Latest / Interfaiths / The Idolatry of Identity and the Case for Transcendence
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. I want to start
- 0:02today by asking you, the listener, to check in
- 0:05with your body for a second. And I mean, seriously,
- 0:07literally check in. Think about the last time
- 0:10you opened a news app, or maybe you clicked on
- 0:12a trending topic on X or whatever social media
- 0:15you use, and you saw an opinion that was just
- 0:18the exact opposite of yours. Oh, I know exactly
- 0:21where you're going with this. I feel it already.
- 0:24You do, right. It's not just an intellectual
- 0:26thought. It's not just, oh, I disagree with that
- 0:28policy. It's... physical. It's a tightness in
- 0:31the chest. Maybe your stomach drops a little
- 0:32bit. Your heart rate actually goes up. It feels,
- 0:35well, it feels dangerous. Right. It's the fight
- 0:37or flight response. Literally, your nervous system
- 0:40is reacting as if a tiger just walked into the
- 0:42room. Exactly. And we're so used to hearing that
- 0:45this is just. just how politics is in the 21st
- 0:48century. We're told it's because of polarization
- 0:50or the algorithms or, you know, fake news. And
- 0:54sure, those are the accelerants. But we have
- 0:56a stack of research today that suggests the fuel
- 0:59for this fire, the actual root cause, is something
- 1:02much, much deeper. It's about the very way we
- 1:05define who we are. It's about this concept we
- 1:07cling to called identity. And here is where it
- 1:10gets fascinating and honestly, a little confronting
- 1:13right out of the gate. The central thesis of
- 1:16the material we're diving into today, it's centered
- 1:18around an essay titled Idolatry of Identity.
- 1:21And it argues that the way we think about identity
- 1:24is actually a mistake. It's a category error.
- 1:27A category error. Yeah. It argues that we have
- 1:29taken these labels, race, party, nation, gender,
- 1:32and we've made them bear more weight than they
- 1:34can possibly hold. We have turned them effectively
- 1:36into idols. Idolatry of identity. That is, I
- 1:39mean, that's a heavy title. It sounds extremely
- 1:41biblical. And I have to ask right off the bat,
- 1:43isn't idolatry a bit of a loaded religious term
- 1:46for what is essentially a political and sociological
- 1:48discussion? It is entirely. intended to be loaded
- 1:51the authors are using it very specifically in
- 1:54a theological sense an idol isn't just a golden
- 1:56calf it's something finite that you treat as
- 1:59if it were infinite it's something created that
- 2:01you worship as the creator okay finite treated
- 2:03as infinite right and the argument here is that
- 2:06we are in a crisis not because we have identities
- 2:08obviously we have them but because we've elevated
- 2:10them to the status of gods we look to our political
- 2:13tribes or our social labels for our salvation
- 2:15our absolute worth our ultimate meaning and because
- 2:19they are just fragile human -made constructs,
- 2:22they are cracking under the pressure. That's
- 2:24the part I want to unpack right away. You said
- 2:26human -made constructs, because it feels like
- 2:29who I am, my identity, is the most natural, ancient,
- 2:32rock -solid thing in the world. But you're saying,
- 2:35based on this research, that identity as we know
- 2:38it is actually a modern invention. That is probably
- 2:40the biggest shocker in the research. We tend
- 2:43to think human beings have always walked around
- 2:45worrying about their identity. But the sources
- 2:47argue that a medieval peasant or a member of
- 2:50a classical Islamic polity or a Roman citizen,
- 2:54they didn't have an identity crisis in the way
- 2:56we do. They didn't have to go find themselves.
- 2:58Wait, so if I'm a peasant in 12th century France,
- 3:00I don't have an identity. Not in the modern sense.
- 3:04You have a role. You have a place. And that's
- 3:07the journey we're going on today. We are going
- 3:08to look at how we invented the modern self, how
- 3:11that invention has been weaponized into the polarization
- 3:14we hate. And then, and this is the really ambitious
- 3:18part of the deep dive, we are going to see if
- 3:20ancient religious traditions offer us a way out.
- 3:23And just to be clear for the listener, because
- 3:25we're bringing up religion and ancient traditions,
- 3:27this isn't a sermon. We aren't here to convert
- 3:30anyone today. Not at all. We are looking at these
- 3:32traditions, Islam, Hinduism, Jainism, Judaism,
- 3:36Christianity, as deep reservoirs of psychology
- 3:39and sociology. These are systems that have spent
- 3:42thousands of years thinking about the human ego,
- 3:44the self, and community. The argument is that
- 3:47they might have the intellectual tools to repair
- 3:49our broken politics. Tools that secular liberalism
- 3:53just doesn't have in its current toolkit. So
- 3:56the mission is to figure out why we are so angry
- 3:58at each other and how ancient wisdom might fix
- 4:01it. Let's start with that history lesson. You
- 4:04said identity is invented. Take us back to that
- 4:06medieval peasant. Right. To understand this,
- 4:09we have to look at the work of the philosopher
- 4:10Charles Taylor. He wrote this massive, dense
- 4:13book called Sources of the Self. It's a complete
- 4:15doorstop, but it's brilliant. Taylor draws a
- 4:18fundamental distinction between the pre -modern
- 4:20self and the modern self. Okay, set the scene
- 4:22for the pre -modern. So imagine you are that
- 4:24peasant in 12th century France. You do not wake
- 4:26up in the morning wondering, who am I, really?
- 4:28You don't take a personality test. You don't
- 4:30curate a bio. Your identity is given to you.
- 4:33Given by whom? By your circumstances. by your
- 4:36family, your guild, your village, and ultimately
- 4:39by the cosmos or God. You are the son of John.
- 4:43You are a blacksmith. You are a subject of the
- 4:44king. You are a child of the church. Your place
- 4:47in the hierarchy is fixed. It's external to you.
- 4:50Taylor calls this the porous self. Porous, meaning
- 4:53things pass through it. Yes, meaning you are
- 4:55open to the world. The meaning of your life comes
- 4:58from outside of you, from the spiritual world,
- 5:00from the community structure. You are a node
- 5:02in a network that already exists. You don't have
- 5:05to invent the network. That sounds, well, on
- 5:07the one hand, incredibly restrictive. You're
- 5:09stuck. If you're born a blacksmith's son, you're
- 5:11a blacksmith. There's no upward mobility, no
- 5:13following your dreams. Absolutely. It was incredibly
- 5:15restrictive. But, and Taylor makes a huge point
- 5:18of this, it was also psychologically restful.
- 5:20Yes. You didn't have the anxiety of definition.
- 5:23You didn't have to constantly prove your existence
- 5:26or your validity. Because your existence was
- 5:28an objective fact of society, you fit. Okay,
- 5:31I can see that. There's a certain safety in knowing
- 5:34your exact place. But we obviously don't live
- 5:36there anymore. We don't want to live there. What
- 5:38changed? Modernity. The Enlightenment. The Romantic
- 5:42Era. Taylor describes this massive shift as radical
- 5:46reflexivity. Radical reflexivity. Break that
- 5:49down for us. It's the turn inward. Think about
- 5:52Descartes, I think, therefore I am. Think about
- 5:55the romantics who believed you had to find your
- 5:57unique inner voice. The source of meaning moves
- 6:00from the outside world, the stars, the king,
- 6:02the church, to the inside of your own head. The
- 6:05self becomes a project. So instead of looking
- 6:08at the stars to know who I am, I look into my
- 6:10own feelings. Precisely. And this is a massive
- 6:13shift in human history. Identity stops being
- 6:16something you receive and starts being something
- 6:17you construct. You have to discover your inner
- 6:19truth, interpret it, and then, and this is the
- 6:22crucial part for our politics, express it to
- 6:24the world. Express yourself. That is the ultimate
- 6:26modern mantra. It is. But this creates a totally
- 6:29new problem that the medieval peasant never had
- 6:31to deal with. Taylor calls it the politics of
- 6:34recognition. Recognition. Okay, explain that
- 6:36mechanism. How does that work? Well, think about
- 6:38it. If my identity is given by the village, if
- 6:41I am the blacksmith, I don't need you to validate
- 6:43me. Everyone sees the anvil. Everyone knows who
- 6:46I am. It's an objective fact. But if my identity
- 6:48is something I discovered inside myself, something
- 6:50unique, personal, maybe a little fragile, then
- 6:54it's invisible to you unless I express it. And
- 6:57once I express it, I desperately need you to
- 6:59confirm it. Yeah. So I need you to say, yes,
- 7:02I see you. Your identity is valid. Exactly. If
- 7:06you ignore me or if you misrecognize me, if you
- 7:09use the wrong label or you mock my inner truth,
- 7:11it doesn't just feel like you're being rude.
- 7:13It feels like you are erasing my very existence.
- 7:16Taylor argues that because identity is now constructed
- 7:18internally but formed in dialogue with others,
- 7:21we have developed an insatiable need for external
- 7:24validation. That resonates so much with the social
- 7:26media age. It's not enough to just be something.
- 7:28I have to post about it. And if I post it and
- 7:30get zero likes or if people criticize it in the
- 7:33comments, I feel this crushing weight. It's not
- 7:35just embarrassment. It feels like an existential
- 7:37crisis. It is exhausting. We've created a world
- 7:40where everyone is walking around holding a fragile
- 7:43glass sculpture of their own ego. go, basically
- 7:46begging everyone else not to drop it. But hold
- 7:49on a second. Is this just about us being sensitive,
- 7:53you know, snowflakes? Or is there something philosophical
- 7:56missing here? Because it feels like we've also
- 7:58lost the ability to even argue about what's good
- 8:01or bad in the public square. You hit the nail
- 8:03on the head. That brings us to the second pillar
- 8:06of our history lesson here, the work of Alistair
- 8:08McIntyre and his book After Virtue. McIntyre
- 8:12argues that that period where we embraced reason
- 8:15and science actually broke our moral compass
- 8:17entirely. How so? I thought the Enlightenment
- 8:20was supposed to liberate us from superstitions.
- 8:22Reason was supposed to fix everything. Give us
- 8:25a solid foundation. It tried to. The Enlightenment
- 8:27thinkers tried to base morality on pure reason
- 8:30alone. They wanted to discard the old superstitions
- 8:32about God or cosmic order. But McIntyre says
- 8:35they failed because they discarded a vital concept
- 8:37called teleology. Teleology. That comes from
- 8:40the Greek word telos, right? Meaning purpose.
- 8:43Right. Telos means the end or the goal or the
- 8:47purpose of a thing. Let's use a really simple
- 8:49example. A watch. What is the talos of a watch?
- 8:54To tell time accurately. Correct. Because you
- 8:57know the talos of a watch, you can make an objective
- 8:59moral statement about it. You can say, this is
- 9:01a good watch if it keeps time, or this is a bad
- 9:04watch if it's slow. The goodness is defined by
- 9:06how well it fulfills its inherent purpose. Okay,
- 9:09that makes total sense for a machine or a tool.
- 9:12Well, in the pre -modern world, we believed human
- 9:14beings had a telos too. Maybe it was to glorify
- 9:16God or to live in accordance with nature or to
- 9:19serve the polis in ancient Greece. Because we
- 9:22had a shared definition of what a human was for,
- 9:24we could agree on what a good human was. We could
- 9:27agree on virtues. But we don't agree on what
- 9:29humans are for anymore. Exactly. Science doesn't
- 9:31do telos. Science tells you how the mechanism
- 9:33works, not what the purpose of the mechanism
- 9:35is. We discarded the idea of a shared purpose.
- 9:38So now we are left with moral rules. Don't kill,
- 9:41be free, treat people fairly, but we have no
- 9:45context for why. McIntyre calls the result emotivism.
- 9:49Emotivism. That sounds like acting on your emotions.
- 9:52Essentially, yes. It's the philosophical view
- 9:54that all moral claims like abortion is wrong,
- 9:57freedom is good, taxation is theft, are actually
- 10:00nothing more than expressions of personal preference.
- 10:03It's like saying, I like vanilla ice cream, but
- 10:05we dress it up in fancy language to sound like
- 10:07objective truth. So when I say this policy is
- 10:10unjust, I'm not actually stating a fact about
- 10:13the universe. I'm just saying, boo, I don't like
- 10:16this. According to McIntyre, that is exactly
- 10:19how our public discourse functions now. We shout
- 10:22justice and rights at each other. But because
- 10:24we have no shared standard of truth or purpose
- 10:26to adjudicate the argument, we are just shouting
- 10:29our emotional preferences. And this connects
- 10:31back to identity. How exactly? Well. If we can't
- 10:34agree on what is true or what is the purpose
- 10:36of life, we retreat to the only thing we have
- 10:39left. Who I am. Identity replaces truth as the
- 10:42basis for political argument. I can't prove I'm
- 10:45right based on a universal standard, so I claim
- 10:47that my identity demands this view. As a blank,
- 10:50I believe this. And if you disagree with me,
- 10:52you aren't just disagreeing with my logic. You
- 10:55are attacking me. You are attacking my existence.
- 10:58Bingo. And that seems to be where all the anger
- 11:00comes from. If we're just debating tax rates
- 11:03and we both agree the goal is economic growth,
- 11:05that's a math problem. We can solve math. We
- 11:08can look at data. But if we're debating my identity,
- 11:11my existence, my recognition, that's a war. And
- 11:15this brings us to the weaponization of identity.
- 11:17Because it's not just that we are isolated individuals
- 11:20wandering around with these fragile selves. We
- 11:24are clumping into tribes. Huge tribes. This is
- 11:27where we get into the work of Liliana Mason,
- 11:29specifically her book Uncivil Agreement. I found
- 11:32this part of the deep dive totally fascinating
- 11:34because she uses hard data to explain why politics
- 11:37feels so much more toxic now than it did 50 years
- 11:40ago. She uses the term social sorting, right?
- 11:42Yes. Social sorting. Explain that. Because I
- 11:45think people assume we've always been fiercely
- 11:46divided. We have, but the structure of the division
- 11:49was entirely different. Imagine the U .S. in
- 11:51the 1960s or 70s. You might be a Republican,
- 11:54but you might also be a union member. You might
- 11:56be a Catholic living in the Northeast. Okay,
- 11:59I'm picturing that guy. Now, generally, unions
- 12:01leaned Democrat, but you're a Republican, so
- 12:04your identities are cross -cutting. You have
- 12:06friends at the union hall who are Democrats,
- 12:08but you agree on labor issues. You have friends
- 12:10at church who are Democrats, but you agree on
- 12:12theology. Your Republican -ness was just one
- 12:16slice of your pie. It didn't consume the whole
- 12:19thing. So I had social pressure to not hate Democrats
- 12:23because my bowling partner was a Democrat. We
- 12:26had other things keeping us together. Exactly.
- 12:27You had overlapping circles of belonging. But
- 12:30Mason shows that over the last few decades, these
- 12:33identities have sorted. They have stacked up
- 12:35on top of each other. Stacked up how? What does
- 12:38that look like today? Today, if you tell me your
- 12:40political party, I can probably guess your religion,
- 12:42your race, whether you live in a city or the
- 12:44country, what kind of car you drive, and even
- 12:47what grocery store you shop at. The circles have
- 12:49all merged into one giant circle. We've created
- 12:52what the source calls the mega identity. The
- 12:55mega identity. And the stakes go through the
- 12:58absolute roof. Because now, if our party loses
- 13:01an election, it's not just that my taxes might
- 13:04go up. It feels like my religion, my culture,
- 13:07my race, and my geographic way of life have all
- 13:10been rejected by the country. It feels like an
- 13:13existential referendum on me. And the data backs
- 13:15this up in a terrifying way. There was a study
- 13:17by Iyengar and Westwood in 2015 that the source
- 13:21cites. They found that partisan discrimination
- 13:23in the U .S. now exceeds racial discrimination.
- 13:26Wait, say that again? That is a massive claim.
- 13:28Partisan discrimination is higher than racial
- 13:30discrimination. In experimental settings, yes.
- 13:33They gave people resumes to review for a scholarship
- 13:36or a job. They found that people were significantly
- 13:39more likely to discriminate against someone from
- 13:41the opposing political party than against someone
- 13:43of a different race. That is wild. But if you
- 13:46think about it, we have very strong social norms
- 13:48that say do not be racist. You get fired for
- 13:50being racist. But we have absolutely no social
- 13:53norms that say don't hate the other political
- 13:54party. In fact, you get rewarded for it. It's
- 13:57social currency. It's the last acceptable prejudice.
- 14:00It allows us to vent all that tribal aggression
- 14:02that we can't use elsewhere. So we have these
- 14:04mega identities and they are fueled by this insatiable
- 14:09need for recognition that Taylor talked about.
- 14:11Francis Fukuyama has a term for this in the research,
- 14:14right? Yes. In his book Identity, he talks about
- 14:16thymos. It's a concept originally from Plato.
- 14:19It refers to the part of the soul that craves
- 14:21recognition and dignity. Fukuyama says there
- 14:24are two types. There is isothemia. Isothemia,
- 14:27like an isosceles triangle. Equal. Right. The
- 14:30desire to be recognized as equal. I am just as
- 14:33good as you. This is the basis of the civil rights
- 14:36movement, feminism. Gay rights. It's the drive
- 14:40for equal dignity. And that's good. We want that
- 14:42in democracy. But there's a dark side. But Fukuyama
- 14:45warns that isothemia has a very dangerous tendency
- 14:47to slide into megalothemia. Megalothemia. That
- 14:50sounds like a Godzilla villain. It's the desire
- 14:52to be recognized as superior, to have your group
- 14:56acknowledged not just as equal, but as the best,
- 14:58the real Americans, the enlightened ones, the
- 15:01chosen ones. When you combine the mega identity
- 15:04with megalithemia, you get a recipe for civil
- 15:07conflict. You get a zero -sum game where my dignity
- 15:10practically requires your humiliation. The irony,
- 15:13and this is the part that might upset some people,
- 15:15but we have to go there to understand the source
- 15:16material, is that the things we are fighting
- 15:18over, these categories, might not even... be
- 15:21as real as we think they are this is the core
- 15:23paradox of the whole thing kwame anthony appear
- 15:26wrote a book called the lies that bind he argues
- 15:29that we are ready to go to war for categories
- 15:31that are in his words riddled with contradictions
- 15:34take race for example right now we have to be
- 15:36very careful here racism is incredibly real the
- 15:39sociological effects of race are undeniably real
- 15:42absolutely sociologically historically race is
- 15:45a massive reality with massive consequences but
- 15:49apia is talking about biology and ontology. He
- 15:52points out a stunning fact. 90 % of genetic variation
- 15:55in humans exists within racial groups, not between
- 15:58them. Meaning there's more genetic difference
- 16:00between two random white guys than between the
- 16:03average white guy and the average black guy.
- 16:06Often, yes. Biologically, race is not a coherent
- 16:09category. It's a sloppy historical shorthand
- 16:12we invented based on superficial traits. Or take
- 16:15nationality. Most modern nations are very recent
- 16:19inventions, or religion traditions are internally
- 16:21fractured with thousands of sects. But we treat
- 16:25these fluid sociological constructions as if
- 16:28they are fixed, hard realities. We treat them
- 16:31as ontological, as the very ground of our being.
- 16:34That's the idolatry part from the title. We've
- 16:36taken a costume that society handed us, and we've
- 16:38convinced ourselves it's our actual skin. Precisely.
- 16:41We've forgotten that we made these categories
- 16:43up. And because we treat them as fixed gods,
- 16:45we are trapped in them. We worship the label.
- 16:48So let's take a breath and look at the diagnosis
- 16:50we have so far. We have a modern self that is
- 16:53anxious, turned inward, and desperate for external
- 16:56validation. We have lost our shared moral language,
- 16:59so we just shout our feelings at each other.
- 17:00We have stacked our identities into megatribes.
- 17:03And we are worshiping these tribes as if they
- 17:05are the ultimate biological truth. That is the
- 17:08incredibly bleak picture. It is bleak. If this
- 17:11were a standard political show, this is where
- 17:13we would say, so vote for this candidate, they'll
- 17:15fix it or pass this law. But the source material
- 17:18strongly suggests that politics cannot fix this
- 17:22because politics is just the symptom. The cure
- 17:25has to go much deeper. Into the spiritual and
- 17:28psychological. Yeah. And again, not in a thoughts
- 17:30and prayers kind of way, but in a let's deconstruct
- 17:33the human psyche kind of way. The argument is
- 17:36that ancient spiritual traditions have actually
- 17:38known about this idolatry of the self for millennia.
- 17:42They have. They've been essentially debugging
- 17:44the human operating system for 3 ,000 years.
- 17:47And they offer a profound corrective. If the
- 17:50problem is a rigid, constructed self that demands
- 17:52constant worship and validation, the solution
- 17:55is to realize that this rigid self is an illusion.
- 17:58Let's start with the East. I was really struck
- 17:59by the section on Islam and the research, specifically
- 18:02the Sufi tradition. They have a concept called
- 18:04the nafs. The nafs. It's usually translated into
- 18:07English as the ego or the lower self. But what
- 18:10I love about the Sufi perspective is that the
- 18:13self isn't a statue. It isn't a fixed thing you
- 18:16have to defend. It's a process. It's incredibly
- 18:19fluid. So I'm not just one thing forever. I don't
- 18:22have a true self I have to protect. No. The Quran
- 18:25describes stages of the self. It's almost like
- 18:28a developmental ladder you climb. You start at
- 18:31the bottom with nafs al -amara. The commanding
- 18:33self. Right. This is the self that commands you
- 18:35to do evil or just gives in to base desires.
- 18:38It's pure impulse, pure ego. It's the toddler
- 18:41in your brain screaming, I want. It's the part
- 18:44of you that wants to dunk on someone on Twitter
- 18:46because it feels really good in the moment to
- 18:48be superior. We've all been there. It does feel
- 18:50good in the moment. We all live there sometimes.
- 18:52But then, ideally, you mature and move to Nafs
- 18:55al -Awamah, the self -blaming conscience. This
- 18:57is when you realize you messed up. You feel guilt.
- 19:00You look at your own anger online and say, you
- 19:02know, that wasn't the real me. I can do better.
- 19:05And the final goal. The goal is to reach Nafs
- 19:08al -Mumain, the soul, at peace. And ultimately,
- 19:11in Sufism, the ultimate spiritual goal is Fana.
- 19:15Fana. That translates to annihilation, right?
- 19:18That sounds terrifying to a modern person. It
- 19:21sounds totally scary to the modern ear because
- 19:23we are so obsessed with preserving ourselves,
- 19:25recognizing ourselves. But fauna isn't destruction
- 19:28in a violent or nihilistic sense. It's the passing
- 19:31away of the ego. It's the deep realization that
- 19:34I am not the center of the universe. It's just
- 19:37getting over yourself. Exactly. William Chittick,
- 19:39who is a great scholar of Sufism, has this wonderful
- 19:41quote in the material. Each moment of the self
- 19:44is unique. It liberates you. If the self is fluid,
- 19:48changing every single moment in relation to God
- 19:50and the world, then you don't have to defend
- 19:52a giant, rigid fortress of me. That is actually
- 19:55very freeing. If I mess up or if someone attacks
- 19:57my identity, I can say, well, that was just a
- 19:59fleeting state. That label isn't my soul. I don't
- 20:01have to burn the world down to defend it. It
- 20:03loosens the grip of the idol. It turns the idol
- 20:05back into dust. Now, Hinduism does something
- 20:08very similar, but it uses a different metaphor.
- 20:10The costume. The actor and the role. This comes
- 20:14from the Gita, doesn't it? Yes, the Bhagavad
- 20:15Gita and the Upanishads. They draw a very sharp,
- 20:18clear distinction between the Atman, the eternal
- 20:21self, the unchanging spark of the divine inside
- 20:24you, and the empirical self. The empirical self
- 20:27being your body, your caste, your job, your gender,
- 20:31your political party. Exactly. And the empirical
- 20:33self, the political party, the job, the social
- 20:36status, that's all part of Maya. Maya. Illusion.
- 20:39Maya. Illusion. Now, illusion doesn't mean it
- 20:42doesn't exist. The traffic jam is real. The election
- 20:44is real. It means it's not the ultimate reality.
- 20:47It's a cosmic play. Imagine you are a method
- 20:50actor on Broadway. You're playing a king. You
- 20:53wear the crown. You give the orders. You feel
- 20:55the power of the scene. But deep down, you have
- 20:57to know, I am not actually the king. I am the
- 20:59actor playing the king. I have to take the crown
- 21:01off and go home. But in our modern politics,
- 21:04we've completely forgotten we're actors. We think
- 21:07the costume is super glued to our skin. We think
- 21:09we are the role. And that's exactly why we fight
- 21:12so viciously. Because if the costume is all I
- 21:15have, if my political label is my entire existence,
- 21:17then an attack on the costume is a lethal attack
- 21:20on my existence. If my party loses the election,
- 21:23I psychologically die. So the spiritual practice
- 21:26here is to wake up on stage. To wake up and realize,
- 21:29I am playing the role of a Democrat, or I am
- 21:32playing the role of a conservative. And I will
- 21:33play it well. I will fight for justice as I see
- 21:36it. But I know that the person across the stage
- 21:39from me, the quote unquote villain, is also just
- 21:43an actor. They have the same eternal Atman. The
- 21:46Gita has a beautiful line about this, the equal
- 21:48vision. Yes. It says the wise person sees with
- 21:50equal vision a Brahmin, a priest, a cow, an elephant
- 21:53or a dog eater, which means an outcast. They
- 21:56see the exact same divine spark in all of them,
- 21:58regardless of the costume they are wearing in
- 22:00this life. That is radical equality. But let's
- 22:03be perfectly honest here. It's really hard to
- 22:06look at a political troll on the Internet, someone
- 22:08saying vile things and see a divine spark. It's
- 22:11incredibly hard. That's why it's called a spiritual
- 22:13discipline and not a weekend hobby. It goes against
- 22:16our tribal nature. Now, if we want a practical
- 22:19tool for how to actually talk to that troll or
- 22:22talk to someone we fiercely disagree with, Jainism
- 22:25is the absolute gold standard in the research.
- 22:29Jainism. These are the folks who are strictly
- 22:31nonviolent, right? Yeah. They wear masks sometimes
- 22:34to avoid inhaling and killing microscopic insects.
- 22:37Yes, ahisa perfect nonviolence is their core
- 22:40tenet. But the source material highlights something
- 22:42brilliant they developed called intellectual
- 22:45ahisa. Intellectual nonviolence. I love that
- 22:48concept. Let's dig into that. It's based on a
- 22:50philosophical doctrine called anekantavada. Did
- 22:53I pronounce that right? You sounded very confident,
- 22:55so let's go with yes, anacondavada. It translates
- 22:57to the many -sidedness of truth. The classic
- 23:00analogy they use, which you've probably heard,
- 23:01is the blind man and the elephant. Right. One
- 23:04touches the trunk and says truth is a snake.
- 23:06One touches the leg and says truth is a tree.
- 23:08One touches the ear and says truth is a fan.
- 23:11Exactly. They are all right based on their experience,
- 23:14but they are all wrong about the whole. Janes
- 23:17believe that reality is so massive and so complex
- 23:19that no single human view can possibly capture
- 23:22it all. Only a fully enlightened being, a Kevelin,
- 23:26can see the whole truth at once. For the rest
- 23:29of us, our view is always inherently partial.
- 23:32So how does a Jane argue politics then? Do they
- 23:35just say, well, everything is true, there is
- 23:37no right answer? That sounds like relativism.
- 23:39No, they aren't relativists. They use a system
- 23:42of logic called sadvada. It means conditional
- 23:44predication. Basically, every statement you make
- 23:48should have an invisible asterisk next to it
- 23:49that says, from a certain perspective. So instead
- 23:52of saying, the economy is failing, which is an
- 23:54absolute dogmatic statement. You would say from
- 23:57the perspective of a wage earner in the manufacturing
- 24:00sector, the economy is failing. And someone else
- 24:02might say, well, from the perspective of a tech
- 24:04shareholder, the economy is booming. And both
- 24:07are true. Both are true. Neither is the whole
- 24:09truth. They are facets of the diamond. If we
- 24:11actually spoke like that, cable news would cease
- 24:13to exist entirely. Tonight on Primetime. From
- 24:17a certain perspective, the other side has a valid
- 24:19point. The ratings would plummet to zero. they
- 24:22would absolutely plummet. But think about the
- 24:25profound epistemic humility that requires. It
- 24:28frames dogmatic attachment to your own view as
- 24:31a form of actual violence. To claim I possess
- 24:33the absolute final truth and you are absolutely
- 24:36100 % wrong is to do violence to the complexity
- 24:39of reality. That is a powerful reframe. Dogma
- 24:42as violence. So we have this massive deconstruction
- 24:45of the ego from the Eastern traditions. Sufism
- 24:48says the self is fluid. Hinduism says it's just
- 24:50a costume. Jainism says your truth is only partial.
- 24:53But there's another side to this puzzle. Because
- 24:55if you just deconstruct everything, you might
- 24:57end up with nihilism. You still need to build
- 24:59something back up. Right. We don't just need
- 25:01to humble ourselves. We need to actively honor
- 25:04the other person. We need a solid basis for human
- 25:07dignity. And this is where the Western Abrahamic
- 25:10traditions, Judaism, Christianity, and Islam,
- 25:12really shine in the source material. They give
- 25:16us an undeniable reason to respect the person
- 25:18we disagree with, even if we think they're dangerously
- 25:21wrong. Let's talk about the Jewish concept of
- 25:23the image of God. B'tzalem Elohim. It comes from
- 25:26Genesis 1 .27. God created man in his own image.
- 25:30This is the absolute bedrock of Western human
- 25:33rights. Even if our secular society often forgets
- 25:36the theological root of it, it means that every
- 25:39single human being, regardless of their utility,
- 25:41their intelligence, their wealth, or their politics,
- 25:43has infinite value. Because they bear the stamp
- 25:46of the creator. And the Talmud raises the stakes
- 25:49on this even higher. The Talmud says one who
- 25:51destroys a single life, it is as if he destroyed
- 25:53an entire world. Think about the gravity of that.
- 25:56Every person is a universe. Leo Beck, the great
- 25:58Jewish thinker, had a specific insight on this
- 26:01regarding diversity and how we view each other.
- 26:03Yes. He wrote that above all castes, classes,
- 26:07and nations stands one certainty, man or humanity.
- 26:11But the specific brilliant Jewish genius here
- 26:15is holding the tension between the particular
- 26:17and the universal. What do you mean by that tension,
- 26:20the particular versus universal? Well, Judaism
- 26:23is a tribal religion. It's a covenant with a
- 26:25very specific people, the Jews. They have particular
- 26:28laws, particular lands, particular traditions.
- 26:31But the theology affirms the universal dignity
- 26:34of everyone, regardless of whether they are in
- 26:36that covenant or not. I can be deeply, passionately
- 26:39committed to my tribe, but I must also recognize
- 26:41the infinite worth. of the stranger that feels
- 26:44like exactly the balance we are completely missing
- 26:47right now we either have people who are all tribe
- 26:49and they hate the stranger or we have people
- 26:52who want to be enlightened global citizens but
- 26:54they have no local roots no tribe at all exactly
- 26:57judaism models how to be both you have a distinct
- 27:00home you love your home but you deeply respect
- 27:03the neighbor christianity takes this universalism
- 27:06and really blasts it out to the empire there's
- 27:08that famous verse in galatians the source mentions
- 27:10galatians 3 .28 Now, I've heard intense arguments
- 27:20about this verse. Is Paul saying those categories
- 27:23literally don't exist anymore? Is he being colorblind
- 27:26or genderblind? Because saying there is no male
- 27:28and female seems biologically... obviously untrue.
- 27:33It's a great question and it gets debated a lot,
- 27:35but most scholars argue he's not saying they
- 27:38physically vanish. He's not saying differences
- 27:40aren't real or don't shape our lives. He's saying
- 27:43they are secondary. They are no longer the fundamental
- 27:45standing of a person before God or the community.
- 27:49Context really matters here, right? Because of
- 27:50Rome. Huge context. In the Roman world, being
- 27:54a slave or free was absolutely everything. It
- 27:57determined if you were a human person with rights
- 27:59or literally a talking farm tool. Being Jew or
- 28:02Greek determined your entire legal and social
- 28:04status. Paul is saying, no, those labels are
- 28:06surface level. Your ultimate worth is determined
- 28:09by something that transcends those labels. He
- 28:11is relativizing the entire social hierarchy of
- 28:14the Roman Empire. So to apply it today, Democrat
- 28:18or Republican might describe how I vote. But
- 28:21it doesn't describe my ultimate worth as a human
- 28:23being. Exactly. It renders the political label
- 28:26penultimate. It's important, but it's not the
- 28:29ultimate truth about you. The mega -identity
- 28:32gets demoted. And Islam has a beautiful parallel
- 28:35to this in the Quran regarding why diversity
- 28:37even exists in the first place. Sura 49 .13 it
- 28:41says we made you into nations and tribes so that
- 28:44you may know one another yes the idea is that
- 28:48diversity isn't a mistake it isn't a bug in the
- 28:51system it's a deliberate feature god didn't make
- 28:54us different so we would fight and sort into
- 28:55mega tribes but so we would learn If everyone
- 28:58was exactly the same, there would be no knowing.
- 29:00There would be no friction, no curiosity, no
- 29:02growth. And there's that Islamic concept of fitra
- 29:04too, which I find really hopeful for the idea
- 29:07of a secular democracy. Fitra is the primordial
- 29:10nature. Think of it as the factory settings of
- 29:12the human soul. Abdulaziz Saqedina, a major scholar
- 29:16in this field, argues that fitra is what actually
- 29:18allows us to have a functioning pluralistic society.
- 29:21How so? How does fitra help us politically? Because
- 29:25Fitcher implies that every single human being
- 29:27has a God -given moral compass. Even if you are
- 29:31an atheist and I am a Muslim or you are a hardcore
- 29:34Republican and I am a progressive Democrat, we
- 29:37both have this innate capacity for reason, for
- 29:40conscience, for knowing right from wrong. So
- 29:42we aren't total aliens to each other, even across
- 29:44massive divides. We aren't aliens. We share a
- 29:47common language of moral justification that exists
- 29:50before our religious or political labels even
- 29:53enter the picture. We can reason together because
- 29:56we come from the exact same source code. So let's
- 29:58bring all these threads together. The Eastern
- 30:00traditions tell us, hey, your ego is a costume.
- 30:03Don't worship it. The Western traditions tell
- 30:05us, hey, that person you hate is made in the
- 30:07image of God. Treat them with ultimate dignity.
- 30:10That's the theory. Deconstruction of the idol
- 30:12and restoration of true dignity. But now we have
- 30:15to land the plane. How do we actually do this?
- 30:17How do we build a modern functioning society
- 30:20on this? Because right now it feels like we are
- 30:22ripping apart at the seams. Telling people to
- 30:26see the image of God in a Twitter troll is a
- 30:28very tall order, especially on Election Day.
- 30:31It is a massive order. And this brings us to
- 30:33the final piece of our source material. and the
- 30:35profound work of the late great rabbi Jonathan
- 30:38Sacks. He was a total giant in this field. He
- 30:42wrote a book called The Dignity of Difference.
- 30:44Great title, by the way. It's a wonderful book.
- 30:46And in it, he makes a crucial distinction that
- 30:48I think perfectly explains why our current politics
- 30:51is failing so miserably. He distinguishes between
- 30:54a social contract and a social covenant. Okay,
- 30:57political science nerds, wake up. This is your
- 31:00moment. Contract versus covenant. Break it down
- 31:02for us. A social contract, which is what modern
- 31:05liberal democracy is entirely built on, going
- 31:08all the way back to Hobbes and Locke and Rousseau,
- 31:10is fundamentally transactional. It's a business
- 31:12deal. Meaning I give you something, you give
- 31:15me something. Meaning I pay my taxes. The government
- 31:18fixes the road. I obey the law. The state protects
- 31:21my private property. It is completely based on
- 31:24mutual self -interest. I do this so that you
- 31:27do that. That pretty much describes most of my
- 31:29interactions with the state. Right. And Sachs
- 31:31says the contract is necessary. You absolutely
- 31:33need it to run a state, collect taxes and pave
- 31:36roads. But it is entirely insufficient to run
- 31:39a society. Because what happens when the deal
- 31:42goes bad? If the government stops fixing the
- 31:44road, I want to stop paying. If the deal isn't
- 31:46working for me anymore. I want out of the contract.
- 31:49Exactly. It's fragile. If the society is just
- 31:52based on interests, then as soon as our interests
- 31:54diverge, which they inevitably will, we are enemies.
- 31:57We have nothing holding us together. A covenant,
- 31:59however, is completely different. How so? What
- 32:02is a covenant? A covenant is relational. It's
- 32:05transformative. Think of a healthy marriage.
- 32:07A marriage isn't, or at least it shouldn't be,
- 32:09a contract where I will wash the dishes only
- 32:12if you mow the lawn, and if you don't, the marriage
- 32:14is void. It's much deeper. It's I am bound to
- 32:18you. Your fate is my fate. I am loyal to this
- 32:21bond regardless of whether it is currently convenient
- 32:23for my self -interest. For better or for worse.
- 32:25Exactly. A covenant creates a we. A contract
- 32:29just manages a bunch of isolated I's. Sachs argues
- 32:32that in the modern West, we have moved from a
- 32:35politics of solidarity, which is covenant, covenant
- 32:37to a politics of identity, which is contract.
- 32:39We basically view the country as a giant hotel
- 32:42where we are all just trying to get the best
- 32:44room service for our specific tribe rather than
- 32:46a home that we actively build and maintain together.
- 32:49So we urgently need to recover covenantal thinking.
- 32:53But does that mean we all have to believe the
- 32:54exact same thing? Because that sounds a lot like
- 32:57assimilation, which people rightly push back
- 32:59against. No, and this is Sack's true brilliance
- 33:02here. He calls for integration without assimilation.
- 33:05Explain the difference between those two. Assimilation
- 33:07is the classic melting pot. You throw everyone
- 33:10in, turn up the heat, and they melt into one
- 33:13uniform sludge. You lose your distinctiveness,
- 33:16your heritage, your specific beliefs. Sack says
- 33:19no. Monotheism. The belief in one God does not
- 33:23mean monism. The belief in only one valid path
- 33:26or one uniform way to be human. The creator actually
- 33:30loves diversity. You can be fully Jewish, fully
- 33:32Muslim, fully Texan, fully Californian. You absolutely
- 33:36keep your distinct identity. So I get to keep
- 33:38my costume. You keep your costume. It's a beautiful
- 33:40costume. But you are bound to the whole society
- 33:43in a way that supersedes your private interest.
- 33:45You are committed to the relationship, to the
- 33:47covenant, more than you are committed to winning
- 33:49every single argument. That sounds incredible
- 33:52in theory, but it also sounds really hard in
- 33:54practice. Is there any empirical evidence that
- 33:57this actually works, or is it just nice philosophy?
- 34:00There is actual evidence. The source points to
- 34:02research by scholars like Ibrat Patel and Mohammed
- 34:04Abernumer. They study interfaith engagement and
- 34:07conflict resolution on the ground. And what do
- 34:09they find when they put these groups together?
- 34:11They find that when people actually engage across
- 34:13lines of difference, but not just sitting in
- 34:16a conference room debating theology, because
- 34:18that usually goes nowhere and just entrenches
- 34:20people. Right. Debates just trigger the megalithymia.
- 34:22Exactly. But when they engage by actually working
- 34:25on a shared project, building a Habitat for Humanity
- 34:28house together, running a local food bank, cleaning
- 34:32up a park. Shared action. Shared action toward
- 34:35a common good. When they do that, the research
- 34:38shows they develop shared moral frameworks. They
- 34:41build a covenant. And they don't lose their religion
- 34:44in the process. A Christian often becomes a better
- 34:47Christian by working alongside a Muslim because
- 34:49they are challenged to actually live up to their
- 34:51own charitable values. But the crucial shift
- 34:54is that the other stops being an existential
- 34:56threat. It's the contact hypothesis, right? It's
- 35:00really hard to hate people close up. It's practically
- 35:02impossible to hate people when you are sweating
- 35:04alongside them, passing them a hammer. The abstraction
- 35:06falls away. The mega identity crumbles. You stop
- 35:09seeing a representative of the evil opposing
- 35:11party and you just see Dave. Just Dave, who is
- 35:14bad at using a hammer, but tells good jokes.
- 35:16And that mundane connection is the literal beginning
- 35:19of a covenant. You know, this whole deep dive
- 35:22has been quite a journey. We started with that
- 35:24physical tightness in our chest, the deep anxiety
- 35:27of the modern self scrolling through social media.
- 35:29We looked at how we turned identity into an idol,
- 35:32demanding constant recognition. And we ended
- 35:36up with Rabbi Sachs basically telling us to get
- 35:38married to our neighbors. It is a lot of ground
- 35:40to cover, but I think the core takeaway, despite
- 35:43all the heavy philosophy, is actually quite simple.
- 35:47Summarize it for us. What is the one thing the
- 35:49listener should take away from all this source
- 35:51material? The idolatry of identity is making
- 35:53us completely miserable. We are worshiping labels
- 35:56and categories that we invented ourselves. The
- 35:59way out of this trap is not to pretend we don't
- 36:01have identities. We do, and they matter. They
- 36:04shape our lives. The way out is to just hold
- 36:06them lightly. I see them as costumes. To see
- 36:08them as costumes. To practice the intellectual
- 36:11humility of the Jains, knowing our truth is always
- 36:14partial. To see the image of God like the Jews
- 36:17and Christians, knowing the other person is fundamentally
- 36:20sacred. And to see the fluid process like the
- 36:23Sufis, knowing that we are always changing moment
- 36:26to moment. And to realize that the person shouting
- 36:29at you on Twitter is also just a person in a
- 36:31costume, probably really scared, probably looking
- 36:34for validation and recognition, just like you
- 36:37are. Precisely. We are all just seeking dignity.
- 36:40Here is a provocative thought to leave you with
- 36:42to mull over on your own. The source suggests
- 36:45that all idols eventually must be transcended.
- 36:48If we can actually do this, if we can look at
- 36:51our own political party, our own tribe, our most
- 36:54cherished labels and say, this is important to
- 36:56me, but it's not God, we might actually find
- 36:59the freedom to connect with the human being behind
- 37:02the label. And maybe, just maybe, the cost of
- 37:05that freedom is admitting we don't have it all
- 37:06figured out. And that epistemic humility might
- 37:09literally be the only way we survive this century
- 37:11together. A huge challenge. But hey, that's exactly
- 37:14why we dive deep. We certainly do. Thanks for
- 37:17joining us for this one. Let us know. Are you
- 37:20ready to take off the costume? Even just a little
- 37:22bit. We'll see you next time.