Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Legal Tech Revolution: Essential AI & Technology Strategies for Modern Law Firms
Transcript
- 0:03Hi, everybody. My name is Dean Sirwin. I am the
- 0:07current chair of the Beverly Hills Bar's law
- 0:10practice management section. I love doing these
- 0:13introductions because I get to share with you
- 0:17some exciting news about the BHBA. First of all,
- 0:20real quick, you'll see in the chat that they're
- 0:23posting the the materials for this exciting webinar,
- 0:29as well as some information about what I'm going
- 0:31to talk about right now, which is our award -winning
- 0:33CLE library, BHBA On Demand. It's fantastic.
- 0:39It's basically YouTube for CLE. If you're like
- 0:43me and you've been practicing for a while, you
- 0:44remember when you get all those solicitations
- 0:47from people, get all your 25 hours in one batch
- 0:50of, yes, videotapes. That's how far back we go.
- 0:54Videotapes and cassettes, then DVDs and CDs,
- 0:57and then online. And they were boring, old, out
- 1:02of date, dull programs. What BHBA has is we're
- 1:08doing typically at least one a day. If there's
- 1:12a new important case or decision that comes down,
- 1:16we've usually got a CLE program up and running
- 1:18about it within a week or two, sometimes even
- 1:21less. And they're all in the on -demand locker.
- 1:27You can go and look for them. They're organized
- 1:29by those hard -to -get specialty items that we
- 1:34all need an hour here and an hour thereof. And
- 1:37you get participation credit for them. This program
- 1:42itself will be posted there. One to three days,
- 1:45we've got so many going on now, including live
- 1:48ones again, that it can take a minute. You'll
- 1:52get a notice about it. You can rewatch it. You
- 1:54can tell your friends about it. The counter is
- 1:58clicking up. We had 1 ,200 people signed up for
- 2:00today. So many of them will watch that again
- 2:04on the, or for the first time once they get that
- 2:08email notice that it's up. This is a webinar.
- 2:12The chat is disabled, only the BHBA and the speaker
- 2:16can use the chat. There is a Q &A, and if you
- 2:21place your questions in there, they'll either
- 2:24be answered along the way or at the end. With
- 2:30that, I'm going to introduce our speaker today.
- 2:33Danny Abir is the managing partner of Axelaw,
- 2:37one of California's largest plaintiff -only litigation
- 2:39firms, which he co -founded back in 2016. Under
- 2:43his leadership, the firm has grown to over 100
- 2:45attorneys and staff and secured more than $1
- 2:48billion in client recoveries, all while fostering
- 2:51a culture dedicated to justice and client service.
- 2:55A frequent speaker and published author. Sorry.
- 3:03Frequent speaker and published author, Danny
- 3:05also serves on the boards of multiple professional
- 3:07organizations, including the Consumer Attorneys
- 3:10of California and the Consumer Attorneys Association
- 3:13of Los Angeles, where he is slated to serve as
- 3:16president in 2028. Very impressive. We're glad
- 3:20to have Danny here with us today. With that,
- 3:22I'm going to turn things over to him for this
- 3:24presentation. Thank you, Danny. Thank you, Dean,
- 3:27for the introduction. Good morning, everybody.
- 3:29I usually start presentations on asking questions,
- 3:35especially when it comes to AI as to how many
- 3:39show of hands, how many people actually currently
- 3:42use AI in their practices and so forth. But given
- 3:47that this is a webinar, I'm going to change things
- 3:49a little bit. Can we have the next slide, please?
- 3:55So I put my information here. Thank you. I put
- 4:00my information here on purpose on the first page
- 4:03because a lot of times, well, I'm zooming through
- 4:07presentations. We don't get to the last page.
- 4:10In case you need the material or you have any
- 4:13questions, you can always reach out to me using
- 4:15the code over here or email or that's my cell
- 4:19phone number. You're welcome to reach out to
- 4:22me if you have any questions. Next slide, please.
- 4:29I put this here on purpose for one reason and
- 4:32one reason only. I gave a presentation on AI
- 4:36a little more than 12 months ago. That was the
- 4:41Flintstones compared to the Jetsons where we
- 4:44are today. This is how fast and how the speed
- 4:48by which the technology is changing and AI is
- 4:53changing. What you have today is going to be
- 4:58dwarfed by what you're going to see in six months
- 5:01and a year from now. It's exponential. So my
- 5:06suggestion before we get into this is you have
- 5:10to hop on and judging from the number of people
- 5:13who are interested in watching this presentation
- 5:16and this webinar, that shows that how many people
- 5:19are actually on board with learning about AI
- 5:23and trying to use technology. to make their practices
- 5:26more efficient. One thing I will say ahead of
- 5:31the next slide is that our practice is primarily
- 5:34or exclusively a plaintiff practice. We do not
- 5:39do family law or any other type of law. So a
- 5:44lot of the tools and the softwares that I'm gonna
- 5:50talk about, they're primarily for litigation
- 5:53purposes. but some of it actually applies to
- 5:57other things as well. So I mentioned that we've
- 6:01gone from the Flintstones to the Jetsons in a
- 6:04matter of a year. Just to give you an idea, a
- 6:09little more than 12 months ago, ChatGPT was on
- 6:13ChatGPT 4 .0. It's already at ChatGPT 5. Pod
- 6:19has gone from 3 .5 to 4 .1 and so forth. The
- 6:22speed is significantly faster. The reasoning
- 6:26is much stronger. It's a lot more accurate. It's
- 6:29doing a lot less creating its own basic reality.
- 6:35And it can take in a lot more information than
- 6:38it did about a year ago. Next slide, please.
- 6:44So. People ask, why is it that we need to focus
- 6:49more with AI and why does AI matter? A lot of
- 6:54attorneys know that the job market for hiring
- 6:58has changed quite a bit since COVID. There is
- 7:02a scarcity in terms of finding good talent, whether
- 7:05it's paralegals, legal secretaries, or attorneys.
- 7:09What AI can do can help get you more efficient
- 7:13with regards to your the work that you're doing
- 7:16so that with the same great staff that you have
- 7:19right now, you'll be able to do more basically
- 7:23with it. Clients will get better and faster results
- 7:27if you're having an hourly practice. Imagine
- 7:30how much faster you're going to be able to do
- 7:32things. And as far as contingency practice are
- 7:39concerned, it's also going to cut into the hours
- 7:42and it is going to help you become a lot more
- 7:45efficient so it makes you more profitable basically.
- 7:51Next slide please. So today's reality there's
- 7:58you have social media you have a lot of information
- 8:03on the internet so whenever you have any kind
- 8:06of a case this applies not just to litigation
- 8:09but regular civil litigation even if it's family
- 8:12law or anything else for that matter There's
- 8:15a lot more information that you have to factor
- 8:18in when you're looking at a case and the documents
- 8:21that you need. Also, the courts, especially in
- 8:25California, are significantly clogged and they
- 8:29are very tight with trial dates and so forth.
- 8:34You end up getting dragged, cases get dragged.
- 8:38So what this helps is that it is going to help
- 8:41you with regards to being able to keep up with
- 8:44those pressures. And also going back to what
- 8:50we were talking about as far as finding employees,
- 8:56finding staff, and being able to handle your
- 8:58work, which things changed after COVID, having
- 9:02Zoom depositions, remote employees, and so forth.
- 9:05having AI and better technology is going to help
- 9:09you be able to utilize those employees a lot
- 9:13more. Next slide, please. So currently, and this
- 9:20applies to not just litigation, this also applies
- 9:25to transactional work and applies to bankruptcy
- 9:30and applies to family law. approximately 80 %
- 9:34of what attorneys do, there is some sort of technology
- 9:38to help. Doesn't mean that 80 % of your work
- 9:42can be done with technology, but out of 10 things
- 9:45that you do as an attorney, that eight of them,
- 9:49you will be able to find some sort of a tool
- 9:51that's gonna be able to help you become more
- 9:54efficient. Now that one tool may make you 50
- 9:57% efficient in one, specific thing that you're
- 10:01doing and 70 % in something else, 20 % in another,
- 10:05but at the end of the day, it is there to make
- 10:09you much more efficient and be able to do a lot
- 10:12more with your day and given the staff and the
- 10:17capacity constraints that you may have. Next
- 10:22slide, please. One of the issues that AI had
- 10:29initially, and I'm sure a lot of folks on this
- 10:33webinar know about it, was that it was fabricating
- 10:37facts and fabricating information. CHAT GPT has
- 10:42done that significantly with regards to hallucinating
- 10:48cases that don't really exist and giving you
- 10:52a law that doesn't exist. So one of the issues
- 10:55that you're finding and you will find with basically
- 10:58AI is that the solution to that is that you have
- 11:03to review everything. This is not a one size
- 11:08fits all. This is not something that you're going
- 11:10to put it into chat GBT or any other software.
- 11:14And you're going to say, okay, my work is done.
- 11:16I don't need to be functioning as an attorney
- 11:19for this. everything that you hand to the court,
- 11:23you have to actually review. Basically, the other
- 11:28part of it is privilege issues when it comes
- 11:30to litigation as well. Remember that what you
- 11:34put on the World Wide Web with regards to chat
- 11:38GBT is unless you take measures to protect yourself,
- 11:42you are going to have issues with regards to
- 11:45privilege. Also, Again, some AI outputs tend
- 11:53to be robotic. The answer is not as emotional.
- 11:58So you have to make sure that you're still using
- 12:01your language. There's still gonna be a human
- 12:05part to this when you're looking at what AI is
- 12:09going to produce for you. Basic AI is trained
- 12:15on old verdicts and it can undervalue claims.
- 12:20It can marginalize your client or the information
- 12:23you're going to give it. So you have to make
- 12:26sure that you don't have any inaccuracies, a
- 12:28two -layer approach. Having basically a couple
- 12:32of reviews of it is going to be very, very important.
- 12:37Next slide, please. So this, unfortunately, is
- 12:42something that I know we actually had One comment
- 12:46about this is geared more towards litigators.
- 12:49And I'm a transactional lawyer, the gentleman
- 12:54mentioned or the lady mentioned. So I'm trying
- 12:56to make sure that I give you as much information
- 12:59as I have that is non litigation driven as well.
- 13:05But for example, this gives you the breakdown
- 13:07of how much of your work and each level of litigation
- 13:11can be done. to some sort of AI technology. So
- 13:17for example, when you're assessing whether or
- 13:19not you would like to, I just noticed that, I'm
- 13:22so sorry. One of the things that you have to
- 13:27look at, it says early case assessment. About
- 13:3135 % of the work that you do when you're trying
- 13:34to determine whether you want to take a case
- 13:37or not, this is something that can be done through
- 13:41AI. When you're drafting feedings, about 45 %
- 13:46of that work can be done with AI. And the dollar
- 13:50figures you see next to it is how much that's
- 13:53going to save you in order to get that done with
- 13:58AI, how much more efficient you become. There
- 14:01are tools out there that you can use for discovery,
- 14:05whether it's written discovery, e -discovery,
- 14:07that can make things a lot more efficient. We
- 14:10will get to each one of the tools that you can
- 14:13use in the different areas or different parts
- 14:17of your practice or different parts of the litigation.
- 14:21But this is just to give you an idea of what
- 14:24percentage of each section, each part of work
- 14:28that can be done with use with AI. So next slide,
- 14:34please. Let's shift the focus from why to how.
- 14:44Having the right tool. How are you going to check
- 14:48things? How is it going to impact you? This is
- 14:52something that I get a lot of questions like
- 14:54this saying, what do you think I should use?
- 14:56What tools do you like? What tools do you use
- 14:59for your firm? Each firm is different. Each practice
- 15:05is different. You know what you can use technology
- 15:09for. You know your staff and your attorneys better.
- 15:12You know your own propensities and how you are
- 15:14better and where you can actually add efficiency.
- 15:19So there isn't necessarily a specific answer
- 15:22to say, okay, what tool should I use unless I'm
- 15:26aware or you have a better understanding of your
- 15:29practice and what it is that your practice needs
- 15:32or how it can become more efficient using AI.
- 15:36Next slide, please. So in order to basically
- 15:45introduce AI into your practice, there are a
- 15:50few things you need to make sure that you keep
- 15:52track of. You have to pick tasks where time saves
- 15:56translates directly into some sort of a margin.
- 16:00So you're going to know what or how efficient
- 16:04that technology is going to do for you, it's
- 16:08going to get you, is to see whether that tool
- 16:11is going to be good for you. Also look and see
- 16:15with regards to your firm, and basically it's
- 16:20a sequence, quick win pilots before culture shift
- 16:25changes. Attorneys tend to be, not just attorneys,
- 16:29but the legal industry tends to be very rigid.
- 16:32We are not good at changing and adapting to technology.
- 16:38So one of the things I would recommend is before
- 16:41you go for a full flow change with your practice,
- 16:45have little pilots to make sure that your staff,
- 16:48your employees, and you yourself are getting
- 16:50used to using technology in order to adapt to
- 16:56it and use it. Technology is only as good as
- 17:01if you use it. So that's kind of like a gym membership
- 17:06that you have and you don't use, or it used to
- 17:10be different memberships that we used to have,
- 17:12or maybe you have a Disney membership that you
- 17:16got, Disney Channel membership, and now your
- 17:18kids are growing up and you don't use it anymore,
- 17:20but it's just, you're just paying for it. So
- 17:22it's basically like that. So you have to make
- 17:25sure there's technology that you're going to
- 17:27use, and it's actually gonna be helpful for you.
- 17:30Some of these technologies tend to be pretty
- 17:32expensive. that makes it that much more important
- 17:35to make sure that you're using something that's
- 17:38going to be helpful for you. Also, with regards
- 17:41to government overlay, you have to make sure
- 17:44that you adhere to, basically, you have to certify
- 17:48that if you're using AI, there's going to be
- 17:52human interaction, you're going to review things,
- 17:55and you're going to make sure that what you're
- 17:57going to give to the judge or the court or whatever
- 18:01product you're going to have, is not just purely
- 18:04use AI to produce. Next slide, please. So this
- 18:16goes back to the verification. There are two
- 18:18pillars for basically successful AI implementation.
- 18:23One is to make sure that all of your AI output
- 18:26is human verified for accuracy. So you have to
- 18:29make sure that there are no hallucinations and
- 18:32basically everything is in compliance with the
- 18:37court rules for certification. Also, again, going
- 18:41back, you wanna make sure that you have a way
- 18:44to track how much time you're saving and what
- 18:48is that going to do for you. So for example,
- 18:51there are tools such as EsquireTech that you
- 18:53can use for discovery. It basically saves approximately
- 18:5860 human hours, and it can tell you how much
- 19:02you're going to be able to save by using S -Prioritype,
- 19:05or even Ops shows how much, what percentage you're
- 19:08going to use. Basically, by use, it's going to
- 19:12make you more efficient. They have their own
- 19:14dashboard monthly that shows you how much time
- 19:17you've saved, so there's no guesswork with regards
- 19:20to it. But generally speaking, You're doing this
- 19:24in order to basically make yourself more efficient
- 19:28and more profitable. So because of that, you
- 19:35have to keep track of how much time it's going
- 19:38to save you basically by using that technology.
- 19:42Next one, please. So now we're gonna get to the
- 19:47different tools. that you can use in your practice.
- 19:50I promise that some of the slides are going to
- 19:54be helpful, regardless of the type of practice
- 19:58you have. And here are some tools that you can
- 20:02use in order to do marketing using AI. This one
- 20:07is one that you may want to take a picture of
- 20:09or definitely print out. There are different
- 20:12types of tools that you can use, like for example,
- 20:15creating viral Facebook posts, there's a tool
- 20:18for that, or generating AI art, or basically,
- 20:23there are tools for ranking higher on Google,
- 20:26creating AI video generated, basically presentations,
- 20:34also slide GPT, I didn't use slide GPT for this
- 20:38presentation, but it's something that you can
- 20:40use. AI webinar hosting, and all these different
- 20:45tools that you have mentioned here. It's something
- 20:48that I would highly recommend checking it out
- 20:50on your own time, seeing if it's something that
- 20:53works for you. And again, marketing is something
- 20:56that any firm has to do, whether or not you are
- 21:00a plaintiff lawyer, defense lawyer, family law
- 21:03lawyer, a transactional lawyer, no matter what
- 21:06you're doing, you're going to need to do marketing
- 21:09in order to get business. And these are the different
- 21:12tools currently on the market that you can use
- 21:16to be able to create some sort of marketing buzz
- 21:20for yourself. Next slide, please. So assume that
- 21:26you do marketing, and now you're going to have
- 21:30people calling. OK. Let's say your marketing
- 21:34was so successful and so good that you now have
- 21:39a lot of callers coming in. What do you do? There
- 21:42are different tools that you can use in order
- 21:47to convert that. Smith AI is a company that we
- 21:51actually use for our firm. At some point, we
- 21:55had something close to 2 ,500 new callers and
- 22:00another 2 ,500 old callers or current clients
- 22:05and so forth calling the firm. There is no reception
- 22:10that I could think of for our firm in order to
- 22:13be able to handle all of that. So we went to
- 22:16Smith AI, which is a combination of both AI as
- 22:20well as human interaction to make sure calls
- 22:25are not missed. So that is one of the things
- 22:29that we can do. Intaker is another one that can
- 22:31help convert a basic FI review into 30 to 60
- 22:36minute brief. with citations telling you exactly
- 22:40what they are. That can be downloaded. The accompanying
- 22:48slides that you see, I can send you, I'd be happy
- 22:52to send you a copy of the presentation, or I
- 22:55believe that Beverly Hills Bar Association can
- 22:57also send you a copy of it. So you get the case,
- 23:07And you're now ready to basically manage the
- 23:12case. Let's move to the next slide, please. There
- 23:18are different types. There are different tools
- 23:21out there with regards to case management. This
- 23:25is basically something that you can use in order
- 23:28to keep track of what's going on with your cases.
- 23:32This happens to be regarding PI. So it's telling
- 23:36you, generating medical chronologies or gaps
- 23:40in missing evidence, or basically trying to figure
- 23:43out what it is that in order for you to have
- 23:45a complete file to look at. Zupio, EvenUp, Eve
- 23:51are three tools that are, all three of them can
- 23:54be used for, as a case management software when
- 23:59it comes to personal injury. I think that's what
- 24:03they're all focused on right now. but you can
- 24:07have different case management softwares. Right
- 24:10now, other case management softwares also have
- 24:13some sort of AI attached to it. So whatever it
- 24:16is that you're currently using in your firm,
- 24:20regardless of the type of practice, one of the
- 24:22things I would highly recommend is reaching out
- 24:25to the company and saying, do you have the...
- 24:28upgrade a version that has AI technology. The
- 24:31good thing about AI technology when it comes
- 24:34to case management is to be able to generate
- 24:36chronologies or to be able to sort through material
- 24:39without having to print thousands and thousands
- 24:42of pages in order to figure out what it is that
- 24:46you're trying to find. And also, depend the tool
- 24:51that you use. One of the things I would factor
- 24:54in is How much human interaction do you think
- 24:57you're going to need? How much are they going
- 24:59to cost you? Basically all these different firm,
- 25:04all these companies basically use platforms to
- 25:08make you be able to handle your cases faster
- 25:10and get access to the information that you need
- 25:14a lot faster. But all of them pretty much at
- 25:17least these three just about do the same things.
- 25:22Next slide please. So you now are going to move
- 25:31forward and you're going to file a complaint.
- 25:33And again, this goes to litigation. EVE allows
- 25:37you to draft legal complaints basically using
- 25:43your tone. This one, sorry. So you can feed it
- 25:50your past. answers for past complaints that you
- 25:55filed. And he can basically use your tone and
- 25:59the way that you basically draft the complaint
- 26:02and create something, create readings in the
- 26:06same manner that basically reflects the tone
- 26:10that you use. They need all the information,
- 26:14you give them all the information, you give the
- 26:16jurisdiction, you give them what the allegations
- 26:18are. and it basically drafts it for you based
- 26:22on that. So you can use Cod and Chat GPT as well.
- 26:30That's another way of doing that. You list the
- 26:32elements of, for example, negligence supervision
- 26:35in California and say, these are the facts. What
- 26:39are the facts that I need in order to draft discovery?
- 26:42You can use the same thing in order to do discovery
- 26:45if you want to do the pleadings as well. By the
- 26:49way, we have a plan of practice. As I said, these
- 26:53are being used by defense firms as well. So to
- 26:55the extent that you do any kind of civil litigation,
- 26:59the tools that I'm mentioning right now are tools
- 27:01that you should be able to use in your practice
- 27:05as well. So I mentioned EsquireTech before. This
- 27:16is one tool that we've been using at our firm.
- 27:18going on about four years now, maybe five. They
- 27:23got on this pretty early on, and the AI is making
- 27:28it faster and faster and faster. You can use
- 27:31it in order to draft basically all sorts of discovery
- 27:36and also responding to discovery. So this is
- 27:40something that I would highly recommend looking
- 27:43into, whether it's a square check or Eve also
- 27:46helps you propound discovery and basically all
- 27:53it does is take the case information that you
- 27:56have from your case management software into
- 28:00drafting a document whether it is to do discovery
- 28:05or pleadings it does that for you using your
- 28:09information again have to point out that you
- 28:13have to make sure that if you are going to use
- 28:16these this technology, you still need human oversight.
- 28:21You still have to make sure that everything is
- 28:24being used properly. Can you share clauses? You
- 28:30put in a retainer agreement that indicate that
- 28:32you said, I don't have that in here, but if you
- 28:35send me an email, I'd be happy to send you basically
- 28:40the clause that you need to put in your retainer
- 28:42agreement that you do use AI. in managing your
- 28:46client's case. So we'd be happy to do that. Also
- 28:50as a transactional attorney lawyer with a substantial
- 28:53library of custom forms, what AI platforms are
- 28:57appropriate for me? So that's one of the things
- 29:00that I started out. Sorry, I'm trying to answer
- 29:03questions as they come in as well. My firm is
- 29:08primarily litigation driven. So I'm not familiar
- 29:12with transactional tools. Having said that, what
- 29:15I do know about Chat GPT and Quad is that you
- 29:19are able to use your previous library of forms
- 29:24and to be able to say, OK, this is what I've
- 29:28used in the past. This is information that you
- 29:31can use. Also, you can use Harvey AI because
- 29:35it actually has a Word plugin. to do in Harvey
- 29:39AI where you can actually say, okay, this is
- 29:42the draft something similar to this based on
- 29:46my custom forms. So Harvey AI would probably
- 29:50be the easiest one for you to use as an entertainment
- 29:54lawyer using your current library of custom forms.
- 29:58That's something I would look at. Harvey AI,
- 30:02as far as the confidentiality is concerned, you
- 30:05have to, I would, You see, my issue with regards
- 30:09to one of the questions here is whether or not
- 30:12confidentiality is going to be an issue. I would
- 30:16err on the side of not putting in client confidential
- 30:22information on any kind of a software at this
- 30:26point. Anything that you put on there, it can
- 30:30be subpoenaed. So I would... stay away from putting
- 30:34it out there. These are just using hypotheticals.
- 30:37And you can use hypotheticals, have it draft
- 30:39a document that you need, and then replace the
- 30:42name of the hypothetical with your client names
- 30:44just to keep the confidentiality the same. Given
- 30:48this acceleration of lawyers' work, what are
- 30:52courts doing unlikely to do to speed up the process
- 30:56of cases and ultimately resolving them? California
- 31:00courts are not as good with regards to technology.
- 31:06They are moving forward. The court leadership
- 31:09is actually very aware of the use of technology
- 31:13and what it can do. They usually trail the lawyers
- 31:19by quite a bit. So I don't think right now it's
- 31:24going to make things faster. But given how fast
- 31:29AI technology is moving, I think the better the
- 31:33technology gets, the more you're going to have
- 31:37for interaction. Right now, they're trying to
- 31:40find a way to regulate it. So just to make sure
- 31:43that they are not creating, it doesn't create
- 31:46issues. Any knowledge of legal insider, which
- 31:51is AI assisted in contract drafting, that unfortunately,
- 31:56uh have I have not had any kind of interaction
- 32:00with because we don't do transactional work but
- 32:02one of the things I would highly recommend when
- 32:05it comes to any kind of technology it's very
- 32:09easy to find like for example you already know
- 32:12legal insider is a tool I would download it try
- 32:16it out and see how it works for you and whether
- 32:19or not it answers the questions or makes you
- 32:22more efficient the reason I'm saying that is
- 32:24because As a managing partner of a firm, that's
- 32:28one of the things that I put on myself. And if
- 32:31I don't have the time, I have somebody with a
- 32:34technological background do that homework and
- 32:37see if it helps them become more efficient. And
- 32:40if so, I'll take a look at it. There is a lot
- 32:42of overlap in the basic and different tools.
- 32:46So I would highly look into that. Isn't co -pilot
- 32:50secure? Co -pilot is secure. That is one. software
- 32:56that is secure. That's something that they're
- 33:01actually proud of. Would an AI prompt and queries
- 33:05be protected by the word product privilege? It
- 33:10all depends. So for example, there are cases
- 33:13in which you're supposed to, I mean, you're not
- 33:17supposed to put the information out there. And
- 33:19it's a gray area, whether it can be, it can break
- 33:23privilege or not. So that's one of the things
- 33:25I would err on the side of not risking it and
- 33:30putting it out there. But certain software, for
- 33:33example, co -counsel by Westlaw. actually has
- 33:40the ability to keep it within and not let it
- 33:43out. But still, I would be careful as far as
- 33:46the risks I take with regards to that. Okay,
- 33:50moving to the next slide, please. Ah, speaking
- 33:56of co -counsel, here are other tools that you
- 34:00can use in order to do analysis with regards
- 34:06to reviewing documents and so forth. Co -counsel
- 34:10has upload production sets. It can upload emails,
- 34:15PDFs, and then ask like a natural language and
- 34:19show every message linking the project like so
- 34:22-and -so and budget overruns, and then it can
- 34:25basically run through it. ChatGBT also does that
- 34:30conceptually. If you put everything in there,
- 34:33it can sort through and give you information.
- 34:35As far as not putting privileged information
- 34:39out there, I would rather use co -counsel than
- 34:41chat GPT. And it's really, really good using
- 34:47these tools because the human eye has limitations
- 34:52as much as if you're going through thousands
- 34:54of pages, you may miss stuff and AI will not.
- 34:59So you can put in there, find me any anywhere
- 35:03in the medical records where the client is complaining
- 35:08of pain or head injury, and it's going to find
- 35:11you exactly what you're looking for as opposed
- 35:14to having to do guesswork. RAG is Retrieval Augmented
- 35:21Generation. Basically, this is where the speed
- 35:25and the quality of the research comes in. It's
- 35:32not, it's faster. It's just, isn't just fastering
- 35:36review, but it also looks, gives you insight
- 35:39on basically things that are not possible to
- 35:44find with the human eye. This is what AI can
- 35:49do. It's basically converting data into an efficient
- 35:54way of doing research and for you to be able
- 35:57to read it. It creates a map of the data that
- 36:00you've indexed basically. And then Harvey AI
- 36:04is another tool that you can use when you're
- 36:07trying to go through documents. So if you guys
- 36:10remember there were, I'm now dating myself, there
- 36:16were jobs when we came out of law school that
- 36:18were just doc review and discovery review. And
- 36:23these are the tools that can help you go through
- 36:25thousands and thousands of pages and finding
- 36:28exactly what it is that you're looking for. It's
- 36:33great for civil litigation. It's also good for
- 36:36family law cases and other types of law where
- 36:41you have voluminous amount of information and
- 36:44you need to digest all that information in order
- 36:48to move forward with your case for representing
- 36:50your clients. Next slide please. So I wanted
- 37:00to show you what we did internally. So when I
- 37:05realized that technology and AI is moving as
- 37:08fast as it is, one of the things that I asked
- 37:13is I asked us to put together a team of folks
- 37:18who are basically focused on technology. And
- 37:20these are not. just tech -savvy folks, but these
- 37:23are folks that actually work in the office and
- 37:28are part of our practice, but they also have
- 37:31an interest in technology. So this is something
- 37:34that, this is our rag, basically our rag software,
- 37:41our rag video to show how we are using it internally
- 37:45by creating a software. And what you see is just
- 37:48the front page of it. it is getting the information
- 37:51off our case management software and bringing
- 37:55it in. And basically you can use natural language
- 38:01to ask questions once it has access to your cases.
- 38:04So if you can push play, please on this. So if
- 38:13you take a look at it, you're gonna put in case
- 38:16number 25160. This is not a real case, by the
- 38:21way. So you start a conversation. So it's on
- 38:26case number 25160, I want you to get me information.
- 38:31And then it says summarize this case for me.
- 38:35So what it does is it goes into our database
- 38:41and gets your information on a case. It tells
- 38:48you when it was settled, how much it was settled.
- 38:50Again, this is not a real case, so don't worry
- 38:52about that part of it, but it's just, it is telling,
- 38:55it gives you all the information you need in
- 38:58order for you to be able to do that. And then
- 39:04it says, if it was settled. So in order to avoid
- 39:24the privilege issues, we created our own AI technology
- 39:30within the firm. So it doesn't have to get information
- 39:33from outside of the firm and everything is in
- 39:37here. We actually had a case where we had 1 ,700
- 39:41clients. We put this together in order to put
- 39:45together victim impact statements for 1 ,700
- 39:48clients. So what this software or what we put
- 39:52together does, it goes and gets information from
- 39:55our own sources on these clients and drafts a
- 40:00specific basically victim impact statement for
- 40:05our clients. Next slide, please. Next slide,
- 40:15please. Okay. Let me ask her some questions.
- 40:22Is there a platform that can scan and organize
- 40:26my internal files without opening up the outside
- 40:32parties? This is exactly the platform that I
- 40:37just showed you. This is something that we use
- 40:40internally in order to do that. There's also
- 40:43a platform called Azure, A, Z as in zebra, U,
- 40:47R, E. that can help you organize your internal
- 40:52files without opening up to outside parties.
- 40:56It's part of Microsoft and gets the information
- 40:59from Microsoft Cloud. Are there apps that can
- 41:04ingest large numbers of lengthy precedents and
- 41:08then assist in drafting contracts? Seems similar
- 41:12to some of the litigation functions you're describing.
- 41:16My gut is that there is, let me check my notes
- 41:22here. I don't have anything on transactional
- 41:26drafting contracts, but Jay, what I would say
- 41:30is this, if I can feed AI right now and say,
- 41:38here are all the documents, draft me a complaint,
- 41:42I'm positive that something like quad, we'll
- 41:45be able to properly do exactly what you're suggesting
- 41:48and what you're asking. So I would try it with
- 41:51Claude and see if that works for you. And I'd
- 41:55be curious if it does work for you, drop me an
- 41:58email, let me know. It'd be interesting to know
- 42:00if it does, but I would try Claude in order to
- 42:03do that. Then to follow the previous question,
- 42:09please elaborate on how the risk of subpoenas
- 42:12for client data uploaded to AI platforms might
- 42:16intersect with a trending work product if such
- 42:19data includes reveals one's analysis, evaluations,
- 42:23and so forth. This is exactly what I mentioned
- 42:26earlier. This is a gray area right now, and we
- 42:28don't know how the courts are going to react
- 42:32with regards to confidential information and
- 42:37privileged information. So until there is an
- 42:41my rule of thumb is until there is something
- 42:43that tells me exactly how the courts are going
- 42:47to view it, I would wait and see how it works
- 42:53out. But right now, I would not take that risk.
- 42:57Next question, has anyone used copilot to draft
- 43:01contracts? We haven't, we don't draft contracts,
- 43:05but it is something that you can use to draft
- 43:08contracts from what I understand. You can use
- 43:12it, you can use chat GPT -5 in order to draft
- 43:14contracts as well. It copilot uses chat GPT -5.
- 43:19Law insider claims to do what Jay is asking about
- 43:23above contract drafting. There you go. But I
- 43:27do know Claude is something that you can also
- 43:29use as well. One of the things that you'd find
- 43:34very interesting is depositions and how far we've
- 43:38come with regards to depositions. There's technology
- 43:42now that you can actually feed existing depositions
- 43:47for, let's say, an ex, you're deposing somebody,
- 43:50and there are previous depositions of that person.
- 43:53You can feed the previous depositions and find
- 43:57contradictions in it so that it actually helps
- 44:00you when you are deposing somebody. So you can
- 44:05map the issues. You can basically use AI to figure
- 44:08out what questions you're going to ask. And there
- 44:12are actually, you can use them in order to find
- 44:14what's the next question when the answer comes
- 44:17in. So this is what you can do in real time when
- 44:22it comes to depositions. Next slide, please.
- 44:28So actually, sorry, previous, let's go back to
- 44:32the previous slide. I wanted to give you guys
- 44:36some, there is... Transcript Genius by Steno,
- 44:41that basically distills your testimony overnight.
- 44:46Within hours of a remote or in -person deposition,
- 44:50the AI sends you a summary of your deposition.
- 44:55So that's something that you can use. You can
- 44:57use Claude and ChatGPT if you're able to feed
- 45:02them previous transcripts in order to ask questions.
- 45:06And also, co -counsel which is a Thompson -Royder
- 45:12Westlaw product can also draft you an outline
- 45:15of what questions you can ask during a deposition.
- 45:19This is particularly very interesting for young
- 45:22attorneys who are starting out and they want
- 45:25to learn how to take a deposition. I would still
- 45:28caution having somebody with experience with
- 45:31that person but we can basically use that in
- 45:36order to go ahead and do that. Next. So we're
- 45:45gonna look at the different types of promotion
- 45:49practice and writing and what you can use for
- 45:52research. There's Lexis AI, there's Code Council,
- 45:57Harvey AI embeds word into inline search. Even
- 46:01Up can extract data from medical records and
- 46:05flagging missing documents. Clear Brief, which
- 46:07is very good. It verifies your opponent's factual
- 46:11assertions and also whether the cases that they've
- 46:14cited to are good cases at straw precedent. So
- 46:18this is just to give you guys some idea for anybody
- 46:22who does motion practice. Lexis AI, again, co
- 46:26-counsel, Harvey AI using word and also even
- 46:30up and clear brief are some of the tools you
- 46:32can use for motion practice and making things
- 46:36a little more efficient. Drafting in opposition
- 46:39to an MSJ or drafting an MSJ can be a lot faster
- 46:43than what it used to be using AI. Next. So you
- 46:53can even use AI for mediation. You're going to
- 46:56draft a basically For your mediation, you wanna
- 47:01draft documents in order for a mediator to take
- 47:03a look at it. It can basically, you can upload
- 47:07medical records, police reports, something to
- 47:10calculate damages. Basically what you're doing
- 47:13is you're trying to give the mediator the most
- 47:17efficient way of finding out what your case is
- 47:20worth and why you're in the right. Mediation
- 47:26is not necessarily gonna be something that's
- 47:28gonna be useful for those who are doing transactional
- 47:31work, but you can also use the mediation tools
- 47:35in family law cases when you're giving the information
- 47:39and you want to summarize it for a mediator when
- 47:44you're going to mediation. Next, so this is something
- 47:50that's really fun for trial prep and courtroom
- 47:53support. You've seen this on shows where they
- 47:59use AI in order to do jury selection and doing
- 48:03focus groups. Right now, you can use AI to do
- 48:08focus groups. It can be very, very both beneficial
- 48:12in terms of strategy with regards to your trials,
- 48:15but also what kind of arguments, how you can
- 48:20argue your cases. I've put in a couple of basically
- 48:25mock trials and focus groups that are AI given
- 48:28here that you can use to kind of, again, instead
- 48:31of guessing what a jury would do, it creates
- 48:33a potential jury pool for you to make those decisions
- 48:39and go forward. Next slide. This is something
- 48:49that we use actually in a case that we were in
- 48:51trial in San Antonio. And after the trial was
- 48:57over, we actually put in all of the information
- 49:01with regards to a case and tried to determine
- 49:04how based on a judge's previous rulings, how
- 49:10a judge, the judge would be likely to rule based
- 49:14on the transcripts of the trial. uh judges propensities
- 49:19and previous rulings and rulings throughout the
- 49:22case and kind of get an idea of where you think
- 49:25your judge is going to be when that's something
- 49:27that we can do using AI uh and just using chat
- 49:32gpt in order to do that but it is actually something
- 49:35that I would um it's very fun to play with and
- 49:40uh you'll be surprised how close to reality it
- 49:43is. Post trial and appeal. Next slide, please.
- 49:51So co -counsel extracts appealable issues. You
- 49:54feed the transcripts, trial transcripts and exhibits
- 49:57and everything and the objections, the rulings,
- 50:01and it tells you, gives you a list of where there
- 50:05are potential appealable issues. Peer brief,
- 50:09basically, it's good to, you can use it to, draft
- 50:13appellate briefs, and it's very helpful. You
- 50:17can scan the factual statements and verify it
- 50:19against the transcripts that you have and the
- 50:22pledge record. And again, Harvey AI is something
- 50:24that's a legal tool that I would highly take
- 50:28a look at both as far as transactional as well
- 50:31as potential appeals are concerned. And this
- 50:34is something that I would do. Do you know what
- 50:36data is used to train jury simulate? I think
- 50:40the information that they are getting for a jury,
- 50:45the question is, do you know what data is used
- 50:47to train the jury simulation apps? I believe
- 50:52that the information that they use is based on
- 50:55demographics that you're going to enter in there
- 50:57and tell them what kind of jury you're going
- 51:01to have, what the jurisdiction is, what the area
- 51:05is, based on past trials and demographics of
- 51:09that area. That's basically what they feed it.
- 51:12It's pretty much what you're going to use for
- 51:14a focus group anyway. So they're going to use
- 51:17whatever they can get publicly on a give demographics
- 51:21of a specific area and the potential jury for
- 51:23you're going to have. And you're going to feed
- 51:26the information that you want in order you believe
- 51:29are going to be the facts of your case. The easiest
- 51:32way to look at it, Jay, is if you're going to
- 51:35do a focus group, you're going to look for jurors
- 51:40of a specific demographic in a specific area.
- 51:45That is pretty much what the information is that
- 51:48you're gonna give the AI tool in order to determine
- 51:51the answer that you're looking for. Next slide,
- 51:58please. So this is really important. And the
- 52:05reason I'm saying really important is because
- 52:08we always like, we say, okay, we're going to
- 52:11implement AI, but how are we going to make sure
- 52:14that something actually happens? And we don't
- 52:17let go halfway through. This is another slide
- 52:20I would take a picture of. I think it's really
- 52:23helpful for anybody who wants to do that to do
- 52:26these different steps. You need somebody who
- 52:28is your AI champion, basically, to pick pilots,
- 52:32what you're going to look at, look at the metrics.
- 52:34As somebody in a leadership position, that folks
- 52:37will listen to and believe that they have to
- 52:41follow what they say. Then I would run a 90 -day
- 52:45quick pilot, track it, and try to see what the
- 52:50errors are, how people are responding to it,
- 52:53what are the feedback on it, what it is that
- 52:56they can basically they are buying into what
- 52:59works and what doesn't work basically. And during
- 53:03that process, you're going to tweak things and
- 53:05make things better so that you're going to be
- 53:09able to move to the next step and next step and
- 53:12not stall and just keep spinning your wheels
- 53:15basically. And then the third one is to what
- 53:20platform you're going to use before you scale.
- 53:23the platform you use should be based on your
- 53:26type of firm and what kind of information you
- 53:29have, how much data you have, what kind of firm,
- 53:31I mean, practice you have. So I gave you some
- 53:34ideas as to what platform to use, but try to
- 53:38use platforms that actually do have a good, they
- 53:42are technologically advanced and they will play
- 53:46well with other platforms. That's going to be
- 53:49the name of the game in the future. Next slide,
- 53:53please. I wish the voice would have come out
- 54:02for this. So I put this in here and it says,
- 54:07at the end of the day, nobody's going to, the
- 54:10best part of the plan is that nobody's going
- 54:12to stop me. At the end of the day, if you use
- 54:16technology and the products that are out there
- 54:19and the new products that come out and you stay
- 54:21on top of things and you are basically, along
- 54:26with the times, you're going to be able to not
- 54:29just survive but conquer because there's still
- 54:33going to be folks out there who are not going
- 54:35to do this. There are going to be folks out there
- 54:38who are going to say, well, this is not for me
- 54:41or it's not happening. I say this to my kids
- 54:46and I say this to the younger generation. Basically
- 54:50AI is to today's world what the World Wide Web
- 54:56was to my generation. So I would basically use
- 55:01that in order to move forward. And that's the
- 55:06way I look at it, is what this is going to do
- 55:08in the future. Can you recommend any AI platforms
- 55:11that will work well for estate planning and probate?
- 55:14Wow. A question from my past, because I used
- 55:18to do estate planning and probate. I haven't
- 55:22looked at anything out there that does it. recently
- 55:26because I haven't done any kind of estate planning
- 55:29for years. But if you drop me an email, I promise
- 55:34that I will look for the best one out there or
- 55:38the most advanced one out there. And I will send
- 55:41you a reply with whatever platform is available
- 55:45for probate and estate planning. My email address
- 55:48is first initial last name. So D as in David.
- 55:52A as in Apple, B as in Roy, I -R at A -C -T -S
- 56:00law .com. So D and B are at PaxLaw .com. Any
- 56:04recommendations for employment law practice?
- 56:07Tracy, I have a number of employment law colleagues
- 56:12that I worked with. And some of these softwares
- 56:17do actually work well. with employment law as
- 56:22well because this general civil litigation. But
- 56:25again, if you send me an email, I'd be happy
- 56:28to ask some of my employment law colleagues and
- 56:31get you the answer to that question as well.
- 56:34It'll be my pleasure. Alrighty, it looks like
- 56:41this concludes today's presentation. Thank you
- 56:44so much, Danny, for your time and thank you so
- 56:46much to our audience. Have a great afternoon,
- 56:47everybody. Thank you, everybody.