Latest / Reformed Thinking / The Gift of Land, The Old Testament
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to Reformed Thinking.
- 0:01Today we're going to get into a topic that really you can't
- 0:05understand the Old Testament without it.
- 0:06We're talking about the land. And it's so much more than just
- 0:10a piece of real estate, right? It's it's the entire theological
- 0:13stage. The sources we're looking at
- 0:14today track it from divine ownership all the way to how
- 0:19prophecy redefined the whole thing.
- 0:21Yeah, and if you think you can just bypass this topic, well,
- 0:24you're missing a huge piece of the puzzle.
- 0:26The sheer frequency of the word in Hebrew is, well, it's pretty
- 0:30staggering. It really is.
- 0:31I mean, Moshe Weinfeld's observation is a great starting
- 0:33point. The Hebrew word eria, which
- 0:36means both land and earth, is the fourth most common word in
- 0:40the entire Old Testament. The 4th, The 4th.
- 0:43That's not an accident. It tells you right away that
- 0:45this is absolutely central to how the Bible thinks and tells
- 0:48its story. It's the stage where redemption
- 0:50happens. OK, so let's start with the
- 0:52Bible. Starts right at the top.
- 0:53The absolute sovereignty of God or I am over the earth over
- 0:58over. Right, so the sources layout
- 1:00that I am is the one and only owner of the Earth.
- 1:03And he makes this claim in two distinct ways.
- 1:06It's a dual claim, and it's not just a philosophical idea, it's
- 1:09what drives the history. So the first claim is the most
- 1:12obvious one, I suppose. Owner by creation.
- 1:14Exactly. He made it so he owns it.
- 1:17Simple as that. But there's a nuance here that
- 1:19the source of point out, which I think is fascinating.
- 1:21As the Creator, he owns everything, but he keeps a kind
- 1:25of transcendence over it. He reserves the heavens for
- 1:28himself, and he gives the earth to humankind.
- 1:31An act of grace. A total act of grace.
- 1:33We're placed here on area, as you could say, God's appointed
- 1:36managers or Regents. Our job is to cultivate it, to
- 1:39build culture, to reflect his own image back onto his own
- 1:42property. But we can never forget who
- 1:44holds the actual title deed. Never.
- 1:47The earth is not ours, the psalmist says it plainly.
- 1:49The earth is the Lord's and everything in it, so our entire
- 1:53existence here is 1 of borrowed stewardship.
- 1:56And that stewardship has conditions, which I think leads
- 1:59us straight into the second claim, owner by conquest.
- 2:02This is where God's ownership gets demonstrated in history.
- 2:05Yes, this is so critical. He doesn't just own the land
- 2:09because he made it in the distant past, he actively takes
- 2:13possession of it as the Divine Warrior.
- 2:16This is key to understanding how Israel got there.
- 2:18It wasn't their own military strength.
- 2:20Not at all. The land is given to them
- 2:22through Joshua's sword. Yes, but I am M is the one
- 2:26wielding it. He is the victor who goes before
- 2:28them, fighting this holy war against the Canaanites.
- 2:31And you can see this tying together the creative right and
- 2:34the historical action. I'm thinking of the song of the
- 2:36sea in Exodus. After Egypt is defeated, Moses
- 2:40sings that God will plant his people on his holy mountain.
- 2:43Which is reference to Zion and by extension the whole land CC
- 2:46the creation claim and the conquest claim are locked
- 2:49together. The land is doubly his by right
- 2:52of creation and by right of redemptive conquest.
- 2:54So as the absolute owner, he's also the one who distributes the
- 2:59property. He's the ultimate distributor.
- 3:00You see this hinted out of the table of nations in Genesis 10.
- 3:03The idea is that God is the one who parcels out the earth,
- 3:06setting the boundaries for all the nations deciding where they
- 3:09should live. So a nation's possession of a
- 3:11territory is never based on their own strength or their own
- 3:14inherent right. Never.
- 3:16It's always a divine assignment. And if God is the one who
- 3:19assigns well, he also has the right to reassign.
- 3:22Which brings us to this idea of sovereign replacement and
- 3:26judgement. This is so important for
- 3:27understanding God's justice. He has the sovereign right to
- 3:31well to evict old owners and bring in new ones.
- 3:34And this wasn't some special rule just for Israel.
- 3:36The sources cite a pattern right even before Israel showed up.
- 3:40Exactly. Before Israel ever got to
- 3:42Canaan, God had already replaced the Emites with the Moabites and
- 3:45the Horites with the Edomites. So this principle of
- 3:48displacement was already an established divine policy.
- 3:51It showed everyone that ownership is conditional.
- 3:54So when it comes to the Canaanites being replaced by
- 3:56Israel, there's a very specific reason given.
- 3:59An absolutely clear reason God replaced them because of the
- 4:02wickedness of those nations. It was a moral judgement.
- 4:05In fact, the grant to Abraham was actually put on hold delayed
- 4:08because, as Genesis says, the iniquity of the Amorites was not
- 4:12yet full. So God waited.
- 4:13He waited until their corruption was, you might say, ripe for
- 4:16judgement. Yes, and that frames the whole
- 4:19conquest in a different light. It's not primarily a political
- 4:23act to favor Israel. It's an act of God's holiness
- 4:26against deep, systemic sin. Israel just happens to be the
- 4:30instrument he uses to carry out the judgement.
- 4:32That makes so much sense. It means the land itself has a
- 4:35kind of moral framework. It does.
- 4:37It can't tolerate certain levels of idolatry and corruption, as
- 4:41the text says, eventually vomit out its inhabitants.
- 4:44The whole thing moves from just being about ancient warfare to
- 4:47being about divine order. And that idea of order is a
- 4:50perfect pivot to the next point, the meaning of the land that
- 4:54goes beyond just territory. It's existential and
- 4:58sociological symbolism. Right, because the reason land
- 5:00is such a powerful theme is that it taps into this really deep
- 5:03yearning. We all have the need for a home,
- 5:06the need to be in a safe, settled, predictable place.
- 5:09It's a basic human psychological need for stability.
- 5:12Absolutely. And Brueggemann makes the point
- 5:14that Hiri is way more than just geographical space.
- 5:17It's a place of memory, a place for a meaningful life.
- 5:20It's what gives you roots, identity, a story that continues
- 5:23through generations. Without the land, a people are
- 5:26adrift. And this need for a home, for a
- 5:29place, connects to the bigger theological idea of order versus
- 5:33chaos. Yes, that's the core contrast.
- 5:36The land symbolizes the move from a disordered, wandering
- 5:39life to one with ordered, governed structures.
- 5:42It stands for a world benevolently ordered by God for
- 5:45human security and flourishing. To really get the value of that
- 5:49order, though, you have to understand its opposite, which
- 5:51is what Israel experienced first, the wilderness.
- 5:54The wilderness is the complete antithesis of a normal human
- 5:57society. It's described as formless,
- 5:59lifeless. It has none of the supports or
- 6:02resources that give life meaning and structure.
- 6:04And that's why it's such a potent place for testing faith.
- 6:07Exactly because in the wilderness you have nothing
- 6:10else. You are thrown to a state of
- 6:12pure, moment by moment dependence on God.
- 6:16It's where you either remember his promises about the land, or
- 6:19you forget them and start wishing you were back in Egypt.
- 6:21So the land is the foundation for human flourishing.
- 6:24It's a Cultural Center, right? It provides the stability you
- 6:27need to produce food, to raise animals, to create wealth and to
- 6:32multiply. It allows people to actually be
- 6:34culture makers. To fulfill that original mandate
- 6:37to be God's regions. You can't really do that from a
- 6:39tent in the desert. You need stability, Law, art,
- 6:42established worship, all of that requires A settled place.
- 6:46The land is the prerequisite, the stage where a righteous
- 6:49society is meant to live out its calling in God's presence.
- 6:52It's a mirror of the garden. OK.
- 6:53So we've established who the owner is and we've talked about
- 6:55what the property means. Now we get to the the terms of
- 7:00the agreement, so to speak, the dual covenant structure.
- 7:03And this duality is maybe the single most helpful concept for
- 7:07making sense of Israel's story. As Gerhard Monrad pointed out,
- 7:11God's call to Abraham to go to Canaan with a promise of that
- 7:14land. That one event basically sets
- 7:17the course for the entire Old Testament.
- 7:19That's the foundation, the unconditional grant.
- 7:21Yes, the Abrahamic covenant. This establishes an eternal
- 7:24right to the land given purely by God's election.
- 7:27It guarantees Israel's existence and their eventual possession of
- 7:31the land forever. So this is a promise that can't
- 7:34be broken. It can't.
- 7:35Even when Israel fails in the most sectacular ways, even when
- 7:39they're judged and exiled, that original promise remains the
- 7:42unshakeable basis for their future redemption.
- 7:46God's faithfulness to his own promise is what guarantees their
- 7:49future, not their own faithfulness.
- 7:51And Abraham's role here is just foundational.
- 7:53His journey out of his homeland is one of the two big events
- 7:56that forms Israel, right? You have Abraham's Exodus which
- 7:59sets the goal Canon, and then you have Moses exodus from Egypt
- 8:02which accomplishes the liberation needed to get to that
- 8:05goal. But this unconditional grant has
- 8:07a partner, doesn't it? And that's the conditional
- 8:09tenure under the Mosaic covenant.
- 8:11Exactly. This is the other side of the
- 8:12coin. The Abrahamic promise ensures
- 8:16they will possess the land, but the Mosaic law defines how they
- 8:20must live in the land. And this is where that legal
- 8:23term comes in, Usefruct. It's a bit technical, but it's
- 8:27essential here. It is, but the concept is pretty
- 8:29straightforward. Use of fruits basically means
- 8:32you have the right to use and enjoy the profits of a property
- 8:35that you don't own. So Israel gets the uses, the use
- 8:38of the land and the fructus, the fruits or profits.
- 8:40They get all. The benefits, all the benefits,
- 8:42but God retains what's called the abuses, the right to dispose
- 8:46of the property He holds the title deed.
- 8:49So their enjoyment of the land is completely conditional on
- 8:52their faithfulness to the covenant, their obedience to the
- 8:55Torah. And if they break that covenant?
- 8:57He reserves the right to withdraw the gift, not
- 9:00permanently. The Abrahamic promise holds, but
- 9:03temporarily, which is exactly what exile.
- 9:06Is you can see this usefruk status playing out in Israel's
- 9:09daily life, like with the sabbatical and Jubilee years.
- 9:11Oh, absolutely. Every seven years the land has
- 9:14to rest. Every 50 years, all land goes
- 9:17back to its original family owners.
- 9:19These cycles were constant, built in reminders that they
- 9:23were not the ultimate owners. They're just managers living
- 9:26under God's rules. And God even defines their
- 9:28status using this kind of language.
- 9:30He calls them aliens and tenants living with.
- 9:33Right. The Hebrew words Gare and tuja,
- 9:36they point to a temporary dependent status.
- 9:39They are guests on God's property.
- 9:42They are under His protection, but they are accountable to Him
- 9:45for how they use His land. This all creates a really
- 9:47interesting tension in Israel's identity because they aren't
- 9:51just tenants, they're also called God sons.
- 9:53And that's the core tension. It mirrors the covenant
- 9:56structure perfectly. On one hand, you have what you
- 9:58could call the indicative mood. It's unconditional.
- 10:01The fact that Israel is God's Son is a fixed reality rooted in
- 10:04his choice. They don't earn that status.
- 10:07But then there's the other side. Then there's the imperative
- 10:09mood, which is conditional. Each generation has to actively
- 10:13obey God to enjoy the rights and blessings of being faithful
- 10:17sons. A son who rebels doesn't stop
- 10:20being a son. But he loses his privileges.
- 10:23Exactly. He loses the benefits, he faces
- 10:25discipline. And this tension explains pretty
- 10:28much all of Israel's history. God never gives up on the
- 10:31indicative. He never revokes their election.
- 10:34But he absolutely enforces the imperative through judgement and
- 10:37discipline. It's a key idea and Reformed
- 10:40thought too, isn't it? The relationship between our
- 10:42unchangeable status and justification and the required
- 10:45obedience of sanctification. It's the exact same pattern.
- 10:48We are forever his children, but we can still be grounded, so to
- 10:52speak, if we violate the household rules.
- 10:55OK, let's move from the legal structure to the actual place
- 10:57itself, the specific land grant, Canaan and Zion.
- 11:00Right. So the heartland promise to
- 11:02Israel is Canaan. God swears an oath to give to
- 11:05Abraham and his descendants as a royal land grant forever.
- 11:08This promise is repeated over and over again.
- 11:11And the sources are pretty clear about the geographic boundaries.
- 11:13This wasn't some vague mythical place.
- 11:15No, not at all. It was a real territory with
- 11:18defined borders, the desert in the South, the Mediterranean Sea
- 11:22in the West, specific mountains in the north and the Jordan
- 11:26River and Dead Sea on the east. A tangible, physical piece of
- 11:30land. And the descriptions of it are
- 11:31just incredible. A land flowing with milk and
- 11:34honey. And that's not just poetry, it's
- 11:37theology. The sources note that the
- 11:39inheritance included houses that Israel did not build, wells they
- 11:43did not dig and orchards they did not plant.
- 11:46Which again reinforces the idea that it's all a gift.
- 11:48It's grace. It's meant to stop them from
- 11:49thinking they earned it themselves.
- 11:51Right. And then within this special
- 11:53land, there's one spot that becomes even more distinct Zion,
- 11:57God's unique earthly residence, which becomes Jerusalem.
- 12:00Yes, it's called the City of God because the great King lives
- 12:03there. The holiness of the entire land
- 12:06sort of flows outward from this one central point of God's
- 12:09presence. And the history of that spot is
- 12:11just layered with meaning. It's identified as the same
- 12:14mountain where Abraham was told to sacrifice Isaac.
- 12:17Which is just incredible. It connects the central promise
- 12:20of the Abrahamic Covenant, the oath God swore to Abraham there,
- 12:23directly to the central place of worship for the entire nation.
- 12:27And then David brings the ark there and establishes it as the
- 12:30place for the temple. And at the temple's dedication,
- 12:32God takes up residence. He declares it his resting place
- 12:36forever. The entire glory and security of
- 12:38that city comes from one fact. God chooses to live there among
- 12:42His people. The holiness of the land comes
- 12:45from the presence of the landowner.
- 12:47So the gift is given, the conditions are set, the location
- 12:50is identified, but as we know, Israel continuously failed to
- 12:54meet the requirements of their tenancy, which brings us to the
- 12:57tests of fidelity in their history.
- 12:59Right. The sources really frame
- 13:00Israel's failures as a series of three distinct tests, starting
- 13:04with the first one in the wilderness, the testing by want.
- 13:07The wilderness, being the opposite of the land, was the
- 13:09perfect training ground, or at least it was supposed to be.
- 13:11It was designed to force total dependence on God and His Word,
- 13:15not on bread alone. But that first generation failed
- 13:18comprehensively. You see it in the constant
- 13:20murmuring, the quarreling, the fear, always wanting to go back
- 13:23to the slavery of Egypt because at least there was food.
- 13:27And the ultimate failure at Kadesh Barnea, a failure of
- 13:30courage, which was really a failure of faith in the one who
- 13:34promised to give them the land. And that failure led to 40 years
- 13:38of wandering. So if that first Test was about
- 13:40having nothing, the second test was the opposite.
- 13:43The land test, the testing by prosperity.
- 13:45Once they're in Canaan, the gift itself becomes the source of
- 13:48temptation. They start to forget the giver.
- 13:51Moses warned them this would happen.
- 13:54In Deuteronomy, he lays out the specific temptation that Privile
- 13:57thought, my power and the strength of my hands have
- 13:59produced this wealth for me. It's a complete denial of their
- 14:02Yusufric status. It's them trying to claim the
- 14:05title deed for themselves. Precisely.
- 14:08And their faithfulness in the land was tested by their
- 14:11obedience to the Torah. That meant giving the tithes,
- 14:14offering the sacrifices, observing the feasts, all of
- 14:18which were constant reminders that the fruit of the land
- 14:21wasn't really theirs, they were just giving a portion back to
- 14:23the true owner. It also required them to finish
- 14:26the job of dispossessing the Canaanites.
- 14:29Yes, and that wasn't about random violence, it was about
- 14:32spiritual hygiene to prevent contamination.
- 14:35God knew that if they coexisted with Canaanite idolatry, it
- 14:39would corrupt them and the land would eventually eject them,
- 14:42just as the covenant curses warned.
- 14:44And since they failed both the test of scarcity and the test of
- 14:47prosperity, the inevitable result was the 3rd test, the
- 14:50test of exile and judgment. Right.
- 14:52The judgment itself becomes another phase of testing.
- 14:54The Exiles are tested in the furnace of affliction.
- 14:57The land literally throws them out for breaking the terms of
- 15:00the covenant. And the sources point to a
- 15:02critical internal reason for this failure, the false prophets
- 15:05of Zion. They played a huge role in the
- 15:08nation's downfall. They kept giving the people
- 15:11lying visions of peace and security.
- 15:13They refused to expose the depth of the people's sin.
- 15:16So they prevented any real repentance that might have
- 15:18changed the outcome. Exactly.
- 15:20They offered cheap grace and it led to ruin.
- 15:23And this collective failure, this refusal to repent, meant
- 15:26that the judgment had to be intensified.
- 15:31And it brings us to a really interesting part of the sources,
- 15:33the sacred numbers and how they relate to prophecy.
- 15:36The sacred semiotics of seven. Right.
- 15:39The number 7 in Scripture is a symbol of divine perfection, of
- 15:43completion. You see it everywhere, the seven
- 15:45days of creation, the Sabbath cycle.
- 15:47When you see seven, you should think a complete finished work.
- 15:50And that extends to the number 70, yes. 70 is the product of 2
- 15:54sacred numbers, 7 for perfection and 10 for fullness.
- 15:58So 70 represents a kind of complete, divinely administered
- 16:00period of time, especially when it comes to judgement.
- 16:03Which is why Jeremiah prophecies a 70 year exile in Babylon.
- 16:07It's presented as a standard sentence for rebellion, a
- 16:11complete period of time for penitence, to let the land have
- 16:14its Sabbaths that Israel had denied it.
- 16:16But then Daniel takes that number and multiplies it.
- 16:18This is where it gets really layered.
- 16:20Daniel's vision in Chapter 9 takes that 70 year period and
- 16:23multiplies it by 770 * 7 or 490 years.
- 16:28And why that multiplication? What does that signify?
- 16:31Well, it ties directly back to the covenant curses.
- 16:33In Leviticus 26, God warns that if Israel keeps disobeying, He
- 16:37will punish them seven times more for their sins.
- 16:41So this multiplication means that this new era of judgment is
- 16:44going to be the ultimate, complete and final one, all
- 16:47leading up to a climactic event in the fullness of time.
- 16:50And this period of 70 sevens was set to accomplish some very
- 16:53specific. Things.
- 16:54Six specific things, yes, including to anoint the most
- 16:57holy, to bring in everlasting righteousness, and to put a
- 17:00final end to sin. It's a divinely decreed
- 17:03timetable for the climax of redemption and judgement.
- 17:06And the prophecy gives a very specific signpost.
- 17:08It says after the 62 sevens, the anointed one will be cut off and
- 17:12will have nothing. Which finds it's clear
- 17:14fulfilment in the rejection and crucifixion of Jesus Christ by
- 17:17his own people. The entire system, land, law,
- 17:21prophecy was pointing to him. He was meant to be the one who
- 17:25would finally bring everlasting righteousness to the land.
- 17:28Instead, he was executed in the land.
- 17:31That signals a major shift in how all these promises are going
- 17:34to be fulfilled. A radical shift.
- 17:36You know Daniel, even while he was in exile in Babylon, he
- 17:38would pray three times a day, facing toward Jerusalem.
- 17:42That act was a statement of faith, a loyalty not just to a
- 17:45city, but to the entire divine destiny tied to that sacred
- 17:48place. The hope persisted even when
- 17:51they were cut off from the land itself.
- 17:53And that persistence of hope even outside the physical
- 17:55borders, that's a perfect transition to our final section,
- 17:58looking beyond the historical reality to the eschatological
- 18:02land. Right, because we have to
- 18:03acknowledge that while the land promises were fulfilled in part
- 18:06under Joshua and then later under David and Solomon, they
- 18:09were never fully consummated. The ideal permanent, unending
- 18:12rest never really happened. Which suggests the historical
- 18:15land was always pointing to something more.
- 18:17Exactly. It suggests there is still a
- 18:19future consummation of that sworn land for the people of
- 18:23God, a final, unending rest. So the ideal isn't just Canaan.
- 18:27The ideal is the regenerated earth, the new heavens and new
- 18:31earth where God's people enjoy his presence without any
- 18:34barriers. The promise extends beyond the
- 18:36original borders of Canaan to become a promise of a new world
- 18:40of security and blessing. And even in the periods after
- 18:43the temple was destroyed, you see this passionate focus on a
- 18:46future glorious restoration of Zion.
- 18:49It led to a rethinking of what Zion even.
- 18:51Was it did. Later literature starts to talk
- 18:55about a heavenly Jerusalem, one that existed before creation and
- 18:58served as the pattern for the earthly city.
- 19:00It shows that the ultimate reality of the land is not bound
- 19:04to our current historical order. So eventually the whole concept
- 19:07of the land was spiritualized. Yes, to refer to the life to
- 19:11come, the world to come after the resurrection.
- 19:13It came to represent the ultimate inheritance, which is
- 19:15intimate fellowship with God Himself.
- 19:17And you can see that idea foreshadowed with the Levites,
- 19:20can't you? They received no land
- 19:21inheritance in Canaan. An amazing foreshadowing.
- 19:25Their inheritance was I am himself.
- 19:27There were perpetual tenants and sojourners in the land living
- 19:31off the offerings given to God. It demonstrates that fellowship
- 19:34with the owner is a far greater inheritance than a deed to the
- 19:38property. It creates this beautiful
- 19:40theological path. The physical land was the
- 19:42preparatory stage, always pointing toward the eternal
- 19:45reality of dwelling with the. Owner.
- 19:47That's it exactly so. After all this, what does it all
- 19:50mean for us today? We've traced this huge
- 19:53structure, this tension between the certainty of the Abrahamic
- 19:56gift and the accountability of the Mosaic enjoyment.
- 20:00Well, it means that our relationship with God as
- 20:02Christians still contains that same tension.
- 20:05Our standing, our election as God's children is absolutely
- 20:09secure. It's unconditional, rooted in
- 20:11his saving work. That's the indicative mood.
- 20:14We're justified. But our enjoyment of the
- 20:16blessings of that status is conditional on our faithfulness,
- 20:18our obedience. That's the imperative.
- 20:20Right. We have to obey, to experience
- 20:22the fullness of what it means to be a child of the King and to
- 20:25avoid the discipline of a Holy Father.
- 20:27The Old Testament story of the land is the grand stage where
- 20:30God demonstrated this reality for all time.
- 20:33He is faithful to His promise, but He is just as faithful to
- 20:36His justice when we corrupt the gift He's given us.
- 20:39It's a reminder that everything we have, our homes, our
- 20:42resources, our security, it's all part of God's here.
- 20:45We're living in a state of use of work.
- 20:46We're tenants. And that leads to the final
- 20:48question, the one for you to think about.
- 20:51How do these Old Testament teachings about the land shape
- 20:54your spiritual life? How do they guide your obedience
- 20:57while you live as an alien and a tenant in this present world?
- 21:01If the physical land required total dependence and
- 21:03faithfulness from Israel, how much more does the spiritual
- 21:06life require our constant faith filled accountability to the
- 21:09Divine Owner of all things?