Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use the Anchoring Effect in Office Negotiations
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's a classic negotiation study — I think it's from 1974, Tversky and Kahneman — where they spin a wheel of fortune in front of participants. The wheel lands on a random number, say 65, and then they ask: what's the percentage of African countries in the UN? People who saw 65 guessed higher than people who saw 15. The random number anchored their estimate even though they knew it was random. Luna: Right, the anchoring effect. And it works in salaries, too — the first number thrown out becomes the reference point, and everything else adjusts relative to it. Lucas: Exactly. And today I want to drill into a real example. A listener — let's call her Sarah — works at a mid-sized ad agency in Chicago. She's a mid-level copywriter, about four years in. She got an offer from a competitor. The offer was ninety-five thousand dollars. Solid number, but she knew she could get more. Luna: And what did she do? Did she counter at a hundred and five? Lucas: She did something more interesting. She didn't counter at all — at first. She went back to her current agency, sat down with her boss, and said: 'Look, I have an offer for a hundred and forty thousand, but I'd rather stay here if you can get close.' Now, that hundred and forty thousand was a deliberate anchor. She knew the market rate for her role was closer to a hundred and ten. But by stating a hundred and forty, she shifted the entire conversation. Luna: Wait — that's a lie, though. She didn't have a hundred-forty offer. Isn't that ethically dicey? Lucas: It is a tactic, and it carries risk. If her boss called the competitor and fact-checked? She'd lose credibility. But in this case, she knew her boss wouldn't — small industry, but not that small. And the anchor worked. Her boss came back with a hundred and twenty-five thousand. She ended up staying at a hundred and twenty-two. That's a twenty-seven-thousand-dollar bump from her original salary, all because the anchor number was high. Luna: So the anchoring effect basically gave her a raise without her having to actually negotiate hard? The anchor did the work. Lucas: Exactly. The anchor sets the range. Once her boss heard a hundred and forty, a hundred and twenty-five felt like a bargain. If she'd said a hundred and ten, her boss might have offered a hundred and five. The same negotiation, different anchor, completely different outcome. Luna: And this doesn't just apply to salary. I've seen it in project deadlines, too. Someone says 'we need this by Friday' and suddenly Thursday feels generous, even though the original timeline was two weeks. Lucas: That's a perfect example. The anchor doesn't have to be a number — it can be a deadline, a scope, a budget. In office politics, you can anchor expectations early in a meeting. Say you're presenting a project plan. If you open with 'this will require six weeks and three people,' that becomes the reference. Even if your team could do it in four, the conversation starts from six. Luna: So the key is to be the one who throws out the first number. Because if you don't, the other side will. Lucas: That's the tactical takeaway. In any negotiation — salary, project scope, even where to go for lunch — if you can set the anchor, you control the range. But you have to be credible. If Sarah had said a hundred and seventy, her boss would have laughed. The anchor needs to be in the realm of plausible. Luna: What if you're on the receiving end? You walk into a negotiation and the other person drops a number first. How do you avoid getting anchored? Lucas: The best defense is to consciously adjust. Know the market rate, know your walk-away number, and before the negotiation, write down your own target. Then when they throw out a lowball, you don't anchor on it — you counter with your pre-written number. Research shows that even just thinking about an extreme anchor beforehand can inoculate you. Luna: So preparation is the antidote. You can't just wing it. Lucas: You really can't. The bias is automatic. Your brain will latch onto the first number it hears, even if you know it's arbitrary. The only way to beat it is to have your own number locked in before you walk in the room. Luna: I want to go back to the ethical question for a second. The listener who lied about the offer — does the end justify the means? She got a raise, but she also set a precedent that bluffing is okay. Lucas: It's a trade-off. I think there are ways to anchor without lying. You can say 'I've done market research and roles like mine in this city are paying between a hundred and twenty and a hundred and forty.' That's true — you can find that data on Glassdoor or LinkedIn. Then you say 'I'd like to be at the higher end of that range.' You're anchoring with a range that includes a high number, but you're not fabricating an offer. Luna: So the tactic is the same — set a high anchor — but the execution can be honest. That feels better. Lucas: And it's safer. Plus, if your boss respects you, they'll respect the research. It shows you're informed, not just aggressive. Luna: Okay, so let's say I'm a manager. I know anchoring is happening. How do I protect my team from being anchored by a candidate or a vendor? Lucas: One technique is to reframe the conversation before the number comes out. You can say 'Before we talk numbers, let's agree on the criteria we're using to evaluate this.' That shifts the focus from the anchor to the framework. Another is to bring in a third party — have someone else on your team lead the negotiation who hasn't heard the anchor yet. Luna: Because if they haven't heard it, they can't be anchored by it. That's smart. Lucas: Right. And you can also just explicitly name the bias. Say 'I know that first number can be sticky, so I want to make sure we're evaluating this based on market data, not just the first thing we heard.' That can defuse the anchor. Luna: So anchoring is powerful, but it's not magic. You can defend against it. Lucas: Exactly. And the best negotiators I've seen are aware of it on both sides. They set anchors deliberately, and they counter anchors methodically. Luna: Speaking of methods — you know, we get a lot of questions from listeners asking how we keep this ad-free. And the answer is pretty straightforward. A small group of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that covers the hosting and production costs. It's not a big ask — it's just how we keep the lights on without running ads. Lucas: And it's genuinely appreciated. If you've gotten something out of episodes like this one on anchoring, or any of our office politics episodes, and you want to help keep it going, that's the way to do it. No pressure, but it makes a real difference. Luna: So back to anchoring — you mentioned that the anchor works even when people know it's arbitrary. That's the part that always gets me. Even if you're aware of the bias, it still affects you. Lucas: It does. That's what makes it so insidious. In the original study, participants were told the wheel was rigged — they knew the number was random — and it still influenced their estimates. So awareness helps, but it's not a full defense. You need the pre-commitment to your own number. Luna: So write it down. Before any negotiation, literally write down your target, your walk-away, and your opening. That's your anchor. Lucas: And if you're the one setting the anchor, practice saying it out loud. It feels awkward to say a high number, but the more comfortable you are, the more credible it sounds. Luna: One last thought — does anchoring work in non-monetary negotiations? Like, if I'm trying to get my team to adopt a new process, can I anchor on a timeline? Lucas: Absolutely. You can anchor on scope, on deadlines, on the size of the project. Say you want to launch a new dashboard. If you say 'this will take three months,' that's your anchor. Even if it could be done in six weeks, the conversation starts at three months. And if someone pushes back and says 'can we do it in two?' you look like you're compromising, even though two is still longer than your actual estimate. Luna: So anchoring is really about framing the conversation in your favor from the first word. Lucas: That's it. The first word, the first number, the first deadline — they all set the stage. And if you're not the one setting it, you're reacting to someone else's stage. Luna: All right, so next time I walk into a negotiation, I'm going to have my number ready and I'm going to say it first. Lucas: And if someone else says theirs first, pause, take a breath, and then counter with your pre-planned number. Don't let their anchor take root. Luna: Good advice. And if you want to hear more office politics tactics like this one, you know where to find us. We'll be back next week with another episode. Lucas: Until then, pay attention to the first number you hear — and the first number you say.