Latest / Booked For Questioning / Was Carrie White a monster, or was she pushed to become one? Stephen King
Transcript
- JoJo: Yeah, okay. so we're talking about high school or are we talking about a horror movie? 'Cause it sounds like both. Kaci: Well, with Carrie, those are basically the same thing. JoJo: Mm, yeah, pretty much. Marilena: Exactly, because today we're putting Carrie White on the stand. Is she a victim? Is she a monster? Is she warning about what happens when people push someone too far? Or are we just asking totally the wrong questions? JoJo: Mm, because if you hand somebody telekinetic powers after years of bullying and humiliation and religious trauma, you are basically giving the universe a very questionable customer service policy and there's no returns for that one. Kaci: Yeah. And in Stephen King's world, the universe has terrible customer service. JoJo: Yes. Kaci: Which is debatable 'cause I'm like, I feel like some of these little kids that get bullied, they need some power. Just go for it. Give give a little own, you know? JoJo: Yeah, for sure. Marilena: Yeah, for sure. Welcome back to Book for Questioning, the podcast where we put horror stories, suspicious characters, and questionable decisions under interrogation. Kaci: Yeah, I am so ready to investigate this topic, but I would like it on the record that I am not responsible for anything that happens in this episode. JoJo: Are you sure? Kaci: Plot well, I'm not gonna claim any of it. I'm not gonna confirm or deny any of it. JoJo: that's exactly what somebody responsible would say, right? Kaci: Tune in to find out. Marilena: Today we're investigating Stephen King's Carrie and the new Prime Video Adaptation. We're talking about bullying, online humiliation, the adults who fail to protect Carrie, and the big question: when tragedy happens, who deserves the blame? JoJo: the bully, the people laughing, the people watching, mmm, or maybe the adults doing absolutely nothing, or Carrie herself. Kaci: And maybe the uncomfortable answer is that the responsibility doesn't always belong to one person. JoJo: Mm that's something. Whoo, here we go. Kaci: Do this thing. Marilena: So before we get into the news series, let's establish the facts. Carrie began as Stephen King's debut novel in 1974. It follows Carrie White, a socially isolated teenage girl raised by her intensely religious and controlling mother, Margaret. JoJo: Mm-hmm. Marilena: And at school, Carrie becomes a target of bullying and humiliation, and at home, she struggles under her mother's control. And meanwhile, she discovers she's got telekinetic powers, meaning she can move objects with her mind. Kaci: So JoJo: Mm. Kaci: we all know this is a close to home my my Stephen King, he's the thing. And I JoJo: That's my favorite. Yeah. Kaci: I found that this show and this book were just so, so good. I mean, this the show remake of JoJo: Uh-huh. Kaci: this is super effective. Plus, like this supernatural element that she's got going on is not separate from her emotions, right? So you see it flare up when her emotions start getting higher, her fear, her anger, her shame and isolation, it's all tied into the way her powers emerge in this story. And I just it was so gripping. It was so good. JoJo: Yeah, and as y'all know, I love me some Carrie this Kaci: Mm-hmm. JoJo: is one of my favorite Stephen King books. Pet Secretary is first, but this one would definitely be second. And so for me, I have a teenager, right? And I've had teenagers because my other kids are grown. I think about like she's dealing with puberty, clearly, hormones, right? A controlling parent. I know what that's like. social rejection. I also know what that's like, but I didn't have any superpowers. And then superpowers she can't fully control, right? So meanwhile, most teenagers are just trying to figure out where they fit in in school, or what to wear, I don't know about you guys, but I was like obsessed with making sure I looked perfectly fine because I want it to fit in, naturally. That's what kids do. But this one was like yeah, this Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: is just like whoa, like whoa. Right. Mm-mm. Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: No. Kaci: I think that's why this story, it's like a tale as old as time, right? It's like it's lasted so long. the telekinesis part of this was the horror movie hook of it all. But the emotional JoJo: Yeah. Kaci: horror is recognizable to anybody, any kid these days, any grown up that's been through it, even a grown up now dealing with it, it's just so JoJo: Yeah. Kaci: recognizable. JoJo: So I think that what makes the s that's what makes the story uncomfortable, right? Because it's still relevant today, Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: even now, even past our time when we were growing up. So Carrie isn't just some villain who randomly decides, I just want to ruin somebody's day or I'm gonna, be this person. She didn't start off that way, right? So we see the people who hurt her, the people who failed to protect her. Her mom is something else, but okay. And then Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: the moment when somebody Could have made a different choice and just didnt Marilena: Absolutely. And that brings me to my first question, you guys. So when we look at Carrie, are we watching a monster that is being created or a person being failed by everyone to protect her? Kaci: I mean, I think that two JoJo: that's hard. Kaci: things can be true at once, but JoJo: Mm-hmm. Kaci: I think personally I feel like and this could just be my feminine rage, which is also why I love Carrie, but like I mean, feel like people failed her in so many ways. You know, JoJo: Mm. Kaci: like and people failed her mom. I think that it was just a whole system of of fails, which just makes everybody angry with it, you know. JoJo: Yeah, I I think a generational spiral 'cause clearly somebody Kaci: yeah. JoJo: did this to her mom, it's a generational thing. And then I also think that nature versus nurture. So Carrie is trying to be this kind person and wants to be in her essence, but then when her emotions, the fight or flight, comes in, then she makes these choices that because she's immature too, because of h her age she makes these choices that are harmful but I don't I don't think she means to but it just comes out that way. And so then I think about the psychology of it like this is how people end up being serial killers or doing things that are not normal within the normal thought process because they're trying to find ways to protect themselves. So it's it's just so much Kaci: Layers. So many layers. JoJo: layers into that into that. And this kinda seems serious. we're talking about a horror film, but this stuff happens in real life, clearly. So Kaci: Mm-hmm. Yeah, just imagine if they had a little button they could push to use superpowers. How many of us would be in trouble or gone? Girl, yeah, don't we know I would? I can't be held responsible for this. Mortal Kombat. Finish him. Marilena: do it all day long every day. Every especially when I'm driving. I know just w what is that? Street Fighter or what what is it? Mortal Kombat. Finish him. JoJo: Gah. I'd be like, finish him, erase him. Monokama, finish him. Get over her. Fatality. You know, just Ugh yeah. Kaci: Yeah. Yeah. Marilena: my gosh. Well, that's what we're trying to investigate today. So when someone is pushed to the breaking point, who's JoJo: Mm. Marilena: responsible for what happens next? And that's the big question today. Kaci: Yeah. For sure. Marilena: So let's talk about the bullying because this is where JoJo: Hmm. God. Marilena: the case really starts. Carrie's classmates don't simply dislike her, they humiliated her and they isolate her and turn her vulnerability into entertainment. JoJo: Yeah, and I think that's something that in that part of the story that's very painful and realistic. And I can relate to that because I was bullied, I didn't speak English when I first came, from Puerto Rico and and went to school. I didn't. My we spoke Spanish in my home. And so I got picked on because I could not speak, people are afraid naturally of what they don't understand. So I can relate to that and then you don't need superpowers to understand, what it's like when a group of people literally decides to hone in on you and find something that is different from from them to use it as a weapon against you. It's that's that's hard. Like it's weaponized. Something you can't even help. You can't help your social status. I couldn't help, I was in the projects. I couldn't help, you know, that we were on wealth. I couldn't help. what I wore or how I spoke or I couldn't Marilena: So taking a look at that, Joe, do you blame the kids or the parents? JoJo: It's I it c starts at home. Every Kaci: Mm-hmm. JoJo: to me, everything starts at home. Kaci: Yeah. and I thought something that was really interesting about this one that brought it this version of the story that brought it to the the relevancy that it had was that this this book was written decades before social media. JoJo: Right. Kaci: And the fact that this was in the show one of the big tools that that was used to manipulate, right? It was used as as JoJo: Mm. Kaci: a centerpiece to the show. And just think about What what all of us would have gone through, right? Because we all went through something traumatic. We're all we're women here. We know how dramatic junior high and high school is. But to think about JoJo: Girl. Kaci: every single part of that being filmed and shared and watched by literally everybody and their access to social media, it just magnifies that. I can't imagine being somebody dealing with it to the rate we were, but then magnify it with social media. that, that's ridiculous. I can't. You would break. JoJo: Well, and the the point of social media when it was first created, right? 'Cause we're I we're older than Google, clearly. the internet came during while we were coming Kaci: Thanks for that. JoJo: up. Hey. But it it started off as something innocent. It was a way to engage with people and connect in a positive way. And then of course, we as humans take things and we turn it into a weapon and we warp Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: it. So we take something that's intended for good and we turn it into something That's a weapon. And that's scary. Yeah, that's just scary. Kaci: Yeah. Ugh, unfortunately. Marilena: that the American way though? Yeah. Yeah. But that's what makes the humiliation even harder because you can't escape it. You go home and everybody knows what you did, JoJo: Yeah. Strangers. Strangers who you don't even know. Even strangers. Even strangers. Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: Yeah. And they don't even know your name. So JoJo: Well they knew hers. Kaci: Yeah. I think it it just can just it turns into like a club of mean kids or mean people. It's not even just kids anymore. And JoJo: Mm-hmm. Kaci: like we said, is it the parents? Is it the kids? It's all of them. They're all doing it. They're all being ugly. We know this, And your friends end up sharing it or, they don't want to be the target. They don't want to be the uncool one. They don't want to be any of that. So then I find it hard to sympathize with both sides. It just sucked so bad. And the fact that Stephen King that many years ago wrote something so relevant now, it just shows that the topic in general we all can relate to and it doesn't go away. It just gets harder to escape from, JoJo: just I just think that bullying has existed forever, forever. It's just been different forms but you know, depending on what tools and access you've had to people and, it is just it's just not it's just something that's not gonna ever go away. It's something that's flawed within us as humans, period. We it probably was a thing, but now where people kids are literally taking their lives, even adults. Marilena: Well, and JoJo: Over. Marilena: then we kinda go to, the point where what what is who's doing the bullying, right? Especially in Carrie's case, because not everybody is everybody that participate a bully? you know what I mean? everybody was to me in my eyes in that movie or that show, everybody was a freaking bully to her, you know. Kaci: Mm-hmm. JoJo: I mean they're a they're an accessory like in like in a murder investigation. Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: if you knew about it and you didn't do anything about it and you stayed quiet and you went along with it, you viewed, you even viewed it, you're just as guilty. Kaci: I agree. And don't y'all know not to get me started because I will pull in them the recent events. If you knew about it, you saw the message, you didn't do anything about it, you are guilty too. And I always even tell my kids that I'm like, if you see somebody hurting, yes. JoJo: Guilty by association. Kaci: If you see somebody hurting and and bullying them or to a feeling where they are like close to taking their lives or doing something dramatic, like you are guilty too. You were guilty. JoJo: And and and I feel a type of way about that, even though putting that pressure on our kids to say, Hey, you gotta speak up because what if this person or this child or their friend takes their life and then I don't want my child to feel like I didn't do enough or it's my fault and now my child is battling with, what I'm saying? With depression and anxiety because it is so hard to be like, Yes, you need to stand up, but I want you to stand up, but tell me, Because I need to be watching and as a parent I need to speak up as well to help you because kids nowadays they don't they don't really be telling us anything. They Kaci: No, I know. JoJo: go to the internet, they go to Reddit, they go to Chat GPT, yeah. Marilena: But i okay, and that's fair, but not everyone feels comfortable confronting a bully in in public, right? Because Kaci: yeah, yeah, yeah. JoJo: Yeah. Marilena: there's there's a difference between being confronted with someone that you may think that you're their next target, you know, and and some kids are just like I ain't in it, you know, like I'm not gonna say anything, even though they know that person's hurting, just like with Carrie, you know, we saw some things in that show that there were people that really hurt for her, but they didn't say anything. Kaci: Yeah. And sometimes all it takes is one person to be like, Hey, I got you. we're gonna get through this together or just one friend. it changes the whole trajectory of everything. Who knows? But that's also why this show was so cool. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. JoJo: It's kinda like a damn damn if you do, damn if you don't type situation. Yeah. Marilena: But I think a lot of high school kids worry about their social standings, Kaci: yeah. Marilena: and JoJo: yeah. Kaci: We do as adults. like if you're yeah. JoJo: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. We care about our appearance. Kaci: out, but also there are grown-ups out there acting like high school children. And that's the problem. JoJo: Yes. Kaci: that are making it a point to just be jerks about it almost at a really bad word. But like, you know who you are? Quit acting JoJo: It wasn't you not you. Kaci: like freaking teenage kids and be a grown-up and move on. Leave people alone. Marilena: I think, you know, up to the point of what we're talking about with Carrie, we gotta we gotta look at the facts of did the cruelty come from one person, who started it, you know, the the parents failed and the teachers failed and like where where did the failure happen, JoJo: that's what the social media was used to hurt. And that's what I'm saying. social media can be used for good or it can be used for bad. somebody may use it for a good thing to help themselves and feel good and put on their best foot forward and other people will use it to destroy somebody because they are they're different and they don't like, what this person represents because they don't understand it or they don't understand the reason why the person is the way they are. Marilena: So you guys, let's discuss another major figure in Carrie's life, her mother, Margaret White. JoJo: Mm. Mm. Kaci: Old Maggie Maggie White What we gonna do with her? JoJo: Maggie mm Ugh G Kaci: I can truthfully say there to some extent this was probably one of my most hated characters in books in general because I see a lot of my myself in this part of the book. And not myself JoJo: Mm. Kaci: as a mother, but myself as a daughter. And I think that this woman is just so controlling. She used religion as a tool. Carrie felt so scared and guilty and just it just she had a hard time understanding outside of that because she trusted her mom so much. JoJo: as parents, we don't come with a guide and we make mistakes, but I think that some things you're purposely choosing to do Kaci: Mm-hmm. JoJo: and to maintain control for for what reason. I I it's beyond me, but I mean, again, I grew up in a religious home as well. can imagine and feel, right, that you're being told Things are normal, right? What you're what you're being taught is normal. It's this is how it's supposed to be. And you're accepting that because you don't know any different, right? and if you do something like that is out of that norm, then yeah, you're gonna feel condemnation, you're gonna feel ashamed, you're gonna feel like you failed, and then you're gonna internally attack yourself, like, what's wrong with me? And look at your and be confused, right? And then you go to school where people are coming from different homes and they're not understanding. what you're going through 'cause they don't have that experience and so there's nobody that can really relate to you because they're not in your home. Marilena: Carrie doesn't have a home to go to because she she's fearful there and then she doesn't have a place, you know, a relationship with her mom at all. And, so her source of fear is everywhere around her. so that leads to her build up and that's, kinda what we're talking about today is she can't trust anybody and she's fearful Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: Mm-mm. Marilena: at school, she's fearful at home. Kaci: Yeah, well and she's JoJo: She can't even trust herself. Kaci: yeah, then it's this whole nother dynamic of religious damnation, like what the hell that'll scare anybody, And I think that was something JoJo: And then being put in a closet. Kaci: yeah, yeah. Marilena: So where do what do we think that shaped Margaret? was without pretending you know what I mean? Like what happened to Margaret Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: that she would treat Carrie that way. Kaci: honestly, I will say that this book, the book did a good job of it and this the series did a good job of it and they were a little bit different, but it it has to some extent deal with mental health too. Right. this can that JoJo: mental health for sure. Kaci: we all live through experiences and they do shape us a lot. But like there JoJo: Mm. Kaci: was a there's another level and this is where I relate to it as well, is like the mental health aspect. That woman had JoJo: Mm-hmm. Kaci: issues and there's no way husband dying or any of that. there's no way she could have recovered from that. there she didn't have the the tools to do that. And I think yeah. Yeah yeah. But that's what I'm saying. It's like she never started with the ability to to cope with husband dying, moving, no job, whatever. she didn't have the beginning foundation of that. Marilena: So with that being said, who's more scary in Carrie's world, her classmates or her mother? Kaci: Her mom. JoJo: mom, her mom and her mom is definitely operating up Marilena: Really? Kaci: What do you JoJo: of f out of Kaci: think? JoJo: fear. Marilena: I don't know. I feel like her mom tried to protect her at i in the like Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: third, fourth, whatever episode. She failed her in the beginning. A JoJo: Within the confines of what she knew, yeah. Kaci: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Marilena: hundred percent failed her. However, when when it came time to throw down, her mom was there. she still didn't do it in the right way, but she was there. Yes. Yes. JoJo: But she exploited it in the in the in the news series, she exploited it because she started liking that attention with the social media and being like heard, she had a voice. So which takes me back to maybe where this is where it stems from her fear and maybe not having a voice or maybe being under a controlling husband who Kaci: Uh-huh. JoJo: never let her have her own thoughts and her own opinions. And that's what she knew, the nature versus nurture and childhood. And she took it instead of and she wanted to protect and it's hard because look, you wanna protect your child but th she's making it seem like she's doing it because she loves her child, but she's doing it where it's gratifying to her and it's not really helping, it's making things worse. Kaci: Then add supernatural elements to it and all kinds of craziness, magic, all the fun things. And then it is a spiral and it kept me watching over and over and over, like one more episode, one more episode, one more episode. It was just so JoJo: Yeah. Kaci: good. It was so good. Marilena: And it makes JoJo: Yeah. Marilena: the supernatural element feel less than that less I can't even talk, less like the beginning of a nightmare and more like something that developed inside already, you know, her terrifying situation. You know what I'm saying? Kaci: Yeah. Right. Yeah. JoJo: Well and I definitely I definitely think locking her in the closet didn't doesn't did not help that either. 'Cause it Kaci: No, religious trauma is a thing. JoJo: it's almost it almost represents her lacking her emotions and suppressing them for so long and then the horrifying events occurred. Kaci: Well, and it's such a weird time for this show to come out because the show is fantastic, guys. If you have not seen it, you have to go and watch every episode JoJo: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Kaci: of it. But like, isn't it a weird time that it's coming up? Because like I feel more more than ever right now, our society, our country is concentrating on like maybe it's our generation, right? We're Gen X millennial generations. But like maybe it's that like we're concentrating on religious trauma. We're concentrating on like women being Held down for so long and now we're all of a sudden getting these voices. it's so crazy that the show came out right now because it is so cool to just see. And in the show, it shows that like Carrie's not the only one. She's not the only one with these powers and JoJo: Mm. No. Kaci: this coven. Like there's a whole network of these people with these supernatural powers. And it's almost like she's finally gonna find out like a phoenix out of this darkness into this group of belonging and ability and all this cool stuff. Yeah. Yeah. Like a super right. And JoJo: X-Men. It's the X-Men element, yeah. Kaci: she's never belonged before, right? She's never belonged and been the cool person and been the one that fits in. And now this coven that's emerged is really cool to me. I'm like, she's found her women, So Marilena: Well, let's talk about the revenge part of that then. So Kaci: Okay. Marilena: with does Carrie deserve revenge? And what I mean is that, you know, we can if someone has been hurt so badly, their first I feel like a first feeling is like, ooh, how can I get them back? Right? Like revenge. Kaci: Mm-hmm. Marilena: So do we blame Carrie for wanting that revenge? JoJo: Think it's human nature to feel that of the initial emotion. Somebody hurt me, I wanna get them back. But acting on it now, that that's a little different. And it depends, I guess, on what you really choose to do with the acting part, what you thought, you know. Some people for me, I'm just gonna have a conversation, then I'm gonna cut you off. Marilena: Yeah, but it's it's easy to condemn JoJo: stuff. I don't it's just Marilena: those actions, right? Because you see that she came back and did all this stuff, but the cruelty came before that. she was hurt. that was not okay what happened to her. Kaci: Mm-hmm. girl Carrie burned it down. Yeah. Marilena: Yeah, JoJo: Yeah, Kaci: But when you so when you watch the promo for the show and you get into the fact that Stephen King's, they're they're making an entire universe, right? So it's all these different characters that include Carrie in this universe JoJo: Mm. Kaci: of people with special abilities. So you're right. It's exactly JoJo: With special powers, yeah. Kaci: like a superhero world. It's just our own really cool Stephen King world universe. But one of the questions in the promo is. If you are what's the difference in people with special abilities? And then on the flip side, what responsibility do they have to that? And I thought that was a cool question because it was like, hey, really cool. You've been hurt, you found you've got magic, but is it now your responsibility to do good with it? Or should you just burn it down and let it happen because they deserve it? And that was one of the questions in the universe commercial I thought was really kind of cool to think about. JoJo: But yeah, that's hard to answer because as human beings, like we said, we have thoughts of we wanna this has happened to me, this was cruel, this, this was hurtful, and I want to give somebody a taste of their own medicine. But how far do you go with that? Kaci: But I also have a question for you guys. Do you think that she c so all this bad, like Marlena was saying, was happening to her? Do you think that she even like we say, she shouldn't do that or she shouldn't get revenge? do you think she was actually controlling it? Or do you think her emotions were just so strong that it just viscerally happened? You know? You do. Marilena: I believe she controlled it. you can tell when she was angry, and she tried to control it, Kaci: Mm-hmm. Marilena: but at the end, you know, once she learned how to use it, like really well, and I think because think about when what's her name, Christine went to the bathroom or whatever, you know, and she went walked in there and she just talked to her. You know, she JoJo: To talk to her. Yeah. Marilena: could have f she could have messed with her then. I almost said a bad word. Kaci: Yeah. Yeah, I know. I almost did too. Yeah, I agree. JoJo: Hay. Marilena: She could've messed with her then. but she sh all she wanted to hear was, I'm sorry. Like, hey girl, I'm truly sorry. And that that girl couldn't do it. So I do think she controlled it. Yeah. Kaci: Yeah, interesting. JoJo: think she controlled it but then I think She think everybody that was in there deserved to die Kaci: Well no, but did the did she give them JoJo: And it there's always casualties. There's always casualties of war. as innocent people get caught up in things too, but I don't know because I mean she Kaci: Yeah, but they didn't give her JoJo: was passive aggressive too though. She was passive aggressive too. Right. I understand that. Yeah. Yeah. Kaci: But what choice did they give her? What choice did they give her? They were relentless on her. You know what I'm saying? JoJo: I think maybe for me I would have just targeted the ones one by one that if I had that power, I would have just targeted the ones one by one that were like Marilena: think at that point though in the show, it it it it's truly casualties of war, right? because how's she gonna be like, wait, I'm not gonna hurt you, wait, I'm not gonna hurt you they were all there. They were still all filming her. When that blood landed on her, everybody had their cameras up. They were laughing. They were like, still still like yeah Kaci: Yeah, yeah. Or in the bathroom, in the locker room, they all were filming her. They were all throwing stuff at her. Marilena: Bro, if I would have seen somebody do that to somebody in a locker room, I'd Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: have I'd a laid hands on everybody in that gym. Like everybody. Kaci: Me too. Me too. Yeah. Marilena: it just wouldn't have been okay. So JoJo: Yeah. Marilena: but you know, that I don't know. I mean, I feel like a little s empathy from people could have helped her, a little intervention, like whatever. It could have helped Carrie, but JoJo: Mm. Marilena: I I don't blame her. I don't think that she's at fault I don't Kaci: No, I don't blame her either. You JoJo: No. what Kaci: know me. JoJo: happened happened. Whatever happened happened. it was it was it was intense. It was intense. It was an outer manifestation of what she felt. Like an outer. Marilena: So I and maybe it's why revenge becomes the only form of justice, for her. I don't know. Kaci: Yeah, I agree. And would JoJo: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Kaci: it have changed if she didn't? No. They would have kept on. Marilena: No. But it kept on going. I mean, that girl got kicked JoJo: And the thing that was Marilena: out of school and still was on her. JoJo: But the thing that was interesting was that she still when she came out of, the powers, how she felt horrible. when she realized she was like so Kaci: Yeah, yeah, she did. She has empathy. JoJo: she did feel remo she had empathy and she felt remorse. So it wasn't like she lost her humanity. Marilena: Yeah, I don't know. So what do you guys what did you guys think of the the remake on Prime Video? I know Kaci: out of ten. Marilena: I never watched the first movie and I didn't read the book 'cause I thought it was gonna be scary, but I did watch this. Mm-hmm. Kaci: Watched all of them, but it's different. It's different. JoJo: Yeah. Kaci: I've watched all of them, and it's still a classic movie. I mean, the movie is still classic. This remake was relevant, it was time appropriate, it was innovative. I JoJo: Mm. Kaci: loved it. Loved it. Like I, yeah. Yeah, I did knowing that it's a part of a a larger universe that's coming. I'm a Stephen King fan. JoJo: Universe, yeah. Yeah. I wanna see how that evolves. Kaci: Yeah, and Mike Flanagan. it's just so good. it just he the way he wrote it, the way it was filmed, like it's just cool. And I'm a nerd. I'm a Stephen King nerd. So all the Easter eggs, all the weird things, all the connections, all the the future things, I'm so excited about. I will be nerding out forever. Marilena: I love that. JoJo: I think I liked this remake, for the generation now 'cause I watched it with my kid. And it was also a conversational piece to open up and Kaci: Uh-huh. JoJo: for me to be like, Hey, have you witnessed anything like this in school? You know, is there somebody in school that, you know, is different and yeah, Kaci: It's like the modern thirteen reasons why. JoJo: it it's just yeah, let's talk about this. Well, how would how would you handle this or what would you do in this situation just to kinda see gauge where my child's mind was and what to see his reactions. So I I did like that. I do like the that there's a second season and we get to see, okay, now that this disaster and this horrible event happened, where does Carrie go from here? You know? That that that's that's the interesting Kaci: Yeah. Well, and if you the things that are out now, so the Institute is already out, so you can go and watch that and it it collaborates with Carrie. And then Welcome to Dairy JoJo: Mm-hmm. Kaci: is out too. And so they all collaborate and then it's gonna keep building. it's just gonna be this cool, now I feel like I get what everybody gets with all their Marvel movies. I get it now with Stephen King. Yeah, so I'm excited. JoJo: Yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: For sure. Kaci: I'm not sure where Welcome to Dairy is or JoJo: I I think Kaci: the institute. JoJo: They're between that, I think a lot of it is in prime, but it could be Netflix or Hulu. I don't know. I have to we have to look at it. Yeah. Kaci: I don't know. Yeah. I don't remember. I'll look and I'll look and let you know. But what did you think about it, Marlena, being that you're the newer one to that universe? Marilena: I really liked it. I I didn't so much like the ending and I know it it's for the bigger the bigger story. Kaci: Yeah. The greater good. Yeah. Marilena: I but I don't know what the other one ended like, right? Kaci: Mm-hmm. Marilena: I just remember seeing the blood on her or whatever. I l I was in it. I really enjoyed it. I was mad I I was hurt for her, the way the cruelty and you know, I I kinda thought while I was watching it, I'm like, they're overdoing it, but they're not. that's really how Kaci: Mm-hmm. Marilena: mean people are. And with the internet and everything else, it's that what kids have to go through these days, I just I couldn't imagine. I d I just couldn't imagine. So Kaci: Mm-hmm. Well, there is a book. Correct me if I'm wrong, guys. Is it Tiffany D. Jackson that wrote the there's a kind of like a fan fiction, not really fanfiction, but like an a modern telling of Carrie. I I'll I'll look it up. But JoJo: Yeah, she she did write one, yeah. I haven't read it though. Kaci: apparently it was a lot like the original, the book that Carrie. And so I was like, it I really want to jump into that and read that too. But like Carrie is such an icon. Like, you know, everyone knows what Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I'll I think it's the weight of the blood or weight of blood or something like that. People have been telling me to go and read. And so I do want to read that because I love when people take this traditional story and do this with it. But the subplots. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, for sure. Yeah. But the the way this adaptation Marilena: Especially a classic like that, Carrie, yeah. Right? Yeah. JoJo: Apply it to our modern times. Apply it to our modern times like that twist. Kaci: pulled in other plot lines, like the, you know, the other subplots. I don't want to spoil it for anybody that hasn't seen it, but JoJo: Mm. The institutes and all that, yeah. Kaci: Well, no, but the stories in the book, the teacher, the things that were going on with the teacher and Yeah. Yeah. JoJo: Yeah. I mean, those are things that are going on right now Marilena: yeah. That shit JoJo: and we're seeing it Marilena: happens, yeah. JoJo: all over the news. Like, you know, those inappropriate things that were happening with the students and you know, the bullying. Did it? Marilena: That one shocked me by the way, in in Carrie. Kaci: Me too. It did, but then what I was telling you gotta go back. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Marilena: I y I wasn't I it did but it didn't. It a at first I was like but then yeah. I don't wanna ruin it for people. JoJo: It it seems suspect. Yeah. Kaci: Yeah. Well, and go back through now, now that you've already watched it and look at the Easter egg stuff. And the whole time I'm like, my God, that's so cool. But like the stand is a book, the Dark Tower series JoJo: Yep. Kaci: that Stephen King writes. And apparently this is gonna make a lot more sense like as you go through it. So like I'm excited about that. But JoJo: Mm. Kaci: it just brought yeah. Yeah, that's what I was saying about all the characters. Marilena: is that have something to do with the stand then? I did not know that. my gosh. I love JoJo: Yeah. Marilena: when people do stuff like that, because then it's like, that's that's pretty cool. Kaci: I know. So genius. Well, and they said that this is gonna show how Carrie because the Carrie was written first, right? So the Dark Tower JoJo: Mm. Kaci: series and all of that stuff happened afterwards. And so this is gonna show JoJo: Afterwards. Kaci: if Carrie could have been one of them before. so I'm excited. It is cool. Marilena: That's interesting. Okay. Well, let's move forward to who's really guilty. Okay. And, you know, obviously it's subjective to all of us, but so here's the lineup. JoJo: God. Everybody. Kaci: All of Everybody. Everybody in the club guilty. Marilena: We're gonna put all the major players on the front line and you guys are gonna decide. So Kaci: Okay. Marilena: first up is Chris Harginson and the JoJo: Mm. Marilena: students who participated in Carrie's Humiliation. What do you guys feel about that? Kaci: I don't know how to say it without being super ugly about it. But she started out as what I thought of like this privileged little white girl, right? And then JoJo: Absolutely. Kaci: you do see a little bit into her family and how she's struggling. But also at that point, I was like, first world problems, bitch. Like, really? You're driving a G wagon. Yeah. Sorry. JoJo: Wait, I thought we were in cussing. Kaci: Did we make that rule? Because I didn't see anyway. That's not gonna. I'm a pirate. I'm trying. But JoJo: You guys have been watching. You guys have kept saying, you guys kept saying I don't want to curse. Kaci: But I'm like, you don't you don't I said JoJo: Yeah. She just said big. Kaci: but I'm like, okay, but you ha you drive a G Wagon and you're worried about paying for college. Sell that hundred and thirty thousand dollar car and pay for your school girlfriend. Yeah. Should have sold it before then. Marilena: got repo'd so she couldn't. All right. JoJo: I didn't feel I mean, pe people's parents get divorced, right? We all, if we've if we've been through something like that, Kaci: Yeah. Hell I've been divorced. JoJo: we understand. Right. And of course, me too. But that doesn't give you the right because your life at home is horrible. And then her thing I think stemmed from more from jealousy because she saw her friend feel, you know, embracing this new person. And she felt like, well, my parents are not. focusing in on me and now my friend is a I'm about to lose my friend's attention is somebody else. So let's make this about me. So I just think she's she's guilty. I I feel n I don't feel sorry for her. And I think her dad is a perpetrator in her personality because he he bailed her out of everything. And I I thought he was a sociopath. I thought he was a sociopath for sure. Like yeah Marilena: He was a human garbage can for sure. Yeah. you saw how he spoke to his ex-wife and Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: you know, everybody. Ugh. Yeah. Because she's privileged. Privileged JoJo: He was just disgusting with and that's where her behavior came from because Yeah. Marilena: little. Yep. Yep. So next, Sue, who is connected to the bullying but JoJo: There. Marilena: begins to feel remorse, and the teacher also asks her to watch out for her. Kaci: Which one was Sue? JoJo: She was the girl the mom was the real estate agent and told her, Carrie's going to school, be nice to her, protect her. She was Chris's best friend. That's why Chris got jealous. Yeah. Kaci: yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I think she struggled the most with like knowing right and wrong and what to do, or she did have feelings about it. And you know, at the beginning, like her boyfriend, I felt like he was trying to say, you know who you are, be true to that. And she should have stuck with that. She should have stuck with it. Marilena: I think he was the best one for Carrie. he was the nicest one without us even knowing it. Yeah. JoJo: Yeah, he was really n at first I thought maybe he was feeling her because she was different and the stars and all that and their connection. but I Sue I had mixed feelings about because I felt like you know your friend is being ugly and you need to tell her she's being ugly and you waited, you knew she was doing the thing, and then you waited till the very end to expose it, and then you kept falling. When someone shows you who they are, believe it. and remove yourself Marilena: Yeah. JoJo: from the situation. And she just kept trying to save you were trying to save the wrong person. You couldn't save your friend. Her focus to me is just like focus more on Carrie because this person, she's she's she doesn't care what you have to say. Kaci: tell y'all if I thought you guys were being ridiculous to somebody else I would be like guys like that something's up you I know you guys, I know your heart, stop doing this stuff. Marilena: It's not cool. Yeah. I'm not Yeah. My daughter my JoJo: Yeah, I I I I I wouldn't do that. if I have a concern, I'm gonna talk to that person and that's just what it is. Kaci: Especially my friend. Marilena: daughter was like that. She was always taking care of like people who got bullied on. She would always stick up for them, which made me so proud of her, yeah. But JoJo: Me too. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Kaci: Yeah, mine too, mine do that too. Yeah, for sure. Marilena: so let's move on to Carrie. So is JoJo: Mm. Marilena: Carrie a victim or Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: is she the problem? JoJo: Yeah she's a victim. No, she's a victim. Everything Kaci: Of circumstance, of trauma, of the world. Yes, she was. Ultimately she was. JoJo: She did the best she could with what she knew. That's that's just what it is. Marilena: I agree. So one one your first answer, no explanation needed. Who was the root of the problem with Carrie? Was it? Really? JoJo: Mama Mamma Kaci: Mamma Yes. Marilena: So let's just say she never went to school and she didn't have all that shit happen to her, right? Yes, it would have been her mom, but like would we have known it would have been her mom? Because nothing would have happened to her. You know what I'm saying? Like she protected her. Kaci: Yeah, but sh eventually mom's gonna JoJo: No, she would've she she she would have come yeah, die. And she she even at home, even in the interpretation of the series, her mom wouldn't even let her talk to her neighbor because she didn't want the neighbor imp imp dropping nuggets about different books and about that's not how people live, sweetheart. what do you mean? you can't come out. Yeah. Yes. Kaci: yeah, forgot about her. I really liked the neighbor girl. Marilena: I'm gonna say this though. I really think it was that Chris girl. I couldn't stand her. I Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: think she was so mean. I just yeah. Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: But I think that that her mom set her up for failure because she did not set her give her the tools to know how to defend she was very naive. She didn't know she wasn't exposed Kaci: And there's a difference. JoJo: to the evils. Kaci: Yes. But also JoJo: Yes. Kaci: let let's look at it this way. okay, there's a difference between between you being a single mom and really just hustling, right? you you guys have to be home by JoJo: Mm-hmm. Kaci: six o'clock at night. You have to do your homework before I get home or whatever. There's a difference between making your kids JoJo: Mm-hmm. Kaci: not necessarily it's just for survival, right? There is that that layer. JoJo: Mm. Kaci: But then there's a difference in go and saying not telling your kid about her period, not telling your kid that, you know, or or or making them pray in a closet and whatever. there's such a difference in survival and then that next step, which is where I think Margaret was. You know what I mean? she could have not done that yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yeah. JoJo: She was the first bully. She was her first bully. She was her first bully. Marilena: I guess you're right, yeah. But even think about when they did the the sh the shooting, the active shooter, like what's it called? Yes, the JoJo: The drill, the drill, yeah. Marilena: drill. Like Carrie was so freaking scared and she Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: knew they kept telling her, It's not real, it's not real. Like so yeah, it probably you're probably right, but I still couldn't stand Chris. Kaci: That whole scene, I was like, that's exactly how I would have expected them to act. You can't do that to people. Yeah. Yeah. JoJo: mean I think we're all we're all right. If it was just like she went from one bully to another. Because that's what she knew. It's norm yeah, Kaci: And it just kept happening. Mm-hmm. JoJo: it's just, Kaci: Ooh, I like that idea. JoJo: God, this is gonna be different. Kaci: Yeah, I guess we're ready as we're gonna get. JoJo: Uhhuh. I guess, yeah, yeah. Kaci: my ass is fighting back. I'm two middle fingers and up and I'm JoJo: Take Kaci: like Yeah. JoJo: I'm taking that lunch tray and I'm smacking somebody right across the face with it. I'm sorry. Marilena: think I would be too. JoJo: I'm sorry. Marilena: All right. You accidentally laugh when someone gets bullied and they turn to stare directly at you. Are you gonna apologize? Are you running or accepting your fate? Kaci: going to apologize because that's shitty. JoJo: think I would laugh. I wouldn't laugh. Kaci: If yeah, or didn't realize that it was that Marilena: I it just accidentally if you say accidentally. It's just hypothetical. Kaci: serious JoJo: Gonna Kaci: and then it turned out to be that serious, I would be ashamed. I would apologize first up. JoJo: Yeah. I would ap apologize, yeah, if that yeah, but yeah. Marilena: Same, same. Same. So Carrie gives you ten seconds to explain why you bullied her. What excuse are you using? It was a prank, I was going through something, or my lawyer will be in touch. Kaci: I would just tell the truth. I was being shitty. I was JoJo: Yeah. Kaci: going through stuff at home this morning. You're right. I'm wrong. it it was shitty of me. That's the easiest way to to do it right. Yeah. JoJo: Yeah, it's something about me. you're different. I don't I don't and you seem happy and I'm not. So I decided to make you miserable with me. Marilena: Just decided to make you miserable. JoJo: Yeah. Marilena: Alright, you're forced to spend 24 hours with Margaret White. What gets you kicked out first? Questioning her parenting, wearing the wrong outfit, or simply breathing too loud? Kaci: Girl, nothing about her agrees with any fiber of my being. Just simply existing, JoJo: Yeah. Kaci: me existing would piss her off. Been there, been there. I'm just letting you know. JoJo: not I'm not I wouldn't even speak to her. Kaci: Yeah, th I couldn't. I couldn't. Yeah. Yeah. JoJo: Yeah. Gurby. think we're bullying. I think people are sensitive. Kaci: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Marilena: Same. Carrie Kaci: This is not my fault. Marilena: Yeah, this is everybody else's fault. Kaci: It's everybody else. Marilena: Carrie can fling one of you across the room, but the other gets to narrate it live on the podcast. Who's JoJo: Damn. Marilena: flying and what's the commentary? Kaci: No JoJo: Marlena, you're definitely commentary. With your seductive voice. Kaci: I think you bitches wanna see me flung across the room, so I think it would be dual narration. JoJo: I think I think Casey wants to be flung. Marilena: We will let you go, come on, come on, Joe. JoJo: I'd like, no, care Carrie, don't don't hit her against that wall. Carrie, protect her face. She has a pretty face, Carrie. Don't hit her face. Marilena: She don't hit her head? Yeah, no, no, throw her throw her feet first. Kaci: Listen to you. Now I'm gonna say a bad word, bitches. Listen, it would be dual narration JoJo: I love you. Kaci: and Casey would be getting flung. I'll take it. I'll take it. There are times I deserve it. Marilena: I'd save you, Casey. If I'd save you. JoJo: I would I would tackle Carrie and she would just grab and Marlena would just grab you, like try to grab you. Yeah. Marilena: I would grab you, yeah. I'd I'd elbow her. I'd be like if she had her down, I'd like sh I'd be start throwing elbows. Yeah. JoJo: I'll just put in a chokehold and choke her out while we try to save you. Kaci: I think that's what that's one of the best things about this podcast is we know that tomorrow the answer will be different, but today they're like Casey's a bitch and she's on one, so we're throwing her across the room. But then nobody would guess any of that. That those would be any of our answers. And then I just straight up accepted defeat. Okay. You're right, guys. I deserve it today. Marilena: All right, you have to defend one character in court. Chris, JoJo: god. Marilena: Margaret, or Carrie. Who are you choosing and how are you possibly gonna justify it? Kaci: Margaret is reason of insanity. you're gonna get away with that. But JoJo: I'm defending Carrie. Yeah. Kaci: also, if I'm just being a total straight up good lawyer that I think I wouldn't be, I'm gonna defend I'm gonna JoJo: I'm defending Carrie. Kaci: defend Chris and you wanna know why? Because only listen, not because I think she's right. No, not because I think she's right. It's because JoJo: Marlena, I'm appalled. I am Marlena. I am appalled. Marilena: I'm all I am appalled. Kaci: zero of it is is admissible in court. None of it could be admissible in court. You know what I'm saying? They're like, she did this. Yeah. Marilena: I guess if you're looking at the way to yeah, I guess JoJo: If they Marilena: that. JoJo: if they pulled them records is gonna be admissible and it was her phone. Marilena: Yeah, her phone. I'm defending Carrie all day and every day. Kaci: See. But if I had I think Carrie's JoJo: Yeah, me too. Kaci: right, obviously. JoJo: She had malicious intent. She had malicious intent to inflict harm. Marilena: Yeah, yeah, I'm defending her all day. All Kaci: Yeah. Deserved, I agree. Marilena: right, final question. The prom is burning, the school is collapsing, and Carrie is walking towards you. You get one sentence before the credits roll. What are your final words? JoJo: I'm so sorry. Kaci: I gotta find some I gotta find some way JoJo: gonna die anyway. Kaci: to hype her up. Marilena: It wouldn't me. JoJo: I'm gonna die anyway. I'm gonna die anyway, but at least somebody I think she wanted somebody to Kaci: yeah. I'm gonna pull a shaggy. JoJo: tell her that they were sorry. I think she wanted I think she wanted to hear someone say, acknowledge, I'm Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: sorry, yeah. Don't be afraid of people who are different and and be open minded and be respectful. Yeah. Kaci: Don't ston' bully. Simple as that. Be nice human beings. Be kind. that's a powerful point. And I think the new series has the opportunity to bring the question to into the present. Online cruelty can travel beyond its original moment, and a crowd can participate in somebody's humiliation without ever seeing the consequences face to face. But I also think we have to resist the easy conclusion that suffering automatically turns somebody into a monster. People who experience bullying and abuse deserve support JoJo: But I also think that we have to resist the easy conclusion that suffering automatically turns somebody into a monster because it doesn't. Like, I don't I don't believe that. People who experience bullying deserve an abuse, right? Deserve support. And they don't deserve violence. Kaci: Yeah. For sure. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. JoJo: Or respond to it or respond to it, right? Respond with it as well. So Carrie is a horror story, not a blueprint for what victims become. Kaci: Exactly. The tragedy is not simply that Carrie has power, it's that people around her repeatedly fail to treat her as a person who deserves dignity and protection. JoJo: Marlene, I was gonna let you take mine. Kaci: Ha ha. JoJo: Okay. And that is why I think the story keeps getting adapted, right? The prom scene is iconic, Kaci: Iconic. JoJo: but the question underneath it is much harder to shake. What did everyone do before it came to that? Like, literally. Marilena: Yeah. So our final verdict, Carrie White is not a simple monster and JoJo: Mm-mm. Marilena: her story is not a simple revenge fantasy. It's a tragedy about isolation, cruelty, power, and the consequences of choices that people make when they think not nobody is watching. JoJo: Yeah. It's the crowd that helps create the conditions for one. For sure. Maybe. Until next season. Kaci: Yeah. Did this series bring something new to Stephen King's story, or do you think the original film still does it best? JoJo: And the most important question, who do you think bears the greatest responsibility for what happened to Carrie? we want your arguments, your hot takes, and your evidence. Marilena: Follow the podcast, share the episode with your horror film fans, and join us next time and put another story in our investigation. Kaci: Remember to be kind to people. JoJo: And maybe don't bully the person who turns out to have telekinetic powers. Kaci: Yeah. But for questioning Bye. JoJo: Books for questioning Bye.