can
- 16:00find a book that like reaches just to reaches to just about
- 16:03everybody, right? And so, you know, if it's a
- 16:06shorter attention span, it's, you know, it's bullish case or
- 16:09Bitcoin, if it's like on the humanitarian side is check your
- 16:12financial privilege. If it's on the banking side,
- 16:15it's going to be something from Lynn Alden.
- 16:18You know, if it's an economics person coming to me, it's the
- 16:20Bitcoin standard. If it's a person with very
- 16:23progressive views or maybe believing a lot in the sort of
- 16:26the energy FUD, it's the progressive case from Bitcoin by
- 16:29Jason Mayer. And so I think having this sort
- 16:32of stuff at at my, you know, have you read these and be able
- 16:35to like hand them out and say, Hey, I got multiple copies of
- 16:38these. You take one, you keep this.
- 16:40When you're ready to learn more about it, do that.
- 16:43And there's been, I don't know how many people on campus, but
- 16:47there's been a number of people on campus where I've given them
- 16:49a book and they've come back to me and they're one response is
- 16:52like, OK, I misjudged this or, you know, totally bought into
- 16:58the FUD. I'll just just to give you 111
- 17:00anecdote. I think you guys will like
- 17:02there's a guy in our hallway who I'm actually working on a paper
- 17:06with right now. And he had very, I'll just say
- 17:10no background in Bitcoin. And him and I were going to
- 17:13trying to figure out what we wanted to write and publish
- 17:14about. And he had a couple topics.
- 17:16And when he came to me, I said, hey, you know, the thing I enjoy
- 17:19writing the most about right now is Bitcoin.
- 17:21So if you're willing to sort of do some homework on this, let's
- 17:25team up together. But you got to like learn about
- 17:28this first. And his background.
- 17:30He spent about 30 years in corporate America at a large, I
- 17:34won't say the name of the company, but a large chemical
- 17:35company. He was in house counsel for
- 17:38them. So he has a, you know, a safety
- 17:42and chemical background, you know, very different from mine,
- 17:44but he is, he's also a lawyer. And I gave him a couple books.
- 17:49I gave him the the progressive Case for Bitcoin by Jason Mayer,
- 17:53especially on the energy stuff. And he had a pretty big
- 17:57background in what we call like, you know, you guys probably
- 18:01smirk at this, right? But like misinformation and
- 18:05disinformation and those topics. And his thought was, hey, all
- 18:11the stuff written about Bitcoin mining, it's like
- 18:13misinformation, right? It's people giving.
- 18:15It's like these New York Times articles that are half truths
- 18:18are loaded with omissions. And so him and I have we're
- 18:20working on a paper together, basically going through all
- 18:23these New York Times articles saying the mainstream media is
- 18:27completely, you know, it's stuff like in the Bitcoin community,
- 18:30we know, but the mainstream doesn't necessarily know is,
- 18:32hey, all this stuff, you know, that the grid balancing, the
- 18:35loading, all this stuff has been missed, understood and sort of
- 18:40the mainstream media And, you know, mining is like an energy
- 18:43positive force, right? It's not this, it's not like a
- 18:46bug of the system. It's like a feature of the
- 18:47system. And so that's probably one
- 18:49example of someone who just works down the hallway from me,
- 18:51who a year and a half ago knew nothing about Bitcoin.
- 18:54And now he's all in, right? And he's bringing his own
- 18:56perspective to it. And so I've got a couple other
- 18:59people like that, but I think that's probably a good one.
- 19:02That's incredible, yeah. I mean, talk about talk about
- 19:07something a report that could make quite a bit of a splash and
- 19:11get a lot of attention and bring a lot of spotlight to Whitewater
- 19:16and to what you guys are doing there with your Bitcoin
- 19:19initiative. You know that like that, that's
- 19:22the opportunity in front of so many organizations, academic
- 19:28institutions to to do some homework and put out something
- 19:30fresh and unique about Bitcoin because there's so much appetite
- 19:35out there for novel, interesting, professional
- 19:40analysis in the Bitcoin space around Bitcoin, trying to
- 19:44understand this phenomenon and what's going on here.
- 19:47And I feel like that has been so untapped to date, you know, and
- 19:51every time someone like David Kraus, you know, opens his mouth
- 19:55about Bitcoin, it gets a ton of attention.
- 19:59And you know that, that that's. That's an incentive that's, you
- 20:04know, available for people to take advantage of or make the
- 20:07most of. And I, I look forward to
- 20:10Whitewater coming out with a report on mainstream media
- 20:15reporting on on the nature of Bitcoin mining, because as a
- 20:20Bitcoin evangelist, we know that it's horribly skewed.
- 20:26It's, you know, the the mainstream media narrative to
- 20:30date has been misinformed and really kind of a perfect example
- 20:37of the gel manned amnesia effect, right?
- 20:40Of, of when you're reading something in in the media and it
- 20:43comes, you come across a topic that you understand well and you
- 20:46realize how hollow the journalists understanding is.
- 20:51It makes you feel less confident about everything else they're
- 20:55writing about. So it's, it's secretly
- 20:56undermining or unintentionally undermining the credibility of
- 21:02the New York Times and other publications when they dip their
- 21:06their toe into Bitcoin and spread misinformation and, you
- 21:10know, reveal how little they understand about it.
- 21:13And that's got to change. So, you know, very excited to
- 21:15see what you guys put out there. Well, and it also highlights the
- 21:21multi layered approach to weaponize greed that Bitcoin has
- 21:24set in the world like layer zeroes, like, all right, there's
- 21:28only going to be 21 billion Bitcoin.
- 21:29If I can get a good portion of that and adoption continues, my
- 21:34wealth will increase. But then you see it on the
- 21:35social layer where it's like, OK, if we are a leader in terms
- 21:40of educating our students and putting out really constructive
- 21:44pieces on how Bitcoin actually works and how it's
- 21:47interoperating with our world, like that is going to set us
- 21:50apart from our peers at the academic level.
- 21:54And then similarly, on the pension side, I mean, going back
- 21:58to David Krause's interview on PBS earlier this week or end of
- 22:03last week, I mean, it really highlighted there too.
- 22:06I mean, a lot of what the interview revolved around is the
- 22:09Wisconsin pension system's penchant for innovating and
- 22:15being innovative and being ahead of trends.
- 22:18And this particular trend being Bitcoin being one of the first
- 22:21pension systems to allocate to Bitcoin ETS after their launch
- 22:24only six months ago. And I think it's a good time to
- 22:28transition into the allocation by the Wisconsin Pension Fund.
- 22:32And David's interview really highlighted the fact this was
- 22:36$180 million allocation, which is .1% of the overall pension
- 22:43system, which is $180 billion. I believe it's the 6th largest
- 22:46pension in the country. And I think David's interview
- 22:51was illuminating for multiple reasons, but one of which is the
- 22:54fact that the Wisconsin, the Wisconsin pension system
- 22:59particularly could make an allocation like this due to the
- 23:01fact that they're over funded. So maybe before we get into the
- 23:07particular allocation of Bitcoin, maybe just talking
- 23:09about which pensions actually have the ability to allocate in
- 23:14the 1st place due to where they are in terms of relative funding
- 23:18for for their liabilities. Yeah.
- 23:21So this is this is an interesting topic.
- 23:22I mean, I think so with with what David Kraus was talking
- 23:27about, he made, he made an interesting point which I have
- 23:29to think about if I agree with or not.
- 23:31I mean, he, one of the things he, I think sort of stuck the
- 23:37flag in on was the idea that Wisconsin was maybe better
- 23:42suited because the pension is so well funded.
- 23:46And I guess I don't know how much I agree with that.
- 23:49I mean, is it nice to think? I mean that I think it's a
- 23:55comment you make if you want, if you're investing in something
- 23:58maybe really risky, right? So he, he thinks this is super
- 24:01risky. We have some extra money.
- 24:04Let's just throw it in this pot and hope there's some upside.
- 24:06But if it goes to 0 big deal, you know it.
- 24:11My opinion is sort of the opposite, right?
- 24:12I sort of think of Bitcoin long term as the least risky asset.
- 24:16And I know I mentioned when I was interviewed on Wisconsin
- 24:19Public Radio, you know, I, I, I said it's like the last thing
- 24:21you sell. So in some ways I, my sense
- 24:25would be that if using his viewpoint, he would sort of, you
- 24:30know, heavily be taking profits and getting out, you know,
- 24:33permanently. In my view, it's really it, it's
- 24:38the longest duration asset. I was trying to think of a
- 24:40better term the other day that to describe this.
- 24:43I, I think the better term is like permanent duration because
- 24:47it's really hard to find circumstances in which you would
- 24:51sell now as a pension fund has to sell some assets, right, to
- 24:55pay out its, you know, former employees over time.
- 24:58But when you're looking at your portfolio, I mean, what's this?
- 25:02What's the stuff you're going to sell before this, right?
- 25:05I mean, you're, you're sitting on some T Bells, you're sitting
- 25:08on, I don't know GE stock or, you know, Apple stock.
- 25:13In my estimation, it's really hard to sort of compare these
- 25:16investments side to side and say, yeah, the bit Bitcoin's
- 25:19the, the thing I want to sell because that's the stuff I need
- 25:21to pay out my employees. I mean, I am an employee in my
- 25:25sense is that would be the last thing we sell, right?
- 25:28You'd, you'd want to be selling all this other stuff 1st.
- 25:32And so, you know, like he mentioned the state of Illinois,
- 25:35which is a good counter example. So I think the state of Illinois
- 25:37is one of the lowest funded pensions in this in the country
- 25:40at about 50%. And you know, it does make you
- 25:45wonder, you know, who needs Bitcoin more?
- 25:48Is it a state like Wisconsin or is a state like Illinois?
- 25:50I'm glad Wisconsin obviously has bought the ETF.
- 25:54But, you know, I think you could objectively look at it and say
- 25:58it's probably a state like Illinois who probably needs to
- 26:00get more invested quicker because there's no real
- 26:06economics to make up that shortfall.
- 26:07And you need something that's, you know, compounded annual
- 26:12growth rate and 30 to 45% a year to probably help make up some of
- 26:15those gaps. So that's just my, yeah, my two
- 26:18cents and the initial thoughts on.
- 26:20I'm glad bullish enough. I'm glad you brought that up
- 26:23because I did think that was peculiar stance.
- 26:25What I think his logic would be was, would be the sensitivity to
- 26:30the volatility if you're underfunded, right?
- 26:34Like if you're underfunded and that volatility happens now,
- 26:37you're more likely and we're all, all these firms are made of
- 26:40individuals, right? And they haven't gone down that
- 26:42education curve of the volatility in the long enough
- 26:45time horizon or time frame on it.
- 26:47So I think maybe if if to make the counter to where he's
- 26:50probably coming from, because I agree with you in the sense of
- 26:53like, if you're underfunded, this is the only way you're
- 26:56going to be able to get back to par.
- 26:58But the alternative is if not everybody has learned about the
- 27:02asset, it's the the volatility profile.
- 27:05If, if they see a drawdown of even 30 to 50%, let alone 70%,
- 27:10that might be the first thing that the over the, the total
- 27:14want to cut. And then that makes it a very
- 27:16bad investment If you end up cutting it at 50% drawdown, that
- 27:20would be yeah. There's a terrible irony in in
- 27:23with with Bitcoin in general that the the people or or
- 27:27organizations that need it most or like could benefit from it
- 27:29most are often the ones that are least positioned, least well
- 27:35positioned to take that like perceived gamble.
- 27:38You know, like, like whether that's a pension that
- 27:40underfunded, underfunded pension or like Social Security, like,
- 27:44you know, Social Security is never going to pay out for the
- 27:46millennials and later, but it would if like Bitcoin was a was
- 27:51a major part of, of that, how those funds are invested.
- 27:55But it's not, and it won't be because there's no political
- 27:57will or, or reason to do that. But you know, and, and, and
- 28:02Paul, to your point, I think to your point before that about,
- 28:06you know, Bitcoin creates this wild dynamic of, of, of, of
- 28:12Gresham's law across all assets, where the Gresham's laws bad
- 28:17money drives out the good, meaning that you end up seeing
- 28:22the good money being held by people.
- 28:25People hold people realize that they should just keep holding
- 28:28good money, gold and spending paper money because.
- 28:31It's a reverse. It's a reverse of Gresham's Law.
- 28:34It's Dear's Law. So is what we've been living in
- 28:39for like the last five decades now.
- 28:41The Bitcoin exists. Dear's Law can be applied
- 28:43because we have a good money and so it drives out all the bad
- 28:46money. How man, I mixed up those two.
- 28:50OK, well, whatever the, the labels are the, the dynamic of
- 28:55in anybody's portfolio that you have this one asset that's
- 28:59better than all the other ones. And if you understand it, you
- 29:02realize like I should keep holding that one, I should
- 29:04probably not sell my winner. And, and that's the, the, the
- 29:08natural reflex of any portfolio manager is to rebalance by
- 29:15scaling out of your winners. And then, you know, rebalance to
- 29:19you to, you know, deploy some of those funds into what are your
- 29:22losers. And this is this funny tension
- 29:25that Bitcoin creates where like you're actually just better off
- 29:28holding the Bitcoin forever as this permanent asset, as you put
- 29:31it, Paul. And that's going to take a lot
- 29:35for people to wrap their heads around still.
- 29:38Yeah. And, and to add to this
- 29:40conversation, Michael, particularly your comments, I
- 29:42think what it is most surprising about the Wisconsin pension
- 29:46allocation is how quickly we move.
- 29:48Because behind the scenes at 1031, we've been talking to a
- 29:53lot of institutions, like our biggest worry, and I'm sure you
- 29:55guys have this worry too at on Ramp is that due to the
- 30:01bureaucracy that exists with a lot of these institutions and
- 30:04the investment committees that you have to go through and the
- 30:06amount of people that you have to convince that they could
- 30:09ultimately be convinced to allocate to Bitcoin.
- 30:11But it's going to be starting from the ETF launch, a 12 to 18
- 30:15month process, at which point they could be giving the go
- 30:18ahead and saying, all right, we're ready to allocate in
- 30:20Bitcoin. Then they top tick the next
- 30:23price peak during the the blow off top of of the next bull
- 30:27market. And that's the biggest worry.
- 30:28And that's why I think particularly for the Wisconsin
- 30:31pension to allocate this quickly after the ETF launching is
- 30:34extremely impressive and hopefully really is a shot
- 30:38across the bow of other pensions and institutional capital
- 30:42allocators across the country to say, hey, they were able to move
- 30:45quickly. Maybe we got to move more
- 30:46quickly here because again, ultimately the goal is to
- 30:49preserve wealth of the pensioners and the institutions
- 30:53where this capital is being preserved.
- 30:55And part of that is timing. And you can stomach the
- 30:58volatility if you if you enter the market at the right time.
- 31:02Yeah, that's it. It's a great point.
- 31:04Like Paul, that was a a thing that obviously on your interview
- 31:08caught you didn't you didn't hedge.
- 31:10I think we got it. We're getting better at this as
- 31:12you know, Bitcoin enthusiasts of like the, the state of the
- 31:15world, all the things it's like look, we know what this thing
- 31:17is, we know where it can go. And you know, you made the
- 31:21comment of .1%, you know, it's just starting out in this one to
- 31:263% you forecasted for other pensions would be good just to
- 31:31share like how you, you know, you think about that.
- 31:33And then I don't know how much color you, you can't share, if
- 31:35you have any about, you know, to Marty's point, the homework that
- 31:38had been done before these ETFs, because I would imagine, you
- 31:41know, had been done 12 months prior.
- 31:43And with the ETFs launched, it was a little bit more of a
- 31:45formality from investment committee before the allocation
- 31:47was made. You know, how that played in or
- 31:52anything you could share there? Because I think that's important
- 31:54from just like anybody that's sitting around, whether it's a,
- 31:57you know, a publicly traded companies, small business or
- 32:01sitting at a larger institution like the, the groundwork starts
- 32:046 to 12 plus months before when you're giving the books out to
- 32:08individuals that ask you about it, not the, you know, the
- 32:10moment the ETF launches. Yeah.
- 32:13I mean, so in, in terms of the one to 3%, I, I, you know, I'm
- 32:19not sure there's magic. And if, if it's, you know, 2%
- 32:23versus 3%. What I do know is that, you
- 32:27know, this cycle or next cycle, it's going to be probably easy
- 32:30to be 10X up at some point. And so even if you're taking a
- 32:34conservative approach like Wisconsin and you're .1%, you
- 32:39know, but I think between this cycle and the next cycle, it's
- 32:42not hard to see that 10X ING. And so then you all of a sudden
- 32:44are at, you know, a one or two percent by just doing nothing.
- 32:47And so I think the fact you're sort of dip your toe in suggests
- 32:53that if you stick around for the ride, you will end up at a
- 32:55larger allocation. And people see this in their own
- 32:57portfolios all the time, right? When you buy Bitcoin and can
- 33:01hold out at least through a cycle, what started out as a
- 33:04small percentage in your portfolio just inevitably ends
- 33:06up as a larger percentage. You know, I think people, you
- 33:11know, on a personal level, I, I've had some people asking for,
- 33:14you know, 1 to 3%, you know, like what an individual should
- 33:16do. And I, I think it's a whole
- 33:17nother animal. If you're an individual person,
- 33:19I think probably 1 to 3% is too low.
- 33:22But I, I on the, on the pension fund in terms of the homework,
- 33:25you know, it's interesting, I'm not sure I have any, you know,
- 33:29proprietary or you know, secret sauce.
- 33:31I could share with anyone on what, you know, the state
- 33:34investment board and the homework they did.
- 33:36I think the stuff that people have been talking about for a
- 33:38while now, which is the complications around holding
- 33:42your own keys from a casino institutional level.
- 33:46I think that's real. And I also think whether we like
- 33:49it or not, the BlackRock and Fidelity stamp is real.
- 33:54You know, Grayscale's been in the business for a while, so
- 33:55that's a little bit different. But at the end of the day,
- 34:01people are going to, they're going to do their homework at at
- 34:05their own rate, right? And I think in Wisconsin, and I
- 34:08guess I'm kind of Patton, Wisconsin on the back here, you
- 34:13know, Wisconsin is Wisconsin's a very purple state, right?
- 34:17I mean, it's sort of a politically divided state.
- 34:22And I think in some senses that reflects well on the state's
- 34:26like educational background. And so it just doesn't surprise
- 34:29me that we have people on the investment board who actually
- 34:33are there like as fiduciaries doing the best interest in
- 34:37making the best investments in other states.
- 34:40I just, there's too many political factors.
- 34:42I don't want to like throw, you know, some of the other specific
- 34:45states that are underfunded, you know, under the bus.
- 34:49But, you know, when you just look at like how Wisconsin is
- 34:52governed in general, it does not surprise me that the people on
- 34:56the board did their homework. And, you know, when I talk to
- 34:59students about this or even people who come to my office,
- 35:01it's this. I tell them the same thing.
- 35:04Bitcoin is a homework test. Tell me what you know about
- 35:08Bitcoin and I will tell you how much homework you did.
- 35:10And so I just think that we're going to see this, you know,
- 35:14replicate across other pension funds, like show me the
- 35:17allocation you made and I'll show you the homework you did.
- 35:19And if guess what, if it's zero, I can show you the homework you
- 35:22did. You didn't do your homework,
- 35:24right? And if it's and if it's .1,
- 35:27well, you probably did some homework.
- 35:28And if you're the first pension and it's .1, you probably did a
- 35:32lot of homework. But but the anti other states
- 35:34are on notice now, right? So the other states are on
- 35:37notice to do their own homework and them them, you know,
- 35:42investing at .1 doesn't suggest they had done the same homework,
- 35:45right? For them to do the same homework
- 35:47as Wisconsin is going to take a 2% investment.
- 35:50And so that's just how I see this playing out across the
- 35:53states. And here here's, here's my quick
- 35:57view of, of the the homework of 0% doesn't make sense if you're,
- 36:03if you're a pension and your mandate is purely to be
- 36:05defensive and have like a, a, a, you know, an allocation,
- 36:11representative allocation across all asset classes.
- 36:14Well, Bitcoin is 0.1% of all the assets in the world.
- 36:17So if, if that's part of your mandate, you should have a 0.1%
- 36:20allocation. But if you include A1 to 2%
- 36:25allocation, which is this comes from an excellent report that 2
- 36:29Ocean Trust put out, your overall portfolio not only
- 36:33receives better performance, but actually reduced volatility in
- 36:38the aggregate because it's not correlated.
- 36:40The volatility with Bitcoin is not correlated with the
- 36:42volatility in other assets. So that's a kind of Holy Grail
- 36:46status. So it makes sense to have one to
- 36:482%. But if you go further down
- 36:51understanding Bitcoin, you realize that it it's an asset
- 36:54that's going to perform 30 to 45% in Paul's opinion.
- 36:58And I share that opinion on a Kager basis.
- 37:02And so that makes it a better asset, more attractive asset
- 37:05class than anything else in your portfolio.
- 37:06So you should probably have more than one to 2%.
- 37:09But like, you know, those are your your clear checkpoints of
- 37:15understanding. And the only one in there that
- 37:17doesn't make any sense is to maintain a 0% allocation.
- 37:23Paul, can you, you reference like the, the purple blood and
- 37:27there's a comment of innovative pension and then like just you
- 37:31in general feeling comfortable and talking to your students
- 37:35about Bitcoin. Like what is it in the the
- 37:37culture, whether it's the exact school you're at or in the state
- 37:40that people feel comfortable because like this stuff, even
- 37:43though we have ETFs and we all feel OK about talking about,
- 37:45it's still like kind of taboo at that level.
- 37:48Like just curious, like how you were able to get to that point.
- 37:51I think it's just interesting but also can provide a framework
- 37:53for others to like, naturally feel out and they don't feel
- 37:56like they're going to get themselves in some trouble or
- 37:58lose their job. Yeah, that's, that's an
- 38:01interesting question. So I would, I guess I'll start
- 38:04off by saying in this again, this is just me wearing a
- 38:08professor's hat on this. But you know, when you're, when
- 38:11you're like in front of a class teaching all day, one of the
- 38:14first things you learn about when you first get in the
- 38:17academic world is you're really only nervous about talking about
- 38:21stuff you don't know. And so if, if you actually know
- 38:25what you're talking about, it's not that nerve wracking to talk
- 38:28about it, right. And so I think from, you know,
- 38:31my perspective, when I have people sort of funneling through
- 38:36it, it doesn't, you know, I'm not like walking on pins and
- 38:38needles talking about this because I'm, I'm confident that
- 38:42like, I basically did the homework, right.
- 38:44So like, it's like it's, it's just like walking into exam, if
- 38:47you did, if you prepared, you're not nervous.
- 38:50Walk into the exam the same way. Like if you're playing in a big
- 38:52sports game, if you prepared, you're not nervous for the game,
- 38:56your preparation is fine. So I think for me personally,
- 38:59that's just sort of just a starting point.
- 39:01Now, I'm not going to pretend that there's, you know, Bitcoin
- 39:04has all these all these things that like leak out in different
- 39:08areas. I don't want to pretend that I'm
- 39:09an expert in every possible area.
- 39:11I don't think anyone is. But so I think from a personal
- 39:15perspective, that's just, that's my approach.
- 39:17And then I think from, you know, like a, a, a whitewater
- 39:20perspective. And, and I don't know if I
- 39:22should say like Wisconsin in general, but I'll just say like
- 39:24from whitewater, you know, whitewater, we take a lot of
- 39:28pride in like having innovative things early on.
- 39:31And so one example people talk about at whitewater is I think
- 39:34we were one of the first universities back in the 90s to
- 39:36have like an online program. And you know, nowadays it's like
- 39:41everyone has an online program, no big deal.
- 39:43And that's something that kind of gets brought up all the time,
- 39:46like, you know, we should be pushing the needle on stuff.
- 39:49And so I know when I went to the the Dean on this and talked to
- 39:52him about this, one of the things I brought up is I know, I
- 39:56know bitcoins going to be loaded with fun and misunderstanding
- 39:59and I'll probably get pushed back.
- 40:01But it is the definition. It is a perfect analog to the
- 40:07Internet in the 1990s. And I, you know, I wasn't
- 40:10teaching in the 1990s, but. I'm confident if I was here,
- 40:14there would have been tons of FUD around.
- 40:16Well, no one's going to take online classes.
- 40:18It's a waste of money. We don't have the band.
- 40:20We don't have the bandwidth or technology or all this stuff,
- 40:23right? And all those same arguments for
- 40:26me just stood perfectly parallel in Bitcoin.
- 40:29And so I sort of always felt comfortable because, you know, I
- 40:33know I'm on the right side of this.
- 40:35And you know, I, like I said, it's my job to transform
- 40:38students, right? And can I do that through
- 40:41teaching tax law and accounting and lots of other things like
- 40:43that? Yes.
- 40:44Can I do it at a greater degree with Bitcoin?
- 40:48Absolutely. So for me that that's why I
- 40:52don't have to like hem and hob here about, Oh, you know, we
- 40:54should be diversifying and oh, you know, the students need to
- 40:56learn a little about it. Like I've for for me personally,
- 41:00I feel like this is the right thing for the students to be
- 41:03learning about. You know, whether the students
- 41:05buy it or tell their parents to buy, I could care less, but they
- 41:09have to, they have to learn about it.
- 41:11They have to, you know, you have to have done your homework and
- 41:15competently dismissed it. You can't fake it and say, well,
- 41:19I, you know, I spent two hours and here's my two cents.
- 41:21It's like, no, you have to like have hold your own keys, right?
- 41:24You need to have set up multi sig.
- 41:26You need to like know how this stuff works.
- 41:27And so for me, that's that's been my approach all along.
- 41:32It's very cool. There's no shortage.
- 41:34We had Rich Kerr, 33 year Charles Schwab vet and he was
- 41:38well on the the pod last week and he called out how, and I
- 41:41don't know if it was 17 or 19. It was one year where somebody
- 41:44brought it up at a local regional, you know, where he was
- 41:46working. And he's like, oh, it's just he
- 41:48was embarrassed by his response. But it was that humility to
- 41:51reference that his response was there and then he went and did
- 41:53the homework eventually. And I think that's a big point
- 41:56for everybody. It's just like this natural,
- 41:59easy way to dismiss it because you know, the world is easy to
- 42:02dismiss when things look too good.
- 42:04But the reality is, if you dig a little deeper, there's a lot
- 42:06more happening. Well.
- 42:09And Paul, to your point earlier, it's never been easier to do
- 42:11your homework on Bitcoin specifically.
- 42:14The amount of literature that's out there that form fits to
- 42:18particular people with a particular set of mind and
- 42:21connect with them is richer than it's ever been in Bitcoin's
- 42:25history. Like there's no excuse to to say
- 42:28you didn't do your homework. It's cognitive dissonance at
- 42:31this point if you're dismissing Bitcoin as it's succeeding right
- 42:36in front of your face. Which all of this begs the
- 42:38question too, like from your seat at the university and as a
- 42:44Wisconsin, a Wisconsin pensioner, Wisconsin pensioner
- 42:48back-to-back is making me say Wisconsin.
- 42:50I don't know why. I'm sorry for that, But like,
- 42:56what do you think this does to again and cite that like the
- 42:59shot across the bow, Like do you think people are dismissing the
- 43:03allocation by the pension system?
- 43:05Do you think people will see what you're doing at Whitewater
- 43:08and say, hey, that's cute, but we're still going to hold out?
- 43:11Or you think now that it's becoming abundantly clear that
- 43:15states like Wisconsin and universities like the University
- 43:17of Wisconsin Whitewater are thinking about this seriously,
- 43:21that people in institutions around the country are moving
- 43:25rapidly to say we have to have a position on this?
- 43:28So, yeah, so I actually think, I don't know if you guys are what,
- 43:32which states you guys are all in right now, but I, I'll, I'll
- 43:36take the I actually think Wisconsin is, I don't know if
- 43:40you guys have thought about in this context or not.
- 43:43I actually think in, in a lot of ways, the fact Wisconsin is
- 43:47leading the way on this is a very, very, I, I don't want to
- 43:54say sneaky good, but it, but it, it is sort of the best case
- 43:58scenario. And I like, I have plenty of
- 44:02friends. I have plenty of friends who
- 44:03live in Texas, right. And I don't want to suggest that
- 44:05if Texas was first, that would be bad or anything.
- 44:10I love Texas too, but I think if you had a state that was
- 44:15politically one way or the other, you know, solid blue or
- 44:19solid red, I think that adds like a, you know, a politics
- 44:24aspect to Bitcoin that's just not really needed.
- 44:27And to have a state like Wisconsin where you can go back
- 44:30and look at the past 20 years of politics or even longer.
- 44:33Wisconsin, you know, Wisconsin's a very interestingly purple
- 44:36state, right? We have big metropolitan areas,
- 44:40lots of rural areas. It's sort of splits, you know,
- 44:44Trump, Biden, I think this type of state going first or, you
- 44:50know, being among the first is, is, is critical.
- 44:53And I think it makes it easier for other states to follow as
- 44:57opposed to if it was a state that's sort of like in the news
- 45:00all the time on the political spectrum one way or the other.
- 45:02So that's how I that's how I see Wisconsin leading the way here.
- 45:07Totally would would love the next handful of pensions to be
- 45:11all the swing state pensions just to put that, you know, make
- 45:16that a politically off, you know, off the table sort of
- 45:20target, you know, because you got to win votes.
- 45:25I think that's a great point that if if, though ironically,
- 45:28since since now the White House has taken a, a, a negative on
- 45:34crypto stance, it would be kind of good for a blue state to
- 45:40embrace it. But you know, given the highly
- 45:43politicized and aligned nature of things, I think that the fact
- 45:47that the White House has taken that anti crypto stance recently
- 45:52makes it less likely for a blue state to embrace it at a pension
- 45:57level versus a red state. But thank goodness for for the
- 46:00purple states first. Whether you're a seasoned
- 46:03bitcoiner or brand new to the asset class, On Ramp provides a
- 46:06best in class private client experience to ensure that your
- 46:09Bitcoin remains accessible, secure, and in your control.
- 46:13You'll have a dedicated advisor to guide you every step of the
- 46:15way. If you want to meet in person,
- 46:17we now have On Ramp branches in New York, New Jersey,
- 46:20Philadelphia, Nashville, Dallas, Austin, Houston, Los Angeles,
- 46:25and Denver, with more on the way.
- 46:27Check out on rampbitcoin.com/branches to
- 46:30learn more and get connected with our team.
- 46:33And with all this in mind, I mean, Jesse, you may be able to
- 46:35answer this and Paul as well, but thinking about what this
- 46:39could do in terms of a catalyst for inflows to Bitcoin
- 46:43specifically, I mean state of Wisconsin pension, 180 billion
- 46:48ten basis point allocation. Now let's push that up to the
- 46:52high end of the range that's been put out there, 3%, that's
- 46:55$5.4 billion that would be allocated to Bitcoin within this
- 47:00one pension. Like how much flow do you think
- 47:04we'll see if this allocation doesn't say FOMO and people
- 47:08start wising up and saying, all right, we need to make an
- 47:10allocation and then they they start pouring in a.
- 47:16Great question, Paul, if you have any thoughts on this, I I
- 47:18have my high level, but but yeah.
- 47:21Yeah, I think it what what's interesting is you know, Marty,
- 47:24original point about when people the timing of when people buy.
- 47:27So if you push it out, say 18 months and they're buying at the
- 47:30peak, you know, their, their Fiat is actually getting them
- 47:33the least amount of Bitcoin possible in that, in that, you
- 47:37know, peak. So, you know, I, I don't, I
- 47:40really don't know. I just don't have a sense for
- 47:43the timing on all of this is fuzzy to me, right?
- 47:46And I think I would just for me, I, I, I like my step back on
- 47:50this is we're clearly going through the store value phase.
- 47:56And when you're in the store value of phase, very difficult
- 48:00to know the timing of when things are going to happen.
- 48:03And so I think that dipping the toes in those allocations just
- 48:07become bigger over time. But the timing, who goes first
- 48:12or who goes next and at what percentages, I sort of feel, I,
- 48:16I feel like it's predicting. It's like predicting, you know,
- 48:18the, the congressional swings on this stuff, right?
- 48:21It's like, you know, one day Trump hates Bitcoin, the next
- 48:24day he's accepting political donations.
- 48:26Who knew? Well, I don't know, it's just,
- 48:28you know, it's like how the winds blew or something.
- 48:30And so that's sort of how I feel like the initial wave is going
- 48:33to come. I think once everyone's got,
- 48:36once, you know, we cross some threshold of 25 states or 35
- 48:40states who have invested in it, then I think the question of
- 48:44total flows becomes really interesting.
- 48:48Because I don't see a path where once states turn on the flows
- 48:53and investments that they're going to turn it off because
- 48:57that, that only suggests they like did their homework and then
- 49:00somehow lost their homework. So maybe a, maybe a board turns
- 49:04over or something like that. But other than that, I, it's the
- 49:08same way on a personal level, right?
- 49:09People generally don't do their homework and just buy 10 bucks a
- 49:12Bitcoin, right? They do their homework and buy
- 49:15more and more and more. And I just see the pension funds
- 49:17doing the same thing. Yeah, totally agree.
- 49:20I, I think for me, this comes back to that the, you know, the,
- 49:23the Super zoomed out view of, you know, the currently the
- 49:28world's value is allocated to the traditional asset classes
- 49:32and there's this osmotic pressure to reallocate a small
- 49:39piece of that to Bitcoin. And that pressure will grow.
- 49:43It's almost like like a glacier going into summer, you know, and
- 49:47you got little drips coming off of it.
- 49:49And those, those drips are small in, in, in their localized
- 49:55areas, but then they trickle into Little River river rats.
- 49:59And then those rivers can converge into a bigger river.
- 50:04And you have a torrent of, of flow from the, from the old
- 50:09state to the new state. But you know, wherever you look
- 50:15from a grassroots point of view, it's a tiny, tiny little
- 50:19trickle. But it all adds up.
- 50:20And I think, you know, I think that's, I think that's the, the,
- 50:25the process that we're living through in general, as the
- 50:29world's assets will be reallocated from the traditional
- 50:33norms and, and into the digital future to accommodate the
- 50:39reality that Bitcoin imposes portfolios, which is to say that
- 50:44here's this asset that's a better store value asset, has
- 50:47better properties and is likely to outperform all of the
- 50:52traditional store value assets. And so that economic reality
- 50:56will be imposed little by little, a trickle at a time on
- 51:03the, on the microscopic level, like if you, if you go talk to
- 51:06any pension, if you go talk to any individual, they might be
- 51:09thinking about a small allocation, but that grows over
- 51:12time. And and each of those
- 51:13individuals making those decisions adds up to a torrent.
- 51:18And one other thing I just would add to this and, and from my own
- 51:21perspective, I think what makes timing so fuzzy on this, I don't
- 51:26have. And I, I like to think of myself
- 51:29as like having done as much homework on this as possible,
- 51:32but I don't actually feel like I have good historical analogies
- 51:37of one asset coming in. You know, we like to use the
- 51:40apex predator analogy. I don't have a good example I
- 51:45can think of where we've introduced another asset that
- 51:51sucked the monetary premium out of other assets.
- 51:56You know, like, I know they exist, right?
- 51:58Like, so at some point gold would have done this, right?
- 52:04Yeah. But but when you think about,
- 52:06you think about these other assets that have done this in
- 52:08history, they were in such different economic environments,
- 52:13you know, it was not like in modern society.
- 52:16It's happened. So it's really hard for me to
- 52:19under to think about to think about the how this stuff goes
- 52:22over. You know, I know people like
- 52:23talk about S curves and adoption rates, but if you're thinking
- 52:26about it in terms of sucking monetary premium out, 'cause
- 52:30that is actually where like dollar for dollar comes,
- 52:32something comes out of real estate into Bitcoin or out of
- 52:35some, some other asset into Bitcoin.
- 52:38That to me, it's, it's really hard to think about what we have
- 52:41in modern society. And you know, the only examples
- 52:45I can think of which are not great examples are it's, it's
- 52:48kind of like the Internet came in and did this to like, you
- 52:51know, brick and mortar companies.
- 52:52So I guess we could look at maybe, you know, like Sears or
- 52:55something like that or Boston store, but even that is not
- 53:00nearly at the level of money. And so I it's just, it's very
- 53:05hard for me to think about this timeline of like how funds come
- 53:09in when it's like this, these dollars competing, sucking up
- 53:13monetary premium of different assets.
- 53:15I don't know if you guys think of it like that, but that's what
- 53:17makes it tough for me. I think there's AI think there's
- 53:19a big component of the human nature aspect of it as well.
- 53:22Like everybody here is talking to other individuals that have
- 53:25been, are now talking to other individuals about this asset,
- 53:28from pensions to publicly private, you know, businesses on
- 53:33treasury management, family offices.
- 53:36And you know, whether it's ETF, the polarization of it or, you
- 53:40know, a pension coming in, everybody's having the
- 53:42discussion and everybody's looking at I'm not everybody,
- 53:45but different cohorts are looking at it as potentially,
- 53:49you know, like we're we're watching it.
- 53:51We're we're having views. Or I remember last year at this
- 53:53time, the price of Bitcoin was whatever $25,000 and you kind of
- 53:57crazy. And now the conversations are
- 53:59coming back like, Oh yeah, I would love to chat.
- 54:01Not in not interested whenever allocate, but would love to
- 54:03learn a little more. And so that that conversation,
- 54:06you know, you think about it as the price appreciates, call it
- 54:09end of this year, next year or whatever it looks like.
- 54:11Well, it's impossible to forecast.
- 54:13What does the committee and the group look like that's been
- 54:16looking at this for the past now 18 months versus 6 or whatever
- 54:20the number is and who goes in? And then to Marty's point, kind
- 54:23of like, you know, apes in and now is sitting underwater and
- 54:26what that volatility. That's why we've always thought
- 54:28like volatility always kind of looks similar to how it has
- 54:30been, at least for the past couple epochs.
- 54:32It's just the the pools of capital coming in and and it's
- 54:35still run by humans. I would say be remiss to say
- 54:39like the, the education doesn't stop, you know with the ETF,
- 54:44Paul, I don't know if you're familiar with like what we do
- 54:47and independent of what we do. There's just this natural
- 54:49problem of the the idea that 90% of the ETF sit at at Coinbase
- 54:53and a pension coming in may not look past the not this.
- 54:59I would imagine not all would do this, but there's this natural
- 55:02idea that somebody looks at the number and the and number go up
- 55:05in the price on a screen. But going back and remembering
- 55:08why they stayed away from it. Some maybe because it looks like
- 55:11upon the other, maybe because it looks like if I allocate it
- 55:14won't be there because of an exchange hacker insolvency and
- 55:17all the things that have been mired in the industry.
- 55:19There is this reality that like the end state isn't an ETF and
- 55:22there's a number of things that somebody may want out of
- 55:25bitcoins exposure outside of just the dollar liquidity or the
- 55:28profile against the dollar. And this nature of it sitting at
- 55:32a single custodian and the risk that comes along with it or the
- 55:35asset, the aspect of like, maybe you want to take the delivery
- 55:38because you need to use it and you know, an economy.
- 55:42There's a lot of things that like continue down the path
- 55:45outside of just the ETF. And so I think that's an
- 55:47important function as individuals go in.
- 55:49It's like it's one, it's the first step, but it's just the
- 55:52beginning when it comes to the allocation via like a BlackRock
- 55:56vehicle. Yep.
- 55:58Go ahead, Paul. Yeah.
- 56:00I mean, I think, you know, this kind of gets into the whole
- 56:02discussion of should, you know, should institutions be holding
- 56:05their own keys. And I think, you know, I think
- 56:10people have people have different views on on the ETF
- 56:15side, you know, is it, is it sort of additive to the whole
- 56:19space of people holding their own keys?
- 56:20I mean, I guess my current position, which I'm happy to
- 56:23change if this is wrong, but my current position is, I think
- 56:27the, I think the ETFs are probably Trojan horses for
- 56:30people learning about it and eventually holding their own
- 56:32keys, but getting institutions right to, to set up the, you
- 56:36know, the key structure and you know, the, the revolving door.
- 56:40So I'll just guys, I'll give you an example here.
- 56:43We've, we've done like thought experiments at the university
- 56:46about like if the university gets Bitcoin sent to us in a
- 56:50donation form and maybe this would be fun conversation.
- 56:54Who on The Who at the university you should hold the keys to?
- 56:59So how many keys should we have? So like what?
- 57:01What should be the multi sig set up and how and how many
- 57:06signature should we have at the university if we wanted to hold
- 57:09our own keys? Do you guys, do you guys have
- 57:11thoughts on that? Oh, yes, yes, we do you.
- 57:14You've happened to stray into our core business here.
- 57:18I guess our perspective is that it doesn't make sense for
- 57:21institutions to be grappling with these issues.
- 57:24It, it, it demands competencies and, and capabilities and
- 57:29systems and processes that are very difficult to build and get
- 57:35comfortable with and manage and maintain a huge, you know,
- 57:39technical learning curve that everybody on the investment
- 57:42committee would have to, you know, get a sufficient amount of
- 57:47familiarity with cryptographic materials and how Bitcoin works
- 57:50and, and how to maintain perfect security.
- 57:53And then, you know, implement and establish and implement all
- 57:58those systems such that it doesn't make sense.
- 58:00It doesn't make sense for an institution to be holding their
- 58:04own keys in a in a multi sig set up, but it also doesn't make
- 58:09sense for an institution to trust Coinbase or any other
- 58:15third party custodian with unilateral control of their keys
- 58:19because frankly, because Bitcoin allows you to have a better form
- 58:23of security with multi sig and you it's a shame if if
- 58:29institutions don't take advantage of that.
- 58:31So what, what on ramp does, has built and has pioneered is multi
- 58:37institution multi sig custody where you, you set up a, a, a, a
- 58:45two of three multi sig and the, and the end client doesn't have
- 58:50to hold their own keys. They don't have to set up their
- 58:52own keys. Instead, it's three different
- 58:55institutions that contribute a key.
- 59:00And, and so in on Ramp's case, that's that's on ramp Bitco and
- 59:04coincover and Bitco and coincover kind of the perfect
- 59:07partners for this because this is what they do.
- 59:09You know, Bitco's been around for 10 years and and invented
- 59:13multi sig and so those are your key holders on behalf of the
- 59:18institution. So in that sense, you managed to
- 59:20take the advantages of Bitcoins multi sig and then wrap that in
- 59:25a, in a legal Tradfi relationship that is familiar to
- 59:31an investment committee. And then that is the
- 59:35relationship by which the control of the assets is
- 59:38governed. And importantly, crucially,
- 59:41there each of those 3 institutions that hold a key on
- 59:45behalf of the client do not have unilateral control because they
- 59:50only hold one key. And so it's the end client that
- 59:53retains control of the assets in the multi sig without themselves
- 59:58having to set up and maintain a key.
- 1:00:03So that's, that's what that's our business.
- 1:00:05That's what we do. And it's because of this problem
- 1:00:08that institutions face of. You know, how do you how do you
- 1:00:11set up and maintain custody of your of your Bitcoin?
- 1:00:17You know, the options to date are trust Coinbase or do it
- 1:00:19yourself, and neither of them really solve for or or take
- 1:00:25advantage of the benefits of multi sig while also, you know,
- 1:00:32solving for the user error that could crop up and and the
- 1:00:36massive amount of setup knowledge and proficiency that's
- 1:00:42necessary in order to master your own multi sig.
- 1:00:45So yeah, that's what we do. Yep.
- 1:00:47Paul, one of the things I think you're probably wondering or you
- 1:00:51references like you mentioned a pension's not going to set that
- 1:00:54up or do spot custody. And we had it announced today,
- 1:00:58Mark Connors joined from three IQ.
- 1:01:01He was at AETP provider in in Canada, traditional Wall Street
- 1:01:05background selling private or this was a public vehicle.
- 1:01:09Where we started was effectively with a grayscale competitor at
- 1:01:13the time pre ETF, which was the underlying leveraging the same
- 1:01:16multi institution custody with the so you benefit from you know
- 1:01:20what Jesse was referencing. If an exchange or something
- 1:01:22happens to a key holder, your assets are OK, but then the
- 1:01:25kicker is you allow for delivery and that's when you really start
- 1:01:29getting into like a best in class product.
- 1:01:31And so that's the the angle like we'll get heavier with this drum
- 1:01:34beat in the sense of like there's a lot of narrative
- 1:01:38that's coming up and it'll continue where more and more of
- 1:01:41the ETFs are being housed. Or you know, I think it's 90%
- 1:01:44now whatever. I guess it's what is it
- 1:01:461,000,000 coins, so 900 KBTC in just the ETF sitting at
- 1:01:53Coinbase. And obviously that will increase
- 1:01:55as the ETF flows. And so there's just a natural
- 1:01:58narrative we think will will continue to grow, especially if
- 1:02:00you can't take delivery, which will, you know, as people who to
- 1:02:04your point get educated, that becomes an A Trojan horse into
- 1:02:09understanding the asset. And then you may wake up and
- 1:02:11realize you don't want 3 million BTC sitting at Coinbase.
- 1:02:14But if you have an ETF, you're effectively have to sell the
- 1:02:17position depending on your account, have a taxable event
- 1:02:21because you're not going to be able to take delivery.
- 1:02:23And so this is the point of like education.
- 1:02:25It's like the education to the point of the ETF starts, but it
- 1:02:27doesn't really end there. And that's a big part of like
- 1:02:30what we're doing here. Yeah.
- 1:02:32And I just you know to add to that or just to sort of comment
- 1:02:34on you guys points. So I mean, I think one, and that
- 1:02:38maybe you guys make this argument already, but I think
- 1:02:41you know, one of the arguments for getting away from the ETFs
- 1:02:43too and to multi institutional custody or however you want to
- 1:02:47design it is, you know, the ETFs are charging, you know, albeit a
- 1:02:52small percentage fee every year. And that that fee looks small
- 1:02:59and feels small, especially over short time frames.
- 1:03:03But if you're, if you're a public institution where the
- 1:03:07duration for the time you hold it, like I said, should probably
- 1:03:09be permanent, that fee is compounding permanently.
- 1:03:15So I would probably argue that setting some other design system
- 1:03:19up is probably a better way to manage your fees long term.
- 1:03:23What then, then, then this, even if the ETF fee is maybe smaller
- 1:03:27to start with as your balance grows, to me, it probably
- 1:03:31doesn't make sense to, to be holding the ETF products for
- 1:03:35long periods of time, right? You're just going to see, I, I
- 1:03:38know even if the, the compound, you know, growth rate is going
- 1:03:40to be great, but you, you still don't want to negate any of that
- 1:03:45over time. And so I would think if you're
- 1:03:48in permanent duration mode, you know, holding your own
- 1:03:51signatures or whatever, however you design multi institutional
- 1:03:54probably is a better mode forward for some of these larger
- 1:03:57pensions. Yeah.
- 1:03:59Yeah, a couple other considerations there.
- 1:04:01This is a little different for pensions because they're they're
- 1:04:05tax exempt. But you know if, like if, if for
- 1:04:07a holder who's who's holding ETFs, they are they don't allow
- 1:04:12any kind redemption, right. So if you decide at some point
- 1:04:15that you want to take possession of your assets, your, your
- 1:04:18Bitcoin and you're not tax exempt, well then you, if you
- 1:04:22want to do that, you're suddenly hit with a 20%, maybe 30%
- 1:04:27depending on the state you're you're living in, hit to your
- 1:04:30assets as, as you have to, you have a taxable event upon
- 1:04:34redemption and then you use those proceeds to buy Bitcoin.
- 1:04:37So we're right there. You know, you could be looking
- 1:04:40at 2030% hit. And then there's the other
- 1:04:42problem of of, you know, if if you're trusting the ETF now and
- 1:04:48into the future, that's great while it's small.
- 1:04:52But if Bitcoin continues to become a bigger and bigger part
- 1:04:57of the financial system, we could enter a timeline where the
- 1:05:05US realizes a little bit late that accumulating Bitcoin is
- 1:05:10imperative to, you know, geopolitical success.
- 1:05:14And you could, you could enter a scenario where there's incentive
- 1:05:18TO61O2 or, you know, seize some Bitcoin and then the, the ETFs
- 1:05:25being held at Coinbase would be the number one target on that
- 1:05:29list. Unfortunately, you know, so, so
- 1:05:32that's a scenario where you could think you're great and
- 1:05:36then it turns into a zero because unknowingly you gave up
- 1:05:41control of your assets when you entered the ETF in the 1st
- 1:05:45place. And, and that's one of the, the
- 1:05:48advantages of self custody, but also multi institution custody
- 1:05:51is that the end user maintains control.
- 1:05:55And that's so important for people to be thinking about, you
- 1:05:59know, whether when they're evaluating whether to go into an
- 1:06:01ETF or a different product. Yeah, I and the other thing
- 1:06:05that's interesting too, and the, I think the elephant in the room
- 1:06:07with with Coinbase and BlackRock, you know, as of right
- 1:06:10now, you know, Ibid is a is a fraction of Black Rock's assets,
- 1:06:16but given enough time, it actually there, you know.
- 1:06:23Yeah, exactly. And so I think, I think the, the
- 1:06:26thing that makes everyone kind of uncomfortable to, to think
- 1:06:29about is, well, if something were to happen to Coinbase right
- 1:06:33now, I think everyone thinks, oh, you know, Black Rock's just
- 1:06:37big enough, they'll, they'll make it right.
- 1:06:39You know, they'll refund everyone.
- 1:06:41But there's going to come a point in time where even
- 1:06:44BlackRock can't do that. The time might not be now or 10
- 1:06:47years from now or 30 years from now, but it, it can and could
- 1:06:51happen. And so the question is, is do
- 1:06:54you sort of play out that scenario and hope for the best
- 1:06:59and hope that BlackRock is just always big enough to sort of
- 1:07:02bail its own customers out in the event something to happen to
- 1:07:04Coinbase? Or do you avoid that to begin
- 1:07:06with? So that's why listen, that's why
- 1:07:09I think the ETF is great for people to dip their toe in or
- 1:07:12for people who don't want to do the homework.
- 1:07:14But for just about everyone else, you know it's an inferior
- 1:07:17product. Yeah, for clarity, totally agree
- 1:07:20with you. I, I think the ETFs are a great
- 1:07:22way for people to dip their toe, learn about it, realize they
- 1:07:25want to own actual Bitcoin. And, and then to the other side
- 1:07:30of things, like if an institution can figure out how
- 1:07:34to educate everybody that needs to be educated on the investment
- 1:07:38committee, committee or whatever and get everybody on board with
- 1:07:42like here's what you need to know about cryptographic
- 1:07:44material, how we're going to set up a multi sig, how we're going
- 1:07:47to run it. The the operationalization of
- 1:07:50those, you know, checks and balances and, and system, system
- 1:07:54is systematizing of all, all of the things that you need to do
- 1:07:58at an institutional level to maintain that and, and run that.
- 1:08:02If they can do that, great. That's like, that's probably the
- 1:08:04best way for an institution to, you know, seize their own self
- 1:08:09sovereignty in the Bitcoin landscape.
- 1:08:11But my sense is that that is an incredibly high barrier.
- 1:08:17And instead you see the behavior, you tend to see the
- 1:08:20behavior of you know what, I'm going to trust Coinbase because
- 1:08:24that'll be way easier and they know what they're doing.
- 1:08:27And I think that the hidden sacrifice and trade off that
- 1:08:32many institutions are, are are making when they default to the
- 1:08:36easy, you know, Coinbase option. I think that is it there there
- 1:08:43are bigger risks there than many institutions realize when they
- 1:08:47are are giving up control of their Bitcoin to to a a company
- 1:08:56that could be is a black box. Ultimately how they're how
- 1:09:00they're maintaining custody and security of those assets is a
- 1:09:04black box. And then of course, the the
- 1:09:06legal layer, the the 61 O2 threat is non 0.
- 1:09:12So you know that I think those are I think if an institution
- 1:09:16can get to multi sig and can set that up, they absolutely should.
- 1:09:20That's fantastic. And if they can't, they should
- 1:09:23be wary of giving over unilateral control of their
- 1:09:27funds to an ETF or to Coinbase, or to any third party custodian.
- 1:09:33I think, yeah, go ahead, Marty. Well, I was going to say, I
- 1:09:37think you may like I think in kind redemptions at some point
- 1:09:41in the next five years going to become table stakes, not
- 1:09:43necessarily for not necessarily for the fiduciaries of these
- 1:09:49funds, but for the end beneficiaries.
- 1:09:51They're going to say, hey, hey, like I don't want you getting
- 1:09:54paper exposure to the selling at a big tax loss then not being
- 1:09:58able to take any kind, especially if what you believe
- 1:10:01and I think we all believe is going to happen if Bitcoin
- 1:10:03begins to suck out the monetary premium from all these different
- 1:10:07assets, the US dollar in the treasury system included, like
- 1:10:10you're not going to want to sell that for dollars and then
- 1:10:12quickly get back into the asset. And so I think in kind
- 1:10:17redemptions will become table stakes will be driven by
- 1:10:19beneficiaries of all these different pension funds and
- 1:10:22endowments that say hey, like you need delivery of the good
- 1:10:25stuff. We don't need paper exposure for
- 1:10:28this. Yeah.
- 1:10:29The beauty of this whole market is it's going to be it's either
- 1:10:32like on the pension side or, you know, corporate treasuries that
- 1:10:35have their banking partners and they say, hey, BNY or whoever,
- 1:10:39like either participate and hold a key or we take our money and
- 1:10:42we go somewhere else. Like that's how this this this
- 1:10:45concept. I know it's probably a little
- 1:10:46newer, Paul, but like it's pretty straightforward to the
- 1:10:48keys. Instead of living with an
- 1:10:50individual, they just live with an institution.
- 1:10:52You can break down like Jesse was being fair or nice to the
- 1:10:55institutions. They they can't hold keys even
- 1:10:57if they won't or at the level of what exists today, if it's
- 1:10:59anything related to consumer grade devices, because churn is
- 1:11:02too big of an issue. If you hold cryptographic
- 1:11:04material and you have a seed and somebody leaves, now you have to
- 1:11:06burn it all down just to restart it.
- 1:11:08Like you can get to institutional grade like
- 1:11:10sharding and all that, but that requires sales and engineers to
- 1:11:12go and didn't do that. So right now it's really not.
- 1:11:15Yeah, operationally, it's just like it's almost impossible
- 1:11:17because you could always move the assets off off platform if
- 1:11:20two people go rogue, which just makes it very difficult.
- 1:11:25And honestly, guys, I think I think this is this all a matter
- 1:11:27of time. So I, I view a lot of this as,
- 1:11:30you know, like the, the difficulty now people have in so
- 1:11:34making like a transition from an so right now, like an ETF to
- 1:11:38some sort of multi sig set up. I think this is the equivalent
- 1:11:41of sending like an e-mail in 1992, right?
- 1:11:44It's just, you know, it's hard for everybody.
- 1:11:47Some people can do it, some people can't.
- 1:11:50You know, you just you can't probably, I'm sure there were
- 1:11:52companies that were successfully running meetings on e-mail in
- 1:11:551992, but it was probably just hard, right?
- 1:11:58What the, the way, the way I view it as if every year schools
- 1:12:02like Whitewater have 30 students graduating and those thirty
- 1:12:06students are going out in the industries and working all doing
- 1:12:09all types of stuff. At some point there will be a
- 1:12:12critical mass of people who have learned this when they were
- 1:12:1617/18/1920 and they're eventually on the corporate
- 1:12:19boards. And so when someone comes to
- 1:12:21them and says, hey, we want a multi sig set up, their thought
- 1:12:25is like, well, of course, this is like an e-mail, right?
- 1:12:28So we just have to like technologically get through to
- 1:12:32the point where there's like enough people in the room who
- 1:12:35don't blink at this and then it becomes, I think, pretty
- 1:12:37intuitive, but to but to the extent no one's familiar with
- 1:12:40the tech it I just think it's it gets really hard, right?
- 1:12:44You're you're essentially educating a whole bunch of
- 1:12:46people from Ground Zero and and multi sig.
- 1:12:49You don't want to do that, right?
- 1:12:50You want everyone to come in with like a base layer level of
- 1:12:53knowledge in. Bitcoin, you don't want to have
- 1:12:55to. You don't want to have to
- 1:12:56convince someone a multi sig who knows nothing about Bitcoin.
- 1:12:59You need them to come in. We we joke like we're making
- 1:13:04products for the market as it gets educated and to your point,
- 1:13:08like pensions and people that are fiduciaries, some of them
- 1:13:10have to do insane amount of diligence and risk.
- 1:13:13And so we're actively like what you're describing.
- 1:13:15They they sit at the highest level working with pensions, you
- 1:13:18know, by notion of educating like advisory firms is exactly
- 1:13:21what they exist for, right? To work with specialists to
- 1:13:23help. Because at a certain level, if
- 1:13:26you get that far into the details in the weeds, you look
- 1:13:28at like the S1 and Coinbase or the ETF basically says you're an
- 1:13:34unsecured creditor if Coinbase goes away in the S1 of the the
- 1:13:37Black Rock ETF. And so that's a non starter.
- 1:13:39They'd rather just not have a position at that level of like
- 1:13:42their brand is everything. And so to your point, it exists
- 1:13:45today, but over time, it's just a function of time and education
- 1:13:48that it'll just be more and more individuals start to look at
- 1:13:51that. And also it's like at a certain
- 1:13:52point it becomes less education and just a market standard,
- 1:13:55right? You just go to the place.
- 1:13:56It's the notion of like you don't test your food every time
- 1:13:58you want to eat it. It's just like doesn't kill you
- 1:14:01in the sense of like we're just been so early that you don't
- 1:14:04know if the exchange is going to kill you.
- 1:14:05And that's where there's been this like, you know, it's kept
- 1:14:07people out. Frankly I'm convinced like this
- 1:14:09idea of multi institution custody in the sense of it's
- 1:14:13just redundancies and fault tolerance built into the asset,
- 1:14:16that once it becomes standard the market price will increase
- 1:14:2010 to 100 X because everybody wants 10X the exposure they have
- 1:14:24in the Bitcoin. If it's zero, they want 10%.
- 1:14:26If it's ten, they want 100. They just don't feel
- 1:14:27comfortable. It'll be there when when they
- 1:14:29need it and historically it hasn't.
- 1:14:33Yeah, we yeah, we're, we're we're building a solution that
- 1:14:39so Paul to to the idea of like, you know, institutions will all
- 1:14:47have the competence, you know, of, of involved participants to
- 1:14:52understand multi segment and know what's necessary there.
- 1:14:55But then the the operational requirements of that will will
- 1:14:59always be prohibitive. I think because in, in a sense,
- 1:15:02what Bitcoin has made possible is you can be your own bank if
- 1:15:08you want to be, but God, is it hard to run a bank.
- 1:15:12You know, like if, if you're, if you're a pension or if you're a
- 1:15:16company, you don't want to have to, you know, install a, a, a
- 1:15:21bank grade safe in in the back and figure out your, your
- 1:15:26employee protocols for who has access and when and under what
- 1:15:29conditions and what are the forms you need to fill out.
- 1:15:32And you don't want to do that. You're going to outsource it to
- 1:15:35a bank. And I think that I think the
- 1:15:39real exciting thing for for us at on ramp about what Bitcoin
- 1:15:43makes possible is a type of bank where you don't have to have,
- 1:15:49you don't have to give up unilateral control to a third
- 1:15:52party bank. You, you can use multi sig to
- 1:15:59put your assets in a multi institution vault where three
- 1:16:03different institutions are each, you know, being a guard and none
- 1:16:09of them individually have control of your assets.
- 1:16:12So it's this, it's totally paradigm breaking form of like
- 1:16:16a, a, a new digital bank that multi sig in Bitcoin makes
- 1:16:21possible. And that's what we're super
- 1:16:23excited about working on. Marty, we need a, we need AE
- 1:16:29cash pod on how that that's going to it's going to
- 1:16:34revolutionize E cash and the everything that's going on
- 1:16:38there. There's a lot to catch up on.
- 1:16:42There is that's all another rabbit hole I don't think we
- 1:16:44have time to jump down on today. Definitely definitely not today.
- 1:16:48I think I mean multi institution custody providers who are
- 1:16:52comfortable with these multi C quorums.
- 1:16:55I mean, I think they're natural, natural leaders in that space in
- 1:17:01terms of like institutionalized E cash mints, like creating
- 1:17:05banking services on top of cold storage Bitcoin or maybe not
- 1:17:09necessarily cold storage Bitcoin, But if you're
- 1:17:11comfortable setting up multi sig quorums running of Fenimen
- 1:17:15particularly should be pretty easy for these institutions and
- 1:17:19you get into weird financial and banking services on top of that
- 1:17:23using Bitcoin collateral. I read that health any post you
- 1:17:26shared a couple weeks ago or like maybe last week that you
- 1:17:29said with Bitstein and it was like, it's just so crazy
- 1:17:32impression, like how clear you needed the different levels to
- 1:17:35like get to a certain point to be able to do it.
- 1:17:38And it's like we were always in free banking.
- 1:17:40Like, I mean, that's what we did before you had notes or you had
- 1:17:44claims on you had notes or claims on the underlying and
- 1:17:48then the reputation on those notes and the institution to
- 1:17:53make you whole was what dictated if you continue to use them.
- 1:17:56And then you built certain reputations and others had runs
- 1:17:58and they went away. And then so it's like it kind of
- 1:18:01seems weird that that would happen, but that was like how it
- 1:18:03existed forever. You parked your because you
- 1:18:06didn't take the gold home because people came and stole
- 1:18:08the gold. Like it's pretty well.
- 1:18:11One last just note on the gold is it came up from one of the
- 1:18:14guys in UK that were here in consensus.
- 1:18:16They brought up this idea of of spotters in London for protect
- 1:18:24Philippe watches. So they just like naturally
- 1:18:26have, and this is probably in a lot of major cities where people
- 1:18:29hang around and they just like stay on corners.
- 1:18:32They watch your mapping of when you leave from home to where
- 1:18:34you're going, and then they'll go steal your watch and
- 1:18:36different versions of how they, like take the watch off your
- 1:18:39wrist. But the point being is that's
- 1:18:40like a 5 to $25,000, you know, item.
- 1:18:45You think of a notion if somebody's holding to 220-5000
- 1:18:48to 250,000 to 300, you know, 3 million and you know, most
- 1:18:53people know all your keys are sitting at home or ones here or
- 1:18:55ones over there. Like this notion that like we
- 1:18:58solve custody today where you know, people are have spotters
- 1:19:02for a $5000 watch. I don't think we fully thought
- 1:19:05through the implications of like, again, the gold doesn't go
- 1:19:08at your home and that's how you had this like banking layer and
- 1:19:10that ties back to like the E cash and being able to park it
- 1:19:13with the reputable source. And, and I think that comes back
- 1:19:16to to Paul's earlier point of like what's the historical
- 1:19:19analog for what's going on here? Paul's example of how capital
- 1:19:24flowed from analog businesses to digital businesses with a lag
- 1:19:28effect as the Internet took over and, you know, Blockbuster
- 1:19:32turned into Netflix and, and, and so on that that happened.
- 1:19:37And that's the best like modern example that we have.
- 1:19:40But to Paul's other point, it's really gold and the and the
- 1:19:45bootstrapping of gold from a nothing rock to being the
- 1:19:49preferred money for the world over A6000 year period.
- 1:19:53That's the the the only like base layer monetary revolution
- 1:20:01upheaval that that we've have in in civilizational history.
- 1:20:05And that's what Bitcoin is doing.
- 1:20:07So it's. It's it's the Internet, but it
- 1:20:11is at this deeper level and it changes everything.
- 1:20:14And all of the infrastructure that makes that new form of base
- 1:20:18layer work still has to be built.
- 1:20:20And that's a long and slow process.
- 1:20:23Yeah, that touches everything. Yeah, I mean, it's going to take
- 1:20:29that and it's crazy. Like Michael bringing up that
- 1:20:31Hal Finney post that he put out in 1993.
- 1:20:36These ideas aren't new either. It's just it there's an order of
- 1:20:41operations to all this, you know, works in fractals and the
- 1:20:45banking system that we're describing right now in the
- 1:20:47digital age with Bitcoin and these charming, immense and
- 1:20:50Lightning Network acting as this connective tissue.
- 1:20:53Like how Finney wrote about these ideas 30 years ago, 31
- 1:20:58years ago now. But it wasn't until the
- 1:21:01combination of the technologies were in place, as they are right
- 1:21:04now that that this idea was able to be brought to fruition.
- 1:21:08And it's in the process of being brought to fruition.
- 1:21:11But it's going to be just that, a process.
- 1:21:13It's going to take time, trial and error, user experience,
- 1:21:18design flows being built on top of this.
- 1:21:20It's going to be really cool. It's, it's, we should all feel
- 1:21:24very fortunate to be alive right now because these are sci-fi
- 1:21:30subjects that were nothing more than ideas that weren't really
- 1:21:33applicable 30 years ago. Now they are.
- 1:21:35And we're on the tip of the spear watching it all be built
- 1:21:38out. And it's insane that the like,
- 1:21:43it's to the point now where it's mature.
- 1:21:45Yes, we're talking about pensions, allocating the Bitcoin
- 1:21:48ETFs, but that's a, that's a big first step.
- 1:21:50Like, imagine what they'll be doing in the future with the
- 1:21:53combination of all these technologies.
- 1:21:58Absolutely. Got it.
- 1:21:59It is exciting. We know what Paul's going to
- 1:22:02talk about in class next class. Yeah, I, I, I should tell you
- 1:22:09guys, you'd probably be interested to, to sort of think
- 1:22:12about like at the university level, like how like the
- 1:22:15approach, you know, you take with students on this, like
- 1:22:17where, where do you start? And to me, this was actually one
- 1:22:23of the harder things to do. Like you figure out like when
- 1:22:25you're teaching this to students, like what problem you
- 1:22:29have to, you have to explain, like what problem are you
- 1:22:31solving here, right? And to do that, you almost, you
- 1:22:34have to go down all these other rabbit holes that you guys have
- 1:22:36already gone down to, right? Modern Monetary theory, all, all
- 1:22:39these other things that they've never been taught.
- 1:22:42And, you know, the stuff we're in now is, you know, to me, like
- 1:22:46the custody stuff and all this other stuff is, I don't want to
- 1:22:50say it's at the very end, but for the, for the students, it's,
- 1:22:55they have to, for them to like really understand that they have
- 1:22:57to know like why we're here, you know, and the idea that like
- 1:23:01something in their pocket is like not worth next year, the
- 1:23:05same amount it is today. That whole concept is just, it
- 1:23:08really is like the matrix, right?
- 1:23:09It's, it's, it's them trusting me to say, OK, go down, go down
- 1:23:13with me for 12 weeks on this path.
- 1:23:16And at the end, I'll basically show you like what we're getting
- 1:23:18AT. And, and custody is kind of like
- 1:23:21at the very end of it, you know? Yeah, yeah.
- 1:23:24Table stakes to to understand why this matters, why this is
- 1:23:27important. Paul, do you, do you have your
- 1:23:29students read Shelling out? Because that's what jumped out
- 1:23:32to me just now and you're like, where do you start?
- 1:23:34I was like shelling out feels like the perfect thing.
- 1:23:37So I, so the, the books I, my general order of operation is I
- 1:23:45give, I have all my students read two books.
- 1:23:48So regardless of their background or whatever, so they
- 1:23:52have to read bullish case or Bitcoin and they have to recheck
- 1:23:57your financial privilege. So the reason I, the reason
- 1:24:01those two books bullish case, it's short, it's got great
- 1:24:05graphs. It talks about, you know, store
- 1:24:07value, meaning of exchange, you know, adoption rates.
- 1:24:10So it, in my mind it like very kind of cohesively gets a lot of
- 1:24:15those points across. And then I like giving students
- 1:24:18check your financial privilege. Alex Gladstine's book, because
- 1:24:22it immediately dispels any concept of like Bitcoin has no
- 1:24:29use. That's like, that's the big
- 1:24:31thing. That's the big thing people
- 1:24:32have, right? It's like, well, it's this
- 1:24:33Internet thing that has no use. And Gladstein's book is 200 plus
- 1:24:39pages of use case. The whole book is that.
- 1:24:42So those two books are always the starter books for people.
- 1:24:47You know, the other book I actually found myself
- 1:24:49recommending recently. I think I have a copy of it.
- 1:24:52It's the. It's the.
- 1:24:53Bitcoin Handbook, you guys read the book Bitcoin Handbook by
- 1:24:58it's it's by I'm sure you've you've probably seen it, but
- 1:25:05looks like that. Oh yeah, yeah.
- 1:25:07I have read that one. So this is, this is fantastic
- 1:25:11because you know, it's a series of, you know, 1 pages on, you
- 1:25:17know, Moore's Law and you just go and you just go down the
- 1:25:19list, right? And so this is also, I think
- 1:25:22great for people who have decided they want to learn about
- 1:25:26Bitcoin. So they're like down the path,
- 1:25:28but they're also just confused. Like every time they listen to a
- 1:25:31podcast, it's like 30 acronyms and words they've never heard.
- 1:25:35And most of the stuff is like in here.
- 1:25:37So this is usually this is sort of like the phase two book I
- 1:25:39give students. And then after that, to me, it's
- 1:25:43personal preference, right? It's things that it's got to be
- 1:25:46things they're interested in. Is it is it the mining aspect?
- 1:25:48Is it the use case aspect? Is it the economic side though?
- 1:25:52Then there's different books for all that stuff.
- 1:25:58Yeah, all that. Your students are very lucky,
- 1:26:01Paul. I feel very fortunate of
- 1:26:03somebody of your caliber out there educating the young minds
- 1:26:06in America, particularly Wisconsin.
- 1:26:10I think as you said earlier, the students going through your
- 1:26:13class are gonna, they're gonna have an edge, and that'll give
- 1:26:17UW Whitewater an edge in the long run as well.
- 1:26:21Yeah, we have, we have, we have great students and this probably
- 1:26:25is not surprising, but you know, very, it's very common in
- 1:26:29academics to, you know, be the Jedi in one realm and quickly
- 1:26:33realize your students are surpassing you.
- 1:26:35And so, you know, lots of really bright students in our stuff.
- 1:26:38And so, you know, we'll talk about there'll be some topic on
- 1:26:41there that's like hardcore encryption or something.
- 1:26:45And after like 10 weeks, you realize, OK, this student is
- 1:26:49like a math wizard. They're actually going to like,
- 1:26:51they're actually going to end up, you know, knowing like how
- 1:26:54all the the probability stuff works better than I do.
- 1:26:57And so that to me is like the fun part too.
- 1:26:59It's like being a coach and realizing at some point, like
- 1:27:01your players surpass you as you were a player type thing.
- 1:27:05That's like the best part about teaching, right?
- 1:27:06Is you get these students that are super eager and you're like,
- 1:27:09OK, they're going to go off and like do even much better things.
- 1:27:13So we got a bunch of those students coming through the
- 1:27:14pipeline, too. This is very enlightening and
- 1:27:20very cool to think that this is happening at lower like middle
- 1:27:24school and high school. And maybe this is how we fix
- 1:27:27education in the sense of like, because it's so
- 1:27:29multidisciplinary, it makes everything else interesting, as
- 1:27:32you know. So if if teachers can include
- 1:27:35this in their own like special, you know, whatever curriculum
- 1:27:39they're, they're teaching, you can naturally like let people
- 1:27:41pick which course they want to go through and have what fun,
- 1:27:44what they find most fascinating. I think that everybody has their
- 1:27:47own version of like what that looks like.
- 1:27:51I never thought about it that way, but that's a very inspiring
- 1:27:53version of like, getting closer to younger minds and where we're
- 1:27:57headed. So, you know, you guys are
- 1:27:59probably right about Ella Huff at Cornell, who's like got her
- 1:28:02own. So long term, I hope is to have
- 1:28:05something like that in place here.
- 1:28:07You know, I think she's she's like one student at one
- 1:28:09university, but I'm kind of optimistic that we could just
- 1:28:13have a program on it, right. So you just you basically come
- 1:28:17out like with a degree and like Bitcoin stamped on it.
- 1:28:20Yeah, we, I mean that that's that's some of the Texas, you
- 1:28:22know, we, I know, you know her mother, Lisa Huff and Kurok Ray
- 1:28:25and Texas A&M. So we like.
- 1:28:26You know we do our. We do our stuff under the hood
- 1:28:28here in Texas too, but we we got to, you know, bump those numbers
- 1:28:31on the, the pension side. You, you Timkos, you know, just
- 1:28:34calling them out. We got to.
- 1:28:35We know some folks over there. We'll make sure to send this one
- 1:28:37over if they need some help. Yeah, do it.
- 1:28:44Well, Paul, this has been awesome.
- 1:28:46Thank you for joining us. I'm really bullish, like I said
- 1:28:50at the beginning of the episode, I think the last 90 days have
- 1:28:53been some of the most bullish fundamental build up that I've
- 1:28:58seen in Bitcoin in quite some time.
- 1:29:00And I think you just confirmed some of my preconceived notions
- 1:29:03there. So thank you for joining us and
- 1:29:07hopefully we do this again at some point.
- 1:29:09Yeah, if you guys are in Nashville, hopefully I'll run
- 1:29:11India and if not, we'll we'll catch up again.
- 1:29:14Awesome. Thanks, Paul.
- 1:29:16Thank you, Paul. See you guys.
- 1:29:20Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:29:23If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:29:25episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:29:28app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:29:30today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:29:32Before we finish, a quick reminder that Onramp Media is
- 1:29:35for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 1:29:38nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:29:41Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:29:43to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com.
- 1:29:46Contact Schedule a consultation with one of our private client
- 1:29:49advisors.