Latest / Old School, New School, Next School with Dom Giordano / Who’s Dumbing Down America? Grade Inflation and the Diploma Problem
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Old School,
- 0:05New School, Next School with Dom Giordano,
- 0:08a podcast devoted to shedding light on issues pertaining to making America smart again.
- 0:15These include, among many topics,
- 0:17school choice and parental rights.
- 0:19This podcast is dedicated to reversing the deeply disturbing trend known as the dumbing down of America.
- 0:27Now,
- 0:28here's your host,
- 0:29Educator.
- 0:30and noted talk media commentator,
- 0:32Dom Giordano.
- 0:35Hey,
- 0:35everyone.
- 0:35Welcome into this week's edition of Old School,
- 0:38New School, Next School with Dom Giordano.
- 0:41And you know the theme of this show is simply MASSA, make America smart again.
- 0:47But we are seeing what I have called and a number of people are calling the great dumbing down of America.
- 0:54So this week,
- 0:55I thought I would give you some of the people that aided and abetted. In other words,
- 1:00this is self-inflicted.
- 1:02It's not China,
- 1:03although they're trying, or foreign powers,
- 1:05or whatever.
- 1:06It's our own people.
- 1:08Writing in The Hill,
- 1:09a comedian writes a column about Nicole Hannah-Jones and how she just ran headfirst into the great dumbing down of America.
- 1:21And she ran into that because of her ideology.
- 1:24She didn't take from that, we talked about it last week,
- 1:27any kind of lesson about school choice.
- 1:30Instead,
- 1:31she just said what is always said, we need more money.
- 1:36So this week, we will recognize,
- 1:39we will target in the sense of making you aware so that you can keep these people in mind.
- 1:47As we try to make America smart again,
- 1:49these idiots of the week are engaged,
- 1:53at least five
- 1:54There were six of them. And I have one good news story this week.
- 1:57They are engaged in making America dumber by the moment.
- 2:03One of them,
- 2:04one group we'll start off with, are the teachers'
- 2:06unions.
- 2:07Now, in any average week,
- 2:09the teachers'
- 2:10unions deserve a tremendous share of blame for the dumbing down of America.
- 2:17Because they really don't care about that.
- 2:20They're fine with it. As long as everybody plays ball and everybody goes along,
- 2:24We're going to graduate people who don't know a whole lot,
- 2:28can't read, and can't do math.
- 2:31So the American Federation of Teachers,
- 2:33though,
- 2:33dumb idea of the week.
- 2:35They are involved in a lawsuit that involves schools.
- 2:40They are trying to block stricter commercial driver's license rules,
- 2:44putting social justice ideology ahead of child safety.
- 2:49In other words, these are the CDL stories you hear about with people that,
- 2:53are here illegally,
- 2:55can't speak English, or only haltingly,
- 2:58Randy Weingarten and her minions are fighting to keep them driving those school buses.
- 3:03Why?
- 3:04These are more and more people that join up with the union.
- 3:10And that's all that they care about.
- 3:12So imagine some of these horrific stories of these truckers that you've heard about, we've all seen.
- 3:17Imagine now this with school bus drivers.
- 3:20If they would do that,
- 3:22what else?
- 3:23would these teachers unions do?
- 3:26Well, we have a changing of the guard at the NEA, the big one in size,
- 3:30National Education Association.
- 3:33A woman named Princess Moss.
- 3:36What a Hollywood name, Princess Moss.
- 3:38She's taken over from Becky Pringle,
- 3:42who is that wild woman we played you screaming all the things,
- 3:45all the things.
- 3:47Ms.
- 3:48Moss says that activism and being an activist,
- 3:53is not a byproduct of teaching.
- 3:57It is what should be taught in schools.
- 4:00We have to inject more and more activism,
- 4:03ideology,
- 4:05politics in schools.
- 4:07I've alerted you that I think Randy Weingarten,
- 4:10at least,
- 4:11they're talking about leading before the midterms to oppose President Trump,
- 4:15the nation's school teachers, and maybe kids,
- 4:18activists,
- 4:19into the fray to go after Trump.
- 4:22So just the two examples I've given you, Randy Weingarten and this Princess Moss,
- 4:28just in one short period of time,
- 4:31who in the world can say that they're doing anything to get us out of the dumbing down of America?
- 4:37Now,
- 4:38I would debate any of these people anywhere,
- 4:40and you know this,
- 4:41anecdotally, you see this, I bring you the stats on this,
- 4:44we are dumbing down America.
- 4:46Every day, we get dumber.
- 4:48Where I am in Philadelphia is one of the capitals.
- 4:52of this.
- 4:53I want to link it to statistics that are mind-boggling.
- 4:58People at the state level in Harrisburg,
- 5:02again,
- 5:03to try to continue the fraud of many of the big city public schools,
- 5:08said you don't have to take a standardized test at the end of the year anymore and pass that and get remediation if you can't.
- 5:16You can graduate if you have an option for a year.
- 5:22or evidence that you should graduate.
- 5:25Full-time job offer,
- 5:27dual enrollment credit,
- 5:28AP score of 18,
- 5:30or easy-to-earn credentials.
- 5:34Now, I told you about it. It's one of our all-time number of people that listen to a podcast,
- 5:41and that is ladder safety.
- 5:43In Philadelphia,
- 5:45you can take floral arrangements,
- 5:47ladder safety. It's a one or two-hour video you watch,
- 5:50maybe.
- 5:51And then they give you a piece of paper moving you through and letting you graduate,
- 5:55even though you don't know anything.
- 5:56Case in point,
- 5:58Abraham Lincoln High School.
- 6:00Think about the greatness of President Lincoln.
- 6:02Some say he is the greatest American president.
- 6:06Abraham Lincoln High School in Philadelphia now has an almost 98 percent graduation rate.
- 6:12But.
- 6:1355 percent of those graduates use this alternative pathway,
- 6:18meaning it's not about their grades.
- 6:20It's not about anything.
- 6:22All it is are these cockamamie online courses that they're given.
- 6:27And then they're able to graduate.
- 6:3255%. So I don't know for sure,
- 6:35but I believe that people in New York have gotten this idea and they are checking out Philadelphia as a way to graduate from New York State schools,
- 6:46not just New York City schools.
- 6:49Because there's a board,
- 6:51and there's a fancy name, it was storied over the years in New York,
- 6:55called the Regents Test.
- 6:57Meaning you had to pass this English math allegedly to get out of high school.
- 7:02Well, they've done away with it.
- 7:04And here is a clip of some of the people that run the Regents Test.
- 7:09And they seem to be indicating,
- 7:11hey,
- 7:11with minority students,
- 7:13standardized tests, you have to be kidding me.
- 7:19that would be like a fish trying to climb a tree.
- 7:22Yeah,
- 7:23this is what they're saying.
- 7:24New York inspires.
- 7:25It's extremely inspiring.
- 7:27And I am so thrilled that all New York State students will now be able to demonstrate their competency,
- 7:33which I know is the expectation,
- 7:35in a manner that showcases their strengths.
- 7:38And I think that it's very important for people to understand because there have been certain comments that have been made that I completely disagree with that are we dumbing down the ability for students? Quite the opposite.
- 7:49It's giving the, I know maybe you've seen the cartoon where you have a fish climb a tree,
- 7:54where you don't assess a fish on climb a tree because fish can't climb trees,
- 7:58right?
- 7:59So I am so thrilled about this. I just want to put it out there and say my question is answered and I will give my time back.
- 8:04Thank you. Thank you.
- 8:06I'm going to remember that one.
- 8:10So New York has gotten rid of the regents exam,
- 8:14unclear what they are going to propose.
- 8:18Headline New York Post says what I would say, New York makes it official.
- 8:22Our high school diploma is worthless.
- 8:25This regents exam is the exam that would at least put the fear of God in these institutions to at least try to get kids close to this.
- 8:37Now, without that,
- 8:38I think they're going to do what Philadelphia does, come up with these cockamamie pieces of paper and online classes,
- 8:45and then they'll be able to skate through.
- 8:47Why not?
- 8:49Why spend all this money? Why don't we just not have them go to school at all?
- 8:52Why don't we just say, hey, some kids can't learn, they can't do X,
- 8:56Y, or Z.
- 8:56Just let them out there.
- 8:58So let me know. You can always email me at domshow at AOL.com.
- 9:04If you see this in New York or where you are, imagine Abraham Lincoln High School, 98% graduation rate,
- 9:1055% of them show up,
- 9:12watch a water safety thing,
- 9:14and go off into the wilderness.
- 9:16We are,
- 9:17through the teachers unions,
- 9:20through progressive politicians,
- 9:22big city schools,
- 9:23we are dumbing down America at a more rapid rate than we could possibly imagine.
- 9:31And you can say,
- 9:32and maybe you can make the argument,
- 9:33so what? We're still America.
- 9:35We can have a lot of dummies,
- 9:37a lot of idiots out there,
- 9:38and we're still going to succeed.
- 9:40If you think that's true long-term,
- 9:43do you really?
- 9:45Do you think that's the case?
- 9:47I don't think so.
- 9:49Case in point though, California now,
- 9:51dumbing down of America.
- 9:54California high school grads score 4.0 GPAs but can't do basic math,
- 10:01say math professors at some of their bigger institutions,
- 10:05the University of California system with straight A's.
- 10:09Try this nugget. Over the last past decade, the number of students applying to the University of California system,
- 10:15all those California schools,
- 10:17With straight A's skyrocketed from 52,989 in 2015 to 103,138 for the class of 2025,
- 10:30with a notable jump during the COVID pandemic between 2020 and 2022.
- 10:36So imagine 104,000, give or take,
- 10:40straight A students applying there versus what it used to be like, 50,000.
- 10:45What is that about?
- 10:48It's about no check or balance on this.
- 10:53And as a result, these kids show up at college.
- 10:56So what do the colleges do?
- 10:57Well, in some cases,
- 10:59they say we're happy to take their money.
- 11:01Let's run them through.
- 11:02Let's give them a phony college degree.
- 11:05It continues and continues and continues.
- 11:08So these are just a few of the people making America dumb again,
- 11:15continuing to make America dumb again.
- 11:19There is one good news story out there this week.
- 11:23Let me see if I gave you all the really idiotic things that I had this week.
- 11:29The governors.
- 11:30There's another group.
- 11:32The governors who are still balking. There's a big three who allege are moderate Democrats.
- 11:38Pritzker in Illinois,
- 11:39Beshear in Kentucky,
- 11:41and in my state, Josh Shapiro.
- 11:43They are going back and forth about whether they're going
- 11:46to accept.
- 11:47In Pennsylvania's case, it probably could be a billion dollars from the big,
- 11:52beautiful bill from the money set aside for school choice.
- 11:56They won't say.
- 11:57About 35 states have jumped in,
- 12:00and they say they're going to take the money.
- 12:03These people are upsetting families who don't know how to plan for next year,
- 12:08and they're upsetting common sense.
- 12:09And why are they doing it?
- 12:11They're afraid of the teachers'
- 12:13unions.
- 12:13Apparently, they're not afraid of parents.
- 12:15They're not afraid of taxpayers who would like that money.
- 12:20Some of it would go to the public schools.
- 12:22All right. One final note this week.
- 12:25I want to slow down on this one because this is an example of something that should be done to combat fraud.
- 12:35And this story,
- 12:36this is the way that you do it, comes from South Carolina.
- 12:40According to what happened this past week,
- 12:43South Carolina said, look,
- 12:46students know they can pass their classes because of school policy known as grade floors.
- 12:53Schools adopted grade floors,
- 12:55which required teachers to give students minimum grades,
- 12:59commonly of 40 or 50,
- 13:00instead of zeros to keep GPAs from being dragged down by missed assignments.
- 13:06But in practice,
- 13:07they've allowed students to scrape by all year.
- 13:10and still end up with a passing grade,
- 13:12says the director of governmental affairs with the Palmetto State Teachers Association and a high school government and policies teacher.
- 13:20And as any high school graduate,
- 13:22I promise you,
- 13:23there'll be a child who walks across the stage where their teacher in the room is going to go, wait, how did they graduate?
- 13:29They didn't do anything.
- 13:31Grade floors are just one piece of the grade inflation trend that is diminishing the value of a high school diploma,
- 13:38said this Kelly, the guy that I referenced.
- 13:40It's a problem that colleges are increasingly wrestling with, too.
- 13:44Two days after South Carolina's grade four law was signed,
- 13:47faculty at Harvard University passed a policy tapping the number of students who can receive A's to 20 percent of an instructor's class plus four students.
- 13:57The move was a response to perceived grade inflation in the aftermath of the pandemic.
- 14:05A's made up two-thirds of the grades given to undergraduates at Harvard in the spring of 2025.
- 14:11So you have South Carolina doing the right thing.
- 14:18Will this start to spread across America? I mean, who knew grade floors?
- 14:23I've seen this before. You have some kids. I'm just not doing any work.
- 14:26I taught in a school where if you got an A in the fourth marking period,
- 14:32you pass for the year.
- 14:33Even if you did zero,
- 14:35the other three mark appearance.
- 14:37I mean,
- 14:37literally zero.
- 14:38By the way, pop question too,
- 14:40the dumbing down of America.
- 14:42I went to Catholic school.
- 14:44As we know, 70 would always be a past and great.
- 14:47I had a kid argue with me that 78 was a low B.
- 14:51Why did I give him a C minus?
- 14:53In Dom's world,
- 14:5578 is never going to be a low B. You talk about nonsense.
- 14:59Get out of here,
- 15:00kid.
- 15:0078 is a low B. Is that what it is?
- 15:03you are.
- 15:04That's one indicator,
- 15:06without studying all this,
- 15:07of what these schools are up to.
- 15:10They're all in it together,
- 15:11the big city public schools, many of them.
- 15:13South Carolina trying to do something to plug up the dam here.
- 15:18And where does it end? Well, I'm sure they would say, hey, these kids are never really going to be that good anyhow.
- 15:24They're going to work in these jobs,
- 15:25sort of. They don't know anything,
- 15:26but so what?
- 15:28They got their high school diploma,
- 15:30and that means something.
- 15:31They can go out into the world now and fend for themselves,
- 15:34even if they can't do math, read or think or do anything else.
- 15:37They know about ladder safety.
- 15:39These are just some of the people dumbing down America.
- 15:44Now, COVID really hurt us as far as lack of classroom time,
- 15:49social interaction.
- 15:50But you know what?
- 15:51It showed people what was going on in schools,
- 15:54how bad it is.
- 15:55And this show each and every week is devoted to trying to move America back.
- 16:01to becoming smarter again, not continue the inch by inch dumbing down of America.
- 16:07The way to do that are some of the things I talk about every week and to point out the people that are driving this because of their own gain, the teachers unions,
- 16:17some politicians and others.
- 16:20And those who just think,
- 16:22hey, I don't care what this kid does. He can't do anything anyhow.
- 16:26What's wrong with just letting them pass?
- 16:28Just let them pass. Just let them go out into the world.
- 16:30Why even pretend anymore?
- 16:33So watch the New York schools.
- 16:35They've gotten rid of the regents test. The first target of the teachers union are the standardized tests because it's pretty hard to fix those,
- 16:44although they have been caught cheating. You may remember national scandals over the years.
- 16:48It's a threat to them.
- 16:50It's a threat to the system. How would you like to be a teacher working really hard,
- 16:54really good,
- 16:55really trying to push kids forward?
- 16:57And you look around you and a kid's watching a video.
- 17:00and laughing on ladder safety,
- 17:02step ladders and the like.
- 17:04Watch for that, New York.
- 17:06We're on to you here.
- 17:07We have international people listening.
- 17:09We're going to catch you with those ladder programs.
- 17:12All right.
- 17:12You can always send me a tip.
- 17:14Dom show at AOL.com.
- 17:17Dom show at AOL.com.
- 17:19Be happy to respond to you.
- 17:21Tell people about old school,
- 17:22new school,
- 17:23next school,
- 17:24where we are dedicated to making America smart again.
- 17:29And the way to do it is to rub out things like this,
- 17:32to reinforce parental rights,
- 17:34and certainly to allow parents to escape from this nonsense.
- 17:40So we do the fighting.
- 17:42Parents and kids are civilians.
- 17:44Let them flee to the castle of school choice.
- 17:49Meanwhile,
- 17:50we'll duke it out in the trenches right there in front on all this and day by day try to win.
- 17:59as Nicole Hannah-Jones did in a misbegotten attempt to turn around something that's going to take years to deal with.
- 18:06Thanks for listening this week.
- 18:08I will see you next week here on Old School,
- 18:11New School,
- 18:12Next School.
- 18:13Old School,
- 18:14New School, Next School with Dom Giordano is a presentation of Giordano Productions LLC.
- 18:20Copyright 2026.
- 18:22All rights reserved.