Latest / Jew York Times / How Do Israeli Elections Work? (W/ Shanie Reichman from Israel Policy Forum)
Transcript
- Eitan Levine: Welcome to the Jew York Times. On today's episode, it is the inaugural first episode of 120 Angry Seats, the lead up to Israel's Knesset elections, which are officially happening on October. 27th. On today's episode, we are doing a broad explainer on how the election system works out here, how the government works out here, and all of those questions just based on the basics of how we get a the whoever the next prime minister is, or maybe the same prime minister. As always, I am joined on this pro on this, as always, I'm joined on this project, not problem. With Shanie Reichman from the Israel Policy Forum. She is our expert who is going to be walking us through all of the stuff that I beautifully do not know and am excited to talk about. we're gonna talk a little bit about recent polling that has come out that shows there is a new leader in the election. There's new laws that are trying to get pushed through before the election. I'm sure we're gonna talk about clavicular at some point. So, all of those stories and more on today's episode of the New York Times, Shanie sing it with me. We we practiced that for several months. Shaani, how is it going? Welcome to election mogging. Shanie: Die, die, die, die, die, die. Everything is great and horrible as always. First of all, I did not sign up to comment on Clavicular. Hope I said that right. But you know, I'm happy to hear your thoughts. It's over. It's over. Great. We missed it anyway, so. Eitan Levine: Said it amazingly. I gotta, it's over. The story's over. I think everyone's gotta move on. It's over. I guess we say, I will say the one, and this is my one question on this that came out of it. It's just, I don't think that Israel should have a TikTok. I don't think that Israel should have an Instagram. I don't think that these entities should have social media accounts, which is one of the controversies that came from it. Is that I don't understand the value of TikTok and Instagram. I think that they should at most be no video, just like. Public almost like a a a like notes app. Yeah. Like that I get. Shanie: Yes, like PSAs, announcements, yeah. You could have like, you would make it like a tourist site, like some formal announcements and a couple pictures, but that's it, like no commentary. And obviously Israel goes much, much, much further than that. And they like take on more of like a Trump vibe in it. It's not necessary. Eitan Levine: It was weird during the Iran War that like everyone's social media kind of like felt one way. And then Israel and America social media very much felt the same. And then at some point also, like Dubai started to put out like TikTok trendy stuff and the UAE. so it's interesting. I I the big takeaway for on this whole thing is I question the value of having, you know, a TikTok. Anyway, I just it's just it does not seem to me to be worth the the hassle that it is causing, is my takeaway here. Shanie: Agreed. Yes. Eitan Levine: Shine, so I just want to go first on just news that has happened in regards to Israel's government and the election over the past couple of days. First of all, I want to talk about polling that has come out. Recently, polling has come out that is showing that we have a new leader in the election. That is Gaudi Eisencott's party. He recently overtook Bibi Netanyahu and Likud in the voting. Shinee, can you just like walk me through how we got to here and do you think it's gonna stick? Shanie: Okay, so my job here is to answer the nuance, which is that it was one recent poll, the most recent poll that showed Gadi Eisenkot one seat above the Likud party. Okay, so like we need to be a little measured about how we talk about this. That is still really exciting. Like it's pretty impressive and surprising to have him, you know, he's just a few weeks in and to have him one seat above Likud is pretty big deal, but it's only one seat. If we look at sort of the aggregate of like, There's actually a great pull tracker that averages the channels 11, 12 and 13. You really have Gotti Eisenkot and Likudin ahead to, oh wait, no. Oh my God, they updated it. And now he's a little... Eitan Levine: Wait, wait, wait, is this June Times 120 Angry Seats breaking news? Shanie: So it looks like if you average channels 11, 12, and 13 from the last poll, it still has Gotti Eisenkott at a seat ahead. I checked this right before hopping on here. So wow, that's quick. So you have them kind of head to head, but you do have Gotti Eisenkott one seat above, and you have Bennett Lapid over at 15 seats. Eitan Levine: That's fresh. Shanie: That's still like in that opposition bloc so to speak you have the democrats your gulans party at around nine to ten Um, all in all you would put the netanyahu bloc at 52 Um, and gaudi eisenkot block. They're now calling it the eisenkot block, which is fascinating. Um, we used to call it the bennett lapide Eitan Levine: Missed opportunity I'm sorry, missed opportunity called the Eisenblock. Go on. Shanie: True, true. They're now calling at that it's 58 seats and then you have Arab parties are 10 seats. Remember you need 61 seats to have a government, but we're gonna talk about all of that today. Eitan Levine: We'll talk about all of that. My question with all of this is based on previous elections and based on polling in previous elections, you know, obviously keeping the fact that it is only a one seat lead, historically, where does the slip kind of happen? Like where do we see the numbers kind of congealing into more representative? Are the polls even, you know, accurate to what the the day of election is gonna be? Shanie: Polls are really accurate for right now. We have a lot of undecided voters in Israel who are still figuring out. There's a lot of people who voted for Netanyahu who are now saying, I don't know who I'm gonna vote for in the next election. A lot of people who in the last election, maybe they voted for Benny Gantz and now he's not even making it into the Knesset. So now they're figuring out who they're gonna vote for. So it's like a lot of moving pieces. Some of these parties don't even have their lists yet, for example. Like they're just trying to figure out what their party list looks like. So it's hard to vote for people when you don't even know who you're really voting for. Gotti Eisenkopf, I see 23 seats here. I only know who the first six or seven of those people are. I don't know who's number 10 on that list, 11, 12. I don't know if he even has those people yet. So there's like a lot to decide. Not that most people are going based on that. They're really like voting for the party head, but you do want to kind of have a better sense of who you're actually voting for. And I do, we'll say I have friends who really vote based on the bottom of the list actually, which is interesting. Eitan Levine: Wanna okay, I wanna get into this, but I think that this is the part we that let's cover that in the next section of this because now I have a bunch of questions that I think for sure exactly. So before we go into that, because we're gonna do a big explainer on how this all works, I just want to ask is that over the past couple days there have been developments in regards to basic laws in Israel. One, can you for just describe to the audience what the basic law concept is here and what some of the legislation that they've been trying to pass is about. Shanie: Yeah, because no one knows what I'm even talking about. Yeah, I'll do as quickly as possible and give a caveat that I think we'll do another episode where we talk all about the judiciary because it's quite complicated and about the Khareedi parties. But a basic law is we call it quasi-constitutional because it's not actually binding and there's no actual constitution. So it's treated as though it's like a bit of a constitutional law, but it's not really binding more than any other law by very much. Like you could still. kind of get rid of it and bring it in a similar way. So like you still just need a 61 to bring it in. But the basic law is the law of Torah study, which sort of enshrines maybe I'll actually read you the quote, Torah study is a foundational value in the heritage of the Jewish people and the state of Israel. Doesn't really sound that bad or that big a deal, but then you kind of dig deeper into why this law is coming to be, which is to serve as a basis for exempting. Haredi men from joining the military. That's kind of the purpose of this law. And it's because they weren't able to pass an exemption that they're now saying like, second best thing is to do this Torah basic study law. And you had combat veterans and reservists going into the Knesset and asking if maybe there could be an amendment to say that they are also, know, military veterans or soldiers are also have this sort of special status and that was rejected. So now this is the law that we have. They are the only. The only population in the country that now has this law that says they have some kind of special status And of course the the purpose is to serve as a legal basis eventually Apparently it's it's not you know, there's like conflicting versions of if it will or won't there was an earlier version that sort of explicitly equated them with soldiers and said like yeshiva students and Military personnel are equal and that's been removed which is a good thing because that could actually harm idf soldiers and their benefits but it's I mean the only reason to to have this kind of law is so that you can use it as a basis to exempt them in the future. Eitan Levine: Why is this happening now? And also I want to add on to that is that it seems to be like this is a fairly unpopular law amongst the Israeli population in general. And a lot of people feel like this is kind of insanely disrespectful to military vets and stuff like that. This seems to be like it would be the worst time to push something forward like this if it's unpopular in Israel and we have an election coming up in the end of October. Why is this happening now? Shanie: Yeah, so Netanyahu is basically just hoping that his voters all forget about this within three months because they don't like this sort of thing. Likud voters are not ultra-orthodox voters by and large, and they overwhelmingly draft into the military, so they don't like this sort of thing. The reason Netanyahu has to do this, and this will explain in greater detail, but when you're building a coalition, when you're building a government, you have to appease not just your voters, but your partners, your party political partners. And so back in 2022 when this government was formed, Netanyahu brought in the ultra-orthodox parties to join with him in the government to build a government together and he needed them to have a government. Okay, and he promised them that he would he would Bring in a blanket exemption so that no Haredi men have to serve in the military. That's what he promised them He wasn't able to deliver this he tried to deliver it a few years ago and the Supreme Court struck it down and said absolutely not and they actually then went and served thousands of draft notices to Haredi men. Not that any of them actually went, very few went. But in theory, they're all these draft dodgers now. And so, by the way, now you can understand why there's this like, butting of heads between the Supreme Court and the military and the Israeli government. Like this is why they don't like each other essentially. And we'll talk, we can talk more about that. But this is the kind of thing the government tries to do something and the Supreme Court says, absolutely not, it's unequal. And therefore we're gonna overturn it. And in fact, We're going to say the military has to now draft all these people. Eitan Levine: It seems to me that that is like an an overarching issue over the past couple of years, also, specifically with like Supreme Court powers and you know what they can do and can't do. I mean, there's no really resolution to it now. I mean, they they explain to me. actually, question is then explain to me exactly what happened. Like the they had a bill that got pushed in front of the Congress. Like, like what, you know, why did this like structurally what happened with? Shanie: Sure. Sure. So I hate to be this person, but back in 1948, David Ben-Gurion, the first prime minister of Israel, said, we're going to allow Yeshiva students to defer the military indefinitely. That's not an exemption. That's a deferral. That means you have to keep extending it and keep passing laws every few years to say they're going to continue to defer. It's not the same as a blanket exemption. Eitan Levine: Yeah. Shanie: And the Horeni people said, that's really nice, but that feels very temporary. So we want to really be enshrined in law that we're going to be exempt entirely. And this is a very different example. I'm an Israeli citizen. I was born abroad, and I lived abroad. So when I was 16, I was served a draft notice that said, you have to come serve in the military. I got a def- def- yeah. Eitan Levine: And by the way, for everyone at home, it the way that it works is that an owl shows up to your house and it drops a letter into your into your your chimney flute and then you you know, that's how Jews get a lot of people think LL is an airplane. No, it is the flu powder network. That's how you get here. Shanie: So so they send me this draft notice and I show up at 16 and I say I live in America and I'm also an American and they say sure Here's your deferral, but you have to every time I go to Israel I still have to go and like renew that deferral until for women I think it was age 21, but for men is 24 and they say okay now you're officially exempt So they want to skip to that exemption at age 18 or 16, whatever They want officially instead of some kind of deferral. They just get an exemption that says you never have to go And then you don't have to keep renewing and you don't have this issue of can you travel abroad? Can you not travel abroad? And you're not at risk of being drafted at any moment, which now they serve draft notices to 24,000 Haredi men ages 18 to 24. I think like 1,000 people showed up. By the way, like the people they're counting, a lot of them are formally Orthodox. A lot of them are like off the direct as we say, so not really Haredi men showing up, but a few did. And that's out of 85,000 who are eligible. And as more context, the IDF chief of staff says that they have a shortage of at least 12,000 men in the military. So if you drafted just like 15 % of those eligible, you would meet the demand. that 15 % is nowhere near being clear. Eitan Levine: I this is the last question I have on this, it's just, you know, did did this pass? What is the process to getting it passed? Like what was the thing that happened basically with it that was different than the other times that this had been, you know, broached? Shanie: So the draft exemption law, they passed it, but then the Supreme Court overturned it. it, I would say it described it as not being passed. The basic law for Torah study did pass, but the Supreme Court is very likely to overturn that. We don't know yet. And there's another law that they are trying to pass. to shield draft dodgers from arrest. So to say like, you're not gonna arrest these 24,000 draft dodgers, which they're probably not gonna do anyway, but sometimes they threaten to do and a different government could do it. So that has not yet passed. There's also, by the way, a law for more gender segregation in academia. Like there's a few other, one on a cashew, there's a few other laws. And again, this is all because Netanyahu needs to show the Haredi parties, don't worry, I got you, I got your back. please stay with me. Like I know I didn't get you everything you wanted, although he gave them a lot of money by the way to appease them for their special, their yeshivas and stuff and such, but like you need to stick with me. Eitan Levine: Well they did they did pull it. Yeah, like UTJ is one of the groups that is responsible for this and they did pull away from it. Didn't they like leave his coalition some point over the past like couple of years? Yeah. Shanie: Yeah, so technically a year ago, UTJ, which is an ultra-orthodox Ashkenazi, and yes, there's a different Misrahi Sephardi party, but really both of them just to different degrees, all of the Haredi parties basically a year ago said, we are pulling out of the coalition, but they didn't bring down the government. And again, this is all because they all have these like sort of rabbinic councils that tell them what to do, which is also interesting. So they pulled out of their ministry positions, they pulled out of their cabinet positions, but they still sat in the government. They didn't bring down the government. There was a lot of discussion and there were people thought they might, but they decided ultimately we're going to stay here and we're going to squeeze whatever we can out of this government and this coalition, but we're not going to like play ball at every table. Eitan Levine: And with that, I'm doing something now that I've been waiting so long to do. Now, I will say that back at home, I'm in Tel Aviv right now. I should actually make that point. I'm currently in the Osrielli Towers, which, by the way, stunning view of Tel Aviv. I'm in a sound booth. actually, I'm probably not gonna say the company that I'm here with, but I'm in a sound booth in Tel Aviv. And I've wanted to do this for so long. Back home in America. I think that there are a ton of people who do not understand how. This voting process and how we get Knesset works. And I say that as someone who also doesn't really know, I know broadly, whatever, but there were specifics that I just kept on coming across that I didn't know the answer to. And with the upcoming election being as viewed as it is going to be, whether you are pro-Israel, anti-Israel, Zionist, anti-Zionist, modern, don't don't care about it or whatever, you're gonna need to be able to talk about it over the next couple of months. And that is what this podcast is for. I would like to just basics, basics, basics. Shani, explain to me what Knesset is and how does it Shanie: I'm gonna go hard right now, right? I'm gonna explain everything and I'm gonna explain it in the order that I want to, not in the order that you tell me to, because I spend a lot of time figuring out how do I explain this to people in a way that makes any level of sense, okay? So here's where we're gonna start, okay? And I really hope, in the best case scenario, people listening have heard of the concept of a parliament before, but if not, we're still gonna help you understand, okay? In Israel, when you place your vote, you don't place your vote for the prime minister. So you know how in America, like I can vote for Eitan Levine: Yes. Yes, please. Beautiful. Shanie: Donald Trump and then vote for the president, but I can vote like Democrat down the ballot, that sort of thing. No, none of that. You don't vote for the prime minister, you vote for the party list. So you would put in like, and by the way, it's like a physical piece of paper. You put it in an envelope, like it's the 1970s. And it says like the Likud party. They actually have a symbol for it. So you'll put like the Likud party, a literal box. Eitan Levine: Into a box by the liter literally into a box. I was actually surprised about that because that for the first time ever a couple days ago I saw what like the voting, what the actual ballot box. It's you go in, there's a table full of papers, you pick the paper you want, and you go over to a literal box on the other end of the room and you drop it in the box. Shanie: It's really cute. It's really wholesome, honestly. And everybody has like, it's usually like two or three letters. I think it's all three letters that are the symbols, which might have nothing to do with it. So, mahal memchet lamed is the Likud symbol, right? Which is a little bit funny. But anyway, you are not picking a person, you're picking a party. And that party is the one that you wanna represent, okay? Now these parties, all together, all the parties that are running together, Eitan Levine: Yeah. It's adorable. Yeah. Shanie: get 120 seats in the Knesset. Knesset is the parliament, okay? And you get seats based on your vote share. So there's proportional representation. The more votes your party gets, the more of those 120 seats you get, okay? Now you need a simple majority to rule the government. That's 61 seats. No single party has ever gotten 61 seats. The closest that anyone's gotten is like 55. It was decades ago, okay? It was like in the 50s or 60s. Okay, so what that means is that you have to team up with other parties to form a coalition. That's what we call a coalition Okay, it's the group of parties that run together to reach that 61 thresholds, right? So I listed you earlier I said that the Netanyahu block has 52 seats Let's say in this scenario not right now. Okay, right. obviously is over 61 now, but you know in this polling for the future Who is that? That's the Likud party plus the Orthodox parties plus the far right messianic religious Zionist parties. When you add them all together, you get to 52. Okay, which is not enough by the way, but let's like right now he has basically all those parties, but they have over 61. Okay, and together they can govern. So in 2022, it included all the parties I just named it included the Likud, it included Bezalas Smotrich's religious Zionist party with Itzmar Ben-Gver's Otzma Yehudit Jewish power party. They were running together. and I'll explain why they're running together later on. Plus this party noam, which like their whole thing is that they hate gay people. It's like his main thing. And they all ran together to make it in. We... Eitan Levine: That that's actually my uncle's that's just my uncle, Noam. It's one guy who got a lot of juice behind him. Guys a question how many current parties are there in this current iteration of Knesset? Shanie: Yes. I think four, does 14 sound right? Okay, I'll tell you why it's confusing because a lot of the parties like they run together and then they split back up. So here, one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, 10, 11, 12, 13, oh, 14, I guess I was right. So. Eitan Levine: Look at that. But in America, in America it's two parties. You're voting Democrat, you're voting Republican. In Israel, the Knesset, I say the biggest difference between the American system and the Israeli system is that there are fourteen parties and it is a power struggle between the fourteen parties versus the two parties. It also means, by the way, and this is my favorite quote that I ever heard about Knesset, is that if you lose the election, you still hang around. And in America, yeah. about Yeah. No. Shanie: Yes. yeah, there's actually a hilarious music video. In America, there's no like tie. There's no such thing as a tie in America. Also remember like how big of a country America is. So it would be crazy to have a tie in a country like America compared to a place like Israel where like things can get very close. And somebody asked us, by the way, you can like DM me or Aton if you have questions. Someone asked us, is there a chance the election ends in a draw? So yes, there very much is a chance for that. If no combination of parties can put together the 61 seats, there is no government. The current government stays in power and you go back to elections. And then if you still can't do it, you go again and again and again. And if anyone's been following this in 2019, 2020, in a matter of 12 months, there were three elections. And in a matter of like three years, there from 2020 to 20, from 2019 to 2022, there were five elections. Okay. So countries had a lot of elections. Eitan Levine: Bef question, before the before that, you know, let's say before two thousand, was it frequent also to have multiple elections for a single election or is this more of a recent kind of phenomenon over the past twenty something years? Shanie: Mm-hmm. It had happened before, but not this level. There had never been three elections in a 12-month period. That was, like, everybody was talking about how insane that was. Eitan Levine: Maybe maybe the dumbest question you'll ever get has Israeli government and Knesset become more polarized and angry over the past twenty ish something years, or has it kind of like stayed on course? Shanie: I wouldn't say polarized. think the whole spectrum has shifted to the right in a really extreme way. So people like to talk about polarization, but actually the whole spectrum has just shifted rightwards. So like the left is, I don't think the left is more left. The left is more right and the right is more right. Everybody's more a little bit to the right. Do they hate each other more? Eitan Levine: That's kind of beautiful. Shanie: Maybe like when Menachem Begin was going into power, people thought that it was like gonna be the end of Israel because he was so far right wing from the Likud, what is now the Likud party. Meanwhile, like today he would def, I mean, his son was pushed out of Likud party and he would never be in Likud today. I think it's safe to say. So, you know, things change. Eitan Levine: Okay, I don't want to screw up your list. What is the next thing that you had written down? Shanie: Please don't, please don't. Okay, so here's what I want. wanna make sure that, I assume it's mostly Americans listening. So there's no geographic districts. And I actually think this is, I've looked into it. This is very unusual. Now, Israel's a really small country, so it does kind of make sense. There's no congressional geographic districts. Similar, like the British parliamentary model, which this is kind of based a little bit on British parliaments, but they have that. There's one nationwide district. So you're voting, like it doesn't matter where you live basically, like your vote. Eitan Levine: Yes. Shanie: counts the same amount as everybody else. Okay, that makes sense? You do have regional and city councils, but that's different. Eitan Levine: Yeah, it's interesting. Like is there like do they do like a political heat map like Steve Kornaki in front of like the CNN map? Like are there there's voting districts and stuff like that? Like does it break down? Like do you see red clumps and blue clumps or whatever color clump? Shanie: Yes. I was only able to find this in Hebrew, but I know that like I've seen in the past after the 2022 election, I was able to see like how people voted in different towns and you can obviously see like different parts of the West Bank, Jerusalem versus Tel Aviv, like you could people are voting the way you think they're voting. If you're secular, you're overwhelmingly voting for the left, especially if you're secular Ashkenazi versus if you're Mizrahi, you're more religious. Like it's very clear how people are voting based on their identities and where they live. Eitan Levine: Do they do they have Shanie: But you don't see it in advance. I don't think there's polling like that ahead of time. I've only seen it post-elections, but I'll look into it. Eitan Levine: Is there do they it'd be kind of funny if they do do like a heat map or whatever, but it has the different every single party represented and it just looks like a Jackson Pollock exploded onto Israel. is like is that the thing you're looking at when you see this, or is it just like two colors, like coalition opposition, or is it broad swath of okay. Shanie: No, no, no, it's based on the party. It's based on the party. So it actually is a Jackson Pollock. right. Now that I'm thinking about it, I think. Yeah, it's lovely. I'll send you it. I don't know if your Hebrews up to par, but I'll send it to you if you want to look. Eitan Levine: Nice. That's beautiful. I can promise you it's not. Actually, after a month and a half of taking Duolingo, I stopped because the only thing I could say was the horse ate a peach. Hasus Ochel off our sake, Shine Reichman. I don't know if you heard this. Shanie: You So what's funny is I speak to my two year old in Hebrew and that's actually like one of the sentences, like she knows all those specific words because they come up in daily life so I think she can say that sentence too. Eitan Levine: she's also doing Duolingo. Good to know, good to know. That's great. what is next on on Shaney's list? Yeah. Shanie: Okay, next up. Okay, so each party has a ranked list of candidates. So Likud, for example, they put up a list of 50 people. Okay, these are our top 50 people. Now, just like for context of what the party list means, the list is the candidates. So like who are the people who are going to be sitting in the Knesset? So every party is putting together their list. Now, they're... They're not so ambitious. Like their list is not 120 people because they know they're not getting 120 seats. But if you're a big party, you might put up 40 or 50 names. Right. So here's how it works. Let's say Shas is a random party. OK, Shas is ultra some ultra orthodox Bizarre party. They win 22 seats, which they are not going to do, but they win 22 seats. That means the first 22 names on that list get into the Knesset. If you're number 23, like if I'm number 23 on that list, I don't get in. You're number 24 on that list. You don't get in. But if Aton's number 22. He's in, okay? Now, the question you're gonna ask is like, who makes this list and what is this list? And by the way, the party chairman is the top of the list. So the names that you're hearing, like Gadi Isengard is the top of his party's list, obviously. Netanyahu, top of Likud. There are a few different ways this is chosen. For the Likud party, for example, your registered voters actually vote in sort of a primary. The Democratic party, Democrats, the Hademocrats, even I don't know in English, Yair Golan's party also has... has an actual primary vote, which is why we don't know their list yet. think later this month, they're gonna do their primaries. But a lot of other parties, you actually have the party leader decide. I think Yesheteed Get Your Lapid chooses. In the case of the Haredi parties, you actually have a rabbinic council, like a bunch of rabbis choose the list, which makes sense. And so it's like all different ways that the lists are created, but basically that's what the list is and does. Does that make sense? Eitan Levine: Yes, I got a question. What is the minimum threshold for if you are a party for even getting on to the ballot? Shanie: Yeah. I think anyone can run. Like I've seen really small parties run. I'll find out if there's actually a minimum to get on the ballot. I assume there must be. But like you have parties that got like 400 seats. So I need to look into that. But the question you're really asking is to get into the Knesset, the electoral threshold. Yes, I know. So a party needs three point two five percent of the national vote to get any seats at all. OK, now that's about Eitan Levine: Yes, sorry, y yes. Shanie: Four seats. So basically the minimum number of seats you can get is three or four seats If you're getting the equivalent of one or two or three seats, you're not getting in and so those are called what we call really wasted votes Okay, and so that's why you end up seeing these small parties merging remember I said Bethesda's Moterich and it's a marban gear and the noam party They all merged together why because on their own Netanyahu specifically was no He was the one who pushed them back in 2019 to run together because he said I don't want to waste right-wing votes Okay, so you need to run together because for years these types of parties were running but not enough people voted for them and so they they never made it in and by the way in 2019 when I would have conversations with people in sort of the pro-israel community in America I would say look at what's happening like these guys are gonna get into the Knesset they were like you're crazy that'll never happen. Are you kidding? And I was like, yes, I was preparing right now to make that happen. Now those people are the finance minister, national security minister is just you know, six years later. Anyway, good example of Eitan Levine: I think one of them was serving me swarma at Yashka the other day, also. I mean, they're everywhere. They got the whole place bugged. Shanie: One more thing just so that you know in 2022 just so that you can understand how consequential this threshold is the merits party that was the left-wing Zionist party Missed the threshold by just a few thousand votes. They got a hundred and fifty thousand votes in Israel That is a lot that it's three point one six percent instead of three point two five percent All of those seats go in the garbage. So there's a lot of like Monday morning quarterbacking saying like They should have merged with the Labour Party because then you would have had another four seats for the opposition for the left and they all just died. So good example of how you can get screwed if you don't merge together. And by the way, in the end, the Labour Party and the Marriott's Party did merge to become the Democrats under Yair Golan, which is who's running now for that very reason. Like if they ran separately, they might not make it in. And then you're risking a lot of votes going to waste for your block. Eitan Levine: This is gonna like throw off your list and I'm curious tell me if you want to hit this later. But the idea of like how do you vote? Like if you are, let's say you're like an Israeli who likes one party but knows that their party potentially is gonna be like a not big influence and it maybe won't even hit the threshold. Like, is there a voting for party over strategy? Is it like what is kind of like the tactic when you're an Israeli going to the voting booth under this system? Shanie: I think a lot of people are voting strategically. If you're looking to vote for a small party, you better be pretty sure they're going to make it in. I had a lot of friends who used to vote for merits and now, and like they always joke like, yeah, my party, like I took a risk on a party that ended up not making it. I mean, people didn't think people thought they were, they were projected to get five votes, five seats, by the way. And they ended up falling below. Like people were really surprised. I remember being really surprised that they didn't make it in. was always new. was possible, but I thought they would get five seats. I think they were projected to get five seats. Eitan Levine: What's what screwed them up? Shanie: You know, people, yeah, no, like there's propaganda before the elections. Netanyahu has a way of like winning elections in general. That guy's real lucky, real strategic. But no, like polling is not always exact. A lot of people don't decide until later on who they're going to vote for. And remember, it's a matter of like a few thousand votes that could have gotten them in. So like, what does it take for 10,000 people in the whole country to change their mind about who they're voting for at the last minute? Not so much. In terms Eitan Levine: I just no. Mm-hmm. sponsorship. Shanie: I actually don't see a ton of, I'm trying to think if I've seen like ads with celebrities in Israel for political campaigns this cycle. I haven't really, but we'll make sure to let you guys know if we see any. Now I haven't seen it. I don't think so, but I'll check. Usually there's like music videos and it's very fun. Eitan Levine: Is that thing historically? Like Yeah. Shanie: It's very funny to see how they end up like, it's very different. I think I've sent you Aton, like some of the music videos, even in like cartoon form that different Israeli politicians have created that you would never have in the States. Like it would be totally insane unhinged if someone had that. Eitan Levine: I was like, at some point, at some point we're gonna do an episode on like just election marketing and how that universe totally works. And the funniest thing is that these these commercials and these music, you know, whatever, it is very like Texas Congress, you know, like like I'm I'm Phil and I'm gonna take out this, you know, whatever. And then you know they have a gun and they shoot something. It's like that level of intensity, but with music videos. And it's funny because the American version of that is like the Kennedy, Kennedy, Kennedy, Kennedy, Kennedy, Kennedy, Ken. Yeah, like it's this like the American version is like nice and happy. And the ones that you have sent me from the Israeli side, not as happy. Not as but still musical, which I really appreciated. Shanie: Okay, back to my list, Eitan, stop distracting me, is the president of Israel, which is a ceremonial role. The reason I'm especially bringing him up is because I made a mistake and I fact-checked myself last episode where I said that the current president, Isaac, Bougie's like his nickname, don't ask me why, Herzog, that his father was the chief rabbi, but actually was his grandfather was the chief rabbi of Israel. His father was actually also the president of Israel. I was explaining how they're kind of like the Kennedy family. Eitan Levine: Yes, sorry, sorry, sorry. Shanie: So yeah, he's the president, his dad was the president, his uncle was the UN ambassador, and his grandfather was the chief rabbi. So that's like a big political dynasty. Anyway, he is the president. The president is voted every seven years. Remember, you have Knesset every, a new election for the national elections every four years. So the president is like beyond the Knesset cycle and beyond the general elections, but the Knesset votes them in. It's a ceremonial role, so they don't do that much. They're supposed to be kind of above politics. Eitan Levine: Yeah. Shanie: and sort of disconnected from that. So they often talk a lot about like unity and how to end building a nation together. But the main like their time to shine is during the election itself, where they actually decide who gets the first opportunity to build a coalition. So after the election within a week, he's meeting with the head of every party that made it into the Knesset. So if you got those four seats or more, you're the head of your list number one on your list. So Netanyahu for the Likud or Gadi Isenkot for the Yashar party, you're sitting in his office meeting with him and he meets with them to figure out who's going to be able to what we call cobble together a coalition and get that 61. It's usually the person who leads with the most seats. if, which means it could be, it's likely to be their Netanyahu or Gadi Isenkot, cause one of them is probably going to have the most seats. And he'll say, all right, you now have one to two months basically. no, you get one month, but you can have a two week extension to put this coalition together, which means that like, let's say it's got the Eisenkutt, now he needs to spend the next month. And again, you can have that two week extension meeting with everybody who he thinks is willing to sit with him and try and negotiate. then you, there's a lot of like, I hate to use the word bribery, but I really am inclined to use that word. It's a lot of promises to, I'll put you in this ministry position. You'll be in this cabinet. I'll give you this budget. for the example, like you want to bring in the ultra-orthodox, you need to promise them a big budget for the Ashivas. You want to bring in the Arab parties. You need to promise them a big budget for their stuff. Like everything is like budgets and cabinet posts. And by the way, one day I'll tell you about how many ministries there are in Israel and so many stupid ones. Why? Because that's one of the like gifts that you give people. create a ministry and you say, here, now you have a ministry. It means you have a budget and you have advisors and an office for literally no reason other than I want you to be in my coalition. So a lot of it's like a little bit ridiculous. and inherently corrupt in my view. Again, like there's corruption everywhere. It's not unique to Israel, but this like version of corruption, find it's like above board corruption. You know I mean? It's not like we're doing shady stuff behind closed doors. Like, no, the whole system is built around like, I need to convince you to come stay with me, which means I need to like incentivize you. And how do I incentivize you with budgets and with pet, whatever. By the way, that's how you ends up with really small parties. Eitan Levine: Yeah. Shanie: Basically, if you're the most annoying person, you're gonna get the most out of it. So someone like Itamar Ben-Vir, Batal Smotrich, because they're crazier, they get more because they're like, I don't care. I don't need to sit with you. I'll be happy in the opposition. What do I need you for, Bibi? Like, you need to give me what I want or I'm running away, right? Versus like the Haredi parties, which I think Netanyahu was like, all right, the ultra-orthodox, they're gonna run with me. They're not gonna go, like they're strategic. They're gonna stick with me. They're not going anywhere else. Versus Itamar Ben-Vir is like, Screw you, I don't care. I'll go somewhere else. I don't need to go anywhere. I don't need to be in the government. I was never in the government before. there's a quest, then you need to give him a lot more. So it's like the threshold is like, however annoying you are, that's how much you're gonna get. That's my perspective. Eitan Levine: Can we I don't know if this is I don't know if you're gonna talk about this later. I don't want to scrub your list, but another question is just like party forming, like I one of the things that I find interesting about the Israeli system is that frequently it's parties that are around for one election cycle or two election cycles and then lose traction. A lot of parties are invented behind a person and then kind of are formed behind a person. So just talk to me a little bit about like how these parties kind of like come to be. If you're a newer party, even if you're Gaudi Eisencott, that his party did not exist last time, if I'm not mistaken, and now is leading in Knesset. So talk to me a little bit about just how like party formation and specifically with personality driving the party works. Shanie: Correct. Yeah, that makes I would say it's very personality driven, but some of them are really long-foring parties. The Likud party has been around for a long time and it predates Bibi Netanyahu. It has now become the party of Netanyahu such that it's even hard to imagine anyone else, but it was a very different party with very different people and very different frankly policies and principles in 1977 when it first came to power. The Labor Party, which doesn't exist anymore, that was the founding party of Israel from it was like it was the party of Ben Gurion. It was the Mapai party back then, but it like transformed into the Havodah party. But it was around for a very, very long time. So you do have a few historic parties that were always around, but most of the parties right now, and the ultra-Orthodox parties don't change as much. Like you don't, see them coming back over and over. You see some version of the ultra-Orthodox parties. I think it's actually more in like that center, center left, where you see like Naftali Bennett, he was running with Ayelet Shaked on a different seat. Then he's running alone. Now he's with Lapid. You see him changing a lot. Yesha Tied is like a medium new party. Like it's not that new. It's like within the last few decades, but it's not like a founding party of the country. The Democrats is relatively new, but it's really the merits. It's like it was the merits and labor party merger. So yeah, I think that some of these are like more institutions and some like are a little bit based on the person. Yesha Gadi Eisenkot is a very good example of like it's just about one guy, but I wouldn't say that's the case for all of them. The ultra-orthodox parties are going to exist. With whoever the rabbis decide from that community are going to exist. the likud party in theory should actually outlive netanyahu, right? Like there is no clear successor because they really like him over there But in theory you could have a primary you could have somebody else the head of likud party same with the democrats. I I really think it's scotty eisenkot's party. That's so centered around one person and bennett as well bennett bennett's party is really about him and his people like he was created with for those like center, right, but what we call mamlqti, which is like you care about statesmanship, being on the straight and narrow, patriotism. Eitan Levine: Teenek New Jersey. It's the Teenek New Jersey branch of the Israeli government. Sorry. We're Shanie: Sure, sure. Eitan Levine: We're gonna I'm I'm leaving like a second. Yeah, yeah, sorry, appreciate it. All right. Security's kicking me out. let's let's go through the what's the next part of your list? Shanie: my God. I was gonna explain like a lot more about the Knesset, but it might be a little too in the weeds. But basically, what's important to know is there's only two branches. There's no like third branch of government. It's the Knesset makes the laws, but it's also like the executive branch and the legislative branch are the same. Like they're connected because the prime minister is the head of the Knesset too, and he chooses the speaker of the Knesset, et cetera. And then you have the judiciary, which is the only check on their power. So there's no like, there's no midterm election. There's no like. Eitan Levine: waits, yeah. Shanie: House representatives, senators in Congress, none of that exists. It's just one party that's making laws together. And that's part of why the judiciary conversation is always coming up because they're always getting in the way and trying to block things they see as non-unconstitutional that the government's trying to do. So we'll get into that later, but that's one piece of it. I did wanna make sure that I said that there are no absentee ballots unless you are... Like a diplomat or like working for the jewish agency So if you are an israeli citizen abroad and you want to fly you have to fly back to vote The aid coalition is helping people figure out how do that. That's aid-coalition.org Aid-coalition.org You should go to that website if you're an israeli living abroad and you want to fly home. turn out is really high, but I think that's important to say Since you're like getting kicked out i'll it's Eitan Levine: Did they put you on a nice airplane? Is it L L or is it Lot Polish Airlines? Shanie: I believe it's, I believe it's El Al, but I'm not sure. And I'm also gonna direct people to Israel Policy Forum's like 120 Project Elections Hub, which has like a lot of explainers if you really wanna dig into it. It's israelpolicyforum.org forward slash 120, not the numbers, the words, like O-N-E 20, yeah. If you can spell, then you're good. And then we can talk about. Eitan Levine: Good, you're good. One twenty. Shanie: since your time is up, the like how and when coalitions fall apart was my next thing, but we can discuss that next time also. Eitan Levine: Yeah, you know what? I think that is actually a very good wrap up because I think next week I really want to go through the individual parties a little bit more and this is a really good place to cut it here. I want to and of any of the questions that were submitted ahead of time, were there any that that were not covered? Because I did get some Instagram questions that we were planning on talking about. Shanie: People, yes, yes, yes. So somebody wanted to know what Israelis find appealing about Eisenkot, which is like a funny, it's a little bit of a snarky question. Like what do people even like about this guy? I think what people like is that he's a nice trustworthy guy. People really believe in him because he came from the IDF, he was the IDF chief of staff, which means that he's from the most trusted institution in Israel. And people really like that. He doesn't have a long history of being in politics, which. can really bar your image because if you're in politics for a bunch of cycles, people are going to have basically a lot of ammunition to attack you with probably because you probably screwed up a bunch of times as politicians do. Whereas here you were just like running the idea of what people really like and respect. If you watch any of his speeches, which I will admit there are not that many in English, but he just like seems like a lovely Quiet down to earth guy who you would like and respect. So I think it's a lot of that It's really the military piece that I think is helping him bring in those center right wing Likud voters who are like maybe they're maybe they want to vote for Likud but they're pissed off because they see the ultra-orthodox draft exemption law, right and they don't like that because they're Reservists then they might go to someone like Gadi Eisenkot who says, know I have a lot of the same principles of the center, right? But I'm gonna draft the ultra-orthodox which is a winning principle a winning policy in the Israeli public But you should also just listen to our last episode where we talked about this for like an hour. Eitan Levine: I to say that. The Gotti Isaac cut explained it episode is out there. I have to start going out here because I'm officially getting kicked out. But Shanie Reichman from the Israel Policy Forum, thank you so much for joining me on the New York Times for another episode of 120 Angry Seats. We will be back next week with another episode of this. please submit all your questions to me and Shainee and the Israel Policy Forum on Instagram. And with that, we'll see you next week, Shanie Barstool.