Latest / Kublai Khan and the Mongol Rule of China — Fexingo History / Kublai Khan's Paper Money The Yuan Experiment with Fiat Currency
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot about Kublai's military campaigns—his invasions of Japan, Vietnam, Java—and we've looked at his astronomers, his postal system, his census. But there's one aspect of his rule that's maybe the most audacious of all: his attempt to run the entire Yuan economy on paper money. Luna: Like, actual paper bills? No coins at all? Lucas: That's right. By the 1280s, Kublai had decreed that the only legal tender in China would be the chao—a paper note issued by the imperial treasury. Coins were demonetised. You couldn't even use gold or silver for most transactions, though they were still hoarded as stores of value. The state wanted a pure fiat system, centuries before the term even existed. Luna: Wait, hadn't China used paper money before? I thought the Song had something. Lucas: They did. The Song Dynasty had experimented with 'flying cash'—jiaozi—as early as the eleventh century. But those were essentially promissory notes issued by private merchants, later taken over by the state. They were regionally limited and always backed by metal reserves. What Kublai did was different: he made paper the sole official currency across the whole empire, and he tried to enforce it by law. Lucas: The Yuan notes were printed from wooden or copper blocks on mulberry-bark paper. They had serial numbers, seals, official stamps—the whole apparatus of modern banknotes. Marco Polo, who arrived in Dadu around 1275, was stunned. He wrote that Kublai 'has more treasure than all the kings of the world' because he could simply print money. Luna: But if you can just print it, doesn't that cause inflation? Lucas: Exactly the problem. Initially, the system worked because the government was disciplined. They set up silver reserves—actually, they called it a 'silver standard'—where each note was theoretically convertible into silver at the treasury. The Zhiyuan era, Kublai's reign name, saw fairly stable prices. But then the wars happened. Lucas: Kublai's campaigns against Japan, Vietnam, Champa, Java—they were staggeringly expensive. The treasure fleets, the army supplies, the shipbuilding. To fund them, the Yuan treasury just printed more chao. By the 1290s, the money supply had swollen. Prices rose. People started losing trust. Luna: And if you lose trust in paper, what happens? People go back to barter? Lucas: Or they hoard metal. The Song loyalists in the south, especially, had always distrusted Mongol paper. They buried their copper coins and used them only in secret. The government tried to ban private hoarding, but you can't police every courtyard. By the time Kublai died in 1294, inflation was already noticeable. Under his successors, it spiralled out of control. Lucas: The Yuan Shi records that by the 1350s, the chao had depreciated so badly that a string of cash coins—if you could find them—was worth more than a wad of notes. The government's solution? Print even more. It became a death spiral. Some historians argue that the economic chaos caused by hyperinflation was a major factor in the Red Turban Rebellion that toppled the Yuan. Luna: So Kublai's paper money experiment pretty much failed? Lucas: In the long run, yes. But it's fascinating that he even tried. He was trying to unify a vast, diverse empire under a single medium of exchange—something that required extraordinary administrative control. The printing infrastructure, the enforcement across provinces, the attempts to set exchange rates with other Mongol khanates... It was a breathtaking ambition. Lucas: And honestly, if today's episode made you think about the power and fragility of trust in currency—like, if it was worth a coffee to you—there's a link at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's the smallest way to keep the show ad-free and independent. Luna: Yeah, it's like we rely on paper every day but rarely think about how it's just... agreed value. Kublai learned that the hard way. Lucas: Right. So back to the system itself—there's a specific note issue called the Zhongtong Baochao, introduced around 1260, before Kublai even fully conquered the Song. That was the first uniform currency across Mongol China. It was printed in denominations from ten cash up to two strings—that's roughly two thousand coins' worth. And for a while, it actually worked. Luna: What did the notes look like? Did they have pictures? Lucas: They were fairly plain by later standards. The obverse typically had a border of stylised clouds or dragons, the denomination written in Chinese characters and in Phagspa script—that's the writing system Kublai's Tibetan lama had devised—and official seals in red ink. There were warnings against counterfeiting, which was punishable by death. Lucas: Counterfeiting was actually a serious problem. The Yuan government tried to stay ahead by changing the designs periodically. They also issued new series: the Zhiyuan Baochao in 1287, which was supposed to be the stable replacement. But it didn't matter—if the treasury itself debased the currency by overprinting, no amount of fancy seals could save it. Luna: So the state was both the issuer and the culprit. Classic. Lucas: Exactly. And there's an interesting parallel with the other Mongol khanates. The Ilkhanate in Persia tried a similar paper money experiment in 1294—they called it chaw, based on the Chinese model. It lasted about two months. The merchants of Tabriz revolted, the bazaars closed, and the Ilkhan had to rescind the order. Paper money just didn't take root outside China. Luna: Why did it work at all in China, then? Was it the existing tradition? Lucas: Partly. The Song had accustomed people to the idea of paper notes. But also, the Yuan had a much stronger central bureaucracy. They could enforce acceptance through tax collection—they only accepted taxes in chao, not in grain or silk. So if you wanted to pay your taxes, you had to use the paper. That gave it a captive demand. Lucas: But it was a fragile equilibrium. Once the state's credibility cracked, the whole system unravelled. And it's a lesson that echoes through history: money is ultimately about trust, not just decrees. Luna: And Kublai's trust ran out. Lucas: It did. But for a couple of decades, the Yuan Dynasty ran one of the world's first comprehensive paper money economies. It's a story that doesn't get told as often as the invasions or the astronomy, but it shaped the lives of millions of people in thirteenth-century China.